ACTG 2011 - Midterm Package - 2012-2013
ACTG 2011 - Midterm Package - 2012-2013
ACTG 2011 - Midterm Package - 2012-2013
MIDTERM Exam-AID
Review Package
Tutor: Balpreet Singh ([email protected])
York SOS
1
Preface
This document was created by the York University chapter of Students Offering
Support (York SOS) to accompany our ACTG2011 Exam-AID session. It is
intended for students enrolled in any sections of 2012/2013 INTRODUCTION TO
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING II-ACTG2011 course who are looking for an
additional resource to assist their studies in preparation for the exam.
References
Friedlan, John (2010). Financial Accounting: A Critical Approach 3rd Ed.
McGraw Hill.
All of the money raised through SOS Exam-AIDs is funneled directly into
sustainable educational projects in developing nations. Not only does SOS fund
these projects, but SOS volunteers help build the projects on annual volunteer
trips coordinated by each University chapter.
York SOS
2
Introduction to Financial Accounting I
Chapter 1 What is Accounting
Accounting System for producing information about an entity and communicating it to users for
decision making
- The more and better information a person has about a situation the better decisions possible
- Information costs money
- Information is limited and thus decisions must be made on assumptions and predictions
2 Fields of Accounting
- Financial Accounting Provides information to people who are external to the entity. (E.g.
Investors, CRA, Lenders, customers). These stakeholders must rely on entity for info
- Managerial Accounting Field of Accounting that provides information to managers of the
entity. This information assists them in making decisions for entity.
Accounting Environment
- Preparers of accounting information must assess who is using statements and for what reason
- The accounting environment influences whom entities provide information to
Entities
- Corporations Separate Legal entity created. Different shareholders have shares in the corporation.
The shareholders are given limited liability.
Corporations can also be private were on person owns all shares
Public Corporations Corporations whose shares are publicly traded in the stock market
- Proprietorship One owner, Unlimited Liability
- Partnership Owned by 2+ people, Unlimited Liability
- Individuals Also accounting entities as they must file tax returns through CRA
Stakeholders
- After looking at different entities we need to access their stakeholders (anyone who has a interest in
the company) their decisions and how the accounting financial statements are prepared accordingly.
(e.g. Owners, Lenders, Suppliers, Customers, Shareholders, Government, regulators)
Constraints on Managers & Financial Reporting
- IFRS, GAAP for Private Enterprise (ASPE), CRA, Canadian Business Act
Page 2 of 28
- Stock exchange securities law
- Voluntary contracts to accounting a certain way
- Bank/lender covenants
Preparers of Financial Statements: decide how and when to release company financial statements and
are not neutral
Managers bonus sometimes based on F/S
Tax paid based on F/S
Business selling price based on F/S
- This conflict requires external opinion
External Auditors They examine the companies F/S in an external audit. Employed by
management or CRA to confirm taxes
Page 3 of 28
Liquidity: Entitys abilities to pay its obligations as they come due
o Working Capital = Current Assets - Current Liabilities
o Current Ratio Current Assets/Current Liabilities
Owners Equity: Owners capital in entity after liabilities
o Owners Investment in the company. The part of the assets they own.
o Indirect Investment: Reinvested Net Income accumulated into retained earnings for
shareholders (if retained earnings negative then deficit)
o Direct Investment: Money given by shareholders for shares in the company. This goes
into capital stock
o Dividends: Payment of the corporations assets usually in cash to shareholders
(Dividends reduce retained earnings)
2) Income Statement: How did we do? Measures Economic performance for an entity over a period of
time
Net Income = Revenue - Cost of Sales - Operating Costs
2 Methods of Accounting
o Cash Basis: Reports Cash in and Cash Out through Cash receipts
o Accrual Basis: Records transactions when they have occurred rather than cash flow
Extended Accounting Equation
o A = L + OE + R V E
Gross Margin = Sales V Costs of Sales
Gross Margin % = Gross Margin/Sales
3) Cash Flow Statement: Shows how cash is obtained and used and used over a period (Cash from
operations, Cash from investing activities)
4) Statement of Retained Earnings: Summarizes changes in retained earnings in period (Bridges the B/S
& I/S)
RE at year end = RE at beginning of year + Net Income - Dividends Declared
Shareholders Equity = RE + Capital Stock
o Dividends is not an expense, it is a reduction in OE
5) Notes in Financial Statements: Expand on Information in F/S, Provide additional information in F/S,
provide additional information and help stakeholders assess entity
Give information on accounting Policies and practices of company
Page 4 of 28
Chapter 3: Accounting Cycle
Accounting Cycle: Process by which data on economic events are entered into an accounting system,
processed, organized & used to make F/S
1. Economic Event/Transaction
2. Prepare Journal Entry
3. Post Journal Entry to General Ledger
4. Prepare & Post Adjusting Entries
5. Prepare Trial Balance
6. Prepare Financial Statement
7. Prepare & Post Closing Entries
1) Economic Event/Transaction: Not all information captured by the accounting system. Financial
Statements do not give exact picture of entity.
