International Finance and Trade (Emba) 5207 2011 Edition
International Finance and Trade (Emba) 5207 2011 Edition
International Finance and Trade (Emba) 5207 2011 Edition
=
n
t
t
m
j
t j t j
k
1 =
1
, ,
1
ER E CF E
= Value
E (CF
j,t
) = expected cash flows in currency j to be received
by the U.S. parent at the end of period t
E (ER
j,t
) = expected exchange rate at which currency j can
be converted to dollars at the end of period t
k = weighted average cost of capital of the parent
Direct Intervention
Indirect Intervention
Practice Questions
1. State and explain reasons why the Central Bank of Zimbabwe should use indirect intervention to
change the value of the local currency.
2. Should the Government of Zimbabwe allow its currency to float freely? What would be the
advantages of letting it currency float freely? What would be the disadvantages for this approach?
35
Chapter Five
Foreign Exchange Exposure Measurement and Management
Learning Outcomes
To be able to understand and discuss the MNCs exposure to exchange rate risk
To be able to understand the nature of transaction exposure and how it can be
measured
To be able to understand the nature of economic exposure and how it be measured
To be able to understand the nature of translation exposure and how it can be
measured.
To learn about commonly used methods of hedging the firms transaction exposure
To understand the various methods and hedging and their advantages and disadvantages.
KEY TERMS
EXCHANGE RATE EXPOSURE EXCHANGE RATE RISK
TRANSACTION EXPOSURE TRANSLATION EXPOSURE
ECONOMIC EXPOSURE ACCOUNTING EXPOSURE
OPERATIONAL RISK CURRENCY FUTURES
MARKET HEDGE FORWARD RATE CONTRACT
FUTURES CONTRACT
5.1. Risks i n International Trade
It is an established argument that a firm can increase its market value by reducing the
variability of its cash flows (operational risk) and which in the case of exchange rate risk
hedging is instrumental.
While exchange rate risk is the major risk in international trade, there are other risks that are
not related to foreign exchange rate risk. These are:
i) Default Risk: The exporter may not ship the goods at all after the sale contract i.e.
fails to perform the contract (performance risk)
ii) Delivery Risk: The goods shipped may not conform to the contracts specifications.
iii) Credit Risk: The importer may fail to pay, or pay too little or too late.
iv) Transfer risk: The importers country may have run out of the foreign exchange
reserves by the time the payment is due and therefore no
remittance
5.1.2. Transaction exposure : is a type of foreign exchange risk faced by companies that
engage in international trade. It is the risk that exchange rate
fluctuations will change the value of a contract before it is settled.
Transaction exposure is also called transaction risk.
Transaction exposure is the risk that foreign exchange rate changes
will adversely affect a cross
A cross
A business contract may extend over a period of months. Foreign
exchange rates can fluctuate instantaneously. Once a cross
contract has be
a specific amount of money, subsequent fluctuations in exchange
rates can change the value of that contract.
Managing Transaction Exposure
This model illustrates the impact of transaction exposure on
cash flows
FIGURE 5.1 Impact of Transaction Exposure on MNC Cashflows.
Transaction exposure exists when the future cash transactions of a firm are affected by exchange
rate fluctuations. When transaction exposure exists, the firm
Identify its degree of transaction exposure,
Decide whether to hedge its exposure, and
Choose among the available hedging techniques if it decides on hedging.
A company that has agreed to but not yet settled a cross
exposure as any change to the exchange rate will impair the
time between the agreement and the settlement of the contrac
associated with exchange rate fluctuation
36
Transaction exposure is the risk that foreign exchange rate changes
will adversely affect a cross-currency transaction before it is settled.
A cross-currency transaction is one that involves multiple currencies.
A business contract may extend over a period of months. Foreign
exchange rates can fluctuate instantaneously. Once a cross
contract has been agreed upon, for a specific quantity of goods and
a specific amount of money, subsequent fluctuations in exchange
rates can change the value of that contract.
Managing Transaction Exposure
This model illustrates the impact of transaction exposure on
cash flows (see Figure 5.1).
Impact of Transaction Exposure on MNC Cashflows.
Transaction exposure exists when the future cash transactions of a firm are affected by exchange
rate fluctuations. When transaction exposure exists, the firm faces three major tasks:
Identify its degree of transaction exposure,
Decide whether to hedge its exposure, and
Choose among the available hedging techniques if it decides on hedging.
A company that has agreed to but not yet settled a cross-currency contract that has transaction
as any change to the exchange rate will impair the companys cash flows. The greater the
time between the agreement and the settlement of the contract Equation, the greater the risk
associated with exchange rate fluctuations.
Transaction exposure is the risk that foreign exchange rate changes
ncy transaction before it is settled.
currency transaction is one that involves multiple currencies.
A business contract may extend over a period of months. Foreign
exchange rates can fluctuate instantaneously. Once a cross-currency
en agreed upon, for a specific quantity of goods and
a specific amount of money, subsequent fluctuations in exchange
This model illustrates the impact of transaction exposure on MNC
Transaction exposure exists when the future cash transactions of a firm are affected by exchange
ct that has transaction
The greater the
, the greater the risk
37
5.1.2.1. Transaction Risk Example
For example, lets say a domestic company signs a contract with a foreign company. The contract
states that the domestic company will ship 1,000 units of product to the foreign company and the
foreign company will pay for the goods in 3 months with 100 units of foreign currency. Assume the
current exchange rate is: 1 unit of domestic currency equals 1 unit of foreign currency. The money
the foreign company will pay the domestic company is equal to 100 units of domestic currency.
The domestic company, the one that is going to receive payment in a foreign currency, now has
transaction exposure. The value of the contract is exposed to the risk of exchange rate fluctuations.
The next day the exchange rate changes and then remains constant at the new exchange rate for 3
months. Now one unit of domestic currency is worth 2 units of foreign currency. The foreign
currency has devalued against the domestic currency. Now the value of the 100 units of foreign
currency that the foreign company will pay the domestic company has changed the payment is
now only worth 50 units of domestic currency.
The contract still stands at 100 units of foreign currency, because the contract specified payment in
the foreign currency. However, the domestic firm suffered a 50% loss in value.
5.2. Hedging Transaction Risk
A company engaging in cross-currency transactions can protect against transaction exposure by
hedging. The company can protect against the transaction risk by purchasing foreign currency, by
using currency swaps, by using currency futures, or by using a combination of these hedging
techniques. Any one of these techniques can be used to fix the value of the cross-currency contract
in advance of its settlement.
5.2.1. A forward contract or simply a forward is an agreement between two parties to buy
or sell an asset at a certain future time for a certain price agreed today. This is in
contrast to a spot contract, which is an agreement to buy or sell an asset today. It
costs nothing to enter a forward contract. The party agreeing to buy the underlying
asset in the future assumes a long position, and the party agreeing to sell the asset in
the future assumes a short position. The price agreed upon is called the delivery
price, which is equal to the forward price at the time the contract is entered into.
The price of the underlying instrument, in whatever form, is paid before control of
the instrument changes. This is one of the many forms of buy/sell orders where the
time of trade is not the time where the securities themselves are exchanged.
The forward price of such a contract is commonly contrasted with the spot price,
which is the price at which the asset changes hands on the spot date. The difference
between the spot and the forward price is the forward premium or forward
discount, generally considered in the form of a profit, or loss, by the purchasing
party.
Forwards, like other derivative securities, can be used to hedge risk (typically
currency or exchange rate risk), as a means of speculation, or to allow a party to take
advantage of a quality of the underlying instrument which is time-sensitive.
5.2.2. Money Market Hedges
38
Objective: borrow/lend to lock in home currency value of cash flow
1. Expected Inflow of Foreign Currency: Borrow present value of the foreign currency at a
fixed interest and convert it into home currency. Deposit the home currency at a fixed
interest rate. When the foreign currency is received, use it to pay off the foreign
currency loan.
Expected Outflow of Foreign Currency: Determine PV of the foreign currency to be paid
(using foreign currency interest rate as the discount rate). Borrow equivalent amount of
home currency (considering spot exchange rate). Convert the home currency into PV
equivalent of the foreign currency (in the spot market now) and make a foreign currency
deposit on payment day, withdraw the foreign currency deposit (which by the time
equals the payable amount) and make payment.
Example
A US firm is expected to pay A$300,000 to an Australian supplier 3 months from now.
A$ interest rate is 12% and US$ interest rate is 8%. Spot rate is 0.60A$/US$.
PV of A$: 300,000/(1+.12/4) = A$291,262.14 Borrow (291,262.14X0.60) US$174,757.28
and convert it to A$291,262.14 at spot rate (0.60/US$) Use the A$ to make an A$
deposit which will grow to A$300,000 in 3 months. Pay this A$300,000 on due date Pay
{174,757.28X(1+0.8/4)} US$178,252.43 with interest for settling the US$ loan.
5.3. Conditions for Use of Money Market Hedge strategy
Firms have access to money market for different currencies
The dates of expected future cash flows and money market transaction maturity match
offshore currency deposits or Eurocurrency deposits are main money market hedge
instruments.
Comparison: Forward and Money Market Hedge The covered interest parity implies
that a firm cannot be better off using money market hedge compared to forward hedge.
In reality, firms find use of forward contracts more profitable than use of money market
instruments, because firms:
Borrow at a rate> inter-bank offshore lending rate
Put deposits at a rate< inter-bank offshore deposit rate.
A closely related contract is a futures contract; they differ in certain respects. Forward contracts are
very similar to futures contracts, except they are not marked to market, exchange traded, or defined
on standardized assets. Forwards also typically have no interim partial settlements or "true-ups" in
margin requirements like futures - such that the parties do not exchange additional property
securing the party at gain and the entire unrealized gain or loss builds up while the contract is open.
A forward contract arrangement might call for the loss party to pledge collateral or additional
collateral to better secure the party at gain
39
5.4. Measuring and Managing Accounting Exposure.
Accounting exposure, also called translation exposure, refers to the change in the value of a
subsidiary, as given by its financial statements in the reporting currency, when these
statements are translated into the currency of the parent firm.
5.4.1. Concept of Accounting Exposure
Exposure = Total unexpected change on Financial Position of a firm, as measured in
home Current, at Time (t)
Unexpected change in S
t
(Spot exchange rate at time, t)
Equivalently, we can say:
Unexpected effect on the financial position of a firm
= Exposure x Unexpected change in S
t
(Spot exchange rate at a time, t)
Two concepts need to be reconciled here.
Financial position from purely accounting position means Accounting Value Net worth as
given by the financial statements of a firm.
Whereas from the economic exposure perspective, financial position is interpreted to mean
the present value of a firms future cash flows.
In other words, translation exposure measures the impact of exchange rate movement on the
accounting value of a firms foreign subsidiary, while economic exposure measures the effect on
the cash flows and consequently its impact on the market value of a firm.
5.4.2. Translating Financial Statements :
If some of the subsidiaries of a firm are located abroad, their financial statements are
typically maintained in terms of the ruling foreign currency.
It therefore becomes necessary to translate these financial statements into the parents
financial reporting currency for consolidation purposes.
Reasons:
(i) Taxes in the parents home country on income earned by the foreign subsidiary are payable
in home currency. This means that the foreign income has to be translated into the home
currency. Thus, translation exposure, even though it deals with accounting data, can have
an impact on a firms CASH FLOWS through its effect on the taxable amounts
(ii) Most countries require consolidation of the parents and subsidiarys financial statements
for financial reporting purposes.
(iii) A firm may also need to translate the financial statements of foreign subsidiaries in order to
consolidate data in order to make investment and financial decisions.
40
(iv) In order to make performance measures comparable, foreign data need to be translated into
a common currency. Decisions to promote or fire managers are also based on performance.
(v) To value the entire firm, one needs far more than just accounting data. Still, valuation is
often partially based on accounting values; i.e. accounting value serves as a reference point.
If the discounted cash flow value of the entire firm turns out to be four times its book value,
one should surely take a closer look at both types of information. This information might
suggest creative accounting.
5.4.3. Different Translation Methods:
Firms would like to hedge translation exposure to eliminate or reduce the swings in reported
profits resulting from translation effects. This exposure depends on the rules used to
translate the accounts of the subsidiary into the currency of the parent firm.
Approaches:
Basically, there are four different translation methods and philosophies. Each method has a
set of rules for translating items in the balance sheet and the income statement. The rules
for translating items in the income statement are quite similar across the different methods.
Hence we shall concentrate on items reported in the Balance Sheets and rules for their
translation.
(i) The Current/Non-Current Method:
According to this method, current assets and liabilities in the balance sheet are translated at
the current exchange rate as on the translation date, while non-current assets (items) i.e.
long term debt are translated at the historical rate (the rate at which they entered the
companys books)
The logic behind this is that the value of short-term assets and liabilities already reflect
movements in the foreign exchange rate and fluctuate with the exchange rate movements.
