Mape Fintech 2016 PDF
Mape Fintech 2016 PDF
Mape Fintech 2016 PDF
June 2016
Preface
Overview majors.
The world is witnessing a major shift in financial services. Technology is A combination of factors is at play. Reduced trust in the global banking
fast changing how we pay, lend, borrow, invest, insure and do a host of system, low interest rates, data flows, analytics and the growth of
financial activities or transactions in our personal as well as business smartphones – all of these have created the enabling conditions for
lives. The large global financial services businesses or institutions which start-ups to attack the traditional financial sector. Backed by venture
handle these activities had till now managed to sidestep the onslaught financing, many of these companies are causing a massive disruption in
of technological tsunami unlike in most other industries. And remained financial services. The bank is being systematically unbundled, and new
intact and unbruised unlike in most other sectors where a new crop of players are attacking every segment of the market. These companies
younger businesses completely transformed the industry landscape. You have improved service levels, reduced costs and dramatically improved
still bank, insure, have your credit card/take mortgage mostly from the the user experience. Term loans in the US are possible within a day,
same set of industry players with whom your mother or grandmother did and one no longer needs to be an HNI for getting personalised
business with. Which is not the case for buying books, searching for investment advisory services. $ 19 Bn poured into the sector in 2015,
information, booking tickets, reserving hotel rooms and the way you which also witnessed several Fintech IPOs. The Economist, rarely given
communicate with other people. Technology led innovations in business to hyperbole, has called it the Fintech revolution.
models and processes had fundamentally changed most businesses in
the last 20 years. Except for a few leviathans like financial service The Indian Context
businesses. Closer home, India seems more than ripe for a Fintech revolution. Just
consider these basic metrics. Until the Jan Dhan initiative, 60%of Indians
Not anymore. were unbanked and 90% of small businesses have no links to formal
financial institutions. Yet 75% of Indians own mobile phones and over
“Silicon Valley is coming” Jamie Dimon, CEO of JP Morgan Chase wrote 25% are expected to have a smart phone by 2017. The penetration of
in his April 2005 letter to his shareholders. “There are hundreds of start- digital banking is an undercurrent that may leave most people surprised
ups with lots of brains and money working on various alternatives to – or shocked. We see the tipping point to be in 2016, when internet
traditional banking.” Technology led companies in the financial services penetration in the country crosses 30%. By 2020, digital transactions are
sector are increasingly offering a serious alternative to traditional likely to account for more than a quarter of transactions in the banking
products and services offered by large financial institutions. Fintech sector. By 2022, digital banking will have more than 50% penetration
companies across the world are offering products and services at much levels. Mobile banking adoption rates are already outpacing web
lesser cost, greater speed, increasing efficiency and more importantly banking.
with a much more “cool” quotient than the large monolith financial
Preface
Jan Dhan Yojana, the financial inclusion initiative of the new Indian rather as the raison d etre like the young start-ups. Innovation, efficiency
Government has resulted in 190 Mn new bank accounts being opened. and disruption are the terms one usually comes across with any
Aadhar, the ambitious national identification number project of the Indian discussion on Fintech companies.
government will soon have 1 Bn people covered facilitating on-line Fintech companies attracted more than US$ 14 Bn of funding in
biometric verification and consequently online enabled KYC and calendar year 2015 and the current estimate is that along with debt
financial transaction possibilities. This two initiatives along with rapidly funding and IPO funding of the larger Fintech companies in United
growing Mobile telephony is expected to create a JAM impetus to States, this number may have touched US$ 25 Bn in 2015. CB Insights,
digitisation and wider inclusive growth – especially amongst the poor a research firm which specialises in Fintech, estimates that the number
hitherto unbanked large mass of citizens - of financial sector growth in of unicorns (private companies with a valuation in excess of US$ 1 Bn)
India. Analysts have pointed that like how most of India bypassed the has touched 36 by the middle of 2015, up from a measly 11 less than an
fixed line telephony penetration and straight away embraced mobile year before. Fintech companies like Lending Club and Square have
telephony, a similar model may be imminent in the Indian financial done successful IPOs in the U.S.
sector. Large part of the population may not ever open a conventional
bank account and straight away use mobile phone to do financial Is Fintech and the new golden dawn they promise for real or is just hype
transactions – whether for payments, lending, borrowing or investing. about “Millennials” pushing their technology habits into the last frontier –
Nandan Nilekani, the technology entrepreneur and the brain and soul financial services? Millennials are the U.S word for the generation born
behind Aadhar goes on to say that the mobile phone will be the bank between 1980 and 2000 and broadly make up one of the largest
account for many Indians and call the current trends as heralding a generations in history, bigger than the baby boom generation. Millennials
“WhatsApp moment in Indian financial services” are investing, lending and sharing money much differently from their
parents assisted by a growing set of tech-driven tools. Host of Fintech
What is Fintech start-ups and the investors backing them are banking on Millennials as a
What exactly is Fintech? Like any new evolving trend, an universal key demographic for their success and many Fintech firms are
definition is hard to come by. However, in general, people talk about leveraging existing technologies – like social networks and mobile
technology led companies that are using technology as a key tool to messaging already popular among young adults – to offer financial
make financial systems more efficient. And while doing so, the start-up products and services.
