The effects of interactions between surface forcings in the development of a model-simulated polar low in Hudson Bay

Philippe Gachon; René Laprise; Peter Zwack; François J. Saucier

Original Research Papers

The effects of interactions between surface forcings in the development of a model-simulated polar low in Hudson Bay

Authors

Philippe Gachon
René Laprise
Peter Zwack
François J. Saucier

Abstract

A 30-km version of the Canadian Regional Climate Model is used to simulate a polar low developmentin early December 1988 over the Hudson Bay. This polar low is quantitatively analyzed in detail, in the initial and mature stages of its development, in order to understand physically how sea surface conditions influence this mesocyclone. This analysis is realized via the description of the effects of different atmospheric forcings (i.e. thermal and vorticity advection, and turbulent and convective fluxes) on the polar low development (called the direct effects) using the diagnostic equations of omega and vorticity tendency. Also, the effects of forcing interactions on subsequent cyclone development (called theindirect effects) is analyzed via the diagnostic equations of vorticity and thermal advection tendencies. In the early stage of development, a low-level cyclogenesis appears over the northwestern Hudson Bay essentially due to diabatic forcings in the context of low-level cold air advection. Progressively, the synergetic effect of time rate of changes in advection terms, resulting from surface diabatic and stress forcings, favours low-level cyclogenesis and baroclinicity over open water near the sea-ice margin, whose shape is determinant for the deepening and tracking of the polar low. In the mature stage, the growth in advection terms becomes the main factor of cyclone intensification with the increase in low-level convection. Forcings are maximum near the surface and differ substantially from the verticalstructure found in classical extratropical cyclones. In the upper troposphere they appear to play a secondary role in this polar low development. Finally, the polar low studied here is primarily the result of combined forcing interactions near the sea-ice edge, which are responsible for vorticity and thermal advection changes at low levels. It is also found that the indented sea-ice shape is a favourable factorfor the local surface cyclogenesis due to the formation of local Laplacians of diabatic and thermal forcings.

