Isabella I of Castile
Isabella I of Castile
Isabella I of Castile
Isabella I redirects here. For other uses, see Isabella I tions were lackluster, under the careful eye of her mother,
(disambiguation). Isabella was instructed in lessons of practical piety and in
For other people named Isabella of Castile, see Isabella a deep reverence for religion.[4]
of Castile (disambiguation). When the Kings wife, Joan of Portugal, was about to give
birth to their daughter Joanna, Isabella and Alfonso were
Isabella I (Spanish: Isabel I de Castilla, 22 April 1451 summoned to court (Segovia) to come under the direct
26 November 1504) was Queen of Castile. She was supervision of the King and to nish their education. Al-
married to Ferdinand II of Aragon. Their marriage be- fonso was placed in the care of a tutor while Isabella be-
came the basis for the political unication of Spain under came part of the Queens household.[5]
their grandson, Holy Roman Emperor Charles V. After
a struggle to claim her right to the throne, she reorga-
nized the governmental system, brought the crime rate to
the lowest it had been in years, and unburdened the king-
dom of the enormous debt her brother had left behind.
Her reforms and those she made with her husband had an
inuence that extended well beyond the borders of their
united kingdoms. Isabella and Ferdinand are known for
completing the Reconquista, ordering conversion or exile
of their Muslim and Jewish subjects, and for supporting
and nancing Christopher Columbus' 1492 voyage that
led to the opening of the New World and to the estab-
lishment of Spain as the rst global power which dom-
inated Europe and much of the world for more than a
century. Isabella was granted the title Servant of God by
the Catholic Church in 1974.
1
2 1 LIFE AND REIGN
1.2 Marriage
The question of Isabellas marriage was not a new one.
Indeed, she had made her debut in the matrimonial mar-
ket at the tender age of six, with a betrothal to Ferdinand,
the younger son of John II of Aragon (whose family was
a cadet branch of the House of Trastmara). At that time,
the two kings, Henry and John, were eager to show their
mutual love and condence and they believed that this
double alliance would make their eternal friendship obvi-
ous to the world.[9] This arrangement, however, did not
last long.
Ferdinands uncle Alfonso V of Aragon died in 1458.
All of Alfonsos Spanish territories, as well as the islands
of Sicily and Sardinia, were left to his brother John II.
John now had a stronger position than ever before and no
longer needed the security of Henrys friendship. Henry
was now in need of a new alliance. He saw the chance Isabella I of Castile
for this much needed new friendship in Charles of Viana,
Johns elder son.[10] Charles was constantly at odds with In 1465, an attempt was made to marry Isabella to
1.3 War with Portugal 3
cession then took place. The war went back and forth the right of conquest over the kingdom of Fez[51][52] ) plus
for almost a year until 1 March 1476, when the Battle a large war compensation: 106.676 dobles of gold.[53]
of Toro took place, a battle in which both sides claimed The Catholic Monarchs also had to accept that Joanna
victory[25][26] and celebrated[26][27] the victory: the troops remain in Portugal instead of Spain[53] and to pardon
of Afonso V were beaten[28][29] by the Castilian centre- all rebellious subjects who had supported Joanna and
left commanded by the Duke of Alba and Cardinal Men- Alfonso.[54] And the Catholic Monarchswho had pro-
doza while the forces led by Prince John of Portugal claimed themselves rulers of Portugal and donated lands
defeated[30][31][32][33] the Castilian right wing and re- to noblemen inside this country[55] had to give up the
mained in possession[34][35] of the battleeld. Portuguese crown.
But despite its uncertain[36][37] outcome, the Battle of At Alcovas, Isabella and Ferdinand had conquered the
Toro represented a great political victory[38][39][40][41] for throne, but the Portuguese exclusive right of navigation
the Catholic Monarchs, assuring them the throne since and commerce in all of the Atlantic Ocean south of the
the supporters of Joanna disbanded and the Portuguese Canary Islands meant that Spain was practically blocked
army, without allies, left Castile. As summarised by the out of the Atlantic and was deprived of the gold of
historian Justo L. Gonzlez: Guinea, which induced anger in Andalusia.[45] Spanish
academic Antonio Rumeu de Armas claims that with the
peace treaty of Alcovas, 1479, the Catholic Monarchs
Both armies faced each other at the camps
"...buy the peace at an excessively expensive price...[56]
of Toro resulting in an indecisive battle. But
and historian M Monserrat Len Guerrero added that
while the Portuguese King reorganised his
they "...nd themselves forced to abandon their expansion
troops, Ferdinand sent news to all the cities
by the Atlantic....[57]
of Castile and to several foreign kingdoms in-
forming them about a huge victory where the Columbus freed Castile from this dicult situation be-
Portuguese were crushed. Faced with these cause his New World discovery led to a new and much
news, the party of la Beltraneja [Joanna] was more balanced sharing of the Atlantic at Tordesillas in
dissolved and the Portuguese were forced to re- 1494, as the orders received by Columbus in his rst voy-
turn to their kingdom.[42] age (1492) show: "[the Catholic Monarchs] have always
in mind that the limits signed in the share of Alco-
vas should not be overcome, and thus they insist with
With great political vision, Isabella took advantage of
Columbus to sail along the parallel of Canary.[57] Thus,
the moment and convoked courts at Madrigal-Segovia
by sponsoring the Columbian adventure to the west, the
(AprilOctober 1476)[43] where her daughter was sworn
Spanish monarchs were trying the only remaining path of
heiress of Castiles crown. That was equivalent to legit-
expansion. As is now known, they would be extremely
imising Isabellas own throne.