Fintech companies are more often than not, disrupting incumbent
financial services companies that still look at technology as an enabler
3
Preface
What are the products/services of Fintech firms closer scrutiny from regulators to this segment of Fintech, this sector is
Now, what exactly are the products/services which these new age firms cited as one of the more promising in India as we have one of the largest
are offering which are being seen as so cool and next-generation? In this offline peer to peer lending markets. Business Lending companies act
report, we look at some of the main sub-sectors and try and plot out the as online digital NBFCs and provide loan to small and medium
key themes and outlook for each of them. enterprises. Kabbage and OnDeck are two unicorns in this space. Ecom
Wallets are the digital equivalent of a physical wallet, with preloaded companies are partnering with business lending start-ups, sharing their
money that can be spent on participating online and offline merchants. merchants’ business data and helping the merchants get working capital
While smartphone boom and low penetration of cards is driving wallet financing. In the Indian context, Lendingkart and CapitalFloat both have
adoption in Asia and other emerging markets, it is the technological raised US$ 10 Mn+ in venture funding. Indian growth potential in this
advancements and associated convenience that is driving wallet space is seen as huge given that most small business firms are outside
adoption in mature markets. Paytm, the Indian wallet player recently the purview of normal bank credit facilities.
made news when it raised US$ 675 Mn from Alibaba/Alipay and then Asset Management or robo-advisory firms offer automated algorithmic
subsequently got a payment banking license from the Indian driven personalised investment advisory services to individuals. A
Government. personalised investment portfolio can normally be set up in minutes by
Payments focused players are leveraging the high transaction fees, high providing information about investment goals, risk aversion etc and an
minimum transaction slabs and high cost of owning traditional payment algorithm adjusts the portfolio on an ongoing basis. Wealthfront and
devices to offer innovative and distinctive solutions to both consumers Betterment are two U.S based players who have both US$ 2 Bn+ of
and merchants. For example, Square provides a simple tech-driven assets under management. Personal Finance Management firms
solution to a serious problem of merchants not having a device to swipe provide account aggregation tools that provide individuals with a single
the customer cards at the point of sale. A free mobile phone based card view to manage their wealth, stock portfolio, personal budgets, taxes etc.
reader of Square can be downloaded as an app which can immediately Credit Karma and Yodlee are two U.S based unicorns in this space.
start accepting payments has led the Company see its valuation zoom to Remittances focused Fintech companies are fast changing the industry
US$ 6 Bn. landscape in inter-country money transfer services. They offer faster,
Consumer Lending companies leverage the power of technology to have cheaper and more transparent remittance services than banks, money
online marketplaces that matches borrowers with lenders. Global players transfer operators and informal channels. The cost of traditional
like Lending Club and SOFI have raised US$ 865 Mn and US$ 766 Mn remittance channels remain high and a World Bank study talks about a
respectively. While the recent troubles of Lending Club has brought global average cost of 5%+.
4
Preface
The hidden cost is the forex spread – the difference between an inter-
bank currency conversion rate and the rate quoted to you by a bank or Who are the consumers
money transfer company. India which receives about US$ 70 Bn in Is it mainly the tech savvy Millenials the main consumer base of these
remittances annually can save a few billion dollars in costs were Fintech new age Fintech companies ? While a superficial look may suggest so
companies to completely take over the remittance space. Instarem, an and anecdotal information about how robo-advisors are signing up U.S
Australian Fintech company saw its monthly remittance volumes to India citizens on the West Coast at a much faster rate than East Coasters may
cross US$ 2 Mn within few months of start of operations. support such a view, reality is much more complex. Yes, the rich and the
P2P Payments or peer to peer payment companies use cashless educated are indeed driving the growth, but technological
method to send, receive and charge money between peers. Money is advancements are also helping the poor and marginalised access
moved between the linked bank account/card and the P2P payment financial products and services, hitherto unavailable to them either
account, and between P2P accounts. People not on the P2P accounts because no financial institution touch their lives or the entry thresholds
can also be paid by referencing their phone or email details. While are too high.
internationally Facebook has enabled P2P transfers through its For instance in India, if the JAM revolution do take place, the real
messaging app, a bank like HDFC has enabled P2P payments for its beneficiaries of the Fintech revolution would be the poor and
customers by signing up with Chillr, a third party app which recently marginalised as in the new world order, all you need is a mobile phone
raised venture funding from Sequoia Capital. (maybe equipped with an IRIS reader to authenticate identity) to send
Crowd-funding companies offer a platform for equity, debt or even and receive money, buy financial products like insurance and mortgage,
donation funding to enterprises or causes than can be driven by large invest or even raise small loans for your businesses. The mobile phone
number of people paying very small amounts. For the average individual, which you anyway own will become your bank account, your depositary,
such firms provide an opportunity to participate in venture funding your loan provider, your investment manager and much more. Indeed a
without the intermediation of VC funds who have large threshold limits truly inclusive scenario.
and on-going management costs. And globally, the Fintech revolution seem to be widespread cutting
Blockchain has the ability to create distributed ledgers facilitating across continents and cultures. While U.S remains the largest market
decentralized transactions. This has reduced the cost and increased the and the hub of most Fintech companies, the list of Fintech unicorns
speed of transactions exponentially. The emergence of permission-less include young Dutch, Indian, Chinese and along with the usual suspects
platforms enabled by public blockchain has led to the Bitcoin and 700 from the G-7 economies.
other cryptocurrencies that have followed on the coat tails of its success.
