MEC-6
MEC-6
1
Agenda
Monitor & Control Project Work
Perform Integrated Change Control
2
Monitor & Control Project Work - Inputs & Outputs
1. PMP 1. WPR
Monitor &
2. WPI 2. Change Requests
Control
3. OPA 3. PMP Updates
Project
4. Schedule Forecast 4. PD Updates
Work
5. Cost Forecast 5. OPA Updates
6. Validated Changes
7. EEF
3
Monitor & Control Project Work Inputs – 1/5
Input Details
Project • Communications management plan
Management Plan • Cost baseline
• Cost management plan
• Human resource management plan
• Process improvement plan
• Procurement management plan
• Scope baseline
• Quality management plan
• Requirements management plan
• Risk management plan
• Schedule baseline
• Schedule management plan
• Scope management plan
• Stakeholder management plan
4
Monitor & Control Project Work Inputs – 2/5
Input Details
Schedule Forecast • Derived from progress against the schedule baseline and
(from Control expressed in terms of schedule variance (SV) and
Schedule) schedule performance index (SPI)
• Forecasted Project Completion Date derived from Planned
Project Duration and SPI
• The forecast may be used to determine if the project is
still within defined tolerance ranges and identify any
necessary change requests.
Cost Forecast • Derived from progress against the cost baseline and
(from Control computed estimates to complete (ETC), expressed in
Cost) terms of cost variance (CV) and cost performance index
(CPI)
• Estimate at completion (EAC) can be compared to the
Budget at completion (BAC) to see if the project is still
within tolerance ranges or if a change request is required
• Forecast also ascertained through ETC and TCPI
5
Monitor & Control Project Work Inputs – 3/5
Input Details
Validated • Approved changes that result from the Perform Integrated Change
Changes Control process require Validation to ensure that the change was
appropriately implemented
• A validated change provides the necessary data to confirm that
the change was appropriately executed
6
Monitor & Control Project Work Inputs – 4/5
Input Details
EEF • Governmental or industry standards (e.g., regulatory agency
regulations, codes of conduct, product standards, quality
standards, and workmanship standards)
• Organization work authorization systems
• Stakeholder risk tolerances
• Project Management Information System (e.g., an automated tool
suite, such as a scheduling software tool, a configuration
management system, an information collection and distribution
system, or web interfaces to other online automated systems).
7
Monitor & Control Project Work Inputs – 5/5
Input Details
OPA • Organisational communication requirements
• Financial controls procedures (e.g., time reporting, required
expenditure and disbursement reviews, accounting codes, and
standard contract provisions)
• Issue and defect management procedures defining issue and
defect controls, issue and defect identification, and resolution and
action item tracking
• Change control procedures, including those for scope, schedule,
cost, and quality variances
• Risk control procedures including risk categories, probability
definition and impact, and probability and impact matrix
• Process measurement database used to make available
measurement data on processes and products
• Lessons learned database
8
Monitor & Control Project Work Outputs … 1/3
Output Details
Change • Variances from comparing planned results to actual results
Requests • Change Requests expand, adjust, or reduce Project Scope, Product
Scope, or Qualty Requirements and Schedule or Cost Baselines
• Change Requests may necessitate the collection and documentation
of new requirements
• Change Requests can impact the project management plan, project
documents, or product deliverables
• Changes that meet the project’s change control criteria should go
through the integrated change control process established for the
project
• Changes may include:
- Corrective action—An intentional activity that realigns the
performance of the project work with the Proj Management Plan
- Preventive action—An intentional activity that ensures the future
performance of the project work is aligned with the Project
Management Plan
- Defect Repair—an intentional activity to modify a nonconforming
product or product component
9
Monitor & Control Project Work Outputs … 2/3
WPR • WPR are the physical or electronic representation of WPI compiled
in project documents, intended to generate decisions, actions, or
awareness
• Project information may be communicated verbally from person
to person. However, in order to record, store, and sometimes
distribute WPI, a physical or electronic representation in the form
of project documents is required
• WPR are a subset of project documents, which are intended to
create awareness and generate decisions or actions
• Specific work performance metrics may be defined at the start of
the project and included in the normal WPR provided to key
stakeholders
• Examples: status reports, memos, justifications, information
notes, recommendations, and updates
PMP/PD
Updates
10
Monitor & Control Proj Work – Tools & Techniques … 1/2
Tools & Techs Details
Expert To interpret the information provided by the monitor and
Judgement control processes, or to resolve any situation emerging from the
M&C process, expert judgement from professionals in the
industry may be sought
11
Monitor & Control Proj Work – Tools & Techniques … 2/2
Tools & Techs Details
Analytical To forecast potential outcomes based on possible
Techniques variations of project or environmental variables and their
relationships with other variables:
• Regression analysis
• Grouping methods
• Causal analysis
• Root cause analysis
• Forecasting methods (e.g., time series, scenario building,
simulation, etc.)
