Islamibank Bangladesh Limited
Islamibank Bangladesh Limited
Islamibank Bangladesh Limited
Introduction
1.0 Introduction
For an expanding economy, a developed and efficient banking system is indispensable. Among others, it helps transfer of financial resources from surplus units to deficit units and, hence, helps accelerate the pace of development by securing uninterrupted supply of financial resources to people engaged in numerous economic activities. The tremendous development that the world economy has experienced in the last few decades was contrib-uted by several factors among which, growing institutional supply of loan able funds must have played the pivotal role. The role of banking is comparable to what an artery system does in the human body. Both commercial banks and other development financial institutions provide short-, medium-, and long-term credits to businesspersons and entrepreneurs who usually take the lead in ventures of economic development. Islamic banking has been defined in a number of ways. The definition of Islamic bank, as approved by the General Secretariat of the OIC, is stated in the following manner. "An Islamic bank is a financial institution whose status, rules and procedures expressly state its commitment to the principle of Islamic Shariah and to the banning of the receipt and payment of interest on any of its operations"(Ali & Sarkar 1995, pp.20-25). Shawki Ismail Shehta viewing the concept from the perspective of an Islamic economy and the prospective role to be played by an Islamic bank therein opines: "It is, therefore, natural and, indeed, imperative for an Islamic bank to incorporate in its functions and practices commercial investment and social activities, as an institution designed to promote the civilized mission of an Islamic economy" (Ibid). Ziauddin Ahmed says, "Islamic banking is essentially a normative concept and could be defined as conduct of banking in consonance with the ethos of the value system of Islam" (Ibid). Now a day, a modern banker must have to perform a number of ancillary services, besides performing the two essential functions of accepting deposits and investing its funds. Remittance of funds can be considered as one of the most important ancillary service provided by a Bank. With a network of the branches spread over the entire country banks are eminently suitable institutions for the remittance of funds from one place to another. Bank remittance is safe, swift, inexpensive, and simple. Bank takes the risk of theft or loss of customers money in exchange of a very little commission. Again, 2
the reserve of foreign remittance plays a great role in national economy. With various types of accounts maintaining in international branches and coordinating international banks these foreign currencies are being carried sending by non-resident Bangladeshis.
major subject is Marketing. For that consequence, WE choose the banking sector for performing our internship and the organization is the IBBL. Our research topic is Customer Satisfaction in Remittance division of IBBL, Uttara branch.
1.3 Objectives
The objective of the study is to measure the consumer satisfaction in Remittance division of IBBL, Uttara branch.
view to measure their level of satisfaction Weve interviewed 40 account holders of IBBL having different profession & who lies in different age group. The interviews have been conducted using a structured questionnaire containing 10 questions representing the five dimensions of customer satisfaction measurement. A sample
questionnaire has been annexed in the appendix part.
b. External Sources
Published literatures Journals & Newspapers Consultation of related books & publications. Website Surfing Consultation of related books & publications.
1.6.1 Population:
The population of the research paper is all the clients who are getting service from IBBL in remittance division. Our population of this research is the IBBL, Uttara branch remittance clients and the clients are 3600 (approximate).
1.6.2 Element:
The sampling element of the research paper is each who is getting the service of remittance from IBBL Uttara branch.
1.6.4 Extent:
The extent of a research paper is the area, which the paper covers to fulfill the objectives. Here it is IBBLs projects.
Chapter Two
Organizational Overview
government bodies of the middle East and Europe including IDB and two eminent personalities of the kingdom of Saudi Arabia joined hands to made the dream a reality. Later, other Islami Banks, Islami Insurance Companies and Financial Institution were established in the country. Some traditional banks opened Islamic banking branches in some major cities.
2.1 Mission and Vision of IBBL Mission To establish Islamic Banking through the introduction of a welfare oriented banking system and also ensure equity and justice in the field of all economic activities, achieve balanced growth and equitable development through diversified investment operations particularly in the priority sectors and less developed areas of the country. To encourage socio-economic uplift and financial services to the low-income community particularly in the rural areas.
Vision Our vision is to always strive to achieve superior financial performance, be considered a leading Islamic Bank by reputation and performance. Our goal is to establish and maintain the modern banking techniques, to ensure the soundness and development of the financial system based on Islamic principles and to become the strong and efficient organization with highly motivated professionals, working for the benefit of people, based upon accountability, transparency and integrity in order to ensure stability of financial systems. We will try to encourage savings in the form of direct investment. We will also try to encourage investment particularly in projects which are more likely to lead to higher employment.
10
11
12
2.5 Commitments
To Shariah To the Regulators To the Shareholders To the Community To the Customers To the Employees To other stakeholders To Environment
13
South Asian Federation of Accountants (SAFA) awarded IBBL as joint Winner in the Corporate Governance Disclosure Award-2010. South Asian Federation of Accountants (SAFA) also awarded IBBL with Certificate of Merit in Banking Sector in the Annual Report for the year 2010. The Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Bangladesh (ICMAB), awarded IBBL as the ICMAB National Best Corporate Award-2007 (First Position, Local Bank) and ICMAB Best Corporate Performance Award 2008 (Second Position, Private Commercial Bank). The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Bangladesh (ICAB) awarded IBBL with 3rd position under the catergory-1, Banking in the best published accounts and reports for the year 2010, the Certificate of Appreciation for the year 2001 & 2010 and Certificate of Merit for the year 2008. The Global Finance, a reputed U.S.A. based quarterly Financial Magazine, awarded IBBL as the best Islamic Financial Institution of the country for the years 2008, 2009, 2010 & 2011. The Global Finance also awarded IBBL as the best bank of the country for the year 1999, 2000, 2004 and 2005. ICICI Bank, Hong Kong, awarded IBBL as The Quality Recognition Award-2009 for U.S. Dollar Clearing (2009). Bankers Forum awarded IBBL as the Best Bank for Corporate Social Responsibility for 2008 and 2009. The Bank-BimaPatrika, a Fortnightly Magazine, awarded IBBL as the Best Islami Banking Award 2007. Exclusive economic weekly The Industry awarded IBBL as the Best Rated Bank Award-2010 The Citi Bank NA awarded IBBL as the Largest Contributor in Foreign Trade Operations in Europe- Bangladesh corridor in 2009. The UAE Exchange awarded IBBL for mobilizing around 30% of total foreign remittance of the country. IBBL is committed to provide banking service that is purely based on Islamic Shariah, transparent and efficient. We would like to express our heartfelt thanks and gratitude to
14
Almighty Allah, our customers, patrons, shareholders, print & electronic media, regulatory authorities and employees whose support and confidence has made us worthy of these great recognitions by the experts like the Global Finance, the Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Bangladesh (ICMAB), the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Bangladesh (ICAB), the Bank-BimaPatrika, the weekly Industry, The Citi Bank NA and The UAE Exchange.