5
Preface
What will happen to the large banks and financial institutions players may still hold an advantage in terms of financial muscle,
Is this going to be a traditional David v/s Goliath story ? Will they be the knowledge and trust of the customers, but the impact will depend on how
2020 equivalent of Barnes & Noble who got swamped by Amazon ? Will these large firms will change with the pace of technology. An interesting
those century-old large financial institutions that survived world wars, observation here is that retail businesses, which are more profitable and
financial meltdowns and numerous other challenges to be where they contribute disproportionately to the financial sector’s return on equity, will
are meet their nemesis in these tech savvy start-ups? Even in the odd be most vulnerable to this disruption by Fintech start-ups.
case of some financial tsunami, financial institutions have survived with
regulator/State assistance using the often railed TBTF (Too Big To Fail) Climbing the Slippery Slope of Regulation
arguments. One of the biggest hurdles facing the Fintech industry is regulation by
Most Fintech companies are hyper-specialising in just one aspect/small authorities. Regulatory framework was decided on the basis of how
segment amongst the multitude of products/services offered by a traditional financial institutions operated. Fintech has disrupted the space
conventional Bank. Many analysts have queried whether the unbundling by operating across different financial verticals and as such face a great
of bank services will mean the Bank has to face a multitude of different, deal of ambiguity on which of the plethora of regulatory agencies they
small, agile, tech driven competitors in most of their customer markets. must comply with. The number of regulations that must be complied with
And consequently will it lead to death by thousand cuts rather than being creates a problem for start-ups who are thinly staffed and don’t have the
a straight jab on the face. An interesting graphic doing the rounds is human resources to navigate the regulatory minefield. This becomes a
how a traditional bank is being challenged by its nimble footed Fintech barrier for a start-up to innovate for fear of non-compliance. Alternate
competitors. We attempt a similar graphic for the ICICI, the Indian bank lending and marketplace Fintech models have been the ones to feel the
and show that how for almost all the service/product lines detailed on its worst of the regulatory friction burn. Internal control policies of Fintech
web home-page, there are atleast one or more Fintech competitors. firms have to better sync with the industry regulation standards. Lending
The pertinent question is whether these TBTF institutions are also TBTC Club, one of the biggest success stories of the Fintech revolution, ran
(Too Big To Change) entities and may get swamped by the tech wave. into troubled waters for loans it had sold to an investment bank without
Globally, incumbents in the banking sector are scooping to invest, making disclosures to its borrowers. This led to a moratorium on buying
mentor or otherwise integrate Fintech firms in their portfolio and Lending Club loans, the resignation of the CEO and a drop of 60% in
systems. For instance, Citi group is an investor in Square and share price. Regulators are reacting to the changing need state of the
Betterment, Wells Fargo in Lending Club, Santander and Amex have industry with steps in the right direction. The FDIC, FTC and CFTC have
their own Fintech venture arms etc. Fintech firms have started to adopt issued papers lending clarity on marketplace lending, consumer
collaborative business models instead of competitive and investors have protection and bridging grey areas between traditional institutions and
shown their approval of this approach with increased investments. Fintech companies.
6
Preface
Europe has been more proactive in addressing this with FCA launching simultaneously, the competitive landscape is evolving rapidly. As an
Project Innovate which seeks to identify and resolve barriers to incumbent, should one worry about the tech-forward banks, the well
innovation that Fintech companies face in UK and the EU. funded mobile-first start-up, the e-commerce players entering finance, or
the emerging online financial supermarkets? Correspondingly, should
India has historically had cautious regulations on financial activity and one’s talent agenda be focused on financial professionals, or on
with the advent of Fintech as a sector have been cautiously evolving its engineers and product managers?
policies to tap into the potential while attempting to balance the need for This document is meant to provide a short overview of trends we see in
the right amount of oversight with the need to facilitate new entrants and the Fintech space. It is based on MAPE and MXV’s proprietary
technology to ensure greater availability, choice and most importantly research, projects and advisory relationships in the sector. Hopefully, it
better financial inclusion in the country. The RBI has issued will give you cause for reflection, and insights for how your business, or
differentiated banking licenses and offered “on tap” banking licenses. portfolio, is likely to be impacted. We look forward to a continued
Payment bank licenses and UPI have been heralded as game changers. dialogue as the brave new world of Fintech dawns upon us.
Initial steps to formalise the unregulated P2P lending service providers
may act as a fillip for the sector by ensuring robust credit scoring Jacob Mathew, MAPE Advisory Group
mechanisms and prudential lending norms. The role Fintech plays in Amit Garg, MXV Consulting
personal financial management has also been acknowledged by the
RBI with financial aggregators being recognised and registered as
NBFCs. Apart from the RBI’s initiatives, large banks like SBI have
commissioned a start-up fund for INR 200 Crore. Steps such as this
lend weight for progressive arbitration by regulatory watchdogs for the
Fintech space. While steps taken have been encouraging there is still
much to be done to come up with consistent and business friendly
regulatory approach.