• Failure mode and effect analysis (FMEA)
• Fault tree analysis (FTA)
• Reserve analysis
• Trend analysis
• Earned value management (EVM)
• Variance analysis
12
M&C PW – Tools & Techniques - Grouping
• Grouping methods
• Causal analysis
• Root cause analysis Root Cause Analysis
• Failure Mode & Effect Analysis (FMEA)
• Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)
• Regression Analysis
• Forecasting methods
Trend Analysis, Smoothing,
• Trend analysis Forecasting
• Earned Value Management
• Variance Analysis
13
Grouping Methods
14
Route Cause Analysis (RCA) & Causal Analysis
15
RCA – Cause & Effect Diagram
• Project: Improving the Quality of a University's MBA3.5 (3.5 yrs) Programme
• 1st Objective: Root cause the reason for low quality of MBA(3.5 yrs) graduates
Educational
Extent of Business
Background
Education
Weak FA/FSc
Weak BA/BSc/BCom
Roadmap
unextenable BA/BSc/BCom from
3.5 yrs vis-à-vis Low-Key Institutes
5.5/6.5 others BA/BSc in Low-Key subjects
Low Quality Product
in MBA (3.5 yrs)
Late Start Weak Inter-Personal Skills
Relatively
Early Finish Weak English
Time & Cost
Fixed
16
RCA – Cause & Effect Diagram leading to Pareto Analysis
The possible root causes ascertained from the Cause & Effect diagram could next could be short-
listed through further RCA. Say a sample of 100 MBA(3.5yrs) students was surveyed which
returned the following data which could then be subjected to Pareto analysis to identify those
root-causes which would be responsible for 80% of the problem.
Raw Survey Data Pareto Tabulation
Root Causes Count Count %age Cum %age
1 Weak FA/FSc 90 97
5 21.1% 21.1%
2 Weak BA/BSc/BCom 18 95
6 20.7% 41.8%
3 BA/BSc/BCom from low-key institutes 7 90
1 19.6% 61.4%
4 BA/BSc/BCom in low-key subjects 15 88
8 19.2% 80.6%
5 Weak Inter-Personal Skills 97 18
2 3.9% 84.5%
6 Weak English 95 15
4 3.3% 87.8%
7 MBA3.5 roadmap unextendable 12 15
10 3.3% 91.1%
8 3.5 yrs vis-à-vis 5.5/6.5 others 88 12
7 2.6% 93.7%
9 Late start 12 12
9 2.6% 96.3%
10 Relatively early finish 15 10
11 2.2% 98.5%
11 Time & Cost fixed 10 7
3 1.5% 100.0%
17
RCA – Cause & Effect Diagram leading to Pareto Analysis
120 100%
90%
100
80%
70%
80
60%
60 50%
40%
40
30%
20%
20
10%
0 0%
18
RCA – the 5 Whys
• Problem: Excavator, an important source on the project, not starting
19
Failure Mode & Effect Analysis (FMEA)
20
FMEA - Application
Monitoring & Control: Track changes to process-
incorporated to avoid potential failures
21
22
FMEA
• Project: New Fuel-Efficient, Composite Material Commercial Plane (Boeing 787
Dreamliner)
• Deliverable: Lithium Ion Batteries
Product/Deliverable: Lithium Ion Battery FMEA Team: ABC (Chief Designer) Page No: 7 of 104
System: Electrical DEF (Head of Elect Dept) FMEA No. 1234
Sub-System: Back-Up Power GHI (Battery Specialist) Date: 7 Nov 2010
Part No: xxxx-xxxx-xxxx IJK (Configuration Manager)
Function Potential Potential Potential Current Recommend- RPN
Detection (D)
Failure Mode Effect(s) of Causes of Controls/ ed Actions
Occurrence
Severity (S)
Failure Failure Tests
(O)
Provide Overheating/ - Toxic Fumes 10 Short- 2 (Test No) 10 Redesign 200
back-up Meltdown in cabin circuiting in
power to - Explosion in Fuel Cells
aircraft battery
instrumen compt Recharging 3 (Test No) 10 Check Elect 300