Date of Incorporation Inauguration of 1st Branch (Local office, Dhaka) Formal Inauguration Share of Capital Local Shareholders Foreign Shareholders Authorized Capital Paid-up Capital Deposits Investment (including Investment in Shares)
36.91% 63.09% Tk. 20,000.00 million TK 12,509.64 Million Tk. 417,844.14 Million Tk. 399,930.80 Million
15
Foreign Exchange Business: Import Export Remittance Branches Total number of Branches Number of AD Branches Number of ATM Booth (Own) Number of Shareholders Manpower 285 45 300 60,302, 11,465 Tk. 284,587 Million Tk. 197,095 Million TK 300,915 Million
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
Important Duties of the Shariah Board As an expert source on Islamic Principles (Including Fatwas), the Board through a representative, usually the General Secretary of the Board, supervises the Shariah compliance of all the transactions in the Bank. To devote time and effort to devising more Shariah -compliant transactional procedures, templates and banking products that enable the Bank to adapt to market trends while maintaining a high competitive edge in deposit procedures, investments, and banking services. At the same time, the Board gives its opinion on proposed new templates, and banking transactions. Analyzing unprecedented situations that are not covered by fatwa, in the Bank's transactional procedures or those reported by different departments, branches and even the customers. This is to ensure Shariah compliance before the Bank develops any new products or implements any new procedure. Analyzing contracts and agreements concerning the Bank's transactions, as submitted by the Chairman of the Board of Directors or any department/branch within the bank or requested by the Board itself so that Shariah compliance can be evaluated and maintained. Ensuring Shariah compliance in the implementation of all banking transactions and correcting any breaches. Analyzing administrative decisions, issues and matters that require the Board's approval. Supervising Shariah training programmes for the Bank's staff. Preparing an annual report in the Bank's balance sheet with respect to its Shariah compliance. The Fatwa & Shariah Supervision Board submits a complete annual report for the Board of Director, summarizing all the issues referred to the Board, as well as its opinion on the Bank's transactional procedures.
23
24
Investment
The special feature of the Investment Policy of the Bank is to invest on the basis of profit-loss sharing system in accordance with the tenets and principles of Islamic Shari'ah. Earning of profit is not the only motive and objective of the Bank's Investment Policy rather emphasis is given in attaining social goal and objective in creating employment opportunities. Following modes are used for investment: BAI-MODES Bai-Murabaha Bai-Istijrar Bai-Muajjal Bai Salam Istisnaa Bai-As-Sarf SHARE-MODES Mudaraba Musharaka IJARA-MODES Hire Purchase Under ShirkatulMelk Under consumer financing, the Bank finances to the individuals for meeting their personal. family and household needs. The Bank has taken up various welfare oriented investment Schemes Investment Scheme Household Durables Scheme (HDS) Investment Scheme for Doctors (ISD) Transport Investment Scheme (TIS) Car Investment Scheme (CIS) Small Business Investment Scheme (SBIS) Micro Industries Investment Scheme (MIIS) Agricultural Implement Investment Scheme (AIIS)
25
Real Estate Investment Program (REIP) Real Estate Investment (Commercial & Working Capital) Agricultural Investment of IBBL NRB (Non Resident Bangladeshi) Entrepreneurs Investment Scheme(NEIS) Women Entrepreneurs Investment Scheme (WEIS)
SME Information
Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited has been working since 1983 in the view to establish a welfare oriented Islami Banking system and also to ensure equity and justice in the field of all economic activities, achieve balanced growth and equitable development through diversified investment operations particularly in the priority sectors and less developed areas of the country and to encourage socio-economic uplift and financial services to the low income community, particularly in the rural areas. Since inception of the Bank, it has been giving priority in financing SMEs. Formation of SME Division The Board in its emergent meeting held on 02.11.2005 approved a memo bearing No. 2005/155 with the following resolution: Resolved that the investment in Small Enterprise shall be made in accordance with the terms and conditions contained in the Annexed Comprehensive Small Enterprise Investment Policy and SME Division under Investment Wing shall be established with necessary restructuring and duly manning with adequate officials as proposed. In order to emphasize SME investment, to run its SME functions smoothly and to strengthen the SME activities of the bank, it has created a separate Division namely Small and Medium Enterprise Division in 2009. Specialized SME Branches
26
As per guideline and regulation of Bangladesh Bank, the Board of Directors of the Bank has selected a good number of SME prone areas, where Specialized SME/Agriculture Branches are being opening in order to facilitate the potential entrepreneurs in accessing to the finance from Shariah based banking sector. So far 30 nos. of such Specialized SME Branches have been opened and more such Branches shall be opened at the SME prone areas by order.