successful on this issue. Isabella had proven herself to
In August of the same year, Isabella proved her abilities be a ghter and tough monarch from the start. Now that
as a powerful ruler on her own. A rebellion broke out she had succeeded in securing her place on the Castilian
in Segovia, and Isabella rode out to suppress it, as her throne, she could begin to institute the reforms the king-
husband was o ghting at the time. Going against the dom desperately needed.
advice of her male advisors, Isabella rode by herself into
the city to negotiate with the rebels. She was successful
and the rebellion was quickly brought to an end.[44] Two 1.4 Reform
years later, Isabella further secured her place as ruler with
the birth of her son John, Prince of Asturias, on 30 June 1.4.1 Regulation of crime
1478. To many, the presence of a male heir legitimised
her place as ruler. When Isabella came to the throne in 1474, Castile was in
Meanwhile, the Castilian and Portuguese eets fought for a state of despair thanks to her brother Henrys reign. It
hegemony in the Atlantic Ocean and for the wealth of was not unknown that Henry IV was a big spender and
Guinea (gold and slaves), where the decisive naval Battle did little to enforce the laws of his kingdom. It was even
of Guinea was fought.[45][46] said by one Castilian denizen of the time that murder,
rape, and robbery happened without punishment.[58] Be-
The war dragged on for another three years[47] and ended cause of this, Isabella needed desperately to nd a way to
with a Castilian victory on land[48] and a Portuguese vic- reform her kingdom. Due to the measures imposed, his-
tory on the sea.[48] The four separate peace treaties signed torians during her lifetime saw her to be more inclined to
at Alcovas (4 September 1479) reected that result: justice than to mercy, and indeed far more rigorous and
Portugal gave up the throne of Castile in favour of Isabella unforgiving than her husband Ferdinand.[59]
in exchange for a very favourable share of the Atlantic ter-
ritories disputed with Castile (they all went to Portugal
with the exception of the Canary Islands:[49][50] Guinea La Santa Hermandad Main article: Hermandad
with its mines of gold, Cape Verde, Madeira, Azores and
1.4 Reform 5
Isabellas rst major reform came during the cortes of churches, hospitals, or the poor.[68]
Madrigal in 1476 in the form of a police force, La Santa Another issue of money was the overproduction of
Hermandad (the Holy Brotherhood). While 1476 was not coinage and the abundance of mints in the kingdom. Dur-
the rst time that Castile had seen the Hermandad, it was ing Henrys reign, the number of mints regularly produc-
however the rst time that the police force was used by the ing money had increased from just ve to 150.[67] Much
crown.[60] During the late medieval period, the expression of the coinage produced in these mints was nearly worth-
hermandad had been used to describe groups of men who less. During the rst year of her reign, Isabella established
came together of their own accord to regulate law and or- a monopoly over the royal mints and xed a legal stan-
der by patrolling the roads and countryside and punishing
dard to which the coinage must approximate. By shutting
malefactors.[61] These brotherhoods, however, had usu- down many of the mints and taking royal control over the
ally been suppressed by the monarch. Before 1476, the
production of money, Isabella restored the condence of
justice system in most parts of the country was eectively the public in the Crowns ability to handle the kingdoms
under the control of dissident members of the nobility
nance.
rather than royal ocials.[62] To x this problem, during
the Cortes of 1476, a general Hermandad was established
for Castile, Leon, and Asturias. The police force was to 1.4.3 Government
be made up of locals who were to regulate the crime oc-
curring in the kingdom. It was to be paid for by a tax of Both Isabella and Ferdinand established very few new
1800 mavedus on every one hundred households.[63] In governmental and administrative institutions in their re-
1477, Isabella visited Extremadura and Andalusia to in- spective kingdoms. Especially in Castile, the main
troduce this more ecient police force there as well.[64] achievement was to use more eectively the institutions
that had existed during the reigns of John II and Henry
IV.[69] Historically, the center of the Castilian govern-
Other criminal reforms Keeping with her reforma- ment had been the royal household, together with its sur-
tion of the regulation of laws, in 1481 Isabella charged rounding court. The household was traditionally divided
two ocials with restoring peace in Galicia. This turbu- into two overlapping bodies. The rst body was made
lent province had been the prey of tyrant nobles since the up of household ocials, mainly people of the nobility,
days of Isabellas father, John II.[65] Robbers infested the who carried out governmental and political functions for
highways and oppressed the smaller towns and villages. which they received special payment. The second body
These ocials set o with the Herculean task of restor- was made up of some 200 permanent servants or conti-
ing peace for the province. The ocials were success- nos who performed a wide range of condential functions
ful. They succeeded in driving over 1,500 robbers from on behalf of the rulers.[70] By the 1470s, when Isabella
Galicia.[66] began to take a rm grip on the royal administration, the
senior oces of the royal household were simply hon-
orary titles and held strictly by the nobility. The positions
1.4.2 Finances
of a more secretarial nature were often held by senior
churchmen. Substantial revenues were attached to such
From the very beginning of her reign, Isabella fully
oces and were therefore enjoyed greatly, on an eec-
grasped the importance of restoring the Crowns nances.
