Half Baked Cookies

These are some of the best cookies in Buffalo. I stopped in for a quick treat after running some errands and I even had enough points for a free cookie!

I have been to this location and the Elmwood location, both are great but this one is a little closer to home. The service is always super quick and friendly at both spots. There are so many cookies to choose from. This time we tried out a couple of favorites plus some new ones like the Strawberry Poptart and Raspberry Cheesecake cookies.

These cookies are huge, and very dense. They really each could be their own dessert but if you have a couple, you will be very full. They remind me of another cookie brand that I have had down south. Pretty cool concept here and they have other desserts too. I even saw what looked like strawberry milk in their cooler and I can't remember the last time I had a glass of that!

Overall, this is a great option for a quick treat or a nice little dessert to finish off a meal. I will definitely be back for more cookies soon since they never last long once I get home.

So I do not bake, so I ordered a tray of cookies for the holidays. I scheduled a delivery, order came early, which I loved. I didn't select the cookies just did a random tray and the selections that came were all very good. The cookies definitely are fresh and homemade. I love the half baked concept! Would definitely buy from them again.

My tray contained:
Monster
Funfetti
Oatmeal raisin
Chocolate peanut butter
Chocolate chip walnut
Molasses
Peppermint

The were cut in perfect sizes and no way I could have eaten a full cookie!!!

A must for anyone who likes cookies!
Big, thick, soft - all around perfect texture.
Check out their site or social media pages to find out their specialty cookies for the week.
They even do a "Name of the Day" where you can get a free cookie if your name is chosen.
They have options for those who eat gluten-free and vegan.
Just be prepared to have to make a tough decision. All look so great!
This trip I tried the Monster - perfect blend of m&ms and Oreo chunks. Loved that it had a slightly underbaked texture. (Pro-tip: microwave for 30 seconds on power level 3 to get that freshly baked taste).
Got my mom one of the specialty gluten-free choices, strawberry lemonade. She said the flavor was spot-on and it reminded her of a mix between a scone and cookie.

Can't wait to go back!

We were craving something sweet after dinner so we stopped by this place, which had been on our "to-try" list for awhile. We were not disappointed! Even at 8:00pm on a Friday night the selection was great and the cookies still felt fresh. We got one chocolate chip, one oatmeal raisin, and one monster. Everyone was very happy with their choices. The staff was friendly and quick to take orders. The only thing we mentioned that could have been better was that we asked for them to be heated up, and they probably could have used a bit longer in the over as the middles were still cold. Still, that's a very small thing when put up next to these very big and very tasty cookies. I even broke mine in half and had the rest the next day, so it felt like I got two cookies! We will be back here for sure!

I was in the area and decided to try this cookie place I've seen a few times. It's very cute and clean inside. There are some seats to eat in if you like. They also have online ordering to make it easier if you want to grab and go, but I wanted to pick out the cookies in person since it was my first time. Lots of options. I got 4 cookies for $18 , funfetti, strawberry cupcake, salted caramel and the oatmeal cream pie. They are pretty big cookies and heavy so one is definitely enough for someone. The four pack came in a small box with 2 stacked on each side. I prefer the flat boxes to see them all, like crumbl but that's no biggie. Honestly they all tasted like some version/variation of a sugar cookie with little tweaks to flavor except the oatmeal cream pie. They were all sweet and fresh, just not my favorite cookies. I will go back to try different flavors though because maybe there will be one that I like or love better than the ones I tried. The strawberry cupcake really tasted like a cupcake. I believe they switch up the flavors but not sure how often. Staff were nice. Nothing bad to say, just need to try more flavors.

Situated in the Williamsville place plaza this place offer lots of cookies plus perry ice cream products for sundaes or milkshakes.With fast and friendly service I ordered the big dubz ,the Oatmeal Chocolate chip, and drumstick.They were all delicious. I can't decide which I should try next as they all look and smell amazing!!Plenty of parking in the plaza.

Located in the Williamsville place plaza with plenty of parking. They offer lots of different flavors of cookies.On my recent visit I ordered the drumstick, oatmeal chocolate chip and big dubz and received them with fast and friendly service. They also serve perrys ice cream and you can order shakes or sundaes.Eveything was incredible and yummy ,I can't wait to go back and try something new !!

First time here and I wasn't sure if I was supposed to take the cookies home to finish baking them . Very clean establishment and friendly staff. I thought the prices were high so just got one chocolate chip cookie. I love chocolate but it seemed too rich for me. I actually didn't feel great later. Now, I'm not saying it was the cookie but may have been. I will update my review when I decide to try again Elle. Their coffee was fresh and awesome

Half Baked Cookies has a TON of options. The menu was so vast it took a long time considering how I wanted to fill my four pack. I opted for the special - Lemon meringue, sea salt caramel, monster, and the lava cake. The lava cake was amazing - so rich!

There's a ton of gluten free options as well. They have coffee and ice cream if you're looking to sit and enjoy your sweet treats!

I've never had a bad cookie here! But Monster remains my all-time favorite. The chocolate milk is the BEST (they also have other flavors - plain, coffee, cherry, strawberry, etc.). I tried the cherry today and I didn't care for it personally but to each their own (I'd rather know than be curious). Return your milk bottles for $1 refund! Use your phone number for rewards ... 1 point per $5, 10 points equals a free cookie! They also send out $3 off coupons.