ELSSG04
ELSSG04
ELSSG04
September 2013
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for
Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
PUBLISHING HISTORY
September 2008
September 2013
Issued
Complete Revision
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for
Secondary Selective Substations
Table of Contents
1. Introduction......................................................................................................2
1.1 Purpose............................................................................................................................ 2
1.2 Scope............................................................................................................................... 2
2. References.......................................................................................................2
2.1 Process Industry Practices............................................................................................... 2
2.2 Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)...................................................2
3. Definitions........................................................................................................2
4. Requirements...................................................................................................3
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5
4.6
4.7
4.8
4.9
4.10
4.11
4.12
4.13
4.14
General............................................................................................................................. 3
Operational Interlocks....................................................................................................... 4
Manual Operation............................................................................................................. 6
Automatic Operation......................................................................................................... 6
System Security................................................................................................................ 7
Double Tie-Breaker Construction......................................................................................7
Arrangement of Controls.................................................................................................. 8
Alarms and Indication....................................................................................................... 8
Example Diagrams........................................................................................................... 9
Nameplates.................................................................................................................... 13
Inspection and Testing.................................................................................................... 14
Documentation............................................................................................................... 15
Shipment........................................................................................................................ 16
Conflict Resolution.......................................................................................................... 16
Page 1 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
1.
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
Introduction
1.1
Purpose
This Practice provides requirements for automatic transfer systems for two-source
secondary selective substations.
1.2
Scope
This Practice describes minimum requirements for design, performance, inspection,
testing, and documentation, for delayed transfer automatic transfer systems (ATS) for
two-source secondary selective substations. ATS provides automatic restoration of bus
voltage upon loss of one of the sources. This Practice also covers remote monitoring and
control requirements. This Practice does not cover fast transfer or delayed in-phase
transfer systems.
2.
References
Applicable parts of the following Practices, industry codes and standards, and references shall be
considered an integral part of this Practice. The edition in effect on the date of contract award
shall be used, except as otherwise noted. Short titles are used herein where appropriate.
2.1
2.2
3.
Definitions
closed transition transfer: A transfer system designed such that both sources of the secondary
selective system are connected at the same time during power transfer. This results in the
temporary paralleling of sources, and prevents a bus from being de-energized while switching
sources. Also known as make-before-break operation.
delayed in-phase transfer: Type of open transition transfer system typically used when a fast
transfer attempt fails (i.e., after approximately 10 cycles). The system waits for the next in-phase
event to transfer (i.e., typically within 20 cycles).
delayed transfer: Type of open transition transfer system designed to wait for a predetermined time
(i.e., typically greater than 20 cycles) or decay of bus voltage to a predetermined level after a bus
power source is removed before connecting the bus to another source. This type of transfer is not
Page 2 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
intended to maintain process continuity; certain motor driven loads may necessitate restart of the
motors on the bus. Also known as slow or long time transfer.
fast transfer: Type of open transition transfer system designed to prevent paralleling of both
sources, but minimize the time to reclose and restore power (i.e., typically less than 10 cycles)
open transition transfer: A transfer system designed such that one main breaker of the secondary
selective system is opened before the tie breaker closes, thereby permitting a bus to be deenergized during the switching process. Also known as break-before-make operation.
owner: The party who owns the facility wherein the automatic transfer system equipment will be
used
purchaser: The party who awards the contract to the supplier. The purchaser may be the owner or
the owners authorized agent.
secondary selective substation: A distribution system with two radial systems with a normally
open secondary tie breaker or double tie breaker between them. The tie may be a cable between
an extra breaker on each bus of two distant stations or a tie breaker between the buses of two
stations located close together.
supplier: The party responsible for manufacturing, furnishing and/or installing the automatic
transfer system equipment
system faults: Phase and ground faults where referenced in this Practice
4.
Requirements
4.1
General
4.1.1
Unless otherwise specified on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet, the ATS
component materials, wiring, and nameplate requirements shall be in accordance
with this Practice and the switchgear Practices PIP ELSSG01 or PIP ELSSG02.
4.1.2
The ATS architecture shall be based on multifunctional devices IEEE Std C37.22008 device number 11 (MFR), or a programmable logic controller (PLC)
supported scheme as specified on the purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet.