tively hereditary basis, by the great Castilian houses of
The reign of Henry IV had left the kingdom of Castile in
nobility. While the nobles held the titles, those individu-
great debt. Upon examination, it was found that the chief
als of lesser breeding did the real work.[71]
cause of the nations poverty was the wholesale alienation
of royal estates during Henrys reign.[67] To make money,
Henry had sold o royal estates at prices well below their
value. The Cortes of Toledo of 1480 came to the conclu-
sion that the only hope of lasting nancial reform lay in a
resumption of these alienated lands and rents. This deci-
sion was warmly approved by many leading nobles of the
court, but Isabella was reluctant to take such drastic mea-
sures. It was decided that the Cardinal of Spain would
hold an enquiry into the tenure of estates and rents ac-
quired during Henry IVs reign. Those that had not been
granted as a reward for services were to be restored with-
out compensation, while those that had been sold at a
price far below their real value were to be bought back
at the same sum. While many of the nobility were forced Ferdinand and Isabella with their subjects
to pay large sums of money for their estates, the royal
treasury became ever richer. Isabellas one stipulation Traditionally, the main advisory body to the rulers of
was that there would be no revocation of gifts made to Castile was the Royal Council. The Council, under the
6 1 LIFE AND REIGN
monarch, had full power to resolve all legal and politi- piling what remained into a comprehensive code. Within
cal disputes. The Council was responsible for supervis- four years the work stood completed in eight bulky vol-
ing all senior administrative ocials, such as the Crown umes and the Ordenanzas Reales took their place on legal
representatives in all of the major towns. It was also the bookshelves.[77]
supreme judicial tribunal of the kingdom.[72] In 1480,
during the Cortes of Toledo, Isabella made many re-
forms to the Royal Council. Previously there had been 1.5 Events of 1492
two distinct yet overlapping categories of royal council-
lor. One formed a group which possessed both judi- 1.5.1 Granada
cial and administrative responsibilities. This portion con-
sisted of some bishops, some nobles, and an increasingly
important element of professional administrators with le-
gal training known as letrados. The second category of
traditional councillor had a less formal role. This role de-
pended greatly on the individuals political inuence and
personal inuence with the monarch. During Isabellas
reign, the role of this second category was completely
eliminated.[73] As mentioned previously, Isabella had lit-
tle care for personal bribes or favours. Because of this,
this second type of councillor, usually of the nobility, was
only allowed to attend the council of Castile as an ob-
server.
Isabella began to rely more on the professional admin-
istrators than ever before. These men were mostly of
the bourgeoisie or lesser nobility. The Council was also
rearranged and it was ocially settled that one bishop,
three caballeros, and eight or nine lawyers would serve
on the council at a time. While the nobles were no longer
directly involved in the matters of state, they were wel-
come to attend the meetings. Isabella hoped by forcing Statue of Isabella by Felipe Bigarny; it resides in the Capilla Real,
the nobility to choose whether to participate or not would in Granada
weed out those who were not dedicated to the state and
its cause.[74] At the end of the Reconquista, only Granada was left
for Isabella and Ferdinand to conquer. The Emirate of
Isabella also saw the need to provide a personal relation- Granada had been held by the Muslim Nasrid dynasty
ship between herself as the monarch and her subjects. since the mid-13th century.[78] Protected by natural barri-
Therefore, Isabella and Ferdinand set aside a time every ers and fortied towns, it had withstood the long process
Friday during which they themselves would sit and allow of the reconquista. On 1 February 1482, the king and
people to come to them with complaints. This was a new queen reached Medina del Campo and this is generally
form of personal justice that Castile had not seen before. considered the beginning of the war for Granada. While
The Council of State was reformed and presided over by Isabellas and Ferdinands involvement in the war was ap-
the King and Queen. This department of public aairs parent from the start, Granadas leadership was divided
dealt mainly with foreign negotiations, hearing embassies, and never able to present a united front.[79] However, it
and transacting business with the Court of Rome. In ad- still took ten years to conquer Granada, culminating in
dition to these departments, there was also a Supreme 1492.
