Field Safety Considerations and Its Design Implications
Field Safety Considerations and Its Design Implications
Field Safety Considerations and Its Design Implications
Purpose
2
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Learning Objectives
3
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
4
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
5
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
6
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
7
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
8
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
N u m b e r o f lo s t ti m e in ju r ie s
Total lost time injuries
180000
Total lost time 160000
according to 100000
60000
40000
20000
0
2011 2012 2013
9
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Their statistics show that the highest number of injuries occurred for
workers between 45 to 54 years old with a total number of 63,417
injuries.
10
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
11
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
12
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• This study was conducted for the years of 2011, 2012 and 2013. Which
three provinces do you think accounted for most injuries?
For the mentioned years. Quebec had the most injury rates followed
by Ontario and British Colombia.
13
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
14
Case Study
15
Case Study
Nick was then rushed to hospital and transferred to Vancouver where he had
13 ½ hours of surgery. Part of his spine was reconstructed and a corner of
one of his ribs was grafted into his back. He spent three weeks in hospital
followed by three months in rehabilitation at GF Strong before returning
home to Victoria.
16
Case Study
Nick mentioned that his only training to operate a forklift was learning
where the brake and gas pedals are in addition to lifting handle.
It is the responsibility of employers to make sure the workers have all
the required trainings for operating and/or using work-related
equipment.
It is also within the safety culture that more experienced staff to prevent
such tragedies to happen by informing the person about the hazards of
the job he/she is about to do.
17
Case Study
18
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Regulatory Information
Regulatory Information
• If an operator does not have a clear view, a signaler who has been
instructed in a code of signals for managing traffic in the workplace must
be used.
• Loads must be carried as close to the ground or floor as the situation
permits.
• Loads that may tip or fall and endanger a worker must be secured;
• Where a lift truck is required to enter or exit a vehicle to load or unload,
That vehicle must be immobilized and secured against accidental
movement.
• A lift truck must not be used to support, raise or lower a worker on a
construction site and must only be so used in an industrial establishment
if the work is carried out in accordance with Regulation 851 (Section 52).
• Barriers, warning signs, designated walkways or other safeguards must be
provided where pedestrians are exposed to the risk of collision.
20
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Regulatory Information
Regulatory Information
• Under the law, workers have the right to refuse work if the type of
work puts themselves and other workers in danger.
• This right is only limited to the following:
• “police officers
• firefighters
• workers employed in the operation of correctional institutions and
similar institutions/facilities
• health care workers and persons employed in workplaces like hospitals,
nursing homes, sanatoriums, homes for the aged, psychiatric
institutions, mental health centres or rehabilitation facilities,
residential group homes for persons with behavioural or emotional
problems or a physical, mental or developmental disability, ambulance
services, first aid clinics, licensed laboratories—or in any laundry, food
service, power plant or technical service used by one of the above
[subsection 43(2)].”
23
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Discussion
24
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Workplace Hazards
Ergonomic Chemical
Psychosocial Biological
Physical Safety
High Risk
Activities
25
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
26
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
27
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
28
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Any biological source that may cause illnesses or other effects on the body
such as viruses, insects, animals, bacteria, plants, etc.
29
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
30
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
31
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
High risk activities are types of job that need special attention as in case of
an occurrence, the results may be fatal or serious injuries. They normally
need special training and/or permit.
32
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Ergonomic Hazards
33
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Ergonomic Hazards
34
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Preventive solutions
- Regardless of whether or not workers have reported
Musculoskeletal Disorders (MSD_ symptoms, or whether or not
they have filed WCB/WSIB claims, MSD prevention needs to be
a key part of a workplace health and safety program. MSD risk
factors should be handled like any other workplace hazard.
35
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Employers should:
• Advise and train workers about the MSD risk factors in their job
and in the workplace
• Encourage workers to participate in the health and safety
program through early reporting of MSD symptoms or concerns
• Identify and assess job related MSD risk factors
• Put in place controls to reduce workers’ exposure to MSD risk
factors, including design considerations
• Follow-up to make sure preventive measures are working
36
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
38
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Chemical Hazards
• Carbon monoxide
– Carbon monoxide is a tasteless, odorless
and colorless gas that is highly toxic to
humans.
