Prelude For Organizational Efficiency: Cost Consciousness
Prelude For Organizational Efficiency: Cost Consciousness
Prelude For Organizational Efficiency: Cost Consciousness
Prelude for
Organizational
Efficiency
C OST AC C OUNTING –
AN EVOLU TIONARY
OVERVIEW
Introduction
In order to trace the evolutionary development of Cost Accounting, we need
to understand the philosophy of the first Book on accounting titled “Smma
De Aithnatica, Geometrieca Proportionilita” or simply “Summa” authored by
Fra Luca Pacioli in 1494 which contains a chapter on double entry system of
Book keeping and some discussions on certain aspects of cost analysis. Today
cost accounting is known as either Cost & Management Accounting or simply
Management Accounting because of significant metamorphosis it has gone
through over the past six countries. Cost Accounting deals with ascertainment
and determination of cost of production and distribution of wants removing
goods and services and transmitting relevant, significant and meaningful cost
information to the management for the purpose of decision making under
different socio-economic situations. Cost consciousness is the pivotal force that
necessitates emergence of Cost Accounting or Cost & Management Accounting
as a distinct discipline and the same has been recognised to be a noble Profession
for guiding different levels of Management in an Organisation which may
include commercial, bureaucratic or entities not for profits.
Evolutionary Sketch
The history and development of Cost & Management Accounting can be
presented in the following way which took place in different parts of the world
and more specifically in the UK, USA, Canada etc. It has been mentioned earlier
that the terms Cost Accounting, Cost & Management Accounting, Management
Accounting & Cost Management are used synonymously and interchangeably in
the literature of Management Accountancy.
Between 1880 & 1914 an approach brown as Scientific Management was developed by F.W. Taylor
who is brown as the Fatter of Scientific Management, F.W. Taylor developed a method for analysing
productivity of the factors of production in a number of industries. Time and motion study is the
contribution of Taylor who applied Standard Costing System as a management accounting tool for
cost control purpose.
Donaldson Brown devised a system for relating costs, net profit and return on investment to short
run output variations. Flexible Budget mechanism is the contribution of Donaldson and this is an
effective tool for planning and control.
Balanced Scorecard as a strategic performance management tool uses both Financial & Non-
Financial measures and the same is found to be in wider practice across the globe.
Conclusion:
In Order to understand the role of Cost Consciousness in bringing about organisational efficiency it
is an imperative to shade some lights on the evolutionary development of erstwhile Cost Accounting
and today’s Management Accounting Management through which Cost Consciousness is practiced
and it generates desired result of the organisation. Philosophically speaking, an organisation should
not spend more than actual requirement and should spent judiciously which forms part of cost.
The gulf between sales and cost is profit and profit is the measure of effective performance of the
management, Cost Management ensures cost control and measures the performance of the factors
production in an economy. The ongoing era is the era of cost management. The evolutionary
development of the discipline of Cost & Management Accounting is presented below.
Cost Recording – Prior to the 19th Century
C OST C ONSCIOUSNESS
VS ORGANISATIONAL
EFFICIENCY
Introduction
Cost is the common denominator and the principal guide for achieving
organisational efficiency under the environment of competition. Under
competitive business environment, price of a product or service is determined by
the interactive forces of demand and supply. In other words, price is determined
by the market and a business has to sell its products or service at the price
determined by the market when market is under the influence of competition.
Price is the contribution and consideration that contains cost and profit. Under
competitive market environment, a business can make only normal profit and
there is hardly any scope for earning extraordinary profit. What a business
can do is to manage the cost of production and distribution of the product or
service and here lies the role of cost consciousness which contributes to bringing
about organisational efficiency, growth and development. Cost Management at
the various phases of production and distribution cycle is the sustainable and
surviving strategy for a business at micro level and the economy as a whole
at macro level that face the heat of cut throat competition under the business
environment of market driven economy. The efficiency of a business is measured
by the degree of efficiency it controls and manages the cost.Cost consciousness
and cost culture play a pivotal role in the practice of cost management in order to
accrue organisational efficiency.
