5988 4.1 Government and The Macroeconomy Govt Role & Polices
5988 4.1 Government and The Macroeconomy Govt Role & Polices
5988 4.1 Government and The Macroeconomy Govt Role & Polices
Macro-economy
4.1 The role of government,
4.2 The macroeconomic aims of government
4.3 Fiscal policy
4.4 Monetary policy
4.5 Supply-side policy
The role of government in an economy
Government
Producer Employers
International Trade
Trading block
• Local Government FDI • Employs worker
• Natural Monopoly Free trade • Operate public sectors
• Strategic Industries • Reduce unemployment
• Trading block • Control price, control wages
• Partnership of public • Provide training
sector & private sector • Provide pensions
The central government makes decisions about how to achieve its macroeconomic aims :
economic growth, stable price levels, low unemployment, a healthy balance of payments and
redistribution of income and wealth. It does this by seeking to use appropriate macroeconomic
policies .For example, the national government may make decisions on the following policy
areas:
• Fiscal policy
• Monetary policy
• Supply-side policies
• Policies to protect the environment
Topic Guide
the macroeconomic aims Economic growth, full employment/low unemployment,
of government stable prices/low inflation, balance of payments stability,
redistribution of income. Reasons behind the choice of
aims and the criteria that governments set for each aim.
possible conflicts between Possible conflicts between aims: full employment versus
macroeconomic aims stable prices; economic growth versus balance of
payments stability; and full employment versus balance
of payments stability.
In general, a large and persistent balance of payments deficit suggests that the country is
uncompetitive in international markets. This can have detrimental consequences for the
domestic economy, such as job losses. Thus, a deficit on the balance of payments will have a
negative impact on economic growth and standards of living.
As it is not possible simultaneously to achieve all five macroeconomic objectives, there is said to be a
trade-off or conflict between these targets. Examples of possible conflicts between a government's
macroeconomic goals are considered below.
• Economic growth versus low inflation – if an economy grows due to excessive consumer demand,
this will force prices to increase, thus creating inflation in the economy. Similarly, the government
might choose to deflate the economy to control inflation, but this limits the ability to achieve
economic growth. Therefore, it is rather difficult to achieve both macroeconomic objectives at the
same time.
• Low unemployment (or full employment) versus inflation - In theory, there is an inverse
relationship between the level of unemployment and the rate of inflation. For example, an attempt to
reduce unemployment via the use of expansionary fiscal policy, such as lowering taxes or increasing
government spending, can cause demand-pull inflation. Similarly, when the government tries to
control inflation by using deflationary policies such as higher taxes or higher interest rates , the
resulting fall in both consumer spending and investment will result in job losses.
• Economic growth versus protection of the environment - Economic growth often leads to
environmental problems such as land degradation, climate change , pollution and the depletion of
non-renewable resources.
• Economic growth versus the redistribution of income and wealth - As an economy grows, there
tends to be a widening income and wealth gap between the rich and the poor .
Progressive tax
Direct tax – taxes on income & wealth Income ($) Tax Paid ($) Tax Rate (%)
100 10 10
Indirect Taxes – Taxes on Expenditure 500 100 20
1000 400 40
Progressive tax – A larger % of Income or
wealth of the rich.
Proportional tax
Income ($) Tax Paid ($) Tax Rate (%)
Proportional tax –same % for all tax 100 25 25
payers 500 125 25
1000 250 25
Regressive tax – A larger % of the income
or wealth of the poor.
Regressive tax
Income ($) Tax Paid ($) Tax Rate (%)
100 40 40
500 150 30
1000 200 20
• Incentives to work - Cuts in income tax can be used to create incentives for people to seek employment and to
work harder. Some economists argue that reducing social welfare assistance such as unemployment benefits
can also create incentives for people to seek employment. Government support for business start-ups can also
create incentives for entrepreneurs and business creation.
• Investment expenditure - Government capital expenditure on infrastructure (such as railroads, motorways,
schools and hospitals) helps to boost investment in the economy.
• Human capital expenditure - This refers to government expenditure on the workforce by investing in
education and training. Such fiscal policies arc designed to boost the productivity of labour (or the human
capital of the workforce). Human capital expenditure is often accompanied by government spending on
health care and transportation networks, as these help to raise labour productivity
• Recognition lags - There is a time lag in recognising that government intervention is needed to
affect the level of economic activity. This is because governments do not necessarily know if the
economy is growing too fast (or declining too quickly).
