Journal Chromatography, 213 (1981) 287-300: C15"n-. CI %I - N 8 n-2 11 R e - N 4 OH OH 0 11 74
Journal Chromatography, 213 (1981) 287-300: C15"n-. CI %I - N 8 n-2 11 R e - N 4 OH OH 0 11 74
Journal Chromatography, 213 (1981) 287-300: C15"n-. CI %I - N 8 n-2 11 R e - N 4 OH OH 0 11 74
13,899
LONG-CHAIN
PHENOLS
XXI*. QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE PHENOLIC LIPIDS IN TECHNICAL CASHEW NUT-SHELL LIQUID, FROM ANACARDIUM OCCIDENTALE, BY HIGH-PERFORMANCE LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY
J. H. P. TYMAN*,
V. TYCHOPOULOS
Scl~ool of Chemistry, Brunei University, Uxbridge, Middleses (Received April 16th, 1981)
SUMMARY
The novel separation of the constituent phenols in technical cashew nut-shell liquid from the industrial processing of Anacardium occidetttale has been effected by high-performance liquid chromatography. The adsorption mode on columns of 5-pm and 1O-pm Partisil and the reversedphase partition mode with 5pm and IO-pm Spherisorb bonded with octadecylsilane have been investigated. Determination of relative molar response values for the main constituent phenols and the use of an internal standard have leu to a quantitative procedure by isocratic elution under reversed-phase partition, preferably with the solvent acetonitrile-water. Gradient elution with tetrahydrofuran and acetonitrile has also enabled the polymeric material to be estimated in the various types of technical cashew nut-shell liquid examined_
INTRODUCTION The principal component phenols of technical cashew nut-shell liquid (CNSL) from the industrial processing of Anacardiml occidentale are cardanol (I; R = H, II = 0,2,4 or 6) and card01 (II; R = H, II = 0,2,4 or 6), and earlier contributions- have been concerned with various techniques for quantitative chromatographic determination_ Although the trimethylsilylated material can be analysed by gas-liquid chro-
C15n-.
CI~%I--n
n-2 11 11 74 n=4
R OH OH
8
0
II:
* Part XX: J. H. P. Tyman, A. A. Durrani and S. C. Goh, J. Chem. Res., in press. ~~1-9673/8l/O~/SO~.~O 0 1981 Ekevier Scientific Publishing Company
288
J. H. P. TYMAN,
V. TYCHOPOULOS,
B. A. COLENUTT
matography (GLC) on polyethyleneglycol adipate6, the derivative process and Ihe possibility of polymerisation of the highly susceptible diene and triene constituents led us to examine quantitative analysis by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). A further requirement to monitor rapidly reaction mixtures involving I and II made it desirable to devise a cold method. No previous analyses have been described in the field of phenolic lipids, although the basis of the method was established qualitatively some time ago. The separation by HPLC of certain homologous 5-lz-alkylresorcinols has been described and of C8-C,0 alkylphenols lo _ Acetylated urushiol obtained by the use of acetic anhydride under acidic conditions has been examined by HPLC. In any area of natural and other products, quantitative HPLC has received little attention. With the reversed-phase partition mode under isocratic conditions and the use of an internal standard the relative molar response values of the constituents of the principal phenols in technical CNSL have been determined, and thence the total quantitative composition without the need for any derivative. By gradient elution following this procedure the polymeric material has been separated. The results agree
with those of a previous GLC method13.
The HPLC method revealed a number of hitherto undetected* minor components probably consisting of geometrical and structural isomers of the principal C,, unsaturated constituents together with the unsaturated constituents of the C,, homologue of cardanol since upon hydrogenation of the technical CNSL the principal phenolic materials observed were only ( 15:O)-cardanol, ( 17:O)cardanol and ( 15:O)cardol.
