Fractures of The Patella : Tension
Fractures of The Patella : Tension
BY
JAMES
F. (ARPENTER.
AND
An
M.D.t.
LARRY
Instructional
of the Patella*
ARBOR.
ANN
5. MATTHEwS.
Course
Lecture,
The
human
sesamoid
bone,
lies
functional
component
of the
Most of the quadriceps
apo-
neurosis
inserts
directly
into the superior
pole of the
patella.
while
the patellar
ligament
arises
from its infenor pole. Some
fibers,
however,
bypass
the patella
anteniorly
and
are
confluent
with
the patellar
ligament.
ANN
American
Anatomy
The patehla.
the largest
within
and is an important
knee extensor
mechanism.
ROBERTA
M.D.t.
KASMAN.
ARBOR.
Acadenv
M.D4.
DETROIT.
MICHIGAN
of Ort/iopaedic
Surgeons
equals
the tibial
force
multiplied
by the tibial
moment
arm), he was able to determine
the effective
quadriceps
moment
arm (the quadriceps
moment
arm equals
the
knee
found
moment
that the
divided
patella
of the quadriceps
tion made
by the
by
serves
the quadriceps
to increase
moment
arm
patella
increases
and
the
force).
He
magnitude
Only
the skin,
a thin layer
of subcutaneous
tissue,
and the
pnepatellar
bursa
overlie
the patella.
This subcutaneous
location
makes
the patella
prone
to injuries
from direct
blows
and falls. Posteriorly.
of the surface
of the patelha
the proximal
are covered
cartilage
thickest
the
that
body.
is among
This
anterior
surface
trochlea.
It has
the
surface
only
found
partially
of the
distal
aspect
major
medial
and
three-quarters
with articular
anywhere
conforms
of the
lateral
femur
in
to
the
and
the
Tension
facets.
Biomechanics
The
patehla
the quadriceps
tella. and the
two
important
principal
transmits
is one
link
muscle,
patellar
in the
the quadriceps
ligament.
The
biomechanical
site
the
mechanism
comprising
tendon.
mechanism
functions.
First,
of insertion
of the quadriceps
tensile
forces
generated
by
the paserves
as it is the
the
muscle,
it
quadni-
the
of the
mechanical
cadavenic
force with
tibia
the
Kaufer5
clearly
enhancing
function
of the
knees,
he
a restraining
balanced
force
at 0 to 120 degrees
moment
about
the
a simulated
at the distal
of knee
knee
flexion.
axis
(the
This
by con-
documented
patehla.
Using
quadriceps
aspect
of the
FIG.
in tenpatello-
tension
at
of
By calculating
extension.
knee
and
moment
*printed
with
permission
of The
American
Academy
of Ortho-
1550
the
His
they
tomy
paedic
Surgeons.
This
article
will appear
in Instructional
Coitrse
Lectures,
Volume
43, The American
Academy
of Orthopaedic
Surgeons,
Rosemont,
Illinois,
March
1994.
tSection
of Orthopaedic
Surgery.
Department
of Surgery.
University
of Michigan
Medical
School,
Ann Arbor,
Michigan
48109.
Henry
Ford
Hospital.
Detroit.
Michigan
48202.
Drawing
demonstrating
that the patella
is loaded
primarily
sion when
the knee
is in full extension.
In this position.
the
femoral
contact
force
is minimum.
knee,
support
should
being
findings
be
have
almost
30
been
confirmed
pen
the
contention
that
avoided
in
treatment
the
cent
full
by others
total
patellecof
patehlar
disorders.
The
knee
quadriceps
tension
nor
patella
extension,
(Fig.
surface
is subjected
it transmits
to complex
almost
loading.
all of the
With
force
of the
contraction
and thus is loaded
primarily
in
1). However,
with knee
flexion,
its postecontacts
THE
the
JOURNAL
distal
OF
aspect
BONE
of the
AND
JOINT
femur
and
SURGERY
FRACTURES
OF
THE
1551
PATELLA
joint
for
a range
of
linear
area
knee
band.
We deterfor the patello-
flexion
angles
patellofemoral
loads2.
These
studies
showed
tact areas
of approximately
two to four square
tens
throughout
(Fig.
3). The
most
force
of the
with
anticular
surface
of the
be estimated
analytically
quadriceps
Three
point
bending
patellofemoral
and
ten
angles,
newtons
tamed
FIG.
Drawing
demonstrating
loaded
in three-point
moment
increases
with
is subjected
face
joint
creates
the
anterior
that
naturally
the
surface
of the
generated
quadriceps.
of loading
position
knee
of the
degrees
of knee
Loads
across
but
they
newtons
of tensile
load
As
at
is additive
to
the
have
of
primarily
knee
and
may
not
on
men5. Considering
bending
stress,
by Smith3
and
data
stress.
and
by Morn-
knee
flexion
for estimation
For
virtually
angles.
of the
all activities
by the tibiofemoral
millimeter)
joints.
tance
ment
These
high
of maintenance
of patellar
stress
joint
and
(two
by other
to five
major
newtons
per
weight-bearing
contact
stresses
magnify
the imporof articuhar
congruity
in the treatfractures
in order
to facilitate
and
distribution.
these
on
moves
into
near
45
precisely
order
to 6000
rise
reported
increasingly
in the ante-
been
the
the
the patellofemoral
contact
stresses
(two to
per square
millimeter)
exceed
those
sus-
square
maximize
extension
contacts
distal
aspect
of the femur
can
with
the use of the primary
of activities
essential
contact
and
patella
contraction
a maximum
are
data
the
in the
from
reaches
probably
the
sun-
which
forces
become
of tensile
forces
patella
called
on this
in tension
contribution
depends
joint.
flexion.
the patella
measured,
young,
trained
sion, three-point
patella,
is
results
by distraction
the bending
magnitude
patella
bending
configuration
load
The relative
of the patella
of the
surface
Loading
bending
bending
the
The
generally
force.
2). This
greater
flexion.
important.
The
non
force,
reactive
a three-point
(Fig.
of the
modes
to a compressive
patellofemoral
patella
that,
bending
increasing
force
arc of flexion
which
and
small concentime-
of 3000
newtons
the magnitude
and compressive
in
of tenforces
that occurs
on the posterior
surface
of the patella
in a
loaded,
flexed
knee, the recognized
prevalence
of patellan fracture
is not surprising.