Long term assets and liabilities, in contrast, will not be realized in the short-run and by the
time they are realized, the current exchange rate change may turn out to have been undone
by the latter. This is to say the long term realization value of long term assets and liabilities
is very uncertain.
Thus accountants who favour Current/non-current method agree that long term items
should be recorded at the historical exchange rate when they were acquired.
Under the current/non-current method, translation at the current rate is restricted to only
the short term assets and liabilities. This means a measure of the translation exposure is
generally given by the difference between short term assets and liabilities, i.e. Net Working
Capital.
Illustration on Current/Non-Current Method:
41
Historical Historical Current Change
Bal. Sheet Exchange rate Exchange in
Rate Value
(R) (0.333 $/R) (0.300 $/R) ($)
Assets:
Cash & securities 1 000 333 300
A/R 1 000 333 300
Inventory 1 000 333 300
Plant & Equipment 5 000 1 625 1 625
Total (a) 8 000 2 624 2 530 -99
Liabilities:
A/P 500 166.5 150
Short term Debt 2 000 666 600
Long term Debt 2 400 780 780
Total Debts (b) 4 900 1612.5 1 530 -82.5
Net Worth
(a) (b) 3 100 1 011.5 -16.5
Alternatively, this 16.5 US$ can easily be calculated thus
Effect of exchange rate change under the Current/Non-Current Method
42
= (Exposure) X s
= [Current Assets Current Liabilities] X s.
= Net Working Capital X s
= 500 X (0.300 0.333) = - $16.5
To translate the subsidiarys income statement, the current/non-current method uses an
average exchange rate over the period, assuming that cash flows come evenly over the
period except for incomes or costs corresponding to non-current items like depreciation of
assets. These are translated at the same rate as the corresponding balance sheet item to
which they are related.
(ii) The Monetary/Non-Monetary Method:
This method translates monetary items in the Balance sheet using the current exchange
rate. When using this method, the values of claims or liabilities denominated in a dropping
foreign currency drop by the same percentage.
Thus, according to this method, we should adjust only the monetary (not real) assets and
liabilities: items whose values are already fixed by contracts to reflect the changes in
exchange rate.
Effect of Exchange rate Change under the Monetary/Non-Monetary Method: Using the
Previous Example:
= [Exposure] x s
= [Financial Assets Financial liabilities] X s
= $[2 000 4 900] X (0.300 0.333) = + $95.7
To translate the subsidiarys income statement, the monetary/non-monetary method uses
an average exchange rate of the period except for income or costs corresponding to non-
monetary sources like depreciation. These are translated at the same rate as the
corresponding Balance Sheet item.
(iii) The Temporal Method:
The temporal method of translating the financial statements of a foreign subsidiary is similar
to the Monetary/Non-Monetary method. The main difference between the two methods is
that, under the monetary system, inventory is translated at the historical exchange rate,
because it is considered a non-monetary item.
However, under the Temporal Method, inventory may be translated at the current exchange
rate, if it is recorded in the Balance Sheet at the current market prices.
43
By making translation movements part of the reported earnings, it does not allow
firms to maintain reserves for currency losses. Thus, if translation gains and losses
are reflected in the income statement of the firm and it can lead to large swings in
reported earnings (incomplete sentence).
(iv) The Current Rate Method:
This so far is the simplest approach for translating financial statements.
According to the current rate method, all balance sheet items are translated at the current
exchange rate.
Typically, exchange gains are reported separately in a special equity account on the
parents balance sheet, thus avoiding large variations in reported earnings, and
these unrealized gains are not taxed.
Income statement is translated (all items) at the current exchange rate or the average
exchange rate of the reporting period. The first method is chosen for consistency with the
balance sheet translation.
However, the second method is recommended on the argument that expenses that have
been made gradually over the year should be translated at the average exchange rate.
Profits, are realized gradually over the years, and should be translated at an average
exchange rate.
Illustration Using the Previous figures:
Effect of exchange rate change under the current rate method:
= [Exposure] x s
= [Total Assets Total Liabilities] x s
= [Net Worth] x s
= 3 100 x (0.300 0.333)
= -$102.3
5.3. 0 Conclusion on Translation Accounting:
Many accounting regulating bodies favour the current rate method. The International
Accounting Standards Committee (IFRSC) also has endorsed the current rate method.
However, the IFRSC can only provide recommendations; it has no statutory power to impose
accounting rules anywhere.
- However, this still does not answer our dilemma.
44
Although one can still argue that the choice of the translation method does not
affect reality, except possibly through its effects on taxable profits, so that the whole
issue is, basically, a non-issue.
- Accounting data are already complicated enough, so that the current rate method is
probably a good choice, given its simplicity and internal consistency.
- Accounting exposure is limited by the fact that assets are valued at historical costs.
- Accounting exposure is limited by the fact that it is an incomplete measure of the
risks that a firm faces because accounting exposure ignores operating exposure.
That is, there is no room in the financial statements of a firm to reflect the operating
exposure that a firm faces.
- The translation effect can be part of reported income (and, therefore,
taxable/deductible). If the company records the translation gain or loss in the
income statement, in case of a loss, its durability has to be proved to the tax
authorities, otherwise they are disallowed.
Practice Questions
1.Jos Corporation is a South African-based firm and needs R600 000 to finance one of its expansion
projects. It has no business in Switzerland but is considering one year financing in Swiss Francs, because
the annual interest rate would be 5% in Switzerland versus 9% in South Africa. The spot rate of the Swiss
Franc is presently R .6200, while the forward rate is R .6436.
(i) Can Jose benefit by borrowing Swiss Francs and simultaneously purchasing Francs one-year forward
to cover the same contract to avoid exchange rate risk? Explain.
(ii) Assume that Jose does not cover its exposure and expects that the Swiss Franc will appreciate by 5%,
3%, 2% and 1% all with an equal probability of occurrence. Use this information to determine the
probability distribution of the effective financing rates. Show how these would appear in a normal
distribution curve.
(iii) Based on your findings above, should Jose finance with Swiss Francs? Explain.
(iv) Assume that Jose does not cover its exposure and uses the forward rate to forecast the future
spot rate. Determine the expected effective financing rate and comment whether Joses should
finance with Swiss Francs. Explain.
2. Why would a firm consider hedging net payables or net receivables with currency options rather
than forward contracts? What are the disadvantages of hedging with currency options as
opposed to futures contracts?
3. Explain how a firm trying to reduce its transaction exposure can use currency diversification.
45
4. Carbondale Company expects to receive SF 500, 000 in a years time from Switzerland. The existing
spot rate of the Swiss Franc is $.60/1SF. The one-year forward rate of the Swiss franc is $.62/1SF.
Carbondale created a probability distribution for the future spot rate on SF in one year as follows:
Future Spot rate Probability
$.61 20%
$.63 50%
$.67 30%
Assume that a one-year put option (an option to sell) on francs is available, with an exercise price of
$.63/1SF and a premium (price) of $.04 per unit. One-year call option on francs is available with an
exercise price of $.60/1SF and a premium of $.03 per unit. Assume the following money Market
rates.
US SWITZERLAND
Deposit rates 8% 5%
Borrowing rates 9% 6%
Given the above information, determine whether a forward hedge, money market hedge, or a
currency options hedge would be most appropriate (cost effective). Then compare the most
appropriate hedge strategy to an un-hedged strategy, and decide whether Carbondale should hedge
its payables position anyway.
46
Chapter Six
Country Risk Analysis
Learning Outcomes
To identify the common factors used by MNCs to measure a countrys political risk and
financial risk;
To explain the techniques used to measure country risk; and
To explain how the assessment of country risk is used by MNCs when making financial
decisions
KEY TERMS
COUNTRY RISK SOVEREIGN RISK
POLITICAL RISK TRANSFER RISK
COUNTRY RISK RATING
6.1. Country risk refers to the risk of investing in a country, dependent on changes in the business
environment that may adversely affect operating profits or the value of assets in a specific country.
For example, financial factors such as currency controls, devaluation or regulatory changes, or
stability factors such as mass riots, civil war and other potential events contribute to companies'
operational risks. This term is also sometimes referred to as political risk; however, country risk is a
more general term, which generally only refers to risks affecting all companies operating within a
particular country.
6.2. Sovereign Risk concerns whether a government will be unwilling or unable to meet its loan
obligations, or is likely to renege on loans it guarantees. Sovereign risk can relate to transfer risk in
that a government may run out of foreign exchange due to unfavourable developments in its
balance of payments. It also relates to political risk in that a government may decide not to honour
its commitments for political reasons. The Country Risk Analysis literature designates sovereign risk
as a separate category because a private lender faces a unique risk in dealing with a sovereign
government. Should the government decide not to meet its obligations, the private lender
realistically cannot sue the foreign government without its permission.
Sovereign-risk measures of a government's ability to pay are similar to transfer-risk measures.
Measures of willingness to pay require an assessment of the history of a government's repayment
performance, an analysis of the potential costs to the borrowing government of debt repudiation,
and a study of the potential for debt rescheduling by consortiums of private lenders or international
institutions. The international setting may further complicate sovereign risk. In a recent example,
IMF guarantees to Brazil in late 1998 were designed to stop the spread of an international financial
crisis. Had Brazil's imbalances developed before the Asian and Russian financial crises, Brazil
probably would not have received the same level of support, and sovereign risk would have been
higher.
47
6.3. Political risk analysis providers and credit rating agencies use different methodologies to
assess and rate countries' comparative risk exposure. Credit rating agencies tend to use quantitative
econometric models and focus on financial analysis, whereas political risk providers tend to use
qualitative methods, focusing on political analysis. However, there is no consensus on methodology
in assessing credit and political risks.
Political Risk concerns risk of a change in political institutions stemming from a change in
government control, social fabric, or other noneconomic factors. This category covers the potential
for internal and external conflicts, expropriation risk and traditional political analysis. Risk
assessment requires analysis of many factors, including the relationships of various groups in a
country, the decision-making process in the government, and the history of the country. Insurance
exists for some political risks, obtainable from a number of government agencies (such as the
Overseas Private Investment Corporation in the United States) and international organizations (such
as the World Bank's Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency).
Few quantitative measures exist to help assess political risk. Measurement approaches range from
various classification methods (such as type of political structure, range and diversity of ethnic
structure, civil or external strife incidents), to surveys or analyses by political experts. Most services
tend to use country experts who grade or rank multiple socio-political factors and produce a written
analysis to accompany their grades or scales. Company analysts may also develop political risk
estimates for their business through discussions with local country agents or visits to other
companies operating similar businesses in the country. In many risk systems, analysts reduce
political risk to some type of index or relative measure. Unfortunately, little theoretical guidance
exists to help quantify political risk, so many "systems" prove difficult to replicate over time as
various socio-political events ascend or decline in importance in the view of the individual analyst.
6.4. Transfer risk measures typically include the ratio of debt service payments to exports or to
exports plus net foreign direct investment, the amount and structure of foreign debt relative to
income, foreign currency reserves divided by various import categories, and measures related to the
current account status. Trends in these quantitative measures reveal potential imbalances that could
lead a country to restrict certain types of capital flows. For example, a growing current account
deficit as a percent of GDP implies an ever-greater need for foreign exchange to cover that deficit.
The risk of a transfer problem increases if no offsetting changes develop in the capital account.
6.5. Exchange Risk is an unexpected adverse movement in the exchange rate. Exchange risk
includes an unexpected change in currency regime such as a change from a fixed to a floating
exchange rate. Economic theory guides exchange rate risk analysis over longer periods of time (more
than one to two years). Short-term pressures, while influenced by economic fundamentals, tend to
be driven by currency trading momentum best assessed by currency traders. In the short run, risk for
many currencies can be eliminated at an acceptable cost through various hedging mechanisms and
futures arrangements. Currency hedging becomes impractical over the life of the plant or similar
direct investment, so exchange risk rises unless natural hedges (alignment of revenues and costs in
the same currency) can be developed.
Many of the quantitative measures used to identify transfer risk also identify exchange rate risk
since a sharp depreciation of the currency can reduce some of the imbalances that lead to increased
transfer risk. A country's exchange rate policy may help isolate exchange risk. Managed floats, where
the government attempts to control the currency in a narrow trading range, tend to possess higher
risk than fixed or currency board systems. Floating exchange rate systems generally sustain the
lowest risk of producing an unexpected adverse exchange movement. The degree of over- or under-
valuation of a currency also can help isolate exchange rate risk.
48
6.6. Predicting Political Stability
Macro political risk analysis is still an emerging field of study. Political scientists in academia,
industry, and government study country risk for the benefit of multinational firms, government
foreign policy decision makers, and defence planners.
Political risk studies usually include an analysis of the historical stability of the country in question,
evidence of present turmoil or dissatisfaction, indications of economic stability, and trends in
cultural and religious activities. Data are usually assembled by reading local newspapers, monitoring
radio and television broadcasts, reading publications from diplomatic sources, tapping the
knowledge of outstanding expert consultants, contacting other businesspeople who have had recent
experience in the host country, and impressive on site-visits.
