Why Children Talk To Themselves: Laura E. Berk (1994)

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

WHY CHILDREN TALK

TO THEMSELVES
Laura E. Berk (1994)

University of British Columbia
PSYC 315, Fall 2013
Private speech = 20-60% of a childs speech acts before
10 years of age
First documented by Vygotsky
Sociocultural theories of cognitive development
private speech is important
vs.
Piagetian theory of cognitive development
private speech is not useful
THE IMPORTANCE OF PRIVATE
SPEECH
Vygotsky:
Private speech is the intersection of speech and
practical activity
Children learn private speech from their interactions
with mature adults
Private speech can replace social scaffolding in some
situations
With age, vocal private speech declines, but never
disappears completely
CHARACTERISTICS OF PRIVATE
SPEECH
Berk:
PS occurs more when children are engaging in challenging tasks
when an adult is not present
Children of less communicative caregivers engage in more vocal
PS than those of communicative parents, and do so until a later
age

PS occurs often in the zone of proximal development
The ZPD contains activities that a child can complete, but usually with
the help of an older caregiver
PS improves abilities on challenging tasks
PS is more effective when it is goal-directed rather than when it is
off-topic
PS decreases as skill increases
PS IN CHILDREN WITH
DEVELOPMENTAL OR BEHAVIOURAL
CHALLENGES
Children with ADHD speak to themselves privately as
much as children without ADHD
But PS is less effective for children with ADHD
PS is more effective when children with ADHD are taking
medication
Children with ADHD and learning disabilities continue using vocal
PS later than normally developing children do
Because of these differences, children with developmental
challenges are often not allowed to continue using PS, even though
its essential to learning
TAKE HOME MESSAGES
Within the sociocultural theory of cognitive development,
private speech is an essential tool for learning
Children use private speech as a substitute for adult
guidance on difficult tasks
More PS when task is hard (in the Zone of Proximal Development)
PS improves performance on challenging tasks
Different children lose vocal PS at different ages
PS is more useful for some children than for others

You might also like