Importance of cost management as a contribution to Organisational Efficiency:
The contemporary era in the evolutionary development of cost and management
accountancy profession has been attributed to cost management era. Cost
management is given prime importance from the angle of supply chain in the
process of procurement of inputs to transfer the ownership in the products or
service in favourer of the customers. Supply chain management takes care of
management of cost of supply of inputs and it continues its effort till the output is finally handed
over to the ultimate customers. There are various techniques used in cost management and some of
them are value analysis, ABC, ABM, ABB, Target Costing, Lifecycle Costing, Theory of Constraints
etc, and CMA(Cost & Management Accountant) is the architect of cost management methodology,
In raw materials procurement, there involves transaction-processing cost, input purchase cost
and input holding or carrying cost. It is an imperative to mention that CMAs guide the business
with regard to the methodology and scope of cost reduction and control of cost in each and every
stage of product planning and design. The business must know at what stage of its operation it
would be able achieve its breakeven and when it would be able to start earning profit. It is to make
industry analysis and make a thorough SWOT analysis in order to identify the avenues when it
can enjoy competitive advantage over others. The profession of cost and management accountancy
has reached over such a stage during last two hundred years where it became an indispensable
discipline that guides the business under different situations. It plays its effective and pivotal role
under different phases of business cycle in appropriate manner.
Competitive Advantage
Why do customers buy one product in preference to other is nothing but the competitive advantage
between the two is compared and it is again cost and quality aspects that matter and help in taking
a decision. Competitive advantage is a set of unique features of a company expressed and translated
in terms of quality and cost per unit. It also takes into consideration its products that are perceived
by the target market as Significant and superior to the competition. The firms to are focus on the
issues relating to cost, product differentiation and niche strategies. These aspects together constitute
the foundation stone of competitive advantage. When a firm is able utilize skilled workforce,
judicious purchase of raw materials and efficient commercial operations, it is said to be working
with competitive advantage. The example of Bata India Ltd. Can be cited in this context. Bata
India Ltd manufactures different kinds of Shoes and sandals and the customers enjoy competitive
advantage of Bata products over other shoe manufacturing companies both in terms of cost and
quality. This is from customers point of view. From the side of the firm, the firm enjoys competitive
advantage in the shoe market as it does have customers’ support since it is able to offer the wider
range of products at reasonable cost with desired quality. Similarly, we may cite the example of
Maruti Suzuki, an Indo- Japanese car manufacturing firm, does have competitive advantage over
other car manufacturing companies in term of cost and quality. Cost is the only mantra for survival
and sustainability under the context of competitive business environment. Cost management is
exercised at product design and development stage and technology with cost efficiency prescribed
by the cost manager is one of the ways of cost minimization.
Product Differentiation
Product differentiation is another mantra for survival under competitive environment. The
mechanism of product differentiation keeping cost at minimum level with requisite quality
conformity allows a firm to compete with others. The gulf between sales and cost is the profit. The
firm cannot influence price under competitive environment but cost control and cost reduction are
under its workable domain. Branding helps in product differentiation and branding has also a cost
and it has to decide that whether a firm should go for branding or not and comparative analysis for
cost with or without branding is made and conclusively an appropriate decision is taken.
Marketing Mix
A marketing mix is nothing but a planned mix of the four Ps within a marketing plan. The four Ps
of marketing mix consist of product. price. place and promotion. A successful marketing mix must
have all four elements created to reach the target market effectively in order to have an efficient and
desired market share for a product likely to be launched. Each element of marketing mix is analysed
and the cost perspective and implication of the same are examined. As far as first ‘P’ i.e. product is
concerned. the first question arises whether the product likely to be marketed in near future is cost
competitive and it takes care of analysis of cost with reference to physical shape. packaging and
brand etc. When we talk of product. we mean the relevance of customer-value. physical appearance
and associated services are taken into consideration in the definition of the product. Physical
distribution or place comes into the next purview of analysis. Place is the location where the
product or service is available for the purpose of purchase by the customers. It is to ensure that the
product or service is available whenever the customers want to buy it. Sometimes product may be
available on a particular location and here the distribution cost is of prime concern and the same is
taken into consideration while the decision with reference to place is taken into consideration. The
prime location or location on posh locality is involved with greater bracket of distribution cost. The
third ‘P’ i.e. promotion which communicates the product value through advertisement and it has
to be a cost effective media otherwise it would overburden product. As far as product promotion is
concerned. Advertising, public relations, personal selling and distribution of samples are the cost
drivers when the product or service concerned is the cost object. Finally fourth ‘P’ i.e. price that
represents the monetary benefit a customer is willing to sacrifice for acquiring the product or a
project. It also uses modular contribution approach for marketing cost analysis. The whole market
is divided into certain number of segments and it ascertains contribution of each segment to profit
besides indirect fixed cost that is associated with the segment. The modular contribution approach
assesses the profitability of specific marketing mix in a specific zone and evaluates and examines the
feasibility for making change in the marketing strategy in the concerned zone. The fundamental
objective of a business is to maximize its revenue and profit. In order to achieve this objective, it is
important to keep in view that quality and cost aspects of a product are to given necessary weightage
at the time of product planning, product design, manufacturing and use. Product planning involves
taking decision about which products and services a firm is contemplating for marketing. The
management is to take a decision with regard to market segment, product features, quantity level,
price and expected volume of sales. The manufacturer must take into consideration the design of
the product by product designer and it must take care of abnormal spoilage and waste of inputs
otherwise it tell upon the financial health of the product. Finally, it must ensure that cost for post
selling period is minimum and the cost implication aspects from product planning to product
reaching the final users is analysed for the new product and before diversification these issues
are critically analysed by the cost manager and places the same before the management for their
appropriate action.
