Effective Psychological Therapies For Alleviating Performance Anxiety
Effective Psychological Therapies For Alleviating Performance Anxiety
Effective Psychological Therapies For Alleviating Performance Anxiety
Research Article
Received: July 20, 2024 Accepted: August 10, 2024 Published: August 18, 2024
Abstract
This study examined existing treatment methods for alleviating music performance anxiety (MPA) and
proposed a new therapeutic approach based on these methods. Existing treatments primarily included
pharmacotherapy, cognitive behavior therapy (CBT), and rational emotive behavior therapy (REBT). Music
therapy techniques were investigated in conjunction with these established psychological therapies, utilizing
methods such as songwriting, improvisation, and music imagery. Building on this foundation, the Neo MPA
therapy method was proposed as a new approach to alleviate MPA. The Neo MPA therapy method consists of
the following steps: First, the treatment is structured as group therapy. Second, muscle relaxation and
meditation techniques from the existing systematic desensitization method are retained, but must
incorporate guitar music. Third, the REBT technique is applied to songwriting, facilitating group songwriting
sessions. Fourth, a group concert employing the exposure and response prevention (ERP) technique is
organized. This study presented a new therapeutic method with supporting arguments for alleviating MPA,
and it holds potential as a resource for future research and practical application in therapeutic settings.
Keywords: Music Performance Anxiety (MPA), Performance, Anxiety, Desensitization, Music Therapy.
1. Introduction
The stage can be both a place to shine and a place of terror for performers. Many performers experience
anxiety on stage, which can range from mild to severe levels that might qualify as social anxiety disorder
according to the DSM-5 (2013). While a certain level of tension and anxiety can enhance performance and
lead to positive outcomes, excessive anxiety can lead to complete immobilization. MPA can create a vicious
cycle of anticipating mistakes, leading to actual errors and post-event rumination, thereby embedding a
sense of failure. This anxiety does not only affect performances but can also result in depression and low
self-esteem, deeply impacting one's psychological well-being (Jin-hee, 2020). While music performance can
be a source of beauty for enthusiasts, for professionals or students striving for excellence, the stress and
anxiety from competitive environments can be overwhelming. Despite the prevalence of MPA symptoms
among performers, the root causes of their anxiety are often unrecognized, and appropriate treatment is
seldom sought (Kim, 2008). This research aims to explore existing methods for alleviating MPA and propose
new approaches to support individuals experiencing this condition.
30
International Journal of Recent Innovations in Academic Research
MPA shares characteristics with anxiety experienced in public speaking, evaluations, and exams, showing
similarities with social anxiety disorder. Social anxiety disorder involves intense fear and anxiety in social
situations where one is closely observed (DSM-5, 2013). Such social situations include public speaking, being
the focus of attention, and receiving evaluations, often leading to a misinterpretation of possible negative
outcomes. Individuals who feel anxiety only in performance contexts but not in other social situations
experience anxiety specifically related to being observed or evaluated (Jin-hee, 2020). Similarly, performers
experience MPA differently depending on the situation. For instance, I have found that my level of MPA is
significantly higher during an actual performance in front of an audience compared to during a rehearsal.
This indicates that the presence of evaluators or an audience affects the level of tension experienced by the
performer.
Firstly, physical symptoms of MPA include trembling hands and feet, excessive sweating as if it were raining,
sudden chills, and cardiovascular imbalances. As anxiety is experienced, the body's autonomic nervous
system becomes activated, leading to symptoms such as chest tightness, increased heart rate, elevated blood
pressure, rapid and shallow breathing, disruptions in breathing patterns, dry lips, and changes in body
temperature. In severe cases, symptoms may include muscle rigidity and sensory abnormalities (Nam and
Han, 2017). For example, my friend A experiences chest tightness and difficulty breathing as soon as the
performance begins. Another friend, B, becomes so extremely nervous upon stepping onto the stage that
they forget the pieces they are supposed to play. Subsequently, their hands sweat excessively, causing them
to drop their instrument.
