Islamic Psychology in The View of Mualana Ashraf Ali Thanvi
Islamic Psychology in The View of Mualana Ashraf Ali Thanvi
Islamic Psychology in The View of Mualana Ashraf Ali Thanvi
4(2022),11-20
https://almisbah.info/
“‘Indeed, your blood, your wealth, your honor is sacred to each other, just as this
day of yours is sacred in this city of yours. Indeed, no one commits a crime except
against himself. Indeed, none commits a crime for which his son is accountable,
nor does a child commit a crime for which his father is held accountable. Indeed
Ash-Shaitan has lost hope of ever being worshipped in this city of yours, but he
will have compliance in what deeds of yours you consider insignificant, which he
will be content with.”1
The holy prophet gave the solution of all problems; there was no concept of prejudice or
discrimination in group and out group. Muhammad (PBUH) paid attention to inner self.
According to Divine’s instructions we must have to control our inner self, then there is a reward
for us otherwise there is punishment for wrong doing. Disciplining and controlling the soul
means that you have good command and control over all your body parts like hands, feet and
eyes etc. These are the Divine instructions to control these all and use them positively not in
the activities of sin or immorality. Quran says
*
Ph.D. Scholar, Dept. Of Psychology, International Islamic University Islamabad.
**
M.Phil. Scholar, Dept. of Education & Psychology, Kohat University of Science & Technology, Kohat.
ISSN-Online: 2790-8828
ISSN-Print: 2790-881X
(Dec-2022) Vol. 2 No. 4
“But unto him who shall have stood in fear of his Sustainer’s Presence, and held
back his inner self from base desires, paradise will truly be the goal!”2
He also stressed on exercise to be relaxed from depression and other disorders. We can
trace many quotations from the teaching of the Holy Prophet for the treatment of psychological
disorders. A simple quotation from the Holy prophet for the treatment of depression is “Look at
those below you in worldly matters and those above you in religious matters” 3 healthy life,
spirituality, soul purity, thoughts clarity, intensions correction and character buildings are the
Sunnah of the Holly Prophet (PBUH). Quran Says
“Obey God, obey the Prophet (s) and obey those charged with authority over
you”4
Today psychologists and all mental health professionals are agreed that psychological
disorders and human crisis have some spiritual or religious etiology and their solution need
religious and spiritual values. The Muslim psychologists and intellectuals can play a role to
device theories, methods and effective psychotherapy techniques for psychological disorders
from the Islamic point of view. The aim of this will be to bring human towards nature.5
12
ISLAMIC PSYCHOLOGY IN THE VIEW OF MAULANA ASHRAF ALI THANVI………REVIEW
to him psychological disorders due to organic etiology needs medications, while disorders due
to functional etiology needs treatment through techniques of psychotherapy.8 Ignorance, pride,
jealousy, lust and hypocrisy are the examples of mental disorders from Islamic perspective. The
teaching of Thanvi is interesting for psychologists because Thanvi and psychologists both are
involved in the assessment, diagnosis and treatment of mental disorders. He also argues about
two forces in every human being like destructive and constructive forces and how they are
utilizing these forces.9 According to him these forces are mostly learned some from their
parents and some from the other members of the society including peers etc. All human beings
have the ability to learn, relearn and unlearn both negative and positive attitudes and
behaviors, which are necessary for personality shaping. Broadly we can comment that Thanvi
also worked the role of parents in shaping personality.10
Theory of Personality
According to Thanvi personality is the unit of the whole individual characteristics. An
individual is the combination of Ruh, Qalb, Nafs and the body. Ruh is the place in fitrah where
God’s imprint resides and it is also pure and invariable. Ruh creates vibration in the body like an
electric shock and it is also something physical residing in the heart. There are some innate
characteristics in the individuals; some of them are common while some are specific to this
individual. These innate human characteristics are collectively called Ars. Spirituality tries to
combine both the internal and external factors of personality. Al-Ghazali also explained this
concept that there are four aspects of an individual personality. They are Nafs, Ruh, Qalb and
Aql. Aql in other words is intellect through which an individual tries to understand the material
world. He stressed mostly on Qalb. An individual behavior, past and future is influenced
through these four. 11, 12 Quran refers three aspects of self; Nafs, Qalb and Aql, but Qalb is
considered the central aspect.