• Locations
– This hazard may occur while breathing from
an air compressor source.
– The air compressor contains air lubricants
that may break down in high temperature Signs of carbon monoxide
and produce carbon monoxide. poisoning
40
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Precautions
– The compressor must be connected to clean outdoor source for
the intake air. The compressor must be used and maintained
according to the manufacturer's instructions.
– Ensure that whenever potential sources of CO are introduced
(diesel fork trucks, generators, furnaces, natural gas dryers, etc. )
that the design accounts for the potential of these fuel burning
devices to accumulate CO and adequate ventilation is provided.
– The carbon monoxide level must be monitored using detectors.
41
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
42
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Precautions
- Ensure that all asbestos containing materials are identified and
workers are informed
- Remediation must be done by qualified workers
- Testing must be conducted to confirm the presence or absence of
asbestos prior to disturbing the area. This is a regulatory
requirement in the Ontario construction regulations.
- Proper PPE such as protective clothing (chemical suits, gloves,
hoods, respirators, etc.) must be available.
43
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
•Compressed gases
–There are many products available as compressed gases that
contain gases and mixture of gases in a pressure cylinder.
•There are three forms of compressed gases:
–Dissolved
–Liquefied
–Non-liquefied
•Dissolved
–The most common gas for this type is acetylene which is
known to be a very unstable gas in terms of its properties.
–Acetylene can be exploded even at atmospheric pressure.
Therefore it is normally used and stored in high pressure gas
cylinders.
44
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Liquefied
– For liquefied, initially the cylinder is almost full of liquid, and gas
fills the space above the liquid. As gas is removed from the
cylinder, enough liquid evaporates to replace it, keeping the
pressure in the cylinder constant. Anhydrous ammonia, chlorine,
propane, nitrous oxide and carbon dioxide are examples of
liquefied gases.
– Health hazards of compressed gasses, in some gas species, the
contact between the skin or eye and liquefied gases in liquid
form can freeze the tissue and result in a burn-like injury.
45
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Non-liquefied
– Gases such as oxygen and nitrogen that do not become liquid at
normal temperature are non-liquefied compressed gases.
• Pressure hazards of compressed gases
– Due to the high pressure of the cylinder, the gas can be released
quickly by either opening the valve or due to a broken valve.
– This might even occur at lower pressure as well.
• Health hazards
– Health hazards associated with compressed gasses can vary
depending on the gas type, area of exposure (eye, skin,
inhalation, etc.), concentration and the length of exposure.
46
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Flammable gasses
– Flammable gasses can burn and explode in some certain
conditions.
– Generally, the concentration of gas in air must be lower than its
flammable range to be safe from any incidents.
– For gasses within the flammable range, any ignition source in
workplace such as open flame, a spark and even hot surfaces
can result in tragedy.
– In some cases, there is no need of any ignition source as auto-
ignition temperate of a gas can be minimum when the gas self-
ignites itself.
47
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
48
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
49
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Oxidizing gasses
– Oxidizing gases include any gases containing oxygen at higher
than atmospheric concentrations (above 23-25 percent),
nitrogen oxides, and halogen gases such as chlorine and fluorine.
– These gases can react rapidly and fatally with the following
gasses:
• Organic (carbon-containing) substances such as most
flammable gases, flammable and combustible liquids, oils,
greases, many plastics and fabrics
• Finely-divided metals
• Other oxidizable substances such as hydrazine, hydrogen,
hydrides, sulphur or sulphur compounds, silicon and
ammonia or ammonia compounds
50
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
51
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Corrosive materials
– Corrosive materials can attack the body with a single
touch by destroying the skin layers.
– They immediately show their effects after exposure.
– They might be hazardous in other ways too, depending
on the particular corrosive material.
