See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/292154656

Mental Health among Government School Teachers

Article · December 2015

CITATIONS READS
0 8,214

3 authors, including:

Chanderkant Gorsy Dr Neeraj Panwar

Maharshi Dayanand University Christ University, Bangalore
12 PUBLICATIONS   2 CITATIONS    16 PUBLICATIONS   8 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Mental Health, Emotion Regulation and Academic Confidence in Relation to Mindfulness View project

Exploratory Research of Stressors View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Dr Neeraj Panwar on 29 January 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

The International Journal of Indian Psychology
ISSN 2348-5396 (e) | ISSN: 2349-3429 (p)
Volume 3, Issue 1, No.10, DIP: C03177V3I12015
http://www.ijip.in | October – December, 2015

Mental Health among Government School Teachers

Chanderkant Gorsy 1*, Neeraj Panwar1, Sandeep Kumar1

ABSTRACT

Teaching is being considered as one of the noblest profession since ancient times. With the
changing socio-economic scenario and increasing unemployment, the values of teachers’ and
their professional concern with the job have forcibly undergone a drastic change which adversely
affects their mental health. The level of mental health of a teacher has been found affected with
numerous personal as well as professional demands. Health of teachers, on social, physical and
mental health domains adds to the efficiency not only to their professional growth and
development but also to their personality. Moreover, they have also been considered as the
constructors of the future of a country. Keeping these facts into the consideration, present study
aimed to access the level of personal mental health of school teachers, particularly those who
work in the public sector schools. Survey method has been employed and Mental Health Index
(MHI) was used for collecting the data. 100 secondary and higher secondary school teachers
were included in the study. The data was analyzed using descriptive analysis and to find the
differences for gender and locations t- test was applied. The t-values reveals that significant
gender differences exist among government school teachers and male school teachers were found
better on mental health than their female counterparts. Additionally, teachers posted at schools
located under urban area were found higher on mental health as compared to teaches posted at
schools located under rural areas.

Keywords: Mental health, Gender, school teachers Urban, Rural

Schools are not the places where students went to study but they are being considered as the
temple of education where teachers play similar role being observed by the priest of any
religious place. Performance of the school is the collective team work of teachers as well as
students. Teachers not only impart education to the students but also act as a bridge to fill the gap
between students, principal, management and parents. Their cordial relation with students
reflects in the behavior and speech of teachers. Sound professional relations of a teacher with
students, their parents, colleagues, and management may lead to their better mental health.

In the present world of professional competence everyone is threatened by increasing

competitions and degraded circumstances. Health is and has been always one of the most
important areas where focus is necessary for all times. Resultantly the concept of health has been

1
Ph.D, Research scholar, Department of Psychology, Maharshi Dayanand University, Rohtak (Haryana)
*Responding Author
© 2015 I C Gorsy, N Panwar, S Kumar; licensee IJIP. This is an Open Access Research distributed under the terms of
the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any Medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
 Mental Health among Government School Teachers

extended beyond the proper functioning of the body; it includes controlled emotions, a sound and
efficient mind. In simple words it means that mind and body both are working efficiently and
harmoniously (Kaur, 2007).

It is evident from the previous researches that mental health plays a pivot and vital role in human
life. It is not only important but essential for survival as a social being. No area of human life is
beyond the range of mental health. It includes every aspect and dimension of human personality
and the individual’s adjustment to own self, others and environment. The main characteristic of
mental health is adjustment, magnitude of which decides the status of mental health. The greater
the degree of adjustment, the greater will be the mental health and lesser degree will lead to the
lesser mental health. The mentally healthy individual can adapt him or herself to every best and
worst condition of life and environment. The expression ‘Mental Health ‘consists of two words-

The word ‘mental’ usually implies something more than purely cerebral functioning of a person.
It includes one’s emotional affective states. It is the equilibrium in one’s Sociocultural context
that is reflected by the relationship one establishes with others.

Similarly, ‘health’ refers to more than physical wellbeing. It also connotes the individual’s intra-
physic balance, the interaction of one’s physic-structure with the external and social environment
(Kaur, 2007). For example, a person who is academically sound and also knows what is to be
taught but at times is not able to impart it due to certain factors of adjustment with his/her
environment.

Mental health stands for the health of the mind, “The wholesomeness of mind”− analogous to the
wholesomeness of the body as implicit in physical health. Accordingly, mental health is
concerned with the health of one’s mind and its functioning in the same way as the physical
health is concerned with the health of one’s physical organs and their functioning.