Studies
in our laboratory
of strain
on the anterior
patellan
surface
that normal
activities,
such as stair-climbing,
ate
magnitudes
of surface
close
to values
microstrain).
that
These
major
the
role
in
equally
important
ods of treatment
The
strain
result
large
initiation
of
anticular
fractures
efficacy
VOL.
75-A,
joint
NO.
10.
OCTOBER
through
much
1993
dangerously
(1000
patella
and
of various
to 2000
play a
have
an
methFI;.
surface
dominantly
convex.
The anterior
femur
is convex
as well. Thus, the
patellofemoral
are
in a fracture
strains
in the
effect
on the
of fractures.
posterior
that
demonstrated
can gener-
of the
patella
articular
surface
point of contact
of the
range
is preof the
for the
of mo-
The
tact
flexion.
dark
regions
in this photograph
area
of the patella
on the femur
These
patellofemoral
b area).
small
areas
in combination
joint
result
in very
high
of the knee
indicate
the conat different
positions
of knee
with
high loads
across
the
contact
stresses
(force
divided
1552
J. E.
CARPENTER.
ROBERTA
Transverse
undisplaced
Vertical
Transverse
displaced
Osteochondral
Comminuted
KASMAN.
AND
L. S. MATTHEWS
)L.
undisplaced
Sleeve
Comminuted
displaced
FIG.
Classification
Classification
the
two
Patelhar
fractures
mechanism
of
major
of patellar
of Patellar
are
injury
mechanisms
injury:
direct
to
There
and
both
are
indirect
trauma.The
patella
may be fractured
by a direct
blow
during
a fall onto the knee or when
it hits the dashboard
in an automobile
accident.
Because
of the small amount
of prepatehhar
soft
distal
aspect
force
of a direct
direct
trauma
tissue
of the
tion,
but
tune
fragments.
and
femur
blow
causes
is little
With
certainty,
area
Indirect
to jumping
trauma
on, more
contact
posteriorly,
there
the contact
direct
is damaged
with
nearly
is delivered
frequently
often
the
to the
displacement
the
articular
by this
that
causes
frequently,
the
all of the
patella.
considerable
Such
comminuof the
mechanism
fractures
can
to unexpectedly
of
of injury.
be
due
rapid
flexion
of the knee against
a fully contracted
quadriceps.
The natural
anatomy
and biomechanics
of the knee,
as
previously
described,
create
tension,
three-point
bending, and compressive
strains
in the
values
sufficient
to cause
a fracture.
from
indirect
those
often
from direct
transverse.
than
with
direct
injury
tend
to be
trauma,
but
The articular
less
patella
that exceed
Fractures
resulting
comminuted
than
and are
damaged
trauma.
Most
patehlar
fractures
occur
as a result
of a combination
of direct
and
indirect
trauma.
Rarely
does
anyone
hit a dashboard
with a relaxed
quadriceps.
In
addition,
Thompson
et ah.33 clearly
demonstrated
that
basis
of fracture
direct
blows
those
sufficient
morphology.
to
the
patella
to cause
of
magnitudes
less
fractures
predictably
patellan
than
damage
the contacting
articular
cartilage
of the patella
and femur
and that early
biochemical
and histological
changes
after
such blows
are consistent
with the initiation
of post-traumatic
osteoarthrosis.
In general,
to facilitate
treatment,
are
classified
occur
These
of
frac-
cartilage
on the
Fractures
classified
according
and morphology.
of
fractures
patelhar
(Fig.
in a medial-lateral
direction
fractures
are usually
in the
the
patella.
inferior
Vertical
direction,
edge
tella
morphologically
of the
and
patella
that
are
they
that
not
do
are
in
are
rare.
not
extend
associated
fractures
Fractures
that
are called
transverse.
central
or distal
third
fractures
and
4).
with
the
superior-
Fractures
of the
across
the
disruption
pa-
of the
extensor
mechanism
are called
marginal
fractures.
Displaced
fractures
are those
with
articuhar
incongruity
(step-off)
of more
than two millimeters
or separation
of
the fragments
of more
than
three
millimeters5.
Fractunes
with
multiple
fragments
are called
comminuted
fractures.
Some
comminuted
tenized
as stellate
also demonstrate
fractures.
comminution
fractures
can
be
Some
transverse
of one or both
Osteochondral
fractures
are primarily
A direct blow, or more commonly
a patellar
may cause
an immediate
fracture
around
chanacfractures
poles.
of two types.
dislocation,
the point
of
contact,
separating
a single
fragment
that includes
anticular cartilage,
subchondral
bone, and supporting
trabecular bone.
This piece
may never
displace,
and in this
case the fracture
usually
heals with time and causes
little
THE
JOURNAL
OF
BONE
AND
JOINT
SURGERY
FRACTURES
OF
1553
THE
PATELLA
tune
tical
or separation
fractures
are
radiographs22.
of the fragments,
or both.
Some
yenbest seen on tangential
on Merchant
Rare
marginal
must
be distinguished
tens that never
fused
ing
a bipartite
or
peripheral
fractures
from secondary
ossification
with the body of the patella,
patella.
Radiographs
of the
cencreat-
contralateral
knee
can help in this differentiation
because
bipartite
patella
rarely
occurs
unilaterally.
Computed
tomography or other
advanced
imaging
techniques
are usually
unnecessary.
fractures,
contrast
FIG.
used
Drawing
showing
the
AO
modified
tension-band
fracture
fixation.
Two 2.0-millimeter
Kirschner
wires
tension
band
are used.
As the knee
is flexed,
the
pressed
at the articular
surface.
technique
of
and an anterior
fracture
is com-
to help
However,
the
fragment
come
a mechanically
has been recommended28
fragments,
Herbert
may
troublesome
in these
displace
loose
situations
stabilization
by transosseous
screw
has been
described27.
osteochondral
curs infrequently,
fracture,
when
a child
or adolescent
enable
amount
a so-called
the inferior
is pulled
of articular
and
be-
body. Excision
but, for large
The
fixation
other
with a
type of
sleeve
fracture,
pole of the patella
off together
cartilage2.
with
Such
ocof
a consid-
a fracture
be difficult
to see on standard
radiography.