– Acids and bases are considered the very commonly
known corrosive materials.
– Common acids include hydrochloric acid, sulfuric acid,
nitric acid, chromic acid, acetic acid and hydrofluoric acid.
– Common bases are ammonium hydroxide, potassium
hydroxide (caustic potash) and sodium hydroxide (caustic
soda).
52
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Organic peroxide
– An organic peroxide is any carbon containing organic material
with two oxygen atoms compounded.
– Organic peroxides can be severe fire and explosion hazards.
• Hazards
– The main hazard related to organic peroxides are fire and
explosion.
– Organic peroxides may also be toxic or corrosive.
53
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
54
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Organic peroxide
– Usage
• Plastics and rubber industries are the main users of organic
peroxides.
• Organic peroxides and mixtures containing an organic peroxide
are used as accelerators, activators, catalysts, cross-linking
agents, curing agents, hardeners, initiators and promoters.
• It is important to take the necessary steps to know the materials
being used as accelerators, activators, catalysts, etc. for the
workers in that sector.
• Using the terms such as accelerators, activators, catalysts, etc.
may cause confusion about the hazardous level and serious
accidents may occur.
55
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Toxic materials
– Toxic materials are dangerous and most likely to be around the
workplace area.
– There are many ways of toxic materials entering the body:
• Skin contact
• Inhalation
• Non-hygienic practices
– Toxic materials can cause serious health effects in an exposed
individual.
56
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
57
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
58
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Ref: Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety, copyright 1997-2014, www.ccohs.ca
59
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Ref: Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety, copyright 1997-2014, www.ccohs.ca
60
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
61
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
62
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Psychosocial Hazards
63
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Preventive solutions
– Implementing collective risk assessment and management measures,
as it is done with other workplace hazards
– Adopting collective and individual preventive and control measures
– Increasing the coping ability of workers by increasing their control
over their tasks
– Improving organizational communication
– Allowing workers’ participation in decision making
– Building up social support systems for workers within the workplace
– Taking into account the interaction between working and living
conditions
– Enhancing the value placed on safety and health within the
organization
64
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Reckless Endangerment
65
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Biological Hazards
Indoor air quality – Moulds and Eye, nose and throat irritation Vent showers and moisture
Fungi: Fatigue generating
This micro-organism generated Aggravation of asthma Humidity control and
from breakdown of leaves, wood Headaches dehumidifiers
and other plants can enter a Concentration difficulty Exhaust fans when cooking or
building through air and they can Cough washing
grow on wood and/or drywall. Immediate flood or spill cleaning
Rapid stain removal of carpets
67
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
68
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
69
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Physical Hazards
70
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
71
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
72
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
•Dependant on the context and conditions, but may include for example:
–Assess your workplace / workstation and identify risks or possible
contributing factors
–Is the task necessary?
–Provide specialist equipment to assist in lifting/ carrying / moving people
or objects
–Carry smaller loads
–Take breaks from repetitive work or introduce variation to the work
–Plan work to avoid the need to lift/carry / move objects when your body
is fatigued
–Lower levels of stress. Tension in muscles long term can lead to injury
73
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
74
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
75
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Improper machinery
guarding is an example of a
mechanical hazard.
• Equipment should be
designed so that no part of a
worker’s body (e.g. hands,
fingers, hair) can become
entangled in or touch
moving equipment.
76
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Preventive solutions
• According to the Canada Labour Code, the preventive measures for
safety hazards are required by law.
Section 19.5:
• The employer shall, in order to address identified and assessed
hazards, including ergonomics-related hazards, take preventive
measures to address the assessed hazard in the following order of
priority:
– the elimination of the hazard, including by way of engineering
controls which may involve mechanical aids, equipment design
or redesign that take into account the physical attributes of the
employee
77
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
80
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
81
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• Activities at work that are dangerous and need special training and/or
permit to perform, are referred as High Risk Activity (HRA).