EXPERIMENTAL
Equipment A self-constructed
liquid chromatograph was used, consisting of a PerkinElmer ultraviolet variable-wavelength spectrophotometer (Model LC55) equipped
with a flow-through cell, an Altex (Anachem) metering pump (Model 1 lOA), a Rheodyne injection system (Model 7120) with a 20-~1 loop, a Servoscribe recorder (Model 1s) and an Infrotonics programmable digital integrator (Model CRS 20-l) with a Monroe (13 10) printer. Subsequently a Hewlett-Packard printer-plotter (Model 3909) was used as computing integrator giving results in agreement and without the erratic and sometimes unpredictable behaviour of the former system. The units were interconnected in the usual way with standard stainless-steel tubing and unions. Gradient elution was carried out with a second Altex metering pump of similar type and an Altex programmer (Model 420). Stainless-steel columns (Altex) were 250 x 4.6 mm I.D. For adsorption conditions they had been packed with silica gel (Par-
tisil) and for reversed-phase partition, Spherisorb bonded with octadecylsilane (ODS). In both types columns with particle sizes of 5 pm and 10 pm were used.
constituents
LONG-CHAIN
PHENOLS.
XXI.
289
Cotditiotrs Generally
for detection
of phenolic
constituents
the wavelength
nm since the absorption maxima were in the range 275-280 nm15_ The pressure in the system depended on the viscosity of the solvent but was usually in the range 100% 1500 p.s.i. and the flow-rate was generally in the range l-3 ml/min. Solute was made with up in chloroform, and generally 5 ~1 of a 10 oA solution was chromatographed,
recorder
sensitivity
In quantitative determinations all HPLC analyses were conducted six times to obtain representative peak areas for integration_ Reproducibility was excellent and the standard deviations for each constituent were low. Isocratic elution with the reversedphase partition mode and solvent acetonitrile-water (66:34) was used for simplicity in the final analysis of the phenolic constituents and subsequently gradient elution for the polymeric material (as discussed later).
Materials
All solvents for HPLC were of liquid chromatography grade. Technical CNSL of three types was used. The first (sometimes termed raw CNSL) was kindly made available by 3M Co. (St. Paul, MN, U.S.A.) and was believed to be of Brazilian origin. Distilled CNSL, representing vacuum-distilled raw CNSL, was from the same source. Blend 3, initially more polymerised, was material obtained five years ago but stored at OC, sealed up and in the dark in the interim. Cardanoi and card01 required for the preparation of a standard calibration solution were obtained by column chromatography as describedI fol!owed by further purification by preparative thin-layer chromatography (TLC). Analytical and preparative TLC were carried out with silica gel G (type 60) as previously described. The constituents of cardanol were separated by preparative argentation TLC on silica gel G containing 15 o/0 silver nitrate with the solvent ethyl acetate<hloroform (2O:SO) and those of card01 with ethyl acetate<hloroform (5050). Bands were located by spraying a narrow strip resulting from a spot separate from the rest of the plate with 50 oA aqueous sulphuric acid and warmin, u in a stream of hot air. The phenolic constituents were eluted with ether-methanol (90: IO), isolated by filtration, concentration under reduced pressure, ethereal extraction of the residue, water-washed to remove some silver nitrate, dried and recovered_ These materials were then all repurified by ordinary preparative TLC