Retail

I visited the American Girl Doll Cafe in NYC and ate lunch with a few of the iconic toys. The experience was unforgettable — if a bit overpriced.

Ann Matica

2022-12-04T12:11:00Z

American Girl Doll cafe layout

The American Girl Place store in New York City launched in 2017, complete with an in-store cafe.
We decided to grab lunch at the cafe and see what the dining experience was like.
While the prix fixe meal didn't feel worth the $27 each, the overall experience was a blast.

Advertisement

Since its inception in 1986, American Girl Doll has established itself as an iconic toy brand. The company has racked up millions in sales and has been at the forefront of creating retail experiences to draw customers to its American Girl Place locations.

Ann Matica/Insider

The company was originally founded by retired teacher and writer Pleasant Rowland who invested $1.2 million into starting her company and grew American Girl to be worth $300 million before selling it to the toy manufacturer Mattel for $700 million in 1998.

American Girl Doll store wall

Source: Forbes

Advertisement

It was also in 1998 that Rowland first had the idea to open a store called the American Girl Place in Chicago. The store — which combined shopping, dining, and entertainment — was by all measures ahead of its time.

American Girl Doll store

Source: Chicago Tribune

Today, there are a total of 18 stores located across the US and Canada. Every American Girl Place features curated displays, games, and even a doll hospital and salon. Larger locations, like the two flagship stores in Chicago and New York, also offer dining experiences.

American Girl Doll store display

Source: Insider

Advertisement

As a former American Girl Doll owner, I decided to visit the American Girl Doll cafe at Rockefeller Plaza in New York City to live out my childhood dreams.

American Girl Doll New York store entrance

I went to the store's website to try to make a reservation and was surprised to find that the cafe was almost completely booked up until January. I managed to find a slot open on a Monday at 2:30 p.m. and snatched it up before it was too late.

American Girl Doll cafe entrance

Advertisement

When we arrived for my reservation, the American Girl Place store windows already had elaborate displays set up for the holidays.

American Girl Doll New York store window display

I had never been inside an American Girl Place location, and peeking in through the window made me feel a childlike giddiness toward the dolls that I so tenderly loved as a girl.

American Girl Doll store window display

Advertisement

As my boyfriend and I entered through the front doors, I rambled on to him about my own 18-inch-tall custom American Girl Doll named Elizabeth that I had received for Christmas one year.

American Girl Doll store doors

The New York City flagship was launched in November 2017 and spans 40,000 square feet across two stories. I didn't see any signs pointing to the cafe, so I asked an employee, who directed me toward the lower level.

American Girl Doll elevator leading to lower level

Advertisement

Underneath a large American Girl sign were the escalators leading downstairs.

American Girl Doll sign

The entrance to the cafe was at the back of the store, among displays of historic American Girl dolls.

American Girl Doll store

Advertisement

There were festive garlands and silver baubles lining the cafe entrance.

American Girl Doll cafe entrance

After I checked in for my reservation at the front desk, the hostess said I could choose an American Girl doll to join us for lunch. We opted for a blue-haired doll and a Bitty Baby doll, which was originally introduced in the 1990s as a toy for smaller children.

American Girl Doll cafe dolls

Source: Insider

Advertisement

We were led by the hostess through the spacious dining area to our table. The interior of the cafe was painted a pastel purple and was brightly lit with ornamental chandeliers.

American Girl Doll cafe layout

Only a few tables were occupied, which seemed expected for a Monday afternoon. Most of the diners were parents with their children, and I felt a little out of place being there as a 22-year-old, even though the American Girl Cafes have reportedly started to become a popular spot for influencers to visit.

American Girl Doll cafe booth seats

Source: The New York Times

Advertisement

A door led off to a private room for larger groups or birthday parties. The cafe offers birthday party packages for up to 10 guests that vary in price from $25 per child to $40 per child.

A private room at the American Girl Doll cafe

For our dolls to sit in, the host provided us with doll-sized chairs that clipped onto the side of the table.