Despite this impressive list of activities, the prediction track record of business firms, the diplomatic
service, and the military has been spotty at best. When one analyzes trends, whether in politics or
economics, the tendency is to predict an extension of the same trends. It is a rare forecaster who is
able to predict a cataclysmic change in direction. Who predicted the overthrow of the Shah of Iran
and the ascent of a dogmatic theocratic government there? Who predicted the overthrow of
Ferdinand Marcos in the Philippines? Indeed, who predicted the collapse of communism in the
Soviet Union and its Eastern European satellites? Who predicted the invasion of Kuwait by Iraq in
1990? Who, in early 1997 could have predicted what would happen to Hong Kong after mid-1997?
What does the difference between the Euro-American policy of imposing sanctions on Myanmar
(formerly Burma) and ASEANs policy of engagement imply for the continuation of Myanmars
military regime or its replacement by the National League for Democracy Party of Aung San Suu Kyi?
The Myanmar military placed Aung San Suu Kyi under house arrest in July 1989, the year before her
party won an open and free election, and kept her there until 1995. Is a confrontation policy more or
less likely than a policy of accommodation to lead to policy and economic liberalization?
6.7 Predicting Firm Specific
From the viewpoint of a multinational firm, assessing the policy stability of a host country is only the
first step, since the real objective is to anticipate the effect of political changes on activities of a
specific firm. Indeed, different foreign firms operating within the same country may have very
different degrees of vulnerability to changes in host country policy or regulations. One does not
expect a Kentucky Fried Chicken franchise to experience the same risk as a Fort manufacturing plant.
The need of firm-specific analyses of political risk has led to a demand for tailor-made studies
undertaken in-houseby professional political risk analysis. This demand is heightened by the
observation that outside professional risk analysts rarely even agree on the degree of macro political
risk that exists in any set of countries.
In-house political risk analysts relate the micro-risk attributes of specific countries to the particular
characteristics and vulnerabilities of their client firms. Dan Haendel notes that the framework for
such analysts depends on such attributes as the ratio of a firms foreign to domestic investments,
the political sensitivity of the particular industry, and the degree of diversification. Mineral extractive
frims, manufacturing firms, multinational banks, private insurance companies, and worldwide hotel
chains are all exposed in fundamentally different ways to politically inspired restrictions.
49
Even with the best possible firm-specific analysts, multinational firms cannot be sure that the
political or economic situation will not change. Thus it is necessary to plan protective steps in
advance to minimize the risk of damage from unanticipated changes. Possible protective steps can
be divided into two categories, both of which have financial implications although they are not
finance
6.7. Establishing operation strategies after the investment is made
6.7.1. Negotiating the Environment prior to investment
The best approach to political risk management is to anticipate problems and negotiate
understandings beforehand. Different cultures apply different ethics to the question of honouring
prior contracts, especially when they were negotiated with a previous administration.
Nevertheless, renegotiation of all conceivable areas of conflict provides a better basic for a
successful economic future for both parties than does overlooking the possibility that divergent
objectives will evolve over time.
6.7.2. Negotiating investment agreement
An investment agreement should spell out policies on financial and managerial issues, including the
following:
The basis on which fund flows, such as dividends, management fees, royalties, patent fees,
and loan repayments, may be remitted.
The basis for setting transfer prices.
The right to export to third-country markets.
Obligations to build, or fund, social and economic overhead projects such as schools,
hospitals, and retirement systems.
Methods of taxation, including the rate, the type of taxation, and how the rate base is
determined.
Access to host country capital markets, particularly for long-term borrowing.
Permission for 100% foreign ownership versus required local ownership (joint venture)
participation.
Price controls, if any, applicable to sales in the host country markets.
Requirements for local sourcing versus import of raw materials and components.
Permission to use expatriate managerial and technical personnel, and to bring them and
their personal possessions into the country free of exorbitant visa charges or import duties.
Provisions for arbitration of disputes.
Provisions for planned divestment, should such be required, indicating how the going
concern will be valued and to whom it will be sold.
6.7.3. Investment and Insurance Guarantees.
Multinational firms can sometimes transfer political risk to a home country public agency through an
investment insurance and guarantee programme. Many developed countries have such programmes
to protect investments by their nationals in developing countries.
The U.S investment insurance and guarantee program is managed by the government owned
Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC), organized in 1969 to replace earlier programmes.
OPICs stated purpose is to mobilize and facilitate the participating of U.S private capital and skills in
50
the economic and social progress of less developed friendly countries and areas, there by
complementing the developmental assistance of the United States. OPIC offers insurance coverage
for four separate types of political risk, which have their own specific definitions for insurance
purposes:
Inconvertibility is the risk that the investor will not be able to convert profit, royalties, fees,
or other income, as well as the original capital invested, into dollars.
Expropriation is the risk that the host government takes a specific step which, for one year,
prevents the investor or the foreign affiliate from exercising effective control over use of
the property.
War, revolution, insurrection and civil strife coverage applies primarily to the damage of
physical property of the insured, although in some cases inability of a foreign affiliate to
repay a loan because of a war may be covered.
Business income coverage provides compensation for loss of business income resulting
from events of political violence that directly cause damage to the assets of a foreign
enterprise.
6.7.4. Operating Strategies after investment decision.
Although an investment agreement creates obligations on the part of both the foreign investor and
the host government, conditions change and the agreements are often revised in the light of such
changes. The changed conditions may be economic, or they may result from political changes within
the host government. The firm that sticks rigidly to the legal interpretation of its original agreement
may well find the host government first applies pressure in areas not covered by the agreement and
then possibly reinterprets the agreement to conform to the political reality of that country.
6.9 Techniques of Assessing Country Risk
A checklist approach involves rating and weighting all the identified factors, and then
consolidating the rates and weights to produce an overall assessment.
The Delphi Technique involves collecting various independent opinions and then averaging
and measuring the dispersion of those opinions.
Quantitative analysis techniques like regression analysis can be applied to historical data to
assess the sensitivity of a business to various risk factors.
Inspection visits involve traveling to a country and meeting with government officials, firm
executives, and/or consumers to clarify uncertainties.
Often, firms use a variety of techniques for making country risk assessments.
For example, they may use a checklist approach to develop an overall country risk rating,
and some of the other techniques to assign ratings to the factors considered.
6.10. Developing A Country Risk Rating
A checklist approach will require the following steps:
Assign values and weights to the political risk factors.
Multiply the factor values with their respective weights, and sum up to give the political risk
rating.
Derive the financial risk rating similarly.
Assign weights to the political and financial ratings according to their perceived importance.
Multiply the ratings with their respective weights, and sum up to give the overall country risk
rating
51
Practice Questions
1.Explain how the theory of comparative advantage relates to the need for international
business.
2.Shahs Corporation of the U.S. owns 100% of Finley of Finland. This year Finley - Finland
earned Fim 102 000 000 equal to US $24 000 000 at the current exchange rate of Fim
4.25/1$. The exchange rate is not expected to change in the near future.
Shahs U.S. wants to transfer half of the Finnish earnings to the United States and wonders which is the
best way to remit this sum is:
3.By a cash dividend of US $12 000 000, or By a cash dividend of US $6 000 000 and a royalty of US $6 000
000 .
4.Finish income taxes are 28% and 5% withholding tax, while the US income taxes are 34%. Which of
these methods would you recommend for Shahs to repatriate its earnings?
Give your reasons.
5.Zen Corporation considered establishing a subsidiary in Zenland; it performed a country risk analysis to
help make the decision. It first retrieved a country risk analysis performed about one year earlier, when it
planned to begin a major exporting business to Zenland firms. Then it updated the analysis by
incorporating all current information on the Key variables that were used in that analysis, such as
Zenland's willingness to accept imports, its existing quotas, and existing tariff laws. Is this country risk
analysis adequate? Explain.
6.It was sometimes argued that projects considered for China could be assessed using a higher discount
rate to capture the possibility of new government policies in order to capture this risk when estimating a
project's NPV. Would this method properly distinguish between projects in China that would be
worthwhile and those that will not?
8.Describe the possible errors involved in assessing country risk. In other words, explain why country risk
analysis is always not accurate.
9.Explain an MNCs strategy of diversifying projects internationally in order to maintain a low level of
overall country risk.
10.Explain some methods of reducing exposure to existing country risk, while maintaining the same
amount of business within a particular country.
11.How could a country risk assessment be used to adjust a projects required rate of return?
Alternatively, how can such an assessment be used to adjust a projects estimated cash flow?
52
Chapter Seven
International Treasury Management and Financing
Learning Outcomes
To explain the difference between a subsidiary perspective and a parent perspective in
analyzing cash flows;
To explain the various techniques used to optimize cash flows.
To explain common complications in optimizing cash flows.
To explain the potential benefits and risks of foreign investments.
KEY TERMS
CENTRALIZED CASH MANAGEMENT DECENTRALIZED CASH MANAGEMENT
BLOCKED FUNDS OPTIMIZING CASH FLOWS
HEDGING STRATEGY TREASURY MANAGEMENT
INTERNATIONAL WORKING CAPITAL
7.1.0.. Cash Flow Analysis:
The viability of any international transaction should be assessed from both the host perspective and
also the parent company perspective. This chapter analyses treasury management and short term
international financing
7.1.1 Subsidiary Perspective
The management of working capital has a direct influence on the amount and timing of cash flow :
inventory management
accounts receivable management
cash management
liquidity management
Subsidiary Expenses
International purchases of raw materials or supplies are more likely to be difficult to manage
because of exchange rate fluctuations, quotas, etc.
If the sales volume is highly volatile, larger cash balances may need to be maintained in order
to cover unexpected inventory demands.
Subsidiary Revenue
International sales are more likely to be volatile because of exchange rate fluctuations,
business cycles, etc.
Looser credit standards may increase sales (accounts receivable), though often at the
expense of slower cash inflows
Subsidiary Dividend Payments
Forecasting cash flows will be easier
overhead charges) to be sent to the parent are known in advance and denominated in the
subsidiarys currency.
7.1.2. Centralized Cash Management
While each subsidiary is managing its own working capital, a
group is needed to monitor, and possibly manage, the parent
cash flows.
International cash management can be segmented into two functions:
optimizing cash flow movements, and
Investing excess cash.
Figure 7.1 shows the movement of cash in an international company.
Figure 7.1 The movement of cash in a multinational
The centralized cash management division of an MNC cannot always accurately forecast the events
that may affect parent- subsidiary or inter
53
Looser credit standards may increase sales (accounts receivable), though often at the
expense of slower cash inflows
Forecasting cash flows will be easier if the dividend payments and fees (royalties and
overhead charges) to be sent to the parent are known in advance and denominated in the
Centralized Cash Management
While each subsidiary is managing its own working capital, a centralized cash management
group is needed to monitor, and possibly manage, the parent-subsidiary and inter
International cash management can be segmented into two functions:
optimizing cash flow movements, and
Figure 7.1 shows the movement of cash in an international company.
movement of cash in a multinational company.
The centralized cash management division of an MNC cannot always accurately forecast the events
subsidiary or inter-subsidiary cash flows.
Looser credit standards may increase sales (accounts receivable), though often at the
if the dividend payments and fees (royalties and
overhead charges) to be sent to the parent are known in advance and denominated in the
centralized cash management
subsidiary and inter-subsidiary
The centralized cash management division of an MNC cannot always accurately forecast the events
54
It should, however, be ready to react to any event by considering any potential adverse impact on
cash flows, and how to avoid such adverse impacts.
7.2. Techniques to Optimize Cash Flows
7.2.1. Accelerating Cash Inflows o
The more quickly the cash inflows are received, the more quickly they can be invested or
used for other purposes.
Common methods include the establishment of lockboxes around the world (to reduce mail
float) and preauthorized payments (direct charging f a customers bank account).
7.2.2.Minimizing Currency Conversion Costs
Netting reduces administrative and transaction costs through the accounting of all
transactions that occur over a period to determine one net payment.
A bilateral netting system involves transactions between two units, while a multilateral
netting system usually involves more complex interchanges.
7.2.3. Managing Blocked Funds
A government may require that funds remain within the country in order to create jobs and
reduce unemployment.
The MNC should then reinvest the excess funds in the host country, adjust the transfer
pricing policy (such that higher fees have to be paid to the parent), borrow locally rather
than from the parent, etc.
7.2.4. Managing Inter-subsidiary Cash Transfers
A subsidiary with excess funds can provide financing by paying for its supplies earlier than is
necessary. This technique is called leading.
Alternatively, a subsidiary in need of funds can be allowed to lag its payments. This
technique is called lagging.
7.2.5. Complications in Optimizing Cash Flows
Company-Related Characteristics
When a subsidiary delays its payments to the other subsidiaries, the other
subsidiaries may be forced to borrow until the payments arrive.
Government Restrictions
Some governments may prohibit the use of a netting system, or periodically prevent
cash from leaving the country.
Characteristics of Banking Systems
The abilities of banks to facilitate cash transfers for MNCs may vary among
countries.
