Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 44 views

    Minutes of Preliminary Conference Group 5 Final

    Uploaded by

    Emrys Pendragon
    1. The case involves a dispute over ownership of a parcel of land between siblings Rafa A. Dela Cruz and Cherry A. Dela Cruz. 2. A preliminary conference was held where the parties discussed marking of evidence, witnesses, and potential stipulations. 3. Key points of contention were the ownership of the land and whether Rafa paid property taxes from 2015-present. 4. Both parties expressed willingness to settle amicably but had differing views on terms of settlement. 5. A pre-trial was scheduled for May 5, 2019.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Minutes of Preliminary Conference Group 5 Final

    Uploaded by

    Emrys Pendragon
    44 views6 pages
    1. The case involves a dispute over ownership of a parcel of land between siblings Rafa A. Dela Cruz and Cherry A. Dela Cruz. 2. A preliminary conference was held where the parties discussed marking of evidence, witnesses, and potential stipulations. 3. Key points of contention were the ownership of the land and whether Rafa paid property taxes from 2015-present. 4. Both parties expressed willingness to settle amicably but had differing views on terms of settlement. 5. A pre-trial was scheduled for May 5, 2019.

    Original Description:

    Minutes if Preliminary Conference Group 5 Final Description

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    1. The case involves a dispute over ownership of a parcel of land between siblings Rafa A. Dela Cruz and Cherry A. Dela Cruz. 2. A preliminary conference was held where the parties discussed marking of evidence, witnesses, and potential stipulations. 3. Key points of contention were the ownership of the land and whether Rafa paid property taxes from 2015-present. 4. Both parties expressed willingness to settle amicably but had differing views on terms of settlement. 5. A pre-trial was scheduled for May 5, 2019.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as doc, pdf, or txt
    44 views6 pages

    Minutes of Preliminary Conference Group 5 Final

    Uploaded by

    Emrys Pendragon
    1. The case involves a dispute over ownership of a parcel of land between siblings Rafa A. Dela Cruz and Cherry A. Dela Cruz. 2. A preliminary conference was held where the parties discussed marking of evidence, witnesses, and potential stipulations. 3. Key points of contention were the ownership of the land and whether Rafa paid property taxes from 2015-present. 4. Both parties expressed willingness to settle amicably but had differing views on terms of settlement. 5. A pre-trial was scheduled for May 5, 2019.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as doc, pdf, or txt
    You are on page 1of 6

    Republic of the Philippines

    National Capital Judicial Region


    METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURT
    Branch 1, Manila

    RAFA A. DELA CRUZ,


    Plaintiff/s,
    Civil Case No. 1237-CV
    -versus- For: Unlawful Detainer
    with Damages

    CHERRY A. DELA CRUZ,


    Defendant/s,

    x---------------------------------------------x

    MINUTES OF PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE

    For the Plaintiff: For the Defendant:


    Rafa A. Dela Cruz Cherry A. Dela Cruz

    Assisted by: Assisted by:


    Atty. Maria C. Aguinaldo Atty. Shashing Eses
    Atty. Joyie Cy

    Marking of Documentary Evidence:

    For the Plaintiff: For the Defendant:

    1. Exhibit “A” – Transfer 1. Exhibit “1” – Transfer


    Certificate of Title (original) Certificate of Title of the
    2. Exhibit “B” – Final subject parcel of land
    Demand Letter to Vacate (also Exhibit “A” for the
    (original) Plaintiff)
    3. Exhibit “C” – Barangay 2. Exhibit “1-A” – name
    Conciliation Certificate to “Ruffa A. Dela Cruz”
    File Action (original) 3. Exhibit “2” – Tax
    4. Exhibit “D” – Property Declaration of the
    Location Picture (original) subject parcel of land
    5. Exhibit “E” – (reserved for (original)
    marking) Judicial Affidavit 4. Exhibit “2-A” – name
    of Rafa A. Dela Cruz “Ruffa A. Dela Cruz”
    5. Exhibit “3” – Tax
    Declaration of the

    Page 1 of 6
    residential house built
    on the subject parcel of
    land (original)
    6. Exhibit “3-A” – amount
    of the market value
    7. Exhibit “4” – Official
    Receipt for the payment
    of the real property tax
    for year 2015 (original)
    8. Exhibit “4-A” – amount
    paid
    9. Exhibit “5” – Official
    Receipt for the payment
    of the real property tax
    for year 2016 (original)
    10. Exhibit “5-A” – amount
    paid
    11. Exhibit “6” - Official
    Receipt for the payment
    of the real property tax
    for year 2017 (original)
    12. Exhibit “6-A” – amount
    paid
    13. Exhibit “7” – Official
    Receipt for the payment
    of the real property tax
    for year 2018 (original)
    14. Exhibit “7-A” – amount
    paid
    15. Exhibit “8” – (reserved
    for marking) Judicial
    Affidavit of Cherry A.
    Dela Cruz
    16. Exhibit “8-A” –
    signature of Cherry A.
    Dela Cruz

    with reservation to present


    additional documentary
    evidence during the course of
    the trial.

