UCSF

Control tissue in studies of various orthopedic pathologies is difficult to obtain and presumably equivalent biopsies from other anatomic sites have been utilized in its place. However, for growth plates, different anatomic regions are subject to dissimilar mechanical forces and produce disproportionate longitudinal growth. The purpose of this study was to compare gene expression and structure in normal physes from different anatomic regions within a single animal species to determine whether such physes were equivalent. Thirteen female New Zealand white rabbits (five 15-week-old and eight 19-week-old animals) were euthanized and physes harvested from their proximal and distal femurs and proximal tibiae. Harvested physes were divided into groups for histological, immunohistochemical (IHC), and reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction analyses. All physes analyzed demonstrated no apparent differences in morphology or proteoglycan staining intensity on histological examination or in type II collagen presence determined by IHC study. Histomorphometric measures of physeal height as well as gene expression of type II collagen and aggrecan were found to be statistically significantly equivalent (p < 0.05) among the three different bones from the total number of rabbits. Summary data suggest that the structural similarities and statistical equivalence determined among the various physes investigated in the rabbit validate these tissues in this species for use as surrogate controls by which physeal abnormalities may be compared and characterized in the absence of otherwise normal control tissues. Other species may exhibit the same similarities and equivalence among different physes so that such tissues may serve in like manner as controls for assessing a variety of orthopedic conditions, including those occurring in humans.