Court of the Santa Hermandad, a Council of Finance,
and a Council for settling purely Aragonese matters.[75] The Spanish monarchs recruited soldiers from many Eu-
Although Isabella made many reforms that seem to have ropean countries and improved[80]
their artillery with the lat-
made the Cortes stronger, in actuality the Cortes lost est and best cannons. Systematically, they proceeded
political power during the reigns of Isabella and Ferdi- to take the kingdom piece by piece. In 1485 they laid
nand. Isabella and her husband moved in the direction siege to Ronda, which surrendered after only a fortnight
[81]
of a non-parliamentary government and the Cortes be- due to extensive bombardment. The following year,
came an almost passive advisory body, giving automatic Loja was taken, and again Muhammad XII was captured
assent to legislation which had been drafted by the royal and released. One year later, with the fall of Mlaga, the
administration.[76] western part of the Muslim Nasrid kingdom had fallen
into Spanish hands. The eastern province succumbed af-
After the reforms of the Cortes of Toledo, the Queen or- ter the fall of Baza in 1489. The siege of Granada be-
dered a noted jurist, Alfonso Diaz de Montalvo, to un- gan in the spring of 1491 and at the end of the year,
dertake the task of clearing away legal rubbish and com- Muhammad XII surrendered. On 2 January 1492 Isabella
1.6 Later years 7
and Ferdinand entered Granada to receive the keys of Isabella and Ferdinand agreed to divide the Earth, outside
the city and the principal mosque was reconsecrated as of Europe, with king John II of Portugal.
a church.[82] The Treaty of Granada was signed later that Isabella was not in favour of Columbus enslavement of
year, and in it Ferdinand and Isabella gave their word to the American natives and attempted to enforce the re-
allow the Muslims and Jews of Granada to live in peace. cent policies of the Canaries upon the 'New World', stat-
An uprising by the Moors in 1500 caused the Catholic ing that all peoples were under the subject of the Castil-
side to consider that the Moors had violated the Treaty: ian Crown and could not be enslaved in most situations.
this gave them a justication for revoking its provisions. The principles she established would have very little ef-
See Morisco Revolt.
fect during her lifetime, however.[86]
During the war, Isabella noted the abilities and energy
of Gonzalo Fernndez de Crdoba and made him one of
the two commissioners for the negotiations. Under her 1.5.3 Expulsion of the Jews
patronage, De Crdoba went on to an extraordinary mili-
Main articles: Alhambra Decree and Spanish Inquisition
tary career that revolutionised the organisation and tactics
of the emerging Spanish military, changing the nature of
warfare and altering the European balance of power. With the institution of the Roman Catholic Inquisition in
Spain, and with the Dominican friar Toms de Torque-
mada as the rst Inquisitor General, the Catholic Monar-
1.5.2 Columbus and Portuguese relations chs pursued a policy of religious and national unity.
Though Isabella opposed taking harsh measures against
Main article: Christopher Columbus Jews on economic grounds, Torquemada was able to con-
Just three months after entering Granada, Queen Isabella vince Ferdinand. On 31 March 1492, the Alhambra de-
cree for the expulsion of the Jews was issued.[87] The
Jews had until the end of July, three months, to leave the
country and they were not to take with them gold, sil-
ver, money, arms, or horses.[87] Traditionally, it had been
claimed that as many as 200,000 Jews left Spain, but re-
cent historians have shown that such gures are exagger-
ated: Henry Kamen has shown that out of a total popula-
tion of 80,000 Jews, a maximum of 40,000 left and the
rest converted.[88] Hundreds of those that remained came
under the Inquisitions investigations into relapsed con-
versos (Marranos) and the Judaizers who had been abet-
ting them.[89]
praised her purity of heart, her big heart and the Towards the end of her life, family tragedies over-
grandness of her soul. whelmed her, although she met these reverses with grace
and fortitude. The death of her beloved son and heir and
the miscarriage of his wife, the death of her daughter Is-
3 Family abella and Isabellas son Miguel (who could have united
the kingdoms of the Catholic Monarchs with that of Por-
tugal), the madness of her daughter Joanna and the in-
dierence of Philip the Handsome, and the uncertainty
Catherine was in after the death of her husband sub-
merged her in profound sadness that made her dress in
black for the rest of her lifetime . Her strong spirituality
is well understood from the words she said after hearing
of her sons death: The Lord gave him to me, the Lord
hath taken him from me, glory be His holy name.
See also: Descendants of Isabella I of Castile and
Ferdinand II of Aragon
4 Sanctity
It is important to note that Isabellas reputation for sanc-
tity derives in large measure from an image carefully
shaped and disseminated by the queen herself.[95] In
1958, the Catholic canonical process of the Cause of
Canonization of Isabella was started by Jos Garca
Goldaraz, the Bishop of Valladolid, where she died in
1504. 17 experts were appointed to investigate more
than 100,000 documents in the archives of Spain and the
Vatican and the merits of opening a canonical process of
canonisation. 3,500 of these were chosen to be included
in 27 volumes.
In 1970, the Commission determined that A Canonical
Isabella and Ferdinand with their daughter, Joanna, c. 1482.
process for the canonization of Isabella the Catholic could
Isabella and Ferdinand had ve surviving children. be undertaken with a sense of security since there was
not found one single act, public or private, of Queen Is-
Isabella (14701498) married rstly to Alfonso, abella that was not inspired by Christian and evangelical
Prince of Portugal, no issue. Married secondly to criteria; moreover there was a 'reputation of sanctity' un-
Manuel I of Portugal, no surviving issue. interrupted for ve centuries and as the investigation was
progressing, it was more accentuated.