Secondly, performers experiencing performance anxiety often feel a sense of shame stemming from a
perception of inferiority. They typically exhibit low self-esteem, and as they make frequent mistakes due to
anxiety on stage, they tend to evaluate themselves harshly, leading to feelings of guilt and shame (Nam and
Han, 2017).
Thirdly, cognitive symptoms include excessive worry about events that have not yet occurred, discomfort
from intrusive thoughts, decreased concentration, and irrational beliefs about needing to be perfect. The
desire to gain approval from parents, teachers, and peers drives a focus on flawless, error-free performances,
leading to an intolerance for even minor mistakes that others might not notice. This belief that the audience
will judge the performance critically can cause severe nervousness and lead to a repetitive thought pattern
of constantly ruminating over what might go wrong, which in turn creates a vicious cycle (Nam and Han,
2017).
In my own experience, a malfunction with the monitor speakers during rehearsal prevented me from tuning
properly, resulting in pitch issues during high notes when singing. This made me anxious about the
upcoming performance. As I waited for my turn, my heart raced, and I had trouble focusing, which led me to
repeat the mistakes from the rehearsal. MPA induces cognitive distortions, increasing anxiety, and fear of
failure, gradually leading to irrational and negative thinking. According to American psychiatrist Aaron Beck,
cognitive distortions include errors such as all-or-nothing thinking, overgeneralization, mental filtering,
minimization and maximization, personalization, mislabeling, mind reading, and fortune telling. These
cognitive errors distort or exaggerate reality in a negative direction, leading to negative emotions and
behaviors (Kwon, 2012).
A. Pharmacotherapy
Individuals who experience anxiety symptoms affecting their performance in presentations, exams, and
musical performances often try various methods to alleviate these symptoms. The most common and
frequently used method is medication. They might obtain prescriptions from a doctor or purchase
medication from a pharmacy based on the pharmacist’s recommendations to alleviate MPA. According to an
interview with pharmacist Yoon Jeong-wan of the Hannam-dong Moon Pharmacy, medication cannot
31
International Journal of Recent Innovations in Academic Research
guarantee its effectiveness for everyone, and its suitability can be uncertain. Most anxiety-reducing
medications work by stabilizing the sympathetic nervous system, which dulls the nerves. Depending on the
individual, side effects such as drowsiness, decreased concentration, nausea, dizziness, and blurred vision
can occur, potentially interfering with performance. Although medication can be an effective treatment, its
side effects can be significant, and it has limitations in continuously controlling psychological symptoms
related to performance anxiety.
The first stage of systematic desensitization involves inducing relaxation through techniques such as muscle
relaxation, deep breathing, or meditation. This step is crucial because relaxation is incompatible with
tension, helping to desensitize the individual to anxiety. The second stage involves creating a hierarchical list
of anxiety-inducing stimuli, ranging from the least to the most anxiety-provoking. This hierarchy is later used
in treatment to systematically desensitize the individual. The final stage involves exposing the individual to
the anxiety-inducing stimuli, starting from the lowest level of the hierarchy and gradually progressing to the
highest, allowing them to overcome their anxiety. For instance, someone with a fear of dogs might start by
imagining encountering a dog on the street, then progress to seeing a dog from a distance of ten meters, then
five meters, and finally one meter, before eventually touching and spending time with the dog. This step-by-
step approach helps the individual overcome their fear of dogs (Naver Encyclopedia, Systematic
Desensitization).
32
International Journal of Recent Innovations in Academic Research
anger, guilt, hurt, jealousy, and shame. Lastly, D stands for dispute, which involves challenging and
questioning one's distorted thoughts and beliefs about external reality, encouraging the individual to
reconsider whether their thoughts are rational (Kwon, 2012).
For example, hearing from family members, "You have always been the most inadequate child in our family.
You must succeed at all costs to gain recognition," is an activating event. The belief, "I must strive to be
recognized as a competent person, so I must perform perfectly. I must excel in any given role, and if I fail, it
will be catastrophic, proving that I am always incompetent and worthless," is the belief system. The resulting
emotions, such as anxiety, panic, depression, despair, avoidance of situations, and feelings of worthlessness,
are the consequence. D can be explained as the dispute received from a therapist or psychologist, challenging
the irrational belief system.
