Phillip G. Kayser-Ruins of Athens-The Curse of The Athenian Model of Education
Phillip G. Kayser-Ruins of Athens-The Curse of The Athenian Model of Education
Phillip G. Kayser-Ruins of Athens-The Curse of The Athenian Model of Education
PHILLIP G. KAYSER
Phillip G. Kayser Ruins of Athens The Curse of the Athenian Model of Education Copyright 2009, 2008 Phillip G. Kayser All Rights Reserved. Published By Biblical Blueprints 13110 Birch Dr STE 148 #370 Omaha, NE 68164-4160 (402) 934-4619 www.biblicalblueprints.org Unless otherwise noted, Scripture quotations are from the Holy Bible, New King James Version. Published by Thomas Nelson. 1994, 1982, 1980, 1979 Thomas Nelson, Inc. Used by Permission.
Ruins of Athens
The Curse of the Athenian Model of Education
Phillip G. Kayser
Contents:
Introduction ...................................................................................1 What Paul Saw...............................................................................2 Athens the most learned, civilized, philosophical, highly educated, artistic, intellectual population on the face of the globe (Ryle)...............................................................................2 Athens - a city totally given over to idols .................................3 The fruit of this idolatrous wisdom (vv. 18-21) .......................5 Lessons ......................................................................................10 What Paul Felt .............................................................................15 Indignation ................................................................................15 Compassion ...............................................................................15 Sorrow .......................................................................................15 Feeling what Lot, David, and Jesus felt ..................................16 What Paul Did .............................................................................17 He did not delay (v. 16)............................................................17 He did something (v. 17)..........................................................17 He pitted the wisdom of God against the wisdom of man (v. 17-18) ........................................................................................18 He pitted the power of Christ (the supernatural) against empty philosophy (v. 18).....................................................................18 He made an antithesis between truth and error.......................19 Closing Lessons............................................................................20 Dont be afraid to stand alone..................................................20 Do not be impressed with the philosophy, art and educational model of Athens (Classical Education)...................................20 Dont neglect the supernatural .................................................22 Dont be overwhelmed by idolatry and unbelief ....................22 You can be faithful in a pagan city..........................................23 We should pursue faithfulness to the old paths, not novelty .23
Introduction 1
Introduction
A man saw a little league baseball game going on one afternoon. He thought hed stick around and see how things were going. He walked up to the dugout and asked a boy there what the score was. The boy responded, Eighteen to nothingwere behind. Boy, said the man, Ill bet youre discouraged. Why should I be discouraged? replied the little boy. We havent even gotten to bat yet. As we come to this text in Acts 17 we know that at least Paul has gotten to bat in other cities. But he definitely has a lot to be discouraged about. For every point hes gotten on the board it seems the other team has more. But he knows that with this spiritual game the points for Christ start accelerating over time. In this city, he isnt yet up for bat. Verse 16 says, Now while Paul waited for them at Athens Paul wasnt planning to engage in ministry here. He was just waiting for the rest of his team to show up. But God had a different plan. God moved Paul to start preaching. And we are going to divide this discussion up rather simply into what Paul saw, what he felt and what he did.
2 Ruins of Athens
This was also the cradle of democracy. It was the cultural and intellectual center of Rome and it was always crowded with students and tourists. Those tourists are mentioned in verse 21. In fact, there were more students and tourists in the city than there were citizens. This was the place that attracted some of the brightest minds of the empire, so much so that one author said, the most learned, civilized, philosophical, highly educated, artistic, intellectual population on the face of the globe resided in this city.1 This could have been a very intimidating place for Paul to preach. Almost everywhere you went you found intellectuals. It was also a university city. Another author says, No other city has contributed more to the civilization of mankind than Athens. It is the place where Socrates was born, Plato, schylus, Sophocles, Euripides and many others. It is the place that humanism and democracy were born. The intellectual light that Athens created will always be alive.2 Of course, it was a pagan who wrote that and I think Jerusalem and Geneva both rivaled Athens. But it is clear that the city of Athens has had an enormous influence. To this day even Christians have been impacted with the thinking of Athens without even realizing it. The wisdom of Athens is almost seductive. So Paul saw the Athens that everyone else saw but he did not react to it the same way some Christians today do.
