Medical Internet of Things and Big Data in Healthcare: Review Article
Medical Internet of Things and Big Data in Healthcare: Review Article
Objectives: A number of technologies can reduce overall costs for the prevention or management of chronic illnesses. These
include devices that constantly monitor health indicators, devices that auto-administer therapies, or devices that track real-
time health data when a patient self-administers a therapy. Because they have increased access to high-speed Internet and
smartphones, many patients have started to use mobile applications (apps) to manage various health needs. These devices
and mobile apps are now increasingly used and integrated with telemedicine and telehealth via the medical Internet of
Things (mIoT). This paper reviews mIoT and big data in healthcare fields. Methods: mIoT is a critical piece of the digital
transformation of healthcare, as it allows new business models to emerge and enables changes in work processes, productiv-
ity improvements, cost containment and enhanced customer experiences. Results: Wearables and mobile apps today support
fitness, health education, symptom tracking, and collaborative disease management and care coordination. All those platform
analytics can raise the relevancy of data interpretations, reducing the amount of time that end users spend piecing together
data outputs. Insights gained from big data analysis will drive the digital disruption of the healthcare world, business process-
es and real-time decision-making. Conclusions: A new category of “personalised preventative health coaches” (Digital Health
Advisors) will emerge. These workers will possess the skills and the ability to interpret and understand health and well-being
data. They will help their clients avoid chronic and diet-related illness, improve cognitive function, achieve improved mental
health and achieve improved lifestyles overall. As the global population ages, such roles will become increasingly important.
Health Cloud
EHR
Medical
tablet Desktop
Body temp
Physician manager Database
sensor
Gateway to
other services
Glucose
sensor Blood pressure
sensor
Insulin
pump
Biobanks Sensor/actuator
with low-power TRx
clinical trials
RFID Reader Network Hub Wearables
desktop computer. securely stores private medical data that can be used for can-
It sounds pretty basic, but the adoption of Electronic Health cer research. Though the platform began with cancer, Intel
Records (EHRs) is a game changer. In less than a decade, an intends to open up the federated cloud network to other
ink-and-paper system of managing records that goes back institutions, including ones working on cures to diseases like
thousands of years will be digitized and replaced [3]. The ad- Parkinson’s.
vantages are obvious and many. Paper records, often written Engineering simulation solutions are making medicine
in questionable penmanship, can get stuffed away in filing participatory, personalized, predictive and preventive (P4
cabinets, out of the reach of researchers or other healthcare medicine) via the medical Internet of Things (mIoT) [6].
providers. Instead, by keeping all the important information
in one place, and easily sharable, EHRs will eliminate many II. IoT - The Future of Pharma?
inefficiencies, and save lives.
One of the major challenges to implementing the IoT has Pharma companies long ago realized that just selling tradi-
to do with communication; although many devices now tional medicines will not produce growth nor even sustain
have sensors to collect data, they often talk with the server in competitiveness. This fundamental change, known as mov-
their own language. Manufacturers each have their own pro- ing ‘beyond the pill’, typically arises from one or two realiza-
prietary protocols, which means sensors by different mak- tions: (1) medicines alone are often not enough to achieve
ers can’t necessarily speak with each other. This fragmented optimal clinical outcomes for patients, and (2) as pharma-
software environment, coupled with privacy concerns and ceutical pipelines dry up, ‘beyond-the-pill’ businesses can be
the bureaucratic tendency to hoard all collected information, valuable new sources of revenues. This has created growing
frequently maroons valuable info on data islands, undermin- interest in methods of utilizing the new technologies and
ing the whole idea of the IoT. business processes for development and patient care, leading
Precision medicine, as it’s called, is a term that will be fre- to Pharma IoT.
quently heard in coming years [4]. It begins with genomics The Pharma IoT concept involves digitalization of medical
and goes through the rest of the omics platforms, provid- products and related care processes using smart connected
ing multiscale data for analysis and interpretation [5]. In medical devices and IT services (web, mobile, apps, etc.)
