IGC-2015 Submission 84
IGC-2015 Submission 84
IGC-2015 Submission 84
50th
IGC
17th 19th DECEMBER 2015, Pune, Maharashtra, India
Venue: College of Engineering (Estd. 1854), Pune, India
ABSTRACT
Expansive soils have tendency to undergo large volumetric changes due to fluctuations in the moisture
content. Stabilization of such type of soils by lime and fly ash is an ancient art of practice due to
effectiveness of these methods. Changes in the swelling behavior of natural expansive soils due to
wetting-drying cycles are well documented but studies performed to see the influence of cyclic wetting
and drying on the swelling behavior of stabilized soils with different admixture needs to be investigated
broadly. Purpose of this study is to understand the durability behavior of lime and low calcium fly ash
stabilization to resist swelling potential under continuous cycles of wetting and drying. In this study, the
effect of lime and fly ash stabilization on two highly expansive clay soils under cyclic wetting and drying
condition has been examined. Swelling potential and swelling pressure tests under cyclic wetting-drying
condition have been carried out on these clay samples. The tests have been conducted on untreated soil
samples and after the addition of lime in the proportion of 3%, 5% and 8% and fly ash in the proportion
of 5%, 10%, 15% and 20% with the soil samples. In each wetting and drying cycle the tested samples
were allowed to fully swell and then dried to their initial water content which constitute one cycle of
wetting and drying and four such cycles are performed on each sample for brevity of work. Full swelling-
partial shrinkage method has been adopted in this study. All the samples were compacted at its optimum
moisture content and maximum dry density and swelling tests are conducted in a conventional one
dimensional oedometer in accordance with IS 2720 (part XLI) - 1977. The experimental result shows that
swelling potential of both the soil types reduces due to application of wetting drying cycles. Soils having
swelling potentials of about 19% and 30% initially are reduced to 7% and 11.5% respectively after fourth
cycle. Lime and fly ash treatment reduces the swelling potentials significantly. Addition of 8% lime
resulted in the reduction of swelling potentials to 4.5% and 7.5% and 20% fly ash to the soil sample,
reduction of swell potential are observed to be 13% and 19% respectively, for both soil types. Both lime
and fly ash stabilized samples also show further decrease in swell potential in successive cycles. Similar
results are also observed in swelling pressure values for both treated and untreated soil samples and for
other percentages of lime and fly ash samples. For all the samples most reduction in the swelling potential
and swelling pressure has been observed after the first cycle itself and subsequently samples show very
less variation after each cycle. However lime stabilization is found to be more effective than the fly ash
stabilization in reducing swelling potential for the materials used in this research work. According to the
test results it can be concluded that both lime and fly ash stabilization can be effectively used under cyclic
wetting and drying condition for an expansive soil.
1
Bhagowati _ Biswajit, Civil Engg. Deptt., NIT Silchar, Silchar, India, [email protected]
2
Borthakur Nirmali, Civil Engg. Deptt., NIT Silchar, Silchar, India, [email protected]
Biswajit Bhagowat & Nirmali Borthakur
Keywords: Expansive soil; Lime stabilization; Fly ash stabilization; cyclic wetting-drying; swelling
potential
50th INDIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONFERENCE
50th
IGC
17th 19th DECEMBER 2015, Pune, Maharashtra, India
Venue: College of Engineering (Estd. 1854), Pune, India
ABSTRACT: In this study, the effect of lime and fly ash stabilization on two highly expansive clay soils under
cyclic wetting and drying condition has been examined. Swelling potential and swelling pressure tests under cyclic
wetting-drying condition have been carried out on these clay samples. The tests have been conducted on untreated
soil samples and after the addition of lime in the proportion of 3%, 5% and 8% and fly ash in the proportion of 5%,
10%, 15% and 20% with the soil samples. Full swelling-partial shrinkage method has been adopted in this study.