The banking systems in different countries usually differ too.
55
7.2.6. Investing Excess Cash
Excess funds can be invested in domestic or foreign short-term securities, such as
Eurocurrency deposits, bills, and commercial papers.
Sometimes, foreign short-term securities have higher interest rates. However, firms must
also account for the possible exchange rate movements.
Centralized Cash Management
Centralized cash management allows for more efficient usage of funds and possibly higher
returns.
When multiple currencies are involved, a separate pool may be formed for each currency.
The investment securities may also be denominated in the currencies that will be needed in
the future.
7.2.7 Implications of Interest Rate Parity (IRP)
A foreign currency with a high interest rate will normally exhibit a forward discount that
reflects the differential between its interest rate and the investors home interest rate.
However, short-term foreign investing on an uncovered basis may still result in a higher
effective yield.
7.2.8 Use of the Forward Rate as a Forecast
If IRP exists, the forward rate can be used as a break-even point to assess the short-term
investment decision.
The effective yield will be higher if the spot rate at maturity is more than the forward rate at
the time the investment is undertaken, and vice versa. Figure 7.2 shows the impact of
international cash management on an MNCs value.
Figure 7.2. Impact of International Cash
Management
on an MNCs Value
( ) ( ) [ ]
( )
=
n
t
t
m
j
t j t j
k
1 =
1
, ,
1
ER E CF E
= Value
E (CF
j,t
) = expected cash flows in currency j to be received
by the U.S. parent at the end of period t
E (ER
j,t
) = expected exchange rate at which currency j can
be converted to dollars at the end of period t
k = weighted average cost of capital of the parent
Returns on International
Cash Management
56
Practice Questions
1.Assume the following information for BIM, a local bank:
Value of Mozambiquean Metical in Rands = R0.2857
Value of Swaziland Emalangeni in Rands = R0.0952
Value of Mozambiquean Metical in Swaziland Emalangeni = R3.300
a. Given the information above, evaluate if triangular arbitrage is possible.
b. If so, explain the steps that would reflect arbitrage , and compute the profit from this strategy if
you had 100 000 Meticals to use.
c. Under what conditions would an MNC subsidiary consider use of a leading strategy to reduce
transactions exposure?
d. When is it optimal for an MNC to rely on centralised currency hedge mechanisms?
2. Explain how the following strategies can be used by a Zimbabwean company faced with a
situation of appreciating dollar.
(a) Lagging
(b) Leading
(c) Off setting
3. Discuss the advantages of centralized cash management for a multinational corporation.
57
Chapter Eight
Multinational Cost of Capital & Capital Structure
Learning Outcomes
To explain how corporate and country characteristics influence an MNCs cost of capital;
To explain why there are differences in the costs of capital across countries; and
To explain how corporate and country characteristics are considered by an MNC when it
establishes its capital structure.
KEY TERMS
INTERNATIONAL COST OF CAPITAL INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL MARKETS
BANKRUPTCY CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL
8.1. Cost of Capital
A firms capital consists of equity (retained earnings and funds obtained by issuing stock) and debt
(borrowed funds). The cost of equity reflects an opportunity cost, while the cost of debt is reflected
in interest expenses. Firms want a capital structure that will minimize their cost of capital, and hence
the required rate of return on projects.
A firms weighted average cost of capital
kc
= (
D
) kd (
1
_
t
) + (
E
) ke
D + E D + E
where Kc Cost of Capital
D is the amount of debt of the firm
E is the equity of the firm
k
d
is the before-tax cost of its debt
t is the corporate tax rate
k
e
is the cost of financing with equity
58
The interest payments on debt are tax deductible. However, as interest expenses increase, the
probability of bankruptcy will increase too. It is favourable to increase the use of debt financing until
the point at which the bankruptcy probability becomes large enough to offset the tax advantage of
using debt. Figure 8.1. shows the trade-off between debt ratio and cost of capital.
Debts Tradeoff
Fig 8.1 Cost of Capital
C
o
s
t
o
f
C
a
p
i
t
a
l
Debt Ratio
8.2. Determinants of MNCs Cost of Capital
The cost of capital for MNCs may differ from that for domestic firms because of the following
differences.
8.2.1. Size of Firm. Because of their size, MNCs are often given preferential treatment by creditors.
They can usually achieve smaller per unit flotation costs, too.
8.2.2. Access to International Capital Markets. MNCs are normally able to obtain funds through
international capital markets, where the cost of funds may be lower.
8.2.3. International Diversification. M NCs may have more stable cash inflows due to international
diversification, such that their probability of bankruptcy may be lower.
8.2.4. Exposure to Exchange Rate Risk. MNCs may be more exposed to exchange rate fluctuations,
such that their cash flows may be more uncertain and their probability of bankruptcy higher.
8.2.5. Exposure to Country Risk. MNCs that have a higher percentage of assets invested in foreign
countries are more exposed to country risk.
59
Fig 8.2. Cost of Capital for MNCs
Possible
access to low-
cost foreign
financing
Preferential
treatment from
creditors
Greater access
to international
capital markets
Larger size
International
diversification
Exposure to
exchange rate
risk
Exposure to
country risk
Cost of
capital
Probability of
bankruptcy
8.3. Methods of calculating the MNCs Cost capital
The capital asset pricing model (CAPM) can be used to assess how the required rates of return of
MNCs differ from those of purely domestic firms.
According to CAPM, k
e
= R
f
+ b (R
m
R
f
)
where k
e
= the required return on a stock
R
f
= risk-free rate of return
R
m
= market return
b = the beta of the stock
A stocks beta represents the sensitivity of the stocks returns to market returns, just as a projects
beta represents the sensitivity of the projects cash flows to market conditions.
The lower a projects beta, will be the lower its systematic risk, and its required rate of return, since
its unsystematic risk can be diversified away.
8.4. Costs of Capital across Countries
The cost of capital may vary across countries, such that: MNCs based in some countries may have a
competitive advantage over others; MNCs may be able to adjust their international operations and
sources of funds to capitalize on the differences; and MNCs based in some countries may have a
more debt-intensive capital structure
The cost of debt to a firm is primarily determined by O the prevailing risk-free interest rate of the
borrowed currency and O the risk premium required by creditors.
The risk-free rate is determined by the interaction of the supply and demand for funds. It may vary
due to different tax laws, demographics, monetary policies, and economic conditions.
60
The risk premium compensates creditors for the risk that the borrower may be unable to meet its
payment obligations. The risk premium may vary due to different economic conditions, relationships
between corporations and creditors, government intervention, and degrees of financial leverage.
Although the cost of debt may vary across countries, there is some positive correlation among
country cost-of-debt levels over time.
A countrys cost of equity represents an opportunity cost what the shareholders could
have earned on investments with similar risk if the equity funds had been distributed to
them.
The return on equity can be measured by the risk-free interest rate plus a premium that
reflects the risk of the firm.
A countrys cost of equity can also be estimated by applying the price/earnings multiple to a
given stream of earnings.
A high price/earnings multiple implies that the firm receives a high price when selling new
stock for a given level of earnings. So, the cost of equity financing is low.
8.5. Using the Cost of Capital for Assessing Foreign Projects
O Derive NPVs based on the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC.)
The probability distribution of NPVs can be computed to determine the probability
that the foreign project will generate a return that is at least equal to the firms
WACC.
O Adjust the WACC for the risk differential.
The MNC may estimate the cost of equity and the after-tax cost of debt of the funds
needed to finance the project.
8.6. The MNCs Capital Structure Decision
The overall capital structure of an MNC is essentially a combination of the capital structures
of the parent body and its subsidiaries.
The capital structure decision involves the choice of debt versus equity financing, and is
influenced by both corporate and country characteristics.
8.6.1. Corporate Characteristics
Stability of cash flows. MNCs with more stable cash flows can handle more debt.
Credit risk. MNCs that have lower credit risk have more access to credit.
Access to retained earnings. Profitable MNCs and MNCs with less growth may be able to
finance most of their investment with retained earnings.
8.6.2. Country Characteristics
Stock restrictions. MNCs in countries where investors have less investment opportunities
may be able to raise equity at a lower cost.
Interest rates. MNCs may be able to obtain loanable funds (debt) at a lower cost in some
countries.
Strength of currencies. MNCs tend to borrow the host country currency if they expect it to
weaken, so as to reduce their exposure to exchange rate risk
61
Country risk. If the host government is likely to block funds or confiscate assets, the
subsidiary may prefer debt financing.
Tax laws. MNCs may use more local debt financing if the local tax rates (corporate tax rate,
withholding tax rate, etc.) are higher.
8.6.3 .Interaction Between Subsidiary and Parent Financing Decisions
Increased debt financing by the subsidiary
A larger amount of internal funds may be available to the parent.
The need for debt financing by the parent may be reduced.
The revised composition of debt financing may affect the interest charged on debt as well as
the MNCs overall exposure to exchange rate risk
Reduced debt financing by the subsidiary
A smaller amount of internal funds may be available to the parent.
The need for debt financing by the parent may be increased.
The revised composition of debt financing may affect the interest charged on debt as well as
the MNCs overall exposure to exchange rate risk.
Amount of Internal Amount of
Local Debt Funds Debt
Host Country Financed by Available Financed
Conditions Subsidiary to Parent by Parent
Higher Country Risk Higher Higher Lower
Lower Interest Rates Higher Higher Lower
Expected Weakness
Higher Higher Lower
of Local Currency
Blockage of Funds Higher Higher Lower
Higher Taxes Higher Higher Lower
Fig 8.3 Interaction Between
Subsidiary and Parent Financing
Decisions
8.7. Using a Target Capital Structure on a Local versus Global Basis
An MNC may deviate from its local target capital structure as necessitated by local
conditions.
However, the proportions of debt and equity financing in one subsidiary may be adjusted to
offset an abnormal degree of financial leverage in another subsidiary.
Hence, the MNC may still achieve its global target capital structure
62
The volumes of debt and equity issued in financial markets vary across countries, indicating
that firms in some countries (such as Japan) have a higher degree of financial leverage on
average.
However, conditions may change over time. In Germany for example, firms are shifting from
local bank loans to the use of debt security and equity markets.
Fig 8.4 Impact of Multinational Capital
Structure Decisions on an MNCs Value
( ) ( ) [ ]
( )
=
n
t
t
m
j
t j t j
k
1 =
1
, ,
1
ER E CF E
= Value
E (CF
j,t
) = expected cash flows in currency j to be received
by the U.S. parent at the end of period t
E (ER
j,t
) = expected exchange rate at which currency j can
be converted to dollars at the end of period t
k = weighted average cost of capital of the parent
Parents Capital Structure
Decisions
Practice Questions
1.Illustrate the impact on a firms financing costs using a potentially stronger vehicle currency, as
against a potentially weaker vehicle currency for a Zimbabwean-based firm in sourcing funds from
abroad.
2.Seminole, Inc., is a US-based company and is considering issuing a Mark-denominated bond at its
present coupon rate of 7%, even though it has no income in Mark cash flows to cover the bond
payments. It has simply been attracted to the low financing rate, since dollar bonds issued in the
United States would have a coupon rate of 12%.
Assume that either bond would have a four-year maturity and could be issued at par value.
Seminole needs to borrow $10 million. Therefore it will issue either dollar bonds with a par value of
$10 million or DM. bonds with a par value of 20 million. The spot rate of the Mark is $.50/1DM.
63
Seminole has forecasted the Marks value at the end of each of the next four years, when coupon
payments are to be paid thus.
Year End Exch. Rate of the DM
1 $.52
2 $.56
3 $.58
4 $.53
Determine the expected annual cost of financing with Mark. Should Seminole Corporation issue
bonds denominated in dollars or in Marks? Explain.
64
Chapter Nine
Foreign Direct Investment
Learning Outcomes
To describe common motives for initiating direct foreign investment (DFI); and
To illustrate the benefits of international diversification.
To explain how DFI can help increase value of an MNC.
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION
INTERNALISATION LOCAL SOURCING
FACILITY LOCATION
Foreign direct investment (FDI) is a measure of foreign ownership of productive assets, such as
factories, mines and land. Increasing foreign investment can be used as one measure of growing
economic globalization.
9.1. Motives for DFI
DFI can improve profitability and enhance shareholder wealth, either by boosting revenues or
reducing costs.
9.1.2 Revenue-Related Motives
Attract new sources of demand, especially when the potential for growth in the home country
is limited
. Exploit monopolistic advantages, especially for firms that possess resources or skills not
available to competing firms.
React to trade restrictions.
9.1.3. Cost-Related Motives
Fully benefit from economies of scale, especially for firms that utilize much machinery.
Use cheaper foreign factors of production.
Use foreign raw materials, especially if the MNC plans to sell the finished product back to the
consumers in that country.
React to exchange rate movements, such as when the foreign currency appears to be
undervalued. DFI can also help reduce the MNCs exposure to exchange rate fluctuations.
65
Diversify sales/production internationally.
