Nilufer Ozmekik's Reviews > The Only Girl in Town

This book left me in a state of ambivalence; I couldn't quite decide if I liked it or not. The pacing, the short chapters, and the lyrical, poetic, highly emotional, and empowering writing style all intrigued me. The central mystery of a town where everyone, including pets, vanishes into thin air, leaving only 18-year-old July Fielding behind, kept me engaged until the end. It was gripping and riveting, maintaining my interest throughout. However, upon reaching the finish line, I found myself questioning if that was all there was and what the real point of it all was.
One aspect that truly resonated with me was the exploration of the experience of loneliness amidst a crowd. The notion that one can feel detached and estranged despite being surrounded by others is a powerful theme that the author skillfully delved into. The inner turmoil and fear that accompany such a feeling, preventing genuine connections and the ability to embrace relationships and commitments, were portrayed with depth and meaning. The book did an admirable job of shedding light on the notion of not feeling deserving of love and the dark thoughts that can consume one's mind, leading to a sense of inferiority, self-sabotage, and even depression. These introspective themes were approached with thoughtfulness and offered valuable insights.

However, the execution of the teenage characters and their interactions left me somewhat perplexed. Instead of exhibiting emotional maturity and open communication about their feelings, they often displayed immaturity, selfishness, and peculiar behavior throughout the narrative. This made it challenging for me to fully connect with July's inner world and empathize with her struggles. While the intention may have been to portray the complexities of adolescence, it sometimes veered into unrealistic territory, which hindered my engagement with the story.

Despite these reservations, I must commend the book's trajectory and the author's ability to keep readers guessing. The buildup of suspense and the climactic moments were skillfully crafted, leaving me eager to discover how the pieces would come together. Although the final outcomes didn't resonate with me as strongly as the book's overall progression, I appreciated the author's willingness to take risks and deliver a unique reading experience.

Overall, while I ultimately settled on a rating of 3 stars, it is important to recognize the merits of this book. Its thought-provoking exploration of loneliness, the encouragement to let go and embrace the present, and its overall mysterious nature make it a worthwhile read. I am grateful for the opportunity to have engaged with this narrative and to have shared my honest opinions.

Once again, I extend my sincere thanks to NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Penguin Young Readers Group/ Dutton Books for Young Readers for providing me with the digital reviewer copy. Their continued support enables readers like myself to discover and engage with brilliant books.

Follow me on medium.com to read my articles about books, movies, streaming series, astrology:

medium blog
instagram
facebook
twitter