tation - Fire Malfunction Charging Sys
Unbalanced 2 (Test No) 10 Redesign 200
Chemical
Reaction
Battery Compt 3 (Test No) 1 Check AC 30
AC failure system
FMEA
• Project: New Fuel-Efficient, Composite Material Commercial Plane
(Boeing 787 Dreamliner)
• Deliverable: Lithium Ion Batteries
• Problem: Over-heating & melt-down
Battery Compartment
23
Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)
24
Fault Tree Analysis
• Project: New Commercial Plane
• Deliverable: Evacuation Chute
• Problem: Failure of Auto-Deployment
25
Fault Tree Analysis
Auto-
• Project: New Commercial Plane Deployment
• Deliverable: Evacuation Chute Failure
26
Quantitative Forecasting
Quantitative
Forecasting
27
Moving Average … 1/3
• Moving Average (Rolling Average or Running Average) is a
calculation to analyse data points by creating a series of averages
of different subsets of the full data set
• Variations include: Simple, Weighted, Centred, Exponential etc
• Moving Average is used to overcome irregular, random, seasonal
or cyclic variations
• Overcoming variations is called "smoothing“
• Moving Average is a smoothing process
• Smoothing by Moving Average is done by taking average of three
(or more) recent observations, then dropping the first observation
and advancing to the next one, and continuing the process till
getting to the period/unit for which forecast is required
28
Moving Average … 2/3
• Each new data point is included in the average as it becomes
available, and the oldest data point is discarded
• The number of observations averaged is referred to as the
“k” number; the constant number k is specified at the outset
• The smaller the number k, the more weight is given to recent
periods; the greater the number k, the less weight is given to
recent periods
• A large k is desirable when there are wide, infrequent
fluctuations in the series.
• A small k is most desirable when there are sudden shifts in
the level of series
• For quarterly data, a four-quarter moving average, MA(4),
eliminates or averages out seasonal effects
29
Moving Average … 3/3
• For monthly data, a 12-month moving average, MA(12),
eliminate or averages out seasonal effect
• Equal weights are assigned to each observation used in the
average
30
Forecasting Variations
Irregular
variation
Trend
Cycle
Seasonal Variations
Case A Case B
Simple and Moving Averages can be House Duration to House Duration to
used to forecast and smoothen data. # Complete # Complete
1 260 1 250
Example: On a multi-housing project, 2 245 2 280
the time of completion of the first 10
3 255 3
houses (H1 to H10) is indicated in the 230
tables, headed Case A and Case B. 4 246 4 220
What can be the forecasted duration 5 254 5 260
of House # 11 (H11) in each case?
6 243 6 250
7 253 7 260
8 242 8 230
9 254 9 220
10 248 10 240
11 ? 11 ?
32
SMA – Understanding the Basic Concepts
265 Case A
260
260 House Duration to
255
255
254 253 254 # Complete
250 1 260
245 248 2
245
246 245
240 243 242 3 255
235 4 246
230 5 254
225
6 243
220
H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H7 H8 H9 H10 H11 7 253
8 242
Forecasted Duration of H11 9 254
Mean 250.0 Fixed Average 10 248
Mean (minus 1st) 248.9 (the 1st House it took longer) 11 ?