Financial Statements are consolidated to make the information more concise
F/S are made comparing 2 years
F/S are made for a period of time that is constant and continuous
2) Prepare Journal Entry: Identify transactions
Which elements are affected
What specific accounts and how are those accounts affected (DR/CR) and by how much
o Increase in Assets & Expense Debit
o Increase in Liabilities, OE, Revenue Credit
I. A = L + OE + R V E
3) Post Journal Entry to General Ledger
General Ledger is a record of all accounts
Posting V Transferring journal entries to the general ledger
T accounts represent general ledger
4) Prepare & Post Adjusting Entries
Adjusting Entries are not triggered with outside entries
o Must make adjustments for accrual system of accounting to update accounting system,
Generally:
Expense and Revenue recognition can happen at different times
Each entry includes a B/S account and I/S account
Each adjusting entry has other entry before or after it
Page 5 of 28
General tips on adjusting Entries
o Needed only when F/S prepared
o Never use cash account
o One B/S & one I/S account
4 Types of Adjusting Entries
I. Deferred Expense V Prepaid Expense V Cash Paid before expense
DR Expense, CR Asset
II. Deferred Revenue V Cash received before revenue recognized
DR Liability, CR Revenue
III. Accrued Expense V Expense realized before paid
DR Expense, CR Liability
IV. Accrued Revenue V Revenue realized before cash
DR Asset, CR Revenue
5) Prepare Trial Balance
6) Prepare Financial Statement
7) Prepare & Post Closing Entries
Closing Entry V To Close revenue & expense accounts into retained earnings (CR retained
earnings if net gain)
Page 6 of 28
C: Collection of Payment is reasonably assured
M: Costs to Earn Revenue Measurable- Matching
P: Performance has occurred V Transfer of risks and rewards
Page 7 of 28
o Influence Stock Price
o Increase Selling Price of Company
o Ability to get loan
o Control Shareholders
o Maintain Loan
o Manager Bonus
Reduce Income: Tax Minimization
o Big Bath: Put more expenses in one year to make next year better
Smooth out income
Constraints
Limit choices available to managers
IFRS, GAAP
Powerful Shareholders
Auditors
Facts: Issues that surround the transactions/economic events
Cash
collection Cash on Cash from
Cash used to from hand investments or
reinvest in customers loans
business or pay
creditors/ share
profits with
shareholders Purchase of
Sale of inventory,
goods marketing,
etc.
Page 8 of 28
Cash lag: delay between expenditure and receipt of cash
Inventory conversion period: time between delivery of inventory from supplier and sale to customer
Payables deferral period: time between receiving goods from supplier to time of payment to supplier
Receivables conversion period: time between delivery of goods to customer to time payment is
received from customer
Inventory self-financing period: time between inventory is paid to supplier to time payment is received
from customer
Total cash lag= payables deferral period + inventory self-financing period
OR inventory conversion period + receivables conversion period
Example: Schulich Corp. purchases books from suppliers and has 30 days to pay once they are delivered.
Customers have 60 days to pay their invoices once they purchase the goods. The books are normally
held for 50 days in the warehouse until sold to customers. What is the inventory self-financing period?
Answer: Total cash lag = inventory conversion period (50 days) + receivables conversion period (60 days)
= 110 days
Total cash lag (110 days)= payables deferral period (30 days) + inventory self-financing period
Inventory self-financing period = 80 days
Page 9 of 28
Step 2: Remove items included in net income calculation which have no effect on cash flow (e.g.
depreciation expense does not involve a cash outlay). If the item was subtracted to get to net income,
add it back and vice versa.
Step 3: Adjust for changes in non-cash working capital accounts
Accounts receivable increased from previous year subtract
Inventory increased from previous year subtract
Accounts payable increased from previous year add
In general , if an operating asset has increased, you will always subtract it from the CFO and if
decreased, you will add it to the CFO. If an operating liability has increased, you will always add
it to the CFO and if it decreased, you will subtract it from the CFO.
Page 10 of 28
still be successful
-selling capital assets and raising
equity to cover negative CFO
- + - -downsizing entity
-depending on sale of assets to
cover debt payments and
negative CFO
- - + -growing entity
-debtors and creditors are
providing financing for growth
- - - -not sustainable for entity, will
lead to eventual failure
Page 11 of 28
Chapter 6: Cash, Receivables, and the Time Value of Money
Unit-of-measure assumption:
All economic activity of an entity can be reported in terms of a single unit of measure (e.g. Canadian
dollars)
Page 12 of 28
Example: There is a lack of segregation of duties in the purchasing department since the
purchasing manager has the power to both order and pay for the items ordered. This can lead to
a misappropriation of assets as the purchasing manager can do a number of fraudulent things
such as create a fictitious supplier and pay for goods that were never delivered (and pocket the
money himself).
