Correlation Between Oral Health and Quality of Lif
Correlation Between Oral Health and Quality of Lif
Correlation Between Oral Health and Quality of Lif
OPEN
Abstract
The aim of this study was to evaluate the oral health among the elderly in Southwest China and to analyze the correlation between
common oral diseases and quality of life (QOL) in the same population, thus providing recommendations to improve their oral health
and life quality.
Elderly people (>60 years’ old) were randomly recruited into our study, and we performed oral health examinations and diagnoses,
using the Community Periodontal Index (CPI) to assess the periodontal condition, and Oral Health Impact Profile-14 (OHIP-14) to
score life quality associated with oral health. Then we analyzed correlations between oral health and QOL as well as body mass index
(BMI).
A total of 687 subjects participated in our study and 212 (30.9%) were diagnosed with gingivitis or subgingival calculus, 291
(42.4%) with moderate chronic periodontitis, 136 (19.8%) with severe chronic periodontitis, 514 (74.8%) with dental caries, and 648
(94.3%) with dentition defects. A total of 653 (95.1%) qualified OHIP-14 scores were collected, with a median score of 13. The scores
of the severe and moderate periodontitis were similar to the dentition defects, but higher than the scores for gingivitis and subgingival
calculus. Considering the most common side effect, 11% of the subjects with severe chronic periodontitis were reported to be
“unsatisfied with eating,” and 48.4% of the participants with dentition defects complained about “troubles with pronunciation.” A
logistic regression analysis revealed that underweight (BMI <20) correlated with dental caries (odds ratio [OR]: 0.167, P = .040) and
dentition defects (OR: 0.119, P = .016).
The general oral health condition was poor among the elderly in Southwest China. Periodontitis and dentition defects have
considerable negative effects on the QOL among this population.
Abbreviations: CPI = Community Periodontal Index, CPITN = community periodontal index of treatment needs, OHIP-14 = Oral
Health Impact Profile-14, OHRQOL = oral health-related quality of life, QOL = quality of life.
Keywords: dental caries, dentition, gingivitis, life quality, periodontitis
1
Sheng et al. Medicine (2018) 97:21 Medicine
Figure 1. World Dental Federation classification of teeth in 4 quadrants with 8 teeth per quadrant numerated from the incisors to the molar teeth. The bold numbers
indicate the teeth zones, which have been analyzed in the study.
2
Sheng et al. Medicine (2018) 97:21 www.md-journal.com
black tooth fossa, ink change on the groove and edge of the Table 1
occlusal surface, dark brown cavity, and residual root or crown. General demographic data.
Group Number %
2.3. Dentition status and treatment demand Sex Male 359 52.3
We checked and recorded coronary dental caries, root dental Female 328 47.7
caries, secondary dental caries, history of filling a tooth, dentition Age, y 60–64 214 31.1
loss and reason for dentition loss, abutment stat,e and the 65–70 258 37.6
71–75 139 20.2
treatment program for each tooth. Dentition defects refer to
76–80 61 8.9
different numbers of natural teeth missing in the maxillary and >80 15 2.2
mandible, whereas dentition loss means that no natural teeth or BMI Obesity (>28) 24 3.5
tooth roots are left on the entire dental arch. Overweight (>24, <28) 103 15.0
Underweight (<20) 26 3.8
Normal (20–24) 534 77.7
2.4. Questionnaire survey
Ethnic groups Han 644 93.7
The general demographic data and OHIP-14 scale were collected Bai 19 2.8
by questionnaire survey.[13] General demographic data included Dai 1 0.1
sex, age, nationality, residence, living conditions, education level, Hui 18 2.6
occupation, monthly income, and marital status, and so on. The Man 1 0.1
NaXi 1 0.1
OHIP-14 scale contained 7 dimensions and 14 items, namely 14
Yi 3 0.4
questions. Each question had 5 answers about frequency, which
Education level Primary school or below 83 12.1
were respectively “very often,” “often,” “sometimes,” “seldom,” Middle school 161 23.4
and “never,” The participants could choose one answer under High and secondary school 259 37.7
investigation and one explanation. The score of OHIP-14 ranged Junior college and above 184 26.8
from 0 to 56. A higher score suggested a worse life quality Monthly income (Yuan) <500 17 2.5
associated with poor oral health. 500–1000 31 4.5
1000–1500 108 15.7
1500–1999 231 33.6
2.5. Statistical analysis 2000–2499 140 20.4
We used Epidata software to establish a data input template, and 2500–2999 78 11.4
>3000 67 9.8
adopted a double input method for all valid questionnaires. We
No fixed income 15 2.2
insured the integrity of data by a data verification program. The score
Marital status Married 631 91.8
of OHIP-14 scale are presented as median and quartile intervals. The Divorced 10 1.5
methods of statistical analysis included logistic regression, descriptive Unmarried 2 0.3
statistics, Pearson x2 test, Fisher x2 test, and rank sum test. Inter-rater Widowed 44 6.4
reliability has been determined by Cohen Kappa coefficient Family members 1 7 1.0
calculation. P < .05 was considered to be statistically significant. 2 180 26.2
3 128 18.6
4 181 26.3
3. Results 5 156 22.7
3.1. General demographic data 6 28 4.1
7 1 0.1
This study investigated 700 participants, 687 of whom completed 8 3 0.4
valid questionnaires (98%). Among the respondents, the number of 9 3 0.4
males was slightly higher than females; 60- to 70-year-old subjects BMI = body mass index.
