Postoperative Blindness After Spine Surgery in The Prone Position
Postoperative Blindness After Spine Surgery in The Prone Position
Postoperative Blindness After Spine Surgery in The Prone Position
A rare complication
What are the causes of postoperative vision loss (POVL) after spine surgery in the prone position? How do we prevent it?
Incidence
0.056%: eye injury over 60,965 cases from 1988-1992 (Roth et al., Anesth., 1996) 0.0008%: vision loss >30 days in 410,189 noncardiac pts from 1986-1998 at Mayo Clinic (Warner et al., Anesth Analg, 2001) Estimated 0.07% for cardiac surgery, <1/10000 (0.001%) for appendectomy (Shen et al. Anesth Analg, 2009)
Incidence
0.094%: 4,728,815 cases of laminectomy/discectomy/spinal fusion in US NIS database from 1993-2002 (Patil et al. Spine, 2008)
0.03%: spinal fusion in 465,345 discharges from 1996-2005 US NIS database (Shen et al. Anesth Analg, 2009) Smaller series ranging from 0.09% to 0.2%
Pathophysiology
Cortical Blindness
External compression or emboli CRAO: Afferent pupil defect, retinal edema, cherry red spot
Anterior versus Posterior Afferent pupil defect, optic disc edema, subsequent atrophy
Cortical Blindness
Much more common in patients < 18 (4.3/10000) versus patients > 18 (0.12-0.25/10000) Patil et al. showed that non-CRAO, non-ION visual loss 5.8 times more prevalent in age <18 vs 1844. Limited literature related to spine surgery Thought to be caused by embolism or sustained profound hypotension resulting in infarction (Williams, Anesthesiology Clin N Am, 2002)
? Due to external compression due to positioning Increased IOP -> occlusion of retinal artery Case of CRAO with OptiGard goggles
the Eyes: An Old Complication with a New Vein Anesth Analg, 2007 Central Retinal Mechanism,
Roth et al. Visual Loss in a Prone-Positioned Spine Surgery Patient with the Head on a Foam Headrest and Goggles Covering Katz and Karlin, Visual Field Defect After Posterior Spine Fusion, Spine, 2005.
Incidence:
Retinal vascular occlusion: 0.6/10000 in spinal fusion (Shen et al) CRAO: 0.001% (0.1 / 10000) (Patil et al.)
All cases of CRAO reported in ASA Postoperative Vision Loss Registry were unilateral (Lee et al., Multiple 2006)reports Anesth, case relating to horseshoe headrests
A small turn in the patients head may result in pressure to the globe
Hollenhorst et al. Unilateral blindness occurring during anesthesia for neurosurgical operations. AMA Arch Ophthalmol 1954 Grossman and Ward. Central Retinal Artery Occlusion After Scoliosis Surgery with a Horseshoe Headrest. Spine, 1993. Bekar et al. Unilateral Blindness due to Patient Positioning During Cervical Syringomyelia Surgery: Unilateral Blindness After Prone Position. J
Anterior ION
Posterior ION
Anterior = in the eye (optic disc) Perfusion pressure affected by MAP and IOP
Posterior = optic nerve in orbit behind globe (retrobulbar) Less blood flow than in anterior portion, less autoregulation
Incidence:
Patil et al.: ION incidence of 0.006% over all spine cases, 0.02% in spinal fusion scoliosis surgeries. Chang et al. (John Hopkins): ION incidence of 0.028% in 14,000 patients Most cases are PION and are frequently bilateral (>50% in Lee et al.)
Patil et al. used risk-adjusted multivariate analysis to identify Hypotension (OR 10.1), Peripheral Vascular Disease (OR 6.3) Anemia (OR 5.9), and Blood Transfusion (OR 4.3) as strongest risk factors for ION in 271 patients
Hypotension and Anemia not specific to intraoperative hypotension or anemia
Prone Positioning
Prone positioning has been shown to increase intraocular pressure (IOP) in anesthetized patients (Cheng et al, Anesth, 2001)
20 patients without eye disease had spine surgery prone IOP followed with Tono-pen
Supine: 13 1 mmHg Prone: 27 2 mmHg Prone at end of case (average 320 min): 40 2 mmHg Supine at end of case: 31 2 mmHg
Unclear how much intraoperative fluids / edema contributed to increase in IOP over duration of surgery
Literature
Case Series:
2 cases CRAO despite head held in pins 12/24 patients had hematocrit > 30%, and 5/24 had EBL<500cc
American Society of Anesthesiologists Postoperative Visual Loss Registry: 93 spine cases 1999-2005, (Lee et. al., Anesthesiology, 2006)
89% of cases were ION (60% PION), 11% of cases CRAO No clear association with anesthetic agent, hypotension, hematocrit 94% of cases > 6 hours
Literature
Case-Control Series:
Myers et al. Spine, 1997: 37 cases of POVL after spine surgery through survey and review of recent cases.
Matched to control group for age, type of surgery, number of levels, instrumentation Relative to control group, affected group had increased blood loss and longer surgery No difference in hematocrit or blood pressure
Holy et al. Anesth, 2009: 17 cases of ION after any surgery, 1998-2005
Each case matched to two controls for age and surgery. 4/17 were spine surgeries. No statistically significant correlation with EBL, intraop hypotension, hematocrit, surgical time, hypothermia, vasopressors
Literature
Literature Reviews:
Roth et al, Perioperative visual loss: what do we know, what can we do?, Brit J Anesth, 2009.
Gill et al, Postoperative visual loss associated with spine surgery, Eur Spine J, 2006. 7 studies, 102 cases
The etiology of postoperative visual loss is probably multifactorial, however, patients with a large amount of blood loss producing hypotension and anemia along with prolonged operative times may be causing a greater risk in developing visual disturbances.
The overall strength of evidence to identify predictors of postoperative ischemic optic neuropathy is Very Low, that is, any estimate of effect is very uncertain. The overall strength of evidence for current recommended preventative measures is also Very Low,
Summary
Causes:
Prevention
Recommendations of ASA Task Force on Perioperative Blindness (2006) Consider informing patients of risk of perioperative visual loss. Use colloids along with crystalloids to maintain euvolemia. Position the head at the level of heart or higher, and in a neutral position, when possible. Consider staging prolonged procedures in highrisk patients. And appropriate positioning and frequent eye checks in the prone position may CRAO and other direct eye injuries from globe compression