Unit 5
Unit 5
Unit 5
Protoplast fusion is a physical method of fusion of somatic cells from different plant to form
hybrid.
Mixing of protoplasts of two different genomes and can be achieved by either spontaneous
or induced fusion methods.
The effect of high pH and calcium ions on the fusion of tobacco protoplasts was first
studied by Keller and Melchers (1973) .
In their method, isolated protoplasts are centrifuged for 3 min at 50x g in a fusion-inducing
solution of 0.5 M mannitol containing 0.05 M CaCl2·2H2O at a pH of 10.5.
The centrifuge tubes containing the protoplasts are then incubated in a water bath at 37°C
for 40–50 min.
After this treatment, 20–50% of the protoplasts were involved in fusion.
Kao and Michayluk (1974) and Wallin et al. (1974) developed PEG method of fusion of
protoplasts.
This is one of the most successful techniques for fusing protoplasts.
The protoplasts are suspended in a solution containing high molecular weight PEG, which
improves agglutination and fusion of protoplasts in several species.
When adequate amount of protoplasts are available, 1 ml of the protoplasts suspended in
a culture medium are mixed with 1 ml of 28–56% PEG (1500 –6000 MW) solution.
The tube is then shaken for 5 sec and allowed to settle for 10 min.
To remove PEG, the protoplasts are then washed several times by the addition of
protoplast culture medium.
The protoplast preparation is again suspended in the culture medium.
The PEG method is popular for protoplast fusion as it yields in reproducible high-frequency
heterokaryon formation, low cytotoxicity to most cell types and the formation of binucleate
heterokaryons.
PEG-induced fusion is non- specific and is thus applicable for interspecific, intergeneric or
interkingdom fusions.
Both the molecular weight and the concentration of PEG are critical in inducing successful
fusions.
PEG less than 100 molecular weight is not able to produce tight adhesions while that
ranging up to 6000 molecular weight can be more effective per mole in inducing fusions.
At higher molecular weight PEG produces too viscous a solution which cannot be handled
properly.
Treatment with PEG in the presence of/or by high pH/Ca++ is reported to be most
effective in enhancing the fusion frequency and survivability of protoplasts.
iv. Electrofusion:
Protoplasts are placed in to a small culture cell containing electrodes, and a potential
difference is applied due to which protoplasts line up between the electrodes.
If now an extremely short wave electric shock is applied, protoplasts can be induced to
fuse.
In this fusion method, two-step procedure is followed beginning with application of an
alternating current (AC) of low intensity to protoplast suspension.
Dielectrophoretic collectors adjusted to 1.5 V and 1 MHz and an electrical conductivity of
the suspension medium less than 10–5 sec/cm generate an electrophoresis effect that
make the cells attach to each other along the field lines.
The second step of injection of an electric direct current (DC) field pulse of high intensity
(750– 1000 V/cm) for a short duration of 20–50 μsec leads to breakdown of membranes in
contact areas of adjacent cells resulting in fusion and consequent membrane
reorganization.
This electrofusion technique has been found to be simple, quick and efficient. Cells after
electrofusion do not show cytotoxic response.
However, this method did not receive much acceptance because specialized equipment is
required.
Membranes of protoplasts are stuck together by fusogen get fused at the point of adhesion
resulting in the formation of cytoplasmic bridges between the protoplasts.
Plant protoplasts carry a negative charge from –10 to –30 mV.
Due to common charge, the plasma membranes of two agglutinated protoplasts do not
come close enough to fuse.
Fusion requires that membranes must be first brought close together at a distance of 10Å
or less.
The high pH–high Ca++ ions treatment has shown to neutralize the normal surface charge
so that agglutinated protoplasts can come in intimate contact.
High temperature promotes membrane fusion due to perturbance of lipid molecules in
plasma membrane and fusion occurs due to intermingling of lipid molecules in membranes
of agglutinated protoplasts.
PEG agglutinates to form clumps of protoplasts.
Tight adhesion may occur over a large or small localized area.
Localized fusion of closely attached plasma membranes occurs in the regions of tight
adhesion and results in the formation of cytoplasmic bridges.
It has been further suggested that PEG, which is slightly negative in polarity can form
hydrogen bonds with water, protein, carbohydrates, etc. which are positive in polarity.
When the PEG molecule chain is large enough it plays role as a molecular bridge between
the surface of adjacent protoplasts and adhesion occurs.
SOMATIC HYBRIDIZATION.
The somatic hybridization involves three aspects. The three aspects are: (A) Fusion of
Protoplasts (B) Selection of Hybrid Cells and (C) Identification of Hybrid Plants.
The conventional method to improve the characteristics of cultivated plants, for years, has
been sexual hybridization. The major limitation of sexual hybridization is that it can be
performed within a plant species or very closely related species. This restricts the
improvements that can be done in plants.