Locker Service
Our safe deposit locker service offered from select branches gives you a completely secured facility for safekeeping of precious items, confidential documents and other valuables. Services Personalised service Facilities to access outside scheduled time Parcel handling Safe custody of goods and bonds/shares Lockers available in various sizes. we.e. Small, Medium and Large. Locker Service Available Head Office Complex Branch Farmgate Branch New market Branch Kawran Bazar Branch Sylhet Branch Rajshai Branch Elephant Road Cox's Bazar Anderkilla Branch Chiringa Branch Gulshan Branch Dhanmondi Branch Uttara Branch VIP Road Branch Khulna Branch Agrabad Branch Chawkbazar Mouchak CDA Avenue Branch Feni Branch
27
28
Send to :6969 (for local clients) +8801714006969 (for international clients) Charges Till now, no charges required except the normal sms service charge. For more information please contact to your nearest branch or see the Rules and regulation given overleaf of the SMS Banking Regitration Form.
ATM Service
IBBL has introduced its ATM Banking service since 2000. Being the largest in online connectivity among the branches we are capable of providing the better customer service to our clints. Services Cash Withdraw Fund Transfer Mini Account Statement Balance Inquiry Transaction Limit For Cash Withdrawal maximum amount is Tk. 50,000 in a calendar date. Charges Tk.300 Yearly fees is applicable.
29
Despite making significant improvements in all the areas relating to financial viability, profitability, innovation and competitiveness, there are concerns that banks have not been able to include vast segment of the population, especially the underprivileged sections and rural people into the fold of basic banking services. On the other hand, rapid growth of mobile phone users and wider range of the coverage of Mobile Network Operators (MNOs) has made their delivery channel an important tool of the trade for extending banking services to the unbanked/banked population. In order to ensure the access of unbanked people by taking advantage of countrywide mobile network coverage, Bangladesh Bank given the permission to start the mobile banking operation for adoption of the unbanked people who have mobile connection. Now, Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited proudly starting the Mobile Financial Services titled Islami Bank mCash which is the completely new addition to its existing services.
SWIFT Service
Society for Worldwide Inter-Bank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT) is a bank owned co-operative serving the financial community worldwide. The SWIFT Transport Network (STN) is a dedicated global network for secure communication between SWIFT Customers. SWIFT supports the financial data communication and processing needs of financial institutions, through a range of financial messaging services and value-added processing, as well as, access through the STN and interface and application software. In short SWIFT is a pioneer in the automation of the global financial industries. Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited has introduced this SWIFT alliance entry system firstly in October 1999 and introduced SWIFT alliance access in October 2001.
Services Personalised service Facilities to access outside scheduled time Parcel handling
30
Safe custody of goods and bonds/shares Lockers available in various sizes.we.e. Small, Medium and Large.
Features: An unique Banking service that driven by IslamiShariyah. 24 hours/day, 7days/week and 365 days/year banking facilities. Clients need not go to branches for availing services. Clients can avail services from all over the world with Bangladesh. Runs with latest technology to ensure highest standard of security. Customers can transact their money in different way by own self except cash transaction. Providing Automated services to the present and future clients from Bank. Customer can avail this service form any Mobile/PSTN provider.
Phone Banking Services: Fund Transfer Check account Balance Check Mini Statement Mobile Recharge Utilities Bill Payment Request for T-pin and Change
31
Registration Procedures for Phone Banking Service: There are two ways to Phone Banking Registration. Clients can register to this service from their nearby IBBL Branch By dialing 16259 or (+8802) 8331090 client can register to this service by our Customer Care Agent TPin Related Information: After successful registration client will be provided a four digits secured TPIN (Telephone personal Identification Number). This TPIN will provide sufficient security for the client and will be needed for every operation all time. Thus this number has to be preserved carefully and maintained with secrecy. Client can change TPIN anytime at will.
32
Fund Transfer: To make Fund Transfer more secured client will be provided an OTP (One Time Password) which will be valid for only 30 minutes. Daily fund transfer limit is BDT 20000 Only. Phone Banking Service Charges: Mobile Recharge :Free A/C balance check: Free Mini-statement check: Free Fund Transfer: BDT 5.00/ Transaction How Safe Phone Banking: Phone banking is totally a safe and secured system where, client has been provided a 4 Digits Pin code that none but him can be disclosed. However, in case of fund transfer client will receive another OTP (One Time Password) by SMS without what fund transfer can not be done. Risks of cash transaction is reduced by this way.
33
Board of Directors, Chairman and CEO: The members of the Board of Directors of IBBL are appointed pursuant to the provision of Companies Act 1994, Securities and Exchange Regulations and Memorandum & Articles of Association of the Bank. The Guidelines of Bangladesh Bank is strictly complied with in the formation of the Board. Independent Directors and Depositor Directors are appointed by the Board as per regulatory requirement.
Audit Committee: The Audit Committee is responsible to the Board of Directors. The duties of the Audit Committee are clearly set forth in writing. The Company Secretary acts as the secretary of the Committee. At least an independent director is required to fulfil the quorum of the audit committee.
Ethics and Compliance: The Bank pays close attention to the moral concerns in order to make the right ethical decisions on a day to day basis over and above observing the law, one of the basic professional requirements for the Bank. IBBL belives that upholding of critical interest to the customers, employees, regulators alike to the Bank itself as secured, reliable and efficient banking system is one of the pillars of economic stability of any country.
34
Human Resources Development and Management: In order to keep pace with the additional human resources requirement and to enhance the employment opportunity in the country, periodic recruitment is done as per need of the Bank. In the year 2012, total 1,152 employees wererecruited and after this recruitment total number of employees of the Bank increased to 12,188 including 407 female officials as on 31st December 2012 against 11,465 including 216 female officials as on 31st December 2011. IBBLs Human Resources Management always believes to look at the man behind the machine because only an educated, talented and skilled employee can ensure the highest yield from the machine and hence the Bank always strives to develop skills and competencies at all levels of the employees.