American Girl Doll cafe dolls

Advertisement

Miniature cups and saucers that customers can take home with them were also set up.

American Girl Doll cafe doll cup

A minimum charge of $27 per person (tax and tip not included) is required to dine at the cafe. For that price, customers enjoy a three-course pre-fixe meal that includes a drink of choice, three appetizers, a selection of main dishes to choose from, and a chocolate mousse dessert.

American Girl Doll cafe menu

Advertisement

The menu offered just enough variety between kid-friendly and more adult dishes so that both children and their parents could be happy. There were also alcoholic beverages ranging from cocktails to sparkling wine that adults can order while their children enjoy milkshakes, juice, or soft drinks.

American Girl Doll menu

I decided to order a cocktail and went with the Aperol Spritz, which was $14, and was taken off guard by how strong it was.

American Girl Doll cafe drinks

Advertisement

My boyfriend decided to go for the house-made margarita and the old-fashioned cherry soda named after the American Girl doll Kit Kittredge. The margarita was $12, while the soda was an additional $1 from the prefixed meal.

American Girl Doll cafe margarita

Our server also brought over cinnamon buns for us and our dolls to enjoy as part of the "warm welcome" portion of the dining experience.

American Girl Doll cafe cinnamon rolls

Advertisement

While my boyfriend and I waited for our appetizers, we played the little game on the table. There were strips of paper with "would you rather" questions and American Girl fun facts for us to discuss.

American Girl Doll cafe game

A three-tiered tray with our pre-set first course was brought to our table. The setup made me feel like I was attending a fancy garden party with finger foods.

American Girl Doll food

Advertisement

The first layer was pita bread with artichoke dip.

American Girl Doll cafe pita bread

The second layer had soft pretzels and mustard.

American Girl Doll cafe pretzel bites

Advertisement

Lastly, there was strawberry yogurt with berries.

American Girl Doll cafe yogurt cups

Our server also brought over fruit and vegetables as an alternative for me since I'm lactose intolerant. I appreciated the gesture as I watched while my boyfriend sampled all the dishes.

American Girl Doll cafe fruits and vegetables

Advertisement

For the main meal, diners can choose from nine different options, including chicken tenders, bow-tie pasta, and fish and tomato ragu.

American Girl Doll cafe menu

I chose the classic club sandwich with avocado and a side of French fries. The sandwiches came with little American Girl-branded flags, plus an array of dips.

American Girl Doll cafe club sandwiches

Advertisement

My boyfriend ordered the macaroni and cheese, which came with a toasted heart and a serving of fruit and vegetables.

American Girl Doll cafe mac n cheese meal

While the food was mediocre at best it's clear that the cafe is more about the dining experience than the food itself.

American Girl Doll cafe table

Advertisement

The server kindly brought me a lemon sorbet as a dairy-free alternative. It was delicious and my favorite thing I had eaten during the meal.

American Girl Doll cafe sorbet

Advertisement

After the meal, our total came out to $87.10 before tip. It was more expensive than the $53 for two pre-fixed meals due to the added drinks.

American Girl Doll cafe check

I made sure to grab my doll's cups and saucers on the way out as a keepsake and returned my doll and her seat to their rightful place on the shelf.

American Girl Doll cafe register

Advertisement

Before heading back upstairs, we browsed the bottom level of the American Girl Place, which had a Girl of the Year display.

American Girl Dolls

There was also a wall of historic dolls from different eras that I geeked out over. Currently, there are 13 historical American Girl dolls that retail for $115 each with their accompanying books included.

American Girl Doll historical doll display

Advertisement

After reminiscing about my favorite American Girl dolls and accessories, we made our way to the exit.

American Girl Doll store sign

While the dining experience felt overpriced for the quality of the food and available menu options, the added-on details such as being able to choose an American Girl doll to sit with, the table games, and the kind servers made the experience fun and unforgettable.

American Girl Doll cafe inside the New York store

Toys Retail

Advertisement

Jump to

Main content
Search
Account