A son, miscarried on 31 May 1475 in Cebreros
In 1972, the Process of Valladolid was ocially submit-
John (14781497), Prince of Asturias. Married ted to the Congregation for the Causes of Saints in the
Archduchess Margaret of Austria, no surviving is- Vatican. This process was approved and Isabel was given
sue. the title "Servant of God" in March 1974.[96]
"Tanto Monta" (They amount to the same, or Equal op- 7.1 Films
posites in balance), it refers their prenuptial agreement.
The conquest of Granada in 1492 was symbolised by the
addition ent en point of a quarter with a pomegranate for
Granada (in Spanish Granada means pomegranate).[99] 7.2 TV series
There was an uncommon variant with the Saint John the
Evangelists eagle and two lions adopted as Castilian royal
supporters by John II, Isabellas father.[100] 7.3 Books
9 Gallery
Isabellas
crown and scepter, and Ferdinands sword, are
Isabella meeting preserved in the Capilla Real of Granada
Christopher Columbus
Royal Monogram
Engraving
of Isabella donating her jewels for Columbus
voyage
[6] Prescott, William. History of the Reign of Ferdinand and [26] Spanish historian Cesreo Fernndez Duro: "...For those
Isabella, The Catholic. J.B Lippincott & CO., 1860, p. who ignore the background of these circumstances it will
8587 certainly seem strange that while the Catholic Monarchs
raised a temple in Toledo in honour of the victory that God
[7] Prescott, William. History of the Reign of Ferdinand and granted them on that occasion, the same fact [the Battle of
Isabella, The Catholic. J.B Lippincott & CO., 1860, p. Toro] was festively celebrated with solemn processions on
9394 its anniversary in Portugal in La batalla de Toro (1476).
Datos y documentos para su monografa histrica, in Bo-
[8] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker letn de la Real Academia de la Historia, tome 38, Madrid,
Press, 1915, p. 68 1901,p. 250.
[9] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker
[27] Manchado, Isabel I de Castilla y la sombra de la ilegitimi-
Press, 1915, p. 35
dad: propaganda y representacin en el conicto sucesorio
[10] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker (14741482), 2006, p. 199 (foot note nr.141).
Press, 1915, p. 3639
[28] Pulgar, Crnica de los Seores Reyes Catlicos Don Fer-
[11] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker nando y Doa Isabel de Castilla y de Aragn, chapter
Press, 1915, p. 39-40 XLV.
[12] Edwards,John. The Spain of the Catholic Monarchs 1474 [29] Garcia de Resende- Vida e feitos d'El Rei D.Joo II,
1520. Blackwell Publishers Inc, 2000, p. 5 chapter XIII.
13
[30] chronicler Hernando del Pulgar (Castilian): "...promptly, [37] French historian Joseph-Louis Desormeaux: "... The
those 6 Castilian captains, which we already told were at result of the battle was very uncertain; Ferdinand de-
the right side of the royal battle, and were invested by the feated the enemys right wing led by Alfonso, but the Prince
prince of Portugal and the bishop of vora, turned their had the same advantage over the Castilians. In Abrg
backs and put themselves on the run. in Crnica de los chronologique de l'histoire de l'spagne, Duchesne, Paris,
Seores Reyes Catlicos Don Fernando y Doa Isabel de 1758, 3rd Tome, p. 25.
Castilla y de Aragn, chapter XLV.
[38] Spanish academic Antnio M. Serrano: " From all of
[31] chronicler Garcia de Resende (Portuguese): "... And be- this it is deductible that the battle [of Toro] was inconclu-
ing the battles of both sides ordered that way and prepared sive, but Isabella and Ferdinand made it y with wings of
to attack by nearly sunshine, the King ordered the prince victory. (...) Actually, since this battle transformed in vic-
to attack the enemy with his and Gods blessing, which he tory; since 1 March 1476, Isabella and Ferdinand started
obeyed (...). (...) and after the sound of the trumpets and to rule in the Spains throne. (...) The inconclusive wings
screaming all for S. George invested so bravely the enemy of the battle became the secure and powerful wings of San
battles, and in spite of their enormous size, they could not Juans eagle [the commemorative temple of the Battle of
stand the hard ght and were rapidly beaten and put on the Toro] . in San Juan de los Reyes y la batalla de Toro,
run with great losses. In Vida e feitos d'El Rei D.Joo II, revista Toletum, segunda poca, 1979 (9), pp. 5570.
chapter XIII. Real Academia de Bellas Artes y Ciencias Histricas de
Toledo, Toledo. ISSN: 0210-6310
[32] chronicler Juan de Mariana (Castilian): "(...) the [Castil-
ian] horsemen (...) moved forward(...).They were received [39] A. Ballesteros Beretta: His moment is the inconclusive
by prince D. John... which charge... they couldn't stand but Battle of Toro.(...) both sides attributed themselves the vic-
instead were defeated and ran away " in Historia General tory.... The letters written by the King [Ferdinand] to the
de Espaa, tome V, book XXIV, chapter X, p. 299,300. main cities... are a model of skill. (...) what a power-
[33] chronicler Damio de Gis (Portuguese): "(...)these ful description of the battle! The nebulous transforms into
Castilians who were on the right of the Castilian Royal light, the doubtful acquires the prole of a certain triumph.
battle, received [the charge of] the Princes men as brave The politic [Ferdinand] achieved the fruits of a discussed
knights invoking Santiago but they couldn't resist them and victory. In Fernando el Catlico, el mejor rey de Espaa,
began to ee, and [so] our men killed and arrested many of Ejrcito revue, nr 16, p. 56, May 1941.
them, and among those who escaped some took refuge (...)