Mental health, in layman terms, is a level of psychological well-being, or an absence of a mental

disorder (Singh, 2004). From the perspective of positive psychology or holism, mental health
may include an individual's ability to enjoy life, and create a balance between life activities and
efforts to achieve psychological resilience. According to World Health Organization (WHO)
mental health includes "subjective well-being, perceived self-efficacy, autonomy, competence,
intergenerational dependence, and self-actualization of one's intellectual and emotional potential,
among others.

Kornhauser (1965) connotes that mental health includes those behaviors, perceptions and
feelings that determine a person’s overall level of personal effectiveness, success, happiness and
excellence of functioning as a person. It depends on the development and retention of goals that
is neither too high nor too low to permit realistic successful maintenance of belief in one’s self as
a worthy, effective human being. Further, it is the condition in which the individual manifest

© The International Journal of Indian Psychology | 118

 Mental Health among Government School Teachers

through self-evaluation, adjustability, maturity, regular life, absence of extremism satisfactory

social adjustment and satisfaction from his chief occupation. Complete mental health is an ideal.
Any individual who possesses the greatest number of these qualities will be nearest the ideal
(Singh, Chandra & Parihar, 2011).

Singh and Gupta (1983) described six indices of mental health i.e. emotional stability
(experiencing subjective stable feeling which have positive or negative); over-all adjustment
(achieving an overall harmonious balance between demands of various aspects of environment,
such as home, health, social, emotional and school of the one hand and cognition on the
other);autonomy(a stage of independence and self-determination in thinking);security-insecurity
(a high or low sense of safety, confidence, and freedom from fear, apprehension or anxiety
particularly with respect to fulfilling the person’s present or future needs); self-concept (sum
total of the person’s attitude and knowledge towards himself and evaluation of his
achievements); and intelligence (general mental ability which helps the person in thinking
rationally, and in behaving purposefully in his environment).

While, the interpretation of mental health by Das (2008) is “Good mental health can be achieved
by following the principle of mental hygiene, which is the science of the investigation and
application of those measures that prevent mental disorder. Mental health is a way of living
satisfactorily and effectively with other members of the society”.

There have been many studies conducted to access the level of mental health among school
teachers in relation to various psychological variables. It is important to emphasize that these
different determinants interact with each other in a dynamic way, and that they can work for or
against a particular individual’s mental health state. Table 1 provides an illustrative set of factors
that may threaten or protect mental health. For example, an individual’s level of self-worth could
be enhanced or diminished depending on social support or economic security at the household
level, which in turn might be influenced by the extent of political stability, social justice or
economic growth in a country.

Table 1: Mental health determinants

(c.f. Risks to mental health, WHO, 2012)
Level Adverse factors Protective factors
Low self-esteem Self-esteem, confidence
Cognitive/emotional Ability to solve problems and
immaturity manage stress or adversity
Individual
Communication skills
attributes
Difficulties in Physical health, fitness
communicating
Medical illness, substance
use

© The International Journal of Indian Psychology | 119

 Mental Health among Government School Teachers

Loneliness, bereavement Social support of family & friends

Neglect, family conflict Good parenting / family interaction
Exposure to violence/abuse Physical security and safety
Social
Low income and poverty Economic security
circumstances
Difficulties or failure at Scholastic achievement
school Satisfaction and success at work
Work stress, unemployment
Poor access to basic Equality of access to basic services
services Social justice, tolerance, integration
Environmental Injustice and discrimination Social and gender equality
factors Social and gender Physical security and safety
inequalities
Exposure to war or disaster

Ananda (1989) conducted a study on mental health of schoolteachers using a mental health scale
and observed that 59 % of teachers were mentally healthy. The state of working bears no relation
to mental health while social values were positively related to mental health of teachers.

Kumar (1992) observed that if a teacher is with bad mental health it not only tends to
incapacitate himself for the performance of his multifarious duties in the school but also creates
difficulties and problem for his students.

Kaur (2007) investigates occupational stress, mental health and coping resources of high and
higher secondary school teachers and their relationship. The results revealed that sometimes
teachers feel stressed due to role overload, responsibilities and physical stressors present in
school. Whereas, teachers those who are mentally healthy use coping resources to combat the
effect of occupational stress. They use recreational activities such as watching T.V., listening
music, getting social support from friends to relief from mental tensions, etc. The result also
indicated that correlation between occupational stress and mental health is negative.
Occupational stress and coping resources also tends to be negative. Correlation between mental
health and coping resources is positive and significant.

