Sample Qualitative Study
Sample Qualitative Study
Sample Qualitative Study
A Thesis Proposal
Presented to the
Faculty of Graduate School
St. Paul University Philippines
In Partial fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
Master of Arts in Education
Major in Guidance and Counseling
by:
MARIA ROSANNA A. DAUIGOY
July, 2012
Chapter 1
Introduction
The new century dawns with colossal changes in all
facets
of
human
existence.
In
these
contemporary
times,
reality
positions
young
people
in
stormy
and
the
society.
development
now
Traditional
stand
at
practices
re-defining
concerning
moment.
youth
School
from
restructuring
the
center
exists,
(Lashway,
through
2010).
innovative
and
Current
creative
brace
them
in
traversing
through
the
21st
century.
Contemporary leaders in education are engaged in out-ofthe-box thinking and creating a vision which translates to
action.
Stakeholders
as
one
body
collaborate
to
when
only
the
institution
head
decides
on
matters
fresh
methods
and
techniques,
new
standards,
21st
loud
call
to
remodel
rather
outdated
school
guidance
efforts
in
installing
comprehensive
guidance
and
states
Gysbers.
School
counseling
and
programs
of
the
future
and
to
start
today
in
the
Philippines
can
seize
this
moment
and
action
researcher
(Clemena,
included,
2010).
started
Guidance
to
Counselors,
invest
time,
this
effort
and
counselors.
trainings
to
in
are
translate
the
Academic
field
and
inspirations
visions
of
into
school
professional
that
moved
actions.
Recent
counseling
sparked
fervor
for
the
21st
century
counselor
to
take
on
restructuring
with
the
K-12
curriculum,
will
dispositions
be
equipped
needed
for
with
better
knowledge,
adjustments
skills
in
and
higher
education.
The current Guidance Program of the Isabela National
High School, the largest public secondary school in the
Province of Isabela is forty years old and evidently, its
responsiveness
generated
much
to
the
demands
concern.
of
Steep
the
present
times
in
tradition,
has
public
operational
for
so
long
may
have
been
adequate
in
the
The
development
of
its
learners.
guidance
the
integral
role
of
Guidance
in
the
Isabela
There
in
activities
the
of
1920s
and
counselors
consists
around
of
six
organizing
major
the
services:
Duties
Model
simply
lists
the
duties
that
counselors
of
this,
guidance
was
seen
as
an
ancillary-
administrative
clerical
duties.
Due
to
lack
of
program.
As
result,
guidance
and
Counseling
entitled,
(2010)
conducted
study
The
School
and
sought
to
determine
the
extent
of
descriptive
questionnaire
survey
based
on
which
made
the
Villar
use
of
Guidance
revised
Evaluation
was
implemented
to
great
extent.
Furthermore,
Guidance
Program
was
high.
The
extent
of
the
the
students
based
on
the
recommendations
and
10
program
was
implemented
to
great
extent
except
for
cater
to
the
needs
of
the
clients
to
some
degree.
for
Recommendations
were
regularly,
improve
it
as
to
be
follows:
the
Career,
fully
functional.
Program
Research
be
evaluated
and
Placement
present
study
endeavored
in
redesigning
the
current
(2009)
Guidance
in
and
her
book,
Counseling
Implementing
Program
in
a
the
11
Assessment
of
the
target
population
to
make
the
Goals
should
be
and
Objectives
specific,
emanating
pertinent,
from
attainable
needs
which
measurable,
financial,
human
material
and
time,
Strategies
Program
Program
Implementation
Evaluation
to
to
carry
determine
the
out
the
benefits
plan
of
and
program
delivery.
Realizing
organizational
oriented
rather
pattern
rather
than
the
than
weak
for
guidance
program
proactive,
points
the
of
the
which
focused,
reasons
traditional
was
position-
remedial-reactive
why
guidance
was
found
need
to
address
this
concern
when
he
guidance
Program
seven steps:
groups,
assess
compare
current
While
program
Living
in
In
his
It.
book,
He
Remodel
described
the
program,
with
select
program
program
model,
model,
establish
12
Gysbers
asserts
different
sense
that
of
doing
so
fulfillment
gives
since
the
she
counselor
can
see
a
the
your
published
by
School
American
Guidance
Counseling
Program,
Second
Association,
ed.
contained
was
founded.