• Depending on the job site, the activities may vary but some general
HRAs are:
• Driving
• Fall from heights
• High-Pressure cleaning
• Working with high temperature equipment
• Confined space
• Line breaks
• Suspended loads
• Powered industrial trucks
82
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Line Break
Line Break
84
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Fall Protection
Fall Protection
86
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Fall Protection
88
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
89
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
90
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
91
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Confined Space
93
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Confined Space
94
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Confined Space
http://www.ccohs.ca/oshanswers/hsprograms/wor
kingalone.html
96
Quiz I
Section
Section
1) 44 –– Qualitative
INJURIES CAUSED Risk
Risk Analysis Assessment
Methods
BY REPEATING THE SAME MOVEMENT CONTINUOUSLY ARE A TYPE
OF …
A) PHYSICAL HAZARD
B) ERGONOMIC HAZARD
C) BIOLOGICAL HAZARD
D) SAFETY HAZARD
2) FLASH-BACK OCCURE WITH:
A) FLAMMABLE GASES
B) CARBON MONOXIDE
C) ASBESTOS
D) CORROSIVE MATERIALS
3) CHEMICAL PRODUCT CONTAINERS CAN BE DISPOSED IN ANY BIN.
A) TRUE
B) FALSE
97
Quiz I
98
Quiz I
99
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
100
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Apply State
controllin controllin
g methods g options
101
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
102
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Engineering Controls
Warnings
Administrative Controls
Warnings
Administrative Controls
105
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Elimination or Substitution
• Elimination is the most effective risk control method as the hazard will
permanently be removed from the job site.
• However, some hazardous materials are key components to the
operation of that facility and cannot be eliminated
106
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Elimination or Substitution
107
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Engineering Controls
108
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Engineering Controls
109
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Engineering Controls
The following list is some of the responsibilities that a safety engineer has:
• Research and interpret safety standards.
• Handle effective Industrial Hygiene Program.
• Support individual facilities to execute strategic initiatives to reach and
sustain world class safety processes.
• Assess risk on safety and ergonomics.
• Evaluate facility procedures to determine conditions needing
enhancement.
• Create, enhance and maintain company safety programs, training and
reports.
• Lead safety project and manage risk execution using project
management skills.
110
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
111
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
112
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
113
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• The hood, located at the face of the vent, helps capture and remove
contaminants from the area.
• The ductwork moves the air to a rooftop vent or cleaning device, such as
a thermal oxidizer or absorber, that may be engineered into the system.
• In some cases, there is an exhaust fan on top instead of a cleaning
device.
• The exhaust fan must overcome all the losses due to friction, hood entry
and fittings in the system to produce the intended flow.
• Air cleaning devices are important as they clean the air from any
particles, gasses, vapours, etc. and protect the surrounding environment
by sending clean air to the exhausts.
• These ventilation devices generally require provincial air discharge
permits.
114
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
116
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
117
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Hazard Control
118
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Administrative Controls
119
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Administrative Controls
• There are various ways for an employer to provide education and training to
raise awareness of occupational health and safety hazards and issues:
• Hands-on training in an operating area
• Classroom instruction
• Regular safety meetings, daily, weekly or monthly
• Email or posting printed material concerning are forms of educating
workers under administrative control.
• It is important to verify the effectiveness of the training by testing or quizzing
the workers about the health and safety at the workplace. This ensures the
workers understand the training.
• Safety education may also contain information on emergency response, to
ensure proper response/rescue and prevent additional injuries or fatalities.
• If a location cannot provide on site emergency response, arrangements with
trained professionals can be made.
121
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
122
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
123
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
124
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
125
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
126
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Administrative Controls
127
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
129
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
130
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
131
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
135
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
136
Quiz II
Section
1)
Section 44 –– ISBowtie
WHICH ONE Analysis
NOT AAnalysis
Risk METHOD OFMethods
HAZARD CONTROL?
A. PROCESS CONTROL
B. DIRECT SUPERVISION
C. EDUCATION AND TRAINING
D. VENTILATION
2) WHEN IT COMES TO HAZARD CONTROL, WHAT COMES FIRST AS THE REQUIRED METHOD BASED ON
THE HIERARCHY?
