Complementary technical information

Protection discrimination

Protection discrimination is an essential element that must be taken into account starting at the design stage of a low voltage installation to ensure the highest level of availability for users. Discrimination is important in all installations for the comfort of users, however it is fundamental in installations requiring a high level of service continuity, e.g. industrial manufacturing processes. Industrial installations without discrimination run a series of risks of varying importance including: b production deadline overruns b interruption in manufacturing, entailing: v production or finished-product losses v risk of damage to production machines in continuous processes b restarting of machines, one by one, following a general power outage b shutdown of vital safety equipment such as lubrification pumps, smoke fans, etc.

What is discrimination?
DB120589

Discrimination, also called selectivity, is the coordination of automatic protection devices in such a manner that a fault appearing at a given point in a network is cleared by the protection device installed immediately upstream of the fault, and by that device alone. b Total discrimination Discrimination is said to be total if, for all fault current values, from overloads up to the non-resistive short-circuit current, circuit breaker D2 opens and D1 remains closed. b Partial discrimination Discrimination is partial if the above condition is not respected up to the full shortcircuit current, but only to a lesser value termed the selectivity limit current (Is). b No discrimination In the event of a fault, both circuit breakers D1 and D2 open.

version: 3.0

557E4300.indd

Complementary technical information

Protection discrimination

Total discrimination as standard with Masterpact NT/NW circuit breakers

Thanks to their highly innovative design and the exeptional performance of their control units, the Masterpact NT and NW circuit breakers offer total discrimination with downstream Compact NSX devices up to 630 A as standard (1).

Natural discrimination with Compact NSX circuit breakers

Due to the Roto-active breaking technique employed by the Compact NSX, the combined use of Schneider Electric circuit breakers provides an exceptional level of protection discrimination. This is the result of the implementation and optimisation of three different techniques: b current discrimination b time discrimination b energy discrimination.
DB115814

Overload protection: current discrimination Discrimination is ensured if the ratio between setting thresholds is greater than 1.6 (for distribution circuit breakers). Low short-circuit protection: current discrimination. Tripping of the upstream device is slightly delayed to ensure that the downstream device trips first. Discrimination is ensured if the ratio between the short-circuit thresholds is greater than 1.5. High short-circuit protection: time discrimination. This protection system combines the exceptional current limiting capacity of the Compact NS and the advantages of reflex tripping, sensitive to the energy dissipated in the device by the short-circuit. In the event of a high short-circuit detected by two circuit breakers, the downstream device limits it sharply. The energy dissipated in the upstream device is not sufficient to trip it, i.e. discrimination is total for all short-circuit currents. Discrimination is ensured if the ratio between the circuit breaker ratings is greater than 2.

(1) Except for the L1 performance level on Masterpact NT and subject to the discrimination rules on page 557E4300/4.

557E4300.indd

version: 3.0

Complementary technical information

Protection discrimination

DB120590

How to use the discrimination tables

b for discrimination between 2 distribution circuit breakers Combinations providing full discrimination are indicated by the symbol T. If discrimination is partial, the table indicates the maximum fault current value for which discrimination is ensured. For fault currents above this value, the 2 circuit breakers trip simultaneously.

Requisite conditions
The values indicated in the tables are valid for operational rated voltages of 220, 380, 415 and 440 V:
Discrimination between two distribution circuit breakers.

For Acti9 range devices (miniature circuit-breakers), two types of tables are provided, depending on the number of phases of downstream circuit:
DB125741

Single-phase downstream circuit, would upstream circuit be single- or triple-phase. These tables are identified by the pictogram opposite. 2P
DB125742

Triple-phase downstream (and upstream) circuit : tables identified by the pictogram opposite. 3P/4P

Upstream TM Micrologic

Downstream TM or Multi 9 Micrologic TM or Multi 9 Micrologic

Frame up / Frame down u 2.5 u 2.5 u 2.5 u 2.5

Thermal protection Ir up/Ir down u 1.6 u 1.6 u 1.6 u 1.3

Magnetic protection Im up/Im down u2 u 1.5 u 1.5 u 1.5

These conditions ensure that curves dont overlap. Curves could also be checked with Curve Direct software tools

version: 3.0

557E4300.indd

Complementary technical information

Protection discrimination

DB125679

b Short time pick up (Isd) Tables indicate selectivity limits assuming Isd = 10 x Ir. In many cases when discrimination is Total lower thresholds could be used if ratio condition between two magnetic protections is fulfilled. When selectivity limit indicated in the tables is equal to 10xIr, the selectivity limit is upstream short time pick up (Isd). b Instantaneous pick up (Ii) Tables indicate selectivity limits assuming instantaneous pick up is set at the maximum value and when its inhibited (Type B Circuit breaker only). With Masterpact, when selectivity limit indicated in the tables is equal to 15 x In, the selectivity limit is upstream instantaneous pick up (Ii). When upstream circuit Breaker is A type, and downstream circuit breaker is B type upstream instantaneous setting can be set lower than 15 In as far as it stay higher than downstream circuit breaker reflex tripping limit. When a Micrologic 5.x is used downstream a Micrologic 2.x Tsd shall be set at 0 and Ii shall be set at Isd. b Short time delay (Tsd) When upstream and downstream breaker are equipped with Micrologic 5.x, 6.x, 7.x: the minimum non tripping-time of the upstream device must be greater than the maximum tripping time of the downstream device. Tsd D1 > Tsd D2 (One Step) b I2t Off / On Tables indicate selectivity limits assuming I2t Function is Off. If I2t function is ON user shall check curves. b Ground Fault protection (Ig, Tg) When upstream and downstream breaker are equipped with Micrologic 6.x, user should implement current and time discrimination: v current sensing discrimination Threshold setting of upstream GFP device tripping is greater than that of the downstream GFP device. Because of tolerances on the settings, a 30 % difference between the upstream and downstream thresholds is sufficient. v time graded discrimination The intentional time delay setting of the upstream GFP device is greater than the opening time of the downstream device. Furthermore, the intentional time delay given to the upstream device must respect the maximum time for the elimination of insulation faults defined by the NEC 230.95 (i.e. 1s for 3000 A). Ig D1 >= 1,3 Ig D2
D1 RCD

Additional Settings conditions according to trip unit type

DB117227

DB125678

Tg D1 > Tg D2 (One Step)

D2 RCD

b Residual current devices To achieve satisfactory continuity of supply for the end user, discrimination must also be implemented to Residual Current Devices. Therefore any couple of upstream / downstream RCD throughout the distribution network, must meet the following conditions : b sensitivity of upstream RCD at least 3 times the one of downstream RCD (In D1 u 3 x In D2) b upstream RCD must be of : v selective (S) type (or setting) if the downstream RCD is of instantaneous type, v delayed (R) type (or setting) if the downstream RCD is of selective type, This will ensure the minimum non-tripping time of the upstream device to be greater than the maximum tripping time of the downstream device for all current values (t (D1) > t (D2)). For further details, see chapters CT6-4 and CT6-1: "response times of residual current devices".

Compact NSX motor trip units

b Compact NSX Trip units dedicated to motor protection ("M" type) can not be used to ensure discrimination with downstream circuit breaker. b Furthermore Compact NSX trip unit dedicated to distribution should not be used to protect motors, even motors wit soft starter or speed drive.

557E4300.indd

version: 3.0