1. Introduction
River deltas and estuaries are dynamic environments in which marine and fluvial processes come together to form complex and transient morphologies. Their internal sedimentary architecture, formed in environments in which fluvial, estuarine, and shallow marine depositional processes have fluctuated over both space and time in response to allogenic controls (e.g., sea-level rise, tectonics, climate change), autogenic processes (e.g., channel avulsion) [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5] and human activities [
6], makes up an important part of the geological record. Many of the world’s largest deltas are densely populated and are becoming increasingly vulnerable to the influences of natural (e.g., climate and sea level) and non-natural (e.g., human activity) factors. While infrastructural works such as coastal protection schemes and the development of underground real estate is ongoing in delta plains, it is particularly important to thoroughly understand the composition of Quaternary sedimentary formations.
The Pearl River Delta (PRD) is the largest delta along the coastline of southeastern China and has been the subject of a great deal of research into deltaic formation and evolution over more than a century. The study of the sedimentary evolution of the PRD plain began with the impressive work of Huang et al. in 1982 [
7]. Since then, numerous studies of its sedimentology, geomorphology, paleoclimate, and pre-historic human activity have been carried out [
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14]. However, most of these have not been able to use core data at a high spatial resolution to reconstruct the paleo river courses and incised valleys that formed during the glacial period. In recent years, more and more detailed studies have been concerned with the formation of PRD in response to postglacial sea level rise [
14] and human impact on the changing shoreline during the late Holocene [
6,
15,
16,
17]. In particular, proxy data from multiple cores in the PRD show a rapid transformation from marine facies to alluvial facies during the late Holocene which may, in part, indicate the impacts of human activity [
18]. However, more comprehensive studies at a larger spatial scale are needed to support the inference that human activities, which have intensified since 3-2 ka, led to accelerated development of the PRD plain [
6,
15,
19].
Many of East and Southeast Asia's largest population and commercial centers are located in coastal regions on rivers and deltas. Both natural processes, such as river discharge, sea-level rise, and human activities have had an ever-increasing impact on river deltas [
20]. The river network in the PRD is one of the most complex in the world [
21]. Existing research suggests that the past river system with radial and beaded patterns formed during the late Pleistocene, and the river network of the delta today basically follows such pattern [
22,
23]. To build on this understanding of deltaic plain geomorphology, river channels, and coastline shifts in the PRD, a synthetic study of the spatial distribution of Holocene deposits, based on a new dataset at a higher spatial resolution of overall deltaic areas, is needed.
For this study we established a dataset of over 2800 sediment cores from the PRD, and used a GIS-based 3D geological model incorporating newly-acquired digital borehole data to create isobath maps of all Quaternary and Holocene deposits in the PRD. A series of reconstructed paleo-coastline maps revealed the delta’s evolution and progradation since the maximum marine transgression. Comparison between the present-day river courses and the reconstructed paleo channels of incised valleys formed during the LGM allows for a more detailed study of natural and human-induced coastline shifts and land growth.
2. Regional setting
The PRD, located at the northern boundary of the South China Sea, is the second largest delta in China after the Yangtze River Delta. Developed within a basin confined by the dominant NW-SE-trending normal faults, the PRD intersects a set of older NE-SW-trending normal faults. Compared to other deltas along the Southeast Asian coast [
24,
25,
26], Quaternary sediments in the PRD area are relatively thin, and their formation was influenced by two major marine-terrestrial sedimentary cycles that have occurred since the late Pleistocene. As a result, the two marine sediment units separated by a weathered clay or fluvial sand are commonly found in the study area [
27]. The Quaternary sediments in the study region consist mainly of deltaic deposits composed by of marine-terrestrial sediment sequence, and alluvial deposits from the lower reaches of the rivers which were laid down before the delta plain formed (
Figure 1). This paper deals primarily with the deltaic areas formed by Quaternary marine-continental sedimentary cycles (including the maximum transgression range during the Holocene), and excludes the areas of downstream pure alluvial and peat deposits from multiple tributaries near the delta margin.