1 2
4 Ruins of Athens
culture. It was their idolatry. If (as Henry van Til says) culture is religion externalized, then there is a connection between this idolatry that made Paul sick and the fascinating culture of Athens. Let's examine this idolatry for a bit. It would be hard to conceive of any city having more idols than Athens. One ancient eyewitness of Athens said that you were more likely to meet a god in Athens than a man. There were 30,000 public statues erected to every conceivable god. When you add the idols in private homes, the other images of gods, the writings and music about the gods, and the streets and forums and places dedicated to gods, you can see why the ancients said that Athens was more religious than any other city. They said that it was hard to walk in some places because the street was so crowded with idols. One ancient author said that the whole city was one whole altar, one entire sacrifice and offering to the gods.3 That shows the demonic stronghold there. And then you had the people who were selling idols to the tourists. And you had eight major festivals to the principle gods and goddesses during which they were continually recommitting themselves to the gods.4 It is no exaggeration to say that the city was full of idols or as the New King James Version has it, was given over to idols. Every aspect of their life and culture was idolatrous. Their sports, their music, their philosophy, their view of family, their politics every aspect was given over to idols. And this in turn led to some rather bizarre concepts in their treatment of women, their idolatry of sports, their love of homosexuality, their strange medicine, their politics and other things we don't have time to explore. Suffice it to say, you
See John Eadie, Paul the Preacher (London: Richard Griffin and Company, 1859; republished by James Family: Minneapolis, 1979), p. 182. 4 The eight festivals were 1) festival to Athena (Minerva in Latin), 2) the festival to Apollo, 3) festival to Demeter in early fall, 4) a female only fertility festival in late fall, 5) a festival to Poseidon (Neptune in Latin), 6) a festival to the spirit of the dead, Anthesterion, 7) the festival of Dionysus (Bacchus in Latin) which was a drunken orgy, 8) a festival to Zeus (Jupiter in Latin) at the beginning of summer.
3
cannot separate the wisdom of Athens from the idols of Athens. Many Christians try, but I dont believe you can do it.
The demons behind the idols and the culture (v. 18b; 1Cor. 10:20)
One of the reasons this so troubled Paul was because of the demonic that lay behind the idols. When some say in verse 18, He seems to be a proclaimer of foreign gods, the word for gods is literally demons. They knew the reality of thousands of demons. They called these gods demons. These demons were a part of their life. Hosea 4:12 and 5:4 indicates that it wasnt simply physical idols that needed to be contended with. He speaks of the spirits behind the idols. Paul says, the things which the Gentiles sacrifice they sacrifice to demons (1Cor. 10:20). He warned the Christians that they could end up in fellowship with demons if they were not careful. They could end up being influenced by demons without even realizing it. Athens was literally swarming with demons just as it was crowded with idols which explains the poor results later in this chapter. Athens was a stronghold of the enemy. It was a pit of darkness, and Paul no doubt felt the oppression of the demonic there just like we missionaries feel it when we go into polytheistic India. I say this to give you a heads-up that when you get deeply involved in your modern Athens, dont be surprised if you get oppressed and even afflicted with demonic issues.
6 Ruins of Athens
about this is that both of those philosophies divorced religion from life and were somewhat skeptical of the gods they worshipped. The Epicureans were thoroughgoing materialists who did not believe in an afterlife, and who saw pleasure as the chief end of life. That is really the ultimate thing they worshipped. They believed that the gods were so far removed from life that they exercised no influence, but the Epicureans also encouraged worship of the gods because it gave a certain aesthetic pleasure. But man, not God was the center of their thinking. It was a thorough going humanism. So you can have all kinds of gods and still be humanistic.
pickers who are always looking for something new to listen to. The descriptions I am giving could just as easily be given of many university professors intelligent, but cynical and ready to poke holes in everything.