“The believers are only those who when Allah is mentioned, feel a fear in their
hearts” 13
“Truly in the body there is a morsel of flesh which, if it is sound, all the body is
sound and which, if it is diseased, all of it is diseased. Truly it is the heart” 14
According to Thanvi Nafs is considered the Self while heart is the central component of
human personality. Heart is the source of knowledge while Ruh and Nafs vary only in their
characteristics. Therefore, we say that Ruh is present in every individual before birth, while Nafs
is a force in the human beings which desire something. It may be constructive or destructive. It
works on pleasure principals like concept of id by Freud. Like Quran and earlier Muslim scholars
Thanvi also reported three stages of Nafs, they are Nafs Ammara, Nafs Lawwamma and Nafs
Mumaina. All the mentioned terms are virtually the same but their context is different. Qalb
(heart) have direct association with God, angles, Satan and other human beings in the society.
Prophet said
“Wealth is in the heart and poverty is in the heart. Whoever is wealthy in his
heart will not be harmed no matter what happens in the world. Whoever is
impoverished in his heart will not be satisfied no matter how much he has in
the world. Verily, he will only be harmed by the greed of his own soul” 15
From Islamic perspective Qalb is central and ever changing while the physical heart
pumps blood to all parts of the body. Some of the researchers used the word soul alternate
with Qalb, while soul is in the form of a force.16 Personality traits have roots from Quran.
13
(Dec-2022) Vol. 2 No. 4
Personality components like Id, Ego and Superego have resemblance with Nafs-al-ammara,
Nafs-al-lawamah and Nafs-al-mutmainah. While Ghazali explained Nafs in two meanings like
the 1st is anger and appetite of a person while the 2nd is soul or self of an individual and then
the self (Nafs) is divided into Ammara, Lawamah and Mutmainah.
ALLAH
Ruh
Nafs Mutmainah
Nafs Amara
Nafs
Shaytan
14
ISLAMIC PSYCHOLOGY IN THE VIEW OF MAULANA ASHRAF ALI THANVI………REVIEW
According to Thanvi the main cause of mental disorders is the detachment and escape
from God and humanity. When there is a detachment from God there will be more chances of
mental disorders because the individual will think irrelevantly, if the cognition is disturbed there
will be more chances for some abnormal symptoms. There are also stages of mental disorders.
Thanvi said the human being is under the influence of two powers, constructive and
destructive. The constructive power guides an individual towards nature while destructive
power works beyond the nature. Therefore, balance between theses power is necessary.21
According to him an individual must be aware from these powers. Otherwise, the
imbalance will lead to mental disturbances. During psychotherapy sessions there will be
concern on the solution of this conflict. Imbalance between these powers is due to conflict
between actions and intensions. He stressed on the significance of environmental factors.22
Challenges and difficulties in life are necessary and it also pulls the people to feel grief, but they
don’t know that this state of grief is temporary and sometimes it is test from God side.
Persistent state of grief sometimes leads to depression. Grief is opposite to happiness. In Quran
Allah told Muhammad (PBUH) not to feel grief over disbelievers
Therapeutic Methods
Currently in the Western or mainstream psychology they are now accepting the role of
religion and spirituality. Much importance is giving to religious and spiritual topics concerned
with mental illness and their intervention. The Western Psychologist are also agreed that
religious and spiritual psychotherapeutic practices can play a positive role the treatment and
solution of psychological issues. Some researchers named them a “theistic approach of
psychotherapy”. Cognitive behavioral therapy is the common technique used by most of the
Muslim psychologists in the form spiritually integrated cognitive behavior therapy. The main
focus of this technique is to change the detrimental and problematic beliefs into more
supportive and positive beliefs. But here the most important thing is the client assessment.24 If
the therapist came to know about cause of the issue, then it became easy to be treated. If the
therapist understand that cause of this illness is religious or spiritual results from detachment
from Allah almighty. Then the therapist will be able to work out on the ways how to refine the
effected soul and how to re-attach the client to God. Foundations of religious and spiritual
interventions will revolve around the client spiritual development; this focus will enhance the
chances of therapeutic effectiveness.25
Reading Therapy
Reading therapy is basically a type of individual therapy. In this type of therapy, the
clients were instructed to write down all their presenting complaints and problems. Strong
rapport between client and therapist is required for this technique. Exchange of letters was
done for rapport development, but it is also obvious that sometimes the client needs direct
guidelines. This technique is like free association of Sigmund Freud. After writing or listing the
client complaints, they will be checked, if there is ambiguity or something questionable, the
client was questioned to clarify. Then the client’s complaints were assisted to plane treatment.