The PRD is surrounded by hills and mountains, and encompasses numerous paleo-river mouth islands. River water input and sediment discharges come from three main streams: the West River (WR), North River (NR), and East River (ER), of which the WR is the largest with a drainage area of some 350,000 km
2. Other smaller rivers include the Tan River (TR) and Liuxi River (LXR). All of these tributaries converge in the delta area to form a very complex delta-plain network of rivers [
28]. Average river network density is as high as 0.8km/km2 within the delta plain. The three main rivers (i.e. WR, NR, and ER) branch out across the delta plain into over 324 small distributaries and streams close to the land-ocean interface, amounting to a total channel length of about 1600 km [
29]. Most watercourses in the delta flow into the estuaries of Lingding Bay and Modaomen Bay. The principal tributary river outlets at the front of the delta are Humen, Jiaomen, Hongqimen and Hengmen to the northeast, and Modaomen, Jitimen, Hutiaomen and Yamen to the southwest (
Figure 1b).
5. Discussion
The spatiotemporal variations in sedimentation rates in the PRD are significant because of the complexity of the estuary topography, spatial heterogeneity of accommodation space, and underlying river valleys. According to the statistical results for sedimentation rates, the mean value for the PRD during the early Holocene is relatively small [
7,
12]. This can be explained by relatively low sea levels, with most of the delta area remaining exposed prior to 9000 year BP [
10,
48,
49] and a limited marine transgression from south to north which was confined to the deep valleys. Only the low-altitude areas of the southeastern PRD were initially affected by the marine transgression, and here the sedimentation rate accelerated.
Relative sea level rose rapidly from the early to mid-Holocene, from about -49m to the present level between 10,500 and 7000 cal. years BP, which averages at around 13.7mm/a [
14]. Sedimentation rates during the early Holocene in the PRD region were relatively small because most of the sediment was transported into the offshore areas in the South China Sea [
12]. A substantial volume of proxy data on the marine sedimentary environment indicates that the age of marine sediments may be as high as >9 ka, and the Holocene marine transgression reached its maximum at around 8-7 ka BP (
Figure 3), while the coastline of the large paleo-estuary was directly bordered by mountains, hills, and terraces. The broad deltaic basin during this period provided a large accommodation space for the delta plain to subsequently prograde [
49]. The sedimentation rate during 7.5-5.0 ka was about 2.34 mm/a on average in the deltaic depocenter [
12]. In this study we found that, according to the data from 22 boreholes, and consistent with previous results, the average sedimentation rate for the PRD as a whole was 2.14 mm/a in 7-6 ka, and then gradually decreased between 6-5 ka (1.91 mm/a) and 5-4 ka (0.94 mm/a). The reduced sedimentation rate was considered to be the result of a progressive decrease in monsoon-induced fluvial discharge [
6]. However, the sedimentary rate calculation did not take into account the hiatuses (time gaps in the sediment sequences, widespread distributed in PRD) in the Holocene stratigraphic record caused by strong erosion during the late Holocene. In general, erosion tended to occur when there was a lack of accommodation space. The results of dating the material in our dataset show a gap in the Holocene sediment record between about 8-4 ka, illustrating a hiatus in the stratigraphic sequence (
Figure 5). This may be the result of sediment erosion by stronger river runoff during the late Holocene. At the beginning of marine regression, coastal sedimentation was largely ascribed to climatic factors [
49,
50], and partly to regional differential vertical crustal movements [
51]. The Mid-late Holocene transition was a period of profound changes in summer monsoon and hydrological conditions in China. A great number of studies have shown that the runoff of the West River and North River was significantly stronger in the late Holocene, since ca. 4000 years BP, coinciding with the decrease in accommodation space. Increasing river runoff and flooding led to the large-scale erosion of underlying early-mid-Holocene sediment layers and/or even Pleistocene deposits, particularly in areas of high hydrodynamic energy. In addition, several studies concluded that the sedimentary characteristics of this period were caused by the unique and complex geomorphic structure of the Pearl River Delta, which was subject to complex and heterogeneous sedimentary processes [
12,
28].