Mean (last 3) 248.0 Moving Average at k = 3
Mean (last 4) 249.3 Moving Average at k = 4
Mean (last 5) 248.0 Moving Average at k = 5
33
SMA – Understanding the Basic Concepts
265261 Case B
260
260 f(x) = − 2.61818181818182
256 x + 264.4 House Duration to
255 253 # Complete
257
250 1 261
247
245 242 2 257
245 239
240 3
240 260
235 4 253
230 5 256
225
6 245
220
H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H7 H8 H9 H10 H11 7 247
Forecasted Duration of H11 8 240
Mean 9 242
250.0 Fixed Average
Mean (minus 1st three) 10 239
246.0 (first three houses took longer)
Mean (last 3) 11 ?
240.3 Moving Average at k = 3
Mean (last 4) 242.0 Moving Average at k = 4
Mean (last 5) 242.6 Moving Average at k = 5
Using Trend Line 235.6 (trend line considers all data) 34
SMA – How to work out Case A
House Duration to SMA SMA Error Squared Error Squared
# Complete (k=3) (k=4) (k=3) (k=4)
(a) (b) (c) (a-b)2 (a-c)2
1 260
2 245
3 255
4 246 253.3 53.8
5 254 248.7 251.5 28.4 6.3
6 243 251.7 250.0 75.1 49.0
7 253 247.7 249.5 28.4 12.3
8 242 250.0 249.0 64.0 49.0
9 254 246.0 248.0 64.0 36.0
10 248 249.7 248.0 2.8 0.0
11 248.0 249.3
Mean Square Error 6.7 5.0
(a-b)2/n (a-c)2/n
35
265260
SMA – Graphical Representation 260
255
255 254 253 254
250
265 Case A 245
240 245 246
243 242
248
235
230
260
260 225
220
H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H7 H8 H9 H10 H11
255
255 254 254
253
250 249.25
248 248
245 246
245
243
242
240
Actual Durations SMA (k=3) SMA (k=4)
235
H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H7 H8 H9 H10 H11
36
Weighted Moving Average (WMA)
• WMA is used when it is required to give different weightage to
different data. For example it may be required to give more
weightage to recent data
• Example: In the original multi-housing project example (Case A), it
is required to forecast the duration of the 11th house by giving 1/2
weightage to the most recent house duration, 1/3 to the middle
duration and 1/6 to the earliest.
8 240
9 245
10 253
11 Forecast = 240/6 + 245x1/3 + 253x1/2 = 248.2
37
Centred Moving Average (CMA)
• CMA is used for a number of situations particularly when there is
a seasonal component, or when there is a requirement to use the
past data
• CMA can be computed, using data equally spaced on either side
of the point in the series where the mean is calculated
• When k is even, “smoothing of smoothing” is done
38
CMA Data as per Case A
k odd (3)
House Duration to SMA CMA CMA Error
# Complete (k=3) (k=3) Squared (k=3)
(a) (b) (c) (a-c)2
1 260
2 245 253.3 69.4
3 255 248.7 40.1
4 246 253.3 251.7 32.1
5 254 248.7 247.7 40.1
6 243 251.7 250.0 49.0
7 253 247.7 246.0 49.0
8 242 250.0 249.7 58.8
9 254 246.0 248.0 36.0
10 248 249.7
11 248.0
Mean Square Error (MSE) 6.6
(a-c)2/n
39
CMA Data as per Case A
265
255
255 254 254
253
250
248.0
248
248
245 246
245
243
242
240
235
H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H7 H8 H9 H10 H11
40
CMA k even (4) Data as per Case A
House Dur to SMA (k=4) CMA (k=4) CMA Error
# Complete Sq (k=4)
(a) (c) (c) (a-c)2
1 260
2 245
2.5 251.5
3 255 250.8 26.3
3.5 250.0
4 246 249.8 15.0
4.5 249.5
5 254 251.5 249.3 15.0
5.5 249.0
6 243 250.0 248.5 54.4
6.5 248.0
7 253 249.5 248.0 19.1