The clients were provided some reading material including books of different Muslim scholars
according to their complaints25. They were also directed to learn some verses from the Holly
Quran. Strong believe on God is required to get full benefits from this therapy. The overall
purpose of the reading therapy was the purification of the effected and shadowed soul.26
15
(Dec-2022) Vol. 2 No. 4
this the therapists are directing the clients and provides some relevant literature to clarify their
state of mind or body. Aim of the given literature was the provision of information, support and
guidelines. This concept is not limited to Thanvi approach or Islamic Psychology but it is also
prevalent in different therapies like different behavioral therapies. Facilitation of clients and
attainment of therapeutic goals are the common concepts of reading therapy. Some of the
researchers reported this technique as spiritual bibliotherapy, which is the reading of sacred
text for the purification of soul. The therapist will not only provide and read the material but
will also explain and interpret in details to get the required goal.27,28 Another research reported
significant association was reported between the individuals participating in bibliotherapy
sessions conducting by Sufis for self-achieving. In contemporary psychotherapies reading
literature is used is an adjunct fragment of the therapeutic intervention. Reading of stories or
narrations are common in the treatment of drug addiction treatment.29
Maulana Asharaf Ali Thanvi view revolve around patient will and the effort they are
interested in the cure of illness or disease. The counselor will only assist whenever the client
need help in understanding etiology of the disease, intervention, precautions or complications,
but the most important thing is the patient trust upon their counselor and abilities of
counselor. In current scenario the researchers are using bibliotherapy to treat panic conditions,
anxiety problems, depression, weight loss, academic issues and know about understanding
individual differences,30,31 helping students to learn, grief reaction, separation disorders, child
abuse and rehabilitation of individuals.32 According to33 bibliotherapy is an effective and
efficient tool in devising and to reinforce therapeutic intervention. Bibliotherapy can be utilized
in psychoeducation and basic health services.34
Communication Therapy
Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi worked for the purification of human self through his
communication therapy. He removed pain of people and filled their heart with satisfaction.
According to him changes in the heart and changes in the mind can change the whole human
being. Through his therapy he tried to establish close association with God. Pleasure of Allah is
that to spent life according to God’s will. Perfect life is that if it is spent according to Sunnah
and Shariah. Due to materialistic desires the people left right path which further proceed to
psychological disorders. This is the main cause of psychological disorders. Through therapy we
may boost our self-esteem of client and it leads to catharsis. The Islamic therapy turns around
the Divine codes revealed by Allah to Muhammad (PBUH) and these codes have diminished the
concept of superiority and inferiority complexes. These are the codes of justice and equality for
all human beings. Invited of the Holy Prophet to come under a single entity of Islam has
abolished all prejudices, discriminations, ingroup and outgroup conflicts.
16
ISLAMIC PSYCHOLOGY IN THE VIEW OF MAULANA ASHRAF ALI THANVI………REVIEW
Meditation
Meditation is a Sufi word used alternatively for Muraqiba. Muraqiba means to take of or
to keep an eye or to help deepen the understanding of sacred life forces. Currently it is
practiced for relaxation or stress reduction. It is practiced from thousands of years. It works like
mind-body complementary medication. Meditation is for the production of deep mind
relaxation. The Holy Prophet regularly practiced meditation. Before prophethood he regularly
visited Mount Hira to practice meditation and to get balanced emotional and intellectual state.
Quran says
“The patient, the true, the obedient, those who spend (in the way of Allah), and
those who seek forgiveness before dawn”39
Due to meditation, the Holy Prophet was able to get balance between spiritualty and
logic necessary for supreme convincing power. There are a lot of acts, sayings and quotations of
the Prophet which we can use as therapy for different psychological and physical disorders.
“They are the repenters, the worshipers, the praisers, the meditators, the
bowing and prostrating, the advocators of righteousness and forbidders
of evil, and the keepers of GOD's laws. Give good news to such
believers” 40
Meditation needs your full attention to eliminate stressful thoughts which is creating
issues in the mind. Meditation is practiced in a specific place where no disturbance occurs. It
will give you a sense of relaxation and quietness, which is necessary for both emotional and
physical well-being.
“During the night, you shall meditate for extra credit, that your Lord may
raise you to an honorable rank. And say, "My Lord, admit me an
honorable admittance, and let me depart an honorable departure, and
grant me from You a powerful support” 41
It also produces coping to fight against stressful thoughts and feelings. Meditation will
keep you centered with internal peace and harmony. According to Thanvi there are five stages
of Muraqiba. They are Yajis, Khatir, Hadees e Nafs, Hum and Azam. Lack of mindfulness to
present is the barrier in progress.42
17
(Dec-2022) Vol. 2 No. 4
the time in the khanqah the client was dealt in groups but they were also free to discuss issues
individually. The clients were engaged in different activities like listening of speeches and
exercises in groups. From his books it is identified that there was no specific number of
sessions. It was fixed after assessment and recovery from first session.43
The procedure and techniques of therapy used by the Holy Prophet and great Muslim
scholars are also currently prevalent in modern day therapies. Technique of group therapy is
utilized in common societal issues like drug addiction treatment, students’ academic and
common classrooms issues. Through group therapy we can enhance sense of hope and self-
esteem and self-confidence among group members. Therapy of all types need consistent
sessions to get the maximum results. In this regard Prophet says
“The most beloved deeds to Allah are those that are the most consistent, even they are
few” 44
As an active member of individual or group therapy the clients are required to resent
and involve their self in all the activities and obey the directions of the therapist. The clients
must care about starting and termination timing of the session. All the names and information
of all the clients in the group will be confidential for both therapist and clients. They will not
share this information with irrelevant persons out of the group members.
