Best Sugar Free Pudding Mixes of 2025

"I really enjoy this pudding mix. It's super tasty and has fewer additives than the sugar-free Jello brand. A great alternative for sure!"

"I was initially concerned about the packaging since some powder spilled, but I found that it was similar to Jello with a sealed packet inside. The taste is fine, though it has a mild 'diet' aftertaste."

"I bought this to make a key lime pie. I mixed it with whipped cream and stored it in the freezer. It tastes great every day! The ingredients are simple and satisfy my hunger. Great value with six boxes and four servings each!"

"I can't get enough of chocolate pudding! I mix in whipped cream to make it mousse-like, and it tastes incredible in a graham cracker crust. The smooth quality and chocolate flavor are just perfect!"

"Using this pudding with my Ninja Creami maker makes the most delicious homemade ice cream. The texture is just amazing, and the fresh smell adds to the experience. I'm not too concerned about the sugar content; the taste is what really matters!"

"This pudding is a simple and affordable way to whip up four cups of dessert. I prefer using a bit more milk, but it also works great in an ice cream maker with less milk or cream. Some family members mentioned a slight starchy aftertaste, but it doesn't bother me at all!"

"I was on a quest to find Cook & Serve pudding and was thrilled to discover it on Amazon. The two-pack was a great value, the shipping was fast, and who can resist a delicious bowl of butterscotch pudding? It’s wonderfully creamy and utterly satisfying!"

"I prefer Cook & Serve pudding over instant varieties. Using organic non-fat dry milk powder and adding walnuts and butterscotch chips enhanced the flavor and nutritional value. The pudding turned out creamy and delicious. Stirring it on the stove brings back comforting memories from my childhood, and it’s a relaxing experience. I just wish Amazon would carry larger packages and perhaps a chocolate fudge flavor!"

"Finding this pudding on Amazon was a relief. Although the price was slightly higher than in stores, it’s not available anywhere else. Jello has taken over the production, and I find their products to be of excellent quality!"

"I find the sugar-free chocolate pudding to be a fantastic value. Just one tablespoon mixed with unflavored Greek yogurt creates a wonderfully tasty, high-protein, low-calorie treat. With about 145 calories and 18 grams of protein, it really helps me during my calorie deficit."

"This pudding is absolutely delicious! I love adding a bit of whipped cream to satisfy my cravings. When mixed with heavy cream, it turns into a wonderful fluff that helps curb my sugar cravings. It’s so versatile—I can add it to drinks, cakes, or even make keto ice cream!"

"I really enjoy this pudding! It's rich and creamy, and I don’t experience any spikes in my blood sugar. It’s incredibly easy to prepare, and the taste is just perfect!"

"This is my favorite flavor of Jell-O cook & serve pudding, tied with butterscotch. I prepare it in the microwave, carefully monitoring the time. I also enjoy experimenting with homemade pudding using potato starch for its gut health benefits, but I appreciate how good this pudding tastes warm."

"I’ve been using this pudding for years, and it has great taste and quality. I love the convenience of having it delivered to my door, and it’s really easy to make."

"I found this pudding when I needed a dessert option for my health. I wasn’t a big fan of puddings, but I absolutely loved it! It's simple to prepare, delicious with just skim milk, and surprisingly cost-effective compared to my usual desserts."

"I bought this to make pies for a potluck, and I'm so glad I did. It made an awesome pie with a Graham cracker crust!"

"I absolutely love this pudding! It's delicious and I can't find it in my local stores, so I end up paying the high Amazon price. But for me, it's worth it to have more variety in flavors."

"I was pleasantly surprised by how quickly and easily this pudding came together. I added strawberries and bits of fruit, and it turned out lovely!"

"I've loved butterscotch pudding since childhood, so when I discovered it as a protein shake flavor, I was excited to try it. Using unflavored protein powder really lets the butterscotch flavor shine. The shake is velvety smooth and enjoyable!"

"I appreciate that this pudding doesn't have an aftertaste, even though it's sugar-free. It's hard to find in my local stores, so I'm thrilled I can order it on Amazon!"

"At 70 years old and prediabetic, enjoying my favorite flavor without sugar has been a game changer. It's smooth and creamy, and the price is just right. I order in bulk without any shipping issues!"

"My husband has lost a lot of weight over the last year, and these puddings have become his favorite dessert. He enjoys one daily, and we were thrilled to find them on Amazon since they are hard to find locally. The price for a case of 24 is slightly better than at the grocery store. They're creamy, chocolatey, and taste great—even with skim milk. I like to add whipped cream for extra flavor! I highly recommend them!"

"As a diabetic who loves chocolate, it can be tough to find snacks that don’t raise my blood sugar. I appreciate that this product contains no sugar alcohols, which can spike blood sugar levels. The flavor is wonderful, and I look forward to trying other varieties soon!"

"I make my sugar-free pudding with tap water instead of milk, which makes it super quick and easy—it takes less than a minute! I often enjoy it for breakfast with mixed fruit. However, I have noticed that it contains a lot of salt, which is a concern for heart patients. It's a great sugar-free dessert option, especially for emergencies or outdoor activities!"

"I can't get enough of this jello for my Ninja Creami ice cream. It tastes great and doesn't make me feel bloated, even when I use a lot!"

"I love this sugar-free jello instant pudding. It’s a staple for my KETO desserts, and I often have to order certain flavors from Amazon because they are hard to find in stores."

"Using this pudding for a Chocolate Eclair cake was a hit with my diabetic friend. Although it’s more expensive in Canada, its delicious taste makes it worth it for a dear friend."

“I really love this brand of sugar-free pudding. It has much cleaner ingredients than the national brands. The texture is perfect, and it blends easily. Plus, the price is just right for what I get. I often use it in my chocolate protein ninja creami recipes, and it gives the right thickness to resemble ice cream.”

“This is my second purchase, and overall, I’m quite happy with it. The flavor is pretty good, though I added a pinch of salt the second time. There’s a minimal aftertaste, but it's not enough to stop me from enjoying it. I recommend using a hand mixer for a smooth texture. It thickens nicely, and I will definitely buy it again!”

“I bought this because I’m diabetic and lactose intolerant. Using unsweetened oat milk, I followed the instructions, but it turned out too thick and grainy. After some adjustments, I achieved the right consistency, but it still had an artificial sweetener aftertaste. The chocolate flavor isn’t as intense as Jell-O's. It’s not awful, but it’s an acquired taste. I’ll keep it for chocolate cravings but won’t buy it regularly.”