In East and Southeast Asia, significant delta progradation after the mid-Holocene is considered to have resulted from forced regression [
49,
52,
53]. Transport of sediment from land to the delta via rivers, land erosion, and soil loss increased progressively. Existing research offers two main schools of thought on the Holocene changes in the coastline of the Pearl River Delta. The first is that, since the maximum marine transgression at about 8-7 ka, the coastline of the Pearl River Delta advanced sequentially from the head deltaic areas (topsets) towards the sea in a roughly parallel expansion pattern (
Figure 6). This pattern of coastline changes is supported by archaeological findings, historical archives, family ancestral books, and modern survey data spanning from the Neolithic Ages through the agricultural period to the modern industrial era [
6,
10]. This point of view is common and generally accepted by geologists and geographers. The alternative point of view is that the evolution of the coastline of the PRD was not driven from north to south, or from the river outlet to the downstream area. Rather, multiple deposition bodies around the islands or sand mounds simultaneously developed in the north and south without overlapping. This perspective emerged from simulation results based on hydrodynamic and bed topographic data using the Pearl River Delta Long-term Morphodynamic Model (PRD-LTMM), reported by Wei et al [
39,
54] and Wu et al. [
55]. They suggest that there is a linear relationship between energy flux and cumulative deposition volume, and that energy flux decreased more in the outer part of the estuary than in its inner areas. We believe that both of the above perspectives have a sound basis in theory and evidence. However, a new study has pointed out that preferential sedimentation alone was not sufficient for the emergence of delta plains around the islands [
6]. Therefore, on the basis of the reconstruction of isobaths conducted for this study, we favor the coastline change pattern proposed by Zong et al. [
10] and Xiong et al. [
6], that the seaward delta progradation was roughly parallel to the paleo coastlines. Only a few areas of the deposition bodies around the islands [
12], tested through sediment lithofacies, showed signs of adaptation. It has been suggested that the rate of sedimentation close to the islands slowed significantly when the accommodation space was reduced to just a few meters, but only when the mouths of distributaries reached the islands, sedimentation resumed and delta plains emerged [
6,
56]. Therefore, we speculate that some of the sedimentary bodies around bedrock islands simulated by the hydrodynamic model may be somewhat exaggerated in terms of surface size. However, we adapted the basic framework simulated by the model (PRD-LTMM) [
54], which is determined by water energy flux and its spatial variation, to reconstruct the paleo channels.
Although humans arrived in the Neolithic age (some 7-6 ka) [
57] neither the climatic factor nor early human activity, including the shift from hunting and gathering to early agriculture around 5.0-4.5 ka [
58] had a significant impact on the formation of the delta. Our calculation of the average sedimentation rate in the PRD over the past 4000 years shows a gradual increase, reaching 3.61mm/a between 2-1 ka and 5.24mm/a between 1-0 ka, the highest rate in the Holocene. This is consistent with previous findings that the average sedimentation rate during the development of the PRD has been at its highest since 2500 BP, because frequent human activities have increased the amount of sediment discharge to the delta [
6,
7,
15]. However, according to Wei et al. [
12], the sedimentation rate of the overall delta has not necessarily increased during the last 2500 years. With the delta plain prograding seaward, accommodation space reducing, and paleo channels narrowing, a large proportion of sediment discharge is transported directly into the lower part of the PRD. In fact, the calculation of the average sedimentation rate in the delta depends on the location of the collected boreholes. Most of the borehole data with dating information in this study are derived from the middle and lower reaches of the delta.
Comparison of historical population evolution [
59] with our reconstruction of the Holocene sedimentation rate, coastline changes, and quantitative land growth in the PRD suggests that human activity has played an important role in the evolution of the delta plain. Since the Qin-Han Dynasties (around 2000 years BP), humans have transformed the transport and deposition of sediment in the deltaic areas where human activity has dominated. On the one hand, human slash-and-burn farming and other agricultural activity since the Qin Dynasty led to forest destruction and soil erosion, resulting in accelerated river sediment discharge and delta plain expansion. On the other hand, the newly increased delta land area created more space for people to inhabit, leading to further population growth in the region (
Figure 7). Our data provides a mechanism for quantifying anthropogenic changes to deltaic sedimentary systems and topographies.
