HINT: Confused? Take a look at the AniDB Wiki or visit us on IRC.

Best anime ever?

Download (Do NOT click!)
Board Index > Anime > Hagane no Renkinjutsushi (2009) > Best anime ever?
NOTE: To leave a comment in the forum you need to register or login in case you already have an AniDB account.

Is FMAB the best anime ever, worthy of clear first place on AniDB?

Yes, it should be number one and no less!!!!!!
No, but it should be number two!!!
No, but it should be number three!!
No, but it should be in the top five!
No, but it should be in the top ten!
No, but it should be in the top twenty!
No, but I do like it.
No, and I don`t really care for it one way or the other.
No, and I dislike it.
No, and I hate it!
No, it`s the WORST ever!!!
daidaisuki
Troll Hunter Z
Rank: User
Posts: 404
Joined: 07.04.2008
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #1 by daidaisuki on 03.05.2011 05:48 (vote: 5.50)

Hmm, after so much inconclusive discussion we should have a poll. You can change your vote whenever you like.

I "only" liked FMAB.
Top
Gorgils
I AM (in) URANUS
Rank: User
Posts: 8967
Joined: 11.10.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #2 by Gorgils on 03.05.2011 05:59 (vote: 8.00)

An interesting poll there, dai-chan. I chose "No, but it should be in the top twenty!".
Top
Rapist
Spammer x Spammer
Rank: User
Posts: 1607
Joined: 01.12.2010
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #3 by Rapist on 03.05.2011 06:06 (vote: hidden)

I agree with Gor here, around top 20 sounds fine.
Top
eamonx
Pimpernella in a Pink Dress
Rank: User
Posts: 6159
Joined: 13.03.2006
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #4 by eamonx on 03.05.2011 07:14 (vote: hidden)

lol, another bait thread for more heated debating about whether its the best anime of the decade or not. I chose "No but I do like"
Top
Faithful
Pimp in a White Suit
Rank: User
Posts: 3575
Joined: 04.10.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #5 by Faithful on 03.05.2011 12:33 (vote: hidden)

I voted the 1st option. I win this thread! Take that you scumbags! xD

*Puts on flame shield*
Top
Seiren
Pimp in a White Suit
Rank: User
Posts: 3795
Joined: 13.09.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #6 by Seiren on 07.05.2011 15:20 (vote: hidden)

eamonx wrote:

lol, another bait thread for more heated debating about whether its the best anime of the decade or not. I chose "No but I do like"

+1
Top
Gorgils
I AM (in) URANUS
Rank: User
Posts: 8967
Joined: 11.10.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #7 by Gorgils on 08.05.2011 01:07 (vote: 8.00)

Not that I care, but right now the votes agree with FMAB being at least in the top 20

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1fvIPKNb52I
Top
abanatsoulis
Pimp in a White Suit
Rank: User
Posts: 2871
Joined: 16.01.2010
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #8 by abanatsoulis on 08.05.2011 02:52 (vote: hidden)

Who cares about rankings? Some like it, some others don't etc. What if it is ranked higher than everything else or not?
Top
Braggelaer
Indecisive Lead Character
Rank: User
Posts: 14
Joined: 02.06.2010
UP UR

post #9 by Braggelaer on 08.05.2011 07:58 (vote: hidden)

No, but I like it.
top 100 I guess?
Top
Justkaz815
Fullmetal Angst Brother
Rank: User
Posts: 128
Joined: 16.04.2011
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #10 by Justkaz815 on 12.06.2011 23:05

I have to admit, overall it's much better than the original series. I am willing to give this an 8.5, but seriously 9.4??? How many people gave this a 10????
Top
5at0h
Fullmetal Angst Brother
Rank: User
Posts: 189
Joined: 12.03.2011
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #11 by 5at0h on 12.06.2011 23:42 (vote: 9.00)

1488, and it's roughly a half of all the votes. btw, that's one hell of a number if you know what i'm talking about (google it if you don't ).

p.s. GTO isn't the best anime ever either tbh, yet you scored it 10
Top
Faithful
Pimp in a White Suit
Rank: User
Posts: 3575
Joined: 04.10.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #12 by Faithful on 13.06.2011 00:18 (vote: hidden)

Justkaz815 wrote:

I have to admit, overall it's much better than the original series. I am willing to give this an 8.5, but seriously 9.4??? How many people gave this a 10????


And you have a problem with that? I think FMA:B well deserves the high marks considering it's quality stuff for a shounen series. I just happen to like it more than you do.
Top
Justkaz815
Fullmetal Angst Brother
Rank: User
Posts: 128
Joined: 16.04.2011
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #13 by Justkaz815 on 13.06.2011 00:28

GTO rates a 10 because it's the funniest anime I've ever seen. Honestly though I scored GTO a 10 because I think it's underrated and needs a higher avg rating. My true rating for it would be a 9.
Top
Faithful
Pimp in a White Suit
Rank: User
Posts: 3575
Joined: 04.10.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #14 by Faithful on 13.06.2011 00:59 (vote: hidden)

How is GTO underrated getting an overall average vote of 8.83? Round it up and you get close to 9. Since when is 8.83 a bad score?

You want overrated? Go see Bleach and Naruto.
Top
bigsimo
Spammer x Spammer
Rank: User
Posts: 1826
Joined: 22.09.2008
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #15 by bigsimo on 13.06.2011 04:00 (vote: hidden)

Justkaz815 wrote:

GTO rates a 10 because it's the funniest anime I've ever seen. Honestly though I scored GTO a 10 because I think it's underrated and needs a higher avg rating. My true rating for it would be a 9.

Yeah GTO isn't perfect but it's still my favorite anime, so I too give it a 10.

Also I voted for the 'top 20' in the poll option.
Top
minsc10
Fullmetal Angst Brother
Rank: User
Posts: 214
Joined: 08.09.2008
UR

post #16 by minsc10 on 13.06.2011 12:18 (vote: hidden)

It should be in top 20, but I can't decide which place. Definitely one of the best so far, but there are other anime which are also great.
Top
madbird117
Indecisive Lead Character
Rank: User
Posts: 40
Joined: 28.09.2008
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #17 by madbird117 on 14.06.2011 16:23 (vote: hidden)

I think "best ever" is a bit of a stretch. It's certainly good, though. I just don't have the deep connection with it that I have with other anime; Evangelion comes to mind.
Top
rupio
Fullmetal Angst Brother
Rank: User
Posts: 209
Joined: 24.08.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #18 by rupio on 15.06.2011 13:57 (vote: 9.00)

It shares 4th place with 12 others for me so i voted top 10.... 31.81% voted yes in this poll so far
Top
Seiren
Pimp in a White Suit
Rank: User
Posts: 3795
Joined: 13.09.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #19 by Seiren on 16.06.2011 08:52 (vote: hidden)

Can't say I care if it's voted first or last. I'm going to like what I like and hate what I hate anyway.
Top
corva
Such Pussy Much Nya
Rank: User
Posts: 3915
Joined: 08.01.2009
UP ML UH WL UV UR

post #20 by corva on 16.06.2011 09:13 (vote: 9.50)

It was so close to my top 5 (6) so i voted for it should be in top 5. It's a freaking good anime and there are many animes that could compete for the top places but having animes at par with this one wont diminish the quality of this one. My top animes change frequently based on what i've last seen but i don't think this will ever fall from my top 20.
Top
Board Index > Anime > Hagane no Renkinjutsushi (2009) > Best anime ever? The Staff • All times are UTC