The optimal method for a firm to penetrate a foreign market is partially dependent on the
characteristics of the market.
For example, if the consumers are used to buying domestic products, then licensing
arrangements or joint ventures may be more appropriate.
Before investing in a foreign country, the potential benefits must be weighed against the costs
and risks.
As conditions change over time, some countries may become more attractive targets for DFI,
while other countries become less attractive
9.2..Benefits of International Diversification
The key to international diversification is to select foreign projects whose performance levels
are not highly correlated over time.
An MNC may not be insulated from a global crisis, since many countries will be adversely
affected.
However, as can be seen from the 1997-98 Asian crisis, an MNC that had diversified among the
Asian countries might have fared better than if it had focused on one country. Even better
would be diversification among the continents.
As more projects are added to a portfolio, the portfolio variance should decrease on average,
up to a certain point.
However, the degree of risk reduction is greater for a global portfolio than for a domestic
portfolio, due to the lower correlations among the returns of projects implemented in
different economies.
Figure 9.1 shows the benefits of diversification. As the number of projects increase, the project
specific risk is reduced.
Fig 9.1 Portfolio Risk Reduction Effect.
9.3 Incentives for FDI
Foreign direct investment incentives may take the following forms:
low corporate tax and income tax
tax holidays
other types of tax concessions
preferential tariffs
special economic zones
investment financial subsidies
soft loan or loan guarantees
free land or land subsidies
relocation & expatriation subsidies
job training & employment subsidies
infrastructure subsidies
R&D support
derogation from regulations (usually for very large projects)
9.4 Host Government View of DFI
For the government, the ideal DFI solves problems such as unemployment and lack of
technology without taking business away from the local
The government may provide incentives to encourage the forms of DFI that it desires, and
impose preventive barriers or conditions on the forms of DFI that it does not want.
The ability of a host government to attract DFI is dependent on the country
resources, as well as government regulations and incentives.
Common incentives offered by the host government include tax breaks, discounted rent for
land and buildings, low-interest loans, subsidized energy, and reduced environmental
restrictions.
66
Foreign direct investment incentives may take the following forms:
[citation needed
income tax rates
other types of tax concessions
investment financial subsidies
guarantees
relocation & expatriation subsidies
job training & employment subsidies
derogation from regulations (usually for very large projects)
For the government, the ideal DFI solves problems such as unemployment and lack of
technology without taking business away from the local firms.
The government may provide incentives to encourage the forms of DFI that it desires, and
impose preventive barriers or conditions on the forms of DFI that it does not want.
The ability of a host government to attract DFI is dependent on the countrys markets and
resources, as well as government regulations and incentives.
Common incentives offered by the host government include tax breaks, discounted rent for
interest loans, subsidized energy, and reduced environmental
citation needed]
For the government, the ideal DFI solves problems such as unemployment and lack of
The government may provide incentives to encourage the forms of DFI that it desires, and
impose preventive barriers or conditions on the forms of DFI that it does not want.
s markets and
Common incentives offered by the host government include tax breaks, discounted rent for
interest loans, subsidized energy, and reduced environmental
67
Common barriers imposed by the host government include the power to block a
merger/acquisition, foreign majority ownership restrictions, excessive procedure and
documentation requirements (red tape), and operational conditions
Fig 9.2. Impact of DFI Decisions on an MNCs
Value
( ) ( ) [ ]
( )
=
n
t
t
m
j
t j t j
k
1 =
1
, ,
1
ER E CF E
= Value
E (CF
j,t
) = expected cash flows in currency j to be received
by the U.S. parent at the end of period t
E (ER
j,t
) = expected exchange rate at which currency j can
be converted to dollars at the end of period t
k = weighted average cost of capital of the parent
DFI Decisions on
Type of Business and Location
Practice Questions
1. Describe some potential benefits to the MNC as a result of direct foreign investment (DFI). To
what extent do they apply to FDI investment in Zimbabwe.?
2. Why would the Government of Zimbabwe provide MNCs with incentives to undertake DFI in its
country?
3. Discuss all the components, explaining the impact of foreign direct investment on the value of the
MNC.
4. Why do companies still invest in countries with high risk indicators?
68
Chapter Ten
Multinational Capital Budgeting Decisions
Learning Outcomes
To compare and understand the capital budgeting analysis of MNCs subsidiary versus that
of a parent.
To understand how multinational budgeting can be utilised to evaluate the viability of an
international project.
To understand how to assess project risk in an international context.
To how the corporate and country characteristics affect an MNCs cost of capital.
To understand the reasons for differing costs of capital in different countries.
KEY TERMS
MULTINATIONAL CAPITAL BUDGETING DOMESTIC PROJECT
FOREIGN PROJECT MULTIPLE SOURCE BORROWING
10.1. Capital budgeting theoretical framework.
Capital budgeting for a foreign project uses the same theoretical framework as domestic capital
budgeting. What are the basic steps in domestic capital budgeting? Multinational capital budgeting,
like traditional domestic capital budgeting, focuses on the cash inflows and outflows associated with
prospective long-term investment projects. Multinational capital budgeting techniques are used in
traditional FDI analysis, such as the construction of a manufacturing plant in another country, as well
as in the growing field of international mergers and acquisitions. The MNC uses capital budgeting
analysis to evaluate its international projects by comparing the costs and benefits of projects.
Capital budgeting, which involves the discounting of incremental project cash flows to arrive at the
project's net present value, is more complex in a multinational environment. This is due to such
problems as the difference in perspective between foreign subsidiary and parent and other
problems specific to the differing laws, business and cultural constraints of the countries involved.
The cost of capital of the MNC is important for capital budgeting decisions and as a determiner of
the value of the MNC as a whole. The MNC strives to utilize a capital structure that can minimize its
cost of capital by optimal use of capital funding opportunities (debt and equity) available to the MNC
globally.
Capital budgeting for a foreign project uses the same theoretical framework as domestic capital
budgetingwith a few very important differences. The basic steps are:
1) Identify the initial capital invested or put at risk.
69
2) Estimate cash flows to be derived from the project over time, including an estimate of the
terminal or salvage value of the investment.
3) Identify the appropriate discount rate for determining the present value of the expected cash
flows.
4) Apply traditional capital budgeting decision criteria such as net present value (NPV) and internal
rate of return (IRR) to determine the acceptability of or priority ranking of potential projects.
10.2. Domestic Project Appraissal Versus Foreign Project
Capital budgeting for a foreign project is considerably more complex than the domestic case. Several
factors contribute to this greater complexity:
Parent cash flows must be distinguished from project cash flows. Each of these two types of
flows contributes to a different view of value.
Parent cash flows often depend on the form of financing. Thus, we cannot clearly separate
cash flows from financing decisions, as we can in domestic capital budgeting.
Additional cash flows generated by a new investment in one foreign subsidiary may be in
part or in whole taken away from another subsidiary, with the net result that the project is
favourable from a single subsidiarys point of view but contributes nothing to worldwide
cash flows.
The parent must explicitly recognize remittance of funds because of differing tax systems,
legal and political constraints on the movement of funds, local business norms, and
differences in the way financial markets and institutions function.
An array of nonfinancial payments can generate cash flows from subsidiaries to the parent,
including payment of license fees and payments for imports from the parent.
Managers must anticipate differing rates of national inflation because of their potential to
cause changes in competitive position, and thus changes in cash flows over a period of time.
Managers must keep the possibility of unanticipated foreign exchange rate changes in mind
because of possible direct effects on the value of local cash flows, as well as indirect effects
on the competitive position of the foreign subsidiary.
Use of segmented national capital markets may create an opportunity for financial gains or
may lead to additional financial costs.
Use of host-government subsidized loans complicates both capital structure and the parents
ability to determine an appropriate weighted average cost of capital for discounting
purposes.
Managers must evaluate political risk because political events can drastically reduce the
value or availabilityof expected cash flows.
Terminal value is more difficult to estimate because potential purchasers from the host,
parent, or third countries, or from the private or public sector, may have widely divergent
perspectives on the value to them of acquiring the project.
10.3. Project versus parent valuation.
Why should a foreign project be evaluated both from a project and parent viewpoint? A
strong theoretical argument exists in favour of analyzing any foreign project from the
viewpoint of the parent. Cash flows to the parent are ultimately the basis for dividends to
70
stockholders, reinvestment elsewhere in the world, repayment of corporate-wide debt, and
other purposes that affect the firms many interest groups.
However, since most of a projects cash flows to its parent, or to sister subsidiaries, are
financial cash flows rather than operating cash flows, the parent viewpoint usually violates a
cardinal concept of capital budgeting, namely, that financial cash flows should not be mixed
with operating cash flows. Often the difference is not important because the two are almost
identical, but in some instances a sharp divergence in these cash flows will exist.
Evaluation of a project from the local viewpoint serves some useful purposes, but it should
be subordinated to evaluation from the parents viewpoint. In evaluating a foreign projects
performance relative to the potential of a competing project in the same host country, we
must pay attention to the projects local return.
Almost any project should at least be able to earn a cash return equal to the yield available
on host government bonds with a maturity the same as the projects economic life, if a free
market exists for such bonds. Host government bonds ordinarily reflect the local risk-free
rate of return, including a premium equal to the expected rate of inflation. If a project
cannot earn more than such a bond yield, the parent firm should buy host government
bonds rather than invest in a riskier project.
Host country inflation. How should an MNE factor host country inflation into its evaluation
of an investment proposal? Inflation is factored into the expected cash flows of the project
rate of return. Relative inflation affects the expected exchange rate due to purchasing power
parity.
10.4. Production and Logistics Strategies
Production and logistic policies to enhance bargaining position include local sourcing, location of
facilities, control of transportation, and control of technology.
10.4.1. Local Sourcing
Host governments may require foreign firms to purchase raw materials and components locally as a
way to maximize value-added and increase local employment. From the viewpoint of the foreign
firm trying to adapt to host country goals, local sourcing reduces political risk, albeit at a trade-off
with other factors. Local strikes or other turmoil may shut down the operation: in addition, such
issues as quality control, high local prices because of lack of economies of scale, and unreliable
delivery schedules become important. Often the foreign firm acquires lower political risk only by
increasing financial and commercial risk.
10.4.2. Facility Location
Production facilities may be located so as to minimize risk. The natural location of different stages of
production may be resource-oriented, footloose or market-oriented. Oil, for instance, is drilled in
and around the Persian Gulf, Venezuela, and Indonesia. No choice exists for where this activity takes
place. Refining is footloose, whenever possible, oil companies have built refineries in politically safe
countries, such as Western Europe or small islands (such as Singapore or Curacao), even though
costs might be reduced by refining nearer the oil fields. They have traded reduced political risk and
financial exposure for possibly higher transportation and refining costs.
71
10.4.3. Control of Transportation
Control of transportation has been an important means to reduced political risk. Control of oil
pipelines that cross national frontiers, oil tankers, ore carriers, refrigerated ships, and railroads have
been used at times to influence the bargaining power of both nations and companies.
10.4.4. Control of Technology
Control of key patents and processes is a viable way to reduce political risk. If a host country cannot
operate a plant because it does not have technicians capable of running the process, or of keeping
up with changed technology, abrogation of an investment agreement with a foreign firm is unlikely.
This approach works best when the foreign firm is steadily improving its technology.
10.4.5. Marketing Strategies
Marketing techniques to enhance a firms bargaining position include control of markets, brand
names, and trademarks.
Control of markets is a common strategy to enhance a firms bargaining position. As effective as the
OPEC cartel was in raising the price received for crude oil by its member countries in the 1970s,
marketing was still controlled by the international oil companies; OPECs need of the oil companies
limited the degree to which its members could dictate terms.
Control of export markets for manufactured goods is also a source of leverage in dealings between
foreign-owned firms and host governments. The multinational firm would prefer to serve world
markets from sources of its own choosing, basing the decision on considerations of production cost,
transportation, tariff barriers, political risk exposure, and competition. The selling pattern that
maximizes long-run profits from the overall viewpoint of the worldwide firm rarely maximizes
exports, or value-added, from the perspective of the host countries. The contrary argument is that
self-standing local firms might never obtain foreign market share because they lack economies of
scale on the production side and are unable to market in foreign countries.
10.4.6. Brand names and trade mark control
Control of a brand name or trademark can have an effect almost identical to that of controlling
technology. It gives the multinational firm a monopoly on something that may or may not have
substantive value but quite likely represents value in the eyes of consumers. Ability to produce for
and market under a world brand name is valuable for local firms, and thus represents an important
bargaining attribute for maintaining an investment position.
10.4.7. Financing Strategies
Financial strategies can be adopted to enhance the continued bargaining position of a multinational
firm. Many of these tactics are covered elsewhere in this module , so for the moment it is sufficient
to list some of the more popular techniques.
Foreign affiliates can be financed with a thin equity base and a large proportion of local debt. If the
debt is borrowed from locally owned banks, host government actions that weaken the financial
viability of the firm also endanger local creditors.
