The 10 Best Doormats, Tested and Reviewed

Best Overall

Entryways Coir Rope Knot Doormat

$89 at Amazon $116 at Walmart View on Bed Bath & Beyond

Out of all of the doormats we tested, our top choice is the Entryways Coir Rope Doormat. When it comes to outdoor doormats, coir (pronounced COY-er) is the gold standard for good reason. Made from coconut husks, this doormat is thick and scratchy. During testing, we found that the material worked great for getting gunk, including dirt and leaves, off shoes. It also absorbs moisture, so you don't track footprints into the house.

But unlike many standard coir options, this one’s attractive design makes it look more than utilitarian. We found its appearance also transcended aesthetics—the weave helps trap more dirt and moisture than your standard doormat, making it great for rainy or snowy regions.

We were also very pleased to see that the doormat remained firm and had not loosened up even significantly when we tested it at home. There were no visible signs of wear and tear, and the weave was completely undamaged. Made of natural fiber, this doormat does shed a little bit, as we noted in our experience, and it's written on the tag itself. The doormat also doesn't have a rubber backing.

However, the doormat was quite stable, and we didn't experience any instances of the doormat slipping. Overall, we think this rug's durability, style, and value make it worthy of the best overall pick. It also comes in two sizes, which makes it an excellent choice for nearly all door sizes.

_{Dimensions: 18 x 30 inches; 24 x 36 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Coir}

Best Budget

Gorilla Grip Traffic Guard Doormat

$21 at Amazon

Just because a doormat is inexpensive does not mean it is ineffective at preventing dirt from entering your home. We tested the Gorilla Grip Traffic Guard Door Mat in our home and found it a great dual indoor-outdoor mat option. After nearly two years of use, our doormat still looks intact, which is quite impressive given that it costs less than $25. 

We placed the doormat in the atrium of our apartment building, and it has been a game changer. Thanks to its ribbed surface, it effectively removes water and debris from shoes, which means less mess for us to clean up inside.

Its low-profile design allows it to fit perfectly in both our entryway and inside our apartment. That said, it might not work well if you have a door draft stopper. While it does slip a bit on less-textured surfaces like tile and laminate, as long as there is weight resting on it from your feet, it stays in place.

The doormat is available in nine different colors; however, we recommend opting for the darker shades. Our charcoal grey doormat collects a lot of dust, but the dirt is hardly noticeable, keeping our entryway looking clean at all times. To remove the accumulated dust, we recommend shaking the mat several times and then running our vacuum over the surface.

_{Dimensions: Varies︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Rubber}

Best Washable

Ruggable Coco Mata Doormat

$139 at Amazon View on Ruggable.com

The Ruggable Coco Mata Doormat is undoubtedly pricey, but during testing, we were obsessed with its innovative design, 100 percent washable materials, and durability. This doormat is actually two separate pieces: a doormat cover and a rubber mat. The rubber mat acts as a grippy base for the cover, which fits into a cutout in the rubber. Even after being subjected to numerous spills and a cat who really enjoyed pulling the rug up, the doormat showed no signs of damage.

The rubber mat features patented ClingEffect Pucks, which keep the entire system in place. It also has holes throughout, so water can quickly drain from the cover and through the rubber. We also found the slanted edges to be a particularly helpful feature, as they made walking over easy without stumbling, catching shoes, or needing to step over. Additionally, it ensured that the mat remained firmly in position and that any accidentally spilled liquids would collect in the rubber mat rather than dripping onto the floor. 

Out of all the doormats on our list, the Ruggable is the easiest to clean because the cover can be machine-washed and hung to dry. Although we dropped a huge cup of coffee on the mat while testing, we simply had to wash the rubber portion by hosing it down, but the mat itself was machine-washable. Almost no work was required to clean it, and it remained spotless throughout.

Not a fan of the Coco Mata design? Not a problem. Ruggable has tons of doormat cover designs from which to choose. Plus, once you purchase the rubber mat, you can purchase the interchangeable covers separately for a truly customizable doormat experience. The inked designs are also UV-resistant, so they'll truly stand the test of every season's weather.

_{Dimensions: 24 x 36 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Rubber}

Best for Rain

Calloway Mills Gatsby Rubber Door Mat

$47 at Amazon $48 at Walmart $38 at Home Depot

Durability is one of the first things we noted about this doormat. We found that the rubber was extremely heavy and well-made. Once you put this mat in place, it’s not going anywhere—you can rub your shoes repeatedly, and it doesn't move a single inch. This is a nice design feature for wetter climates, not only because of slippage but also because it doesn’t get water-logged the same way other types of doormats do.

This mat was the largest one we tested, measuring in at an impressive 48 inches in length. While we appreciated that it covered a lot of surface area by our door, keep in mind that the mat might be too cramped for a particularly tiny area. 

With that said, the mat is mold-, mildew-, and odor-resistant. This material is great for removing excess dirt, salt, and other debris from your shoes, but it won't help you dry them because it isn't porous. It's very effective for the most part and has a nice design. The elegant fleur-de-lys pattern looks right at home just about anywhere.

_{Dimensions: 48 x 30 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Rubber}

Best Design

Letterfolk Tile Mat

$74 at Amazon $75 at Target View on Letterfolk.com

The Letterfolk Tile Mat is a real standout, not only because of its attractive black-and-white colorway (it comes in more than two dozen other colors, too!) but also because of its customization. The doormat comes with additional “tiles” you can swap in and out to create your personal color pattern or even use to write a word.