2015, Intel and the Oregon Health and Science University during drug development, clinical trials and patient care.
launched a joint project, the Collaborative Cancer Cloud: The outcomes of Pharma IoT in development and clinical
a high-performance analytics platform that collects and trials can employ combinations of advanced technologies
and services to create totally new kinds of disease treatment • Glaxo recently announced that it is investing in electro-
possibilities (e.g., Treatment 2.0). ceuticals, bioelectrical drugs that work by micro-stimula-
In patient care, Pharma IoT will enable patients and health- tion of nerves [13].
care professionals to use medicines with advanced sensor • J&J has teamed up with Google to develop robotic sur-
hardware, and craft personalized care services and processes gery. In addition, they are collaborating with Philips on
(Product 2.0). Good examples of the Pharma IoT solutions wearable devices such as blood pressure monitors [14].
are the connected sensor wearables for Parkinson’s disease • Novartis is working with Google (again) on sensor tech-
and multiple sclerosis patients, which provide medication nologies, such as the smart lens, and a wearable device to
management, improving the patient outcomes and the qual- measure blood glucose levels [15].
ity of life [7]. Sensors can provide a lot of information to support pharma
In addition, existing medical device products such as inhal- development, but it is particularly important to recruit the
ers and insulin pens can be added to the sensor and connec- right patients for the right clinical trials. Body sensors, once
tivity technologies to collect data for further care analytics, gadgets that were mainly used by athletes and runners, are
and even personalized therapy [8]. All this will substantially now rapidly entering the general market, and consumers and
improve personal medication and care processes, because pharma will soon have access to a wealth of information in-
patient care data provides new sources of innovation and cluding not only pulse, blood pressure, ECG and respiratory
competitiveness. rate, but also more advanced data, such as inflammation,
The transformation also involves some challenges: at the sleep patterns, etc.
same time, pharma companies need to take into account the A number of mobile apps which support device handling
forthcoming European Union (EU) data protection and pri- have emerged, including myDario and SleepBot among
vacy legislation, which will give patients control of their care others [16,17]. The Hacking Medicine Institute recently an-
data [9]. For example, patients will be allowed to transfer nounced RANKED Health, a program to critically evaluate
their care and health data across multiple service providers, and rank health-focused applications and connected devices
leading to the emergence of totally new kinds of service plat- [18].
forms and business models, e.g., data brokers [10]. It has been predicted that in the near future we will look at
our phone or smart watch to check health outcomes more
III. Devices and Mobile Apps for often than we do now to check our mail or WhatsApp. A
Healthcare typical situation might involve an elderly person, recovering
from a medical condition at home, linked to a combination
We are heading into the age of information, where knowl- of several connected services streaming data towards differ-
edge and data will be key. We are also entering the age of the ent parties, such as family members, tele-carer and physi-
customer, in which more than ever the customer is going to cians (Figure 2).
determine what they want. myTomorrows is one example of Recently it was announced that Medtronic will be partner-
the changing look of business models, in this case, directly ing with a digital health app company named Canary Health
connecting customers and pharma [11]. to be a re-seller of its digital chronic disease management
In this new age, devices and apps will be used to create a programs, including its CDC-recognized Diabetes Preven-
“health selfie”. For example: tion Program, which is aimed at changing behaviors in pre-
• The
Myo, originally a motion controller for games, is now diabetic people. But the partnership goes beyond just resell-
being used in orthopedics for patients who need to ex- ing Canary Health’s digital tools. In fact, both Canary Health
ercise after a fracture. With the aid of the Myo, patients and Medtronic plan to develop solutions that “leverage
can monitor their progress and doctors can measure the Medtronic’s devices, services and infrastructure as well as
angle of movement. Canary Health’s suite of behavior-change programs, design
• The
Zio Patch measures heart rate and electrocardiogram expertise, and deep user engagement experience,” according
(ECG) and is the US Food and Drug Administration ap- to a Canary Health news release [19].