7.5 248.0
8 242 249.0 248.6 33.1
8.5 249.3
9 254 248.0
10 248 248.0
11 249.3
Mean Square Error (MSE) 5.2
(a-c)2/n 41
CMA Data as per Case A
265
255
255 254 254
253
250
248
249.25
248.625
245 246
245
243
242
240
235
H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H7 H8 H9 H10 H11
42
Exponential Moving Average (EMA)
• EMA weigh past observations using exponentially decreasing
weights as the observations get older; recent observations are
given relatively more weight than the older observations
• The amount of weight applied to the past observations, or the
degree of smoothing required, is determined by the “smoothing
constant”
• In summary, This is in contrast to the SMA, in which the same the
weights assigned to the observations are the same and are equal
to 1/n. In EMA, however, there are one or more smoothing
parameters to be determined (or estimated) and these choices
determine the weights assigned to the observations
43
EMA
• The exponential smoothing equation is:
Fn+1 = yn + (1- )Fn
where Fn+1 = Forecast for the next unit (to be estimated)
a = Smoothing constant, such 0 < ≤ 1
yn = Actual value of the most recent unit
Fn = Forecasted value of the most recent unit
• Expanding the Equation:
Fn+1 = yn + (1- )Fn
[ yn-1 + (1- )Fn-1]
= yn + (1- )
= yn + (1- )yn-1 + (1- )2Fn-1
= (1- )0yn + (1- )1yn-1 + (1- )2Fn-1
[ yn-2 + (1- )Fn-2]
= (1- )0yn + (1- )1yn-1 + (1- )2
= (1- )0yn + (1- )1yn-1 + (1- )2Yn-2+ (1- )3Fn-2
= (1- )0yn + (1- )1yn-1 + (1- )2Yn-2+ (1- )3Fn-2 ……… (1- )n-1y1
= [(1- )0yn + (1- )1yn-1 + (1- )2Yn-2+ (1- )3yn-3 ……… (1- )n-1y1]
44
EMA
• However, in application, EMA is a simple affair. All what is
required to be done is:
– Select a suitable smoothing constant ()
– Take the most recent observation (yn) and multiply it with the smoothing
constant
– Take what was the forecasted (Fn) value of the most recent observation/
event and multiply it with the complementary of the smoothing constant
i.e (1- )
– Add the two products; the sum is the forecasted value for the next unit
• If the forecasted value (Fn) of the recent most event is not
available, then:
– Start analysing the data from the start, or from where the last (Fn) is
available, by calculating Fn using the EMA equation
– Continue calculating Fn by applying the EMA equation until the forecasted
value of the target event is available
45
46
EMA
# Actual Forecasted # Actual Forecasted
Observation Observation Observation Observation
(yn) (yn)
(Fn, ,=0.8) (Fn,=0.8)
260.0
2 245 260.0 2 245
248.0
3 255 248.0 3 255
253.6
246 253.6 246
247.5
254 247.5 254
252.7
243 252.7 243
244.9
253 244.9 253
251.4
n-2 242 251.4 n-2 242
243.9
n-1 254 243.9 n-1 254
252.0
n 248 252.0 n 248
248.8 248.8
n+1 n+1
EMA
• Small ( 0) would mean:
– Little consideration to actual/historical data, maximum consideration to
previously forecasted data
– Maximum smoothening of the data
• Large ( 1) would mean:
– Maximum consideration to actual/historical data, little consideration to
previously forecasted data
– Little smoothening of the data
47
48
EMA – Example (original Case A)
• Consider the data for the original Case A
• yn & Fn for various values of are tabulated:
H# Duration to Forecasted Duration (Fn)
Complete (yn)