Risk Management: As per guidelines of Bangladesh Bank, The Risk Management Wing (RMW) has been established in IBBL, which is responsible for identification and management of risks faced by the Bank. The details of our internal and external risk management mechanism is included in a separate section titled Risk Management of IBBL and steps have been taken to manage risks.
35
36
farmers, working women, professionals, education loan to the students, housing loans, and consumer loans. Even customers life style, their behavior, and consumption patterns have changed which acted as an opportunity as well as a threat for Banking Industry. Technological Factor: Development in technology has encouraged the bankers to change the concept of Branch Banking to Anywhere Banking. Information Technology (IT) usage remained a key lever in the journey of Indian Banking Sector towards a competent, effective, responsive and user-friendly financial system. Technology brought devices like automatic voice recorders and currency accounting machines. Banks are also issuing smartcards or debit cards also called as electronic purse. Technological changes had forced bankers to adopt customer-based approach instead of product-based approach. The Foreign Banks operating in India made the beginning with respect to technology innovation and new Private Sector Banks aggressively started proposing technology based services. However, Public Sector Banks has also moved towards technology execution to prevent loss of market share.
38
Advertisement: Advertisements of various types and length were published in print & electronic media round the year. Around 113 official advertisements including financial statement, balance sheet, AGM notice, tender and recruitment notice; and 162 promotional advertisements like branch opening and ATM, months long campaign programs, product advertisement and on occasions of newspapers & TV channels founding anniversary were publicized. About 486 issues of different magazine, periodicals, and souvenirs published our advertisements on different products and themes. Design of different Advertisement of the Bank was improved.
39
Sponsorship & Participation: The Bank earned huge publicity in the year 2012 sponsoring the National School Football Islami Bank Tournament, an event unprecedented in the countrys grass root sport history. About 5,000 school teams comprising one lakh students from all over the country participated in the tournament held in 480 upazilas. Positive image of the Bank was created among the schoolmen, parents andsport enthusiasts. During the year, the Bank sponsored East Zone Team in the first time franchisee-based longer version national cricket tournament namely Bangladesh Cricket League.
40
Other Publicity: The Bank continued road side publicity withbillboards at Banglamotor, Ruposhi Bangla point, Gulishthan, Bangabhavan gate, Matijheel Shapla Chattar and Bijoy Sarani. Digital board displays were arranged on the occasion of differentnational programs and fairs. The Bank sponsored Kamalapur to Rajarbag road-median beautification program by color showy and herbal plants. A number of quality documentaries were made on theBanks performance and its CSR activities were displayed on rious Bank programs across the country.
Public & Media Relations: During the year the Bank devised a slogan Sholo Koti Manusher Kache Jai, Amader Desh Amra Sajai and observed two multi purpose campaign programs namely Setubandhoner 100 Din & Antorik Sebar 3 mas. A number of public programs including discussion seminar, clients meeting, NRB get together, peoples representative & elite assembly, Shari`ah conscious meeting, professionals assembly, entrepreneur
development program etc. were organized across all the branches on the occasion. Through these programs, the Bank was able to fulfill its aim of proving itself as a transparent, accountable and benevolent financial entity in this country. The Bank also arranged reception program for Bangladesh Cricket Board President Mr. AHM Mostafa 41
Kamal MP for assuming his responsibilities as ICC Vice President. With a view to consolide good relations with the media, a good number of bilateral and person-to-person meetings between\ the top management of the Bank with Editors, Senior Journalists and Reporters from prominent print and electronic media were arranged.
Publications: Publications of the Bank increased remarkably in 2012 in addition to witnessing qualitative change. All the publications were updated in standard form. Publications of periodicals were regularized. Five books, booklets and manuals were published in the year including Islamic Banking in Bangladesh: An Alternative Paradigm for Sustainable Socioeconomic Development and updated `Islami Bank: 30 Years of Progress. Four issues each for Islami Bank house-magazine Porikroma and RDS magazine Palli Unnayon Barta were published. Twelve folders were published in modified version and these were also reprinted.
42
Responsibility to the Employees Responsibility to the Customers Responsibility to the Suppliers Responsibility to the Community
43
IBBL Chairman is handing over Winter Cloths to Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina for Prime Ministers Relief Fund
44
Chapter Three
45
46
Issuance of FDD,FTT& purchasing, payment of the same Passport endorsement Encashment Certificate F/C Account opening & filing Opening of Export FC Retention Quota A/C & maintain Maintenance of ledger of Cash Dollar, FC Deposit A/C & TC Maintain FBC register & follow up FBC Opening of Student file & maintain Preparation of all related statement, Voucher & posting Preparation of Weekly, Monthly, Yearly Statement for Bangladesh Bank returns timely.
47
48
corresponding VOSTRO Account. Foreign Demand Draft Bank issue Demand Draft in favor of purchaser or any other according to instruction of purchaser. The payee can collect it for the drawee bank in which the Issuing bank of Demand Draft holds its NOSTRO Account.