    Page 2 of 6
    Genuineness and Due Execution Admitted:

    For the Plaintiff: For the Defendant:

    The Defendant admits the The Plaintiff admits the


    genuineness and due genuineness and due
    execution of the following execution of the following
    Plaintiff’s exhibits only: Defendant’s exhibits only:

    1. Exhibit “A” – Transfer 1. Exhibit “1” – Transfer


    Certificate of Title (original) Certificate of Title of the
    2. Exhibit “C” – Barangay subject parcel of land
    Conciliation Certificate to 2. Exhibit “2” – Tax
    File Action (original) Declaration of the subject
    parcel of land (original)
    3. Exhibit “3” – Tax
    Declaration of the
    residential house built on
    the subject parcel of land
    (original)
    4. Exhibit “4” – Official
    Receipt for the payment of
    the real property tax for
    year 2015 (original)
    5. Exhibit “5” – Official
    Receipt for the payment of
    the real property tax for
    year 2016 (original)
    6. Exhibit “6” - Official
    Receipt for the payment of
    the real property tax for
    year 2017 (original)
    7. Exhibit “7” – Official
    Receipt for the payment of
    the real property tax for
    year 2018 (original)

    Listing of Witnesses and Object Evidence:

    For the Plaintiff: For the Defendant:

    1. Rafa A. Dela Cruz 1. Cherry A. Dela Cruz


    2. One (1) reserved witness

    Page 3 of 6
    Object Evidence:
    For the Plaintiff: For the Defendant:

    - None - - None -

    Possibility of Settlement:

    For the Plaintiff: For the Defendant:

    The Plaintiff is open to an The Defendant is willing to


    amicable settlement with the enter into an amicable
    Defendants provided it is fair settlement provided that:
    and reasonable.
    1. Plaintiff is open to settling
    this dispute amicably subject
    to a concrete proposal that is
    fair and reasonable from a
    reciprocal manifestation of
    openness from the
    Defendant; and

    2. The desired terms of any


    amicable settlement would
    involve, first, an admission of
    amount due and owing to the
    Defendant, and, second, a
    schedule of payments.

    Proposed Stipulations:

    For the Plaintiff: For the Defendant:

    1. Personal circumstances of 1. The Plaintiff and the


    the parties [ADMITTED] Defendant are both
    2. Sending and receipt of legitimate children of Ruffa
    Defendant of the final A. Dela Cruz. [ADMITTED]
    Final Ddemand Lletter to 2. The 2-storey residential
    Vacate [ADMITTED] house standing on the
    3. Barangay conciliation subject parcel of land was
    proceedings were built from the Defendant’s
    unsuccessful [ADMITTED] own funds. [NOT
    4. Plaintiff is the absolute ADMITTED]
    owner and title holder of 3. The Plaintiff, from 2015 up
    the parcel of land [NOT to the present, did not pay
    Page 4 of 6
    ADMITTED] nor shared in the payment
    5. That there is already the of the real property tax of
    need to use the property, the subject parcel of land.
    hence, repeated demands [NOT ADMITTED]
    to vacate was were made
    to the Defendant [NOT
    ADMITTED]
    6. Plaintiff filed a complaint
    for ejectment at MeTC
    Branch 1, Manila
    [ADMITTED]
    7. Failure of the Defendant to
    vacate constrained the
    Plaintiff to retain services
    of herein counsel
    [attorneys fees and cost of
    litigation same in the
    Complaint] [NOT
    ADMITTED]
    8. No Plaintiff has no
    knowledge of the building
    of the 2-storey concrete
    residential house nor the
    approval of the
    construction of the same
    by the deceased mother
    [NOT ADMITTED]

    Other Matters:

    Pre-trial is set on May 5, 2019 at 3:00 o’clock in the afternoon.

    CONFORME:

    RAFA A. DELA CRUZ CHERRY A. DELA CRUZ


    Plaintiff Defendant

    Assisted by: Assisted by:


    Page 5 of 6
    MARIA C. AGUINALDO SHASING ESES
    Counsel for the Plaintiff

    JOYCIE CY
    Counsels for the Defendant

    Page 6 of 6

    You might also like