=1 = 0.8 = 0.6 = 0.5 = 0.4 = 0.2 = 0.1 = 0.0
1
260 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0
2 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0 260.0
245
3 245.0 248.0 251.0 252.5 254.0 257.0 258.5 260.0
255
4 255.0 253.6 253.4 253.8 254.4 256.6 258.2 260.0
246
5 246.0 247.5 249.0 249.9 251.0 254.5 256.9 260.0
254
6 254.0 252.7 252.0 251.9 252.2 254.4 256.6 260.0
243
7 243.0 244.9 246.6 247.5 248.5 252.1 255.3 260.0
253
8 253.0 251.4 250.4 250.2 250.3 252.3 255.0 260.0
242
9 242.0 243.9 245.4 246.1 247.0 250.2 253.7 260.0
254
10 254.0 252.0 250.5 250.1 249.8 251.0 253.8 260.0
248
11 248.0 248.8 249.0 249.0 249.1 250.4 253.2 260.0
49
EMA – Example (original Case A)
262
260 260.0
258
256
254
253.2
252
250.4
250
248.8
248 248.0
248
246
244 249.0
242
Yn Fn @ α=1.0 Fn @ α=0.8
240 Fn @ α=0.6 Fn @ α=0.5 Fn @ α=0.4
Fn @ α=0.2 Fn @ α=0.1 Fn @ α=0.0
238
H1 H2 H3 H4 H5 H6 H7 H8 H9 H10 H11
50
EMA – Example (original Case B)
• Consider the data for the original Case B
• yn & Fn for various values of are tabulated:
H# Duration to Forecasted Duration (Fn)
Complete (yn)
=1 = 0.8 = 0.6 = 0.5 = 0.4 = 0.2 = 0.1 = 0.0
1
261 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0
2 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0 261.0
257
3 257.0 257.8 258.6 259.0 259.4 260.2 260.6 261.0
260
4 260.0 259.6 259.4 259.5 259.6 260.2 260.5 261.0
253
5 253.0 254.3 255.6 256.3 257.0 258.7 259.8 261.0
256
6 256.0 255.7 255.8 256.1 256.6 258.2 259.4 261.0
245
7 245.0 247.1 249.3 250.6 252.0 255.5 258.0 261.0
247
8 247.0 247.0 247.9 248.8 250.0 253.8 256.9 261.0
240
9 240.0 241.4 243.2 244.4 246.0 251.1 255.2 261.0
242
10 242.0 241.9 242.5 243.2 244.4 249.3 253.9 261.0
239
11 239.0 239.6 240.4 241.1 242.2 247.2 252.4 261.0
51
EMA – Example (original Case B)
262
261.0
260
258
256
254
252.4
252
250
248
Yn Fn @ α=1.0 247.2
246 Fn @ α=0.8 Fn @ α=0.6
52
53
Equation of a Straight Line
14
y = a + bx 13
f(x) = 2 x + 3
where 12
11 y-diff 8
x = value of independent variable, Slope = x-diff = 4 = 2
y-differential (=8)
10
on the x-axis 9
on the y-axis 7
6
a = intercept on the y-axis; fixed 5
cost, quantity etc 4 x-differential (=4)
differential in y-values to 2
Intercept on Y-axis (= 3)
corresponding differential in 1
x-values -2 -1
0
0 1 2 3 4 5
-1
-2
54
Correlation & Regression - Example
• The amount of cement consumed on a multi-housing project is a
function of the covered area of the house
• Independent Variable (x) Covered Area (deca square meters)
Dependent Variable (y) Cement consumed (deca bags)
• Data as follows:
x y
10 30
12 32
6 25
15 46
8 29
5 19
• Work out the Regression Line and the Correlation Coefficient (R)
55
Correlation & Regression - Example
x y xy x2 y2
45
f(x) = 2.26635514018692 x + 9.01401869158879
40 R² = 0.900599953290171
Cement Bags (x10)
35
30
25
20
15
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Covered Area (sq meter x 10 )
56
Correlation & Regression
57
Finding the Regression Line Equation & the “R”
58
59
How to Work out “R” & Regression Equation
• Manually (like we did)
• Scientific Calculator
• Trend line on Chart
• Excel Sheet, manually with formula
• Excel Sheet, using Data Analysis Feature
• Softwares, eg Minitab
60