3.3 The process of remittance, bank must have to make profit as a business institution. Profit is made in two ways:
1. Commission Charge 2. Difference in the buying and selling rate. Remittance of profits: Branches of foreign firms/companies including foreign banks, insurance companies and financial institutions are free to remit their post-tax profits to their head offices through banks authorized to deal in foreign exchange (Authorized Dealers) without prior approval of Bangladesh Bank. Remittance of dividend/capital gain: Prior permission of Bangladesh Bank is not required for remittance of dividend income to non-residents in respect to their investments in Bangladesh; remittance of dividend declared out of previous year's accumulated reserves; and dividend and sale proceeds (including capital gains) of shares of companies listed in a Stock Exchange in Bangladesh. Such remittance may be affected prior to actual payment of taxes provided that the amount payable to the tax authorities at the applicable tax rate is withheld by the company. Remittance of sale proceeds of shares of companies not listed in Stock Exchange requires prior Bangladesh Bank permission, which is accorded for amounts not exceeding the net asset values of the shares. Remittance of salaries and savings by expatriates: Expatriates working in Bangladesh with the approval of the Government may remit 49
through an Authorized Dealer (AD) 50% of salary and 100% of leave salary as also actual savings and admissible pension benefits. No prior Bangladesh Bank approval is necessary for such remittances. Remittance of royalty/technical fees: Industrial enterprises may enter into agreements for payment of royalties, technical know-how/technical assistance fees abroad without prior permission if the total fees and other expenses connected with technology transfer do not exceed (a) 6% of the previous years sales of the enterprises as declared in their tax returns, or (b) 6% of the cost of imported machinery in the case of new projects. These agreements, however, need to be registered with the Board of Investment (BOI). Agreements not in conformity with these general guidelines require prior permission of the BOI. ADs may remit the royalties, technical know-how/technical assistance fees payable as per agreements registered with/approved by BOI, without prior approval of Bangladesh Bank. Remittance on account of training and consultancy: Industrial enterprises producing for the local market may remit through ADs up to 1% of their sales as declared in their previous year's tax returns for the purpose of training and consultancy services without prior approval of Bangladesh Bank. Remittance by shipping lines, airlines, courier service companies: Foreign shipping lines, airlines and courier service companies may send abroad, through an AD, funds collected in Bangladesh towards freight and passage, after adjustment of local costs and taxes, if any.
50
AE exchange Prabha Merchant Trade EzRemit of Bahrain exchange Habib Express of HabibQater International exchange Company May back Turbo Cash of Zenj exchange NBL Quick Pay Cash Express of Al Ansari exchange Est. Ceylinco Fast Cash of Seylon Bank Ltd Remit Master And some other houses E-Mail based SpotCash: E-Mail based SpotCash Arrangements with 33 (thirty three) Banks / Exchange House s.
Balance inquery from SMS or iBanking Service. Transaction Limit For Cash Withdrawal from ATM booth maximum amount is Tk. 50,000 in a calendar date. Any number of amount from bank counter. Charges No charges is applicable.
53
Chapter Four
54
4.0 Introduction
Superior service quality is widely acknowledged as a driver of perceived value, which, in turn, will enhance customer loyalty (Parasuraman and Grewal, 2000) and improve the providers image, sales and profitability (Buzzell and Gale, 1987; Gummesson, 1993). Because satisfaction is basically a psychological state, care should be taken in the effort of quantitative measurement, although a large quantity of research in this area has recently been developed. Work done by Berry, Brodeur between 1990 and 1998 defined ten 'Quality Values' which influence satisfaction behavior, further expanded by Berry in 2002 and known as the ten domains of satisfaction. These ten domains of satisfaction include: Quality, Value, Timeliness, Efficiency, Ease of Access, Environment, Interdepartmental Teamwork, Front line Service Behaviors, Commitment to the Customer and Innovation. These factors are emphasized for continuous improvement and organizational change measurement and are most often utilized to develop the architecture for satisfaction measurement as an integrated model. Work done by Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry between 1985 and 1988 provides the basis for the measurement of customer satisfaction with a service by using the gap between the customer's expectation of performance and their perceived experience of performance. This provides the measurer with a satisfaction "gap" which is objective and quantitative in nature. Work done by Cronin and Taylor propose the "confirmation/disconfirmation" theory of combining the "gap" described by Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry as two different measures (perception and expectation of performance) into a single measurement of performance according to expectation. According to Garbrand, customer satisfaction equals perception of performance divided by expectation of performance.
55
56
57
58
satisfaction with the CSA and the Islamic financial institution should not be necessarily expected. Taking this matter into account, we some times see that in a service context the CSA and the selling Islamic financial institution or banks products are often indistinguishable in the mind of the customer. Hence, a positive association exist between core service and level of customer satisfaction with an Islamic financial institution.
4.5.2 High Level Customer Satisfaction (H2) Leads to Trust (H3) and Loyalt y (H4)
Research in services marketing has widely shown that customer satisfaction leads to customer loyalty. For instance, in the mainstream literate on marketing, there are many examples that whether customers had replaced their insurance policies or allowed them to lapse depended on their prior satisfaction with the whole life coverage. Similarly, the core-service satisfaction is positively associated with repurchase intentions. Furthermore, customer satisfaction with Islamic financial institutions has a significant and positive effect on loyalty. A few literature on customers of Islamic financial service industries provide evidence of the positive influence of customer satisfaction both with the Islamic financial institution as service provider and the core service on customer intention to use the facilitys services again, and recommend the service to a friend.
institution or detract from its reputation and ultimately destroy trust. Figure 1 suggest that Islamic ethical sales practices, as perceived by Islamic financial service customers have increased customers trust (H3) in CSAs.
60
61
6. Anticipate Your Clients Needs & Go out Of Your Way to Help Them Out 7. Honor Your Promises Customer service, like any aspect of business, is a practiced art that takes time and effort to master. All you need to do to achieve this is to stop and switch roles with the customer.
62
63
widely accepted as the most important measure for gauging the financial stability of a bank.
South Asian Federation of Accountants (SAFA): South Asian Federation of Accountants (SAFA) rewarded IBBL as Winner of the SAARC Anniversary Award for Corporate Governance Disclosures for the year 2011. SAFA awarded IBBL also with the 1st Runner up title under Private Sector Banks (including Co-operative Banks) in the best presented annual reports for the year 2011. SAFA declared IBBL as the Joint Winner in the Corporate Governance Disclosure Award-2010. SAFA also conferred IBBL the Certificate of Merit in Banking Sector in the Best Presented Accounts & Reports Award for the year 2010.