33
International Journal of Recent Innovations in Academic Research
changing faulty thoughts and creating songs with the group that address these erroneous thoughts, the
effectiveness of the therapy is enhanced. We aim to overcome MPA by holding a group music session using
an enhanced ERP technique that builds upon systematic desensitization.
A. Group Therapy
Above all, the treatment for MPA should be in the form of group therapy rather than individual therapy. A
group can instill hope in its members that their issues can be improved, and this hope itself can have
therapeutic effects. Additionally, members can find comfort in knowing that their current symptoms are not
unique to them, but that others have similar conflicts and problems. They can acquire necessary information,
gain a clear understanding of their issues, and receive direct or indirect guidance, suggestions, and advice
from other group members, which is expected to boost their confidence. It is believed that openly expressing
one's anxious emotions in front of others is a crucial process for MPA treatment. Through interactions with
group members, individuals may gain insight that others will not only view them as objects of evaluation
when on stage but will also recognize and appreciate their performance. This insight provides a platform to
test the belief that they can fully express their desired skills as performers.
Stringed instruments, like the guitar, can be played using various tools or directly with the hands. However,
even when using different tools, the method of producing sound differs from that of bowed instruments.
While bowed instruments produce sound through the friction of the bow against the strings, plucked
instruments create sound by strumming or plucking the strings. Plucked instruments, such as guitars and
harps, produce vibrations that create a gentle and smooth sound, which is often perceived as more relaxing
compared to the continuous and intense sounds of bowed instruments. The sound of plucked instruments
fades more quickly, creating a more peaceful auditory experience ideal for relaxation. On the other hand,
bowed instruments sustain sound longer, which can be less relaxing (en.wikipedia.org-2). Instruments like
the guitar and harp are frequently used in therapeutic settings due to their ability to produce calming and
peaceful tones, whereas bowed instruments might evoke a broader range of emotions rather than solely
relaxation (classicalcompass.org).
C. Group Songwriting
Through songwriting, individuals naturally express their unconscious emotions and conflicts, allowing them
to examine their own feelings (Jung, 2006). Songwriting can help individuals become aware of their negative
thoughts and reframe them into positive language, aiding in the correction of these negative thoughts. This
process utilizes music as a form of projective identification, where individuals reflect on and internalize the
behaviors and emotions of others as if they were their own. For example, adolescents might listen to a
popular singer's song and change their behavior, engage in deviant actions, use songs to facilitate learning,
or sing to maximize group cohesion during rallies (Jung, 2006). In particular, group songwriting activities
are believed to be highly effective as they allow the group to collaboratively create and perform lyrics that
help overcome MPA, potentially enhancing the therapeutic benefits many times over.
34
International Journal of Recent Innovations in Academic Research
immediate physical and psychological responses to their instrument, potentially providing a more effective
means of addressing MPA compared to non-specialists.
7. Conclusion
Musicians are prone to perfectionism, which serves as a driving force for continually improving their
performances. They also tend to have a high self-image, which makes them fearful of criticism and judgment
from others. This fear of disappointing those who have high expectations, combined with the fear of failure,
leads to the onset of performance anxiety. This study aimed to review the current methods for alleviating
performance anxiety and to propose future directions for such treatments. We investigated a range of
approaches, including counseling techniques, relaxation through meditation, and music-based therapies,
without restricting ourselves to any specific method, and sought to develop new approaches based on this
review.
2) In conjunction with these therapeutic techniques (CBT, Systematic Desensitization, REBT), music
therapy techniques were employed. The music used included methods for physical relaxation, music
listening, songwriting, and improvisation.
Performance anxiety ultimately stems from the act of performing music, but music therapy techniques are
actively used to alleviate this anxiety for the following reasons: Although music can create a complex and
ambivalent relationship with performers experiencing performance anxiety, musicians respond to music
both physically and psychologically in ways that differ from non-musicians due to their musical training.
They engage more deeply and actively compared to other media. Existing treatments typically adopted only
one technique per therapy. However, the Neo MPA therapy method proposes a combined approach,
integrating systematic desensitization and REBT techniques. Additionally, it presents the use of ERP
techniques through concerts as a therapeutic method. The most crucial aspect is the provision of group
therapy involving a therapist and multiple participants, leveraging the dynamics and energy of the group.