Conclusion
It may be relevant to assert that a product failing the test of cost competitiveness cannot sustain
and survive in market other than
monopoly. In monopoly, the firm
strategy enables
price is determined in competitive
market by demand-supply forces
prevailing in the market. In the same
a firm entering way, it can be stated that product
differentiation ensures how a firm’s
into new markets product or services differ from other
competitors in terms of quality and
with completely cost. Product development strategy
is adopted by a firm when its existing
new product market is saturated and it tries to
leverage its market related experience
and here lies and effective customer relations
management with the existing
assessment.
of customers preference. Product
development strategy is practiced to
move away from hard degree cut throat
competition and creating uncontested
market which may be called ‘Blue Ocean Strategy’. Here it is to ascertain the impact of research
and development cost and advertisement focus over the concerned product or service. Finally,
diversification strategy enables a firm entering into new markets with completely new product and
here lies the risk and risk assessment. It may not be irrelevant to mention that to cite the example of
Honda that leveraged upon the core competency of engines to enter into the business of generators
and lawn mowers as has been dealt with by Gary Hamel and C. K. Prahlad in their famous book
‘Competing for the Future’ and here also the role of cost management is well accepted and thus
cost is the principal guide in framing the sustainable business strategy and cost competitiveness
is the test that needs to be passed by any product or service for survival and sustaining in the
competitive business environment particularly when it is the buyers’ market. Moreover for the
purpose of generating maximum customer value, cost competitiveness is a must for the product or
service in order to create a niche of its own.
66 Educating people about meaning, significance and importance of costs. Fixing responsibilities
and roles of the rank and file in managing and saving to Costs.
66 Bridging the behavioural and professional gulf between Finance & Accounts and Other
wings processionals.
66 Ensuring that everybody favours decision-making on costing information.
66 Obtaining Support of top management to sensitive the areole organisation about Cost
consciousness and its workability.
Communication w.r.t. importance of cost
Fixing cost management responsibility on managers
Ensuring decision made on costing information
Cost saving acts as panacea for survival growth and development of an organisation. The objective of
non-profit organisations is to generate surplus whereas profit motive organisation’s main purpose is
to earn profit in order to ensure perpetuity of existence in the business. Managing financial aspects
of an organisation is nothing but similar to personal finance management through prudence and
ultimate objective is to ensure that it is subject to profitability and for this purpose, it is to create
cost consciousness to manage the commercial operation carefully.
Conclusion
Organisational well being depends upon the principles of there ‘Es` and E-1 Stands for Economy.
Efficiency means to do the thing right, E-2 stands for Effectiveness which means to do the right
thing and finally E-3 means Economy which refers to the philosophy – ‘ waste not, want not’ and
the third ‘E’ is the foundation of cost consciousness.
Efficiency
Survival, Growth & Effectiveness
Economy Development of an organisation
depends upon
Workability of Three Es
Cost management is the managerial action built on the foundation of cost consciousness and cost
culture and no organisation including government establishment cannot sustain and survive in
absence of cost culture.