with the solvent ethyl acetate-chloroform (5:95). The purity of all six materials was determined by HPLC examination. All gave single peaks*_ Saturated cardanol and saturated card01 were obtained as described*6 and purified by recrystallisation from light petroleum (b-p. 40-6OC). p-Cresol (BDH. Poole, Great Britain) gave a single peak by HPLC. For the preparation of the standard containing the unsaturated phenols. cardanol monoene (11.36 mg), cardanol diene (1.55 mg), cardanol triene (I 1.51 mg), card01 diene (0.75 mg), card01 triene (10.30 mg) and the internal standard, p-cresol (2.1 mg), were weighed on a five-place balance. (Unfortunately in the final standard prepared, following a number of trial runs, insufficient card01 monoene was available_) The mixture was prepared in chloroform (2 ml) and stored under nitrogen
* Cardanol monoene contained obtaining pure constituents. a trace of peak BI. Preparative HPLC should ideally be used for
TABLE I
RETENTION TIMES AND RETENTION VOLUMES OF CASHEW-NUT PHENOLS UNDER ADSORPTION CONDITIONS ON PARTISIL (5 pm)
IR
Soh?trt
Retetlliotr
paratncter
Floa-rarc (ttr//tnitr)
2-h4er/lJ&
card01 _ _
I -
3.75 3,75 2.5 5.0 26.15 26.75 25.5 51.0 32.5 32.5 30.25 60.5 20.3 20.3 24 48
4 4 2.15 5.5
3 6
3.31 6.14
22 22 21.75 43.50
24.5 24.5 26 52
26.75
30.1
38,O
3.5 5.25
$R I, V,{ t,, Vn 3.75 3.75 4.75 5.25 5.15 6.5 4.25 4.87 4825 4.87 5.12 5.12 I7 I7 -
I.5
IO.0
15,o
5887 8.80
Ffl
IR
tr-Hcxano methanol (100:2) tr-Hcxane-ethyl acetate (100:5) tr-Hexane-isopropanol(100:4) Isooctanemethanol (100:4) Isooctanemcthanoldiethyl ether (100:3.6:1.2)
22.0 22.0 26.25 26.25 28.1 28.1 31.0 31.0 36.25 36.25 37.25 37.25
vR
LONG-CHAIN
PHENOLS. XXI.
291
at - 20C when not required. A separate standard of saturated cardanol(ll.70 mg), saturated card01 (9.84 mg) and p-cresof (1.92 mg) was prepared and made up similarly in chloroform solution. A linearity check with the six constituents and p-cresol was made to check the validity of Beers law for the concentration ranges encountered, and substantially straight-line plots were found for volume (pl) versz~speak area in all cases.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
Retention volumes of the constituents of the cotnponent phenols Adsorptioii mode. A large number of solvents were examined for the separation of the component phenolic constituents of technical CNSL. In these experiments IIhexane or isooctane was the major component and a minor proportion of methanol. ethyl acetate, or isopropanol was used. The results in terms of retention time and volume are summarised in Table I. Reduction of polarity in the solvent led generally to the expected increase in retention volume, the minor, more polar component of the binary combination exerting the greater effect. Thus a change from IIhexane to isooctane did not greatly affect the complete resolution of the four constituents of cardanol, cardol and Lmethylcardol (II; R = CH,, N = 0, 2,4 or 6), but replacement of methanol by a similar proportion of isopropanol resulted in no resolution of the constituents of each phenol, and three collective peaks were observed for cardanol, cardol and 2-methylcardol. Departures from the combinations shown in the table led to exceedingly long retention times or loss of resolution of the conacetate stituents of each component phenol. ,z-Hexane, dichloromethane-ethyl (90:10), chlorohexane-ethyl acetate (96:4), rz-hexane-acetonitrile (100:2) were all ineffective. A typical chromatogram obtained with N-hexane-methanol (100:4) is shown in Fig. 1. Partition mode. The results