A. PPE
B. ENGINEERING CONTROLS
C. ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROLS
D. ELIMINATION
3) WHICH ONE OF THE FOLLOWING IS NOT A METHOD OF ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROL?
A. PROCESS CONTROL
B. EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS
C. SIGNS AND INFORMATIVE LABELS
D. SAFETY CULTURE
4) WHAT DOES PPE STAND FOR?
A. PERSONAL PREPAREDNESS EVALUATION
B. PERSONAL PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT
C. PERSONAL PROFESSIONAL EQUIPMENT
D. PERSONAL POWERED EQUIPMENT 137
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Decision Making
Decision making
1. Identify problem or opportunity
2. Collect information
3. Analyze the situation
4. Develop options
5. Evaluate the options and alternatives
6. Make a selection
7. Implement the decision
138
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Decision Making
Decision Making
140
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Decision Making
6. Make a selection
– Select the proffered alternative
– Determine if there might be any
problems it create.
7. Implement the decision
– After careful consideration and
following the necessary steps, act on
the decision.
– Reconsider the allocated resources for
implementation and make sure this is
accepted and supported by colleagues.
141
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
•In this table the options and objectives are listed. Based on the each
objective, an option will be rated to determine the overall level of
importance.
•For instance, considering an equipment change in a factory, the employee
responsible to make an educated decisions can consider the following
objectives:
–Cost
–Safety
–Durability
–Adaptability/trainability
–Overall effectiveness
•Please note that the objectives may vary based on the employer’s decision or
other factors.
142
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Let’s say your employer asked you to choose the best option for an old
equipment replacement; How would you rate the objectives?
Option 1: Do not
change
Option 3: Used
purchase
143
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Option 1: Do not 10 2 1 1 14
change
Option 3: Used 5 7 6 4 22
purchase
• The rating in this example shows that buying a brand new equipment might be a
better option.
• In order to get more accurate results, it is strongly recommended to weigh each
objective. For instance, safety always comes first and must have the highest
weight. Therefore, the rate of the option can be multiplied by the weight.
144
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Considering the example below with the following rates of cost (8), Safety
(10), Durability (8) and Effectiveness (7):
145
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Risk Assessment
146
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Risk Assessment
147
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Risk Assessment
148
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Risk Assessment
Risk Assessment
150
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Risk Assessment
151
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Risk Assessment
152
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Risk Assessment
• In order to determine the severity of the hazards, they should be ranked and
prioritized. It is important to consider personnel exposure to the hazard first
and treat this as a priority. Below are recommended for ranking and
prioritizing:
– Percentage of workforce exposed
– Degree of harm
– Probability of the occurrence
– Frequency of exposure
• The above are helpful but not limited. There is no simple one way to
understand the importance of the risks caused by hazards.
• Risk assessment matrix is a very effective method to determine the risks of
hazards.
• The matrix is in form of a table that basically determines the likelihood and the
severity of the hazards
153
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
154
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
– Very Unlikely
• This is the least risk level
and it is normally an
educated assessment of a
chance of exposure of 1%
by an individual in their
working lifetime.
155
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
– Low
• These risks are normally not in need of control measures unless
they can be implemented at a very low cost.
– Very low
• These are acceptable risks and there is no further action
required for their control.
158
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
159
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
An example of a risk
matrix
160
Quiz III
161
Quiz III
162
Case Study
The lack of clear instructions and proper supervision in the dangerous business of
demolition lay at the core of a breach of the Occupational Health and Safety Act that
resulted in a $75,000 fine being imposed on Delta Pty Ltd in the Industrial Relations
Commission.
This conclusion by Justice Boland in the case that led to two workers sustaining
serious injuries after a building collapsed sent a clear safety message to all demolition
operators, the Acting General Manager of WorkCover NSW stated.