• Administrative lags - There is a time delay between recognising the need for fiscal policy
intervention and actually implementing's appropriate action, such as approving tax changes or
alterations to the government budget.
• Impact lags - There is a time lag between implementing fiscal policy and seeing the actual
effects on the economy. A cut in income tax, for example, will take time to have a significant
impact on the spending habits of households.
Interest rates
With contractionary monetary policy, also known as tight monetary policy, an increase
in interest rates rends to reduce spending and investment in the economy.
Thus, this slows down economic activity. Tight monetary policy is used to control the
threat of inflation, although it can harm economic growth and therefore cause job losses
in the long run.
» Changes in money supply — the government can control the money supply in order
to influence the level of economic activity.
» Changes in foreign exchange rates — the foreign exchange market has a direct
impact on the domestic money supply.
Expansionary monetary policy, also known as loose monetary policy, aims to boost
economic activity by expanding the money supply.
Monetary policy measures can enable the government to achieve its macroeconomic aims :
» Economic growth — the monetary policy measure of lower interest rates can be used to
achieve economic growth.
» Full employment/low unemployment — lower interest rates, as described above, will
tend to cause economic growth. More spending and investment in the economy will tend to
create more jobs.
» Stable prices/low inflation — economic growth stimulated by lower interest rates will
result in higher consumption and investment expenditure. This will increase the productive
capacity of the economy, so more can be produced without having to incur higher prices. By
contrast, higher interest rates are used to limit consumption and investment in order to control
the rate of inflation.
» Balance of payments stability — a lower exchange rate, through government
intervention in the foreign exchange market, will tend to improve the international
competitiveness of the country. Hence, this should help to improve the balance of payment.
A central bank can increase money supply by printing more money, buying back government
bonds or encouraging commercial bank to lend more.
- Printing money is a straightforward way of increasing money supply (resorting to the printing
press).
- Buying government bonds gives commercial banks more money to lend their customers.
- Increase borrowing to spend on consumer and capital goods.
- Increase consumer spending and investment
- Increase AD
- Increase output
Furthermore, economic activity is not totally and only dependent on interest rates. Other factors,
such as consumer and business confidence levels, have an impact on gross domestic product. The
global financial crisis of 2008 proved that, de spire interest rates being close to, or equal to, 0 per
cent in countries such as Japan, the USA and Hong Kong, the lack of business and consumer
confidence led to a prolonged economic recession.
Some economists argue that the use of monetary policy can be counter productive because it
restricts economic activity and discourages foreign direct investment in the country. For example,
higher interest rates raise the costs of production for firms, as existing and new loans become
more expensive. This has negative impacts on profits, job creation, research and development
expenditure, and innovation. Hence, higher interest rates (used to combat inflation) can conflict
with other macroeconomic objectives, especially with economic growth and employment.
Privatisation
Training and
education
Capital investment, programmes for
infrastructure, New
workers
technologies, R & D
Incentives to Deregulation,
work taxes reforms,
Enterprise zones
Incentives to
invest
inflation) AD1
- Increase BOP ( increasing productive potential AD
and efficiency)
- Increase export and reduce imports
0 Y Y1 Real GDP
From this, two measures can be used to gauge the level of economic growth:
» Real GDP refers to the value of national income (GDP) that is adjusted for inflation. It reflects
the true value of goods and services produced in a given year because inflation artificially raises the
value of a country’s output.
» GDP per head (or GDP per capita) measures the gross domestic product of a country
divided by its population size. This is a key measure of a country’s economic growth and standards
of living, as GDP per head indicates the mean average national income per person. Ceteris paribus,
the larger the population size, the lower the GDP per head for a certain level of GDP.
An increase in any of the components of GDP (consumption, investment, government spending or net
exports) can cause economic growth. In addition, an increase in the quantity and/or the quality of factors of
production can also create economic growth, such as an increase in the labour supply or improvements in
the state of technology. The factors that account for the differences in the economic growth rates of
different countries include variations in the following:
» Factor endowments — this refers to the quantity and quality of a country’s factors of production.