Clinical
findings of local pain and tenderness,
an extension
lag (the
inability
to fully
graphs
showing
extend
the
knee
a high-riding
actively),
patella
and
indicated
appropriate,
of the
that
conservative
depending
on
fragments
niceps
and
mechanism.
the
importance
tella
in
the
Conservative
and
of subluxation
treatment
of patellar
operative
repair
carefully
examination,
same
time
flexion
with
extend
the
extension,
tenderness,
accurate
while
localized
knee,
the
a thorough
is nearly
diagnosis.
some
lateral
VOL.
anteropostenior
nadiognaphs
75-A,
NO.
Weak
ment.
Usually,
disrupted
at the
of immobilization
the extensor
time of such
followed
and,
later,
quadriceps-strengthening
produces
good
results.
While
a few
flexion
are frequently
host, the over-all
satisfied
patient
of the
with
little
patients
and
surface,
cast
treat-
mechanism
is not totally
fractures.
Four to six weeks
by gentle
but progressive
exercises
extreme
or no discomfort
of 212 fractures
Bostr#{246}m5 found
on
millime-
degrees
result
of
is a
on disability.
followed
after non-operative
slight on no pain in 89 per cent
normal
on slightly
of motion
impaired
was
function
0 to 120 degrees
as the
Most
Treatment
patellar
tively. Treatment
patellar
function
open reduction
is important
fractures
should
be
treated
opera-
should
be aimed
at the preservation
of
whenever
possible,
preferably
through
and internal
fixation
of the fragments.
It
to obtain
comminution
secure
fixation.
for secure
open
If there
reduction
and
is too
inter-
blow, an
rapid
voluntary
contusion,
to make
an
radiographs
are
neces-
and facilitation
is difficult
to see
radiographs.
More
reveal
the comminution
1993
two
evaluation
and localized
the examiner
of the fracture
The patella
10, OCTOBER
comminuted,
with
was contracted,
toinability
to strongly
diagnostic.
High-quality
peripheral,
associated
physical
radiographic
quadriceps
pain and the
a palpable
defect,
and swelling
help
fractures
much
ensure
diagnostic
success.
A history
of a direct
extraordinary
muscle
contraction,
or unexpected,
knee
gether
Fractures
Fractures
history,
accurate
pa-
recommended
mechanism.
of Patellar
an
emphasized
at the
extensor
recorded
and
of Patellar
vertical,
transverse
Operative
Alkire4
and
even
fractures.
is
capacity
or dislocation
fractures
instability
of the
Evaluation
A
functional
with
with
stress
and osteochondral
with or without
use of
Bone
scans have been
Treatment
undisplaced
In a series
treatment,
this diagnosis.
operative
neauthors2
have
or operative
treatment
the extent
of the separation
Heckman
association
radio-
in comparison
the contralateral,
uninjured
side support
Houghton
and Ackroyd5
recommended
pair
of these
avulsion
fractures.
Other
to identify
range-of-motion
can
for occult
tomography,
may be helpful.
Treatment
For
trouble.
However,
computed
medium,
often
of
on
than not,
of the frac-
FIG.
Drawing
showing
with 4.5-millimeter
stabilization
lag screws
6
of
alone.
a transverse
patellar
fracture
1554
J. E.
(ARPENTER.
ROBERTA
KASMAN.
AND
fracture.
L. S. MATTHEWS
In
addition,
quently
develops,
Care
should
be
the soft
flexion,
ment
a large
tissues
from compressive
or direct
contact
with
must
be delayed,
stretching
the
necessary
to postpone
unusual.
cording
Fu;.
nal fixation,
but
with a substantial
a major
amount
is present,
partial
proach.
Occasionally,
fragments
are
(usually
of normal
patellectomy
good
present
with
distal
superior)
articuhar
comminution
situations.
we
mid-portion,
the
poles.
proximal
and
functional
The
and
the
appole
of the
middle
created
a smaller
Operative
soft
direct
but
tissue
overlying
the
patella
or abrasion
is often
time
of the
patellar
fracture
after
FIG.
Radiograph
autogenous
showing
graft.
a displaced.
transverse
knee
treatthat
is
considered.
If
repair;
internal
fixation
and
wound
is clean.
The fracture
can
knee
treated
followed
however,
this
delayed
and
Often
there
the
primary
be approached
closure
when
via a midline
longi-
or a transverse
incision.
Although
the
is superior
after
a transverse
incision,
seldom
be used for other
procedures
on
should
gated,
these
become
necessary
integrity
in the
incision.
Once
in the extensor
medially
fracture
of the
is comminution
or laterally,
site is then
fragments
that
future;
the fracture
mechanism
was
or
inn-
is evaluated.
not
regarding
and internal
patellectomy
recognized
whether
fixation,
is then
7-B
a reconstruction
is
with
immediate
by open reduction
on the radiographs.
The
decision
to proceed
with an open reduction
a partial
patellectomy,
or a total
re-evaluated.
injured
at the
be
the
be
operative
extending
several
centimeters
both,
is usually
identified.
The
Principles
compression
should
of
could
thus, we prefer
a longitudinal
has been
exposed.
a defect
have
successfully
preserving
both
fretissues.
injury
to
of a hematoma
skin
the skeleton
are
and d#{233}bnidement
tudinal
incision
cosmetic
result
this incision
can
patella.
General
from
distal
the
fragment
cartilage
is the appropriate
and proximal
of the patelha.
In such
removed
the comminuted
and
soft
Open
fractures
of the patella
are treated
acto the same principles
as open fractures
of other
parts
of
irrigation
7-A
hematoma
splints,
excessive
ice. If operative
aspiration
anterior
there
is severe
compromise
operative
wound-healing
fracture
further
compromising
the
taken
to minimize
additional
of the
anterior
THE
cruciate
JOURNAL
ligament
OF
BONE
with
AND
a patellar-ligament
JOINT
SURGERY
FRACTURES
OF
FIG.
Radiograph
Open
are
tion
made
cannulated
Reduction
Transverse
the most
and
after
and
fractures
amenable
internal
screws
Internal
tension-band
wires
Fractures
a small
it
amount
best
portion.
suited
The
for
3.5-millimeter
this
pect
of operative
reduction
of the
should
be achievable
application.
cortical
The
repair
is assurance
patellan
articular
in the treatment
most
screws
important
VOL.
75-A,
NO.
the
technique
10. OCTOBER
of partial
as-
of a congruous
surface.
This
goal
of transverse
frac-
1993
patellectomy.
This
is difficult
the
are
the
fracture.
procedure
to visualize
The
fracture
subsequently
united.
or palpate
the
articular
there
and
surface.
reduction
of the anterior
surface
of the
not guarantee
an anatomical
reduction
articular
surface.