The experimental result shows that swelling potential and swelling pressure of both the soil types reduces due to
application of wetting drying cycles. Both lime and fly ash stabilized samples also show further decrease in swell
potential and swell pressure in successive cycles. For all the samples most reduction in the swelling potential and
swelling pressure has been observed after the first cycle itself and subsequently samples show very less variation
after each cycle. However lime stabilization is found to be more effective than the fly ash stabilization in reducing
swelling potential. According to the test results it can be concluded that both lime and fly ash stabilization can be
effectively used under cyclic wetting and drying condition for an expansive soil.
primarily responsible for the modification of the soil [9-15]. A decrease in swell potential was
engineering properties of clay soils when treated observed by Guney et al. in low plasticity soil
with even a small amount of lime. The studies treated with lime, but trend was to increase for
reported in the literature showed that the addition other clay soils [9]. Effect of purity of lime on soil
of lime increases the optimum water content, stabilization also has effect on its durability or
shrinkage limit and strength, and reduces the cyclic swelling-shrinkage behavior [16]. Further
swelling potential, liquid limit, plasticity index and studies are to be conducted on chemically treated
maximum dry density of soil. Bell, (1996) found expansive soils for better estimation of the long-
that the optimum addition of lime needed for the term behavior.
stabilization of the soils is between 1% and 3%,
while the other researchers suggested the use of The objective of this study is to study the influence
lime between 2% and 8% lime by weight [2]. Bell of cyclic wetting drying cycles on the swelling
also indicated that further additions of lime do not behavior of natural expansive soil and lime and fly
change the swelling potentials, but increase the ash stabilized expansive soil.
engineering properties of expansive soil.
MATERIALS
Another important stabilizing agent for expansive Materials used in this research work are expansive
soil is cement, which is composed of oxides of soils, lime and fly ash. Two different types of
calcium, silica, alumina and iron. Cement bentonite clay soil are collected from different
stabilization is also similar to lime stabilization and sources and two types of admixtures, lime and fly
produces similar results. Addition of cement ash are used. Bentonite powders used in this study
reduces the swelling potential; plasticity index, are collected in sealed bags in powdered form from
liquid limit, and increases shrinkage limit and shear suppliers; one from Guwahati (Soil A) and another
strength [4]. The stabilization is due to the from Kolkata (Soil B). Both the soils are highly
formation of cementitious bonding between the expansive in nature having different plasticity.
calcium silicate and aluminates hydration products Locally available commercial hydrated lime having
and the soil particles. specific gravity 2.24 is used in this study. Lime
sample used contains 7% sand and 93% silt and
Fly ash is a material produced as by product from clay content. Fly ash is collected from Topcem
flue gases of furnace fired with coal. It may be cement factory situated in Meghalaya. Fly ash used
used as stabilizing material because of its has specific gravity of 2.15, sand content of 15%
pozzolanic and cementitious properties, low cost, and silt and clay content of 85% and it is has low
and to reduce air and water pollution that may be lime or low calcium concentration.
caused from the disposal of it. It is observed that
the addition of fly ash significantly reduces the Some of the geotechnical properties of soils and
swelling potential of expansive soil [5, 6]. admixture used in this study is given in table 1 and
chemical composition of lime and fly ash is given
Previous studies related to influence of cyclic in table 2.
wetting drying cycles on the swelling behavior of
stabilized and natural expansive soils indicates that Table 1 Index properties of soils and admixture
swelling potential of natural expansive soils Properties Soil A Soil B Lime Fly Ash
exposed to full swell-full shrink cycles increase LL (%) 143 248 - -
and it decreases for soils exposed to full swell- PI (%) 99 206 NP NP
partial shrink cycles [7, 8]. G 2.67 2.70 2.24 2.15
Sand (%) 0 0 7 15
It is observed from earlier studies that reduction of Silt (%) 52 38
swelling potential can be preserved after cyclic 93 85
Clay (%) 48 62
swell-shrink cycles in case of silica fume, polymers
and fly ash, but it loss partially in lime stabilized
50th INDIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONFERENCE
50th
IGC
17th 19th DECEMBER 2015, Pune, Maharashtra, India
Venue: College of Engineering (Estd. 1854), Pune, India
cell is dismantled. The sample (still within the percent (S), which is defined as the percentage
consolidation ring) is then allowed to air-dry (at a increase in height in relation to the original height
room temperature) to its initial water content. All and was calculated as;
dried samples were carefully weighed before
S= ,
proceeding with the next swelling cycle. After
Where H is the axial expansion in mm, and H is
swell test, the weights of the sample were recorded
the original thickness of the specimen in mm.
regularly until the initial dry unit weight reached.
