ASTM 128 Grade (110mn13) PDF
ASTM 128 Grade (110mn13) PDF
ASTM 128 Grade (110mn13) PDF
ABSTRACT
This investigation is conducted to assess the influence of some heat treatment procedures on the
structure and mechanical properties of cast ASTM A grade B-4 steel to which formation of grain
boundary carbides have been a major problem. Some cast ASTM A grade B-4 steel samples were
quench-hardened, martempered and tempered. The as-cast and heat-treated samples were there-
after tested for tensile strength, yield strength, impact strength, ductility and hardness. Some of
the samples were also prepared for metallographic examination and their microstructures were
studied. It was observed that in all cases, the microstructures were mainly austenite matrix with
or without carbides at the grain boundaries and in the austenitic grains depending on the heat-
treatment adopted. The measured mechanical properties varied and were greatly dependent on
the presence or absence of carbides either at the grain boundaries or at both the grain bounda-
ries and in the grains of austenite matrix. Two of the heat treatment procedures were found to be
appropriate as post-casting processes suitable for ASTM A 128 grade B-4 steel components de-
signed to function under a condition in which impact strength and hardness are simultaneously
required.
Keywords: austenitic manganese steel, heat treatment, mechanical properties, grain boundaries,
carbides
Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009 107
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
1990; Bayraktar et al, 1994; Miyahara et al, influence on the structure and some mechanical
1994; Takahashia et al, 1998; He, et al, 2002; properties of this alloy.
Kuc et al, 2006; Zhang et al, 1998), by varying
its composition (Zhang et al, 1998; García, EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
2005; Gavriljuk et al, 2006) or subjecting it to Sample Preparation
various treatments (Pelletier et al, 1995; John Austenitic manganese steel was prepared in
and Cornog, 1997; Owen and Grujicic, 1998; accordance with ASTM Standard (ASTM
Zhang et al, 2007; Wang et al, 2007) in order to A128/A128M-93, 2007) to conform to ASTM
meet different engineering application. Im- A 128 grade B-4 (Table 1) steel. Cylindrical
provement on the mechanical properties of aus- rod with a diameter of 20 mm and 500 mm
tenitic manganese steel over the years has not length sample was cast from the prepared steel.
been exhausted. In all cases austenitic manga- From the rod, some standard test pieces were
nese steels are generally useful engineering machined to diameter 11.4 mm by 75 mm
materials. length and notched to 3.3 mm and 45º included
angles for impact test. Similarly, standard test
However, in as-cast condition it is difficult to
specimens were prepared in accordance with
obtain an austenitic structure in austenitic man-
British Standard for proportional round test-
ganese steel that is sufficiently free of grain
pieces for tensile strength (BSI BS EN 10002-
boundary carbides. The presence of grain
boundary carbides is detrimental to strength 1, 2001). The impact strength, tensile strength
and ductility. Although carbides formed in the and hardness were determined and the proof
stress, percent elongation and reduction in area
castings that are cooled slowly in the moulds,
at fracture were also determined.
they form in practically all as-cast grades of
austenitic manganese steels containing more
than 1.0% C, regardless of mould cooling rates Heat Treatment
(Subramanyan et al, 1990). The final micros- Sixty test samples comprising twenty-five
specimens for tensile strength, twenty-five for
ture in most as-cast grade is not fully austenitic
impact, five each for hardness and micro ex-
but contains carbide precipitate and pearlite in
amination were rapidly heated inside a Bogie
an austenite grain boundary and matrix
Hearth heat treatment furnace to 340ºC. This
(Wiscers, 1980). The presence of these carbides
causes the embrittlement of the material and in was followed by slow heating at the rate of
essence affects its application as engineering 100ºC per hour to 1040ºC and held at this tem-
perature for about 1.5hr to homogenize the
material that has resistance to impact and abra-
structure (Prabhudev, 1988). They were there-
sion wear.
after subjected to various treatments as detailed
The embrittlement of ASTM A 128 grade B-4 below:
(Table 1) is major setback to its use in as-cast
Water Quenching: Forty-eight of the samples
condition for the production of products for
were removed and then quenched in agitated
which toughness at reasonable level and high
water for hardening and tempering heat treat-
hardness is simultaneously required. Though
ment operations. Out of these twelve were used
works have been done on different austenitic
manganese steels over the years, the response for mechanical testing and micro examination
in quench hardened conditions, and thirty-six
of ASTM A 128 grade B-4 (Table 1) to various
were used for tempering heat treatment.
heat-treatment procedures with respect to its
mechanical properties has not been reported. Martempering: The remaining twelve samples
Thus in this work, a grade of an austenitic were quenched in a molten salt-bath maintained
manganese steel, ASTM A 128 grade B-4 at 250ºC. They were soaked in the bath at this
(Table 1) is cast and subjected to different heat temperature for about 1hr to ensure uniformity
treatment procedures in order to evaluate their of temperature for all the samples at 250ºC. The
108 Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
samples were then taken out of the bath and Where HB = Brinell hardness number, in kg/
allowed to cool in air. mm2; P = Applied load in kg, D = Diameter of
ball in mm and d = Diameter of indent in mm.