SUSTAINABILIT Y OF
BUSINESS THROUGH
C OST C ONSCIOUSNESS
Introduction
The question of sustainability of business is central to business strategy. A business
can sustain only when it sets its priority to meet the interest of the stakeholders.
The key issue of strategic management is that of how an organization uses its
resources and capabilities to develop a sustainable competitive advantage in
its favour. The long term success of a firm depends upon the ability to create
and sustain a competitive advantage over the rivals that operate parallel in
the market. A sustainable business is required to understand the dynamics of
economic environment whose essentials constituents are the internal and
external stakeholders that include investors, customers, suppliers, employees and
regulators. Investors provide capital, customers are the source of profitability,
suppliers supply credit, employees are the cause of productivity and regulators
i.e. government ensures environment for fair and healthy competition and
social justice in the business environment. The business in turn is to prioritize
the responsibility for capital appreciations as return and dividend as reward for
the investors, timely delivery of high quality products and services at reasonable
price for the customers, profit for the suppliers of funds in order to sustain in
the business, support, respect, fair treatment, training for upgrading of skill and
competence and sustainable with comfort a remuneration for the employees
and finally, regulators want a business complies with rules and law of the land,
honesty and fairness in the day to day dealings of the firms besides payment of
tax in time. The essence of sustainability should be considered as a strategic issue
for every business and a business cannot sustain without securing the Interest of
the stakeholders.
Profit-Indicator of Performance
An organization generally targets at attaining economic prosperity and environmental quality. No
business can sustain without profit-and according the Michael E. Porter, new entrants to business,
power of buyers, power of suppliers, substitutes and rivalry among the competitors directly or
indirectly influence the degree of profitability of a business. New entrants into the market brings
extra capacity and intensify competition, existing competition and its intensity and powerful
buyers can enforce price cutting, suppliers attributed with bargaining power charge higher prices,
substitutes threat across industries and in order to have harmonious balance of these five forces,
the business has to gain strength from the stakeholders. No business can rise to the zenith of
its success by ignoring the interest of the stakeholders. The theory of stakeholders has become
a prominent subject and occupied an important room in the literature of management since
publication of the book' Strategic Management; A Stakeholder Approach' authored by R. Freeman
in year of 1984. Freeman says, "Current approaches to understanding the business environment
fail to take account of a wide range of groups who can affect or are affected by the corporation, its
stakeholders". Modern businesses in developed countries are seen to be more serious in protecting
the interests of the stakeholders than that of business organizations operating in developing
countries like India. Overall commercial success of a business depends on successful management
of relationships that a firm does have with the stakeholders. Again, in the version of Freeman, a
firm ceases to exist without the support of the stakeholders. The stakeholders do have direct and
indirect influence on the long term strategic decision of the firms and without spontaneous support
of the stakeholders, it is difficult maintain its continued success in the economic environment.
Employees and investors are the internal stakeholders and customers, suppliers and government
are the external stakeholders of the firms. It is to take into consideration the fundamental interest
of the stakeholders in the process of architecting planning and formulating policy of a company. In
India, business management policies are formulated without taking into consideration the views
of the stakeholders in many cases. Employees are exploited to the possible extent and in private
sectors, organizations barring few private sector multinational companies who adopt the standard
practice in treatment of the people with respect , customers is provided with adulterated products
, promoters vanish from the market with investors money, suppliers claim are dishonoured, and
regulatory bodies i.e. governments is deprived of due tax through the mechanism of tax evasion
and tax avoidance process.
product or service and the cost of resources used for generating revenue which is technically called
cost. A business cannot survive and sustain if the customers shun the business. Peter F. Drucker,
the renowned management thinker of the twentieth century says that customer is the business and
sales is the only window through which revenue enters into the business.