Its
structural
Components
cover
the
13
individual
placement.
appraisal,
Responsive
individual
services
are
advisement
delivered
and
through
support
includes
professional
development,
outreach
program
and
research,
community
relations,
council,
community
advisory
management
and
operations.
Program
time deals with how time should be spread across the total
program. Resources which are crucial to the success of the
program included human, financial and political components.
This program model leads to guidance activities and
structured group experiences for all students. Counselors
are
kept
busy
because
they
have
guidance
program
to
It
is
proactive
rather
than
reactive
and
is
because
of
standards-based
educational
movement
14
effectiveness
was
very
little.
In
response
to
this
elementary,
America
and
Association
middle
crafted
National
and
the
high
school
American
Standards
counselors
School
for
School
in
Counselors
Counseling.
and
Career,
nine
Standards
and
specific
Standards
in
2003
ushered
in
unique
period
of
by
Graham-Migel
(2002),
The
Comprehensive
Guidance and Counseling Programs: The Beechville-LakesideTimberlea Experience. BLT Schools in Nova Scotia, Canada
with a population of 1200 from primary grade nine was
chosen by the Education Department to pilot a CGCP starting
in the school year 1996-1997. This manuscript presents an
overview of the program and its development after a fiveyear implementation and represents a guidance counselors
perspective, outlining the various components of the program
that
were
initiated
to
meet
the
students
needs.
It
15
of
students,
community
program
evaluation,
involvement.
The
staff
training
and
Comprehensive
Guidance
and
consultant,
guidance
counselor,
administrators,
CGCP
at
the
BLT
Schools
was
evaluated
to
be
very
Guidance
and
Counseling
Programs
Among
as
well
as
the
various
components
of
school
of
128
practicing
counselors
in
Midwestern
analyzed
using
descriptive
analysis.
The
School
16
Counselors
Awareness
of
Secondary
School
Comprehensive
highly
components
aware
of
the
of
the
objectives
comprehensive
and
guidance
the
and
different
counseling
vision,
clearly
goals
explained
communication
and
and
objectives
and
of
CGCP
opportunities
collaboration
are
are
of
fostered
specific,
extensive
among
all
Research
Journal
of
International
Studies
Nigeria.
personnel,
services
Qualification
availability
were
of
hypothesized
of
guidance
facilities
not
to
and
and
counseling
quality
significantly
of
predict
17
student
adjustment.
practicing
guidance
Sixteen
secondary
counselors
were
schools
tested
with
with
420
inadequate
counseling
facilities
and
guidance
services
they
provide
to
secondary
students
in
how
to
improve
guidance
and
counseling
services
to
within
developed
comprehensive
school
in
which
students,
the
there
is
outcomes
a
and
match
the
among
the
needs
intervention
of
the
selected.
18
success
and
comprehensive
school
counseling
groups
classes
and
and
classes,
motivational
time
management
approaches
such
as
groups
and
behavioral
and
counseling
Henderson
programs.
and
Myrick
sample
of
models
269
school
for
school
counseling
The
questionnaire,
cover
letter
for
their
within
two
months,
102
were
retrieved.
The
results
19
system
school
planning,
guidance
responsive
curriculum,
services
and
individual
system
student
support.
The
guidance
is
an
ancillary
service
rather
than
an
Counseling
Materials:
investigate
Programs
survey
national
of
Use
of
National
trends
in
Guidance
Trends.
the
use
Curricula
It
of
aimed
to
curriculum
and
in-service
school
counselors
summary
of
of
practices
to
an
educational
program
20
materials
used
in
their
CGCP
including
the
the
district
objective(s)
guidance
addressed
by
and
the
counseling
curriculum
program
materials.