72
If the firm must finance with foreign-source debt, it should borrow from banks in countries other
than its own home country. If, for example, debt is owned to banks in Tokyo, Frankfurt, London and
New York, influential institutions in a number of foreign countries have a vested interest in keeping
the borrowing affiliate financially strong. If the multinational is U.S.-owned, a fall out between the
United States and the host government is less likely to cause the local government to move against
the firm if it might lead to a default on creditors in other countries.
Practice Questions
1. Wolverine Corp presently has no existing business in Germany but is considering the establishment of a
subsidiary there. The following information has been gathered to help in the assessment of the project:
(a.) The initial investment required is DM 50 million. Given the existing spot rate of $.50 per Mark, this initial
investment in dollars is $25 million. In addition to the DM50 million initial investment on plant and
equipment, DM 20 million will be needed for working capital and will be borrowed by the subsidiary from a
German bank. The German subsidiary of Wolverine will pay interest only on the loan each year, at an
interest rate of 14% percent. The loan principal is to be paid in 10 years.
(b.) The project will be terminated at the end of year 4, when the subsidiary will be sold as a going concern.
(c.) The price, demand, and variable costs of the product in West Germany are as follows:
Year Price Demand Variable Cost
1 DM 500 35,000 units DM 30
2 DM 511 45,000 units DM 35
3 DM 530 55,000 units DM 40
4 DM 524 50,000 units DM 45
(d.) The fixed costs, such as overhead expenses, are expected to be DM 6 million per year.
(e.) The exchange rate of the Mark is expected to be $ .52 at the end of year 1; $.54 at the end of year 2; $.56
at the end of year 3 and $.59 at the end of the year 4.
73
(f.) The US government will impose an income tax of 30 percent while the German corporate tax is 28 percent.
In addition, the German government will impose a withholding tax of 10 percent on earnings remitted by
the subsidiary to the US. The US government currently has entered into an agreement with its German
counterpart aimed at eliminating double taxation and therefore will allow tax credits on the portion of
remitted earnings.
(g.) 80% of cash flows received by the subsidiary are to be sent to the parent at the end of each year. The
subsidiary will use its working capital to support her on-going operations.
(h.) The plant and equipment are to be depreciated over 10 years using the straight-line method.
(i.) In four years, the subsidiary is to be sold. Wolverine Corp. expects to receive DM 70 million after
subtracting capital gains taxes on selling the subsidiary.
(j.) Wolverine requires a 20 percent return on this project.
Required
1. Determine the Net Present Value of the project and comment whether Wolverine should accept this
project.
2. Assume that Wolverine decides to implement the project, using the above-proposed financing
arrangement. Also assume that after one year, a German firm offers Wolverine a price of $27 million
after taxes for the subsidiary and that Wolverines original forecasts for years 2, 3 and 4 have not
changed. Should Wolverine divest the subsidiary? Explain
3. Assume Wolverine used the originally proposed financing arrangements and that funds are blocked
until the subsidiary is sold. The funds to be remitted are reinvested at a rate of 6% (after taxes) until the
end of year 4 when the project is to be sold. How is the projects net present value affected?
4.Illustrate the impact on a firms financing costs using a potentially stronger vehicle currency, as against
a potentially weaker vehicle currency for a Zimbabwean-based firm in sourcing funds from abroad.
5.Seminole, Inc. is a US-based company and is considering issuing a Mark-denominated bond at its
present coupon rate of 7%, even though it has no income in Mark cash flows to cover the bond
payments. It has simply been attracted to the low financing rate, since dollar bonds issued in the
United States would have a coupon rate of 12%.
Assume that either bond would have a four-year maturity and could be issued at par value.
Seminole needs to borrow $10 million. Therefore it will issue either dollar bonds with a par value of
$10 million or DM. bonds with a par value of 20 million. The Spot rate of the Mark is $.50/1DM.
74
Seminole has forecasted the Marks value at the end of each of the next four years, when coupon
payments are to be paid thus.
Year End Exch. Rate of the DM
1 $.52
2 $.56
3 $.58
4 $.53
Determine the expected annual cost of financing with Mark. Should Seminole Corporation issue
bonds denominated in dollars or in Marks? Explain.
4. On September 24, 2001, Smith Chemical Company sold C$2500,000 of agricultural pesticides to
Hindustan Agri Chemical Company, payable in 3 months at, Metropolitan Bank, Manitoba. The sale was
denominated in Indian rupees at a time when the rupee traded at 36.56 rupees per Canadian dollar.
On 22nd October 2001, the Reserve Bank of India announced a 240 billion-rupee budget package
designed to repair its relations with the International Monetary Fund and to end uncertainty over its
ability to service its C$128 billion foreign debt. (At that time, India's foreign exchange reserves were
estimated at C$761 million, worth about four weeks of imports). The Reserve Bank's discount rate was
then raised 3 percentage points to 20%, and the rupee was devalued to 40.22 per C$.
a) What was the percentage amount of devaluation?
b) What was the dollar loss experienced by Smith Chemical Company? When was it experienced?
c) Was the loss described in part (b) of a transaction, translation, or operating nature? Explain your
answer.
d) What precaution should have been taken to ensure that such losses do not get repeated?
5. Why should capital budgeting for subsidiary projects be assessed from the parents perspective?
6. What additional factors deserve consideration in a multinational capital budgeting project that is not
normally relevant for a purely domestic project? Explain.
7. What are the limitations of using single-point estimates of exchange rate when carrying out
multinational capital budgeting?
8. Explain briefly how the result of country risk analyses is finally incorporated into a multinational capital
budgeting process.
75
Chapter Eleven
International Payments
Learning Outcomes
To describe the methods of payment for international trade;
To explain common trade finance methods; and
To describe the major agencies that facilitate international trade.
KEY TERMS
INTERNATIONAL PAYMENTS TRADE BILL
TRADE ACCEPTANCE TRANSFER RISK
DOCUMENTARY CREDIT BANKERS ACCEPTANCE
FACTORING COUNTER TARDE
COMPENSATION TRADE COUNTER PURCHASE TRADE
INCOTERMS
Introduction
In any international trade transaction, credit is provided by either the supplier (exporter),
the buyer (importer), one or more financial institutions, or any combination of the above.
The form of credit whereby the supplier funds the entire trade cycle is known as supplier credit.
11.1. Managing the Default and Transfer Risks:
Cash payment after delivery, which in a domestic business transaction is referred to as
selling goods on account or credit is a well-known tradition and an established standard
practice.
Internationally, the practice of shipping goods on an open account is also widely
accepted, especially between those parties who have a long-standing and positive business
relationship and when the transfer risk is negligible.
However, if the foreign customer is new and unknown to the exporter or importer, or
if his/her credit standing deteriorates, or if the customers country is short of foreign
exchange reserves, the exporter faces default and transfer risks. In these
circumstances, payment after delivery is rated poorly in terms of these risks.
76
11.2. Approaches in dealing with default and transfer risks:
11.2.1. Cash payment before shipping:
This is a case when the supplier ships the goods only after receiving payment from
the foreign customer. In contrast to the case where goods are shipped on open
account, now the importer bears the default and delivery risks.
In the same contract the exporter has shifted the following risks to the importer:
i) Delivery risk
ii) Credit risk and
iii) Transfer risk
The above discussed mode of payment is an extreme way in which the risks can be
shifted from the exporter to importer and vice-versa and stifles international trade.
Cash payment method shifts the trading risks from the exporter to the importer.
To reduce the bad sides of the above method of international trade settlement,
its variants are used.
11.2.2.Use of trade Bills:
The use of personal trade bills mitigates the delivery and default risks facing the
importer after making payments, since the importer will honour the bills when the
terms of the export contract are fully met. Similarly, the exporter can discount the
bill immediately and absolve himself from the contract.
A second issue in international trade is the financing of working capital. Normally
the mode of payment determines which party has provided which part of the
financing of exports. Unless one party can obtain financing at a cost below the
regular bank rates, the investment in working capital is usually financed through
short-term bank loans.
Bank loans for international trade are easily obtained, and at attractive interest
rates, if the payment involves a trade bill (Also known as a draft or a bill of
exchange).
A trade bill is like a summary invoice. If it is drawn on and accepted by the
importer, it is called a Trade Acceptance; however, a bill drawn on and
accepted by a bank is called a Bankers Acceptance.
In many ways an acceptance payable on sight is similar to a cheque because
it can be cashed in at any moment.
Further Trade Bills once accepted by the importer can be discounted and
traded. The discounting of the trade bills is done by commercial banks or by
specialized financial institutions (i.e. discount house).
For all good intentions, banks favour bills--especially export bills, and are
willing to discount them at attractive interest rates.
77
Personal trade bills, though extensively used, from the point of view of
credit risk and transfer risk, the instrument remains almost as risky as an
invoice. For instance:
- The drawee might not even accept the bill after taking delivery.
- Might default on it; or
- Might not have a license to remit foreign exchange.
Normally, the legal redress in case of default by either the exporters or the
importers is slow and costly because the two parties are governed by
different laws; thus, it is wise for the parties to compromise contracts and
sought proactive methods to avert these risks.
Thus credit and transfer risks cannot be solved and this has led to the evolution
of documentary payment modes.
In a bid to improve on the negative sides of the payment through personal bills,
we can improve the situation through documentary payments.
Fig 11.1. Documentary Credit
Procedure
Buyer
(Importer)
OSale Contract
Seller
(Exporter)
ODeliver Goods
O
Request
for Credit
Importers Bank
(Issuing Bank)
O
Documents
& Claim for
Payment
O
Present
Documents
O
Deliver
Letter of
Credit
OPresent
Documents
OSend Credit
Exporters Bank
(Advising Bank)
OPayment
11.3. Documentary Payment Modes With Bank Participation
Given the inadequacy of legal redress with personal trade bills, one would wish to
choose a mode of payment in which the risks are shared between (importers,
exporters and at times the intermediating finance institution), and that reduces both
the probability as well as the cost of default.
78
Such contracts usually involve at least one financial institution, which acts as a
trustee for the importers and exporters.
The role of banks is, as we shall see, similar to that of a trustee. The arrangement is
that the bank receives a set of documents rather than the goods themselves. The
importer and exporter have to agree on what documents will be required.
11.4. Documents against Payment:
Here the bank receives a set of documents as agreed by the parties and remits the same to
the other party goods are not involved. This provides a reasonable solution to the default
risk
Under documents against payment (D/P), the bank checks whether all documents listed in
the contract are present. If nothing is missing, the bank remits these documents to the
importer against payment that is, the importer receives the papers only when the agreed-
up price has been paid to the banker. The importer, being in possession of the documents,
can then claim the merchandise from a designated warehouse.
11.5 Documents against Acceptance:
A D/A is a variant of a D/P, but has a built-in feature to allow the exporter to obtain finance
to process the exports before shipment
From a pure financial angle, the drawback of D/P is that it precludes the use of bills, which in
the domestic commercial transactions are instrumental in financing working capital because
of the possibility of them be discounted and cash got immediately. For that reason, a variant
of D/P is D/A.
Under D/A, the documents will be sent to a remitting bank that will pass them to the
customer after satisfying themselves that everything is in order. The set of documents now
will include a bill drawn by the exporter on the importer.
If the set of documents is complete, the bank will remit the documents to the importer who
would signify his acceptance of the bill. As soon as the latter has accepted (signed) the bill,
the acceptance is sent back to the exporter, who may discount it immediately to get cash.
The main difference between a D/P and D/A is that the importer may still default after
taking possession of the goods in the contract and this becomes the risk of a D/A (see Figure
11.2).
79
Fig 11.2. Life Cycle of a Typical Bankers
Acceptance
8. Pay Discounted Value of BA
1- 7 : Prior to BA
1. Purchase
Order
Importer Exporter
5. Ship
Goods
Importers
Bank
2. Apply
for L/C
11.
Shipping
Documents
14. Pay
Face Value
of BA
10. Sign
Promissory
Note to Pay
6.
Shipping
Documents
& Time
Draft
4. L/C
Notification
9. Pay
Discounted
Value of
BA
7. Shipping Documents
&
Time Draft
Exporters
Bank
3. L/C
12. BA
Money Market
Investor
13. Pay Discounted Value of BA
16. Pay Face Value of BA
15. Present BA at Maturity
14- 16 : When BA
matures
8- 13 : When BA
is created
11.6. Obtaining a guarantee from the Importers Bank: the Letter of Credit.
An LC reduces the credit risk, default risk, transfer risk and delivery risks
involved in the D/P and D/A.
There is an obvious and simple way to resolve the default risk in a D/A arrangement. The
exporter can insist that the importer have the payment or bill guaranteed by his/her bank,
which also acts as the remitting bank. The exporter will insist on evidence to such a
commitment before sending any documents.
If, as is usually the case, the banks guarantee is conditional on receiving a set of
conformatory documents, this type of arrangement is called a documentary credit. Note
that in contrast to D/P or D/A payments, the receiving bank is now responsible for the
payment as soon as it accepts that the documents conform to the standard contract and
therefore is part and parcel of the export contract.