[40] Vicente lvarez Palenzuela- La guerra civil Castellana y
in their Royal battle that was on left of these six [Castil-
el enfrentamiento con Portugal (14751479): That is the
ian] divisions. " in Chronica do Principe D. Joam, chapter
battle of Toro. The Portuguese army had not been exactly
LXXVIII.
defeated, however, the sensation was that D. Juanas cause
[34] chronicler Juan de Mariana (Castilian): "...the enemy had completely sunk. It made sense that for the Castilians
led by prince D. John of Portugal, who without suer- Toro was considered as the divine retribution, the compen-
ing defeat, stood on a hill with his forces in good order sation desired by God to compensate the terrible disaster of
until very late (...). Thus, both forces [Castilian and Por- Aljubarrota, still alive in the Castilian memory.
tuguese] remained face to face for some hours; and the
Portuguese kept their position during more time (...)" in [41] Spanish academic Rafael Dominguez Casas: "...San
Historia General de Espaa, tome V, book XXIV, chapter Juan de los Reyes resulted from the royal will to build a
X, p. 299,300. monastery to commemorate the victory in a battle with an
uncertain outcome but decisive, the one fought in Toro in
[35] chronicler Rui de Pina (Portuguese): And being the two 1476, which consolidated the union of the two most impor-
enemy battles face to face, the Castilian battle was deeply tant Peninsular Kingdoms. In San Juan de los reyes: espa-
agitated and showing clear signs of defeat if attacked as it cio funerrio y aposento rgio in Boletn del Seminrio de
was without King and dubious of the outcome.(...) And Estdios de Arte y Arqueologia, number 56, p. 364, 1990.
without discipline and with great disorder they went to
Zamora. So being the Prince alone on the eld without suf- [42] Justo L. Gonzlez- Historia del Cristianismo Archived
fering defeat but inicting it on the adversary he became 16 June 2013 at the Wayback Machine., Editorial Unilit,
heir and master of his own victory in Chronica de El- rei Miami, 1994, Tome 2, Parte II (La era de los conquista-
D.Aonso V... 3rd book, chapter CXCI. dores), p. 68.
[36] French historian Jean Dumont in La imcomparable Is- [43] Historian Marvin Lunenfeld: In 1476, immediately af-
abel la Catolica/ The incomparable Isabel the Catholic, ter the indecisive battle of Peleagonzalo [near Toro], Fer-
Encuentro Ediciones, printed by Rogar-Fuenlabrada, dinand and Isabella hailed the result as a great victory and
Madrid, 1993 (Spanish edition), p. 49: "...But in the left called a cortes at Madrigal. The newly created prestige
[Portuguese] Wing, in front of the Asturians and Galician, was used to gain municipal support from their allies(...)"
the reinforcement army of the Prince heir of Portugal, well in The council of the Santa Hermandad: a study of the
provided with artillery, could leave the battleeld with its pacication forces of Ferdinand and Isabella, University
head high. The battle resulted this way, inconclusive. But of Miami Press, 1970, p. 27.
its global result stays after that decided by the withdraw
of the Portugals King, the surrender... of the Zamoras [44] Prescott, William. History of the Reign of Ferdinand and
fortress on March 19, and the multiple adhesions of the Isabella, The Catholic. J.B. Lippincott & CO., 1860, p.
nobles to the young princes. 184185
14 10 NOTES
[45] Battle of Guinea: Alonso de Palencia, Dcada IV, Book between Portugal and Castile instead of the monopoly the
XXXIII, Chapter V (Disaster among those sent to the Portuguese acquired.
mines of gold [Guinea]. Charges against the King...), pp.
9194. This was a decisive battle because after it, in spite [53] Mendona, 2007, p. 101103.
of the Catholic Monarchs attempts, they were unable to
[54] Edwards,John. The Spain of the Catholic Monarchs 1474
send new eets to Guinea, Canary or to any part of the
1520. Blackwell Publishers Inc, 2000, p. 38
Portuguese empire until the end of the war. The Perfect
Prince sent an order to drown any Castilian crew captured [55] Mendona, 2007, p. 53.
in Guinea waters. Even the Castilian navies which left
Guinea before the signature of the peace treaty had to pay [56] Antnio Rumeu de Armas- book description,
the tax (quinto) to the Portuguese crown when they re- MAPFRE, Madrid, 1992, page 88.
turned to Castile after the peace treaty. Isabella had to
[57] M Monserrat Len Guerrero in El segundo viaje colom-
ask permission of Afonso V so that this tax could be paid
bino, University of Valladolid, 2000, chapter 2, pp. 49
in Castilian harbours. Naturally all this caused a grudge
50.
against the Catholic Monarchs in Andalusia.
