Origen: An Introduction to His Life and Thought

Origen

An Introduction to His Life and Thought

Ronald E. Heine

ORIGEN

An Introduction to His Life and Thought

Cascade Companions #

Copyright ©

2019

Ronald E. Heine. All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in critical publications or reviews, no part of this book may be reproduced in any manner without prior written permission from the publisher. Write: Permissions, Wipf and Stock Publishers,

199

W.

8

th Ave., Suite

3

, Eugene, OR

97401

.

Cascade Books

An Imprint of Wipf and Stock Publishers

199

W.

8

th Ave., Suite

3

Eugene, OR

97401

www.wipfandstock.com

paperback isbn: 978-1-4982-8895-8

hardcover isbn: 978-1-4982-8897-2

ebook isbn: 978-1-4982-8896-5

Cataloguing-in-Publication data:

Names: Heine, Ronald E., author

Title: Origen : an introduction to his life and thought / Ronald E. Heine.

Description: Eugene, OR : Cascade Books,

2019

| Series: Cascade Companions | Includes bibliographical references and index.

Identifiers: ISBN 978-1-4982-8895-8 (paperback) | ISBN 978-1-4982-8897-2 (hardcover) | ISBN 978-1-4982-8896-5 (ebook)

Subjects: LCSH: Origen. | Origen—Criticism and interpretation. | Bible—Criticism, interpretation, etc.—History—Early church, approximately 30–600. | Christianity—Philosophy. | Fathers of the church.

Classification: LCC

BR65.068 H456 2019

(print) |

BR65.068

(ebook)

Manufactured in the U.S.A.

February 25, 2020

To Katrina

Table of Contents

Title Page

Abbreviations

A Note on References to the Psalms

Introduction

Part I: A Sketch Of Origen’s Life

Chapter 1: Major influences that shaped Origen’s mind

Chapter 2: Origen among Christians and Jews in Alexandria and Caesarea

Part II: Origen’s Thought

Chapter 3: The Interpretation of Scripture

Chapter 4: The Focal Points of Origen’s Theology

Suggestions for Further Reading

Bibliography

Abbreviations

ACW / Ancient Christian Writers

ANF / Ante-Nicene Fathers

Cels / Contra Celsum

ComCt / Commentary on the Canticle of Canticles

ComJn / Commentary on John

ComMt / Commentary on Matthew

DialHer / Dialogue with Heracleides

Ep / Epistle(s)

EpistGreg / The Letter to Gregory

ExpProv / Expositions of Proverbs

FOTC / Fathers of the Church

FragJn / Fragments on John

GCS / Die grieschischen christlichen Schriftsteller

H.E. / Ecclesiastical History

HomEz / Homilies 1–14 on Ezekiel

HomEx / Homilies on Exodus

HomLk / Homilies on Luke

HomGn / Homilies on Genesis

HomJer / Homilies on Jeremiah

HomJob / Homilies on Job

HomIs / Homilies on Isaiah

NPNF / Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers

OECT / Oxford Early Christian Texts

PEuch / On Prayer (Peri Euches)

PG / Patrologiae Graecae

Philoc / The Philocalia of Origen

Princ / On First Principles

SC / Sources chrétiennes

SelEz / Selecta on Ezekiel

SelGn / Selecta on Genesis

SelPs / Selecta on the Psalms

SerMt / Series of Commentaries on Matthew

trans. / translation

A Note on References to the Psalms

The numbering of the Psalms differs in the Septuagint from that in the Hebrew Bible (on which English versions are based) by one Psalm after Psalm

10

. Hence, a reference to Psalm

10

by Origen would be to Psalm

11

in an English Bible, etc. I have used the English numbering of the Psalms as much as possible, but when Origen refers to the number of a psalm I have followed his number with the English Bible reference in brackets as follows: Psalm

36 (37)

; Psalm

18 (19):8–11

.

Introduction

O

ne can only wish

or dream that her or his own intellectual work on understanding Scripture or setting forth its theological meaning will endure so long or reach so far as that of Origen of Alexandria. While he was dead by the middle of the third century, Origen’s work has continued to stir deep admiration and animosity down to the present time, although much of the animosity has abated since the work of some significant scholars in the twentieth century.