This mat lacks a bit in efficacy, though—we found that although it removed debris from shoes, the glossy texture made it difficult to dry the mud and wetness adequately. In fact, the mat even became a little bit slippery in wet conditions. Fortunately, it's really simple to clean, so you can dry it quickly and get it back to use right away.

When shopping for a high-quality, aesthetically pleasing doormat, the Letterfolk Tile Mat is a great pick for individuals who enjoy adding a personal touch to their home decor. Compared to the other doormats on our list, it stands out due to its distinctive design and personalizability.

_{Dimensions: 18 x 30 inches; 24 x 36 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Flexible vinyl}

Best Durable

The Rope Co. Lobster Rope Doormat

View on Theropeco.com $105 at Food52

Like our best for rain pick, the Rope Co. Nautical Rope Doormat was also extremely durable during testing. The ropes on this mat are woven extremely tight, so we found that it isn't susceptible to premature wear, no matter how many people wipe their feet on it each day.

As an added bonus, the mat's construction from nautical rope makes it mold- and mildew-resistant and prevents it from soaking up too much water, making it ideal for wet regions. Regarding the design, we were drawn to its beachy aesthetic and its availability in nearly 30 colorways, allowing it to complement various home designs.

If there’s any downside, it’s that there’s no rubber on the back. Because of this, the doormat tends to slide around a bit, which The Rope Co. mentions in the product listing. We found it was best to put this mat right up against the door, so you can still get the traction you need to wipe your shoes. You can also purchase a rug pad separately, if you're looking for the most traction, especially during slippery weather.

_{Dimensions: 18 x 30 inches; 21 x 34 inches; 24 x 38 inches; 26 x 50 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Nautical rope}

Best Indoor/Outdoor

L.L.Bean Heavyweight Recycled Waterhog Doormat

$45 at L.L. Bean

Featuring an elegant leaf design, this doormat is more beautiful than it appears despite its simplicity. But don't let its appearance fool you; it's still very efficient as both an indoor and outdoor mat. With its non-slip backing, this lovely mat stayed put no matter how hard we rubbed our shoes on it. Because it's pretty thin, you can place it indoors in your entryway without the concern of it preventing the door from opening.

We put the doormat at our back door for testing purposes and found that all of the moisture and dirt from our yard would get trapped inside the mat's fibers and off our floors. Aside from picking up leaves and grime off our shoes, the mat can also hold almost two gallons of water per square yard, making it great for places with heavy rain or snowfall.

To clean the doormat, we used a vacuum to pick up the dirt and debris that had settled into it from the yard. That said, because of the raised leaf motif, we had to run the vacuum through it multiple times to get into all the nooks and crannies.

_{Dimensions: Varies︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Polyester and rubber}

Best for Winter

Calloway Mills Hello Natural/Black Script Door Mat

$28 at Amazon $37 $28 at Walmart $28 at Home Depot

Coir's remarkable resilience to severe weather makes it ideal for usage in the winter and other cold and wet seasons. We tested this doormat in our home and were quite pleased with its performance. We found that it's great for drying out shoes before you bring them inside your house, thanks to its rough texture for sloughing off dirt, snow, and debris.

The bright and cheery design was one of the things that we loved best about this doormat. We think it would be a beautiful complement to any foyer. Keep in mind that, like our experience with our best overall, shedding is a normal part of using coir mats, yet it is worth mentioning nonetheless. If you are shopping for a long-lasting, practical, and aesthetically pleasing doormat that'll keep the snow and ice melts off your home floors, this coir doormat is a great pick.

_{Dimensions: 24 x 36 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Coir}

Best for Sand

Crate & Barrel Teak Mat

$90 at Crate And Barrel

It doesn’t get much prettier than this sustainably forested teak-slatted doormat. It not only looks nice but is also expertly crafted and appears much more expensive than it is. If you’re wondering where it lost out, it’s for a minor flaw—because of the slats, the doormat doesn’t dry shoes quite as well as some other options.

Still, in wet weather, the wood dries very quickly. And overall, it's excellent at removing debris from shoes. We noticed this doormat would be perfect for beachfront and tropical locations because the dirt and debris fall between the slats rather than become trapped in fibers. To clean the sand (or other dirt and debris) away, you can simply lift the mat and give the area a quick sweep or vacuum.

Overall, the mat is extremely heavy and durable, so it doesn’t slip and slide as you wipe your feet. Just be careful where you place this mat—we didn’t have any issues with the material staining the floor, but the teak material could leave stains over time.

_{Dimensions: 20 x 32 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Teak}

Best for Pets

Home Dynamix Comfy Pooch Clean Paw Door Mat

View on Home Depot

We don't want to point fingers (or paws), but our furry friends are often the (unintentional) culprits of tracking mud and dirt through our clean homes. The Home Dynamix is specifically designed for pups who love to play in the rain and mud. I tested this doormat in my home and can attest to how well the texture cleaned my pup's wet and muddy paw after a rainy walk.

The microfiber is also very soft, making it appropriate for sensitive paws and bellies compared to traditional coir or rope mats. One of my favorite features of this doormat is that machine washable. Even after multiple washes, the doormat looks brand new and retains its original appearance. It also has a non-slip backing without the latex coating that often deteriorates over time.

While this doormat is wonderful overall, I do wish it was more suitable for outdoor use (aside from enclosed porches), however, we don't fault it for this based on its otherwise stellar design.

_{Dimensions: 30 x 21 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Polyester}