» The labour force — the size, skills and mobility of the economy’s workforce has an impact on the
country’s economic growth.
» Labour productivity — this refers to the amount of goods and services that workers produce in a
given time period. It is often referred to as output per worker, expressed as a monetary value (GDP divided
by the country’s labour force).
» Investment expenditure — investment is a component of overall demand in the economy, so any
increase in investment should help to boost the country’s GDP.
In general, economic growth is desirable due to its positive consequences for members of society.
These advantages include the following:
Economic growth can be promoted by using macroeconomic policies to increase demand in the
economy and/or boost the productive capacity of the economy. These policies include demand-
side policies (namely fiscal and monetary policies) and supply-side policies.
» Fiscal policy involves the use of taxation and/or government spending to control the
level of economic activity in the economy. If demand in the economy is too low, the
government may choose to stimulate economic growth by cutting taxes and/or increasing its
own expenditure in order to boost the level of economic activity.
» Monetary policy involves the central bank changing interest rates in order to control the
level of demand and hence economic activity. To promote economic growth, lower interest
rates can be used to cut the costs of borrowing to consumers and firms.
» While both fiscal and monetary policies target demand in order to achieve economic growth,
supply-side policies are used to increase the economy’s productive capacity. These
policies seek to increase competition, productivity and innovation in order to promote
economic growth.
There are several interrelated reasons why a recession may come about:
» higher interest rates, which discourages investment but raises demand for
savings
Causes: Consequences:
• Decrease in AD or AS • Rise unemployment
• Fall in consumer or Business • Lower living standard
confidence • Fall in investment
• Reducing govt. spending • Revenue will decline
Full employment refers to the ideal situation when everyone in a country who is willing
and able to work has a job. Governments strive to ensure that everyone who is able and
willing to work finds employment. This helps the economy to make the most of its human
resources.
The unemployment rate shows the percentage of the country's workforce (those of working age)
that is unemployed. It is calculated by the formula:
X100
Alternatively, this can be expressed as
X100
The ILO measures a country's unemployment based on the number of people who are:
• willing to work, bur unable to find it
• actively looking for work - that is, they have looked for a job in the last 4 weeks
• able to start work within the next 2 weeks or waiting to start a new job within in the next 2 weeks.
While the price of food has increased the least (only 10 per cent) since the base year, spending on food
accounts for 40 per cent of the typical household's spending. This has a much larger impact on the cost of
living than the 15 per cent increase in the price of entertainment, which accounts for only 20 per cent of the
average household expenditure.
Aggregate supply
Aggregate demand
Inflation can be controlled by using macroeconomic policies to slow down the growth of
demand in the economy and/or boost the rate of growth of the economy’s overall supply of
goods and services. These policies include the following.
Fiscal policy
Fiscal policy involves the use of taxation and/or government spending to control the level of
economic activity in the economy. If the general level of demand in the economy is too high
(causing demand-pull inflation), the government may choose to ‘tighten fiscal policy’ by
raising taxes and/or reducing its own expenditure in order to reduce the level of economic
activity.
Monetary policy
Monetary policy involves the central bank changing interest rates in order to control the
level of economic activity. For example, higher interest rates may reduce consumer and
investment expenditure as the cost of borrowing (to fund household spending and business
investments) soars.
Lower interest rates can also be used to control deflation as the cut in interest rates
reduces the exchange rate, ceteris paribus. This is because foreign investors receive a lower
return on their investments. The resulting fall in the exchange rate brings about a fall in
the price of imports and hence an increase in the demand for exports.
Supply-side policies
Whilst both fiscal and monetary policies target the demand side of the economy in order to
tackle the issue of inflation or deflation, supply-side policies are used to increase the
economy’s productive capacity. These policies seek to increase competition,
productivity and innovation in order to maintain lower prices. Some countries, such as Iran
and France, have used subsidies for food and fuel to reduce prices in the economy.
A reduction in corporate tax rates can also encourage risk-taking and greater
investment. Countries that do not charge any corporate tax include Bahrain, the Bahamas,
the Cayman Islands, the Isle of Man and the United Arab Emirates.
In the short run, fiscal and monetary policies are used to control inflation or
deflation. In the long run, supply-side policies boost the productive capacity of
the economy, thereby giving it flexibility to grow without suffering from the costs of inflation.