Step 3: Give a recommendation on how to improve this internal control
Example: Once the purchase order is placed by the purchasing manager, the order should be
forwarded to the warehousing clerk who will be responsible for reconciling that the amount
ordered is the same as the amount received. The warehouse clerk will then forward the invoice
to the accounts payable department, who will pay the suppliers in order to ensure segregation
of duties.
Receivables
Sometimes customers will receive a discount if they pay early (e.g. on a $1,000 invoice, 2 percent
discount is given if paid x number of days before it is due so only 980 must be paid)
Page 13 of 28
Dr. Cash 980
Dr. Discount on A/R 20
Cr. Accounts Receivable 1,000
Uncollectible Receivables:
Direct write-off method: item by item basis, recognized when it becomes apparent that the customer
will not pay poor matching since this is not known until a period of time passes, which could cause
recognition of bad debts in a different period than in which the revenue and receivable arose
Journal Entry: Dr. Bad Debt Expense xx
Cr. Accounts Receivable xx
THE DIRECT WRITE-OFF METHOD IS NOT ACCEPTED UNDER ACCRUAL ACCOUNTING
Percentage of receivables method: estimation at the end of the period of percentage of receivables
that will not be collected better matching since recognized in same period
Balance sheet approach since an aging schedule of receivables is used to estimate the allowance for
uncollectible accounts and the allowance is the main focus whereas the bad debt expense is simply
there to balance the entry
Journal Entry: Dr. Bad Debt Expense xx
Cr. Allowance for uncollectible accounts xx
Percentage of credit sales method: estimation at the end of the period of percentage of credit sales
that will not be collected
Income statement approach since management uses a historical rate of collection of credit sales to
calculate the bad debt expense, which is the focus of this method while the allowance for bad debts is
the balancing amount to the entry
Journal Entry: same as above
Page 14 of 28
Long-term receivables:
Receivables due in more than a year or operating cycle
If interest is not being paid on the long-term receivable or the interest is below the market rate, revenue
amounts will be too high
The entry should be recorded at the time of sale at its present value:
Dr. Long-term receivable PV
Cr. Revenue PV
At every period ending, an adjusting entry should be made for the amount of interest accrued. This will
bring the Long-term receivable up to the value that will be received in the future by the time it is due:
Dr. Long-term account receivable xx
Cr. Interest Revenue xx
At the time it is due/paid, the long-term receivable will be equal to the amount of money received from
the customer. First, the long-term account receivable must be reclassified to become current since it is
due in this period:
Dr. Accounts Receivable yy
Cr. Long-term Account receivable yy
Dr. Cash yy
Cr. Accounts receivable yy
Chapter 7 Inventory
What is inventory?
IAS 2 defines inventory as, assets held for sale in the ordinary course of business
(finished goods), assets in the production process for sale in the ordinary course of
business (work in process), and materials and supplies that are consumed in production
(raw materials)
Classification as inventory depends on what an entity does
Manufacturing companies, companies that process inputs into finished goods, can break
inventory down into three subcategories: Raw Materials, Work-in-Process, and Finished
Goods
Where is inventory reported? Which financial numbers are affected by inventory valuation?
Which financial ratios are affected by inventory valuation?
Cost of inventory on hand is reported on the Statement of Financial Position (Balance
Sheet) and cost of inventory sold is reported on the Profit and Loss Statement (Income
Statement)
Page 15 of 28
Valuation of inventory on hand would affect current assets, as well as total assets, and the
amount for cost of goods sold would affect reported earnings on the Income Statement
Financial accounting measures and ratios are affected by the cost formula used because
cost of inventory and cost of sales is different under each approach
o gross margin, return on assets, return on equity, profit margin, current ratio and
debt-to-equity ratio differ for each of the cost formulas
Inventory Control Systems: Perpetual Inventory Systems and Periodic Inventory Systems
A perpetual inventory control system keeps an ongoing tally of purchases and sales of inventory,
and the inventory account is adjusted to reflect changes as they occur
o Computerized system of keeping track of inventory
o Can determine cost of sales at any time and is recorded at the time of sale (transactional
entry)
Page 16 of 28
A periodic inventory control system does not adjust the inventory account after every
transaction and purchases are accumulated in a separate purchase account
o Inventory balance at the end of a period is determined by a physical count of inventory
o Cost of sales is determined indirectly: Cost of sales = Beginning inventory + Purchases
Ending Inventory
o No journal entry is recorded for cost of sale until the end of the period when the
inventory is physically counted
The choice between a periodic and perpetual inventory control system is an internal control
issue, not an accounting issue
Page 17 of 28
o FIFO results in a higher current ratio when prices are rising as compared to the average
cost method
o Stakeholders who base predictions on an income statement based on FIFO might
overestimate future profitability
o Average cost provides a balance sheet measure of inventory which is not as current as
FIFO but cost of sales is more current than with FIFO
What are the tax implications of the chosen accounting policy for valuing inventory?