It is not
some
plastic
non aspect
deformation
of the patella
this
makes
this
the
adequacy
Therefore,
FIG.
Drawings
showing
fixation
is not possible.
to stabilize
Anatomical
tella
does
of comminution
can often
be first converted
to a simple
transverse
fracture
by lag-screw
fixation
of the comminuted
used
tunes. However,
once
the fragments
are reduced,
is no longer
a large gap in the extensor
mechanism
or no comminution
with open
neducwith
1555
PATELLA
7-C
were
Fixation
with little
to treatment
fixation.
and
THE
surface
of the
we
unusual
for
there
paof
to
unreliable
reduction
recommend
for
of the
extension
the
judgment
anticulan
of
the
of
surface.
exposure
8
is preferred
to total
be
or comminution
of the anteas a result
of the injury,
and
patellectomy
if open
reduction
and
internal
J. E.
1556
CARPENTER.
FIG.
with
Figs.
9-A
through
9-E:
Figs.
9-A
and
Preoperative
a medial
distance
release
ization
9-B:
A closed,
parapatellar
proximally
medially.
to allow
adequate
of the fracture
site
KASMAN.
The small
Provisional
fracture
incision
There
for
must
a short
be enough
and partial
anatomical
visualreduc-
can be closed
after fixation.
of the fracture
can usually
be obtained
with one or two
with Kirschner
wires. Definitive
with wires
and screws,
either
Weber
bone-reduction
forceps
on
fixation
can be achieved
alone
or in combination.
et al.35, in a biomechanical
study,
technique
modified
demonstrated
the modified
tensionby the AO group,
prorecommended
use of
with additional
circumferentension-band
technique
is cur-
accepted,
and several
studies
have
of good results372#{176}.In a clinical
series,
Bostman
et al.4 found
superior
results
with the
modified
tension-band
technique
compared
with those
obtained
partial
erature
with
screw
patellectomy.
supports
possible4372.
The technique
millimeter
smooth
fixation,
with
circumferential
wining,
and
The contemporary
orthopaedic
litthe use of this technique
whenever
the
large
9-B
inferior
and
superior-pole
fragments.
18-gauge
and
over
the anterior
aspect
of the patella
to act as a tension
(Fig. 5)24. This anterior
tension
band neutralizes
the
band
large
use
wires
of two parallel
2.0combined
with
an
wire
looped
distraction
force
with contraction
of the knee.
sive forces
fracture
Failures
ative
the
Kirschner
As tension
are generated
is resisted
at the
wires
the anterior
and also with
by this
posterior
wire, compresaspect
of the
surface.
in open-
technique7.
the
then
placed
patella
reduction
longitudinal
through
the
fracture
technique
longitudinal
surface
across
and
fracture
more
wines
is the method
may be obtained
applied,
Kirschner
fracture
site,
wires
brought
in a retrograde
the
allows
for
Kirschnen
forceps,
after
in an antegrade
the fracture.
reliable
in the
band
poles
this
can
be
flush
manner,
after
reduction.
that we prefer.
and secured
and
This
placement
mid-portion
of the
of the
Alternatively,
with reduction
which
the Kirschner
wires
can be placed
fashion
through
the patella
and across
It is essential,
when
the tension
band
is
that
the
anterior
wire
be placed
adjacent
to the patella
as it courses
posterior
previously
placed
Kirschner
wines. The most
error
in this technique
is the failure
to bring
distal
When
surface
flexion
gap, improving
stability
at the articular
are often
directly
attributable
to errors
with
being
over
that occurs
across
of the quadriceps
The
parallel
placed
initially
sion
involves
Kirschner
intact,
radiographs.
palpation
to ensure
anthrotomy
stabilization
L. S. MATTHEWS
FIG.
patellar
AND
9-A
comminuted
capsular
and
ROBERTA
directly
into
of the patella,
happens
and
THE
JOURNAL
contact
with
the
BONE
AND
to the
common
the ten-
proximal
leaving
intervening
the fracture
is then
OF
directly
and
soft tissue.
loaded,
the
JOINT
SURGERY
FRACTURES
OF
THE
1557
PATELLA
FIG.
Radiographs
fragments
were
made
secured
fragments
may
the
band
effort
tension
In an
ment
separation,
ified
tension-band
after
the
to each
slip
significant
may not
be
apart
on
the
becomes
taut.
to overcome
which
can
fragments
a tension
and
the
use
of
frag-
tamed
and confirmed
with the
the arthrotomy
on the medial
of the
mod-
can
screw
or with reduction
forceps.
The screws
the fracture
in a lag fashion,
with the
intenfragmentary
advocated
study,
(Fig. 6).
reported
in better
stability
than
technique
for simulated
it is not clear
if this
difference.
Screw
able to resist
the
Benjamin
that
screw
et al.2,
fixa-
and
be achieved
internal
with
fixation,
patella
and
the larger.
to partial
patellectomy.
reduction
wires
problem
with
9-D
were
removed
from
the mid-portion
of the
hand.
This procedure
was done
as an alternative
until
Kinschner
occur
technique,
fixation
has been
in a biomechanical
tion resulted
tension-band
tunes.
However,
smaller,
comminuted
other
with screws
the
reduction
can
be
pole
oh-
cannulated-screw
guide-wires
are placed
across
threads
engaging
fixation
alone,
large
bending
however,
forces
that
occur
with knee
flexion,
and the addition
of a tension
band
has been
advocated
by some.
Unfortunately,
it is
difficult
to secure
the tension
band
because
the screws
do not protrude
interlocking
with
treated
band
has
sufficiently
the wire.
No
from
the bone
to allow
clinical
series
of patients
a tension
At our institution,
we evaluated
a method
in which
interfnagmentany
screw
fixation
can be easily
and securely
combined
with the use of an anterior
tension
band
(Fig. 7-A).
resistance
traction
tance
This
Theoretically,
to fracture
when
knee
to displacement
technique
was
of appropriately
screws.
As with
method
transverse
VOL.
the
75-A,
this construct
should
provide
displacement
from
anterior
disis in extension
as the knee
made
possible
sized
(4.0
NO.
to 4.5-millimeter)
the modified
is most appropriate
fractures.