This Practice is not intended for implementation with hardwired systems.
4.1.3
Where this Practice references a control switch associated with the ATS, the
control switch functionality may be part of an MFR or PLC if the same degree of
control capabilities is provided. Final implementation of control switches shall be
agreed with owner before start of fabrication.
4.1.4
If an MFR is provided for both protection and control functions, the protection
and control configurations should be developed concurrently to avoid creating
two configuration files with the capability of one to overwrite the other.
4.1.5
MFR or PLC shall have an internal self check fault analysis system that verifies
the software and hardware integrity of the device itself. A common, fail-safe
alarm shall be provided to indicate a system failure for remote indication.
4.1.6
Page 3 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
52A and 52B in Figure 1) closed. Unless otherwise specified on purchasers PIP
ELSSG04D Data Sheet, device 52T operation in this Practice shall include double
tie-breakers as a sub-system. See Section 4.6.
4.1.7
The ATS shall be designed with both manual and automatic modes of operation
in accordance with Sections 4.3 and 4.4, respectively.
4.1.8
4.1.9
MFR and PLC control power shall be provided by separate and individually
protected DC or redundant UPS AC control power circuits.
4.1.10 A detailed control and testing procedures shall be developed and submitted for
owner approval before equipment manufacturing for new systems or before
implementation on existing systems.
4.1.11 Design of the controls shall be logical and clearly labeled.
4.1.12 If indicated on the contract drawings or purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet,
a mimic diagram shall be provided on the front of the ATS equipment.
4.1.13 Event recording (i.e., historian) functionality shall be provided to facilitate
analysis of system operation including failure of the ATS.
4.2
Operational Interlocks
4.2.1
4.2.2
If the ATS Not Ready alarm is activated, the ATS system shall be disabled. See
Section 4.8.3.
4.2.3
Synchronism check function shall interlock the manual transfer operation to:
a. Prevent manual closed transition (i.e., parallel) operation if the sources are
not synchronized
b. Permit breaker closure by control switch if any two breakers are open
Comment: If an additional power source is connected to a bus (e.g.,
connection to a generation source such as a stand-by generator),
additional functionality may be required.
4.2.4
Page 4 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
4.2.5
System faults that are not cleared by out-going secondary circuit protective
devices shall open the incoming breaker (see 52-A or 52-B in Figure 1). The tie
breaker shall remain open and the ATS shall be automatically locked out.
4.2.6
If a differential device (e.g., 87B, 87T, 87G) detects a fault, the following shall
occur:
a. The ATS shall be blocked from operation.
b. The automatic reset shall not be used.
c. If a transformer differential interlock is specified on purchasers
PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet, the ATS shall be blocked if a transformer
differential is initiated.
Comment:
4.2.7
4.2.8
4.2.9
For a closed transition operation (see Section 4.3), an interlock with the
following characteristics shall be provided:
a. The time duration of the parallel condition shall be the shortest duration
possible. The duration can be instantaneous (e.g., by monitoring the position
of the breaker status contacts); however, if a time delay is required, a delay
no greater than 2 seconds shall be implemented, unless otherwise specified
on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet.
b. Failure of any one control device (e.g., PLC, MFR, etc) shall not disable the
interlock.
c. The interlock shall only be implemented if all three breakers are fully
inserted in the operating position.
4.2.10 The system configuration shall permit removal and/or testing of an MFR or PLC
without initiating an automatic transfer operation.
4.2.11 Closing of the tie breaker during an automatic operation shall be blocked by one
or both of the following interlocks:
a. A residual voltage interlock reading the bus voltage.
Comment: Once the respective bus main breaker opens, the interlock keeps
the tie breaker from closing until the bus voltage decays to a
predetermined level, typically 0.25 pu voltage.
b. A timer that provides a delay after the main breaker opens.
Comment: In certain applications (e.g., large motors with capacitors) the
timer may need to be set to a relatively long time.
Page 5 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
4.2.12 Typically both interlocks described in Section 4.2.11 must be cleared to close the
tie breaker. However, if specified on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet, the
logic may be changed to either of the two interlocks being cleared to close the tie
breaker. See section 4.4 and Figure 3.