Sustainable Strategy
Business strategies should be formulated within the framework of overall objectives of a firm with
a view to meet the needs of the stakeholders. If someone sees from micro point of view, it can
be understood that strategy comprises of how and where to compete, how management uses the
financial resources and how it maintains its relationship with that of suppliers of capital. The mission
of an economic entity normally is embodiment of three questions and they are as to why does a
business exist, what does it provide and for whom does it exist? If someone thinks deeply, strategy
is nothing but mechanism for meeting the needs of the stakeholders. In this context of generating
value for the stakeholders, perhaps it will be pertinent to refer the McKinsey 7-S Model where
strategy has been given an important room. While dealing with the needs of the stakeholders, it is
to keep in view the transparent corporate governance which is embodiment of governance, ethics
and social responsibility and fair dealings with the stakeholders is possible under the spirit of these
aspects of modern management principles. Stakeholders' support is unconditionally available when
an organization practices in transparency, accountability and commits to social responsibility since
these are essential ingredients of sustainable strategic management. R. Freeman says that it is the
business of the business to honour the due claims of the stakeholders having direct and indirect
contribution to the growth, development, survival and sustainability of business and therefore
entrepreneurs should have broad view as to how to generate confidence of the stakeholders in the
economic affairs of the business. It is therefore worthwhile to mention that in order to maintain
the reasonable degree of flow of sustainability of a business, it is a compulsion and not just an
imperative to take care of the interests of the stakeholders and cost consciousness is a productive
strategy to generate necessary surplus for the business in general and the investors in particular.
Cost is the measure of the sacrifices of the resources that transform into consumable goods and
services. The fundamental theory of cost consciousness is bared on the premise that ’waste not,
want not’. Costs can be reduced through innovation. Enhancing efficiency of the inputs would
enable cost reduction. Under competitive business environment, price is fixed by interaction of
market forces and the producer can hardly influence over price. It is the cost that remains within
the Control of the producers. Cost leadership Strategy can only ensure survival and sustainability
of a business under competitive environment. Thus, cost consciousness and cost competitiveness
have no substitutes.
Conclusion
Cost management culture develops only through cost consciousness at individual as well as business
level. It is the religious responsibility of the business organisations to derive the result of being cost
consciousness at no cost. It is possible through positive behavioural actions.
C O ST E F F IC I E NC Y
F OR ST R AT E G IC
C A PA B I L I T Y OF
I N DIA N E C ONOM Y
T H ROU G H C O ST
C ON S C IOU SN E S S
Introduction
India is attributed with a vast economy comprising of public sector and private
sector manufacturing hubs. A commercial organisation's ability to grow, survive
and develop depends upon its strategic capability and cost efficiency is the pivot
which ensures strategic capability to the concerned business organisation in
particular and the whole economy in general. Cost management is the nucleus
of cost efficiency philosophy. Cost efficiency is practiced on the foundation of
efficient and judicious uses of factors of production which essentially includes
land, labour, capital and entrepreneurial ability and it is the outcome of efficient
management of the rewards payable to the contributors of the factors of
production. The degree of cost efficiency depends on how effectively costs are
managed or the ability of a firm to manage cost. The need and requirement of
achieving cost efficiency is equally applicable to both the public sector and private
sector organizations though the objectives of public sector organizations are
different to certain extent from that of private sector organizations. Government
of India is very serious in using cost and management accounting theory and
philosophy of cost management and promoting cost culture in the country. In
this context, the role played by the Institute of Cost Accountants of India (ICAI)
formerly the Institute of Cost and Works Accountants of India (lCWAI) is vital.
The name of ICWAI has been changed to ICAI by dint of the Cost and Works
Accountants (Amendment) Act, 2011 (Act No. 10 of 2012) and the professional
designation of the Members of the ICAI have been changed to ACMA(Associate
Cost & Management Accountant) and FCMA (Fellow Cost & Management Accountant) from
AICWA (Associate Incorporated Cost & Works Accountant) and FICWA(Fellow Incorporated
Cost & Works Accountant) respectively by the same Act of Parliament.
operation, outbound logistics, marketing and sales and rendering services and measure earnings
in terms of margin. The margin represents excess of consideration over cost paid to the firms for
obtaining bundle of values added to the inputs through manufacturing operations. Cost incurred
through various primary and secondary activities need proper monitoring and reporting to the
strategic level management for appropriate action.
of Cost Accountants
sanitation etc are covered by the canvas of
Cost Audit. But it is the need of the hour in
of India (ICAI)
order to make the nation Cost competitive
that cost audit should be extended to other
Accountants of India
an essential measure that needs to be adopted
throughout the length and breadth of the
(lCWAI) is vital.
country. Cost efficiency through cost audit is
possible since cost audit has been emerged as
on effective tool of cost management. It helps
in bringing about industrial efficiency, effective
business decisions with the help of attentive
cost information and over and above all it
enables the economy to cause faster economic
development by optimum utilisation of
economic resources.