accounted for the majority (68.7%); most of them were from the
Han nationality (93.7%); the education level was high school or
secondary school among most participants (37.3%), followed by more likely to develop into the severe stage in male subjects (30.9%
junior college and above (26.8%); monthly income was relatively vs. 35.5%). Moreover, we found that with an increase in age, the
high (>1500 yuan, 75.2%); most of them were married (91.8%) and severity of the disease also increased gradually: subjects aged 60 to
had 2 to 5 family members (93.8%) (Table 1). 64 years were mainly diagnosed with gingivitis or subgingival
calculus (45.5%), those aged 65 to 70 years and 71 to 75 years were
diagnosed with moderate periodontitis (48.4% and 58.3%),
3.2. Oral diseases
whereas the oldest subjects (76–80 years) were likely to be
Kappa values of interexaminer agreement were 0.75 to 0.80. The diagnosed with either severe periodontitis or moderate periodon-
results of the oral health evaluation for the 687 respondents were titis (respectively 32.6% and 37.0%). There were only 10
reported as a serious problem, and the numbers of subjects with participants above 81 years of age, which limited the interpretation
gingivitis or subgingival calculus, moderate periodontitis, and for patients in this group. Considering the education level,
severe periodontitis were reported to be 212 (30.9%), 291 participants of the middle school group were more likely to be
(42.4%), and 136 (19.8%), respectively. Only 2 subjects had diagnosed with gingivitis or subgingival calculus, whereas the
completely healthy teeth and the remaining 41 had no experiences others mostly had moderate periodontitis. We further analyzed the
or no access to CPI examination. As shown in Table 2, both male correlation between monthly income and the prevalence of each
and female participants were mainly in the moderate stage of condition, and found that as income increased, the prevalence of
periodontitis. When compared with females, periodontitis was moderate or severe periodontitis decreased: the prevalence rate of
3
Sheng et al. Medicine (2018) 97:21 Medicine
Table 2
Comparison of correlations between different stages of periodontitis and the baseline information of enrolled patients.
Severe chronic Moderate chronic Gingival bleeding with or
Group periodontitis (136) periodontitis (291) without plaque (212) x2 P
Sex Male 84 (25.5) 144 (43.6) 102 (30.9) 8.128 .043
Female 52 (16.8) 147 (47.6) 110 (35.6)
Age, y 60–64 39 (18.7) 75 (35.9) 95 (45.5) 32.232 <.001
65–70 60 (23.6) 123 (48.4) 71 (28.0)
71–75 20 (16.7) 70 (58.3) 30 (25.0)
76–80 15 (32.6) 17 (37.0) 14 (30.4)
>81 2 (20.0) 6 (60.0) 2 (20.0)
Education level Primary school or below 8 (11.0) 44 (60.3) 21 (28.8) 39.375 <.001
Middle school 20 (13.4) 55 (36.9) 74 (49.7)
High and secondary school 58 (24.3) 121 (50.6) 60 (25.1)
Junior college or above 50 (28.1) 71 (39.9) 57 (32.0)
Monthly income (Yuan) <500 2 (18.2) 8 (72.7) 1 (9.1) 17.341 .001
500–1000 4 (13.8) 22 (75.9) 3 (10.3)
1000–1500 24 (22.9) 55 (52.4) 26 (24.8)
>1500 103 (21.5) 198 (41.3) 178 (37.2)
No fixed income 3 (21.4) 8 (53.3) 4 (28.6)
The analysis was performed using Pearson x2 or probability analysis on different classifications (sex, age, education degree, and monthly income) of various periodontitis patients. Data are represented as n (%).