The Outlook
The conditions are ripe. Across segments, there are new companies
emerging. What may today appear like a couple of pin-pricks in the
financial services landscape, have the potential to cause massive
disruption. With the process of disruption and re-creation happening
7
Contents
8
The World is witnessing a massive shift in financial services
Technology
The role of technology
in financial services
had been limited to
₹
facilitating the internal
operations of financial
institutions and
Institution Fintech
customer interactions ₹
with the bank, with the
financial institutions Due to the rise of the digitized,
retaining their central • Access to internet
on-demand economy, Fintech
role. Institution • Penetration of mobiles Technology has opened up direct linkages
• Trust in technology
between customers, and
• Personalization of
between the customer and the
solutions
service provider, increasing
• Speed of delivery
accessibility and inclusion, and
• Reduced cost
putting the customer in the
• Open architecture
drivers seat
Customers Customers
Traditional Model Innovation
Fintech is the innovative use of technology to upend traditional business models and the banking experience
It puts the focus back on the customer by unbundling and aggregating financial products by segment, allowing 24x7 access, reducing the complexity
and ambiguity of the traditional banking experience
For the financial services provider, data, analytics and technology are used to reduce costs and increase market share by accessing untapped
segments
9
What Fintech is Not
10
How Fintech companies have changed the landscape
Transformed SME lending by Matches a remittance Reduces intermediation of Wallets have allowed
creatively assessing credit transaction to a reverse financial incumbents by consumers to consolidate
risk and providing loans in transaction on the same route opening direct channels multiple solutions into one
record time and settles locally, avoiding between borrowers and
international transfer charges investors
Payment intermediaries have
improved the under-banked’s
access to financial services
London Stockholm
Dublin Berlin
Silicon NY
Valley Tel Aviv
Hong Kong
Mumbai
Bangalore
Singapore
Established hubs
Emerging hubs
Sydney
Intensity of funding activity
Jan 2010- Jun 2015
- +
Payments Lending Markets Wealth Management Risk & Security Insurance Other
84
Xiaomi begins public beta testing
65 of online money market fund that
enables users to earn interest on
their Xiaomi wallet balance
Source: Life.SREDA
14
New entrants are being seen in every segment
Services Equity/Debt Financial Management
Business Lending
Credit Scoring
Payments Wallets
Asset Management
P2P Payments
Consumer Lending
16
Financial services penetration is still very low in India
Cards outstanding in India (#Mn)
602
43% of bank accounts
dormant
1226
1045 699 Mn bank accounts
903 2012 19 314
810 799 are held by 287 Mn
735
Active account holders
2013 19 373
FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15
Have a debit Received Received Paid utility bills Saved at a FI Borrowed from
card wage in wage in cash using cash FI 0 200 400 600 800 1000
account
Credit Card Debit Card
World India
J Pradhan Mantri
A Aadhaar
M Mobile
JAM strategy is Jan Dhan Yojana
driving financial
inclusion
Currently covers 70% With more mobile
Launched in August connections than bank
of the population;
2014, 200 Mn bank
extended for pension, accounts, it provides a
accounts have been
provident fund and bridge to the
opened till Feb 2016
Jan Dhan Yojana underbanked
Internet penetration in
India
46% 59%
24% 34%
13%
Source: World Bank; IAMAI; TRAI; ComScore; Morgan Stanley; MXV Analysis; MAPE research
18
Government encouragement of Fintech Sector
Start-up India initiative launched by the Government of India in • New startups will have a provision for 100% deduction of
2016 will provide funding support through a $1.5 Bn fund of funds taxes on profit for three out of first five years
SBI opened a INR 200 Crore fund for Fintech start-ups in a bid to • Long term capital gains (LTCG) tax for unlisted companies
collaborate and modernize its banking operations is now applicable for 24 months instead of 36 months
Startups will get support from the government for their patents • Removal of LTCG tax on sale of residential properties
filing, trademark and other design work when proceeds are invested in specified startup fund
Improved mobile connectivity through better infrastructure is • 80% rebates on the patent costs will incentivise innovation
expected to boost mobile usage and thus expand the user pool for amongst start-ups
technology startups as a whole including Fintech • Tax exemption for investment above fair market value has
been proposed to encourage seed investment
• Merchants with more than half of their transactions done
digitally could get tax rebate or 1-2% VAT reduction
50%
45% UK China
77% Germany 57%
50%
40% Japan
83%
USA India
35% 75% 18%
Smartphones to
30% exceed number of
active bank
account holders
25%
10%
Mobile transactions gains
momentum: 2x transactions
5% and 3x value over previous
year
0%
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Year
INR BIllion
15 50
40
10 30
20
5
10
- 0
Axis HDFC ICICI Kotak SBI Axis HDFC ICICI Kotak SBI
m-Wallet m-Banking
• While mobile banking transactions have
tripled in the two years till 2014-15, going
Value (Bn) 82 from 53 Mn to 172 Mn transactions per
year, m-wallets have grown 7x in the same
29 period, going from 33 Mn to 256 Mn
10 172 transactions per year
• Some estimates suggest that value of m-
95 255 wallet transactions may grow 50x between
Volume (Mn)
2014 and 2020
53 108
33 • The Bharat Bill Payment System in the RBI
pipeline offers offering interoperable and
2012-13 2013-14 2014-15
accessible bill payment service, enabling
1035 multiple payment modes, including wallets.
60 224 Such nationwide initiatives are expected to
further amplify adoption of alternative
payment systems.
