Jump to content

User:Robertsky/XfD log/Archive 2022

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


February 2022

  1. Rahul Singh (author): nominated at AfD; notified Rastrakm (talk · contribs) 08:12, 7 February 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: Promotional content. Potentially failing WP:BIO. Many of the sources do not denote the notability of subject.
      There are 18 sources; 7 sources are REFBOMB, trying to support the assertion that he lead a fundraiser. But from the sources, it seems that the fundraiser is a joint effort that's spread across multiple universities' alumni networks.
      Notability as a guest lecturer is questionable as anyone can be invited as a guest lecturer as long the topic matches the subject matter a person is an expert/more experienced in.
      There are three books listed in the bibliography, but it might as well be just two books, as Engineering to Ikigai and You know the glory, Not the story are the same book with different titles (as reveal in a source). There are a review for each book, which I don't think qualifies for notability under WP:AUTHOR: such work must have been the primary subject [sic] of multiple independent periodical articles or reviews.
{{ source assess
| source = https://milaap.org/fundraisers/SUMO?utm_source=shorturl
| ind = n
| ind_just = Crowdfund information page. Can be considered as primary source
| rel = n
| rel_just = Crowdfund information page. Can be considered as primary source
| sig = n
| sig_just = Nothing in the body text indicated that he led the team.
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.iimnagpur.ac.in/news/guest-session-mr-rahul-singh/
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = -
| rel_just = Labelled as guest speaker. But written in promotional tone.
| sig = y
| sig_just =
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.iimb-vista.com/past-speakers
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel =  ?
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just = just a list of previous speakers. Nothing to denote his notability.
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.iimtrichy.ac.in/events/details/Nzk%3D/An_Atheist_Gets_the_Gita
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just = Just an event notification. Nothing to indicate notability of the subject
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.ntu.edu.sg/alumni/events/detail/2021/07/31/default-calendar/ntu-international-alumni-webinar-series-310721
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just = Just an event notification. Nothing to indicate notability of the subject
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://gyanalogy.com/
| ind = n
| ind_just = He runs the site.
| rel = n
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just = Homepage of the site. Nothing to indicate his notability.
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.wionews.com/india-news/covid-19-alumni-of-singapore-universities-launch-crowdfunding-drive-for-oxygen-concentrators-to-india-382911
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just = Primarily on the fundraiser, as a group effort.
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/major-international-food-company-partners-with-ihc-in-singapore-to-provide-crucial-covid-19-supplies-to-india/articleshow/82453756.cms?from=mdr
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just = Primarily on the fundraiser, as a group effort.
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/others/indian-origin-alumni-of-singapore-univs-to-help-up-in-pandemic-times-101620224495135.html
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig =
| sig_just = Primarily on the fundraiser, as a group effort. Not even mentioned by name
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.tamilmurasu.com.sg/tabla/singapore/helping-virus-hit-indians-breathe-again
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just = Primarily on the fundraiser, as a group effort.
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://nus.edu.sg/alumnet/thealumnus/issue-117/community/alumni-happenings/details/Mission-SUMO
| ind = n
| ind_just = Submission by the fundraising team. Promotional content
| rel =  ?
| rel_just = Not sure what's the editorial process with regards to submissions by alumni
| sig = n
| sig_just = Primarily on the fundraiser, as a group effort. Not even mentioned by name
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.ntu.edu.sg/alumni/alumni-stories-news/detail/extending-a-helping-hand-overseas
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel =  ?
| rel_just = I see it as a cross between press release and a promotional content, and celebratory of an alumni involved in the project
| sig = -
| sig_just = Primarily on the fundraiser, as a group effort. This is written as he's sharing his perspective and involvement in the fundraising.
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://alumni.smu.edu.sg/news/2021/may/06/covid-19-alumni-singapore-universities-launch-crowdfunding-drive-oxygen
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just = Repeat of source 7/wionews.
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://rupapublications.co.in/books/an-atheist-gets-the-gita/
| ind = n
| ind_just = Book listing
| rel = n
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just =
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.tamilmurasu.com.sg/tabla/singapore/ancient-wisdom-simplified-modern-minds
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig = y
| sig_just = Book review
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://induspublishing.myshopmatic.com/products/engineering-to-ikigai-25-journeys-towards-purpose
| ind = n
| ind_just = Book listing
| rel = n
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just =
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.worldscientific.com/worldscibooks/10.1142/12103
| ind = n
| ind_just = Book listing
| rel = n
| rel_just =
| sig = n
| sig_just =
}}
{{ source assess
| source = https://www.tamilmurasu.com.sg/tabla/singapore/flying-high-thanks-sia-scholarships
| ind = y
| ind_just =
| rel = y
| rel_just =
| sig = y
| sig_just = Book review. In fact, this reveals that both Engineering to Ikigai and You know the glory, Not the story are the same books, just titled differently for the different national markets.
}}


Source assessment table:
Source Independent? Reliable? Significant coverage? Count source toward GNG?
This table may not be a final or consensus view; it may summarize developing consensus, or reflect assessments of a single editor. Created using {{source assess table}}.