Furthermore, the effectiveness of guitar tones for relaxation was demonstrated, and improvisation with the
musician's most beloved or ambivalent instrument was utilized.
A limitation of this study is that the proposed method could not be practically applied and tested. This study
aims to present this method as a resource for therapists and psychological counselors dealing with
performance anxiety.
Declarations
Acknowledgments: I wish to thank Seoul Innovation Research Institute.
Author Contribution: The author confirms sole responsibility for the following: study conception and
design, data collection, analysis and interpretation of results, and manuscript preparation.
Conflict of Interest: The author declares no conflict of interest.
Consent to Publish: The author agrees to publish the paper in International Journal of Recent Innovations
in Academic Research.
35
International Journal of Recent Innovations in Academic Research
Data Availability Statement: The datasets used or analyzed during the current study are available from the
corresponding author on reasonable request.
Funding: This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement: Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement: Not applicable.
Research Content: The research content of manuscript is original and has not been published elsewhere.
References
1. Abramowitz, J.S., Deacon, B.J. and Whiteside, S.P. 2019. Exposure therapy for anxiety: Principles and
practice. Guilford Publications.
2. American Psychiatric Association, DSM-5 Task Force. 2013. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental
disorders: DSM-5™. 5th Edition, American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc. 199-247pp.
3. Choi, S.G. and Kang, K.S. 2018. The effects of cognitive-behavior music therapy on stage fright of music
major students. Music Theory Forum, 25(2): 135-159.
4. Fundamentals of Understanding Behavior Management.
http://www.sigmapress.co.kr/shop/shop_image/g33182_1497420840.pdf
5. Guitar Music’s Impact on Mental Wellness. https://breakthroughguitar.com/guitar-musics-impact-on-
mental-wellness/
6. https://classicalcompass.org/strings/viola/
7. Jin-hee, K. 2020. Review of music intervention to alleviate music performance anxiety. Master’s Thesis,
Ewha Womans University Graduate School, Department of Music Therapy.
https://www.riss.kr/search/detail/DetailView.do?p_mat_type=be54d9b8bc7cdb09&control_no=0e6e44
d4aa6c1584ffe0bdc3ef48d419
8. Juncos, D.G. and Markman, E.J. 2016. Acceptance and commitment therapy for the treatment of music
performance anxiety: A single subject design with a university student. Psychology of Music, 44(5): 935-
952.
9. Jung, H. 2006. Music therapy techniques and models. Seoul: Hakjjisa.
10. Kim, Y. 2008. A descriptive study of music performance anxiety of high school musicians. Korean Journal
of Music Therapy, 10(2): 40–56.
11. Kwon, S.M. 2012. Contemporary theories of psychotherapy and counseling. Seoul: Hakjjisa.
12. Nam, J. and Han, J. 2017. A study of psychological phenomena for university music major students who
experience music performance anxiety. Korea Journal of Counseling, 18(2): 149–168.
13. National Center for Mental Health. https://nct.go.kr/distMental/rating/rating01_3_3.do
14. Plucked Instrument and Bowed Instrument. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plucked_string_instrument
(wikipedia.org-2).
15. Review of Ego Development Group Counseling. https://inno.hongik.ac.kr/webzine/25/06.html
16. Systematic Desensitization (wikipedia.org-1).
https://ko.wikipedia.org/wiki/%EC%B2%B4%EA%B3%84%EC%A0%81_%EB%91%94%EA%B0%90
%ED%99%94
17. Systematic Desensitization.
https://terms.naver.com/entry.naver?docId=4353251&cid=40942&categoryId=31531
18. Types of Behavioral and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Techniques (tistory.com).
https://doniwa.tistory.com/313
Citation: Kaylin Lee. 2024. Effective Psychological Therapies for Alleviating Performance Anxiety.
International Journal of Recent Innovations in Academic Research, 8(8): 30-36.
Copyright: ©2024 Kaylin Lee. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
36