8 Ruins of Athens
In fact, so much of modern education is modeled after the Greeks. When God is excluded from the government classrooms, it is not an innocuous thing. It flows from this demonic culture of Athens. And even Christians have picked up this sacred/secular dichotomy. When they go to the so-called book of nature for studying evolution, sociology, psychology and other disciplines and go to the book of Scripture for church they are doing just what these philosophers did. Demons know that the human heart longs to worship, so they provide vehicles for that, but they also want to insulate the mind from seeing all of life as subject to God. So they had a secular education. These people are doubly hardened in their unbelief. They feel religious, but they are practical secularists.
quest for truth to investigate everything. Only Biblical religion was sneered at in academia, just as it is today. Why? Because Biblical truth is absolute, allows no competitors, hates syncretism and is lethal to every form of humanism.
10 Ruins of Athens
...judging, and illuminating all the statements of all men.... Therefore nothing except the divine words are to be the first principles for Christians; all human words are conclusions drawn from them and must be brought back to them and approved by them. Presuppositional thinking is the antithesis of humanism. Youve got to start somewhere, but there are really only two options: 1) Start with Gods mind (as revealed in the Bible) or 2) start with mans mind. The former is Christianity; the latter is humanism. Gods Word must be the touchstone for life.
Lessons
The need for divine revelation to guide a city
Let me summarize what Paul saw by giving some further lessons. First, we can learn the absolute need for divine revelation (what Luther spoke of as the first principles for everything, or the axioms for everything). In 1Corinthians 1:21 Paul said, The world through wisdom did not know God. This is a city in utter darkness even though it has the brightest of the bright guiding it. Brilliance alone is not enough to guide a city. It needs the revelation of the Scriptures. Unguided wisdom will never save a person. Unguided wisdom will never be enough for education, government, counsel; it will never be enough for a city or a State. America needs the guidance of the Bible. And the darkness of Athens certainly illustrates that.
The danger of thinking that you can separate the wisdom of Athens and the culture of Athens from the idolatry of Athens.
A second lesson is that there is a danger in thinking that you can separate the wisdom of Athens from the idolatry of Athens. This is what the great Roman Catholic scholar Thomas Aquinas sought to do. He tried to take the best insights of the Greek philosopher Aristotle and mix them with the Bible. Little did he
realize that it made for a syncretistic religion with terrible results. Let me just give you a couple results: Aristotles false view of money was adopted by the Roman Catholic Church and it gave rise to one of the most messed up and socialistic economic systems to ever come out of the church. Roman Catholic countries have always tended toward socialism, poverty and stagnation. Second example: Thomas Aquinas mixed the political views of the Greeks with the Bible and ended up making Roman Catholic countries centralized in politics. John Robbins has a great book that demonstrates these two results: Ecclesiastical Megalomania: the Economic and Political Thought of the Roman Catholic Church. Many other examples could be cited. Aquinas mixed the philosophy, art, historiography, astronomy and other views of Athens with the Bible and produced error. The problem that Galileo was opposing was not the Bible, but the Roman Catholic practice of taking Aristotles science as truth. The bottom line is that you cannot separate the wisdom of Athens from the idolatry of Athens. They are inseparably mixed. This is the problem that I have with most modern Classical Education. It is immersing people in the art, math, history, literature and philosophy of Athens. It is idolizing their wisdom just like the world of that day did. When Christians immerse their children in Athens, they shouldnt be surprised when their children think and act like Athenians. When you send your children to Caesar dont be surprised when they become Romans (as upwards of 80% of Christian children are becoming after they enter college). It is ultimately impossible to be totally successful in separating the demonic aspects of culture from the culture itself. The culture has got to be Christianized. As Henry Van Til said, culture is religion externalized. You ought to memorize that phrase. Another way of saying this is that culture is worldview
12 Ruins of Athens
made tangible. We need a radically Christian culture, not a Christianized version of the Athenian culture. I know that there are many godly Christians who disagree with me on this, but I ask you to look at the fruits of Classical Education over a long period of time. We cant keep doing the same thing and expect different results. The Puritans were godly peopleI admire them greatly. But they lost their children over this very issue. They were trying to mix the educational philosophy of Athens with the theology of the Bible. Im telling you that the implications of Classical Education down the road are not good. I have seen it in history over the generations, and I have seen it in graduates of current schools and home schools. Some will object that they know many people who have gotten a secular education and/or a classical education that is mixed with Christianity, and they have turned out fine. Let me quote Robert L. Dabneys response to this viewpoint. "Christianity must be a present element of all the training at all times, or else it is not true and valuable education. Some one may say that this broad proposition is refuted at the outset by frequent instances of persons who received, at least during a part of their youth, a training perfectly nonChristian, and who yet are very useful, and even Christian citizens. The answer is easy: It is the prerogative of a merciful Providence, and the duty of His children to repair the defects and misfortunes of His creatures and to bring good out of evil. But surely this comes far short of a justification for us if we willingly employ faulty methods which have a regular tendency to work evil. Surely it is not our privilege to make mischief for God and good Christians to repair!"5
Robert L. Dabney, The State Free School System, in Discussions, vol. IV (Harrisonburg, VA: Sprinkle Publications, 1979), p. 220.