With the saturation of the samples within the
consolidation cell and drying it to the initial weight Swelling Pressure
in air-dry environment, a drying-wetting cycle was This test is intended to measure the axial stress
completed. Here four cycles of alternate wetting necessary to constrain radially confined soil
and drying is allowed for tested specimens. For specimen at constant thickness when immersed in
brevity of work and time restriction swelling water within in the cell. In other words, the swell
pressure of 5% FA, 15% FA, 3%L and 5% L added pressure of test specimen was measured using the
samples for both soil types are not tested for cyclic constant volume method. The preparation of the
wetting-drying condition. Swell potential of 5% specimen and the consolidation cell were the same
FA, 15% FA and 5% L mixed samples for soil type as in the axial swell percent test. It was then
B is also not tested. flooded with water and the volume was kept
constant by continuous addition of loads at each
Swelling Tests axial expansion of the specimen, observing the dial
Swelling potential has been used to describe the gauge displacement keeping at zero level. The load
ability of a soil to swell, in terms of volume change was maintained by using loading arm of the
or the pressure required to prevent swelling. For consolidation cell. The addition of load via the
swelling tests, cylindrical specimens were prepared loading arm was continued until deformation of the
at maximum dry unit weight and optimum specimen could not be observed. The swelling
moisture content of the soils, soil-fly ash and soil pressure was calculated from the total load applied
lime mixtures. About 60mm inner diameter and divided by the cross-sectional area of the specimen
20mm height mold was used to prepare a minimum and was calculated as;
two samples for each combination of soils for = ,
swelling tests. No curing period was allowed for where is the axial stress in kPa, N is the total
these tests. Swelling tests were carried out in load in kN, and A is the area of cross section of the
accordance with IS : 2720 ( Part 41 ) 1977. specimen in m2.
Swelling Potential Test RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The swell percent of the specimen is measured Swelling potential and swelling pressure tests
using the loaded-swell method. It is carried out by under cyclic wetting-drying condition are
the standard one-dimensional consolidation ring. performed on both soil A and soil B and its some
The sample, which is in the ring, was placed combinations with lime and fly ash in the
between two porous stone which has a number of procedure described earlier. This type of test is
small holes. The ring with the specimen was placed very useful to understand long term behavior or
on the lower porous stone, followed by placement durability of stabilized and unstabilized soil
of the upper porous stone. The specimen was then samples under alternate weather conditions. Here
loaded to a seating pressure of 5 kPa and it was four cycles of alternate wetting and drying are used
maintained with water to cover the top porous for the tested samples. All the samples are allowed
plate. The displacement measurement, dial gauge, to swell fully for about 4 days under inundated
is initialized. The specimen is allowed to swell condition and then allowed to dry to its initial
under the initial seating load. The dial gauge water content under laboratory condition which
readings are recorded periodically until no further generally takes 1.5 to 3 days. All the dried samples
changes in expansion are observed. The swell
50th INDIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONFERENCE
50th
IGC
17th 19th DECEMBER 2015, Pune, Maharashtra, India
Venue: College of Engineering (Estd. 1854), Pune, India
are carefully weighed periodically before The experimental result shows that swelling
performing next wetting cycle. potential of soil A reduces due to application of
wetting drying cycles. Soil A, having swelling
Variation in swell potential and swell pressure with potentials of around 19% reduced to 7% after
no of cycles for soil A treated with different fourth cycles of alternate wetting and drying. Lime
stabilizers are presented in graphical form and and fly ash treatment reduces the swelling
shown below in figure 1, figure 2 and figure 3 potentials significantly in the 1st cycle itself.
respectively. Addition of 8% lime resulted in the reduction of
swelling potentials to 4.5% and addition of 20% fly
ash to the soil sample, reduction of swell potential
are observed to be 13%. Both lime and fly ash
stabilized samples also show further decrease in
swell potential in successive cycles. Similar results
are also observed in swelling pressure values for
both treated and untreated soil sample A and for all
percentages of lime and fly ash addition. Swelling
pressure of soil A which was 1.65 kg/cm2
decreased to 0.7 kg/cm2 after the fourth cycle. 8%
Figure 1 Swell Potential values of fly ash treated lime and 20% fly ash addition resulted in swelling
soil sample A pressure of 0.45 kg/cm2 and 1.1 kg/cm2
respectively for soil A and these values further
decreased after consecutive cycles. For most of the
samples, most reduction in the swelling potential
and swelling pressure has been observed after the
first cycle itself and subsequently samples show
very less variation after each cycle.
Figure 3 Swell Pressure values of fly ash and lime Figure 4 Swell Potential values of fly ash treated
treated soil sample A soil sample B
Biswajit Bhagowat & Nirmali Borthakur
REFERENCES
1. Basma, A.A., Al-Homoud, A.S., Husein,
M., and Al-Bashabsheh, M.A., (1996),
Swelling-shrink behavior of natural
Figure 10 Percentage decrease in swell pressure expansive clays, Applied Clay Science, 11
values of fly ash and lime treated soil sample B (24), 211227.