Institute of Chartered Accountants of Bangladesh (ICAB): The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Bangladesh (ICAB) conferred IBBL with the 1st position under SAARC Anniversary Award for Corporate Governance for the year 2011. ICAB also conferred IBBL the 3rd position under banking category in the Best Presented Annual Reports 2011 & 2010.
Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Bangladesh (ICMAB): The Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Bangladesh (ICMAB) glorified IBBL with the ICMAB National Best Corporate Award-2011, 2010 (First Position amongst the Private Commercial Banks in Islamic Operation), ICMAB Best Corporate Performance Award2008 (Second Position amongst the Private Commercial Banks) and the ICMAB National Best Corporate Award-2007 (First position among the Local Banks).
65
despite of having many new banks and branches, Ialami Bank Bangladesh Ltd. could increase the market share.
Sector wise Investment: Industrial 29% SME 47% Commercial 11% Real Estate 5% Agriculture 6% Transport 2%
Market Share (Remittance) Year Market Share (Percentage) 2012 28% 2011 27% 2010 26% 2009 22% 2008 19%
67
Figure 2-2: Market Share Remittance of IBBL Import, Export & Remittance Performance: Sector 2012 mill Tk Import Export Remittance 284,588 197,095 300,915 2011 million Tk 301,207 178,244 236,607 2010 million Tk 246,281 148,421 214,629 2009 million Tk 161,230 106,424 194,716 2008 million Tk 168,329 93,962 140,168
68
Figure: 2-5: Import, Export & Remittance Performance of IBBL 2.5.5.3 Net Profit after Tax Year TK in Million 2012 5,524 2011 4,841 2010 4,463 2009 3,404 2008 2,675
69
Market value Per Share (Highest Taka) Year Highest Taka 2012 59.00 2011 83.98 2010 90.00 2009 89.00 2008 83.00
Table 2-9 Market values Per Share (Highest Taka) Figure 2-9: Market Value Per Share of IBBL
70
71
6.0 Actual Task: Our internship experience at Islami Bank Bangladesh Ltd. started in the Uttara Branch, located at sector 3 Uttara beside rajlaxmi shopping complex which is a popular, sophisticated, spacious and quiet branch. The most attracting thing of the branch is the state-of-the-art interior design and space of the bank premise. 6.1 Job at Remittance and Accounts section: Job Responsibilities: - Job responsibilities at accounts and remittance were short because of the work sensitivity. Giving the remittance service through designated file paths in online when the officer was unavailable. Though the authorizing limit was very low Registering day to day pay slip into register and excel template Checking the debit and credit entry in number and amount from audit trail to general accounts sheet and put on the voucher register. Calculating daily entries and position of demand deposits, time deposits, loansadvances and schemes 6.2 Specific Responsibilities of Job: The duties and responsibilities, We had to perform in the bank are given below: Before joining in the branch, having an eight days training in the Islami Bank Training and Research Academy. After joining in the branch, performing any kind of duties that is ordered by the manager and the senior principal officer. Explaining different massage and issues to the supervisor. Additionally, sitting in the Account Opening desk to help the customers to open an account.
72
Besides, being in the cash counter. Solving different problems of computers. Typing different papers Checking different e-mails. Entering data in the computer. Reading different books of Islami Bank Training and Research Academy. Putting seal in different papers. 6.3 Different Aspects of Job Performance: Before joining in the branch, We have an eight days training in the Islami Bank Training and Research Academy and after conducting the training, We have to participate in an examination. We have scored good marks on the examination. When We join in the branch, we have to perform different duties that were ordered by the manager and the senior principal officer and they are very pleased on our performance. WE have to explain different massage and issues to the supervisor. In addition, we sat in the Account Opening desk to help the customers to open an account. There we have to write the forms and give information about what is required to open the account. Besides, we were in the cash counter to collect cash from the customers. We also solve different problems of computers. Moreover, we typed different papers of agreements of loan and investment. We also check different e-mails of the bank. Sometimes, we entered data of account opening form in the computer. we read different books of Islami Bank Training and Research Academy too which are written by different Islamic researchers. 6.4 Observations: The task of accounts is very sensitive and warrants highest attention in recording and scrutiny activities. The learning from accounts helped us to forwarding work as WE know the term of balance sheet which is an accumulation of entire function of a branch. The work of credit became easy because our understanding of accounts was good. Going through different files from CIB to maintenance has helped to get idea on regular
73
Chapter Seven
74
Research Part
7.0 Problem Statement: While doing internship we have found that there was less foreign remittance transactions than transactions occurred in last two months. So, to find out the reason we have conducted a survey to our client and try to find their satisfaction level.