Income Tax Act is not very specific about accounting for inventory, in the calculation of taxable
income ,which means that entities will use the inventory accounting methods selected for
general purpose financial statements for tax purposes as well
Entities are also allowed to use the LCM rule for tax purposes which allows the taxpayer to
reduce income taxes by writing down the value of inventory to NRV
Entities are restricted to change inventory valuation methods for tax purposes from year to year
without justifiable reasons
Inventory management
Inventory turnover ratio provides information on how efficiently inventory is being managed by
measuring how quickly the entity is able to sell its inventory
o Inventory turnover ratio = Cost of sales / Average Inventory
o Average inventory can be calculated by summing the amount of inventory at beginning
and the end of the period and dividing by two
o A higher inventory turnover ratio is better because it indicates that the entity can sell or
turn over the inventory more quickly
The average number of days inventory on hand indicates the number of days it takes an entity
to sell its inventory
o Average number of days inventory on hand = 365/inventory turnover ratio
o A company improves its efficiency by reducing the number of days it holds inventory on
hand and indicates that the inventory is more liquid
Page 18 of 28
Chapter 8 Capital Assets
What qualifies as an Asset under IFRS?
Resources that contribute to earning revenue over more than one period by
helping an entity produce, supply, support, or make available the goods or
services it offers to its customers
Are not bought and sold in the ordinary course of business, unlike inventory
Categories of capital assets: Property, plant and equipment; intangibles; and
goodwill
o Property, plant and equipment are tangible items that are held for use in
the production or supply of goods or services, for rental to others, or for
administrative purposes are expected to be used during more than one
period
o Intangible assets are capital assets without physical substance
o Goodwill is an intangible asset that arises when one business acquires
another and pays more than the fair value of the net assets purchased
Interest can be capitalized but only until the asset is ready for use, after which it is
expensed
Costs that are not necessary or related to the acquisition, such as repairs or
unnecessary work caused by poor maintenance, should NOT be capitalized
A betterment increases the future benefit associated with a capital asset, perhaps
by increasing the assets useful life or improving its efficiency or effectiveness,
and should be capitalized and depreciated over the remaining life of the asset
Expenditures enabling an asset to do what it is designed to do are considered
repairs or maintenance and should be expensed when incurred
IFRS uses the term depreciation for the process of allocating the cost of property,
plant and equipment to expense and amortization for intangible assets; depletion
is used for natural resources
IAS 16 defines depreciation as the systematic allocation of the depreciable
amount of an asset over its useful life
o Depreciable amount is the cost of an asset, or other amount substituted for
cost, less its residual value
o The depreciation method used shall reflect the pattern in which the assets
future economic benefits are expected to be consumed by the entity
Not all assets are depreciated
o Land is not subject to depreciation because it does not wear out or become
obsolete (an exception is land mined for natural resources)
o Intangibles with indefinite useful life are not amortized
o Internally generated intangible assets not amortized
o Goodwill is also not amortized
Several methods are accepted for deprecation and each of them allocates the cost
of a capital asset to expense in a different way, resulting in different net income
and carrying amount of the asset
o Under straight-line depreciation, the depreciation expense is the same in
each period, implying that the contribution to revenue by the capital asset
is the same each period
Depreciation expense = Cost Estimated residual value
Estimated useful life
o Accelerated depreciation methods allocate more of the cost of a capital
asset to expense in the early years of its life and less in the later years
based on the assumption that the assets revenue-generating ability is
greater in the early part of its life
Appropriate for assets sensitive to obsolescence and assets that
clearly lose efficiency and/or effectiveness over time (e.g. high-
tech equipment)
Depreciation expense = Carrying amount at the beginning of
period * Rate
o If an assets consumption can be readily associated with its use and not to
the passage of time or obsolescence, then a usage-based depreciation
method can be used
Unit-of-production method is the most common one but the
number of units that the asset will produce over an assets useful
life must be measurable
Depreciation expense = No. of units produced in the period * (carrying
Estimated no. of units produced amount)
over the assets life
What other alternatives are available to value Capital Assets other than historical cost,
under IFRS?
IFRS provides the option of valuing certain assets at market value using the
revaluation model
o Property, plant and equipment can be reported at market value if the
market value can be measured reliably
o Intangibles can be valued at market value if there is an active market for
them
o Gross method or the Proportional method can be used to revalue the
capital asset to its market value
o Gains are recorded in other comprehensive income in the statement of
comprehensive income and as accumulated other comprehensive income
revaluation surplus in the equity section of the balance sheet
o Losses due to revaluation are recognized in the income statement
o IFRS requires that revaluations be performed often enough so the
difference between the carrying amount and market value is not significant
based on the volatility in the price of the asset
Which intangibles can be recognized on the financial statements? How are they valued?