As
10. OCTOBER
as well
moves
by the
tension-band
as resis-
into flexion.
development
cannulated
technique,
FIG.
this
for simple,
non-comminuted
with other
techniques
of open
1993
Intraoperative
the articular
of the patella.
photograph
surfaces
despite
9-E
demonstrating
removal
of the
the good
comminuted
alignment
mid-portion
of
1558
J. E.
(ARPENTER.
ROBERTA
KASMAN.
AND
4.0 or
Screws
monly
preserve
patients
patient.
the
anterior
the other
band.The
18-gauge
one of the cannulated
surface
cannulated
of the
patella,
screw,
and
the
tension-band
screws,
then
through
the
back
over
then
wine
over
center
of
the
with
ported
ment
The
which
not
determined,
partial
the surgeon
It is helpful
institution
showed
analysis
this
of
cadavenic
construct
to
knees
fail,
on
at
the
our
and
standard
than
partial
surface
osteoarthrosis
ment
anteriorly
is important
that
Radiograph
band
repair
age.
knee
with
10
showing
loss of fixation
following
because
of comminution
at the distal
a quadriceps
flexed
45
force
degrees,
of 732
while
modified
tensionpole of the patella.
newtons
screws
with
alone
554 newtons
(p < 0.05) and the modified
technique
alone
failed
at 395 newtons
sites of fractures
that had been
repaired
the
failed
at
tension-band
(p < 0.05).
The
with the mod-
has
is performed
by
fragments.
length
of the
the
as
possito the
use of mulsutures
(for
polyester)
(Fig. 8). These
surface
should
enter
near
there
is a minimum
step-off
lead
or tendon
intact
change
to joint
without
cartilage.
in the an-
overload
excessive
important
distal
pole,
which
markedly,
lead to
FIG.
patellectomy
and
as well as to avoid
rotation
of the fragand posteriorly
in the sagittal
plane.
It
to try to maintain
the length
of the re-
is especially
normal
patellar
knowledge.
the remaining
any abrupt
could
was
of a partial
of the patehha
through
and heavy
non-absorbable
ligament
This
of the
or the quadriceps
tendon
or tendon
is then
brought
between
the tendon
and
The goal is to minimize
ing.
size
be-
results
performance
patellectomy
braided
fracture
so that
re-
fragment
poor
a complete
to our
example,
number-2
holes
through
the
the articular
surface
maining
patellar
minimum
the
results
retained
fragin only one
removing
all of the comminuted
to preserve
as much
of the
fractured
surface
tiple drill-holes
ticular
or excellent
yielded
the
established,
are techniques
to
In a series
of forty
size of the
centimeters
of the
to allow
patellar
ligament
bhe. The
ligament
aver-
good
size
rather
been
cent
et al.29, the
4.1 square
patellectomy
needed
(Figs.
not
but there
as well.
minimum
low
patellectomy
pole,
pole
78 per
by Saltzman
was less than
nor surface
of the patella,
where
it is twisted
to the other
end of the wire. Two twists
in the wire can be used to
tighten
each
limb
of the tension
band
symmetrically
7-B and 7-C).
Biomechanical
superior
inferior
the
fragment
the ante-
L. S. MATTHEWS
with
can shorten
a low-riding
patellofemoral
shorten-
excision
the patellar
patella,
and
of
the
ligament
create
ab-
biomechanics.
Some
in parallel
This
wire
surgeons
have found
it helpful
to place a wire
with the ligament
repair
to act as a checkrein.
or cable
carries
a portion
of the load
be-
tween
patella
the
and
the
tibial
tubercle,
thus
decreasing
remaining
patella
and
through
the
tibial
transof
tubercle,
ified tension-band
technique
and cannulated
screws
also
demonstrated
superior
rigidity.
displacing
an average
of 1.0 millimeter
with simulated
knee
extension
compared
with 1 .5 millimeters
(p value not significant)
when
screws
alone
had been
used
and 4.4 millimeters
(p <
0.05) when
the modified
tension-band
technique
alone
had been
used.
Goings
and Cole
reported
nineteen
good
or excellent
results
in a series
of twenty-one
patients
who had been
managed
with a similar
technique.
and
repair
has
at
though
no comparable
Partial
not
all patehlar
ble to open
reduction
and internal
found
that, in most of the remaining
ment
of the
patella
healed,
inferior
pole
ceps tendon,
Patellectomv
Unfortunately.
can
be preserved.
fractures
are
amena-
fixation.
We
cases, a large
This
is most
have
fragcom-
polyester)
drill-hole
centimeters
rein and
can
be
patella
suture
a range
of
of disrupt-
approximately
placed
secured
proximal
protect
the
THE
repair.
it should
technique
of the
a heavy
and
patient
to obtain
with less fear
eight
can
weeks.
be used
is repaired
to the
(such
as number-S
through
a transverse
when
Althe
quadnibraided
patehlar
to the quadriceps
tendon
several
to the repair
site to act as a checkrepair.
We do not find these
tech-
JOURNAL
OF
BONE
AND
JOINT
SURGERY
FRACTURES
niques
to be routinely
to protect
was
the safety
excellent
in
however,
repair
they
as well
of beginning
twenty
can
help
side.
drews
and
patellectomy
severely
Similar
results
Hughston.
be done
extensor
Total
that
none
mechanism
(50
per
cent),
patients
with
were
reported
of it can
by
An-
that
patella
total
is so
be used
as part
separation
of the
and
ment
of tight
may
compromise
prolonged
worrisome,
swelling
as they
and range-of-motion
begun.
Unfortunately,
are
strength,
common
Einola
had
power
the
et al.9 found
a patellectomy,
that
was
power
of
that,
equal
the
knee.
than
Jakobsen
continuous
of the knee
of fragments
and
bone
motion
However,
patellar
quadriceps
power
to be, on the average,
of the opposite
limb. Three
long-term
cent
al.5
cartilage.
This
an osteochondral
two-thirds
studies43237
surface.
after
evaluated
the clinical
results
of patellectomy,
and while
this treatment
was found
to be better
than no treatment
at all, there
were
very few excellent
results.
When
reported,
the
reduced98.
cal reduction
quadriceps
strength
was
Most
authors
concluded
always
markedly
that an anatomi-
ofthe
On
poles
Comminution
rare
ofthe
with
Adequate
occasions,
remain
but
adequate
the
central
severely
comminuted.
A patella
tune pattern
can sometimes
be
reduction
and
internal
the distal
pole
(after
ments)
with
use of
VOL.