[58] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker
[46] Historian Malyn Newitt: However, in 1478 the Por-
Press, 1915, p. 121
tuguese surprised thirty-ve Castilian ships returning from
Mina [Guinea] and seized them and all their gold. An- [59] Borucho, David A. Historiography with License: Is-
other...Castilian voyage to Mina, that of Eustache de la abel, the Catholic Monarch, and the Kingdom of God.
Fosse, was intercepted ... in 1480. (...) All things con- Isabel la Catlica, Queen of Castile: Critical Essays. Pal-
sidered, it is not surprising that the Portuguese emerged grave Macmillan, 2003, pp. 242247.
victorious from this rst maritime colonial war. They
were far better organised than the Castilians, were able to [60] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker
raise money for the preparation and supply of their eets, Press, 1915, p. 125
and had clear central direction from ... [Prince] John. In
A history of Portuguese overseas expansion, 14001668, [61] Edwards,John. The Spain of the Catholic Monarchs 1474
Routledge, New York, 2005, pp. 3940. 1520. Blackwell Publishers Inc, 2000, p. 42
[49] Alonso de Palencia, Decada IV, Book [65] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker
XXXI, Chapters VIII and IX (preparation Press, 1915, p. 123
of 2 eets [to Guinea and to Canary, respec-
tively] so that with them King Ferdinand crush [66] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker
its enemies [the Portuguese]...). Press, 1915, p. 133
[50] Alonso de Palencia, Decada IV, book XXXII, chapter [67] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker
III: in 1478 a Portuguese eet intercepted the armada of Press, 1915, p. 150
25 navies sent by Ferdinand to conquer Gran Canary [68] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker
capturing 5 of its navies plus 200 Castilians and forced Press, 1915, p. 152155
it to ed hastily and denitively from Canary waters. This
victory allowed Prince John to use the Canary Islands as [69] Edwards, John. Ferdinand and Isabella. Pearson Educa-
an exchange coin in the peace treaty of Alcovas. tion Limited, 2005, p. 28
[51] Pina, Chronica de El-Rei D. Aonso V, 3rd book, chap- [70] Edwards, John. Ferdinand and Isabella. Pearson Educa-
ter CXCIV (Editorial error: Chapter CXCIV erroneously tion Limited, 2005, p. 29
appears as Chapter CLXIV.Reports the end of the siege
of Ceuta by the arrival of the eet with Afonso V). [71] Edwards, John. Ferdinand and Isabella. Pearson Educa-
tion Limited, 2005, p. 2932
[52] Quesada, Portugueses en la frontera de Granada, 2000,
[72] Edwards, John. Ferdinand and Isabella. Pearson Educa-
p. 98. In 1476 Ceuta was simultaneously besieged by the
tion Limited, 2005, p. 30
moors and a Castilian army led by the Duke of Medina
Sidnia. The Castilians conquered the city from the Por- [73] Edwards,John. The Spain of the Catholic Monarchs 1474
tuguese who took refuge in the inner fortress, but a Por- 1520. Blackwell Publishers Inc, 2000, p. 4247
tuguese eet arrived in extremis and regained the city.
A Ceuta dominated by the Castilians would certainly have [74] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabella of Castile. The Knickerbocker
forced the right to conquer Fez (Morocco) to be shared Press, 1915, p. 142
15
[76] Edwards,John. The Spain of the Catholic Monarchs 1474 [97] Isabel la Catlica en la Real Academia de la Historia.
1520. Blackwell Publishers Inc, 2000, p. 49 Madrid: Real Academia de la Historia. 2004. p. 72.
ISBN 84-95983-54-0.
[77] Plunkett,Ierne. Isabel of Castile. The Knickerbocker
Press, 1915, p. 146 [98] Princess of Isabellas coat of arms with crest: Garca-
[78] Edwards, John. Ferdinand and Isabella. Pearson Educa- Menacho Osset, Eduardo (2010). El origen militar de
tion Limited, 2005, p. 48 los smbolos de Espaa. El escudo de Espaa [Military
Origin of Symbols of Spain. The Coat of Arms of Spain].
[79] Edwards, John. Ferdinand and Isabella. Pearson Educa- Revista de Historia Militar (in Spanish). Instituto de His-
tion Limited, 2005, p. 4849 toria y Cultura Militar (Extra): 387. ISSN 0482-5748.
[80] Edwards,John. The Spain of the Catholic Monarchs 1474 [99] Menndez-Pidal De Navascus, Faustino; El escudo;
1520. Blackwell Publishers Inc, 2000, p. 104106 Menndez Pidal y Navascus, Faustino; O'Donnell, Hugo;
Lolo, Begoa. Smbolos de Espaa. Madrid: Centro de
[81] Edwards,John. The Spain of the Catholic Monarchs 1474 Estudios Polticos y Constitucionales, 1999. ISBN 84-
1520. Blackwell Publishers Inc, 2000, p. 111 259-1074-9
[82] Edwards,John. The Spain of the Catholic Monarchs 1474
[100] Image of the Isabellas coat of arms with lions as support-
1520. Blackwell Publishers Inc, 2000, p. 112130
ers, facade of the St. Paul Church inValladolid (Spain)
[83] Liss,Peggy. Isabel the Queen, Oxford University Press, Artehistoria. Retrieved 3 January 2012.
