Biocon
Biocon
Biocon
Identification of issues
Biocon, in collaboration with CIMAB has developed BIOMAb, a proprietary drug for head and
neck cancer. Biocon has recently concluded Phase 2 trials for BIOMAb, the results of which
were positive. The problems at hand for Biocon are:
1. whether to launch BIOMAb as a drug for head and neck cancer as soon as
possible with just having conducted Phase 2 trials, to further conduct Phase 3 trials for
the same indicator for more credibility, or to explore further possibilities for other
indicators (viz. colorectal cancer) and invest in Phase 2 trials for the same.
2. to decide the appropriate marketing mix for BIOMAb.
Analysis of the issues
Immediate launch
Advantages:
First movers advantage
Impressive Phase-2 results which will help them gain approval of DCGI
They will save precious time and resources on further trials
Disadvantages:
No experience in marketing and selling oncology drugs
Without the result of the phase 3 trials, competitor can attack the credibility
Launch after Phase-3 trials
Advantages:
Boost in credibility due to positive Phase 3 results
Stronger sales pitch; assuage doctors possible concerns
Enough time to work upon the sales and marketing strategies
Disadvantages:
Loss of first mover advantage
Stiff competition from Erbitux
Huge investment of money and time for Phase 3 trials
Invest in Phase-2 trials
Advantages:
Possibility of expansion of treatment for other types of cancers other than head and neck
Disadvantages:
High investment of time and money; loss of first mover advantage
Akash Gupta | Avijeet Boparai | Bhabna Roy | Chandra Prakash Verma | Maheshwari Ruchika | Nikita Parmar | S. Priyatham Swamy
Product
Immediate Launch
Simultaneous launch
Advantages
Advantages
First mover
Opportunity to
before the launch of
build own sales force
BIOMAb
Opportunity to
Opportunity to
cash on the image of
strengthen salesforce
being Indias first
before the launch of
proprietary drug developer
BIOMAb
Provide time
for Phase 3 trials of
BIOMAb
Advantages
More facetime
for the salesreps with
doctors
More
compelling sales pitch to
the oncologists
Larger revenue
base that justifies
investment in salesforce
Greater
product mix
Disadvantages
Lesser
credibility in absence of
Phase 3 results
Strong
competitive reaction from
Erbitux
Insufficient
sales force
Disadvantages
Dilution of
image as Indias first
proprietary drug developer
Difficulty in
capturing market share
from Erbitux
Disadvantages
No first-mover
advantage
Difficulty in
capturing market share
from Erbitux
Price
Particulars
Option 1
Option 2
Option 3
Option 4
Capital Investment
25000000
25000000
25000000
25000000
Price
1000
3000
5000
5200
250
750
1250
1300
150
450
750
780
Marketing (30%)
300
900
1500
1560
Profits
300
900
1500
1560
11400
11400
11400
11400
3420000
10260000
17100000
17784000
Breakeven (years)
7.31
2.44
1.46
1.41
Akash Gupta | Avijeet Boparai | Bhabna Roy | Chandra Prakash Verma | Maheshwari Ruchika | Nikita Parmar | S. Priyatham Swamy
Place
Direct Selling
Advantages
Advantages
Disadvantages
Disadvantages
Promotion
Traditional Detailing
Advantages
Disadvantages
Limited reach
Recommendations
1.
BIOMAb should be launched after Phase 3 trials to get more credibility and
develop salesforce, which will compensate for the loss of first mover advantage. Till the
launch, generics should be launched to gain traction with oncologists and test the new
market.
2.
Akash Gupta | Avijeet Boparai | Bhabna Roy | Chandra Prakash Verma | Maheshwari Ruchika | Nikita Parmar | S. Priyatham Swamy