In
component
as
teaching-learning
process
aids
in
guidance
related
resources
being
used
any
differences
included
real
implementation
emerged
the
across
following:
develop
levels.
school
Missouri) was
consistency.
grade
by
Curricular
Recommendations
district-wide
guidance
develop
and
implement
through
guidance
classroom guidance
curriculum
that
21
State.
They
randomly
selected
150
elementary
moderately
implemented
implemented
reported
counseling
for
Initially,
programs
the
counseling
program.
and
students
or
Comparative
those
in
program
that
schools
had
with
highly
data
no
no
were
programs.
counseling
in
implementation,
both
high
schools,
usage
those
schools
students
did
better
in
high
on
both
The
researchers
suggest
that
their
findings
be
Missouri
Comprehensive
Guidance
Program
had
been
socio-economic
status
of
the
students
because
of
its
following
findings
based
on
hierarchical
linear
22
used
the
same
set
of
data
and
research
The
follows:
students
implemented
findings
who
reported
in
attended
schools
comprehensive
school
their
study
with
were
more
counseling
as
fully
programs
all
Counseling
theoretical
of
them
dwelt
Program.
framework
The
of
on
Comprehensive
present
the
study
CGCP.
The
is
Guidance
based
studies
on
and
the
reviewed
23
Local
Efforts
to
Adopt
the
American
School
Counselors
future
thus
asserts
Dr,
Carol
Dahir,
Counselor
and
practitioners.
one
of
Americas
top
school
counseling
the
Counselor
guidance
Philippines
Skills
and
and
conducted
Development
counseling
which
another
was
practitioners
workshop
designed
develop
on
to
help
and
hone
24
To
benchmarks
lay
for
the
groundwork
school
for
the
counseling
development
programs
in
of
the
in
the
Philippines.
She
based
her
suggested
development.
ASCA
defines
Standards
as
and
personal-social
development
that
promote
and
in
the
Philippines.
program,
performance
or
The
ethical
book
did
standards
not
include
but
instead
professionalization
are
not
enough
assurance
that
25
guidance
counselors
develop
more
responsive
the
educational
system
in
trying
to
improve
student
achievement.
During
Association
of
the
the
Integrated
Professional
Philippines
(IPCAP)
Counselors
3rd
annual
how
professional
counselors
everywhere
would
of
the
students.
Their
competencies
are
thereby
make
difference
in
the
lives
of
the
students
in
26
minimum
indicator,
and
its
application
is
then
of
Guidance
Counselors
in
Implementing
School
Fifty participants in
the
focus
group
discussion
(FGD).
Appropriate
and
27
tasks
they
perform
appropriate or not.
and
indicate
whether
these
are
successes
problems
of
Quantitative
and
school
and
failures
counselors
as
qualitative
counselors
and
data
and
counseling
were
common
programs.
collected
using
process
needed
to
come
up
with
book
on
General
Agreement
About
Components
Of
where the
(GCC)
professional
Convention
Workshop
organizations
of
in
Manila,
counselors
officers
and
of
graduate
28
practitioners
development
of
Programs.
The
and
find
National
convention
out
Model
implications
for
School
participants
who
to
the
Counseling
came
from
officers
important
from
professional
because
advancement
of
of
the
their
profession.
organizations
leadership
Given
was
role
their
deemed
in
the
exposure
to
tapped
Four
to
guide
provide
relevant
questions
for
research-based
discussion
were
29
the
needs
of
the
students
in
specific
learning
institution.
(3) A need for the ASCA National Standards to be
adopted with innovations to suit multicultural diversity of
Filipinos although additional components and features were
proposed to make it culture-sensitive.
program.
information
different
All
campaigns
stakeholders
groups
saw
the
and
orientation
for
them
to
need
to
programs
know
the
conduct
for
the
nature
and
Another
popular
suggestion
was
to
involve
councils.
Professional
leaders
emphasized
the
the
Philippine
Association
for
Education,
of
counseling
standards
in
practitioners
Guidance
and
towards
Counseling
developing
and
their
30
questions.