The L/C arrangement reduces the probability and cost of default. L/C arrangement is still far
from perfect. Occasionally, letters of credit turn out to be counterfeited or issued by banks
that, from their name and logo, look like branches of major international banks but are in
fact just minor local and useless banks. Finally, even if the issuing bank is sound, transfer
risk still exists. In managing all of the problems, the exporters own bank can play a useful
role.
The problem with the above letter of credit is that it can be a counterfeit letter of credit and
further it still does not solve the transfer risk. This problem requires an independent bank to
the importers bank to confirm the letter of credit.
11.7. Advised or Confirmed Letters of Credit
There are several ways in which an exporter can further reduce the default risk, even after
obtaining an L/C.
80
The exporter can ask the issuing bank to send the L/C to a designated bank trusted
by the exporter, called advisory bank. The advisory bank receives the L/C from the
issuing bank; its task is to check whether the bank exists and is in good financial
standing, whether the signatures are legitimate and signed by the banks manager
duelly authorized to do so.
- The exporter can also ask the importer to have the L/C confirmed by a bank located in
the exporters country, or at least confirmed by a well-known bank trusted by the
exporter. Under such an arrangement, the confirming bank will actually guarantee the
payment; that is, it will pay the exporter if the original issuing bank defaults, or if the
transfer is blocked.
Thus a confirmed L/C offers insurance against default on behalf of the issuing bank
against transfer risk
- The exporter can also have a bank-backed bill or the issuing bank accept discounting the
bill without recourse. This again shifts the transfer risk and default risks to the issuing
bank. This technique is called forfeiting implying discounting regular commercial
invoices on a non-recovery basis.
11.8. Other standard ways to cope with Default Risk:
A letter of credit is only but one of the many ways to insure against credit risks. Exporters
can also use factor companies, or they can buy insurance from export credit insurance
companies.
11.8.1. Factoring
This is a pure debt collection contract with recourse to the seller should the customer fail to
pay or without recourse to the client should the customer fail to pay.
A credit insurance agent is a factor who, over and above credit collection, also guarantees
payments should the customer default.
Accounts receivable financing; a factor can also finance the invoices, after the deduction of
interest (at the rate applicable on straight loans.)
Financing of insured invoices also eliminates foreign exchange risk.
Therefore factoring is similar to non-recourse discounting of bills, or forfeiting.
11.8.2.Credit Insurance
Virtually every country has a government agency that insures export credit and / or transfer
risk. Usually, if the exporters contract is with a foreign government institution, credit risks
and transfer risks are often not separate and one needs to insure both.
81
11.8.3.Export-Backed Financing:
Firms in a country experiencing a temporary shortage of hard currency may find it difficult to
import goods. In such a case, banks may grant advances to firms against the firms future
export proceeds. To ensure the safety of the loans, the lending bank typically adds two
clauses to the loan contract:
- The exporting firm must sell its export output forward.
- The buyer of the forward sale must pay the proceeds through the bank
When the payment is received, the bank withholds the amounts required to service its loan,
and pays out the balance to the exporting firm.
Export-backed finance means obtaining finance on the basis of anticipated
export proceeds.
11.8.4. Counter trade:
Counter-trade is viewed as a form of financial engineering, as it involves:
i) Selling;
ii) Buying; and
iii) Cleverly securing financing on such exports; this is because most of these
contracts invariably involve a delay between delivery and receipt of
payment.
The advantages of counter-trade are essentially the components packaged together such as:
- An opportunity to trade;
- Use of trade intermediaries;
- Obtaining finance and
- Risk shifting through forward trade/sub-contracting
There are several techniques / forms of carrying out counter-trade transactions.
11.8.5.Barter trade
Pure barter-trade consists of an exchange of goods for goods simultaneously or
within a short interval of time.
b) Compensation trade
Compensation trade is a type of barter where one of the flows is partly in goods and
partly in cash (hard currency). An L/C may be used to insure the cash component of
the transaction.
c) Counter Purchase trade:
This is closer to a standard trade than is the compensation trade. It consists of an
autonomous contract, i.e.;
82
- Purchase of one combine harvester against cash, and a second contract,
which is conditional on the first one.
- Purchase of goods from the first sales proceeds worth a given amount from
the initial contract.
d) Buy-Back
Here the exporting countrys firm builds a turn-key plant (and often also provides
training and management assistance often referred to as technological transfers)
and is paid in stated amounts of the plants output at stated intervals.
e) Switch Trade
This is similar to a negotiated counter-purchase contract. For example, a Canadian
exporter delivers a combine harvester and obtains the right to buy C$300, 000 worth
of the importer countrys goods within a stated period. Now, suppose the Canadian
company can utilize only C $200,000 worth of goods and finds it difficult to use the
C$100 000 balance. Under switch trade this balance can be sold to another firm or
to another trader usually at a discount.
11.8.6. Advantages of Counter trade:
o With asymmetric and proprietary information and bid-offer spreads for
transactions, the drafting, monitoring and implementation of one
contract is probably cheaper and easier than that of three separate but
interlinked contracts like:
Turnkey project;
The loan agreement; and
The long term sales contract;
Camouflaging the deal, a single packaged contract allows one to hide the
true revenues and costs of the component transactions.
Since counter trade involves several contracts in one, they are more
economical to draft. Further, because several contracts are crafted into one
contract, this enables the exporter to hide revenues and costs of individual
contracts components
11.9.. AGENCIES THAT MOTIVATE INTERNATIONAL TRADE:
Due to the inherent risks of international trade, insurance against various forms of
risk is desirable. Some agencies provide insurance or combine it with various loan-
support programmes or guarantees.
In the US, the prominent agencies providing these services are:
11.9.1 Export-Import Bank (Exim Bank)
The programmes of Exim Bank are designed to meet two broad objectives:
83
i) Assumes the underlying credit and country risk and encouraging private
lenders to finance export trade; and
ii) Provides direct loans to foreign buyers when private lenders are unwilling
to do so. These goals are broadly achieved through the provision of:
(a) Guarantees;
(b) Loans; and
(c) Insurance.
11.9.2.Export Credit Insurance:
A variety of short term and medium term insurance policies are available to
exporters, banks and other eligible applicants. Basically, all the policies provide
insurance protection against the risk of nonpayment by foreign buyers. Exim Bank
operates these policies.
i. If a foreign buyer fails to pay due to commercial reasons such as cash flow
problems or insolvency, the policy pays between 90 to 100% of the
insurance amount.
ii. If the failure is due to war or political reasons such as foreign exchange
controls, Exim Bank reimburses 100% of the insured amount.
11.9.3 Private Exchange Funding Corporation (PEFCO)
A consortium of commercial banks and industrial companies own this. Working
together with Exim Bank, PEFCO provides medium and long term fixed rate financing
to foreign buyers. Exim Bank guarantees all export loans made by PEFCO.
11.9.4 Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC):
Is a self-sustaining federal agency responsible for insuring the direct US investments
in foreign countries against the risks of currency inconvertibility, expropriation and
other political risks
11.8. INCOTERMS
Language is one of the most complex and important tools of international trade. As in any complex
and sophisticated business, small changes in wording can have a major impact on all aspects of a
business agreement.
Word definitions often differ from industry to industry. This is especially true of global trade where
such fundamental phrases as "delivery" can have a far different meaning in the business than in the
rest of the world.
For business terminology to be effective, phrases must mean the same thing throughout the
industry. That is why the International Chamber of Commerce created "INCOTERMS" in 1936.
INCOTERMS are designed to create a bridge between different members of the industry by acting as
a uniform language they can use.
Each refers to a type of agreement for the purchase and shipping of goods internationally. There are
more than 13 different terms, each of which helps users deal with different situations involving the
84
movement of goods. For example, the term FCA is often used with shipments involving Ro/Ro or
container transport; DDU assists with situations found in intermodal or courier service-based
shipments.
INCOTERMS also deal with the documentation required for global trade, specifying which parties are
responsible for which documents. Determining the paperwork required to move a shipment is an
important job, since requirements vary so much between countries. Two items, however, are
standard: the commercial invoice and the packing list.
INCOTERMS were created primarily for people inside the world of global trade. Outsiders frequently
find them difficult to understand. Seemingly common words such as "responsibility" and "delivery"
have different meanings in global trade than they do in other situations.
In global trade, "delivery" refers to the seller fulfilling the obligation of the terms of sale or to
completing a contractual obligation. "Delivery" can occur while the merchandise is on a vessel on the
high seas and the parties involved are thousands of miles from the goods. In the end, however, the
terms wind up boiling down to a few basic specifics:
Costs: who is responsible for the expenses involved in a shipment at a given point in the
shipment's journey?
Control: who owns the goods at a given point in the journey?
Liability: who is responsible for paying damage to goods at a given point in a shipment's transit?
It is essential for shippers to know the exact status of their shipments in terms of ownership and
responsibility. It is also vital for sellers and buyers to arrange insurance on their goods while the
goods are in their "legal" possession. Lack of insurance can result in wasted time, lawsuits, and
broken relationships.
INCOTERMS can thus have a direct financial impact on a company's business. What is important is
not the acronyms, but the business results. Often companies like to be in control of their freight.
That being the case, sellers of goods might choose to sell CIF, which gives them a good grasp of
shipments moving out of their country, and buyers may prefer to purchase FOB, which gives them a
tighter hold on goods moving into their country.
In this glossary, we'll tell you what terms such as CIF and FOB mean and their impact on the trade
process. In addition, since we realize that most international buyers and sellers do not handle goods
themselves, but work through customs brokers and freight forwarders, we'll discuss how both fit
into the terms under discussion.
INCOTERMS are most frequently listed by category. Terms beginning with F refer to shipments
where the primary cost of shipping is not paid for by the seller. Terms beginning with C deal with
shipments where the seller pays for shipping. E-terms occur when a seller's responsibilities are
fulfilled when goods are ready to depart from their facilities. D terms cover shipments where the
shipper/seller's responsibility ends when the goods arrive at some specific point. Because shipments
are moving into a country, D terms usually involve the services of a customs broker and a freight
forwarder. In addition, D terms also deal with the pier or docking charges found at virtually all ports
and determining who is responsible for each charge.
85
Recently (2004) the ICC changed basic aspects of the definitions of a number of INCOTERMS; buyers
and sellers should be aware of this. Terms that have changed have a star alongside them.
EX-Works
One of the simplest and most basic shipment arrangements, places the minimum
responsibility on the seller with greater responsibility on the buyer. In an EX-Works
transaction, goods are basically made available for pickup at the shipper/seller's factory or
warehouse and "delivery" is accomplished when the merchandise is released to the
consignee's freight forwarder. The buyer is responsible for making arrangements with their
forwarder for insurance, export clearance and handling all other paperwork.
FOB (Free On Board)
One of the most commonly used-and misused-terms, FOB means that the shipper/seller
uses his freight forwarder to move the merchandise to the port or designated point of origin.
Though frequently used to describe inland movement of cargo, FOB specifically refers to
ocean or inland waterway transportation of goods. "Delivery" is accomplished when the
shipper/seller releases the goods to the buyer's forwarder. The buyer's responsibility for
insurance and transportation begins at the same moment.
FCA (Free Carrier)
In this type of transaction, the seller is responsible for arranging transportation, but he is
acting at the risk and the expense of the buyer. Where in FOB the freight forwarder or
carrier is the choice of the buyer, in FCA the seller chooses and works with the freight
forwarder or the carrier. "Delivery" is accomplished at a predetermined port or destination
point and the buyer is responsible for Insurance.
FAS (Free Alongside Ship)*
In these transactions, the buyer bears all the transportation costs and the risk of loss of
goods. FAS requires the shipper/seller to clear goods for export, which is a reversal from
past practices. Companies selling on these terms will ordinarily use their freight forwarder to
clear the goods for export. "Delivery" is accomplished when the goods are turned over to
the Buyers Forwarder for insurance and transportation.
CFR (Cost and Freight)
This term, formerly known as CNF (C&F), defines two distinct and separate responsibilities-
one is dealing with the actual cost of merchandise "C" and the other "F" refers to the freight
charges to a predetermined destination point. It is the shipper/seller's responsibility to get
goods from their door to the port of destination. "Delivery" is accomplished at this time. It is
the buyer's responsibility to cover insurance from the port of origin or port of shipment to
THE buyer's door. Given that the shipper is responsible for transportation, the shipper also
chooses the forwarder.
CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight)
This arrangement is similar to CFR, but instead of the buyer insuring the goods for the
maritime phase of the voyage, the shipper/seller will insure the merchandise. In this
arrangement, the seller usually chooses the forwarder. "Delivery", as above, is accomplished
at the port of destination.
CPT (Carriage Paid To)
In CPT transactions the shipper/seller has the same obligations found with CIF, with the
addition that the seller has to buy cargo insurance, naming the buyer as the insured while
the goods are in transit.