Under IFRS
Income Tax Act is very specific about how capital assets can be depreciated for
tax purposes
o Uses the term capital cost allowance (CCA) to describe depreciation for
tax purposes
o Very detailed about the method and rate that must be used for each type of
asset
o There is no choice or discretion available to the managers the rules in the
ITA must be followed exactly
o The half-year rule requires an entity to deduct for tax purposes, in the year
the asset is purchased, only one-half of the otherwise allowable amount of
CCA
Prevents entities from getting the full tax benefit from a new
capital asset if the asset is purchased late in the year
Hence, the choice of one depreciation method over another, for financial
accounting purposes, will have NO effect on the income taxes payable because all
entities are required to use the CCA method for tax purposes
o Reducing income tax expense can NOT be a valid motive in the choice of
choosing a depreciation method for accounting purposes
Current liabilities are obligations that will be settled in one year or one operating
cycle
o Important information for assessing the short-term liquidity of an entity
o Loans are reported as current liabilities if the amount has to be repaid
within the next year or if the loan is a demand loan, in which case it must
be repaid whenever the lender requests payment
o A line of credit allows an entity to borrow up to a specified maximum
amount whenever it requires the money
Is only classified as a current liability if money is actually
borrowed
o Accounts Payable are amounts an entity owes to suppliers for goods and
services
o Collections on behalf of third parties, such as GST or HST, does not
belong to the entity and a liability represents the obligation to remit the
amount
o Incomes taxes payable represents the amount of income taxes accrued
o Dividends payable is an obligation to pay the corporations shareholders a
dividend that has been declared
Is only recorded when a dividend is declared
o Accrued liabilities are recorded when an entity incurs an expense which
will be paid in the future (e.g. rent payable, wages payable)
o Provision is a non-financial liability of uncertain timing or amount
A non-financial liability is one which has no offsetting financial
asset on the books of another party
Payment is probable but amount is uncertain
Managements best estimate, expected value or the most likely
outcome should be used to record the provision
o Unearned revenue is recognized as a liability when an entity receives cash
in advance of providing goods or services (e.g. advance rent payment, gift
card purchases, points or rewards as part of a loyalty program)
Past transaction is the payment received in advance and agreement
on the services
Represents a future obligation to provide good or services
What is a bond? What are the characteristics of a bond? How is it recognized in the
financial statements?
What is a lease? What are the different types of leases and how are they accounted for
differently for financial reporting purposes?
A lease is a contract in which one entity, the lessee, agrees to pay another entity,
the lessor, a fee for the use of an asset
o An entity does not have to obtain separate financing for the purchase
which can be important when there is already a lot of debt and lenders
There are two categories of leases: capital or finance leases and operating leases
and each have different accounting implications
o A financing or capital lease transfers the risks and rewards of ownership to
the lessee and the leased asset and liability are recorded on the lessees
balance sheet at the present value of the lease payments to be made over
the life of the lease
A capital lease is considered to be similar to a purchase of an asset,
in substance, thus recognized on the financial statements in a
similar manner
o An operating lease does not transfer the risks and rewards of ownership to
the lessee but are retained by the lessor and the lessee recognizes an
expense when the payment to the lessor is paid or payable and the lessor
recognizes revenue from the lease when payments are received or
receivable
The lessee does NOT record the leased asset or the associated
liability on its balance sheet
Lessee has off-balance-sheet financing which may be preferable in
terms of decreasing debt-to-equity ratio
A lease should be classified as a capital lease if ANY of the following three
criteria are met:
o It is likely that the lessee will get ownership of the asset by the end of the
lease
o The lease term is long enough that the lessee receives most of the
economic benefits of the asset
What are contingencies? When and how are they recognized in the financial statements?
IFRS identifies economic events called contingent liabilities, which have the
following characteristics:
o A possible obligation whose existence has to be confirmed by a future
event beyond the control of the entity (e.g. lawsuit)
o An obligation with uncertainties about the probability that payment will be
made or about the amount of payment
A contingent liability is not recognized in the financial statements but is disclosed
in the notes unless payment is probable (>50%), in which case it is classified as a
provision and recorded
A contingent asset is an asset whose existence is uncertain
o Are NOT recognized in the financial statements, but are disclosed in the
notes if realization is probable
IFRS defines probable as more like than not
o The asset is only realized if the realization of the asset becomes virtually
certain (>95%)
What are subsequent events? When and how are they accounted for?
A subsequent event is an economic event that occurs after an entitys year-end but
before the financial statements are released to stakeholders
What gives rise to future income taxes? How are they accrued on the financial
statements?