Individual
and
group
responses
were
All the
counseling
efficiency
and
effectiveness
to
be
With
reference
to
counselors,
three
groups
for
Guidance
and
Counseling
Programs
on
the
31
national
level
while
the
present
study
has
similar
information
about
the
opinions,
perceptions,
and
Barbour,1999).
They
are
use
to
draw
out
(1997)
methodology
stated
with
that
the
in
order
philosophical
to
align
research
underpinnings
of
the
primarily,
greater
quantitative
recognition
and
perspectives
acceptance
of
to
newer,
and
to
better
design,
assessment,
applicability
focus
program
serve
as
methods
clients.
groups
can
development
be
and
of
gathering
Depending
used
on
for
evaluation
the
needs
by
32
and
useful
than
traditional
research
methods
counselor
can
be
used
to
encourage
focus
group
This
explains
why
many
counseling
human
development,
empowerment
and
cultural
groups
gathering
contribute
are
one
information
to
practical
and
improved
and
effective
conducting
counselor
research
practice
means
of
that
can
(Kress
and
Shoffner, 2007).
Pabiton C.P.,(2003) a former counselor educator from
De
La
Salle
University
and
presently
member
of
the
33
The
main
purpose
of
which
is
to
and
determine
education
heads
were
also
looked
into.
Data
gathered from the study will form the baseline data for a
nationwide survey on counselor licensure. The focus group
discussion (FGD) was used as a research method since no
documented information on this topic was available locally.
Qualitative data was collected from four FGDs composed of
guidance counselors who were grouped homogenously to enhance
the quality of the data gathered thru FGD. The researcher
organized
the
FGDs
using
the
developmental
level
of
UP
Manila,
Diliman
and
Centro
Escolar
34
prohibition
qualification
exemptions
against
for
from
the
practice
examination,
taking
of
Scope
examination,
of
counseling,
examination,
renewal
of
license,
for
the
licensure.
Moreover,
the
participants
to
for
counselor
study
the
and
education
heads
implement
specific
professional
standards
and
of
government
measures
Guidance
in
and
(2007),
also
present
member
of
the
workers
specifically
the
new
entrants
to
the
for
collecting
the
desired
data
was
focus
group
35
employees per batch with age range from 20-30 years old.
In
as
interview
guides.
Findings
from
personal
professionalism/work
operating
growth
ethics,
procedures,
relationships,
opportunities
structured
good
challenging
to
engage
and
in
the
study
(financial
development,
and
objective
working/interpersonal
work/work
leisurely
variety
and
pursuits)
while
search
for
excellence
through
their
human
local
and
multinational
companies
operating
in
the
36
Conceptual
Framework of Reference
Norman Gysbers, PhD. and Patricia Henderson, EdD
Your
expanded
and
School
Guidance
extended
the
Program
implementation
substantially
steps
of
out
in
70s
in
another
book
with
Gysbers
as
the
of
the
change
process
is
Awareness of the
helpful
since
this
37
attempt
will
lead
to
confusion,
anxiety,
anger
and
struggle
to
survive.
Along
the
way,
resistance
to
Development
of
trust
and
confidence
among
contribute
to
the
establishment
of
leadership
for
also
includes
forming
and
convening
school-
be headed by a community
personnel
shall
directly
assist
in
the
planning
change
going
and
guard
oneself
from
wavering
and
38
Provide a leadership
II.
from
language
planning
enables
through
the
students,
next
four
parents,
phases.
Common
teachers
and
This is
39
planning
takes
place.
Within
the
basic
framework,
the
services
counselor
to
be
time
provided
must
be
and
the
tailored
allocation
of
specifically
to
The
need
to
gather
information
of
students
and
program
relevance
of
must
be
considered.
services
is
ascertained.
With
this
Current
data,
resources
Perceptions
about student needs and what they should know and be able to
do
and
opinions
about
the
current
program
provide
Interviews
From
this
point
under
the
third
phase
of
the
40
to
educate
school
administrators
and
other
people
more
responsive
discussion
inputs
Guidance
will
serve
Program.
as
bases
These
for
focus
a
redesigned
group
41
organizing
and
conducting
seven
(7)
focus
group
this
research
study
will
answer
the
following questions:
1.What are the inputs of the stakeholders of Isabela National
High School towards:
1.1
1.2
The
current
Guidance
Program
of
Isabela
National
High School.