for a number of reversed-phase partition experiments under isocratic conditions are given in Table II. The use of methanol-water compared with acetonitrile-water resulted generally in lower retention volumes for all the constituents, but frequently lack of resolution of minor components. The resolution of minor constituents was used as a criterion for the effectiveness of the particular binary combination under examination. The solvent acetonitrile-water (66:34) was an improvement generally in giving resolution of the minor components BI to B7 as in the typical cllromatogram illustrated in Fig. 2. Fig. 3 shows the separation in methanol-water (80:20). The lower viscosity of the former solvent enabled the pressure to be reduced considerably by comparison with aqueous methanol combinations. On account of the better resolution effected, the reversed-phase partition mode was the preferred method for use in quantitative analysis. Furthermore, a profusion of large peaks in the adsorption mode at the commencement of the chromatographic run complicated the choice of internal standard_ The average height equivalent to a theoretical plate (HETP) for the separations in Fig. 2 was 0.005 cm. Determination of relative molar response (RMR) r-ahes The reversed-phase partition mode simplified the choice of an internal standard and enabled a lower alkylphenol to be used. p-Cresol was available in pure form and was generally more suitable than m-cresol, p-ethylphenol, p-isopropylphenol, or p-tert.-butylphenol. The internal standard and the pure monoene, diene and triene
TABLE II
RETENTION TIMES AND RETENTION VOLUMES OF CASHEW NUT-SHELL PHENOLS UNDER PARTITION (REVERSED-PHASE) CONDITIONS ON SPHERISORB BONDED WITH OCTADECYLSILANE (5 pm)
A = Ace\onitrile; E = ethanol; M = methanol; W = water; I, = retention time (min); V,{= relcntion volume (ml); NR = not resolved. 2Cardnlrol
-0th Bl cotIsIiIuctIIs (twitor)
Curdal
15:3
IS:2
IS:1
15:O
82
B3
B4
B5
86
B7
1.5
;fl Ifi vn
1.0
A-W (75:25) A-W (70:30) A-W (68:32) A-W (65:35) 9.25 13.87 15 15 IO.15 16812 14.15 22.12 12.12 20.60 37852 53.56 85485 165.35 35.31 13.75 20.62 22.4 22.4 I6 24 22.75 34012 18.5 31,45 7.62 11.43 12.55 12.55 8.87 13.30 12.37 18.55 IO.12 17.20 16.25 24,37 26.5 26,s 19.12 28.68 28.0 42.0 22.5 38825 22.5 33.75 31,s 31.5 27 40.2 40.25 60.31 32.25 54.82 35 52.5 58.5 58.5 42.5 63.75 64,s 96.75 51.62 87.75 68 102 -
;n 111
1.5
V,,
1.5
&Y34)
4l vn
1.7
5.2 7.8 II,25 Il.25 800 12.0 10.81 16.30 8.75 14.81
15.37 23.05 25.4 25.4 18.25 27.37 26.5 39.15 21.25 36.12
24.5 36375 41,25 41,25 29.25 43,87 43,87 65.80 35.5 60.35
61.75 9286 49,75 84.57 41017 49.81 58.73 66.59 74.37 81.94
V,
I.7
:Gz,
;H
1.0
NR
NR
NR
NR
;z)
$n
1.0
;z7.5)
$8
I.5
gzZ)
$,{
I.8
1.8
6.37 6.37 10.5 10.5 7.87 II.8 7.5 13.5 10.64 19.15
NR 7,75 1.75 NR 13.25 l3,25 NR 12.5 l8,75 - . IO.5 .-, 1 NR 18.9 . NR 15.14 27.25
900 940 16.5 16.5 15.0 22.5 12.25 22.05 18.34 33.01
10.75 10.75 21.12 ,21.12 19.75 29.62 16.0 28.8 24.72 44.49
13.87 13.87 29.25 29025 28.5 42.75 23.12 41.61 36.71 66.19
20.15 20.75 49.5 49.5 51.25 76.81 40.5 72.9 75.05 135.09
25.8 25.8 17.25 NR 25.0 37.5 25.81 14.25 NR 20.25 36.45 25.65 19.16 20.62 26.64 32.36 35.57 37.12 47.95 58,25
27.25 40.01 -
0.9
NR
68.0 61.2
NR
25.25 NR 22.72
* Mnrginal separation.
LONG-CHAIN
PHENOLS
XXI.
293
Fig. 1. HPLC separation of mixed cardanol and card01 under adsorption conditions on Partisil(5 pm) with rz-henane-methanol(100:4). Flow-rate, 1.0 ml/min. Peaks: D = cardanol monoene; E = cardanol diene; F = cardanol triene; G = card01 monoene; H = card01 diene; I = card01 triene.