High Temperature Tempering: Twelve of the
water-quenched samples were slowly heated to The tensile strength, also known as ultimate
550 ºC at the rate of 50 ºC per hour, holding at tensile strength (σUTS) is the maximum stress
this temperature for 1hr and thereafter cooled in that the material can withstand before failure
air to ambient temperature. and it is calculated by an expression:
Medium Temperature Tempering: Another
Fmax (2)
twelve of the water-quenched samples were σ UTS =
slowly heated to 450ºC at rate of 50ºC per hour, Ao
holding them at this temperature for 1hr and
followed by air-cooling to ambient temperature. where Fmax and Ao is the maximum applied load
Low Temperature Tempering: The remaining and initial cross sectional area respectively.
twelve of the water-quenched samples were From tensile testing, other properties of materi-
slowly heated to 250 ºC at rate of 50 ºC per als such as yield strength, elongation and reduc-
hour, holding them at this temperature for 1hr tion in area are also determined. The yield
and followed by cooling in air to ambient tem- strength is determined as the stress at which
perature. plastic deformation (elongation/extension) of
the tensile specimen takes place at a constant
Mechanical Testing load.
The Brinell hardness tester was employed for Percent elongation, ε, is a change in length per
determining the hardness of the samples. A 10 unit length of the tensile specimen expressed
mm hardened standard steel ball under a con- thus:
sistent load of 3000 kg was pressed into the L f − Lo
surface of the specimens to be tested. Having ε = × 100 (3)
Lo
removed the load, indentation diameter left on
the surface of the specimen was measured and
where Lf and Lo is the final and initial gauge
the hardness value determined using Eq. (1).
length of the tensile specimen respectively.
The tensile test was performed using Universal
Reduction in area which is often expressed in
Tensile Testing Machine. The values of proof
percentage also computed by equation:
stresses were read directly from the graph of
stress strain curve and tensile strength deter- Ao − A f
mined using Eq. (2). The percent elongation RA = ×100 (4)
Ao
and reduction in area were calculated in accor-
dance to Eq. (3) and (4) respectively. where Ao and Af is the initial and final cross-
The impact strength in this study was measured sectional area of the tensile specimen respec-
by Izod impact test method (Rajan et al, 1999) tively. Reduction in area is independent of the
using universal impact testing machine. sample gauge length and reflects the local de-
formation in the necked region. For these rea-
The Brinell Hardness Number (BHN) is the sons, it is considered as a better measure of
ratio of an applied load to area of indentation ductility.
produced by spherical steel ball pressed into a
specimen under the action of the applied load Impact strength is capability of a material to
and calculated thus: absorb energy without failure under impact
loading. In actual service, a component such as
P crusher jaw is subjected to dynamic loading for
(π D / 2)(D − ))
HB =
(D 2
−d2
(1)
which reason; knowledge of tensile strength
Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009 109
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
Table 1: The Chemical Composition of the Prepared ASTM A 128 Grade B-4
Element C Mn Si P
110 Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
Plate 1: Optical micrograph of the prepared as-cast ASTM A 128 grade B-4 showing collec-
tion of carbide precipitates (darkish) concentrated at austenite grain boundaries and sparsely
distributed in the austenite matrix
Plate 2: Scanning electron micrograph of as-cast ASTM A 128 grade B-4 prepared showing
grain boundary carbide precipitates
Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009 111
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
austenite grain boundaries but there are no and large black spots are non-metallic inclu-
grain boundary carbides. In martempering con- sions. In tempering condition, the microstruc-
dition, the microstructure also reveals austenitic ture reveals austenite grains with precipitated
grains (Plate 4) with no grain boundary car- carbide at grain boundaries and in grain as
bides. The austenite grain boundaries however, shown in Plate 5 - 7. But the proportion of vol-
have almost disappeared. The very scanty tiny ume of precipitated carbides increases with
black dots are grain boundary carbide particles increase in tempering temperature.