Year: 2003

Volume: 55 Issue: 1

Page/Article: 61-87

DOI: 10.3402/tellusa.v55i1.12079

Submitted on Nov 29, 2000

Accepted on Jun 18, 2002

Published on Jan 1, 2003

Peer Reviewed

CC BY 4.0

References

Albright , M. D. , Reed , R. J. and Ovens , D. W. 1995 . Origin and structure of a numerically simulated polar low over Hudson Bay . Tellus 47A , 834 – 848 .
Bergeron , G. , Laprise , R. and Caya , D. 1994 . Formulation du modèle de mesoechelle compressible communautaire (MC2; Formulation of community compressible mesoscale model). Centre cooperatif pour la recherche en mesometeorologie (CCRM) , 165 pp , Bilingual Document. [Available from second author] .
Branscome , L. E. , Gutowski , W. J. Jr. and Stewart , D. A. 1989 . Effect of surface fluxes on the nonlinear development of baroclinic waves. J. Atmos. Sc i . 46 , 460 – 475 .
Caya , D. 1996 . Le modèle regional de climat de l’UQAM (The Regional Climate Model of UQAM) . Ph.D. Thesis , Universite du Quebec h Montreal, Montreal , Canada . 100 pp . [ Available from second author ].
Caya , D. and Laprise , R. 1999 . A semi-implicit semi-lagrangian regional climate model: The Canadian RCM. Mon. Wea. Re v . 127 , 341 – 362 .
Desjardins , S. 1993 . Etude diagnostique d’un front froid l’aide de l’equation de developpement de Zwack et Okossi version etendue utilisant les sorties du modèle regional au, x elements finis (Diagnostic study of a cold front with extended version of Zwack-Okossi equation using outputs of regional finite-element model). MSc Thesis, Universite du Quebec h Montreal, Montreal, Canada. 137 pp. [Avail-able from third author].
Fett , R. W. 1989 . Polar low development associated with boundary-layer fronts in the Greenland, Norwegian and Barents Seas. In: Polar and Arctic lows . (eds. P. F. Twitchell , E.A. Rasmussen , and K. L . Davidson ). A. Deepalc Publishing, Virginia, USA , 313 - 322 .
Gachon , P. 1999 . Effets de la distribution de la glace marine sur le developpement des depressions a meso-echelle et sur le climat regional (Effects of the sea-ice distribution on mesoscale low pressure development and on regional climate). Ph.D. Thesis, Universite du Quebec h Montreal, Montreal, Canada. 352 pp. [Available from first author].
Gates , W. L. 1992 . AMIP: The Atmospheric Model Inter-comparison Project . Bull. Am. MeteoroL Soc . 73 , 1962 – 1970 .
Gronhs , S. , Foss , A. and Lystad , M. 1987 . Numerical simulations of polar lows in the Norwegian Sea . Tellus 39A , 334 – 354 .
Haltiner , G. J. and Williams , R. T. 1980 . Numerical prediction and dynamical meteorology . Second edition , John Wiley & Sons , New York , 477 pp .
Hanley , D. E. 1993. A case study of a polar low in the Labrador Sea. MSc Thesis, Deptartment of Oceanogra-phy, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Canada. 165 pp .
Irbe , G. J. 1992 . Great lakes surface water temperature clima-tology, climatological studies . Environment Canada, Atmospheric Environment Service , 43 , 215 pp .
Kuo , Y. H. , Low-Nam , S. and Reed , R. J. 1991 . Effects of surface energy fluxes during the early development and rapid intensification stages of seven explosive cyclones in the western Atlantic. Mon. Wea. Re v . 119 , 457 – 476 .
Langland R. H. and Miller , R. J. 1989 . Polar low sensitivity to sea surface temperature and horizontal grid resolution in a numerical model. In: Polar and Arctic lows ,. (eds. P. F. Twitchell , E. A. Rasmussen , and K. L. Davidson ). A. Deepak Publishing, Virginia, USA , 247 - 254 .
Ledrew , E. E 1984 . The role of local heat sources in synoptic activity within the Polar basin . Atmos. Ocean 22 , 309 – 327 .
Mailhot , J. , Hanley , D. , Bilodeau , B. and Hertzman , O. 1996 . A numerical case study of a polar low in the Labrador Sea. Tellus 48A , 383 - 402 .
Mak , M. 1998 . Influence of surface sensible heat flux on incipient marine cyclogenesis. J. Atmos. Sc i . 55 , 820 – 834 .
Mansfield , D. A. 1974 . Polar lows: The development of baroclinic disturbances in cold air outbreaks . Quart. J. R. Meteorol. Soc . 100 , 541 – 554 .
McFarlane , N. A. , Boer , G. J. , Blanchet , J.-P. and Lazare , M. 1992 . The Canadian Climate Centre Second Generation General Circulation Model and its equilibrum climate . J. Clim . 5 , 1013 – 1044 .
MEP Company , 1989 . Polar lows in Canadian offshore wa-ters . Rep. MT 88250 , available from Atmospheric Environment Service , Western Region, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada .
Montgomery , M. T. and Farrell , B. E 1992 . Polar low dy-namics . J. Atmos. Sci . 49 , 2484 – 2505 .
Morneau , G. 1995 . Sensibilite du calcul des flux de surface face a la resolution horizontale et temporelle d’un modèle atmospherique (Sensitivity of calculation of surface fluxes on horizontal and temporal resolution of atmospheric model). MSc Thesis, Universite du Quebec a Montreal, Montreal, 94 pp. [Available from second author].
Nordeng , T. E. and Rasmussen , E. A. 1992 . A most beautiful polar low. A case study of a polar low development in the Bear Island region . Tellus 44A , 81 – 99 .
Nordeng , T. E. , Foss , A. , Gronhs , S. , Lystad , M. and Mitbo , K. H. 1989 . On the role of resolution and physical parameterization for numerical simulations of polar lows. In: Polar and arctic lows . (eds. P. F . Twitchell , E. A. Rasmussen , and K. L . Davidson ). A. Deepalc Publishing, Virginia, USA , 217 - 232 .
Räisänen , J. 1997 . Height tendency diagnostics using a generalized omega equation, the voracity equation, and a nonlinear balance equation . Mon. Wea. Rev . 125 , 125 – 1597 .
Räisänen , J. 1995 . Factors affecting synopticscale vertical motions: A statistical study using a generalized omega equation . Mon. Wea. Rev . 123 , 123 – 2460 .
Reed , R. J. and Duncan , C. N. 1987 . Baroclinic instability as a mechanism for the serial development of polar lows: A case study . Tellus 39A , 376 – 384 .
Roch , M. , Benoit , R. and Parker , N. 1991 . Sensitivity experiments for polar Low forecasting with the CMC mesoscale finite-element model . Atmos. Ocean 29 , 381 – 419 .
Saulesleja , A. 1986 . Great Lakes climatological atlas . Canadian Government Publishing Centre , Environment Canada , AES, Ottawa, Canada . 145 pp .
Shapiro , M. A. , Hampel , T. and Fedor , L. S. 1989 . Research aircraft observations of an Arctic front over the Barents Sea. In: Polar and arctic lows . (eds. P. F . Twitchell , E. A. Rasmussen , and K. L . Davidson ). A. Deepak Publishing, Virginia, USA , 279 - 290 .
Tardif , R. 1992 . Estimation du mouvement vertical a l’aide des donnees en surface seulement: etude systematique et compa raison avec le mouvement vertical provenant d’un modèle numerique (Estimate of vertical motion with surface data only: Systematic study and comparison with vertical motion issued from numerical model). MSc Thesis, Universite du Quebec a Montreal, Montreal, Canada, 150 pp. [Available from third author].
Zwack , P. , Page , C. and Tardif , R. 1996 . DIONYSOS: Un outil diagnostique d’etude des sorties des modèles numeriques de prevision meteorologique (DIONYSOS: a diagnostic tool for study the outputs of numerical forecast model). Internal Report of Groupe des Sciences de l’Atmosphere, Universite du Quebec a Montreal, Montreal, Canada, 35 pp. [Available from third author].