I
E
Fig. 2. HPLC separation of distilled CNSL under reversed-phase partition conditions on Spherisorb ODS (5 .nm) with acetonitrile-water (66:34). Flow-rate, 1.7 ml/min. Peaks: D-I as in Fig. 1; J = 2-methylcardol triene; K = 2-methylcardol diene; S = saturated cardanol.
constituents of cardanol and cards1 were incorporated in one solution which was chromatographically examined twelve tunes in order to select six representative results. To obtain a measure of agreement between the relative molar response (RMR) values for the monoene, diene and triene it proved necessary for chromatographic reasons or owing to integrator problems to examine four different standards before the required accuracy could be achieved, so that a considerable number of chromatograms were carried out to achieve the final result. A second standard of saturated
294
J. H. P. TYMAN,
V. TYCHOPOULOS,
B. A. COLENUTT
_j
1
was prepared, and the results for both are
Fig. 3. HPLC separation of distilled CNSL on Spherisorb ODS (5 pm) with methanol-water (80:20). Flowrate, 1.8 ml/min. Peaks as in Fig. 2. C = p-Crcsol. cardanol given in and saturated card01 withp-cresol
Table III. The lower RMR values for the card01 constituents compared with those of cardanol are expected from their respective E values14. RMR values for the constituent phenol (RMR), in relation to that for p-cresol (RMR, = 1) were calculated from (peak area), (peak area), RMRJRMR, = (g mole), I (g mole),
TABLE III RELATIVE MOLAR RESPONSE VALUES PHENOLS (WITH REFERENCE TO p-CRESOL Phenol Weight (n1g) p-Cresol ( 15:3)-Card01 (card01 triene) (15:2)-Card01 (card01 dieae) (15:1)-Card01 (card01 monoene) (15:3)-Cardanol (cardanol triene) (15:2)-Cardano: (cardanol dienc) (lS:l)-Cardanol (cardanol monoene) p-Crcsol (15:0)-Card01 (card01 saturated) (15:0)-Cardanol (cardanol saturated) * Calculated value. 2.10 10.30 0.74 11.36 7.55 il.51 1.92 11.70 9.84 26.29 f 0.39 OF CASHEW AS INTERNAL NUT-SHELL STANDARD) CONSTITUENT
Relative molar response v&e 1.000 0.992 0.997 o-997* 1.296 1.279 1.305 1.000 1.001 1.294
1.25 + 0.014
LONG-CHAIN
PHENOLS.
XXI.
296
J. H. P. TYMAN, V. TYCHOPOULOS,
B. A. COLENUTT
CARDOL, 2MATERIAL
82.38 63.13
11.25 10.31
2.05 1.88
3.98 3.05
0.34 21.63
* Based on triangulation and proportion of cardanol present. The same RMR value as for cardanol was assumed. * The same RMR as for card01 was used.
Minor monomeric and polymeric material Minor monomeric constituents. It was not found possible to use the particular
integrator available to determine the peaks Bl to B7, or 2-methylcardol triene and diene. From previous work2 on the analysis of hydrogenated and methylated technical CNSL the proportion of 2-methylcardol associated with card01 is fairly constant. On the basis of card01 having an associated 18 o/o 2-methylcardol, the calcuof lated proportion of 2-methylcardol in the three samples of CNSL is given in Table V. By triangulation, the contribution of the minor peaks Bl to B7, due to monomeric substances, in the case of distilled CNSL was found to be 3.97% (in relation to the
* Generally the results show the instabiiity of triene constituents, particularly that of cardol, towards distillation and the increase of the percentage of polymer with age of the material accompanied by diminution of both cardanol and card01 triene constituents. tf Anacardic acid was eluted prior to cardol, the constituents giving tailing peaks. The proportion was negligible in comparison with that reported earherr as l-l_S~.
