Harvard Rules of Procedure
Harvard Rules of Procedure
Harvard Rules of Procedure
&
GENERAL GUIDE
5. Motions
Motions are specific actions made to direct debate in a certain direction.
Motions should be raised for caucuses which can be:
Moderated Caucus: moderated by the chair board, moderated caucuses are for
the purpose if closed debate on a specific topic and have a designated time limit.
Delegates can speak once the chair has added them to the speakers list and given
recognition.
Unmoderated Caucus: unmoderated by the chair board, unmoderated caucuses
are lobbying sessions with designated time in which delegates are free to roam
around the committee room and communicate with other delegates, mainly used
for the preparation and editing of documents.
e.g. “The delegate of … would like to raise a motion for a moderated caucus to
discuss …for 10 minutes and individual speaking time being 45 seconds.”
Moderated Caucuses are substantive motions, therefore voting by acclimation is
the method used. This is done by delegates stating their seconds or objections. If
there are any objections, a simple majority vote must be reached.
e.g., “The delegate of … would like to raise a motion for an unmoderated caucus
to … for 15 minutes”
Unmoderated caucus motions are voted upon in a similar manner to a moderated
caucus.
Extension motions can be raised for both types of caucuses and must be under
the time limit of the original motion.
e.g. “The delegate of … would like to raise a motion for an extension of the
previous moderated caucus for 7 minutes”
Order of precedence for motions:
1. Motion for extension
2. Motion for an unmoderated caucus
3. Motion for a moderated caucus
Precedence is also given to the “most disruptive” motions, meaning most time
consuming will be taken to a vote first. If moderated caucuses have the same time
limit but different speaking times, the moderated caucus that allows for more
speakers shall take precedent.
6. Working Papers and Draft Resolutions
The first set of solutions and ideas drafted upon the topic is called a working
paper. A working paper has no specific format and is simply the ideas that
delegates hope to guide to the resolution through negotiations and compromise.
The working paper is then submitted to the chair board and can be turned into a
draft resolution through debate and lobbying.
Note: Any written document that is not submitted to the Committee Board is not
considered an official document of the committee.
The draft resolution should be in correct format and has predetermined parts.
These include:
1. Heading: name of the committee, topic, sponsors and signatories
a. Sponsors are the initial drafters of a document,
b. Signatories are the delegates that would like the document to be debated on
and usually have supported, assisted or approved its culmination.
2. Preambulatory Clauses: points that define and acknowledge the issues –
preambulatory phrases must be used to start these clauses
3. Operative Clauses: specifications of the solutions for the given issue – operative
phrases must be used to start these clauses.
The main submitter of a draft resolution must then introduce it and present it to
the committee.