75-A,
NO.
fixation
and
of the
inferior
patella
proximal
is
fracopen
pole
with
use
be permitted
tion
that
of
1993
to maintain
postoperatively.
the patella
Even
fracture
is loaded
Weight-bearing
is satisfactory,
be permitted.
and the time
fractures,
a range
first several
weeks.
of motion
are
have
with
Thus,
for
of
in a
with
with
itself
weightbalance,
a range
of moof motion
before
a
The amount
that
is needed
depend
well fixed,
of motion
The ideal
not
minimized
state.
support
an external
as tolerated.
wound-healing
can generally
is allowed
on the
simple,
stability
transverse
of
can be initiated
within
the
techniques
for early range
been
identified.
active
flexion
mobilization
Disruptive
followed
forces
by
passive
techniques
Resistive
exercises,
however,
who have
well before
should
be
had
this
delayed
until there
is evidence
of fracture-healing.
tective
splint
and crutches
can generally
when
the
90 degrees
good
quadriceps
range
of motion
control
has
has
reached
and
returned.
Complications
to
removal
of the intervening
frageither
the modified
tension-band
10. OCTOBER
areas
of continuous
has not been
up in a non-weight-bearing
time.
Poles
superior
remaining
the role
fractures
held
Patellar
Mid-Part
portion
are
be most effective
been
treated
with
not increase
quadriceps
force;
it may actually
rethe force of the contraction
of the quadriceps
comwith the force
that results
from
the limb being
there
motion
may
rehealing
of an-
formed
early
postoperatively.
A removable
splint
may
be used
for protection
between
periods
of rehabilitation. With rare exceptions,
a range
of motion
should
be
initiated
by six weeks
to prevent
prolonged
stiffness
of
patellectomy.
Severe
ice
and
extension.
and secure
internal
fixation,
or partial
patwere
preferable
to total
patellectomy.
Total
should
be reserved
for salvage
treatment
that cannot
be fixed or treated
with partial
ellectomy,
patellectomy
of fractures
might
has
extension,
the
of the quadriceps.
range
of motion
is initiated
the operative
repair.
With
that
have
with
enythema
does
duce
pared
Once
of
contact
passive
improve
technique
fracture
It is generally
impossible
mechanically
unloaded
state
bearing,
should
found
as the
occur
and are at times
infection;
however,
they
and
exposed
passive
75 per
et
commonly
may suggest
excision
an extension
after
total
as well
Marked
despite
reasonable
of twenty-five
patients
who
only
seven
had
quadriceps
to or greater
intact
prolonged
articulan
patellectomy.
had
or
ticular
when
is sustained
tissue,
resolve.
the knee
in full
each contraction
of knee extensor
discomfort
9-A
with these
injuries,
it is important
closely
after the operation.
Place-
wound-healing.
one method
on another.
After
operative
repair,
these
patients
should
be managed
with application
of a cylinden or above-the-knee
cast for six weeks,
after which
the
a loss
persistent
(Figs.
frequently
of soft
fracture
no major
total
patellectomy,
may be the only
that
layer
bandages
determined.
of motion,
lag, and
described
Management
trauma
swelling
that occurs
to monitor
the wound
treatment.
The defect
resulting
from removal
of the patella can be closed
in a ventical,purse-stning,
on transverse
fashion.
There
is no convincing
evidence
to recommend
cast is removed
ing exercises
are
already
overlying
Postoperative
duce
stiffness
comminuted
fragments
fragment
remaining
intact,
its recognized
limitations,
of the
thin
usually
knee.
a severely
technique
Because
by the
Patellectomy
For
screw
9-E).
Postoperative
of forty
patients
patellectomy,
the
patients
of the
1559
PATELLA
early motion.
study
partial
They
recommended
only when
the entire
comminuted
of the
THE
on the
through
as to reas-
in eleven
(28 per cent),
fair in six (15 per cent),
poor
in three
(8 per cent)29.
Quadriceps
strength
on the average,
85 pen cent of the strength
on the
uninjured
with
soft-tissue
one long-term
follow-up
had been
managed
with
result
good
and
was,
necessary;
a tenuous
OF
Infection:
patellar
Fortunately,
infection
after
is uncommon;
however,
fracture
a repair
because
of a
the
I560
F.
J.
thin overlying
skin is often
be delayed
and infections
treated
sionally,
with
with
local
open
by delayed
damaged,
wound-healing
may develop.
Infection
closure.
managed
initially
with
However,
if the
infection
ous
or if there
sis, a formal
ROBERTA
incision
and
antibiotics.
the
subcutane-
fracture
of septic
and
should
internal
fixation
be
may
osteoarthrobe performed,
of patehlar
complication
is most
commonly
or underappneciated
fragment
volving
the distal
fixation
wires
pole
(Fig.
fractures.
due to
comminution,
10). This
unrecognized
usually
condition
allows
of motion
prevent
further
displacement
while allowing
tory healing.
If, however,
major displacement
three
millimeters)
occurs,
a reoperation
sary. Partial
patellectomy
salvage
procedure.
This
avoidance
the
of open
quality
Knee
a patellar
of the
one
bone
or two
weeks)
and
internal
fixation
when
degrees
of flexion
Early
motion
may
help
to reduce
is lost
(within
the
full
first
incidence
of
stiffness,
so it is important
to obtain
Seat the time of the repair.
Prolonged
immohas been
contracture.
despite
treated
operatively
If an extension
develops
apy,
tune
operative
treatment
(removal
hardware
and knee
anthroscopy
intensive
of adhesions)
may be necessary.
verity
of the patellar
restriction,
lease,
or both,
may be necessary.
knee
should
be included
it should
be done
gently
Depending
lateral
or
Manipulation
of
with
osteoarthrosis:
Because
the patellofemorah
following
patellar
of the
1930
fractures.
to 1951,
patellar
needed
adequate
is probably
Irritation
subcutaneous
bone,
readily
after
not uncommon5.
S#{248}rensen3 evaluated
patients
ten to
thirty
years after a patellar
fracture
and found
that fortyfive (70 per cent) ofsixty-four
knees
demonstrated
patellofemoral
osteoanthrosis
compared
with twenty
(31 per
that
not
unite.
to be on the
treatment.
However,
if the
in noticeable
weakness
of
the
indicated
treatment
osseous
present,
hardware
defect.
partial
the
has
palpable.
irritating
bothersome.