proved [12]. One reason that Medtronic must have been attracted to Ca-
Where is pharma in all this turmoil? Interestingly, there nary Health is that the company’s digital tools are reimburs-
are signs that pharma is reaching out from its traditional able. As digital health programs mature, payers are looking
medicine-centric approach. at innovative, yet proven, ways to reduce their cost burden
Bio samples
Telehealth
Career
a Stress
Health coach
Service can Figure 2. A typical situation involved
help you
Relationships
with... Exercise an elderly person, recover-
Rehab
tracking Sleep
ing from a medical condi-
todiforfitness.com
tion at home, linked to
Telemedicine
a combination of several
Medication connected services stream-
tracking ing data towards differ-
ent parties, such as family
members, tele-carer and
physicians.
for chronic diseases like diabetes. tions Salesforce to be able to bridge the gap between patient’s
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Preven- medical data and pharma.
tion (CDC), people with prediabetes who take part in a “Big data” is a phrase that has been used pervasively by
structured lifestyle change program—like the one Canary the media and the lay public in the last several years. While
Health has developed, or programs championed by Omada many definitions have been proposed, the common de-
Health and Noom Health, among others—“can cut their risk nominator seems to include the “three V’s”—Volume (vast
of developing type 2 diabetes by 58% (71% for people over amounts of data), Variety (significant heterogeneity in the
60 years old)” [20]. The CDC adds that “this finding was the type of data available in the set), and Velocity (speed at
result of a program helping people lose 5% to 7% of their which a data scientist or user can access and analyze the
body weight through healthier eating and 150 minutes of data) [23].
physical activity a week” [21]. Defined as such, healthcare has become one of the key
Given that diabetes is an expensive, chronic disease, hos- emerging users of big data. For example, Fitbit and Apple’s
pitals, doctors, patients, and payers are equally keen to tame ResearchKit can provide researchers access to vast stores of
this epidemic. In other words, the move is helping to trans- biometric data on users, which can then be used to test hy-
form companies from simply providing care to the sick to potheses on nutrition, fitness, disease progression, treatment
actually delivering healthcare. success, and the like.
Most complex high dimensional data sets include imag-
IV. Data, Data, Data ing (photos, X-rays, MRIs, and slides), wave analysis such as
EEG and ECG, audio files with associated transcripts, free
The driver behind all these wearable sensors is the data that text notes with natural language processing (NLP) outputs,
is generated, and various parties are trying to bundle the and mappings between structured concepts such as lab tests
data streams and obtain control. Microsoft developed the and the Logical Observation Identifiers Names and Codes
Health Vault, an e-health safe, acting as an EMR. In Holland (LOINC) codes or the International Classification of Dis-
the Radboud University Medical Center collaborated with eases-9 (ICD9) and ICD10 codes. Among the things that the
Philips and Salesforce on HereIsMyData, a database where data analysis should provide is the means to continuously
patients can store their health data and determine who can update the annotations based on acquired knowledge, while
access them [22]. The role of Salesforce is interesting. The keeping the location of the data in place.
Salesforce platform powers Veeva, the customer relationship The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) have
management (CRM) now widely used in pharma. This posi- vast stores of billing data that can be mined to promote high
value care; the same is true of private health insurers. And easy to connect devices and perform device management
hospitals have attempted to reduce re-admission rates by functions, scaled through cloud-based services, and to apply
targeting patients where predictive artificial intelligence (AI) analytics to gain insight and achieve organizational transfor-
algorithms indicate people who may be at highest risk based mation.
on an analysis of available data collected from existing pa- (2) Easy device management: A thoughtful approach to
tient records (Figure 3). device management enables improved asset availability,
Underlying these and many other potential uses, however, increased throughput, minimized unplanned outages and
are a series of technology, legal and ethical challenges relat- reduced maintenance costs.