Source: RBI; MXV Analysis
21
While some areas are in early stages of adoption, others have already gained
wide acceptance
Wallets
Payments
Business
Crowdfunding Lending Asset management
- 2014
Wallets
- 2020
Growth Rates (2014-2020) (%)
Loans
Loans
Insurance
Insurance
MFs
MFs
5,793
4,597
2,837
1,890
181
Business Lending
Credit Scoring
Payments Wallets
Asset Management
P2P Payments
Consumer Lending
Fintellix (formerly
Analytics Undisclosed $ 15 Series C May-15 $ 15
iCreate)
Source: World Bank; IAMAI; TRAI; ComScore; Morgan Stanley; MXV Analysis; MAPE research
26
Since 2014, about $1.3 Bn has been invested in Fintech India contd..
Funding
Total Investment in
Segment Company Investors Amount Series Date
Segment ($ Mn)
($ Mn)
28
Key Trends in Fintech
In the following pages, we have summarised 4 key trends as follows..
Bill
payments
Payments
Credit CONVERGENCE
products
Loans Insurance
Asset Meeting of E-Commerce
management Insurance and Fintech
₹
Investments Payments
COLLABORATION
• E-commerce is boosting
Fintech by creating demand
Traditional institutions for lending and payment
partnering with Fintech start-ups. Meanwhile,
Remittance AGGLOMERATION companies Fintech companies are
entering the e-commerce
space and vice versa
Creation of online financial • Fintech companies offer a
EROSION supermarkets cost effective way to scale up
their businesses through
partnership
Unbundling of bank • Early Fintech leaders are
services using their strength in one
segment to expand into allied
services
• Fintech start-ups are
replacing individual services
within the retail and
commercial segments of
traditional financial
institutions.
29
CONVER
Erosion AGGLOM
ERATION
COLLAB
ORATIO
N
GENCE
EROSIO
This customer-centric
approach is more often
attractive than the traditional
banking experience.
30
CONVER
Erosion AGGLOM
ERATION
COLLAB
ORATIO
N
GENCE
EROSIO
Fintech solutions Cost of customer Lifetime value War for Talent Loss of high value
preferred by the new acquisition opportunities customers
generation
•Preference is shifting •Early stage Fintech •With the shift towards •Growth phase of •It is more likely for high
from physical stores & start-ups require large Fintech, incumbents will Fintech provides an value customers to be
human interaction to investments for see a decrease in the interesting opportunity tech-savvy, thus
digital businesses customer acquisition to lifetime value of for people looking to preferring faster
achieve scale, deterring customers unless innovate and make interaction and results
traditional institutions traditional banking effective changes to made possible by
from entering the models are reinvented financial services Fintech solutions
segment directly
31
CONVER
EROSIO
• Alipay - Third party payment • Zhong An - China’s first online • Zhao Cai Bao & Sesame • Mybank - Launched by Alibaba
solution launched by Alibaba in insurance seller credit - Open platform for and Ant Financial with capital
the Chinese market • Yu’e Bao - Money market fund investment solutions & credit base of $646 Mn targeting small
enabling users to invest wallet rating system to unlock credit borrowers
balance flow to smaller players
• Alipay wallets - Online &
offline application with over 190
Mn active users
• Ant Credit - Offers micro loans
to SMEs and online
entrepreneurs
Asset
Payments Insurance Wallets
Management
Crowd-
Lending Analytics Digital Bank
funding
EROSIO
IPO and acquisition Competition from Moved $228 Bn in 26 Listed online money
by eBay for $1.3 Bn Google Wallet and currencies transfer tech
Square ‘s technology company acquired for
met by acquisition of $890 Mn
credit card capture
app
EROSIO
2014
boom Expands
2016
into the
hyperlocal
market by
investing in
Jugnoo,
LogiNext
2012
2015
and Little
Offered payment Taps into the P2P
gateway solution – payment space with
Paytm Payments P2P funds transfer
Bought title
sponsorship
rights for
Tied-up with Capital BCCI games
Float to provide SME till 2019
loans
2 4
Collaboration AGGLOM
ERATION
COLLAB
ORATIO
N
GENCE
EROSIO
Convergence AGGLOM
ERATION
COLLAB
ORATIO
N
GENCE
EROSIO
Payments
E-com players
Lending Start-
ups
Suppliers Consumers
Lending Start-
ups
Convergence AGGLOM
ERATION
COLLAB
ORATIO
N
GENCE
EROSIO
Globally, incumbents in the banking sector are scooping the opportunity to invest, mentor or otherwise integrate Fintech in their portfolio and systems
Partnerships are undertaken as a means to overcome the slow technology transition of legacy institutions
For instance, Citi acquiring Payquik and integrated its remittance platform, Quikremit, into its portfolio
Allocated for
global investment
BBVA Barclays Amex
in retail & capital HSBC
Ventures accelerator Ventures
markets financial
services
technology firms
38
This is just the beginning..