March 2022

  1. Imaginary Friends Studios: nominated at AfD; notified Mbfiasco (talk · contribs) 03:27, 29 March 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: May not pass WP:GNG. A search on Google shows limited new coverage.

June 2022

  1. Elza (film): nominated at AfD; notified Jehowahyereh (talk · contribs) 15:47, 11 June 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: Does not satisify WP:NFF. Unable to find sources using terms like 'Elza India films/movies' etc. Sources on the page are promotional and does not establish the notability of the subject. Article was draftified once, and moved back promptly by the author of the article.
  2. Vezham: nominated at AfD; notified Jehowahyereh (talk · contribs) 17:43, 11 June 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: Promotional sources. Does not satisfy WP:NFF. Proposing draftification until the notability of the film can be established.

August 2022

  1. Category:2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:January 6 United States Capitol attack 15:48, 12 August 2022 (UTC)
  2. Pregnancy of unnamed 10-year old Ohio girl in 2022: nominated at AfD; notified Jax 0677 (talk · contribs) 10:17, 13 August 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: Not convinced that the article as written avoids WP:BLPCRIME. WP:BLP1E and WP:NOTNEWS may also be applicable. I am unable to see a long-lasting societal impact from this unwanted pregnancy. News stopped at where this story broke. A merge to Abortion in Ohio, at least to indicate that the abortion laws in the state may have resulted in such situation, may preferrable to an outright deletion.
  3. Category:Aftermath of the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Aftermath of the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:38, 15 August 2022 (UTC)
  4. Category:Deaths related to the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Deaths related to the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:38, 15 August 2022 (UTC)
  5. Category:Defending officers during the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2A); New name: Category:Defending officers during the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:39, 15 August 2022 (UTC)
  6. Category:Groups and movements involved with the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Groups and movements involved with the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:39, 15 August 2022 (UTC)
  7. Category:Multimedia productions about the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Multimedia productions about the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:39, 15 August 2022 (UTC)
  8. Category:Proceedings surrounding the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Proceedings surrounding the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:39, 15 August 2022 (UTC)
  9. Category:Protesters in or near the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Protesters in or near the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:39, 15 August 2022 (UTC)
  10. Category:People criminally charged for acts during the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:People criminally charged for acts during the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:39, 15 August 2022 (UTC)
  11. Category:Convicted participants in the 2021 United States Capitol attack: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Convicted participants in the January 6 United States Capitol attack 07:39, 15 August 2022 (UTC)

September 2022

  1. Barney the DInosaur: nominated at RfD; Target: Barney & Friends (notified); notified Amidamaru89 (talk · contribs) 19:11, 13 September 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: Unlikely captialisation and search term. There exists Barney the Dinosaur redirect already.

November 2022

  1. Category:2019 Piala Belia: nominated at CfD (CfM); merging to Category:Piala Belia; notified Bromalayan (talk · contribs) 00:31, 2 November 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: upmerge. single article.
  2. Category:2019 Piala Presiden (Malaysia): nominated at CfD (CfM); merging to Category:Piala Presiden (Malaysia); notified Bromalayan (talk · contribs) 00:46, 3 November 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: Single article. Upmerge.
  3. Nikki A.S.H.: nominated at RM; New name: Nikki Cross 09:20, 6 November 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: Plenty of page moves being made between Nikki A.S.H. and Nikki Cross within the 2 days, with the former being the previous ring name, and the latter the new ring name. Opening up a discussion seeking a consensus as to which name should this article be placed under.
  4. Category:Modern Paganism: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Modern paganism 06:47, 8 November 2022 (UTC)
  5. Category:Modern Pagans: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Modern pagans 00:57, 9 November 2022 (UTC)
  6. Category:Lee Tae-min: nominated at CfDS (C2D); New name: Category:Tae-min 14:50, 25 November 2022 (UTC)

December 2022

  1. Oliver Fricker: nominated at RM; New name: 2010 Singapore train depot transpassing and vandalism case 10:16, 6 December 2022 (UTC)
    • Reason: There's significant coverage internationally, thus GNG. However, given a lack of substantial/continued coverage of the subject as a person after his release, we can possibly look at this article as WP:BLP1E.
  2. Heinrich Reuss: nominated at RM; New name: Heinrich XIII, Prince Reuss of Köstritz 18:36, 7 December 2022 (UTC)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Robertsky/XfD_log/Archive_2022&oldid=1191964835"