LONG-CHAIN
PHENOLS.
XXI.
297
peak area of cardanol diene, 16.03 %)_ The final column in the table gives an estimate by difference of the proportion of polymeric material present in the three samples examined. For a total quantitative analysis ideally it would be preferable to integrate the peak areas of Bl to B7 and to establish their chemical identity. Our work in this direction is as yet incomplete_ From their retention data they are mostly related to C,, cardanol constituents and to the C,, bis homologue, the presence of which in the monoene, diene and triene form has been shown by mass spectroscopy. Upon hydrogenation of the CNSL sample, peaks B 1 to B7 substantially disappeared. A new large peak appeared after that for (15:0)-cardanol at the retention expected for saturated C,, (17:0)-cardanol, and a small peak preceded that for ( 15 :O)cardanol. From the retention data found for 3-butylphenol, 3-undecylphenol (log retention time, 1.36) available from synthesist8 and (15 :O)-cardanol (3-pentadecylphenol) (log retention time, 2.05) together with the linear relationship between methylenic carb& chain length and log (retention), the expected relative retention (1.5 1) compared to that of (15:0)-cardanol, the retention time for (17:0)-cardanol was found. On the reasonable basis that a similar relative retention holds for (17: l)-, (17:2)- and (17:3)-cardanol it seems most probable that peaks B7 and B4, respectively, correspond to the two latter constituents. It is considered that the remaining minor constituents are probably structural and geometrical isomers of (15:1)-, (15:2)- and (15:3)-cardanol. In a study of the effect of using different wavelengths for detection it was observed that at 240 nm certain of the Bl to B7 peaks exhibited maximum absorption consistent with the presence of conjugated side-chains. The small peak preceding (15:0)-cardanol is probably ascribable to C,, chain-length material. Polymeric material. The presence of polymeric material has previouslyj been inferred from quantitative GLC analysis, but by gradient elution it proved possible
Fig. 4. HPLC separation of distilled CNSL on Sphcrisorb ODS (5 pm) by gradient elution, starting with acetonitrile-water (66:34). Flow-rate. 1.7 ml/min. Peaks D-I and S as in Fig. 7; P = polymer; C = pcresol.
298
J. H. P. TYMAN,
V. TYCHOPOULOS,
B. A. COLENUTT
G J
iL 0
Fig. 5. HPLC separationof new CNSL on Spherisorb ODS (5 ,um) by gradient elution, startingwith
acetonitrile-water (66:34). Flow-rate, 1.7 ml/min. Peaks as in.Fig. 4.
by HPLC to demonstrate its presence. Gradient elution was also desirable because of the long retention of (15:O)-cardanol. In the absence of gradient elution, stepwise elution of (15:O)-cardanol was effected with acetonitrile (100 %)* and of polymeric material with tetrahydrofuran (100 %). With gradient elution a progressive programmed change from acetonitrile-water (66:34) to tetrahydrofuran (THF) (100 %) was effected. Figs. 4,5, and 6 show the complete cbromatograms for distilled, new and old (blend 3) technical CNSL, respectivelyn;. The heterogeneous nature of the polymeric material is clear since a number of peaks are produced upon elution with acetonitriletetrahydrofuran. The retention information suggests that the material is probably
I G ~
Fig. 6. HPLC separation of old CNSL on Spherisorb ODS (5 m) acetonitrik-water (66:34). Flow-rate, 1.7 ml/min. Peaks as in Fig. 4. d
l Rapid analysis of hydrogenated technical CNSL was effected with acetonitrile (100 %). ff Adsorption conditions were not suitable for demonstrating the presence of polymer.
LONG-CHAIN
PHENOLS.
XXI.
299
dimeric and trimeric and relatively saturated. Recovery of the eluted polymeric material and TLC examination (Fig. 7) indicated an increase of complexity and polarity with level of polymerisation.