5
14 Ruins of Athens
more computers, train teachers more scientifically There is no end to the optimism modern men have in science and technology. But what Paul saw did not impress him as being the solution. To Paul, the only solution was the kingdom and the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ. That summarizes what Paul saw. He saw a city in desperate need and they did not know it. They were blind in their wisdom.
Compassion
There was a second emotion we see in Paul compassion. It can be seen in his preaching to Jew and Gentile alike in the public square. It can be seen in his sermon on Mars Hill. It can be seen in Pauls attempts to free these men from their bondage to Satan and to see them brought into the kingdom of Gods love.
Sorrow
J.C. Ryle says there is one other emotion that is hinted at sorrow. One dictionary says that this word for provoked has implied in it a deep concern. Paul was sickened and saddened by what he saw. It moved him to see hands capable of such excellent work being used to oppose God. It grieved him.
16 Ruins of Athens
18 Ruins of Athens
He pitted the wisdom of God against the wisdom of man (v. 17-18)
Thirdly, Paul pitted the wisdom of God against the wisdom of man. He didnt just push his way around. He didnt take clubs and knock the heads off of idols. He knew he had to start with the minds of men because this was the gateway into their souls. So verse 17 says that he reasoned and he didnt reason evidentially. He reasoned from the Scriptures. Verse 18 says, because he preached to them Jesus and the resurrection. Paul was arguing presuppositionally. He knew that they would reject that, and in his later speech he demolishes their arguments by a transcendental argument by arguing the impossibility of the opposite. If His message of the Gospel is rejected, then they dont have an intellectual leg to stand on. We will look at that at a later time. But he starts pitting Gods good reasoning against their foolish reasoning and he knows they are thinking the opposite to be true that the Gospel is foolish. 1Corinthians 1:23 says, but we preach Christ crucified, to the Jews a stumbling block and to the Greeks foolishness. He knew that it would sound foolish, but he gives it anyway. Why?
He pitted the power of Christ (the supernatural) against empty philosophy (v. 18)
Well, this point gives part of the answer: the Gospel is the power of God unto salvation. It works even when people initially reject it. So Paul pits the power of Christ (as seen in the resurrection) against the emptiness of their speculative philosophies. Their philosophies could not rescue anyone from drunkenness. In fact, if a person wanted to get drunk, he would turn to Dionysius. If he wanted to indulge his lusts, he would turn to Aphrodite. If he wanted to steal, he had Hermes on his side. These gods could help people to sin, but could never rescue people from their sins. They could bring death, but they could never bring life from death. Pauls message of Jesus and the resurrection speaks of a power that went way beyond their religion.
20 Ruins of Athens
Closing Lessons
Dont be afraid to stand alone
Let me conclude with six more lessons. First, dont be afraid to stand alone. Paul felt all alone in a pagan city, but he stood his ground for the glory of God. Where would we be today if Athanasius had not stood alone in the fourth century in defense of the Trinity? Where would we be today if Luther had not stood alone against the Emperor on the issue of indulgences? Where would we be if people had not stood alone at the stake because they cared for Gods glory? Where would Naaman have been if the little maid in Syria had been ashamed of her strange faith and had not stood alone and given her mistress the only solution to Naaman's leprosy the God of Israel? We must be willing to stand alone.