Future income taxes appear as assets and liabilities on the balance sheet and they
are reported on the income statement as part of the income tax expense
Future income tax assets and liabilities and future income tax expense arises
because the accounting methods used to prepare general purpose financial
statements are sometimes different from the methods used to calculate the income
tax an entity must pay
o Differences arising due to revenues and expenses being recognized at
different times for accounting and tax purposes are called temporary
differences
o Permanent differences are revenues and expenses recognized for tax
purposes but not for financial reporting purposes, or recognized for
financial reporting purposes but not for tax purposes
The amount of future income tax associated with an asset or liability at a point in
time is calculated using the following formula:
o [Tax basis of an asset or liability Accounting basis of an asset or
liability] * tax rate
The tax basis of an asset or liability is its carrying amount for tax
purposes
The amount of future income tax expense for a period related to an asset or
liability is calculated as follows:
1 - Hammer Ltd had 1,000 units of inventory on hand at the beginning of the year worth
$4,000. During the year they purchased 15,000 units at $4.25 and 10,000 units at $4.40.
They sold 24,500 units during the year at an average price of $7.50 and pay taxes at 25%.
(20 minutes)
Avg. cost per unit = [(1000 units @ $4) + (15,000 units @ $4.25) +
(10,000 units @ $4.40] / (1000 + 15,000 + 10,000) = $4.30 / unit
Ending inventory = (Beginning inventory + purchases sales) *Avg. cost
per unit
= (1000 + 15,000 + 10,000 24,500) * $4.30
= $6,450
* The sales price of inventory is irrelevant in determining the value of inventory to be
recognized in the Statement of Financial position because inventory is valued at lower of
cost or market value.
b) Hammer has a bank loan outstanding, the size of which is related to the
company's inventory. If prices are rising which cost flow assumption would
management most likely prefer?
FIFO values the most recent inventory as ending inventory on the Statement of
Financial Position as cost of the earliest inventory is transferred to the income
c) For its next fiscal year end (not the current year end) Hammer Ltd is
considering changing to the FIFO cost flow assumption. How will this impact
financial reporting?
Changing to the FIFO cost flow assumption could possibly have a significant
impact on the financial statement numbers but the magnitude of the impact would
depend upon the difference in the change in prices. Changing to FIFO from
Average cost would result in a higher ending inventory, higher current
assets, higher total assets, a higher current ratio, lower cost of sales and a
higher net income.
2 - Noisy Kitchens Inc has a new showroom that cost $400,000. During the construction
phase Noisy Kitchens Inc incurred interest expense of $10,000 (not included in the
$400,000). It took six months to build. It will be amortized using the declining balance
method at a rate of 5%. The estimated residual value of the building is $50,000, and it has
an expected useful life of 20 years. Noisy Kitchens Inc records a full year amortization in
the first year of purchase or use. Assuming the first year's amortization expense was
recorded properly. Answer the following questions as they relate to Noisy Kitchens Inc
and its new showroom. (25 minutes)
* Note: all of the following answers are based on the assumption that we are referring to
Year 2 as the current year.
a) What would be the amount of amortization expense for the second year?
c) What would be the net book value of the showroom at the end of the second
year (after adjusting entries)?
d) What would be the impact on the Statement of Cash flows for the current year?
Interest expense of $10,000 incurred during the construction phase should be dealt
with as part of the acquisition cost of the asset and is thus capitalized with the
asset. Each year, using the declining balance method, a portion of the capitalized
interest is transferred to the income statement along with the depreciation expense
on the asset as a whole.
3- The following items pertain to the liabilities of ABC Corporation. You may assume
that ABC Corporation began business on January 1, 2010. (10 minutes)
*On January 1, 2010, ABC Corporation issued bonds with a face value of $
50,000. The bonds are due in five years and have a face interest rate of 10%. The
market rate on January 1 for similar bonds was 12%. The bonds pay interest
annually each December 31. Brent has chosen to use the effective interest method
of amortization for any premium or discount on the bonds.
* On December 31, 2010, ABC Corporation signed a lease agreement with York
Leasing. The agreement requires ABC to make annual lease payments of $ 3,000
per year for four years, with the first payment due on December 31, 2011. The
agreement stipulates that ownership of the property is transferred to Brent at the
end of the four year lease. Assume that an interest of 8% is used for the leasing
transaction.
(a) Make the accounting entries necessary on December 31, 2010 for the
above 2 transactions.
(b) Explain if the entry for year 2 will be the same as (a) above (You do
not need to do the journal entries)
The same account will be debited and credited for the bond in year 2 but
the numbers will differ. Discount amortization will increase each year
and so will the interest expense because effective interest method is
being used by ABC Corporation.
After the initial recording of the leased asset and lease liability, the asset
and liability are accounted for separately. Leased capital asset is
accounted for much the same way as any capital asset depreciated
over the useful life of the asset because ABC will be getting ownership at
the end of the lease term. Interest expense will also be recognized in
subsequent years by multiplying the liability outstanding at the beginning
of the year by the interest rate.
(c) Is the structure of the lease the best for ABC Corporation? Why?