¹

His influence has crossed all boundaries in the church from the ancient Greek and Latin speaking East-West boundaries to the modern ones of Orthodox, Catholic, and Protestant. Much of his extensive work was lost or destroyed soon after his lifetime, but a large corpus has continued to exist, either in its original Greek or in later Latin translations. In more recent times additional texts have been recovered through fortuitous discoveries, first that of the Tura papyri in Egypt in the mid-twentieth century, which yielded two previously unknown texts: the Dialogue with Heraclides and the Treatise on the Passover, along with portions of texts already possessed, and more recently, in

2012

, the discovery of twenty-nine Greek homilies on the Psalms in a twelfth

-

century codex in the Bayerischen Staatsbibliothek in Munich. New editions and translations of Origen’s works continue to be produced in numerous countries and languages. They can be found in series and in individual translations in German, French, Italian, Spanish, and English, and probably in others of which I am unaware.

In the last decade of the twentieth century I was director of a small research institute called the Institute for the Study of Christian Origins sponsored by the Disciples of Christ in Tübingen, Germany. I recently revisited Tübingen to participate in a symposium. In a conversation with one of the participants at the symposium I was asked who was teaching theological subjects at the University when I was working in Tübingen. When I began to list a few of the theologians who were at the University at that time—Martin Hengel, Jürgen Moltmann, Hans Küng—my conversation partner interrupted me and said, O, you were here when the giants were here! I had not thought of them in that particular way when I was living and working in Tübingen, but that is a good descriptive term for the collection of notable theological scholars who were clustered at the Eberhard Karls University in Tübingen at that time. And that is a good descriptive term for Origen.

Origen was a giant in the early church. When one thinks beyond the first century and the apostles, there was no one comparable to him until one gets to Augustine in the late fourth century. Origen moved like a colossus over the intellectual life of the early church, whether one thinks of biblical interpretation, theological insight, doctrinal development, or influence on subsequent leaders of the church. He had a lasting influence on how the church read Scripture, especially the Old Testament, and on how it thought about and formulated its doctrines. His pervasive influence spread through his immediate contact with students and the publication of his numerous writings.

Origen was greatly admired and intensely disliked during his lifetime and afterwards. Both of those reactions were often elicited by the fact that his thought was frequently outside the box, so to speak. At a time when the majority in the church, including its bishops and presbyters, believed that Scripture must be read and understood in the simple, literal meaning of the words, Origen deftly practiced a non-literal way of understanding Scripture’s words that rankled the feelings of many of his readers or listeners. This can often be detected by remarks he makes in his homilies and commentaries. His teachings about the basic Christian doctrines of the creation of the universe, the incarnation of Christ, and the consummation of history also diverged, significantly in many cases, from views held by multitudes in his time. Aspects of these same views, nevertheless, would later become incorporated into the general faith of the church in the West as well as the East. Many of the most important leaders of the western church in the fourth century were strongly influenced by Origen’s way of interpreting Scripture and by his theological insights, including Augustine of Hippo, Ambrose of Milan, and Jerome of Bethlehem.

Origen did not develop his thought in an academic context nor did he envision his many treatises serving such an audience. He developed his thought in the context of the church and he produced his treatises to serve the church—to protect it from straying from what he considered to be the truth of the message of Christ and to enable it to understand this message in its diverse Scriptural expressions. In one of his earlier works, written while he was still living in Alexandria, Origen notes that he has undertaken to write books interpreting the Scriptures because numerous such books were being produced by heterodox Christians that threatened to confuse or mislead those faithful to the common understanding of the church.

²

Origen was always concerned about the faith of the church, both in protecting it and in interpreting it to help others grasp its obvious and less obvious meanings. He was a practicing Christian all his life. He commented in one of his homilies that he wanted to be and be called a Christian in his action as well as his thought.

³

In modern jargon one could say that he did not just talk the talk; he walked the walk. He was a man of deep faith and prayer. He often requested the prayers of his listeners to help him in his preaching, and he considered prayer to be the most important element in interpreting Scripture.

⁴

This book begins by sketching the more important influences on the formation of Origen’s thought, including the circumstances of his life, so far as that is knowable. The sources for depicting Origen’s life are scarce. While a large number of his writings have been preserved, he says very little about himself in them.