4.2.13 The ATS system shall be disabled if either of the main breakers fails to open on
command or the tie breaker fails to open on command, see Figures 3 and 4.
4.3
Manual Operation
4.3.1
4.3.2
4.3.3
For an open transition operation, the ATS shall permit dead-bus closing of the
main breakers; however, interlocks related to fault detection shall remain
operational.
4.3.4
For a closed transition operation, the ATS interlocks shall be in service except for
the residual voltage interlock and transfer timer.
4.3.5
Execution of the closed transition requires one of the breakers to be opened after
the system is paralleled. Therefore, the ATS shall include a breaker selector
switch with the following capabilities:
a. Controls to open the selected breaker once the system is paralleled in
accordance with Section 4.2.9.
b. Controls to prevent reclosing of the selected breaker.
c. Only operational if the system is being manually operated.
4.3.6
Except for the case in Section 4.3.7, manual open transition operation shall be
permitted without the automatic operation components. Therefore the following
shall apply:
a. A failure of the PLC shall not prevent manual and safe operation of the
switchgear.
b. Failure of an MFR used for the dual purpose of protection and control shall
not cause loss of manual transfer control.
4.4
4.3.7
4.3.8
Automatic Operation
4.4.1
Page 6 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
4.4.2
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
4.5
4.6
4.4.3
If voltage on both Circuit A and Circuit B is lost, incoming breakers 52A and 52B
shall remain closed and tie-breaker 52T shall remain open.
4.4.4
If voltage of Circuit A is lost, the main breaker shall open after a predetermined
time; however, the ATS shall block the tie breaker from closing if the voltage on
Circuit B is below acceptable levels. Likewise, transfer from Circuit B to A shall
be blocked in the same manner.
4.4.5
The tie breaker shall remain open if either incoming breaker (52A or 52B) is
opened by its protective device or control switch.
4.4.6
System Security
4.5.1
System devices that execute control of the system shall be provided with security
measures to avoid inadvertent or malicious tampering as specified on purchasers
PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet (e.g., MFRs / PLCs may have the capability of
password or key-switch protection).
4.5.2
4.5.3
System security shall be reviewed with owner and shall be consistent with
existing security procedures.
If double tie breakers are provided, the operation of the tie breaker system shall
be in accordance with this Practice.
4.6.2
One tie breaker shall be designated as the automatically controlled tie breaker.
The other tie breaker shall be manually operated only.
4.6.3
The ATS shall control the automatically operated tie breaker only.
4.6.4
Tie breakers shall be interlocked such that the automatically operated tie breaker
can only be closed once the manually operated tie breaker is closed. Execution of
this interlock shall only be permitted if both breakers are fully connected.
4.6.5
For normal operation, the automatically controlled tie breaker shall normally be
open, and the manually controlled tie breaker shall normally be closed.
4.6.6
Page 7 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
4.7
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
Arrangement of Controls
4.7.1
4.7.2
Centralized ATS controls shall be arranged such that an operator can maintain
sight of all critical indications and measurements while operating the system. The
following capabilities shall be provided:
a. All measurements, indications and control devices can be interpreted and
operated while an operator stays in place.
b. Unless otherwise specified on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet, the
height and configuration of controls shall be between 48 inches (122 cm) and
60 inches (152 cm). Indications and measurements shall not be located
greater than 78 inches (198 cm) above grade.
4.7.3
4.7.4
4.7.5
4.7.6
4.8
As a minimum, the following control indicator lights shall be provided near the
ATS control switches/panel:
a. ATS Ready to Transfer
b. Unless otherwise specified on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet,
Sources In Sync indication for each breaker
c. Open and close breaker position for each main and tie breaker
4.8.2
As a minimum, the following alarms for remote indication shall be provided with
the ATS.
a. ATS Not Ready, see 4.8.3.
b. Abnormal System Configuration, initiated if the system is not in the normal
configuration with both mains closed and the tie breaker open, and if any of
the main and tie breakers are not fully installed in the connected position
c. ATS Failure, from MFR or PLC self-check system
Page 8 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
ATS Not Ready alarm shall be initiated and the ATS Ready to Transfer indication
shall go out if any of the following events occurs:
a. Alternate source voltage not available (i.e., outside acceptable range or
sources not in synchronism)
b. Fault detected (i.e., system blocked by time-overcurrent or differential
device)
c. Control device failure (e.g., MFR, PLC)
d. DC or redundant UPS AC power supply failure
e. If specified on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet Loss of Line potential
transformer (PT) alarm
f.
