Josh’s 4-star review:
Look! It's a nightclub! No, it's a pizza place! No, it's a microbrewery!
Oddly enough, not only is it all three, but it turns out that it's actually pretty good at all of them.
First of all, don't expect to just walk in there and get a table, ever. Maybe during the summer, when Yale is out of session, on a holiday weekend, but otherwise, you can expect to wait. Sometimes for an hour. Sometimes longer.
But while you wait, you're free to hang out in the bar area and enjoy any of their brewed beers or visiting selections. You might think a nightclub/pizza bar would have terrible microbrews, but you'd be wrong. They are all pretty solid, though I particularly enjoy their stout.
Then, of course, we have the infamous mashed potato pizza. It sounds weird and unnecessary and a little like an affront to the Pizza Gods, and yet... something about it just works. Try it with bacon and garlic. Of if you're a vegetarian, spinach.
Finally, we have the full-blown nightclub in the back. What, you expected some kind of half-hearted dance floor with a disco ball? Nope. We're talking full-on towers of speakers, lighting systems, the whole deal. As far as I can tell, it's the most happening nightclub in New Haven that doesn't cater to underage girls looking to make a bad decision (not that there's anything wrong with that). If you're looking to bust it out to the newest hot beats, this is the place to be.
They do charge a cover after 10:00 pm, I believe, on Fridays and Saturdays. They also have a lot of free indie music on Wednesdays if you follow them on Facebook or check their web page.
Overall, BAR is a New Haven institution, and it's not hard to see why, from the delicious takes on classic beers, to the impressive pizza, to the night club.