⁵

His letters, which would be an important source of information, have largely perished. Eusebius refers to more than a hundred letters that he had seen—letters to an emperor and his wife, to bishops, and to various other persons—and arranged in separate roll-cases to preserve them, but they seem to have perished in antiquity. Only two have been preserved in the Greek language in which Origen wrote them; one to a former student named Gregory, and another to a scholar named Africanus. There is also a letter to some friends in Alexandria preserved in a Latin translation of the fourth century by Rufinus of Aquileia. Besides these three letters, we have only occasional sentences from letters quoted in Eusebius’ Church History. The Apology for Origen written by Pamphilus—an early fourth-century priest, martyr, and devotee of Origen—would also have been a good source for information about Origen. Pamphilus wrote the Apology in Caesarea, where Origen spent the latter part of his life. Origen’s library was there, which would have contained his own works as well as others he had gathered for his work. Pamphilus had a passion for collecting books.

⁶

He had copied many of Origen’s works with his own hand. He was later imprisoned and while in prison he wrote the five books of his Apology with the help of Eusebius. After Pamphilus’ martyrdom, Eusebius added a sixth book. These books too, with the exception of the first, have perished.

There are only a few sources from which we derive our biographical information about Origen, all from the fourth century. Jerome and Rufinus, Latin authors of the Western church, both translated numerous works of Origen from Greek into Latin and in the process provided some information about his life. The first book of the Apology for Origen by Pamphilus is another source of information. The Apology, however, is primarily a defense of Origen’s thought and says very little about his life in general. This, too, has been preserved only in a Latin translation by Rufinus in the fourth century. The two main sources from antiquity that provide biographical information about Origen’s life are both from the Eastern Greek-speaking church: works of Eusebius of Caesarea and Epiphanius of Salamis. The sixth book of the Church History of Eusebius, bishop of Caesarea in Palestine, is the most important source. Origen was a kind of hero of the faith in Eusebius’ eyes. The other source is section sixty-four of the Panarion (Medicine Chest) of Epiphanius, bishop of Salamis in Cyprus, for whom Origen was a heretic.

Eusebius, as bishop in Caesarea, had ready access to important resources about Origen’s life. Origen had spent the last portion of his life in Caesarea, and Pamphilus, who had studied Origen’s works thoroughly, was presbyter there before Eusebius. Furthermore, it is generally recognized that a unique feature of Eusebius’ historical works is his wide use and careful quotation of written sources.

⁷

We do not know, on the other hand, where Epiphanius got his biographical information about Origen. For some of the views he presents he seems to be dependent on impressions he has drawn about Origen from a group of monks who claimed to be Origen’s followers. Epiphanius considered these monks to be an heretical sect. He has very little to say about Origen’s life in his account. Most of the rather lengthy section on Origen in the Panarion is devoted to refuting some controversial doctrines Epiphanius attributed to Origen. So, while Eusebius may give a rosy tint to his account of Origen’s life, on the whole it is better to trust a person’s friend for accurate information about him, especially if he has had access to reliable information, than trust an avowed enemy who wants to cast him in the worst possible light. The general approach to Origen’s life in this book is structured by the information given by Eusebius.

⁸

This book is not an attempt to say everything that can be said about Origen, especially in the chapter on his thought. It is an introduction and as such hopes, beyond simply making him known to those who are unfamiliar with his life and thought, to elicit an interest in reading some of Origen’s texts and wrestling with their complexities. I have also tried to allow Origen to speak for himself as much as possible, and in this way to give the reader access to Origen’s own words (in English translation, of course). As I indicated at the beginning of this introduction, Origen was one of the most important and influential thinkers in the early church. Throughout his life he worked diligently at the interpretation of Scripture in his commentaries that covered most of the books of the Bible and in the application of Scripture to life in these commentaries as well as in his homilies. The extent of his influence on the church’s faith makes an acquaintance with his life and thought essential to anyone who wants to understand the roots of Christian faith.

1

. See Robert J. Daly, S.J., The Discovery of the True Origen.

2

. Origen, ComJn

5

.

7

.

3

. HomLk

16

.

4

. EpistGreg

4

.

5

. See Perrone, Origen’s ‘Confessions,’ for an attempt to cull biographical information from Origen’s writings.

6

. Grafton and Williams, Transformation of the Book,

179

–

85

.

7

. Grafton and Williams, Transformation of the Book,

200

–

203

; Gamble, Books and Readers,

156.

8

. Eusebius’ work has been given critical attention especially by two modern works: Nautin, Origène, and Grant, Eusebius as Church Historian. On the problems involved in writing a life of Origen see the insightful essay by Urbano, Difficulties, and the chapter on Eusebius’ ‘Life of Origen’ in Cox, Biography.

Part I

A Sketch Of Origen’s Life

Chapter

1

Major influences that shaped Origen’s