7.1 Project Timeline: To prepare this project report we spend total 30 days. The project activities have shown in the following Gantt chart. Week 01: Developed the research plan Week 02: Developed the hypothesis Week 03: Conduct survey research
75
Description of activity Developed the research plan Developed the hypothesis Conduct survey research Data analysis and Interpretation
Week 01
Week 02
Week 03
Week 04
The total expenditure to prepare this project as followed Particulars Transportation Printing, Photocopy & Binding Cell phone & Internet Bill Bills Amount (Tk.) 140 1,000 1,200 480
76
1,000 5580
7.3 Research Methodology: 7.3.1 Type of research: Descriptive 7.3.2 Research Approach: Survey (Quantitative research) 7.3.3 Instrument of Research Questionnaires with Structure question ( closed end) 10 Questions and pattern is Likert Scale
7.4 Population Definition: Population: The population for the survey was the 195 (Approximately) Element: Clients of IBBL. Extent:Uttara Branch Duration:18 Jan to 18 March 2014. 7.5 Sampling Plan: Sample Unit:The Clients of IBBL considered as the Sample unit. Sample Frame: The sample frame of this study consists of all the clients or remittance section. Sample Size: The sample size of this research is 40 clients of IBBL. As if in our surveyed, WE take sample size is 40.As our sample size is more than 30, thats why WE am following Z test. Sampling Procedure: Probability Sampling - Simple Random Sampling
77
7.6 Contact Method -Questionnaire Survey 7.7 Analysis and Presentation of Data: After collecting all the data WE had analyzed all the data individually. For analysis of data Microsoft Word, Microsoft Excel, different tables and graphs were used to make the data meaningful. WE present the data through graph, chart, table etc. Based on our analysis WE made findings, recommendation and conclusion. The following formula has been followed:
X s n
Z test =
7.8 Hypothesis scale: In order to analysis the data a 5 point Liker scale has been used 1 stands for strongly disagreed customer, 2 stands for only disagreed customer, 3 stands for the neither agree or disagreed customer, 4 stands for agreed employee, and 5stands for strongly agreed employee. The scale has been shown below:
Scale
Weighted
78
1 2 3 4 5
Table 3: Hypothesis scale 7.9 Hypothesis Development: Some relevant hypothesis has been formulated for this study to fulfill the objectives of the study. HA: IBBL remittance section uses proper procedures to meet the customer demand. HA: IBBL uses modern technologies for foreign remittance activities. HA: IBBL has effective transaction timeline. HA: IBBL ensures secure Banking HA: Customer gets true and full information before opening new account. HA: Service charges of IBBL are reasonable as comparatively to other banks. HA: IBBL completes transaction rapidly. HA: Employee of IBBL has enough knowledge to answer customers queries. HA: The behavior of employee of IBBL installs confidence in customers. HA: Employees are cooperative to customers. 7.10 Hypothesis Testing
H1
H2
H3
H4
H5
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10
03
04
02
02
04
03
07
02
05
05
04
05
04
03
05
06
10
03
03
03
79
3=Neither Agree Nor Disagree 4= Agree 5= Strongly Agree Total Average Standard Deviation Z - test value
05
03
05
03
07
06
02
02
04
04
15 13
12 16
14 15
20 12
13 11
16 09
13 08
21 12
16 15
13 15
151
151
156
157
137
142
125
157
158
150
3.78 3.78 3.90 3.92 3.43 3.55 3.13 3.95 3.95 3.75
1.23 1.37 1.17 1.07 1.39 1.22 1.45 1.06 1.15 1.37
6.48 6.48 7.57 8.45 4.23 5.44 2.75 8.65 7.97 5.77 Table 4: Hypothesis Testing
7.11 Graphical Representation: 01.HO: IBBL remittance section does not use proper procedures to meet the customer demand. HA:IBBL remittance section uses proper procedures to meet the customer HO: = 2.5 demand.
80
= 6.48
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said IBBL remittance section uses proper procedures to meet the customer demand.
H1
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
33%
7%
10% 12%
38%
Hypothesis 1
02.HO: IBBL does not use modern technologies for foreign remittance activities. HA: IBBL use modern technologies for foreign remittance activities. HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.78 = 1.37 81
Z=
= 6.48
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said IBBL remittance section uses proper procedures to meet the customer demand.
H2
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
30%
Hypothesis 2
03.HO: IBBL has no effective transaction timeline. HA: IBBL has effective transaction timeline. HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.9 = 1.17
82
Z=
= 7.57
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said IBBL remittance section uses proper procedures to meet the customer demand.
H3
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
5% 38%
10% 12%
35%
Hypothesis 3
04.HO: IBBL does not ensure secure Banking HA: IBBL ensures secure Banking HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.93 = 1.07
83
Z=
= 8.45
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said that IBBL ensures secure Banking.
H4
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
5% 30%
7% 8%
50%
Hypothesis 4
05.HO: Customer doesnt get true and full information before opening new account. HA: Customer gets true and full information before opening new account. HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.43 = 1.39
84
Z=
= 4.23
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said Customer gets true and full information before opening new account. .
H5
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
26%
10% 13%
18% 33%
Hypothesis 5
06.HO: Service charges of IBBL are higher as comparatively to other banks. HA: Service charges of IBBL are reasonable as comparatively to other banks. HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.55 = 1.22
85
Z=
= 5.44
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said Service charges of IBBL are reasonable as comparatively to other banks.
H6
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
23%
7% 15%
15%
40%
Hypothesis 6 07.HO: IBBL doesnt complete transaction rapidly. HA: IBBL completes transaction rapidly. HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.13 = 1.45
86
Z=
= 2.75
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said IBBL doesnt complete transaction rapidly.
H7
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
20%
17%
25% 33% 5%
Hypothesis 7
08.HO: Employee of IBBL doesnt have enough knowledge to answer customers queries. HA: Employee of IBBL has enough knowledge to answer customers queries. HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.95
87
= 1.06 Z=
= 8.65
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said Employee of IBBL has enough knowledge to answer customers queries.
H8
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
5% 30%
7% 5%
53%
Hypothesis 8 09.HO: The behavior of employee of IBBL doesnt install confidence on customers. HA: The behavior of employee of IBBL installs confidence on customers. HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.95 = 1.15
88
Z=
= 7.97
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said The behavior of employee of IBBL installs confidence on customers.
H9
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
5% 38%
10% 7%
40%
Hypothesis 3
10.HO: Employees are not cooperative to customers.. HA: Employees are cooperative to customers.. HO: = 2.5 HA: > 2.5 n = 40 Here, X = 3.75 = 1.37
89
Z=
= 5.77
At 5% level of significance, follows Z distribution =1.645 Since Z cal> Z tab, the null hypothesis is rejected. So at 5 % level of significance, it can be said Employees are cooperative to customers..
H10
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
12% 38%
7% 10%
33%
Hypothesis 10
7.12 Findings: 1. Around 33% of respondents are strongly agreed, 38% are agreed, 12% respondents are neither agreed nor disagreed that IBBL remittance section uses proper procedures to meet the customer demand.