The species barriers for plant improvement encountered in sexual hybridization can be
overcome by somatic cell fusion that can form a viable hybrids. Somatic hybridization
broadly involves in vitro fusion of isolated protoplasts to form a hybrid cell and its
subsequent development to form a hybrid plant.
Plant protoplasts are of immense utility in somatic plant cell genetic manipulations and
improvement of crops. Thus, protoplasts provide a novel opportunity to create cells with new
genetic constitution. And protoplast fusion is a wonderful approach to overcome sexual
incompatibility between different species of plants. More details on the applications of
somatic hybridization are given later.
Somatic hubridization involves the following aspects:
A. Fusion of protoplasts
B. Selection of hybrid cells
C. Identification of hybrid plants.
A. Fusion of Protoplasts:
As the isolated protoplasts are devoid of cell walls, there in vitro fusion becomes relatively
easy. There are no barriers of incompatibility (at interspecific, inter-generic or even at inter-
kingdom levels) for the protoplast fusion. Protoplast fusion that involves mixing of
protoplasts of two different genomes can be achieved by spontaneous, mechanical, or induced
fusion methods.
Spontaneous fusion:
Cell fusion is a natural process as is observed in case of egg fertilization. During the course of
enzymatic degradation of cell walls, some of the adjoining protoplasts may fuse to form
homokaryocytes (homokaryons). These fused cells may sometimes contain high number of
nuclei (2-40).
PEG treatment method is widely used protoplast fusion as it has several advantages:
i. It results in a reproducible high-frequency of heterokaryon formation.
ii. Low toxicity to cells.
iii. Reduced formation of bi-nucleate heterokaryons.
iv. PEG-induced fusion is non-specific and therefore can be used for a wide range of plants.
Electro-fusion:
In this method, electrical field is used for protoplast fusion. When the protoplasts are placed
in a culture vessel fitted with micro- electrodes and an electrical shock is applied, protoplasts
are induced to fuse. Electro-fusion technique is simple, quick and efficient and hence
preferred by many workers.
Further, the cells formed due to electro-fusion do not show cytotoxic responses as is the case
with the use of fusogens (including PEG). The major limitation of this method is the
requirement of specialized and costly equipment.
Mechanism of fusion:
The fusion of protoplasts involves three phases agglutination, plasma membrane fusion and
formation of heterokaryons.
1. Agglutination (adhesion):
When two protoplasts are in close contact with each other, adhesion occurs. Agglutination
can be induced by fusogens e.g. PEG, high pH and high Ca2+.
2. Plasma membrane fusion:
Protoplast membranes get fused at localized sites at the points of adhesion. This leads to the
formation of cytoplasmic bridges between protoplasts. The plasma membrane fusion can be
increased by high pH and high Ca2+, high temperature and PEC, as explained below.
(a) High pH and high Ca2+ ions neutralize the surface charges on the protoplasts. This allows
closer contact and membrane fusion between agglutinated protoplasts.
(b) High temperature helps in the intermingling of lipid molecules of agglutinated protoplast
membranes so that membrane fusion occurs.
(c) PEG causes rapid agglutination and formation of clumps of protoplasts. This results in the
formation of tight adhesions of membranes and consequently their fusion.
3. Formation of heterokaryons:
The fused protoplasts get rounded as a result of cytoplasmic bridges leading to the formation
of spherical homokaryon or heterokaryon.
B. Selection of Hybrid Cells:
About 20-25% of the protoplasts are actually involved in the fusion. After the fusion process,
the protoplast population consists of a heterogenous mixture of un-fused chloroplasts,
homokaryons and heterokaryons (Fig. 44.5). It is therefore necessary to select the hybrid cells
(heterokaryons). The commonly used methods employed for the selection of hybrid cells are
biochemical, visual and cytometric methods.
Fusion Products of Protoplasts
Biochemical methods:
The biochemical methods for selection of hybrid cells are based on the use of biochemical
compounds in the medium (selection medium). These compounds help to sort out the hybrid
and parental cells based on their differences in the expression of characters.
Drug sensitivity and auxotrophic mutant selection methods are described below:
1. Drug sensitivity:
This method is useful for the selection hybrids of two plant species, if one of them is sensitive
to a drug. Protoplasts of Petunia hybride (species A) can form macroscopic callus on MS
medium, but are sensitive to (inhibited by) actinomycin D. Petunia parodii protoplasts
(species B) form small colonies, but are resistant to actinomycin D.
When these two species are fused, the fused protoplasts derive both the characters —
formation of macroscopic colonies and resistance to actinomycin D on MS medium. This
helps in the selection of hybrids (Fig. 44.6). The parental protoplasts of both the species fail
to grow. Protoplasts of P. parodii form very small colonies while that of P. hybrida are
inhibited by actinomycin D.
Drug Sensitivity Method
Drug sensitivity technique was originally developed by Power et al (1976) for the selection of
hybrids of Petunia sp. A similar procedure is in use for the selection of other somatic hybrids
e.g., hybrids between Nicotiana Silvestre’s and Nicotiana knightiana.