ing to, among other things, privacy, discrimination, intellec- (3) Information ingestion: Intelligently transform and store
tual property, tort, and informed consent, as well as research IoT data. APIs bridge the divide between the data and the
and clinical ethics [24]. cloud, making it easy to pull in the data that’s needed. Data
is ingested from diverse data sources and platforms, then the
V. Challenges for mIoT essential values are extracted using rich analytics.
(4) Informative analytics: Gain insight from huge volumes
Leading IoT platforms must provide simple, powerful ap- of IoT data to make better decisions and optimize opera-
plication access to IoT devices and data to help designers tions. Apply real-time analytics to monitor current condi-
rapidly compose analytics applications, visualization dash- tions and respond accordingly. Leverage cognitive analytics
boards and mIoT apps. The following are 5 key capabilities with both structured and unstructured data to understand
that leading platforms must enable: situations, reason through options, and learn as conditions
(1) Simple connectivity: A good IoT platform makes it change. An intuitive dashboard makes it all easy to under-
Clinical data
EHR data
Molecular omics data
Wearables data
Medical apps
developers
Squared error
Correlations
ID causes and effects Accuracy
Linear regression
Machine Likelihood
Probability
learning Cost/utility
Pattern recognition Real-time data Simulation
Recursive
Markov chain monte carlo Neural networks Symbolic artificial intelligence
Random forests Gradient descent Agent-based models
Recommender systems Cellular automata
Neural networks Discrete event simulation
Logistic regression
Data
visualization
Figure 3. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) data system.
care industry is the remote health monitoring system, where kinet 2013;52(10):833-54.
patients can be monitored and advised from anywhere. 6. Flores M, Glusman G, Brogaard K, Price ND, Hood L.
Real-time location services are another major approach IoT P4 medicine: how systems medicine will transform the
offers. By using the service, doctors can easily track device healthcare sector and society. Per Med 2013;10(6):565-76.
locations, which directly reduces excess time spent. Smart- 7. van Uem JM, Maier KS, Hucker S, Scheck O, Hobert
phone usage is increasing rapidly, and people have started MA, Santos AT, et al. Twelve-week sensor assessment
using mobile apps for almost everything. When it comes to in Parkinson’s disease: impact on quality of life. Mov
the healthcare industry, mobile apps can improve communi- Disord 2016 May 31 [Epub]. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/
cations between patients and doctors over a secured connec- mds.26676.
tion. 8. Dzubur E, Li M, Kawabata K, Sun Y, McConnell R, Intil-
The primary duty of Digital Health Advisors and the clini- le S, et al. Design of a smartphone application to monitor
cians will be to work collaboratively when the organization is stress, asthma symptoms, and asthma inhaler use. Ann
shifting towards IoT-enabled infrastructure. Proper training Allergy Asthma Immunol 2015;114(4):341-2.e2.
and feedback are mandatory for better deployment. The tra- 9. European Commission. Clinical trials - regulation EU
ditional method of recording a patient’s details, i.e., a pad of No 536/2014 [Internet]. Brussels: European Commis-
paper hanging on the patient’s bed, is not going to work any- sion; c2016 [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Available from: http://
more, since such records are only accessible to a limited few, ec.europa.eu/health/human-use/clinical-trials/regula-
and can be lost or scrambled. This is an application where tion/index_en.htm.
on-field mobile/tablet technology might work, since they of- 10. INNT Foundation [Internet]. Amsterdam: INNT
fer hassle-free record management on the applications in the Foundation; c2016 [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Available from:
device. Health data information will be available in just a tap https://www.innit.foundation.
when information is recorded electronically, once security 11. MyTomorrows [Internet]. Amsterdam: MyTomorrows;
and privacy issues are met. c2016 [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Available from: https://myto-
morrows.com.