90
2. Around 40% of respondents are strongly agreed, 30% agreed with the statement of Employees of IBBL uses modern technologies for foreign remittance activities. 3. In the statement of IBBL has effective transaction timeline 30% of respondents are strongly agreed, 35% agreed and 12% neutral. 4. Around 30% of respondents are strongly agreed, 50% agreed with the statement that IBBL ensures secure Banking. 5. In the statement of Customer gets true and full information before opening new account 26% of respondents are strongly agreed, 33% agreed and 18% neutral. 6. Around 23% of respondents are strongly agreed, 40% are agreed, 15% respondents are neither agreed nor disagreed that Service charges of IBBL are reasonable as comparatively to other banks. 7. Around 20% of respondents are strongly agreed, 33% agreed with the statement of IBBL completes transaction rapidly. 8. In the statement of Employee of IBBL has enough knowledge to answer customers queries. 30% of respondents are strongly agreed, 53% agreed and 5% neutral. 9. Around 38% of respondents are strongly agreed, 40% agreed with the statement of The behavior of employee of IBBL installs confidence in you. 10. In the statement of Employee of Employees are willing to help you 38% of respondents are strongly agreed, 33% agreed and 10% neutral.
7.13 Recommendation: Bank is a service providing organization. The main objectives of the world famous and successful banking organizations are to make profit through addressing the clients time to time with new piece of service instruments by ensuring their
91
satisfaction .
research and findings: 1. Though IBBL uses proper procedures to meet the customer demand but they need to concern about it. 2. Although they are using modern technologies but customer are not 100% satisfied so their technologies should be flexible for customer. 3. Customer wants their transaction as fast as possible. Sometime IBBL takes some more time for doing transaction. They should reduce it for providing better service. 4. IBBL has a strong safety for their customer. If they make some advertising about that they will be more popular to upcoming clients. 5. IBBL should provide as much as true and detail information to their customer for making better understands. 6. Service should be as less as possible for attracting customer in competitive market. 7. Clients have a great complain about rapid transaction. IBBL should complete transaction rapidly. 8. New employee should be well train up for providing better service. 9. Employee should be well mannered for making customer confident and safe. 10. Employee should be more willing to customer. Because when a client will be happy then he/she will bring new client.
92
References
Annual Reports and Journals: IBBL Annual Reports 2012, 2011, 2010 Journals of Bangladesh Bank Tri-monthly publication of IBBL Bank Internship Reports on IBBL Bank and other commercial banks Auditors Reports of IBBL Bank Different types of brochures of IBBL Bank Books: Principles of Marketing by Philip Kotler and Gary Armstrong, 11 Edition Mirakhor, A (1997), Progress and Challenges of Islamic banking, Review of Islamic Economics, vol. 4, No.2. A way to Islami Banking, Dr. Mohammed Haider Ali Miah, 2008 Edition Business Research Methods, (8th edition), William G. Zikmund. Bank Management and Financial Services, 6th ed, Roes, Peter S., Hudgins, Sylvia C (2005) Mcgraw Hill Publications.
th
93
Web Sites: www.islamibankbd.com www.bangladeshbank.org.bd.com. www.google.com http://www.customerservicemanager.com/customer-service-articles.htm Abbreviations: IBBL LIM LTR A/C DD FDD TT FTT EB EFT L/C SWIFT VP Ltd List of Table Table No 2-1 2-2 2-3 2-4 2-5 2-6 2-7 2-8 Description Sector Wise Investment Market Share Remittance Return n Asset Return on equity Import, Export and Remittance performance Gross Profit Ratio Net profit before Tax Gross Profit After Tax Page 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited Loan against Import Merchandise Loan against Trust Receipt Account Demand Draft Foreign Demand Draft Telegraphic Transfer Foreign Telegraphic Transfer Export Bill Electronic Fund Transfer Letter of Credit Society for worldwide Inter Bank Financial Vice President Limited
94
Market Values per share Name of the PSI Agency Accounting procedure of import L/C Project Timeline Internship Budget Information Hypothesis Testing
27 51 52 71 71 74
List of Figures: Figure No 2-1 2-2 2-3 2-4 2-5 2-6 2-7 2-8 2-9 3-1 5-15-7 Description Sector Wise Investment Market Share Remittance Return n Asset Return on equity Import, Export and Remittance performance Gross Profit Ratio Net profit before Tax Gross Profit After Tax Market Values per share Hierarchy of Foreign Exchange Department Graphical Representation of Hypothesis testing 34 75-81 Page 23 24 24 25 25 26 26 27 27
95
Questionnaire: Dear Respondent, We are Rakibul Hasan and Fahmida Hossain Tania students of Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA); in the College of Business Administration (CBA) at International University of Business Agriculture and Technology (IUBAT). WE am doing survey on Customer satisfaction in Remittance division of IBBL, Uttara branch. as a partial fulfillment of the course Internship Report (BUS-490). Would you mind giving us few minutes to answer some questions? Answering the questions will be highly acknowledged and esteemed, as it will be a great assistance for us to complete the research paper. Questionnaire on Customer satisfaction Name: . Profession: Age: ...Cell No: .. How do you agree with those questionnaires? Give a tick () mark on your answer. 1) IBBL remittance section uses proper procedures to meet the customer demand. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 2) IBBL use modern technologies for foreign remittance activities. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 3) IBBL has effective transaction timeline. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree
96
4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 4) IBBL ensures secure Banking 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agrees nor disagree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 5) Customer gets the full and true information before opening new account. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 6) Service charges of IBBL are reasonable as comparatively to other bank. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 7) IBBL completes transaction rapidly. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 8) Employee of IBBL has enough knowledge to answer your question. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 4. Agree
97
5. Strongly agree 9) The behavior of employee of IBBL installs confidence in you. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree 10) Employees are willing to help you. 1. Strongly Disagree 2. Disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 4. Agree 5. Strongly agree Comments or Suggestion: Thank You
98