Issuejudgmentdecisiondilemma The Deontology
Issuejudgmentdecisiondilemma The Deontology
Issuejudgmentdecisiondilemma The Deontology
We need to help students realize that in order to know what to do in a given situation,
they should explore issues carefully–gathering all the relevant facts, considering the
actions involved, and evaluating the potential consequences.
Once they have clarified these points, their personal values can guide them in making a final
decision.
Decision -the action or process of deciding something or of resolving a question.
Some common mistakes that decision makers should be aware of
include:
PRIORITIE
VALUES
S
are a person's
or society’s a thing that is
beliefs about regarded as
good behavior more important
and what than another
things are
important.
The leadership development team at Melius have identified six ways to improve personal judgement:
1. Be aware of personal bias. Recognise where your unconscious preferences and motivations influence how
you make decisions.
2. Consider opposite points of view. Good judgement is about making the best decision rather than ensuring
your viewpoint wins out.
3. Accept your mistakes. Good leaders are self-aware, able to take responsibility for mistakes and to take
negative feedback when required.
4. Learn from experience. Bank what works and avoid repeating what didn’t.
5. Avoid flip-flopping. Use instinct where necessary to make a decision and start to take action.
6. Automate repeat and routine decisions to free your mind for more important decisions.
Keep a track record of your judgements for what went wrong and right
What is right today may be wrong tomorrow when events have moved on.
make sure you are not just getting what you like to hear or see
• Example 2
• My mom gave me two choices: do the dishes or clean the bathroom.
Neither sounded like much fun. What a dilemma.
Types of Dilemmas
a. Moral/Ethical Dilemma
One of the most popular themes in literature is the “moral dilemma” or “ethical dilemma,” where a character is faced
with a conflict of morals or ethics. In such a dilemma, choosing one moral will result in violating another; or, doing
one thing could bring positive results but is morally wrong. A common example is “stealing from the rich to feed the
poor.”
e. Sophie’s Choice
Getting its title from the novel of the same name, a “Sophie’s Choice” dilemma involves a choice between two things
that will lead to the death or destruction of whichever isn’t chosen.
In moral philosophy, deontological
ethics or deontology (from Greek: δέον, 'obligation,
ETHICS OR DEONTOLOGY (FROM GREEK: ΔΈΟΝ, 'OBLIGATION,
Second, Kant argued that it was not the consequences of actions that make them
right or wrong, but the motives of the person who carries out the action.
•Act only according to that maxim by which you can also will that it would become
a universal law;
•Act in such a way that you always treat humanity, whether in your own person or
in the person of any other, never simply as a means, but always at the same time
as an end; and
•Every rational being must so act as if he were through his maxim always a
legislating member in a universal kingdom of ends.
Although not all deontologists are religious, some believe in the divine command
theory, which is actually a cluster of related theories that essentially state that an
action is right if God has decreed that it is right
The divine command theory is a form of deontology because, according to it, the rightness
Divine of any action depends upon that action being performed because it is a duty, not because
of any good consequences arising from that action. If God commands people not to work
command on Sabbath, then people act rightly if they do not work on Sabbath because God has
commanded that they do not do so. If they do not work on Sabbath because they are lazy,
theory then their action is not, truly speaking, "right" even though the actual physical action
performed is the same.
If God commands not to covet a neighbour's goods, this theory holds that it would be
immoral to do so, even if coveting provides the beneficial outcome of a drive to succeed or
do well.
One problem the deontological pluralist has to face is that cases can
arise where the demands of one duty violate another duty, so-
called moral dilemmas
A typical example of epistemic
•An example of deontic
authority in Bocheński's
authority would be "the relation
usage would be "the relation of
between an employer and his
a teacher to his students." A
employee." An employer has
teacher has epistemic authority Contemporary
deontology deontic authority in the act of
when making declarative
issuing an order that the employee
sentences that the student
is obliged to accept and obey
presumes is reliable
regardless of its reliability or
knowledge and appropriate but
appropriateness.
feels no obligation to accept or
obey.
Deontology and consequentialism