“Truly God alters not what is in a people until they alter what is in themselves”45
The Nafs presents different ideas and thoughts to the person. It tries to distract them
from good deeds to evil deeds. The person should suppress his Nafs to follow the right path of
Deen. While treating the Nafs a person should set aside for a short time in the morning and
night before going to bed. A person should sit alone and try to free the heart from all thoughts.
Quran Says
“It is God who purifies whomsoever He will, and they shall not be wronged so
much as the thread of a date stone”46
Guide your Nafs like “O Nafs! You are like a merchant in this world. Your capital is your
life and its profit is that world, it should attain salvation in the hereafter. If you attained the
goal your wealth, your business will be considered profitable. If you have not attained the goal
(salvation) you have lost great. The time is very precious. It can’t return in the life”. O Nafs be
grateful to Allah that his granted you another day in life. Make taubah from all your sins and
never commit them again. You will spend that entire day in remembrance and obedience of
Allah. Guide your Nafs and reform yourself to follow straight path towards Allah on daily
basis.47
Conclusion
Islam the most growing religion of the world. Islamic codes are those principles of Allah
revealed through the Holly Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). These codes are practiced with full
enthusiasm from the date of revelation to till date by all Muslims without any discrimination.
Islam is the religion of oneness of God and equality. Acts of the Holy prophet are also weight
like sacred codes and it is necessary for Muslims to obey these acts. From the mentioned
literature it is concluded that the Muslim psychologists must be aware from the methods of
spiritual healing used by the Holy Prophet or great Muslim scholars. The contemporary Muslim
18
ISLAMIC PSYCHOLOGY IN THE VIEW OF MAULANA ASHRAF ALI THANVI………REVIEW
psychologist must try to take help from the techniques of early Muslim scholars. These
techniques have universal efficiency by obtaining strong association between the contaminated
soul and God. They are also suggested to take interest in traditional psychotherapy methods
and adopt them according to their own culture and religion.
REFERENCES:
1
Ibn Majah no. 3055
2
Qur’ān, Sura Al-Nāzi’āt, 79: 40-41.
3
Sunan Ibn Majah no. 4142
4
Qur’ān, Sura an-Nisa 04;59
5
Sham, F. M. (2015). Islamic Psychotherapy Approach In Managing Adolescent Hysteria In Malaysia. J
Psychol Abnorm Child 4: 142
6
Haque, A. (2004). Psychology from Islamic Perspective: Contributions of Early Muslim Scholars and
Challenges to Contemporary Muslim Psychologists. Journal of Religion and Health, Vol. 43, No. 4.
7
Haque, A. and Mohamed, Y. (Eds.) (2009). Psychology of Personality: Islamic Perspectives. Pp.
295.Cengage: Singapore
8
Al-Karam, C.Y. (2018). Islamically Integrated Psychotherapy: Uniting Faith and Professional Practice.
Templeton Press.
9
Kaplick, P. & Skinner, R (2017). The evolving Islam and Psychology Movement. European Psychologist, 22,
3, 198-204
10
Mansoor, A., A. (1998). Muslim Nafsiyat. Sham k bad Publications. Lahore. A Bahawalpure Road. PP 188-
210.
11
Rothman, A., & Coyle, A. (2018). Toward a Framework for Islamic Psychology and Psychotherapy: An
Islamic Model of the Soul. Journal of Religion and Health
12
Haque, A., & Keshaverzi, H. (2014). Integrating indigenous healing methods in therapy: Muslim beliefs and
practices. International Journal of Culture and Mental Health. Vol. 7, No.3, PP 297-314
13
Qur’ān, Sura an-Anfal 08;08
14
Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī no. 52
15
Al-Mu’jam al-Kabīr 1643
16
Basharat, Tahira. "A Comparative Study of the Personality Formulates of Ghazali and Freud." Journal of
Islamic Thought and Civilization 10, no. 2 (2020): 223-242.