The particularly high rate of land growth and rapid coastline shift in the past few hundred years has been interpreted as showing that human activities have significantly increased fluvial sediment delivery. Since the Ming Dynasty, wide and scattered sandy lands gradually accumulated in the area of the southern central Pearl River Delta close to the paleo shorelines, and the river network formed during the late Ming and Qing dynasties. The comparison between modern rivers and deep incised valleys shows that the major watercourses today (especially the lower West River) are close to the paleo-channels of the incised valleys. That is, the evolution from paleo to modern river courses has a certain inheritance (
Figure 8). However, the complex network river system formed through the interaction of nature and human activities over the past few hundred years. The distribution of Holocene riverbed sand bodies [
60] which our results illustrate show that an environment characterized by scattered sandy lands, which play a role in the formation of the modern river network, emerged between 600 and 300 years ago. That is, the modern watercourses are generally located beside the Holocene sand bodies. This landscape of scattered “sand land” surrounded by water was transformed from the Song Dynasty onwards into lands for rice cultivation, with easy irrigation and, subsequently, fish ponds.
6. Conclusions
For this paper, we established a borehole dataset which contains information from over 2800 sediment cores in the PRD, the highest resolution dataset so far available. This dataset makes it possible to demonstrate the spatiotemporal characteristics of the marine and terrestrial stratigraphy and sedimentary evolution history of the PRD. High-resolution isobath maps of Quaternary deposits were created, providing brand-new insight into Holocene sediment distribution, showing a beaded and elongated zone of depocenters (generally >20 m), which mainly run from the northwest to the south of the delta. This reflects that the Holocene basal topography, with deep incised valleys forming during the LGM, was largely controlled by the faults which run in a NW-SE direction. Two subparallel deep incised valleys increase in both size and depth towards the downstream of the West River and North River. The largest incised valleys may reach 10 kilometers in width near Hongqimen and Hengmen, and can be traced upstream to a point of origin to the northwest of Foshan City. We also found that there was no obvious deep incised valley downstream of the East River possibly due to small water flow during the last glacial maximum.
Multiple proxy data from the cores in the PRD show that the sediment interval with the greatest abundance of marine indicators (ostracods, foraminifers, saltwater diatoms, and mangrove pollen) is concentrated within the period between 8000 and 5000 years BP, and the Holocene marine transgression reached its maximum at around 8000-7000 years BP. Sedimentary facies of the late Holocene since 5000 years BP is characterized by increasing alluvial sediments, revealing a rapid transformation from marine to fluvial facies. Around 2000 years BP, in the context of little accommodation space in the PRD, substantial river discharge and increasing fluvial transportation accelerated the evolution of the deltaic plain.
Based on the dating results from 22 boreholes and the reconstructed paleocoastline, we calculated the average sedimentation and land growth rates since 7000 years BP. The reduced sedimentation rate during 7000-4000 years BP is likely to result from a large sedimentary accommodation space and progressive decrease in the monsoon-induced fluvial discharge. Our calculation of the average sedimentation rate over the last 4000 years shows a gradual increase, with the rates between 2-1 ka and 1-0 ka BP reaching their highest during the entire Holocene. Considering with historical population evolution and quantitative land growth of PRD, we conclude that human impact became increasingly important to the evolution of the delta plain [
6,
7,
12,
15]. The comparison of major modern rivers and reconstructed deep incised valleys demonstrates that the evolution from paleo to modern major watercourses (especially the West River) has a certain inheritance. Finally, our results regarding the distribution of the Holocene riverbed sand layer [
60] together with the landscape of scattered “sand land” surrounded by water which has characterized the area over the past few hundred years since the Song Dynasty, explains the complexity of the modern network river system as a result of the interaction between natural forces and human activities. As well as new data, this study provides a better understanding of delta evolution that can be extended to the assessment of future coastline scenarios and may be used as a basis for coastal zone management and urban planning.