Page 19 of 28
EXAMPLE CASE SOLUTION TO BBEAN COFFEE INC.
Page 20 of 28
To: BBean Coffee Inc.
From: Accounting Advisor
RE: Accounting Options and Recommendation for the BBeanss franchise sale transaction
Introduction: BBean Coffee Inc. can recognize revenue from its sales of franchises in a few ways.
However, management needs to pick a revenue recognition policy which meets their and the
stakeholders objectives. The fact that BBean Coffee Inc is a public company, we have to adhere to IFRS
principles. We have to ensure that all criteria for recognizing revenue are met.
Users and Objectives
BBeans Management (primary): The main objective of the Management is to maximize earnings so that
they can attract more clients and increase the number of franchises. Furthermore, they need to make
sure that they adhere to IFRS principles, since, potential franchise holders would want to see
transparency and accuracy in their financial statements.
Auditor: The auditors main objective is using the right revenue recognition policy to ensure BBean is
adhering to IFRS.
Franchise Owners: The main objective of the franchise owners is to see that BBeans is not involved in
any fraudulent activities. In another words they want to ensure that BBean receives and unqualified
opinion from Audit (Clean). If BBeans were involved in any accounting scandal, it would have a negative
impact the value of their investment, which is the franchise. Hence, the current franchise owners would
want to see and make sure that the reputation of BBeans Coffee Inc. is not hampered in any way.
Potential Franchise Owners: Their main objective would be to make sure that the company in which
they are investing their money, has a good reputation, and also has fair accounting principles. For
potential franchise holders, their most important concern is that the company does not go bankrupt,
which usually happens when the management manipulates their financial statements to make them
look more appealing. Hence, the potential franchise owners would want to make sure that BBeans
Coffee Inc. has transparent and fair accounting practices.
Canada Revenue Agency (CRA): The main objective of the CRA is to make sure that BBeans Coffee Inc. is
reporting accurate net income, which conversely would affect the amount of taxes they pay.
Shareholders: Since, shareholders are a major stakeholders of almost every public company. The
primary objective of shareholders would be to maximize yield on their investment.
Page 21 of 28
Issue: Revenue recognition
The issue at hand is whether BBean should continue using their current revenue recognition policy or
change it?
Revenue from sales can be recognized in the following ways:
Alternative 1: Cash collection - Revenue can be collected when cash is received from the customer in
instalments. This approach to recognizing revenue removes all uncertainties regarding BBean Incs
revenue which is very important in this case because we have to abide by IFRS. The revenue recognition
criteria is met, performance, revenue amount, cost amount and cash collection have already happened.
The cost and revenue are measureable, performance has occurred because the franchise has been sold
and assurance of collection is met because we are recognizing revenue after the cash payment is made.
This takes care of the Auditors concern about earnings being overstated because revenue is not
recorded immediately after the sale; it is recorded once the payment is received. The first payment of
$100,000 will be recognized immediately and the remaining $200,000 will be recognized in annual
instalments of $50,000. The company will also pay a lower tax rate because this alternative will
recognize revenues in instalments which will reduce the Net Income. This approach also provides steady
cash flow which can be very beneficial to BBean Inc, because potential buyers will be impressed by the
steady growth of the company.
Alternative 2: Record immediately with providing collateral- Revenue can also be recognized
immediately as long as the franchise owners can provide collateral for the remaining payment. If we
have collateral against the remaining $200,000 that is to be paid in instalments, we have assurance of
collection. Performance has already occurred because we have already sold the franchise and revenue
and costs are measurable. Revenue recognition criteria is met which is the most important concern
because BBean is a public company. This meets managements objective to record the full amount
($300,000) immediately. This increases the Net Income which the management wants so they can
attract potential buyers. This increases the Net Income in the period the sale is made which also means
that higher taxes will have to be paid. The auditors concern is that earnings are overstated, however as
long as we have collateral against the pending amount of $200,000; the auditor should not be
concerned because we are adhering to IFRS principles. There will however remain a deviation in
earnings from one accounting period to another. Lets say in one accounting period we sell two
franchises ($600,000) and in the next accounting period we sell only one franchise ($300,000), this will
create a lot of deviation in the earnings in one accounting period relative to the other.
