The Power of Batteries: The Story of BYD: 2.1 A Fast Growing Legend
The Power of Batteries: The Story of BYD: 2.1 A Fast Growing Legend
The Power of Batteries: The Story of BYD: 2.1 A Fast Growing Legend
Abstract This chapter discusses the case of BYD, a leading new-energy powered
carmaker in China. Its vision capitalizes on the trend of emerging new energy
industries, and the case will examine its ability to integrate business lines to
generate synergies and its unique business development model that has attracted
global investors including Warren Buffet.
Keywords New energy Rechargeable batteries New-energy-powered automobiles Electric-power storage stations Vertical integration Industry chain
On September 29, 2008, Warrant Buffett announced his USD $230 million
investment to acquire 10 % of shares of a Chinese company called BYD, a firm
that makes the next-generation batteries, electric cars and consumer electronics
parts. BYD was actually the second Chinese company that Warren Buffett chose to
invest. Since then, the price of BYD stock shoot to the roof, jumping nearly 10
times, and the initial investment of Buffet also appreciated from $230 million to
$2.3 billion in merely one year. As an investor famous on gains from long-holding
strategies, the speed and rate of return for his investment in BYD may seem a
sweat surprise for Warren Buffet. No question, the secret for BYDs success
for both its business and its getting such a favor from Warren Buffett and the
global financial market would be intriguing, and lets take a close look at it.
All data for BYD are from Prospectus of BYD, 2011 unless indicated otherwise.
Worldwide Market Update on NiMH, Li Ion and Polymer Batteries for Portable and the Future
Applications, Institute of Information Technology (IIT), 2010.
3
Analyst Report on BYD, Guotai Junan Securities, 2011.
2
So the question is, what actually happened behind these magical numbers, and
what business models and strategies powered BYD for its fast development and
drove BYD to where it is today. Lets take a closer look.
http://www.caam.org.cn/newslist/a35-1.html
10
5
6
http://www.casted.org.cn/en/web.php?NewsID=5327
http://auto.sohu.com/20120712/n348008224.shtml
11
On the other hand, the economy of scale plays an important role in the auto
industry, and it wont be profitable until a certain level of scale is achieved.
Therefore, it is usually difficult for a new company to be able to conduct largescale production and secure the operation funds from day one. In addition, there is
also high requirement for the technology used, and a company may be stuck in an
unfavorable situation if it lacks independent research ability and its core
technology.
12
cameras, digital video cameras and MP3 have gradually become parts of consumers daily life, and lithium-ion battery has been gradually adopted in these
electronic products. As a result, the demand for lithium-ion battery has been
increasing significantly. Meanwhile, the market share of NI-MH battery and
nickelcadmium cell has been decreasing due to the low energy density. However,
the NI-MH battery market share remained stable due to the demand from the
hybrid cars. In addition, the government policy supports towards the new-energydriven automobiles will further increase the demand of rechargeable battery
including NI-MH battery, because such battery serves a critical role for newenergy-driven cars.
More specifically, there are three factors that BYDs rechargeable batteries
powered the success of BYDs car business. The first one is BYDs independent
research that enabled BYD to develop the lithium iron phosphate battery, which is
a safer, greener, longer lasting, and less expensive technology with a technical
advantage over the NI-MH battery in the operation of hybrid electric vehicles
(HEV) in terms of energy density, power generating, discharge rate, and the
improvement in the acceleration performance, maximum speed and endurance of
cars. At present, BYD has more than 100 lithium iron phosphate battery patents
and more than 90 patent applications.
The second one is the better power generator for the electric vehicle that BYD
produced. The permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM) developed by BYD
has bigger power, torque, and lower weight-to-power ratio, with productivity of
560 kw, which can completely meet the requirements of dual-mode electric
vehicles and Blade Electric Vehicles (BEV).
The third one is the synchronized power control system. The integrated power
control system of BYD matches power cell, driving motor and the whole vehicle
system all together. This system combines the hybrid mode and the EV mode, and,
in this way, the goal of going green and environment protection is also achieved
in the sense that cars may only rely on the battery when the cell is full. When
battery is low, however, it will be switched to the hybrid mode and the fuel
efficiency is also raised.
13
efficiency. Therefore, solar energy has become one of the major trends of future
energy development in the world, including China.
Technically, however, the solar and wind types of energy cannot be integrated
directly to the traditional power grid due to their highly dependence on the
environment and unstable power. For this reason, electric-power storage stations
can help smooth the electricity power provision of solar energy and solve the issue
of instability. In addition, the electric-power storage station can store the energy
surplus and release them when there is a need or shortage. This functionality of
electric-power storage station can adjust and iron out the peaks and troughs in
the electricity demand curve.