1992. p. 316
[101] Scotts Specialized Catalogue of United States Stamps
[84] Edwards, John. Ferdinand and Isabella. Pearson Educa-
tion Limited, 2005, p. 120 [102] Scotts Specialized Catalogue of United States Stamps:
Quantities Issued
[85] Edwards, John. Ferdinand and Isabella. Pearson Educa-
tion Limited, 2005, p. 119
Roth, Norman (1995) Conversos, Inquisition, and Desormeaux, Joseph-Louis Ripault (1758) Abrg
the Expulsion of the Jews from Spain. (Madison: chronologique de l'histoire de l'spagne, Duchesne,
The University of Wisconsin Press) Paris, 3rd Tome.
Stuart, Nancy Rubin. Isabella of Castile: the First Dumont, Jean (1993) La imcomparable Isabel
Renaissance Queen (New York: St. Martins Press, la Catolica (The incomparable Isabella, the
1991) Catholic), Madrid: Encuentro Editiones, printed by
Rogar-Fuenlabrada (Spanish edition).
Tremlett, Giles. 'Isabella of Castile. Europes
First Great Queen"' (London: Bloomsbury, 2017)
Gonzlez, Justo L. (1994) Historia del Cristian-
Tremlett, Giles. "Catherine of Aragon. Henrys ismo, Miami: Editorial Unilit, Tome 2. ISBN
Spanish Queen (London: Faber and Faber, 2010) 1560634766
Weissberger, Barbara F. Queen Isabel I of Castile: Guerrero, M Monserrat Len (2002) El segundo vi-
Power, Patronage, Persona (2008) aje colombino, Alicante: Biblioteca Virtual Miguel
de Cervantes. ISBN 8468812080
Weissberger, Barbara F. Isabel Rules: Constructing
Queenship, Wielding Power (2003) Manchado, Ana Isabel Carrasco (2006) Isabel I de
Castilla y la sombra de la ilegitimidad. Propaganda y
representacin en el conicto sucesorio (14741482),
11.1 In Spanish and Portuguese
Madrid: Slex ediciones.
Articles
Mendona, Manuela (2007) O Sonho da Unio
Ibrica guerra Luso-Castelhana 1475/1479, Lis-
Beretta, Antonio Ballesteros (1941) Fernando el boa: Quidnovi, book description. ISBN 978-
Catlico, in Ejrcito revue, Ministerio del Ejercito, 9728998882
Madrid, nr 16, p. 5466, May 1941.
Pereira, Isabel Violante (2001) De Mendo da
Casas, Rafael Dominguez (1990) San Juan de los
Guarda a D. Manuel I. Lisboa: Livros Horizonte
reyes: espacio funerrio y aposento rgio in Bo-
letn del Seminrio de Estdios de Arte y Arqueolo-
gia, number 56, p. 364383, University of Val- Chronicles
ladolid.
Duro, Cesreo Fernndez (1901) La batalla de Toro Gis, Damio de (1724) Chronica do Principe D.
(1476). Datos y documentos para su monografa Joam, edited by Lisboa occidental at the ocina da
histrica, Madrid: Boletn de la Real Academia de Msica, Lisboa (Biblioteca Nacional Digital).
la Historia, tomo 38.
Mariana, Juan de (1839) Historia General de Es-
Palenzuela,Vicente ngel Alvarez (2006) La guerra paa, tome V Barcelona: printing press of D. Fran-
civil castellana y el enfrentamiento con Portugal cisco Oliva.
(14751479), Universidad de Alicante, Biblioteca
Virtual Miguel de Cervantes. Palencia, Alfonso de Gesta Hispaniensia ex annal-
ibus suorum diebus colligentis, Dcada III and IV (the
Quesada, Miguel-ngel Ladero (2000) Portugueses three rst Dcadas were edited as Cronica del rey
en la frontera de Granada, Revista En la Espaa me- Enrique IV by Antonio Paz y Meli in 1904 and the
dieval, Universidad Complutense, nr. 23, pages 67 fourth as Cuarta Dcada by Jos Lopes de Toro in
100. 1970).
Serrano, Antnio Macia- San Juan de los Reyes y
la batalla de Toro, revista Toletum, segunda poca, Pina, Ruy de (1902) Chronica de El- rei D. Aonso
1979 (9), pp. 5570. Toledo: Real Academia de V, Project Gutenberg Ebook, Biblioteca de Clssi-
Bellas Artes y Ciencias Histricas de Toledo. ISSN: cos Portugueses, 3rd book, Lisboa.
0210-6310
Pulgar, Hernando del (1780) Crnica de los Seores
Reyes Catlicos Don Fernando y Doa Isabel de
Books Castilla y de Aragn, (Biblioteca Virtual Miguel de
Cervantes), Valencia: edited by Benito Monfort.
Armas, Antonio Rumeu (1992) El tratado de Torde-
sillas. Madrid: Colecciones MAPFRE 1492, book Resende, Garcia de Vida e feitos d'El Rei D.Joo
description. II electronic version, wikisource.
17
12 External links
Isabella I in the Catholic Encyclopedia
{{int:Coll-attribution-page|
|
19
}}