Biswajit Bhagowat & Nirmali Borthakur
2. Bell F. G., (1996), Lime stabilization of clayey soils modified by silica fume,
clay minerals and soils, Engineering Applied Clay Science, 52 (2011) 345352.
Geology, 42 (1996) 223-237. 13. Fateme, Y. and Shahaboddin, Y.S., (2010),
3. Bhuvaneshwari, S., Robinson, R. G. and Effect of cyclic wetting and drying on
Gandhi, S. R., (2014), Behaviour of Lime swelling behavior of polymer-stabilized
Treated Cured Expansive Soil Composites, expansive clays, Applied Clay Science, 50
Indian Geotechnical Journal, July (2010) 461468.
September, 2014, 44(3):278293. 14. Fehime, A. and Mustafa, A., (2012), Effect
4. Kolias S., Rigopoulou, K.V. and Karahalios of wettingdrying cycles on swelling
A., (2005), Stabilisation of clayey soils behavior of lime stabilized sandbentonite
with high calcium fly ash and cement, mixtures, Environmental Earth Science,
Cement & Concrete Composites 27, 2005, (2012) 66:6774.
301313. 15. Rao, S.M., Reddy, B.V.V. and Muttharam,
5. Kumar, P.B.R. and Sharma, R.S., (2004), M., (2001), The impact of cyclic wetting
Effect of Fly Ash on Engineering Properties and drying on the swelling behavior of
of Expansive Soils, Journal of stabilized expansive soils, Engineering
Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Geology, 60 (2001) 223-233.
Engineering, Vol. 130, No. 7, July 1, 2004. 16. Uma, A., Kanaujia, V.K., Alok, R., Swami
6. Kumar, P.B.R. and Sharma, R.S., (2007), R.K. and Sudhir, M., (2013), Effect of
Volume Change Behavior of Fly Ash- purity of lime on strength and durability of
Stabilized Clays, Journal of Materials in soil lime mixes, Indian Highways, (August
Civil Engineering, Vol. 19, No. 1, January 2013) 47-54.
1, 2007. 17. Arvind, K., Walia, S.B. and Asheet, B.,
7. Dey, R.W., (1994), Swell-shrink behavior (2007), Influence of Fly Ash, Lime, and
of compacted clay, Journal of Geotechnical Polyester Fibers on Compaction and
Engineering, vol. 120, No. 3, March 1994. Strength Properties of Expansive Soil,
8. Al-Homoud, A.S., Basma, A.A., Hussein, Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering,
A.I.M. and Al Bashabsheh, M.A., (1995), Vol. 19, No. 3, March 1, 2007.
Cycling Swelling Behavior of Clays, 18. Erdal, C., (2001), Use Of Class C Fly
Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, Vol. Ashes For The Stabilization Of An
121, No.7, p.562-565, 1995. Expansive Soil, Journal of Geotechnical
9. Yucel, G., Dursun, S., Murat, C. and and Geoenvironmental Engineering, Vol.
Mustafa, T. (2007), Impact of cyclic 127, No. 7, July, 2001.
wettingdrying on swelling behavior of 19. Harichane, K., Ghrici, M., Kenai, S. and
lime-stabilized soil, Building and Grine, K., (2011), Use of Natural Pozzolana
Environment 42 (2007) 681688. and Lime for Stabilization of Cohesive
10. Estabragh, A.R., Pereshkafti, M.R.S., Soils, Geotechnical Geol. Engineering
Parsaei, B. and Javadi, A.A., (2013), (2011) 29:759769.
Stabilised expansive soil behaviour during 20. Asgari, M. R., Dezfuli, A., Baghebanzadeh
wetting and drying, International Journal and Bayat, M., (2013), Experimental study
of Pavement Engineering, 14:4, 418-427. on stabilization of a low plasticity clayey
11. Ali, A.R.A., Hago, A.W. and Sarmi, H.A., soil with cement/lime, Arab J Geosci, Saudi
(2005), Effect of lime, cement and Sarooj Society for Geosciences, 2013.
(artificial pozzolana) on the swelling
potential of an expansive soil from Oman,
Building and Environment, 40 (2005) 681
687.
12. Ekrem, K., (2011), Impact of wetting
drying cycles on swelling behavior of