that have failed to dissolve during austenizing
112 Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
Plate 6: Optical micrograph of medium tempered sample (heated to 1040 ºC, water quenched
and re-heated to 450 ºC) showing the precipitated carbide (blackish) at the grain boundaries
and in the grain of austenite matrix
Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009 113
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
Plate 7: Optical micrograph of high tempered sample (heated to 1040 ºC, water
quenched and re-heated to 550 ºC) showing the precipitated carbide (blackish) at the
grain boundaries and in the grain of austenite matrix (grayish)
114 Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
that in as-cast condition ASTM A 128 grade B- the presence of carbides at grain boundaries
4 is harder (215HB) than in water-quenched and in the grains makes the castings to be very
(209HB) and martempering (201HB) condi- hard with characteristic low toughness. The
tions. This may be due to the presence of car- impact strength is also noted to be decreasing
bide along the austenite grain boundaries of the with increasing tempering temperature (Table
as-cast sample (Plate 1). This may also explain 2). This may be attributed to the observed in-
its inferior toughness (117J) when compared crease in the volume fraction of carbides as the
with martempered (138J) and water-quenched tempering temperature increases. This however,
(134J) conditions. favours increase in hardness and decrease in the
ductility and consequently, low impact
As noted earlier, water-quenched and martem-
strength.
pered samples do not have carbides precipitates
at the grain boundaries (Plate 3 and 4). How- Two of the opposing mechanical properties,
ever, the high hardness (Table 2) exhibited in hardness and impact strength, are reasonably
water-quenched condition as compared to mar- exhibited simultaneously in the water-quenched
tempered may be attributed to well defined and martempered conditions compared to other
austenite grain boundaries in the microstructure heat treatment procedures conducted. Therefore
of water-quenched samples (Plate 3) which these two heat treatment procedures fairly rep-
have almost disappeared in the microstructure resent post-casting processes suitable for
of martempered samples (Plate 4).Holding the ASTM A 128 grade B-4 steel components de-
matempered samples in salt bath until the tem- signed to function under a condition in which
perature of the whole section thickness is con- two properties, toughness and hardness are si-
stant at 250ºC also decreases the overall ther- multaneously required at a reasonable level. In
mal gradient thereby reducing the residual spite of higher tensile strength and hardness of
stresses associated with heat treatment opera- components produced from as-cast and tem-
tions and hence reduction in hardness. pered ASTM A 128 grade B-4 steel, they are
susceptible to embrittlement. This susceptibility
In tempered conditions, the hardness values
to embrittlement can therefore lead to early
(228HB-245HB) are higher than in water-
quenched condition (215HB). The reason may failure by brittle fracture and consequently limit
be due to the presence of carbide both at the their sphere of engineering applications.
austenite grain boundaries and in the matrix as
seen in the microstructure of tempered sample CONCLUSION
(Plate 5 - 7). The hardness in tempered condi- The presence of large carbides either at the
tion, however, increases with tempering tem- grain boundaries or at both the grain boundaries
perature (250ºC /228HB, 450ºC /241HB and and in the grain of ASTM A 128 grade B-4
550ºC /245HB). The reason for this can be ad- austenitic manganese steel affects its unique
duced to increase in volume fraction of car- resistance to impact and abrasion wears. Its
bides as the tempering temperature increases as wear resistance becomes high but very suscep-
shown in microstructure of tempered samples tible to earlier brittle fracture under an impact
(Plate 5 - 7). and abrasive wear condition.
Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009 115
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
116 Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009
Mechanical properties of Quench-Hardened, Martempered ... Ibitoye et al.
Manganese Steels, Materials Science and Peening, Materials Science and Engineer-
Engineering A, 110: pp77-87. ing: A, 458(1-2): pp249-252..
Smith, R.W. DeMonte, A. and Mackay, W.B.F. Wieser, P.F. (1980). Steel Casting Handbook,
(2004). Development of High-Manganese 5th ed., Steel Founders’ Society of Amer-
Steels for Heavy Duty Cast-to-Shape Ap- ica, Ohio: pp16-11 – 17-3
plications, J. of Materials Processing Tech- Zhang, F., Lv B., Hu B. and Li, Y. (2007).
nology: 153-154, pp589-595.
Flash Butt Welding of High Manganese
Subramanyan, D.K., Swansiger, A.E., and Steel Crossing and Carbon Steel Rail, Ma-
Avery, H.S. (1990). Austenitic Manganese terials Science and Engineering: A, pp454-
Steels, ASM Handbook l, New York: 455: 288-292.
pp821-837.
Zhang, G., Xing, J. and Gao, Y. (1998). Impact
Takahashia, H., Shindoa, Y., Kinoshitaa, H., Wear Resistance of WC/Hadfield Steel
Shibayamaa, T., Ishiyamab, S., Fukayab, Composite and Its Interfacial Characteris-
K., Etob, M., Kusuhashic, M., Hatake- tics, Wear, 260(7-8): pp728-734.
yamac, T. and Satoc, I. (1998). Mechani-
cal Properties and Damage Behavior of
Non-Magnetic High Manganese Austenitic
Steels, J. of Nuclear Materials, 258-263(2):
pp1644-1650.
Wang, T.S., Lu B., Zhang, M., Hou, R.J. and
Zhang, F.C. (2007). Nanocrystallization
and α Martensite Formation in the Surface
Layer of Medium-Manganese Austenitic
Wear-Resistant Steel Caused by Shot
Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 29, No. 2, Aug., 2009 117