Page 22 of 28
Alternative 3: Recognize the revenue when all the instalments have been received- the third alternative
would be to recognize revenue after all the instalments have been made by the franchise owner. By
using this alternative, all the criterions of revenue recognition are met. The first criterion is that
performance has occurred: in this case, since the franchise has already been sold, performance has
occurred. The second criteria is that the amount of revenue can be reasonably measured: in this case,
since the franchise has already been sold for a monetary value, there is no need to estimate the
revenue, as it can be easily calculated, since it has already been collected by BBeans Coffee. The third
criterion of revenue recognition requires costs to be measurable. In this case, the cost incurred can be
easily estimated, as BBeans Coffee has been in this business for a few years, and also has a lot of
experience in selling the franchises. Hence, they can easily measure the costs that are associated with
revenue collection, which comes from selling franchises. The last criterion is that the collection of the
revenue should be reasonably assured. In this case, we recognize the revenue only when all the
instalments are received by BBeans Coffee Inc. Hence, we have complete assurance that revenue will be
collected. Therefore, all the four criterions of the revenue recognition are met. Moreover, by using this
method of revenue recognition, we are not overstating the net income which is a major issue for BBeans
Coffee. Another benefit of using this method is that, BBeans would be showing transparency in their
accounting practices, as nowadays, shareholders are willing to invest in the companies that adhere to
IFRS principles, especially after the accounting scandals of WorldCom, and Enron. This method
recognizes revenues the latest which can be of concern to management because they are looking to
inflate earnings to attract potential buyers.
Recommendation: As an accounting advisor, I believe recognizing revenue upon cash collection in
instalments would be the most appropriate course of action. This method of accounting for revenue
meets the revenue recognition criteria keeping BBean Coffee Inc. away from fraudulent accounting
practices. The cost price is measurable considering BBean Inc. has been in business for quite a significant
time. As mentioned in the company profile BBean Coffee Inc. first sold large franchises and have now
moved on to selling relatively small franchises. Revenues are measurable because the selling price is
already determined ($300,000) and performance has already occurred because we have sold the
franchise and lastly assurance of collection is also met because we are recording revenue after cash has
been collected. That being said, I concur with the auditors concern that recognizing revenue
immediately overstates earnings and fails to reflect the substance of the transaction stream.
Recognizing revenue upon cash collection takes care of that concern because we are only recording
$100,000 as revenue immediately deferring the rest till we receive the payments. The remainder
Page 23 of 28
$200,000 is recorded as recognized when the yearly instalments are made. Managements objective is
to record the full amount so that earnings seem significant. Although this policy fails to meet the
managements objective, the management is still able to recognize $100,000 as immediate revenue,
which is still a significant amount. This accounting policy also provides them with steady cash flow
because revenue is recorded upon cash collection, which is essential in a business operation.
Furthermore, earnings will grow at a steady pace because revenue will be recognized when cash is
collected; steady growth in earnings can fulfill managements purpose of attracting potential franchise
buyers. Steady growth adds to a companys goodwill which attracts potential buyers. Public companies
are taxed on earnings; there is a direction correlation between the two variables. If this accounting
policy is implemented, BBean Inc. will pay a lower tax rate because earnings will be relatively lower. This
will leave the company with a higher disposable income, which can benefit management who are
seeking to make Net Income seem as high as possible. Franchise owners also benefit from this
accounting policy. The fact that this accounting policy results in growth at a steady pace, it increases the
market value of BBean Coffee Incs franchise.
Why not the other alternatives? The third alternative recognizes revenue at the very end when all
payments are made. This accounting policy fails to meet the managements objective. The second
alternative, fails to meet the auditors concern who feels that recording revenue immediately does not
reflect the substance of the transaction stream and overstates earnings. Even though this accounting
policy meets the management's objective, it fails to bring about growth at a steady pace. The third
alternative fails to meet the management's objective who is the most important stakeholder in this case.
Whereas the second alternative ignores the auditors concern about earnings being overstated. The first
alternative recognizes the auditors concern and also recognizes the management's objectives and offers
concrete evidence that all IFRS principles will be adhered to.
2) The course of action that BBean is taking would have the following impact on balance sheet and
income statement accounts. Under assets, the account that is affected is accounts receivable. The
current accounting policy recognizes the full payment ($300,000) immediately. The journal entry is as
follows:
Dr. Cash 100,000
Dr. Acc. Receivable 200,000
Cr. Sales Revenue 300,000
Page 24 of 28
The recommended accounting policy would reduce assets because revenue is recognized when cash is
collected. Hence, the full amount will not be recognized which will reduce the assets for the fiscal year.
The entry would look like the follows:
Dr. Cash 100,000
Cr. Revenue 100,000
The recommended change in the accounting policy will not have any impact on BBean Incs liabilities.
This is because we are not recording cash payments as unearned revenue. Hence, BBean Incs liabilities
would remain the same. Revenues will be impacted by the recommended change in accounting policy.
The current accounting policy recognizes the total franchise selling price immediately when it is sold.
The recommended accounting policy recognizes only $100,000 immediately which significantly lowers
BBean Incs revenues. Expenses on the other hand will remain unchanged. As a result Earnings would
have the same impact as revenue because only $100,000 is recorded immediately after the sale of the
franchise whereas the rest is recognized when instalments are received.
I hope that I have answered all your questions, and please feel free to contact me if you have any
queries.
Yours Sincerely,
Accounting Advisor
Page 25 of 28
Case Taken up during session:
Page 26 of 28
Page 27 of 28