17
Skinner, R. (2010) An Islamic approach to psychology and mental health, Mental Health, Religion &
Culture, 13:6, 547-551
18
Thanvi, A. A. (n.d.). Islah-e-Dil (Amelioration of the Heart). 297 pages, Umar Faruq Publishers, Karachi,
Pakistan
19
Thanvi, A. A. (n.d.). Tarbiah as-Salik. 1736 pages. Zamzam Publishers, Karachi, Pakistan
20
Yasmin Nilofer Farooqi (2006) Understanding Islamic Perspective of Mental Health and
Psychotherapy, Journal of Psychology in Africa, 16:1, 101-111
21
Deuraseh, N., Abu Talib, M. (2005). Mental health in Islamic medical tradition, The International Medical
Journal. 4(2), 76-78.
22
Amber Haque & Hooman Keshavarzi (2014) Integrating indigenous healing methods in therapy: Muslim
beliefs and practices, International Journal of Culture and Mental Health, 7:3, 297-314
23
Qur’ān, Sura al- Imran 03;176
24
Keskinoğlu, M., & Ekşi, H. (2019). Islamic spiritual counseling techniques. Spiritual Psychology and
Counseling, 4, 333–350
25
Azhar, M. Z.,& Varma, S. L. (1995). Religious psychotherapy as management of bereavement
Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 91(4), 233–235
26
Ali, I., S. (2007). Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi ka Tariq e Islah (Urdu). Lahore. Bait ul Uloom. Purani Anar Kali.
PP 293-310.
27
Frame, M. W. (2003). Integrating religion and spirituality into counseling: A comp sive approach. Pacific
Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole
28
Tan, S. Y. (2007). Use of prayer and Scripture in cognitive-behavioral therapy. Journal of Psychology and
Christianity, 26, 101-111.
29
Khan, H.Z., Mughal, I., and Khan,Y. (2013). Combination of Psychological and Religious Intervention in
Reducing Psychological Distress among University Students. Dialogue,8(3),261-272
19
(Dec-2022) Vol. 2 No. 4
30
Febbraro, A. R. G. (2005). An Investigation Into the Effectiveness of Bibliotherapy and Minimal Contact
Interventions in the Treatment of Panic Attacks. Journal Of Clınıcal Psychology, 61, 6, 763-779.
31
Gavigan K. W. & Kurtts S. (2011). Using Children’s and Young Adult Literature in Teaching Acceptance and
Understanding of Individual Differences. The Delta Kappa Gamma Bulletin, 77(2), 11-16
32
Rapee, R. M., Abbott, M. J.& Lyneham, H. J. (2006). “Bibliotherapy for children with anxiety disorders
using written materials for parents: a randomized controlled trial”, Journal of Consulting and Clinical
Psychology, 74, (3), 436-444.
33
McCulliss D. (2012). Bibliotherapy: historical and research perspectives. Journal of Poetry Therapy, 25, (1)
23-38
34
Naylor, V. E. vd. (2010). Bibliotherapy as a treatment for depression in primary care, journal of clinical
psychology in medical settings, 17, (3) 258-271
35
Majeed A, Jabir K (2017), The Contribution of Muslims and Islamic Concepts: Rethinking and Establishing
the Actual Origin of Concepts and Thought in Psychology ,International Journal of Indian Psychology,
Volume 4 (2)
36
Aten, J.,& Leach, M. (Eds.). (2009). Spirituality and the therapeutic process: A com- prehensive resource
from intake through termination. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
37
Bibi, A., Arouj, K. (2015). Group therapy of Ashraf Ali Thanvi in present era. Conference Proceeding. 2nd
International Conference on Mental Health. International Islamic University Islamabad, Pakistan
38
Utz, A. (2011). Psychology from the Islamic perspective. Riyadh: International Islamic Publishing House
39
Quran; Surat Al Imran 3;17
40
Quran: Surat A-Tawba, 9:112
41
Quran; Al-Isra, 17:79-80.
42
Isgandarova, N. (2018). Muraqaba as a Mindfulness-Based Therapy in Islamic Psychotherapy. Journal of
Religion and Health. 58(4), 1146-1160.
43
Al-Thani, A. (2012). The person-centred approach and the Islamic view of counselling. Healthcare
Counselling & Psychotherapy Journal, 12(1)
44
Sahih Al Bukhari, no 6464.
45
Quran Surat al-Raʿd 13: 11.
46
Quran Surat al Nisāʾ 4: 40.
47
Hussein, R. G. (2015). Islamic counselling: An introduction to theory and practice. USA: Taylor & Francis
Group
20