However,
patellectomy
the
that
is necessary,
is open
excision
of intervenbone-grafting
if it is
the procedure
of choice.
from
hardware:
Because
removal
magni-
did
reported
fixation
with
supplemental
to correct
a large
bone stock is not
routine
joint,
postfracture
is
in
S#{248}rensen3 found
was
not need
or results
mechanism,
is
However,
fractures
of non-union
and internal
tissue
and
fraclysis
quad-
of ad-
fractures
were
more
often
non-union
was more
comstudy of patients
who had
and
follow-up
son mechanism
does
non-union
is painful
then-
on the semedial
neof the
Quadnicepsplasty
an associated
displaced
fracture
fixation
is frequently
knots
seem to be particularly
compromised
extensor
mechanism.
not indicated
unless
there
has been
niceps
or femoral
injury.
tude of the loads
across
traumatic
osteoanthrosis
physical
minimization
in
order
of 1 pen cent or less34. If non-union
does
occur,
treatment
should
be based
on the symptoms.
A patient
with a painless
non-union
and a well functioning
exten-
reduction
ing fibrous
while
the
re-
surface.
patellar
of the
the rate
of damage
fracture
non-union
after
a fracture
of
because
of the frequent
opera-
of
from
the extensor
of knee motion
after
than the exception.
contracture
Post-traumatic
neces-
is questionable.
of a knee
that
to postoperative
secondary
fixation
be
management
Recently,
type
good
Clearly,
the goal
of this complication
and
anticulan
Non-union:
Presently,
patella
is uncommon
cent
This
with
patellectomy.
is avoidance
reduction
to the
managed
blow.
even
Although
there
is no simple
way to
osteoanthrosis,
symptoms
may be
patellectomy.
elevation
of the tibial
fracture
insults
10 to 55 per
for satisfac(more
than
may
by accurate
been
Some
slight
loss
is the rule rather
only a few
is maintained.
postoperative
cure fixation
bilization
can lead
reduction
stiffness:
fracture
Generally.
extension
is generally
problem
or even total
management
tive
may
suspension
tubencle,
fracture
the
with
a direct
and repair7.
post-traumatic
with partial
the
If it
and
and
the
from
to osteoarthrosis,
duction
manage
reduced
in-
the distal
pole with contraction
of the quadriceps.
is recognized
before
there
is marked
displacement
the development
of articular
incongruity,
immobilization
in extension
through
resulted
lead
ditional
of
knee
to slide
This
substance
the
or screws
knees.
Osteoarthroincongruity
and the
which
lead to over-
and
can
followed
by delayed
closure.
Occasionally,
joint
aspiration through
an uninfected
area,
with a cell count
and
culture
of the fluid, helps
to guide
treatment.
Loss
of fixation:
Loss
of fracture
fixation
and reduction
is a disheartening
complication
after
open
reduction
care
is a question
drainage
L. S. MATTHEWS
below
infections
wound
extends
or, occafollowed
AND
Superficial
local
KASMAN.
can
be
can
wound
care and antibiotics
irrigation
and d#{233}bnidement
wound
tissue
CARPENTER.
patella
been
is a
used
we
for
Wires
and wire
to tissues;
screws
We do not think
but
if
remove
that
hardware
fracture
is solidly
united
discomfort.
In summary,
distraction
and
if the
patient
patellar
three-point
fractures
bending
usually
occur
from
of the patella
as well
as from
blows.
has
direct
for fractures
that are
tens and may include
Operative
tion, partial
patellectomy,
We have presented
a new
of a simple
transverse
results
in laboratory
treatment
displaced
more
open
reduction
or rarely,
technique
than
and
is necessary
two millimeinternal
fixa-
total
patellectomy.
for the stabilization
fracture
that has provided
superior
tests. Postoperative
complications
can be minimized
by good
attention
to wound
care,
accurate
fracture
reduction,
secure
fracture
fixation,
and
an early
range
of motion.
Despite
the surgeons
best
efforts,
however,
post-traumatic
osteoarthnosis
may develop
and may lead to additional
treatment.
THE
JOURNAL
OF
BONE
AND
JOINT
SURGERY
FRACTURES
OF
THE
1561
PATELLA
References
1. Andrews,
2.
J. R., and
Benjamin,
Hughston,
.J.; Bried,
J. C.: Treatment
J.; Dohm,
M.;
fractures.
J. Orthop.
3.
Bostman,
0.;
Kiviluoto,
0.;
and
4.
Bostman,
0.;
Kiviluoto,
0.;
Santavirta,
Trauma
Surg.,
5.
Bostr#{246}m, A.:
6.
Curtis,
7.
Donohue,
of the
.J. M.;
D.;
11.
Buss,
and
Acta
G. S., and
Annual
Meeting
Goldstein,
of The
S. A.;
D. P.; Carey,
12.
Grogan,
13.
Haajanen,
J., and
14.
Heckman,
.J. D.,
424-428,
15.
16.
17.
displaced
J.; and
of 422
of the
T. R., Jr.;
65-A:
patella
patella.
and
948-957,
fractures
ofthe
WiIppuIa,
E.: Fractures
fractures.
Acta
various
Med.
forms
patella.
of the
use
American
Academy
Weiss,
of
fixation
of
817,
1977.
transverse
patellar
Injury,
13: 196-202.
patella
treated
1981.
by operation.
Arc/i.
Orthop.
and
of two
T. P.; Leffers,
Alkire,
C. C.:
screws
and
M.;
Ogden,
titanium
and
of indirect
follow-up.
follow-up
patella.
patellar
cable
B.;
and
hundred
fractures.
for
the
Francisco,
Joint
blunt
143,
Surg.,
1972.
72-B(2):
trauma
on
280-282,
adult
1990.
canine
articular
Acta Orthop.
Scandinavica,
60: 712-714.
1989.
results
with
special
reference
to functional
of patella
of the
Feb.
L. S.:
patella.
consecutive
A
fixation
California.
Matthews,
fractures
One
pole
San
Meller,
of the
Distal
effects
A 30-year
Long-term
Surgeons,
Grossnickle,
D.; and
Supplementum
J. Bone
1976.
of Orthopaedic
E.: Fractures
Scandinavica,
methods.
1983.
of cannulated
A.-P.;
Orthop.
A comparison
Thompson,
Sept.
47: 441-447,
J. D.: The
E;
G. R., and
165-168,
1979.