C O ST OF
I N E F F IC I E NC Y:
A C ASE ST U DY
Introduction
Modern India Limited (MIL), a multinational firm engaged in manufacturing of
alternator parts (P1, P2, P3 and P4) of generator for last fifty years. The product of
the company has international market and it leads in term of cost efficiency and
quality management. The company has manufacturing units in UK, USA, Japan,
South Africa and Australia besides India. The company's financial performance
during last five years is sluggish and depressive. All the manufacturing Units
across the globe are functioning as individual Strategic Business Units (SBUs)
and they compete with one another. However, they work on the principles of
goal congruence. Each SBU is headed by a General Manager (Operations) and
the organization structure of the company is of pyramidal and traditional headed
by CEO Cum Managing Director. There is intra- SBU competition and one SBU
can exercise option to buy input from another SBU or open market. Transfer
Pricing Mechanism is in place. The company has four directorates and they are
Marketing, operations, Finance and Human Resource and all the board members
and their immediate subordinates sit in the Headquarters of the company. The
leaders of the SBUs function as an individual decision making entity and report
to the CEO thorough the concerned directorates. The company works on the
strong guiding principles of focus, cost leadership and product differentiation.
The firm has a full -fledged Total Quality Management (TQM) cell and the total
quality management cell of the company was very active and efficient at the initial
years of operations and it did never make any compromise in quality control and
quality management of the product keeping in view the international standards
and parameters. This was the inherent strength of the company. The company
was always watchful on market standing, productivity, management of financial
resources, performance of the managers, attitude of the staff, professionalism,
surplus creation and honouring corporate social responsibilities. These are the
preambles of the company on which it is founded. But the company is not in a
position to make its way in the roads of globalisation. The case of the company's
performance in totality can be understood, from the foregoing account as is made
with marketing managers. Scientific inventory and remaining 60% is locked up in physical and
management techniques can help in managing infrastructural assets. The CFO of the firm is
inventory carrying cost and inventory ordering worried that operational cost is with upward
cost according to the CMA. Purchase manager trend and revenue earning is with downward
can help in getting reasonable discount in trend and it is a very difficult situation to match
following effective purchase policy. Work study revenue with escalating expenses. An Earning
was undertaken by the SBUs five years back and per share is abruptly low and it is difficult to
the recommendations of work study group are earn the confidence of the investors under
under the cover of dust. such circumstances. There is accumulation of
book debts and inventory and stores and this
Finance Functions disturbs the short term liquidity of the business.
The Finance Directorate is headed by Director The cost structure in terms of the cost of sales
(Finance) and CFO and is assisted by GM of the product comprises of 50% material, 30%
(Finance) at corporate level and Finance Function employee costs, 20% overhead and 5% of the
at SBU level is headed by Dy. GM (Finance) who cost of sales hardly contributes to profit. CFO
is essentially a qualified CMA as per the policy feels that abnormal loss in material handling
of the company. According to the periodical and overhead needs to be controlled and the
report generated by Finance Wing, cash flow is performance based incentive scheme for the
very weak and there is irregular flow of revenue employees should be adopted in order to make
to the coffer of the company. Collection cell is the firm financially solvent.
under the administrative control of Marketing
Directorate and functionally responsible to the Human Resource Functions
Finance Directorate. It violates the principles The HR Directorate is headed by Director
of unity of command and as result it causes (HR). The Company has a full-fledged
an administrative problem for securing Human Resource Directorate and it deals with
accountability and this has been brought to recruitment, training and development and
notice of the HR Directorate over time and promotions of the people of the organizations
again but no workable solution is generated so in general. The HR Directorate functions and
far. Financing working capital is dependent of monitors the HR Budget as is framed by the
the strength of cash flow. Purchase Department company. There is centralization of HR Policy.