1.3
2.What
are
the
common
concerns
coming
from
the
different
groups of stakeholders?
3.What is the Redesigned Guidance Program based on the result
of the study?
42
learning.
school
Research-based
stakeholders
redesigning
administrators
which
will
traditional
in
setting
perceptions
serve
program
policies
as
will
for
from
valid
different
bases
motivate
an
in
school
effective
and
data
to
bolster
their
confidence
in
planning,
guidance
program
will
enhance
their
43
Teachers.
from
their
end can
surely be
program
will
motivate
them
to
work
understanding,
childrens
involvement
academic,
and
vocational
support
and
for
their
personal/social
development.
Students.
comprehensive
guidance
program
made
to
in the attainment of
academic,
As
Guidance
evolved
into
variables
program development as
indigenous model that
learners in the
that
they come
influence Guidance
up
will address
with
their
own
44
inputs
on
school-based
initiative
to
Purposive
sampling
was
used
to
identify
the
to
gather
the
data.
Qualitative
method
using
Definition of Terms
The following terms are operationally defined to
provide clarity of their use in the course of the study:
Comprehensive Guidance and Counseling Program. A 21st
century Model program that leads to guidance activities and
structured
group
experiences
emphasized
administrative
and
for
all
clerical
students.
tasks,
It
de-
one-to-one
45
Focus
Group.
It
is
carefully
planned
series
of
and
Counseling.
It
is
profession
that
well-
functioning
him/her develop
individual
primarily
by
helping
interest
Are
all
in
the
those
people
continuing
who
have
effectiveness
a
and
School
employers
and
communities
(Gross
and
46
Chapter 2
METHODS AND PROCEDURES
Research Design
The
descriptive-qualitative
research
design
was
47
sampling
was
utilized
to
determine
the
sample
into
two
groups:
the
first
group
composed
of
comprised
the
Alumni
group.
Six
(5)
people
48
and
after
signifying
their
intention
to
group discussions were held in the school and two (2) were
held outside due to conflicting schedules of the invited
participants.
The researcher functioned as moderator and facilitated
the focus group discussions.
team
member.
Furthermore,
observations
of
group
in
the
disseminated
conduct
before
of
the
focus
start
group
of
the
discussion
discussion
were
and
49
Debriefing
with
the
assistant
moderator
group
discussion
to
ensure
accuracy.
The
Framework
Instrumentation
Six (6) process questions based on the objectives of
the
study
were
formulated
by
the
researcher
with
the
the
assistance
of
Dr.
Norman
Gysbers,
considered
by
with
him
through
the
The researcher
electronic
and
that
can
be
addressed
by
the
Guidance
50
2.
What
are
the
current
Guidance
services
and
4.
5.
Data Analysis
The Framework Analysis Method by Krueger (1994) and
Ritchie and Spencer (1994) was used for the qualitative
analysis of the focus group interviews.
process
using
thematic
approach
It is an analytical
that
allows
themes
to
research
participants.
This
analysis
is
systematic,
Furthermore,
increases
the
it
extent
provides
of
trail
dependability,
of
evidence
and
consistency
and
51
by
lifting
the
quotes
from
their
original
52
REFERENCES
Books
American
School
Counselors
Association
(2005).
The
ASCA
School Counseling
Systematic
School
Improvement.
Lanham.MD:
Guidance
and
Counseling
Program
(5th
ed).
53
School
Counseling
Programs
in
the
Philippines.
and
Stone
(1981).
Fundamentals
of
Guidance
(4th
Boston, MA.
Implementing a Comprehensive
Aligned
Transformations
Publications.
Makati,
Philippines.
Journals
Abiva , T.G. (2004). The Counselor in the 21st Century. The
Guidance Journal.
1-8
Psychology. 1-20
On-Line Databases