50% penetration of digital banking by 2022; more than a quarter of banking transactions to be digital by 2020
Continued governmental push for financial inclusion. Low cost inclusion will required the adoption of technology
driven models
Increased access can take the transaction value from $33 Bn in 2016 to $73 Bn in 2020 growing at a CAGR of 22%
Adoption of technology and trends by the industry is positioning India as a ripe market for Fintech start-ups
$1.6 Bn Startup India initiative launched by the government in 2016 followed by SBI’s $30 Mn fund
Success in any one segment can enable a player to enter other segments and create an online financial
supermarket. There is already some evidence of this
Collaboration over
competition is an While individual start-ups may appear tiny compared to the institutions, they are also nimble, tech-savvy and well
emerging theme funded - with a different profit horizon. Traditional institutions like SBI are partnering with start-ups to increase their
reach at a much lower cost
Recent announcement of UPI by the RBI means that banks and NBFCs will see a huge amount of growth from the
online and mobile space and reliable startups will be vital in making this transition
40
Wallets
The digital equivalent of a physical wallet, with preloaded money that can be spent at participating online and offline
merchants
In India, prepaid wallets can be:
Closed wallets, for transacting with a single associated merchant
Semi Closed wallets, usable at multiple merchant establishments
Open Wallets which can be used for payments and cash withdrawals
Global India
Smartphone boom and low penetration of cards is India Opportunity Funding Events in India
driving wallet adoption in Asia
The low penetration of banking Paytm
In mature markets, advancements such as NFC ˗ Raised $675 Mn from Alibaba
in India coupled with high
provide convenience that will translate to higher along with Alipay in Sept. 2015
mobile phone usage provides
transaction volumes ˗ Valued at roughly $4 Bn
an opportunity for wallets
Wallet integration with payment and PoS systems MobiKwik
˗ Can provide additional
is increasing efficiency, and customer reach
solutions such as ˗ Raised $50 Mn in Series C led by
Joint venture between mobile payment system and remittances Tree Line Asia in May 2016
mobile carriers that use NFC ˗ Total funding of $80 Mn
˗ Provides backbone for BillDesk raised $150 Mn from General
a larger Fintech and e- Atlantic in March 2016
commerce play
Banks, telecom service
Mobile wallet integrated with Apple providers and start-ups are
Watch, raised $24 Mn up to Series Start-ups Bank Wallets Telecom Wallets
providing wallet solutions
A
User acquisition is costly,
Combines mobile payments and a which will lead to consolidation
wallet to pay at enabled stores, in the segment, or providers
$16.7 Mn funding received focusing on niches
41
Payments
Being disrupted by solutions such as P2P payments, mobile wallets, mobile check deposits, mobile PoS devices and
proximity solutions like NFC
Digital currency is changing payments and settlements with greater speed and lower fees
Pre-paid cards act like debit cards without checking accounts
Global India
Innovation in payments coming from telecoms, card India Opportunity Funding Events in India
companies, technology companies and banks
High transaction fees , high FreeCharge
˗ Retail companies in the US have combined ˗ Raised $80 Mn in Series C led by
minimum transaction slabs and
to develop a merchant owned mobile Valiant Capital Management
cost of traditional payment
payment system ˗ Total funding of $116.5 Mn
devices are driving adoption of Innoviti
˗ Banks are innovating with lower cost new payment technologies ˗ Raised $5 Mn from Catamaran
solutions like mobile check deposits
Mobile wallet and telecom Ventures and others in July 2015
Banks collaborating to use blockchain technology, companies entering the ˗ Total funding of $6.6 Mn
transforming financial transaction processing payment bank space Momoe
˗ Raised $1.2 Mn in seed funding
Mobile recharges, ecommerce, Citrus
restaurants, tax services and ˗ Raised $25mn in Series-C from
Started as mobile based payments utility payments are sectors Ascent and Sequoia in Oct-15
solutions provider, expanded into that drive growth
other areas raised $590 Mn; IPO in
2015
42
Consumer Lending
Global India
Ecommerce companies are providing consumer India Opportunity Funding Events in India
financing services e.g.: Huabei in China
High growth potential as India Faircent
Emergence of on-demand market places, where ˗ Raised $250 K at a valuation of $8
has one of the highest offline
borrowers can be funded in real-time Mn in June 2015 from M&S
P2P lending markets in the
Expansion of lending players into other products world Partners
such as mortgages
Consumer lending is getting a ˗ Raised $4 Mn in Series A funding
Recent troubles in 2016 with Lending Club with boost from e-commerce. E.g.: from Aarin Partners and JM
regards to loans sold to an investment bank has led Snapdeal now offers financial Financials in May 2016
to closer scrutiny of this segment of Fintech products on its platform after IndiaLends
acquiring majority in ˗ Pre-Series A funding in July 2015
RupeePower
With better regulation and
Online credit marketplace, total access of credit reports,
funding of $1.2 Bn, IPO in December lenders can make better
2014 raised $865 Mn investment decisions and
borrowers can build their credit
Student loan refinancing, lent $4 Bn
rating
in 4 years, raised $766 Mn to date,
including $400 Mn debt financing
43
Business Lending
Online financial platforms that act as digital NBFC’s and provide loan financing to SME’s
Ecommerce companies have partnered with business lending start-ups, sharing their merchants’ business data, helping them
acquire finance for working capital
This is the mainstay of most start-ups in this field
Global India
Banks reduced SME lending after 2008, creating India Opportunity Funding Events in India
an opportunity for disruptive players
With India’s booming CapitalFloat
Ecommerce companies can develop accurate ˗ Raised $13 Mn in Series A led by
ecommerce market, more