Srivastava and Khan (2008) conducted a study to know the impact of mental health on the level
of burnout of the teachers teaching at different education level. They concluded that teachers
with low mental health are more prone to burnouts than the teachers of average and high mental
health.

Srivastava(2010) assessed the personality and mental health among primary and secondary
teachers. The result indicates that personality types/traits influence the mental health of primary
and secondary teachers and extrovert teachers enjoy better mental health as compared to
introvert teachers.

© The International Journal of Indian Psychology | 120

 Mental Health among Government School Teachers

Kale (2011) conducted a study on awareness of mental health among newly admitted B.Ed.
Students. The researcher has applied survey method for collecting the data. The results reveal
that there is great awareness about the mental health among newly admitted B.Ed students.

Kumar (2013) reported results of t-test reveals that urban elementary school teachers scored
higher mean scores on mental health (t = -16.06; p<.01) whereas, elementary school teachers
from rural schools are scored low on mental health. Meaning thereby, awareness of self-mental
health would make elementary school teachers’ to cope with stressful situation in an enhanced
way and are in a better position to perform appraisal of pupils’ undesirable behaviour at
elementary school level.

In sum a teacher can often create a classroom environment in an image of their own childhood
experiences and cultural influences (Kroeger & Bauer, 2004). This image could mimic how they
were taught at school, and in still their own beliefs on how homes and lives are organized,
believing that this is the right way and is how will be (Thorsborne & Vinegrad, 2006). Some of
the researchers like Langley (2008) suggested that teachers need to consider there are times when
the problem is within themselves and not the child.

OBJECTIVES
On the basis of provided conceptual description and literature review regarding mental health
among school teachers following objectives were proposed for the present study:
1. To assess the mental health among government school teachers.
2. To find out gender differences among school teachers with regard to mental health.
3. To compare mental health level of school teachers posted at urban located schools versus
school teachers posted at rural located schools.

Hypotheses:
1. There would be significant gender differences with regard to mental health.
2. There would be significant differences between school teachers posted at schools located at
rural and urban areas.

METHODOLOGY
Sample
Random sampling technique has been used for selecting the sample. The investigator selected
100 secondary and higher secondary school teachers within the age range of 35 to 50 yearsfrom
various districts of Haryana. For the final testing 100 participants were equally divided into two
group’s male and female (50 in each group).All the teachers hold at least five years of minimum
teaching experience at present posting and living with family members.

© The International Journal of Indian Psychology | 121

 Mental Health among Government School Teachers

Tools
The following tools were used for the present investigation:
1. MENTAL HEALTH INDEX [MHI-38; Davies, Sherbourne, Peterson, & Ware
(1998)]: All of the 38 MHI items, except two, are scored on a six-point scale (range 1-6).
Items 9 and 28 are the exception, each scored on a five-point scale (range 1-5). The pre-
coded values of each item are shown on the copy of the instrument on the preceding
pages.

Procedure
After getting the formal permission from the Principals’ of concerned institutions, data was
collected. Participants were briefed about the nature and the purpose of the research in order to
receive the reliable data. They were assured about the confidentiality of the data. Instructions
were given regarding the questionnaires. The scale was filled by the participants, while they
were on duty and collected immediately after completion.

Statistical analysis
Descriptive analysis and t test were used for the assessment of teacher’s mental health. The data
was analyzed with the help of SPSS-21. Obtained statistical results are given in the section
following.

RESULTS & DISCUSSION

The results of statistical analysis for the present investigation has been presented with the help of
tabulation, show the descriptive statistical values for the said variables. Additionally, gender
differences and differences between teachers posted at urban and rural located schools t-test was
applied.

Table 1: Shows descriptive statistics for the overall data.

Variable N Mean SD Skewness Kurtosis
Mental Health 100 99.92 38.18 .266 -1.051

It is evident from the Table1 that mean values for mental health are falling on the higher side.
Which means that majority of government teachers comprises the present sample experience
higher mental health associated with their occupational demands.

Table 2: Mental health of male and female school teachers

GENDER N Mean SD t -value Level of significance
Male 50 108.86 39.01
2.39 0.02
Female 50 90.98 35.49

© The International Journal of Indian Psychology | 122

 Mental Health among Government School Teachers

Form the Table 2, indicates the difference of mental health between both the groups (male and
female). It is evident that mental health of male and female school teachers has significant
difference(t = 2.39; p ≤ .02).Male experience better mental health as compared to their female
counterparts. Reasons may be, single role as a teacher by male teachers whereas females has to
maintain personal as well as professional fronts even if commute long distances, men can
manage whereas females has to face lots of difficulties.