2. Auxotrophic mutants:
Auxotroph’s are mutants that cannot grow on a minimal medium and therefore require
specific compounds to be added to the medium. Nitrate reductase deficient mutants of
tobacco (N. tabacum) are known. The parental protoplasts of such species cannot grow with
nitrate as the sole source of nitrogen while the hybrids can grow.
Two species of nitrate reductase deficiency— one due to lack of apoenzyme (nia-type
mutant) and the other due to lack of molybdenum cofactor (cnx- type mutant) are known. The
parental protoplasts cannot grow on nitrate medium while the hybrid protoplasts can grow
(Fig. 44.7).
Asymmetric hybrids have abnormal or wide variations in the chromosome number than the
exact total of two species. These hybrids are usually formatted with full somatic complement
of one parental species while all or nearly all of the chromosomes of other parental species
are lost during mitotic divisions. Asymmetric hybrids may be regarded as cybrids but for the
introgressed genes.
As given in Table 44.3, protoplast fusion between N. tabacum (2n = 48) and N. nesophila (2n
= 24) results in a symmetric hybrids, while asymmetric hybrids are formed when B. napus
and B. junea are fused.
Cybrids:
The cytoplasmic hybrids where the nucleus is derived from only one parent and the
cytoplasm is derived from both the parents are referred to as cybrids. The phenomenon of
formation of cybrids is regarded as cybridization. Normally, cybrids are produced when
protoplasts from two phytogenetically distinct species are fused. Genetically, cybrids are
hybrids only for cytoplasmic traits.
Hybrids formed despite somatic incompatibility may exhibit structural and developmental
abnormalities. Several generations may be required to eliminate the undesirable genes. Due to
this limitation in somatic hybridization, cybridization involving protoplast fusion for partial
genome transfer is gaining importance in recent years.
Methodology of Cybridization:
A diagrammatic representation of the formation of hybrids and cybrids is given in Fig. 44.9.
As the formation of heterokaryon occurs during hybridization, the nuclei can be stimulated to
segregate so that one protoplast contributes to the cytoplasm while the other contributes
nucleus alone (or both nucleus and cytoplasm). In this way cybridization can be achieved.
Some of the approaches of cybridization are given hereunder:
1. The protoplasts of cytoplasm donor species are irradiated with X-rays or Ƴ-rays. This
treatment renders the protoplasts inactive and non-dividing, but they are efficient donors of
cytoplasmic constituents when fused with recipient protoplasts.
4. It is possible to suppress nuclear division in some protoplasts and fuse them with normal
protoplasts.
Somatic Hybrids
Applications of Cybrids:
Cybridization is a wonderful technique wherein the desired cytoplasm can be transferred in a
single step. Cybrids are important for the transfer of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS),
antibiotic and herbicide resistance in agriculturally useful plants.
Some of the genetic traits in certain plants are cytoplasmically controlled. This includes some
types of male sterility, resistance to certain antibiotics and herbicides. A selected list of
agronomic characters transferred through cybrids is given in Table 44.5 (along with somatic
hybrids).
Cybridization has been successfully used to transfer CMS in rice. Cybrids of Brassica
raphanus that contain nucleus of B. napus, chloroplasts of atrazinc resistant B. campestris and
male sterility from Raphanus sativas have been developed.
1. Disease resistance:
Several interspecific and inter-generic hybrids with disease resistance have been created.
Many disease resistance genes (e.g., tobacco mosaic virus, potato virus X, club rot disease)
could be successfully transferred from one species to another. For example, resistance has
been introduced in tomato against diseases such as TMV, spotted wilt virus and insect pests.
2. Environmental tolerance:
The genes responsible for the tolerance of cold, frost and salt could be successfully
introduced through somatic hybridization, e.g., introduction of cold tolerance gene in tomato.
3. Quality characters:
Somatic hybrids for the production of high nicotine content, and low erucic acid have been
developed (Table 44.5).
ADVERTISEMENTS:
2. Protoplast fusion will help in the combination of mitochondria and chloroplasts to result in
a unique nuclear-cytoplasmic genetic combination.
3. Somatic hybridization can be done in plants that are still in juvenile phase.
The success of the technique largely depends on overcoming these limitations, some of which
are listed below:
1. Somatic, hybridization does not always produce plants that give fertile and visible seeds.
2. Regenerated plants obtained from somatic hybridization are often variable due to
somaclonal variations, chromosomal elimination, organelle segregation etc.
4. Protoplast fusion between different species/genus is easy, but the production of viable
somatic hybrids is not possible in all instances.
5. Some of the somatic hybrids, particularly when produced by the fusion of taxonomically
different partners, are unbalanced and not viable.
6. There are limitations in the selection methods of hybrids, as many of them are not efficient.