CIP (Carriage and Insurance Paid To)
This term is primarily used for multimodal transport. Because it relies on the carrier's
insurance, the shipper/seller is only required to purchase minimum insurance coverage.
When this particular agreement is in force, freight forwarders often act in effect, as carriers.
The buyer's insurance is effective when the goods are turned over to the Forwarder.
86
DAF (Delivered At Frontier)
Here the seller's responsibility is to hire a forwarder to take goods to a named frontier,
which usually is a border crossing point, and clear them for export. "Delivery" occurs at this
time. The buyer's responsibility is to arrange with their forwarder for the pick up of the
goods after they are cleared for export, carry them across the border, clear them for
importation and effect delivery. In most cases, the buyer's forwarder handles the task of
accepting the goods at the border across the foreign soil.
DES (Delivered Ex Ship)
In this type of transaction, it is the seller's responsibility to get the goods to the port of
destination or to engage the forwarder to move cargo to the port of destination uncleared.
"Delivery" occurs at this time. Any destination charges that occur after the ship is docked are
the buyer's responsibility.
DEQ (Delivered Ex Quay)*
In this arrangement, the buyer/consignee is responsible for duties and charges and the seller
is responsible for delivering the goods to the quay, wharf or port of destination. In a reversal
of previous practice, the buyer must also arrange for customs clearance.
DDP (Delivered Duty Paid)
DDP terms tend to be used in intermodal or courier-type shipments, whereby the
shipper/seller is responsible for dealing with all the tasks involved in moving goods from the
manufacturing plant to the buyer/consignee's door. It is the shipper/seller's responsibility to
insure the goods and absorb all costs and risks, including the payment of duty and fees.
DDU(Delivered Duty Unpaid)
This arrangement is basically the same as with DDP, except for the fact that the buyer is
responsible for the duty, fees and taxes.
1. Practice Questions
Flexi-Bilt, Inc., of South Carolina, has just purchased a Thai company that manufactures plastic
beams and sockets for childrens construction toys. The purchase price is 120.000.000 Thai baht
(symbol B), with payment due to the selling Thai shareholders in six months. The currency spot rate
is B25.60/$, and the six month forward rate is B26.60/$. Additional data rate as follows:
Six-months Thai baht interest rate: 12 00%p.a
Six-months U.S interest rate: 4.00%p.a
Six-months call option on baht at 26.00 3.0%premium
Six-months put option on baht at 26.00 2.4% premium
Assume that Flexi-Bilt can invest at the given interest rates or borrow at 1% per annum above the
interest rates. Flexi-Bilts weighted average cost of capital is 20%.
a) Compare alternative ways that Flexi-Bilt might deal with its foreign exchange exposure.
b) What do you recommend and why?
2.ELECTRONIX, INC
Electronix, Inc., of Seattle, Washington, sold an Internet protocol system to Kompu-Deutsche of
Germany for DM2, 000,000 with payment due in three months. The following quotes are available:
87
Three-month interest rate (borrowing or investing) 6, 00% per annum
On U.S Dollars.
Three-month interest rate (borrowing or investing) 8.00% per annum
On Deutschemarks:
Spot exchange rate DMI.6000/$
Three-month forward exchange rate: DMI.6120/$
Three-month options from bank of America:
Call option on DM2, 000,000 at exercise price of DM1, 6000/$ and a 1% premium
Put option on DM2, 000,000 at exercise price of DM1.6000/$ and a 3% premium
Electronixs cost of capital is 10.0%, and it wishes to protect the dollar value of this receivable.
a) What are the costs and benefits of each alternative? Which is the best alternative?
b) What is the break-even reinvestment rate when comparing forward and money market
alternatives?
3.VALDIVIA VINEYARDS
Valdivia Vineyards of Chile were recently acquired by Sauvignon Winery of Napa, California. At
present Valdivia is paying 50% p.a.interest on Ps 100 million of five-year, balloon maturity, and peso
debt. It would be possible to refinance this into dollar debt costing only 10% p.a., saving some 40
percentage points over the cost of peso debt.
All of Valdivias wine is exported to the United States, where it is sold for dollars. Valdivia is
allowed by Chilean regulations to use hard currency earned to pay hard currency expenses, including
interest.
The currency exchange rate is Ps32/$, and both Chile and the United States have a rate to drop to
Ps48/$ one year from now, and to continue to deteriorate thereafter at the same rate.
a) As assistant financial manager of Sauvignon Winery in charge of the Latin American
Beverage Division, should you refinance Valdivias Chilean peso debt into dollars?
b) Would your answer be different if all of Valdivias sales were within Chile? (Explain and
show your calculation.)
4.GAMBOAS TAX AVERAGING
Gamboa, Incorporated, is a relatively new U.S-Based retailer of specialty fruits and vegetables. The
firm is vertically integrated with fruit and vegetable-sourcing subsidiaries in Central America, and
distribution outlets throughout the southeastern and northeastern region of the United States.
Gamboas two Central American subsidiaries are in Belize and Costa Rica.
88
Maria Gamboa, the daughter of the firms founder, is being groomed to take over the firms financial
management in the near future. Like many firms of Gamboas size, it has not possessed a very high
degree of sophistication in financial management, simply out of time and cost considerations. Maria,
however, has recently finished her MBA and is now attempting to put some specialized knowledge
of U.S taxation practices to work to save Gamboa money. Her first concern is tax averaging for
foreign tax liabilities arising from the two Central American subsidiaries.
Costa Rican operations are slightly more profitable than Belize, which is particularly good since Costa
Rica is a relatively low-tax country. Costa Rican corporate taxes are a flat 30%, and there are no
withholding taxes imposed on dividends paid by foreign firms with operations there. Belize has a
higher corporate income tax rate of 40%, and imposes a 10% withholding tax on all dividends
distributed to foreign investors. The current U.S. corporate income tax rate is 35%.
Belize Costa Rica
Earnings before taxes $1, 000,000 $1, 500,000
Corporate income tax rate 40% 30%
Dividend withholding tax rate 10% 0%
a. If Maria Gamboa assumes a 50% payout rate from each subsidiary, what are the additional
taxes due on foreign-sourced income from Belize and Costa Rica individually? How much in
additional U.S. taxes would be due if Maria averaged the tax credits/liabilities of the two
units?
b. Keeping the payout rate from the Belize subsidiary at 50%, how should Maria change the
payout rate of the Costa Rican subsidiary in order to most efficiently manage her total
foreign tax bill?
c. What is the minimum effective tax rate which Maria can achieve on her foreign sourced
income? `
5.PRETORIA PRODUCTIONS, LTD
Hollywood Video, Inc., of Los Angeles, California, wants to loan US$6, 000,000 to its new South
African affiliate, Pretoria Productions, Ltd. Pretoria Productions was formed after the election victory
of Nelson Mandela to produce and distribute Hollywood movies in video form throughout South
Africa. Hollywood Video owns a wholly owned finance subsidiary in Malta, which is used to redirect
funds between affiliates in the eastern hemisphere.
Corporate income taxes are 34% in the United States and 48% in South Africa. No taxes are levied in
Malta. Hollywood Video may either (1) have its Maltese finance subsidiary loans $6 million directly
to Pretoria Productions, or (2) have the Maltese subsidiary deposit $6 million in National
Westminster Bank (NatWest), London, at 11.5%. NatWest would then loan the same sum at 12% to
Pretoria Productions. NatWest would charge only 0.5% to act as a financial intermediary because
none of its own funds are at risk, as Maltas deposit provides 100% collateral. Which option do you
advocate and why?
89
Past Final Examination Papers 1
SECTION A (ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS FROM THIS SECTION)
QUESTION ONE
1.(a) Explain the fundamental technique for forecasting exchange rates (5 marks)
1.(b) Explain how the theory of comparative advantage relates to the need for international
business. (5 marks)
1.(c) How is the product life cycle related to the growth of MNCs? (5 Marks)
1.(d) How would a weakening Zimbabwean dollar affect its balance of payment? (10 marks )
QUESTION TWO
2. (a) You are given the following information:
Spot rate USD = 26.50MT
180-day forward rate of USD = 25.60MT
180-day American Interest rate = 15%
180-day Mozambiquean interest rate = 12%
Based on this information, is covered interest arbitrage by a Mozambiquean investor feasible?
Explain. Assume the investor starts with 1 000 000Meticals. (8 marks)
2(b). Assume that the Central Bank of Mozambique believes that the Metical should be weakened
against the United States dollar. Discuss how it would use indirect intervention strategy to
weaken the Meticals value with respect to the dollar. If the future inflation rate in Mozambique is
expected to be high, why would the Central Bank Of Mozambique attempt to weaken the Metical?
(17 marks)
SECTION 2 (ANSWER ANY TWO QUESTIONS FROM THIS SECTION)
QUESTION THREE
What factors affect a firms degree of transaction exposure in a particular currency? For each
factor, explain the desirable characteristics that would reduce exposure. (25 marks)
QUESTION FOUR
Describe some potential benefits to the MNC as a result of direct foreign investment (DFI). To
what extent do they apply to FDI investment in Mozambique? (25 marks)
90
QUESTION FIVE
Identify common political and economic factors for an MNC to consider when assessing country
risk. Briefly explain how each factor can affect the risk to the MNC. (25 Marks)
QUESTION SIX
Discuss the following terms:
6.(a) Interest Parity Theory
(b) Purchasing Power Parity Theory
(c)International Fisher Effect
(d) Interest Covered Arbitrage
(e) Forward Rate agreement
SECTION A (ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS FROM THIS SECTION)
QUESTION ONE
1.(a) Explain the motives for forecasting exchange rates by MNCs. (5 marks)
1.(b) Assume an MNC hires you as a consultant to assess its degree of economic exposure
to exchange rate fluctuations. How would you handle this task? Be brief and specific. (7)
marks)
1.(c) Assume the following information for BIM, a local bank:
Value of Mozambiquean Metical in Rands = R0.2857
Value of Swaziland Emalangeni in Rands = R0.O952
Value of Mozambiquean Metical in Swaziland Emalangeni = R3.300
Given this information, is triangular arbitrage possible? If so, explain the steps that would
reflect arbitrage , and compute the profit from this strategy if you had 100 000 MT to
use.(8 marks)
(d) Under what conditions would an MNC subsidiary consider use of a leading strategy
to reduce transaction exposure? (5 marks)
QUESTION TWO
2.(a) A local company, Terminus Hotel, has contracted to purchase 1000 air conditioners at
US$200 each. It has been granted 6 months to settle the account. The company can borrow
at 7% above base rate in either market and invest at 6% below base rate in both markets as
well. The current market rates are 13% in the US market and 22% in Mozambique.
The exchange rates are as follows:
MT per USD
Spot Rates 26.65 28.70
I month Forward 29.20 - 30.24
91
6 Months Forward 31.24 -33.24
Illustrate possible policies that Terminus Hotel might follow regarding this transaction
and provide a recommendation for which policy Terminus Hotel must follow. (20 marks)
2.(b). Define the terms transaction exposure , economic exposure and translation exposure (5
marks)
SECTION TWO (CHOOSE ANY TWO QUESTIONS FROM THIS SECTION)
QUESTION THREE
Why would the Government of Zimbabwe provide MNCs with incentives to undertake DFI in its
country? (25 marks)
QUESTION FOUR
4(a) How can the Central Bank of Mozambique use indirect intervention to change the value of the
currency? (10 marks)
4(b) Should the Government of Mozambique allow its currency to float freely? What would be the
advantages of letting their currencies float freely? What would be the disadvantages for this
approach? (15 marks)
QUESTION FIVE
5. (a) Explain how diversification can be used by a company to reduce transaction exposure. (15
marks)
5. (b) When is it optimal for an MNC to rely on centralised currency hedge mechanisms. (10 marks)
QUESTION SIX
Discuss reasons advanced by MNCs for foreign investment. To what extent do they apply to FDI
investment in Mozambique? (25 marks)
QUESTION SEVEN
Montclair Company, a United States of America Co., plans to use a money market hedge to hedge
its payment of $3 000 000 for Australian goods in one year. The U.S. interest rate is 7%, while the
Australian interest rate is 12%. The spot exchange rate of the Australian dollar is $0.85, while the
one year forward rate is $0.81.
A) Determine the amount of US$s needed in one year if a money market hedge is used.
B) Determine the amount of US $s needed in one year if a
C)
D)
E) forward market hedge is used?
Reference List
92
Buckley, A. (2004) Multinational Finance , 5
th
edition, FT Prentice Hall
Eiteman , D.K, Stonehill, A.I. and Moffet, M.H. (2007) Multinational Business Finance , 11
th
edition,
Addison-Wesley
Eun, C,S. and Rennick, B.G. (2006) International Financial Managaement, 4
th
edition, McGraw-Hill.
Madura, J. (2006) International Corporate, 8
th
edition Fiance on, Thomson
Pilbeam, K. (2006) International Finance , 3
rd
edition, Palgrave.
Shapiro, A.C. (2006) Multinational Financial Management, 8
th
edition, John Wiley & Sons