According to a forecast released by Pike Research, the market scale of energy
storage stations will increase from USD $1.5 billion in 2010 to $35.3 billion in
2020.7 With the development of the new-energy-generated electricity and smart
grid, the large scale of commercial application of the electric-power storage station
will be accelerated, and this will greatly enhance the development of the new
rechargeable batteries represented by the iron cell. According to the data provided
by the European Photovoltaic Industry Association (EPIA), the installed capacity
of solar energy reached 7,203 MW in 2009, and will reach 0.3 billion MW in
2014, and the sales revenue of solar energy battery will attain $165 billion in
2015.8
Holding the core technology and well maintained government relationship,
BYD has become the leader in the new energy industry in China by making great
effort and progress in the new energy automobiles, solar energy and electric-power
storage stations.
The key for new energy vehicle is the battery which is also one of the most
important factors that customers are concerned on new energy vehicle. The
competition of new energy vehicles boils down to the competition of the batteries.
However, BYD started the R&D on battery technology very early and gained
tremendous early comer advantages. BYD is now a leading electric vehicle maker
in the entire world. In 2008, BYD introduced the hybrid car F3DM which was the
first model not relying upon the professional charging stations, and electric car E6
and electric bus K9 appeared later. BYDs good government relationship also
helped BYD promote and commercialize its electric vehicles successfully. In
2010, BYD sold 1,000 K9 electric bus to Changsha municipal government. In
addition, in 2011, BYD signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the
SMRT Corporation in Singapore, which manages public transportation of Singapore, for further cooperation in the electric buses and taxies, and an agreement
with the DAN Bus Company in Israel to replace the half of its current operating
vehicles with BYDs electric bus, which is also the first time for Israel to have the
full-sized electric bus. Whats more is that the BYDs E6 pure electric taxi running
in Shenzhen has very good performance. On average, every E6 car has been
7
8
14
running over 1 year and 100,000 km without any technical defects and the quality
of battery has been tested to be highly stable and reliable. Motivated by the
maturing technology, abundant government subsidies, and the establishment of the
charging facilities, the electric vehicle industry starts to grow fast, and BYD is
undoubtedly the largest beneficiary.
Solar energy is another revenue engine for BYD in its initial fieldrechargeable battery industry. BYD has established a vertical integration of business lines
including poly-silicon, Silicon chip, battery module and packaging. BYD entered
into the solar industry in October 30, 2008 by taking the Solar Cell Project from
the Shangluo municipal government in Shanxi province. This is a multi-phased
construction program for an annual productivity of 1 GW poly-silicon and 1 GW
solar energy. In the first phase of project, BYD had achieved the annual output of
100 MW poly-silicon and 100 MW solar energy in 2010, and in phase two, it had
realized the annual output of 300 MW in 2011. So far, the annual output has risen
to 600 MW and the ultimate goal is to reach 1 GW annually. The businesses of
solar cells and parts have brought revenue of RMB 759 million to BYD. For any
solar energy companies, the core competence would be the energy conversion
efficiency and the conversion cost. As for the energy conversion efficiency, BYD
has a leading edge of 16.5 % of efficiency in the world. Then, for the conversion
cost, BYD adopted the metallurgical method instead of the traditional Siemens
process.9 This helps BYD lower down its cost by 20 %. With the superiority in
cost and efficiency, solar cell has become the important cash cow of BYD.
BYD also did well in the electric-power storage stations. The iron cell of BYD
has an advantage over those traditional lead acid batteries in that iron cells have
high-power chargedischarge property and avoid the problem of instability of
wind energy and solar energy. BYD got the pilot project to build up the electricpower storage stations and the energy conversion system for the China Southern
Power Grid Co. in August 2010. Later, BYD started cooperation with the Los
Angeles Department of Water and Electricity (LADWP) in the project to develop
the renewable electricity power grid in September 2010. BYD also signed a
contract with the Changsha municipal government for a project of a 10 MW
electric-power storage station. With the support of the various level of government
in and outside China, BYD made the steady progress in the commercialization of
electric-power storage stations.
15
16
17
its advanced battery technology. Rupert Hoogewerf10 once said, Chuangfu Wang
follows the trend in scientific and technology development, innovation in new
energy, and the rising environmental concerns, and thus, created a new pattern in
the auto industry.
Furthermore, the BYDs vertical integration covers a whole industry chain
including energy generation, collection, transportation, charging, electro mobile
parts, and electro mobiles. According to a forecast issued by the World Bank,11 the
market value for the entire automobile chain can reach USD $280 billion by
2020a very promising future for the companies in the industry. And currently,
BYD is the only auto company who has integrated the whole industry chain.
Rupert Hoogewerf, born in Luxembourg, is the publisher of the Hurun Report, a monthly
magazine best known for its China Rich List, a ranking of the wealthiest individuals in China.
As a qualified chartered accountant, Hoogewerf worked for 7 years at Arthur Andersen, before
launching Hurun Report.
11
The China New Energy Vehicles Program: Challenges and Opportunities, World Bank, 2012.
18
http://www.springer.com/978-3-642-44912-3