Table 3: Mental health of rural and urban school teachers

Locality N Mean SD t- value Level of Significance
Rural 50 79.16 33.32
-6.46 0.001
Urban 50 120.68 30.91
Form the Table 3, it is found that there is significant difference between rural and urban school
teachers mental health (t = -6.46; p ≤ .001). Government school teachers posted at urban areas
are found high on mental health as compared to those who are posted at rural areas located
schools. Reasons may be, better commuting facilities, short distance between school and home,
connectivity to district authorities and better life style (facility of parks for walks, medical
facilities, better network quality, access to hobby classes for self and children etc.).

In sum, it has been found that the male school teachers’ mental health is found to behigher than
the female school teachers. Additionally, based on locality the urban school teacher is found to
be higher than the female school teachers. Hence, both the hypotheses is accepted.

CONCLUSION
Mental health is a specialized field of psychiatry and its objective is to safeguard mental health
by preventive measures, controlling factors effective on the development of mental diseases,
timely diagnosis of mental diseases, prevention from complications due to relapse of mental
diseases and the providing a healthy environment as a contributory factor on sound human
relationship (Milanifar, 1997). Present study investigates this issue and tries to provide answers
for the following question with regard to mental health of school teachers.

Ananda (1989) conducted a study on mental health of school teachers using a mental health scale
and observed that fifty nine percent of teachers were mentally healthy. The development of our
country is in the hands of the teachers. Good mental health is highly essential for all in general
and particularly teachers. Poor mental health of teachers has an adverse effect indirectly as well
as sometimes directly on the development of learner’s personality. All the school administrators
and higher authorities should take keen interest in developing and maintaining positive mental
health of teachers and students.

Therefore, it is necessary to establish guidance and counseling cell in all the schools. It will help
to solve mental, psychological and health related problems of teachers and students. Mental
health promotion related workshops, seminars, groups discussions and conferences should be

© The International Journal of Indian Psychology | 123

 Mental Health among Government School Teachers

organized at the interschool level then only teachers and students benefited. The teachers’ mental
health is directly related to the work of classroom. Thus, good mental health of the teacher
should as important qualification as academic competence.

REFERENCES
Anand (1989). Buch, M.B., 1983-88, Fourth Survey of Research In Education, Vol -1. New
Delhi: NCERT.
Das, C. (2008). Need for health education in the 21st century with special reference to
reproduction health of adolescents. Journal of Community Guidance and Research,
25(2), p-26-32
Kaur, H. (2007). Mental health of Post Graduate Students in relation to their Value-Conflict.
M.Ed. Dissertation, Punjab University.
Kornhauser (1965). Quoted in Singh,A.K. and Gupta, A.S. (1983). Mental Health Battery.
Ankur Psychological Agency, 22/481, Indira Nagar, Lucknow. p.-3.
Kumar, P. (1992). Mental Health Checklist. National Psychology Corporation, Agra.
Kumar, R. (2013). A study of relationship between teacher’s mental health and appraisals of
student’s undesirable behaviors at elementary level. M.A. Psychology project submitted
to IGNOU.
Milanifar, B. (1997). Mental Health, 5th ed, Tehran: Qums Publications.
Moser, K. (1997). Commitment in organizations. Psychologies, 41 (4), 160-170.
Singh, A &Walia, G. S. (2004). Health and Physical Education. Vinod publications, Ludhiana.
Singh, A. K. & Gupta, A. S. (1983). Mental Health Battery. Ankur Psychological Agency,
22/481, Indira Nagar, Lucknow. pp.1-11.
Singh, K. P., Chandra, T. &Parihar, A. J. S. (2011). Advanced Educational Psychology. Meerut:
R. Lall Book Depot, pp. 772-774.
Srivastava, D. K. & Khan, J. A. (2008). Disability Needs Attention Now!.Indian Journal for the
Practicing Doctor, 5, 3-4.
Srivastava, S. K. (2003). An assessment of Personality and Mental Health among Primary and
Secondary Teachers. Retrieved on (September, 10, 2010) from online Access link
http://medind.nic.in/haa/t05/i2/haat05i2p50.pdf
The world health report 2001 - Mental Health: New Understanding, New Hope (PDF). WHO.
Retrieved 4 May 2014.
WHO. (2012). Risks to mental health: an overview of vulnerabilities and risk factors. 1-14.

© The International Journal of Indian Psychology | 124

View publication stats