the low-income (<500 yuan) subjects was 90.9%, whereas the rate 3.3. Dental caries, tooth loss and filled teeth
of the high income (>1500 yuan) subjects was 62.7%. Two healthy There was a significant difference between the age groups
participants were found in the high-income group (>1500 yuan). regarding dental caries and dentition defects (P < .001). Among
Finally, according to Pearson x2 test, there were significant 687 respondents, 514 (74.8%) had dental caries. The prevalence
differences (P = .043) between male and female subjects, among of dental caries in the older subjects (>75 years’ old) was lower
subjects of different ages (P < .001), education levels (P < 0.001), than those aged 60 to 75 years. In addition, 648 (94.3%) of them
and monthly income (P = .001). had dentition defects, the average missing teeth were 11.21, and
31 (4.5%) had dentition loss. The rate of dentition defects in
Table 3 males and females was comparable (93.9% and 94.8%). Similar
The prevalence of dental caries and dentition defects in subjects of to dental caries, the dentition defect rate was lower in the older
different age groups. subjects (>75 years’ old) compared with those aged 60 to 75
Age, y Dental caries Dentition defect P years (Table 3).
60–64 (214 cases) 159 (74.3) 209 (97.7) .064
65–70 (258 cases) 210 (81.4) 254 (98.4) .141 3.4. OHIP-14 scores
71–75 (139 cases) 101 (72.7) 124 (89.2) .282
76–80 (61 cases) 36 (59.0) 49 (80.3) .322 In total we collected 653 (95.1%) qualified OHIP-14 scores from
≥81 (15 cases) 8 (53.3) 12 (80.0) .569 687 respondents. As shown in Figure 3, the median score was 13
P <.001 and the highest score was 39. We further analyzed the correlation
between oral diseases and QOL. Participants with severe and
Data are represented as n (%).
Figure 3. Distribution of the OHIP-14 scores. OHIP-14 = Oral Health Impact Profile-14.
4
Sheng et al. Medicine (2018) 97:21 www.md-journal.com
Table 4
The effect of periodontitis stages in subjects on OHIP-14 Chinese version evaluation items.
Gingivitis and subgingival Moderate periodontitis Severe periodontitis
OHIP-14 items calculus (CPI = 1 or 2) (n = 212) (CPI = 3) (n = 291) (CPI = 4) (n = 136) x2 P
Trouble pronouncing words 11 (5.2) 19 (6.5) 13 (9.6) 2.555 .279
Sense of taste worse 6 (2.8) 16 (5.5) 12 (8.8) 5.931 .052
Painful aching in mouth 5 (2.4) 6 (2.1) 11 (8.1) 9.247 .010
Uncomfortable to eat foods 12 (5.7) 11 (3.8) 12 (8.8) 4.574 .102
Being self-conscious 4 (1.9) 10 (3.4) 7 (5.1) 2.827 .243
Felt tense 3 (1.4) 2 (0.7) 3 (2.2) 1.757 .415
Unsatisfactory diet 7 (3.3) 6 (2.1) 15 (11.0) 15.517 .000
Had to interrupt meals 2 (0.9) 2 (0.7) 4 (2.9) 3.353 .187
Difficult to relax 3 (1.4) 6 (2.1) 3 (2.2) 0.396 .820
Being embarrassed 4 (1.9) 2 (0.7) 1 (0.7) 1.7077 .426
Being irritable with others — 1 (0.3) 4 (2.9) 4.979 .026
Difficulty doing usual jobs 2 (0.9) 2 (0.7) 1 (0.7) 0.106 .949
Felt life is less satisfying 1 (0.5) 2 (0.7) 5 (3.7) 6.525 .038
Totally unable to function — — 1 (0.7) — —
The analysis was performed using a Pearson x2 or probability analysis on different items of OHIP-14 scale among moderate and severe periodontitis patients; “—” means having no available data. CPI =
Community Periodontal Index, OHIP-14 = Oral Health Impact Profile-14.
moderate chronic periodontitis had similar OHIP-14 scores, with Concerning the item of “trouble pronouncing words,” both
a median score of 15.5 (10, 19) and 14 (7, 18), respectively. dentition defects and loss patients reported the most pronounced
In comparison, the OHIP-14 scale scores of gingivitis and negative effects (7.1% and 48.4%) (Table 5). In addition,
subgingival calculus participants were relatively lower, with a dentition loss patients experienced more negative effects than
median score of 6 (2.75, 11.5) and 8 (2, 14), respectively. It was those with dentition defects in the following items: “trouble
noted that participants with severe periodontitis complained pronouncing words,” “sense of taste worse,” “unsatisfactory
mostly about “being unsatisfied with eating” (11.0%), whereas diet,” “had to interrupt meals,” and “felt life is less satisfying,”
patients with moderate periodontitis commonly reported (6.5%) with statistical significance being achieved (Table 5).