4.9
4.8.4
A form c alarm contact shall be provided for annunciating each of the alarm
conditions listed in Section 4.8.2 to owners alarm-monitoring system. Unless
otherwise specified on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet, alarm contacts
shall have a minimum rating of 2A at 120VAC and 125VDC.
4.8.5
Example Diagrams
4.9.1
One-Line Diagram
4.9.1.1
4.9.1.2
4.9.1.3
Page 9 of 16
COMPLETE REVISION
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
September 2013
CIRCUIT B
Communications
Sense line UV,
initiate transfer to
B, block transfer
from B, sync
check.
MFR
MFR
52B
52A
MFR
N.C.
N.C.
52T
N.O.
BUS A
Sense bus residual
voltage, block
transfer, sync check.
BUS B
IF REQUIRED
4.9.2
Block Diagrams
4.9.2.1
4.9.2.2
4.9.2.3
Page 10 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
Page 11 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
Page 12 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
4.10
Nameplates
4.10.1 Nameplates shall be provided in accordance with this Practice and the
requirements in the switchgear Practices PIP ELSSG01 or PIP ELSSG02
referenced on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet.
4.10.2 Permanent engraved lamicoid nameplates shall be provided identifying the
control devices, voltage indications and control indicator lights of the ATS.
4.10.3 Stand-alone ATS panels shall include a stainless steel nameplate identifying the
manufacturer, year of manufacture, and shop order number.
Page 13 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
4.10.4 If a mimic diagram is specified on the purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data Sheet,
the diagram shall be provided as follows:
a. As a minimum, the diagram shall show the configuration of the system,
buswork, circuit breakers, supply sources, load designations, voltage
transformers, and current transformers.
b. Breaker control switches shall be beside the breaker symbol.
c. Devices shall be labeled using engraved lamicoid.
d. The mimic buswork and components shall be attached with stainless steel
screws.
4.11
Page 14 of 16
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
4.12
COMPLETE REVISION
September 2013
Documentation
4.12.1 Documentation Content
4.12.1.1
4.12.1.2
4.12.1.3
All control programs (e.g., MFR settings, MFR or PLC logic, etc.)
shall be provided to owner.
4.12.1.4
Page 15 of 16
COMPLETE REVISION
PIP ELSSG04
Automatic Transfer Systems for Secondary Selective Substations
September 2013
B
For
Review
X
C
Final
Certified
X
D
As
Built
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Description
Bill of materials giving schematic identification,
quantity, make, rating, model, and manufacturer of
component
Extended warranty information
Proposed layout of equipment, showing estimated
dimensions and weights
Equipment drawings, showing floor plans, front
view elevations, relay and control device panel
layouts, typical sectional views. Drawings shall
show all locations of all equipment and devices.
Installation drawings, showing dimensions and
weights of all shipping sections and location and
type of all interconnections between shipping
splits
Connection wiring diagrams for all electrical
equipment
Logic scheme documents
Certified Test Reports
Installation, Operation, and Maintenance Manual
Complete parts list
Recommended priced spare parts list
Device software
Notes:
A. These documents shall be provided with proposal.
B. These documents shall be provided for purchasers review and authorization to proceed before
fabrication.
C. These documents shall be provided as part of the final certified document submittal.
D. As-built documents shall be provided within 2 weeks following shipment.
4.13
Shipment
Preparations for shipment shall be in accordance with the requirements in the switchgear
Practices PIP ELSSG01 or PIP ELSSG02 referenced on purchasers PIP ELSSG04D Data
Sheet.
4.14
Conflict Resolution
Any conflicts between the referenced documents shall be identified in writing to the
purchaser for resolution. If resolving conflicts, the following order of precedence shall
apply:
Purchase Order
Page 16 of 16