Conflict of Interest 12. Tung CE, Su D, Turakhia MP, Lansberg MG. Diagnostic
yield of extended cardiac patch monitoring in patients
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was with stroke or TIA. Front Neurol 2015;5:266.
reported. 13. Famm K, Litt B, Tracey KJ, Boyden ES, Slaoui M. Drug
discovery: a jump-start for electroceuticals. Nature
References 2013;496(7444):159-61.
14. Cuba-Gyllensten I, Gastelurrutia P, Riistama J, Aarts R,
1. Zanella A, Bui N, Castellani A, Vangelista L, Zorzi M. Nunez J, Lupon J, et al. A novel wearable vest for track-
Internet of things for smart cities. IEEE Internet Things ing pulmonary congestion in acutely decompensated
J 2014;1(1):22-32. heart failure. Int J Cardiol 2014;177(1):199-201.
2. Bauer H, Patel M, Veira J. The Internet of Things: sizing 15. Senior M. Novartis signs up for Google smart lens. Nat
up the opportunity [Internet]. New York (NY): McK- Biotechnol 2014;32(9):856.
insey & Company; c2016 [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Avail- 16. MyDario.com [Internet]. Burlington (MA): MyDario.
able from: http://www.mckinsey.com/industries/high- com; c2016 [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Available from: http://
tech/our-insights/the-internet-of-things-sizing-up-the- mydario.com/.
opportunity. 17. SleepBot [Internet]. New York (NY): SleepBot; c2013
3. Kruse CS, Kothman K, Anerobi K, Abanaka L. Adop- [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Available from: https://mysleepbot.
tion factors of the electronic health record: a systematic com/.
review. JMIR Med Inform 2016;4(2):e19. 18. RANKED Health [Internet]. [place unknown: publisher
4. Scheen AJ. Precision medicine: the future in diabetes unknown]; [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Available from: http://
care? Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2016;117:12-21. www.rankedhealth.com/about/.
5. van Leeuwen N, Swen JJ, Guchelaar HJ, 't Hart LM. The 19. Canary Health [Internet]. Los Angeles (CA): Canary
role of pharmacogenetics in drug disposition and re- Health Inc.; c2016 [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Available from:
sponse of oral glucose-lowering drugs. Clin Pharmaco- http://www.canaryhealth.com/.
20. Sepah SC, Jiang L, Peters AL. Long-term outcomes of a 24. Filkins BL, Kim JY, Roberts B, Armstrong W, Miller MA,
Web-based diabetes prevention program: 2-year results Hultner ML, et al. Privacy and security in the era of digi-
of a single-arm longitudinal study. J Med Internet Res tal health: what should translational researchers know
2015;17(4):e92. and do about it? Am J Transl Res 2016;8(3):1560-80.
21. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Lifestyle 25. Hackl WO. Intelligent re-use of nursing routine data:
change program details [Internet]. Atlanta (GA): Cen- opportunities and challenges. Stud Health Technol In-
ters for Disease Control and Prevention; c2016 [cited form 2016;225:727-8.
at 2016 Jul 1]. Available from: http://www.cdc.gov/dia- 26. Foley P, Steinberg D, Levine E, Askew S, Batch BC,
betes/prevention/lifestyle-program/experience/index. Puleo EM, et al. Track: a randomized controlled trial of
html. a digital health obesity treatment intervention for medi-
22. HereIsMyData [Internet]. Nijmegen: Radboud Universi- cally vulnerable primary care patients. Contemp Clin
ty Medical Center; c2015 [cited at 2016 Jul 1]. Available Trials 2016;48:12-20.
from: http://www.hereismydata.com/. 27. Giraldo-Rodriguez L, Torres-Castro S, Martinez-Ramirez
23. Auffray C, Balling R, Barroso I, Bencze L, Benson M, D, Gutierrez-Robledo LM, Perez-Cuevas R. Tele-care and
Bergeron J, et al. Making sense of big data in health re- tele-alarms for the elderly: preliminary experiences in
search: towards an EU action plan. Genome Med 2016; Mexico. Rev Saude Publica 2013;47(4):711-7.
8(1):71.