“trouble pronouncing words,” whereas patients with gingivitis
and subgingival calculus (5.7%) were “uncomfortable eating
3.5. Body mass index (BMI) was associated with dentition
foods” (Table 4). When comparing the negative effects of
defects and dental caries
moderate and severe chronic periodontitis, we concluded that
severe periodontitis had more negative effects than moderate Finally, we analyzed correlations between oral health and body
periodontitis on the following items: “painful aching in the weights of the subjects in a logistic regression analysis. The results
mouth,” “unsatisfactory diet,” “being irritable with others,” and showed that dental caries and dentition defects were significantly
“felt life is less satisfying,” with statistical significance being reflected in subjects with BMIs <20 (odds ratio [OR]: 0.167,
attained (Table 4). P = .040 and OR: 0.119, P = .016, respectively) (Table 6).
Considering the effect of dentition defect/loss of life quality, we
found that the median OHIP-14 score in the elderly with
4. Discussion
complete dentition was 3 (0.25, 5.75), the median score of
patients with dentition defects was 13 (6, 18), and the median Oral diseases, especially periodontal disease and dental caries, are
score of patients with dentition loss was as high as 23 (16, 28). still major health problems in the world today.[14] Our study
Table 5
The effect of dentition defects or dentition loss on OHIP-14 item scores.
∗
OHIP-14 items Dentition defect (n = 648, %) Dentition loss (n = 31, %) x2 P
Trouble pronouncing words 46 (7.1) 15 (48.4) 61.680 <.001
Sense of taste worse 34 (5.2) 11 (35.5) 43.710 <.001
Painful aching in mouth 23 (3.5) 1 (3.2) 0.009 .923
Uncomfortable to eat foods 37 (5.7) 11 (35.5) 39.922 <.001
Being self-conscious 22 (3.4) 7 (22.6) 14.429 <.001
Felt tense 9 (1.4) 1 (3.2) 0.523 .470
Unsatisfactory diet 31 (4.8) 9 (29.0) 17.817 <.001
Had to interrupt meals 8 (1.2) 4 (12.9) 10.590 <.001
Difficult to relax 14 (2.2) 1 (3.2) 0.137 .711
Being embarrassed 7 (1.1) — — —
Being irritable with others 5 (0.8) — — —
Difficulty doing usual jobs 6 (0.9) 1 (3.2) 1.0083 0.315
Felt life is less satisfying 8 (1.2) 3 (9.7) 6.5967 0.010
Totally unable to function 1 (0.2) — — —
The analysis was performed using Pearson x2 or probability analysis on different items of the OHIP-14 scale among patients with dentition defect and loss; “—” meant have no data. OHIP-14 = Oral Health Impact
Profile-14.
5
Sheng et al. Medicine (2018) 97:21 Medicine
6
Sheng et al. Medicine (2018) 97:21 www.md-journal.com
[11] Sharma PS, Wadhwa P. Evaluation of the FDI two-digit system of [15] Johansson G, Ostberg AL. Oral health-related quality of life in Swedish
designating teeth. Quintessence Int Dent Dig 1977;8:99–101. young adults. Int J Qual Stud Health Well-being 2015;10: 27125.
[12] WHO. Oral Health Survey—Basic Methods. 4th ed. Geneva: World [16] Inglehart M, Bagramian R. Oral Health Related Quality Of Life (p. 2).
Health Organization; 1997. Chicago, IL: Quintessence Books; 2002.
[13] Allen PF, McMillan AS. The impact of tooth loss in a denture wearing [17] Song IS, Han K, Ryu JJ, et al. Association between underweight and
population: an assessment using the Oral Health Impact Profile. tooth loss among Korean adults. Sci Rep 2017;7: 41524.
Community Dent Health 1999;16:176–80. [18] Seman K, Abdul Manaf H, Ismail AR. Association between functional
[14] WHO. Oral health country/area profile project. CAPP. World Health dentition with inadequate calorie intake and underweight in elderly
Organization; 2014. people living in “Pondok” in Kelantan. Arch Orofac Sci 2007;2:10–9.