financial projections for their merchants, enabling SAIF partners and Sequoia in
businesses will seek workising
better and faster loan decisions February 2015
capital to scale quickly ˗ Raised $25 Mn in Series B led by
˗ Less than 10% of existing investors in May-16
SME’s can access ˗ Total funding of $41 Mn
finance from banking Lendingkart
institutions ˗ Raised $32 Mn in Series B from
Bertelsmann and Darrin Capital in
˗ Ecommerce majors Jun-16to take total fund raise to
are tying up with $42mn
lending start-ups, for Neogrowth
Automated lending for small example Flipkart had ˗ Raised $35mn in Jul-16 from IIFL and
businesses, funding received $465 tied up with Capital Accion to take its total funding to
Mn Float and Lendingkart $47mn
Automated and semi-automated investment service firms that use algorithms to optimize investment returns
Cost of these services are quite low compared to an investment manager
A personalized portfolio can normally be set up in minutes by providing information about investment goals, risk appetite
An algorithm adjusts the portfolio on an ongoing basis
Global India
Large, renowned brokerage firms are starting to India Opportunity Funding Events in India
offer robo-advisory services to keep up with start-
ups Penetration of investment FundsIndia
instruments is still very low in ˗ Raised $11 Mn in Series C led by
Ecommerce companies have launched money Faering Capital in June 2015
India
market funds, distributed on their platform/wallets Scripbox
Solutions are integrating
Small clients are being tapped by lowering the ˗ Raised $2.5 Mn in Series A led by
accurate, actual tracking of
minimum holding size Accel Partners and other angel
performance of offline assets
Start-ups are attractive, targeting niche segments such as gold, jewellery, and investors in August 2015
such as Silicon Valley customers real estate MyUniverse
˗ IFC invested $10 Mn in Aditya
Retention is high, but capturing Birla Money in September 2014
users requires investment in
marketing
Automated investment service with
AUM of $2Bn in 3 years, funding
received $129 Mn
45
Personal Finance
Account aggregation tools that provide individuals with a single view to manage their wealth, stock portfolio, personal
budgets, taxes, etc.
Financial data displayed on a dashboard
Provides tools to assist savings to a set target, or managing and using the most cost effective credit card
Automatically segregates spends into consumption categories like – food, clothing, rent, etc.
Global India
PFMs are pivoting towards personal wealth India Opportunity Funding Events in India
platform
Tracking personal MoneyView
Wearables are being used to help make real-time ˗ Raised $8.5 Mn from Tiger Global,
expenses by reading SMS
spend decisions Accel India and Ribbit Capital in
received from banks and billing
Offer multiple credit scores for comparison to merchants to streamline and April 2015
detect errors in scoring automate financial information
Change from purchases is rounded up and Tax saving planning and bill
invested into a portfolio e.g.: Acorns payment services offers an
entry point for personal finance
46
Remittances
Faster, secure, cheaper and more transparent than remittance via banks, money transfer operators and informal channels
Transfer is initiated via digital device and received by bank deposit, cash pickup, mobile money or mobile recharge
Customers are generally charged a flat fee per transaction, with no hidden costs
Global India
Mobile remittance technology adding messaging India Opportunity Funding Events in India
features
As India received the most In Oct-15, Wildcard acquired Great Indian
Giving senders control of the transfer by cash-to- Retail for $254mn
remittances in 27 of the past
goods service like paying for phone bills or Eko, which has raised $6mn in funding
30 years, there is a large
medication from Creation Investments, expanded to
opportunity for both
Incumbents are exploring partnerships with digital international and domestic offer international remittances for the first
currency start-ups remittances time to Nepal
Telecom carrier partnership enable remittance High volume opportunity with
through top-up recharges unbanked, replacing informal
Incumbents are competing by lowering rates on channels with lower transfer
key US-India and UK-India routes fees and time
Provider of inter-country consumer RBI making it possible for
money transfer services, raised $15 Mn funds receipt regardless of
in May-16 from Viber owner Rakuten bank account
taking its fundraise to $47mn
P2P transfer service targeting foreign
students and global businesses, raised
$26mn from Baillie Gifford in May-16,
taking its valuation to $1.1bn
Online cross border money transfer
service for migrants and expats, raised
$45mn in debt financing in Feb-16
taking its total fund raise to $148 Mn
47
Insurance
Insurance is a sector ripe for disruption but has been slower to innovate; the last year reversed that with a number of
companies attacking that space
Sub-segments of disruption are
Insurance aggregation- online platforms providing quotes from a range of providers
Negotiation – collective negotiation for groups with unique needs
SaaS tools for brokers
Global India
Collective bargaining for individuals with similar India Opportunity Funding Events in India
requirements and evolution towards insurance
companies bidding for such groups Indian insurance regulator has PolicyBazaar
capped the fee for insurance ˗ Raised $40 Mn in Series D from
IoT devices are enabling providers to understand PremjiInvest and others in April
leads initiated online, forcing
risk better and service customers with better deals 2015
changes in model, towards
˗ Usage-based-insurance that leverage becoming money ˗ Total funding of $69.6 Mn
wearables to provide better costs/prices supermarkets - selling multiple CoverFox
products like loans, credit ˗ Raised $12 Mn in Series B from
cards, etc. existing investors Accel Partners
and SAIF Partners in April 2015
48
Crowdfunding
Way of raising money for a project by which a large number of people contribute a small amount each, as:
Donation
Reward
Equity exchange
If the target collection is reached a service fee, or a percentage of the total collection is charged