Fig. 7. TLC separation on silica gel G of THF eluted polymer. 1 = From old CNSL; 2 = from new CNSL; 3 = from distilled CNSL; 4 = new CNSL; 5 = old CNSL. Solvent, chlorofomwzthyl acetate (9O:lO). a = Cardol; b = 2-methylcardol; c = cardanol.
Comparison of HPLC with other methods of amal_v.sis for phenolic lipids Previous analyses based essentially on GLC have consisted of two stages, the component phenols being determined after hydrogenation and methylation and the unsaturated constituents of each analysed by preliminary TLC separation of each component phenol followed by GLC on the methyl ethers, or mass spectrometry on the component phenols. More recently6, trimethylsilylated technical CNSL has been examined by GLC on polyethyleneglycol adipate and all the unsaturated constituents were separated_ This procedure is somewhat similar to the HPLC adsorption mode in the order of emergence of constituents. The need for derivativisation and the relatively high temperature involved, which may cause some polymerisation, particularly in the preheater of the GLC apparatus, are disadvantages of the hot method. The HPLC method, particularly, in the reversed-phase partition mode, avoids the preceding difficulties and gives a higher degree of resolution of all the constituents, although good integration equipment is necessary for all the minor constituents to be determined. A rapid method is now available for the industrial evaluation of technical CNSL in terms of the principal phenols and polymeric material and for this purpose the internal standard is not absolutely necessary_ We have examined natural CNSL and urushiol by HPLC and derivative formation in the latter case appears unnecessary. Bearing in mind the increasing numbers of phenolic lipid types being found, most of which contain some highly unsaturated constituents, there is little doubt that for their analysis HPLC is the method of choice.
3ocl ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
J. H. P. TYMAN,
V_ TYCHOPOULOS,
B. A. COLENUTT
We wish to acknowledge 3M Co., for financiai support possible, and Mr. D. Read for some technical assistance. REFERENCES
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 II i2 I3 14 15 16 17 18 19
J. H. P. Tyman, J. C/rrornurogr., 111 (1975) 285. J. H. P. Tyman. AML Chem., 48 (1976) 30. J. H. P. Tyman, J. Chromafogr., 111 (1975) 277. J. H. P. Tyman, J_ CIwonratogr_, 136 (1977) 289. J. H. P. Tyman, J. Cilromafogr., 156 (1978) 255. J. H. P. Tyman and K. H. Tam, unpublishedresults,1978J. Rooth and J. H. P. Tyman, unpublished results; B. G. K. Mm-thy and M. A. Sivasamban, unpublished results. J. H. P. Tyman and K. H. Tam, unpublished results; R. F. K. Meredith, personal communication. A. Kozubek, W. S. M. Geurts van Kesel and R. A. Demel, J_ Chronratogr., 169 (1979) 422. V. Raverdino and P. Sassetti, J. Chronzarogr., 153 (1978) 181. Y. Yamauchi, R. Oshima and J. Kumanotani, J. Chronzatogr., 198 (1980) 49. J. Fleischer, Chronmtogrup/ziu, 12 (1979) 380. J. H. P. Tyman and M. A. Kashani, unpublished results; M. A. Kashani, M. Phil. Thesis, Brunei University, Uxbridge, 1978. S. C. Goh and J. H. P. Tyman, unpublished results. J. H. P. Tyman, J. Chronrarogr., 166 (1978) 159. J. H. P. Tyman, J. Chenz. Sot., Perkin Trans. Z, (1973) 1639. J. H. P. Tyman, D. Wilczynski and M. A. Kashani, J. Amer. Oil Chem. Sot., 55 (1978) 663. A. A. Durrani and 1. H. P. Tyman, J. C/rem. Sot., Perk-in Trans. Z, (1979) 2069, 2079. J. H. P. Tyman, Chent. Sot. Rev., 8 (1979) 499; C. J. Baylis, J. H. P. Tyman and S. W. D. Odle, J. Cfienz. Sot, Perkin Trans. Z, (1981) 132.