fails to secure more credit period from the It is the responsibility of the GM (HR) at
sundry creditors than the collection period corporate level to act as the chief coordinator
allowed to sundry debtors and the same is being among the SBU level HR Managers. The SBU
practiced by the collection department without HR Managers prepare HR Budgets annually and
any review. The company is contemplating the same is incorporated in the Master Budget
for diversification of its business from of the Company. It is has been observed that a
manufacturing alternator parts of generator substantial portion of the HR budget remained
to manufacturing of industrial cranes and for unutilised during the panned period and the
this purpose it needs injecting both debt and GM (HR) could not justify the non-utilization
equity in terms of RS.1000 crores. But it is of the HR Budget. Budget proposal is placed by
afraid as to whether people would subscribe SBU HR Managers and the same is forwarded
to the equity since for last five years rate of by the GM (Operations) .to Headquarters of
dividend payment is marginal even less than the company located at Mumbai, India for
that of savings bank interest rate. Currently the adoption. Moreover GM (HR) takes lot of time
company has a capital base of Rs. 2,000 crores to communicate the approved HR budget to
out of which 40% is invested in working capital the SBU HR Managers and SBU In-charges.
The world is changing very fast keeping pace external failure cost, appraisal cost and
with advancement of science and technology. correcting costs are major components of TQM
Staff cost is 30% of the cost of sales in general but they remain unreported in most of the
and every employee has to contribute positively time. There is huge gap between contemplation
to growth and prosperity of the company. and action. An organization means people and
The people of the organization have to work it fails to deal with its people in time-honoured
keeping in view of importance and Significance conducive manner that can inspire and motivate
of economy, efficiency and effectiveness. the workforce of the company. The CMA was
Non performers have to be identified and giving continuously alarming bell but the
the company does not have a time-honoured management did not give due attention to it. It
mechanism and parameters for measuring is now high time to draw the existing balanced
the efficiency of the people. The company HR scorecard and the budgeted one for the given
Policy is back dated. It is observed that a person firm. Both the principles of management by
who joined as Foreman/ supervisor remained objectives and management by exception need
in the same position during last twenty or to be made workable in cohesive manner. The
more years. The employees at all levels are sustainability and survival of the company under
found demoralized and de- motivated. The fierce competitive environment needs to be
Cost of inefficiency burdens the pricing of the ensured. The CEO & Managing Director is not
product in particular and the firm in general. getting relevant information for the purpose of
The people of the organization are concerned formulating appropriate strategy. Management
with mission, vision, objectives and goal of the Information System (MIS) is inactive, inefficient
company only in paper and it lacks initiative in and ineffective. The whole organization is
translating vision into action and action into plagued by inefficiency and they ultimately
result. The leadership of the company is found have failed to deliver the result. Under the
to bureaucratic and sometimes it is autocratic. circumstances, the CEO & Managing Director
Chain of command and control is centralized at requested the CMA as the business strategist
corporate level. There is mounting court cases to submit its report on the overall functioning
between the unhappy workforce and the firm. of the firm incorporating its recommendations
The company is functioning in a closed ended for revamping, sustainability under competitive
system. is environment, honouring the claims of
various stakeholders and complying with the
Conclusion requirement of corporate social responsibility
It is evident from the above that the firm in our of multi-product-multinational firm as the
Case is ambitious for expansion of the business present one. It also should suggest an efficient
in one hand and on the other hand it is not in a transfer pricing mechanism that would promote
position to manage the existing business in cost goal congruency in the organization on overall
effective manner. It fails to generate reasonable count.
rate of return on capital employed, could not
pay good dividend, working capital financing is
weak as a result of feeble cash flow, burdened
with inefficient workforce and attributed
with alarming rise in cost of production and
attributed with declining trend of earning
revenue. The cost of inefficiency is yet to be
worked out. The Total Quality Management
(TQM) hardly works. Internal failure cost,
C ost C onsciousness
Cost Awareness
Cost Competitiveness
Helps to Industry
Helps to Economy
Helps to Society
N OT E S
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
....................................................................
The Institute of Cost Accountants of India
(Statutory body under an Act of Parliament)
HEADQUARTERS
CMA Bhawan
12, Sudder Street, Kolkata – 700 016
Tel: +91 33 2252 1031/1034/1035/1492/1602/1619/7373/7143
Fax: +91 33 2252 7993/1026/1723
DELHI OFFICE
CMA Bhawan
3, Institutional Area, Lodhi Road
New Delhi – 110003
Tel: +91 11 24666100, 24622156/57/58
Fax : +91 11 43583642
Website: www.icmai.in