Additionally, these platforms act as a testing ground for the product’s market
Global India
Markets getting more segmented with separate India Opportunity Funding Events in India
platforms for real estate, creative projects, funds for
a cause, etc. Crowd-funding already Wishberry
provides an alternative funding ˗ Raised $650 K in seed funding in
Debt funding, as a variant of P2B funding, is also January 2015
channel for events, campaigns
present for crowd funding of small business Ketto
and films in India
Retail market places will allow funds pooling for ˗ Raised $700 K in July 2015
single item-high value buys
49
P2P Payments
Global India
Increased security through anonymity for one-time India Opportunity Funding Events in India
payments
RBI guidelines for P2P Chillr
Consumers can make direct purchases from ˗ Raised $6 Mn in Series A led by
lending, protecting the lender
advertisers on social media Sequoia Capital in October 2015
and requiring registration
Tech companies getting into the P2P payments ˗ Total funding of $6.5 Mn
Increased convenience and
space with device integration
security for daily transactions iKaaz
Banks providing free P2P service within a fixed of several under banked –high ˗ Raised seed investment in 2014
weekly limit potential markets and launched Mowa earlier this
Businesses can reimburse or provide rebates to year
Adoption can be increased by
customers through this network
˗ Linking directly to bank
account eliminating
P2P transfers enabled through card fees
Facebook messaging app ˗ Improving security
benefits
PayPal subsidiary enabling P2P
payments, raised $1.3Mn
50
Blockchain
Blockchain are distributed databases that can be used to initiate and verify transactions and records without recourse to a
central authority
The system operates on a peer-to-peer basis and promises to eliminate the need for a central authority to clear transactions
thereby reducing costs and increasing transaction speeds
Payments has been the immediate beneficiary of blockchain and could disrupt cross border remittances which are currently
slow and expensive
Given the nascent stage of the technology, institutions while accepting the importance of it, have been slower to adopt with a
lack of understanding being seen as an impediment
Global India
Opportunity Overview Industry Acceptance & Threats India Opportunity
Potential to reduce banking industry’s operational Governance and regulatory acceptance will be Blockchain / Bitcoin startups are
and infrastructure cost by up to $15-20 Bn per year required for broad acceptance of blockchain starting to emerge with early movers
like Zebpay and Coinsecure recently
Global investment in blockchain is expected to R3CEV, with a global consortium of 45 financial
companies, is developing a distributed ledger raising Series A funds.
increase 4x by 2019, highlighting the importance it
could play in financial services technologies for the global financial markets RBI is studying blockchain, and will set
up a committee to study use of
Decentralized permissionless platforms based on The Hyperledger Project is a collaborative effort to
address important features for a cross-industry blockchain to reduce paper currency
blockchain, such as ledgers, will replace
centralized systems open standard for distributed ledgers Axis Bank has declared intent to use
blockchain for high volume corporate
Immediate opportunities include ledgers for Current issues include speed and efficiency cost of
blockchain networks, and cost of integration with transactions in trade finance and forex
clearing and settlement of global transactions, such
as transnational payments legacy applications
Source: KPMG, Accenture, Morgan Stanley Global Insights, Santander, PwC, Literature review
51
About MXV Consulting & MAPE Advisory Group
MXV Consulting (www.mxv.in) is a strategy and MAPE was founded in 2001 by ex DSP Merrill Lynch
management consulting firm based out of Bangalore in senior bankers as an investment bank focused on M&A
India. Our focus is on building sustainable competitive advisory and Private Equity fund raising
advantage for our clients and helping them become industry
leaders MAPE has an excellent deal track record having
successfully closed over 150 transactions, across
We have the experience of working across multiple sectors, totaling to a deal size of over US$ 5 Bn (approx.)
industries and functional areas - enabling us to bring in
fresh ideas and a strategic perspective to every MAPE is present across 3 cities:
engagement. Our insights are backed up by a rigorous
˗ Mumbai
process of analysis and solution development. This ensures
that our recommendations are well researched, practical ˗ Bangalore
and tailored to an organisation’s requirements. In many ˗ Chennai
instances, we also take on the role of implementation
managers MAPE has been consistently ranked amongst the top 10
investment banks in the country (per Bloomberg league
Our clientele includes leaders across various industries. We tables) for the last 13 years (CY2002 – CY2014) and was
believe in long term relationships with our clients, and have awarded the Boutique Investment Bank Of The Year
worked on multiple engagements with most of them Award at the India M&A Atlas Awards 2012
MXV has worked on more than a 150 assignments till date. Leading clients who have closed signficant M&A / PE
Our clients are global in nature – including India, the US, transactions include Tata Sons, Dr. Reddy’s Labs,
Middle East, Europe and Asia Pacific Goldman Sachs, Godrej Consumer, Blackstone Group,
Mahindra, Wipro, Café Coffee Day, CRISIL, Star Health
Insurance, Glenmark Pharmaceuticals and Jyothy Labs
In 2014, MXV Consulting was listed among the most
amongst others
promising business consultants in India
52
Authors of this report For further discussion, please contact
MXV Consulting MAPE Group Amit Garg Jacob Mathew
Bangalore Bangalore
Amit Garg Jacob Mathew
[email protected] [email protected]
Dhritiman Borkakoti Saloni Jain
Havisha Reddy Prabodh DP Shalabh Agrawal Saloni Jain
New Delhi Mumbai
[email protected] [email protected]
Kim Bingham Prabodh DP
New York Bangalore
[email protected] [email protected]