Huberti,
H. H.;
2: 49-54,
proposed
common
in children:
a report
Patellar
J. Pediat.
cases.
fractures.
Ann.
surface
Orthop.,
Chir.
Poster
exhibit
at the
18. 1993.
strain.
70: 32-35,
of injury.
Am.
J. Bone
and
Res.,
4:
1990.
10: 721-730,
Gynaecol.,
mechanism
J. Orthop.
1981.
J. Sports
Med.,
12:
Hung,
Ackroyd,
Hayes,
C. E.: Sleeve
W. C.;
Stone,
fractures
J. L.; and
of the
Shybut,
patella
G. T.: Force
ratios
in the
of three
quadriceps
cases.
tendon
and
Joint
ligamentum
Surg.,
61-B(2):
patellae.
J. Orthop.
1984.
L. K.; Chan,
16: 343-347,
K. M.; Chow,
Y. N.; and
Leung,
P. C.: Fractured
patella:
operative
treatment
using
the
tension
band
principle.
Injury,
1985.
18.
.Jakobsen,
19.
Kaufer,
H.:
Levack,
B.;
20.
A study
fractures
Oegema,
Karaharju,
and
Southern
of
1984.
Houghton,
Res.,
patella.
Surg..
Coale,
1986.
Comminuted
S.; Nirhamo,
Scandinavica,
Cole,
372-377,
patellectomy.
evaluation
Orthop.
Goings,
by partial
Biomechanical
1987.
Nirhamo,J.:
for
Joint
B.; Johnell,
S.; Aho,
A.
fractures
M.:
1983.
fixation
J. Bone
Edwards,
Einola,
78-81,
Fracture
disability.
10.
102:
of patellar
McMurtry,
1: 219-222,
M. J.: Internal
cartilage.
8.
9.
Trauma,
and
J.; Christensen,
K. S.; and
Mechanical
function
Flannagan,
J. P.; and
Rasmussen,
of the
0.
patella.J.
Hobbs,
5.: Patellectomy.
Bone
A 20-year
andJoint
S.: Results
Surg.,
of surgical
follow-up.
53-A:
Ada
1551-1560,
treatment
of
Orthop.
Dec.
patellar
Scandinavica,
56: 430-432,
1985.
1971.
fractures.
J. Bone
and
Joint
Surg.,
67-B(3):
416-
419, 1985.
21.
Matthews,
L. S.; Sonstegard,
navica,
22.
48: 511-516,
Merchant,
Joint
A. C.; Mercer,
Surg.,
56-A:
D.
A.;
and
Henke,
J. A.:
Load
bearing
characteristics
of the
R. L.; Jacobsen,
1391-1396,
and
Cool,
C. R.:
Roentgenographic
analysis
Muller,
M.
25.
Group,
Peeples,
translated
by J. Schatzker.
Ed. 2, pp. 348-252.
New York,
Springer.
1979.
R. E., and Margo,
M. K.: Function
after
patellectomy.
Clin. Orthop.,
132:
26.
Perry,
C. R.;
McCarthy,
J. A.;
clinical
study.
J. Orthop.
Trauma,
Rae,
Rorabeck,
P. S., and
29.
Smidt,
31.
Sarensen,
32.
Sutton,
Thompson,
June
34.
Thompson,
35.
Weber,
36.
of the
Wendt,
Joint
37.
VOL.
75-A,
andJoint
M. J.; Janecki,
NO.
Scandi-
of patellofemoral
congruence.
J. Bone
and
J. Biomech.,
H.:
R. L.:
Manual
Patellar
3: 431-451,
1970.
Internal
Fixation.
of
180-186,
fixation
Techniques
Recommended
a load-sharing
cable:
by
the
AO
1978.
protected
with
a mechanical
and
1988.
fixation
of osteochondral
dislocation
of the
fractures
patella
with
of the
patella.
osteochondral
Injury,
fracture.
A review
of eighteen
cases.
J. Bone
McClellan,
R. T.; Schneider,
andJoint
of knee
after
flexion
fracture
C. H.; Lipke,
Surg.,
J.; and
L. A.;
72-A:
and
extension.
of the
Matthews,
Oct.
Acta
6: 79-92,
Orthop.
D. B.: The
L. S.:
Results
of
treatment
of
displaced
patellar
1990.
J. Biomech.,
patella.
Kettelkamp,
and
1279-1285,
1973.
Scandinavica,
effect
34:
of patellectomy
198-212,
1964.
on
function.
knee
J. Bone
and
Joint
Surg.,
1976.
experimental
study
of surface
67-A:
10, OCTOBER
73-A:
C. J.; McLeod,
726-732,
Fracture
Surg.,
patella.
.1. Bone
and
P. P., and Johnson,
Wilkinson,J.:
Orthop.
injury
to articular
cartilage
and
enzyme
responses
within
the joint.
Cliti.
Orthop.,
1975.
Bone
Surg.,
Pearson,
screw
Bone
model.J.
Acta
1976.
analysis
R. C., Jr.: An
107: 239-248,
and
Herbert
prognosis
and
W. P.: Acute
J. A.;
late
Willenegger,
C. C.;
patellectomy.J.
K. H.: The
in locomotion.
R.;
2: 234-240,
237-240,
G. I.: Biomechanical
537-540,
Kain,
Z. M.:
Goulet,
function
Schneider,
Bobechko,
58-B(2):
by partial
30.
33.
and
C. L.;
fractures
58-A:
Khasawneh,
Surg.,
Saltzman,
of muscle
Allg#{246}wer, M.;
C. H.,
andJoint
mechanics
R. H.;
Morrison,
27.
joint.
1974.
24.
28.
J. B.: The
Oct.
23.
E.;
patello-femoral
1977.
990-1001.
J. L.; and
Aug.
P.; Nelson,
Wallace,
C. L.; and
Thompson,
Joint Surg.,
62-A:
215-220,
March
1980.
R. P.: A study
of quadriceps
excursion,
June
of the
L.: Osteoarthrotic
changes
after
acute
transarticular
load.
An
animal
1991.
J. A.:
torque,
Efficacy
and
the
of various
effect
forms
of patellectomy
of fixation
on
of transverse
cadaver
knees.
59-B(3):
352-354,
fractures
.1. Bone
1985.
patella
1993
treated
by total
excision.
A long-term
follow-up.J.
Bone
andJoint
Surg.,
1977.
and