Do not be impressed with the philosophy, art and educational model of Athens (Classical Education)
A second admonition that I would give to you is that we really shouldnt be impressed with the philosophy of Athens, or the art of Athens, or the educational model of Athens that has become Americas model.6 The citizens of Athens were taught how to read, write, understand math, science, arts, philosophy and literature in a purely academic way without any reference to God. Their approach rips out the two biggest foundations of Hebrew education that education must lead to godly application and that all of education must be grounded in Gods Word and bring glory to God. Our government schools teach
Paul was certainly not impressed. As Matthew Henry says, A scholar that has acquaintance, and is in love, with the learning of the ancients, would think he should be very happy if he were where Paul now was, at Athens, in the midst of the various sects of philosophers, and would have a great many curious questions to ask them, for the explication of the remains we have of the Athenian learning; but Paul, though bred a scholar, and an ingenious active man, does not make this any of his business at Athens
6
Closing Lessons 21
people how to read, write, understand math, science, the arts, philosophy and literature without any reference to God and the Bible whatsoever. This means that it is a godless education. God is taken out of everything. Robert L. Dabney said that to have education without Christ is like reading Shakespeares Hamlet play without Hamlet. He went on to say The comparison of these truths will make it perfectly plain that a non-Christian training is literally an anti Christian training.7 I am very desirous of ending all government education because without Christian education, America will never be restored. It will continue to raise up godless generation after godless generation with the increasing fruits of Athens. Read the horrible lifestyle of Athens and you will begin to understand why America has increasing violence, homosexuality, pedophilia, debauchery of every form, cheating, clogged courts, and the host of other problems present in ancient Greece. You cannot follow the educational model of Greece without seeing some of the results of Greece in our own land. The Puritan writer, Matthew Henry said, And this city [Athens], after the empire became Christian, continued incurably addicted to idolatry, and all the pious edicts of the Christian emperors could not root it out, till, by the irruption of the Goths, that city was in so particular a manner laid waste that there are now scarcely any remains of it. It is observable that there, where human learning most flourished, idolatry most abounded, and the most absurd and ridiculous idolatry, which confirms that of the apostle, that when they professed themselves to be wise they became fools (Rom. 1:22), and, in the business of religion, were of all other the most vain in their imaginations. The world by wisdom knew not God, 1Cor. 1:21. They might have reasoned against polytheism and idolatry; but, it seems, the
Robert L. Dabney, Secularized Education, in Discussions, vol. IV (Harrisonburg, VA: Sprinkle Publications, 1979), p. 238.
7
22 Ruins of Athens
greatest pretenders to reason were the greatest slaves to idols: so necessary was it to the re-establishing even of natural religion that there should be a divine revelation, and that centering in Christ.8 Matthew Henry was saying that without a restoration of the Bible as the foundation of learning and without making Christ the heart of our education, we will never be able to reform a society. Despite all the attempts of Christian emperors to convert Athens, they were unsuccessful. The most important issue was neglected that of education. Matthew Henry understood this. Modern Christians do not seem to.
Matthew Henry, Matthew Henrys Commentary, vol. VI (Old Tappan, NJ: Fleming H. Revell Company, [nd]), p.
8
Closing Lessons 23
Ruins of At hens
The Curse of the Athenian Model of Education
Phi ll ip G. Ka yser
n this study of Acts 17 we see how Scripture, and in this case Paul, confronts worldly systems of education. Let us all feel and act as Paul did to shine the light of the Gospel into this critical area of society.
Phillip Kayser is the Senior Pastor of Dominion Covenant Church in Omaha, NE. He holds a M.Div. from Westminster Theological Seminary (California) and a Ph.D. from Whitefield Theological Seminary (Florida). He and his wife Kathy have 5 children.
Biblical Blueprints
Living By Gods Design
Omaha, NE www.biblicalblueprints.org