In 1997 the defendant was contracted to demolish a number of buildings on the Fox
Studio premises in Sydney. On 30 May one of the buildings was being demolished in a
method known as controlled collapse.
Two employees of the defendant were on a scissor lift cutting timber purlins inside
the building when the structure collapsed, toppling the lift. One worker sustained a
compound fracture to one arm, injuries to the liver, fractured ribs and a fractured
pelvis. The other employee suffered a fractured pelvis, loss of several teeth, and
injuries to his tendon, cheek and mouth.
163
Case Study
The court heard that hinge cuts and rust in several of the building’s steel supports had
weakened the structure and contributed to its collapse. Justice Boland said that the
absence of the demolition supervisor as approved by the defendant’s state manager,
and his replacement with someone who was not experienced enough for such a
dangerous operation, was a serious error of judgement in respect of the defendant’s
responsibilities under the Occupational Health and Safety Act.
164
Case Study
4) List some control measures that could have been used to prevent the accident.
165
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Review
•Accidents are unwanted and can happen anytime during a working shift.
•What matters is understanding how we can predict the possible
accidents and prevent them from turning into tragedies.
•Those accidents that can cause harm to people and the workplace are
categorized as hazards when it comes to occupational health and safety.
•A responsible employer has all the safety measures to identify and
control hazards to provide a safe working environment for employees.
•Learning from past experiences is important. As engineers, it is your
responsibility to perform tasks with extra caution and check the outcome
over and over again to ensure worker safety.
•Your iron ring is a reminder of a tragedy in 1907 - the Quebec bridge
collapse.
•With the advantages of today’s tools and technologies, tragedies such as
these can be avoided.
166
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Review
167
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
– Ergonomics
– Chemical
– Psychosocial
– Biological
– Physical
– Safety
– High Risk Activities
Ref: Sign media, free sign, UK
168
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
169
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
170
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Review – Ergonomics
172
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
173
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
•This general hazard category focuses on two aspects - mechanical hazards and
human error hazards.
•Examples for this hazard are slips, trips and falls, being struck by a tool or moving
equipment, and situations that my cause MSDs.
•Below are additional examples:
–Careless driving habits
–electrical hazards
–Spills on floors or tripping hazards such as blocked aisles or cords running across
the floor
–Working from heights including ladders, scaffolds, roofs, or any raised work area
–Unguarded machinery and moving machinery parts; guards removed or moving
parts that a worker can accidentally touch
–Electrical hazards like frayed cords, missing ground pins, improper wiring
–Confined spaces
175
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
176
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
177
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
178
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
179
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
180
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
181
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
Review – PPE
182
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
184
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
186
Workplace Decision
Introduction Hazard Control Risk Assessment Review
Hazards Making
• www.ccohs.ca
• www.ihsa.ca
• www.labour.gc.ca
• www.canoshweb.org
• www.servicecanada.gc.ca
189
References
7. Robson, Lynda S., Judith A. Clarke, Kimberley Cullen, Amber Bielecky, Colette
Severin, Philip L. Bigelow, Emma Irvin, Anthony Culyer, and Quenby Mahood.
"The Effectiveness of Occupational Health and Safety Management System
Interventions: A Systematic Review." Safety Science (2007): 329-53. Print.
http://library.ryerson.ca/
8. "Health and Safety Topics." Worksafebc.com. 2015. Web. 21 Sept. 2015.
http://www.worksafebc.com/
9. "Safe Work Australia." Occupational Health and Safety. 2015. Web. 14 Sept.
2015.
http://www.safeworkaustralia.gov.au/
10. Chamberlin, John. "Hazard Identification and Control." SpaceOps 2008
Conference (2008). Print.
http://library.ryerson.ca/
11. "UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR." Occupational Safety and Health
Administration. 2015. Web. 5 Sept. 2015.
http://www.dol.gov/
12. Dejoy, David M. "Reprint of “Managing Safety in the Workplace: An Attribution
Theory Analysis and Model”." Journal of Safety Research(2013). Web.
http://library.ryerson.ca/
191
References
192