Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 83 views

    Literary Criticism As A Tool For Interpreting Literature

    Uploaded by

    Juliet Ardales
    The document discusses literary criticism and how it can be used to interpret literature. It defines literary criticism and explains that criticism can help readers develop their own interpretations of works. The document provides guidance on how and when to incorporate criticism into analyses of literary works.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Literary Criticism As A Tool For Interpreting Literature

    Uploaded by

    Juliet Ardales
    83 views4 pages
    The document discusses literary criticism and how it can be used to interpret literature. It defines literary criticism and explains that criticism can help readers develop their own interpretations of works. The document provides guidance on how and when to incorporate criticism into analyses of literary works.

    Original Title

    Literary Criticism as a Tool for Interpreting Literature

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document discusses literary criticism and how it can be used to interpret literature. It defines literary criticism and explains that criticism can help readers develop their own interpretations of works. The document provides guidance on how and when to incorporate criticism into analyses of literary works.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    83 views4 pages

    Literary Criticism As A Tool For Interpreting Literature

    Uploaded by

    Juliet Ardales
    The document discusses literary criticism and how it can be used to interpret literature. It defines literary criticism and explains that criticism can help readers develop their own interpretations of works. The document provides guidance on how and when to incorporate criticism into analyses of literary works.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 4

    Literary Criticism as a Tool for Interpreting

    Literature
    What Is Interpretation?
    In general, to interpret something is to make it personally meaningful. Our brain takes
    raw data from the senses and makes it meaningful by relating it to our previous
    experiences. We may, for example, respond to a loud noise by saying "That sounded
    like a gunshot." When we read or hear a sentence, we put the words together into a
    meaningful whole, rather than just noting their separate dictionary definitions. Most
    everyday language is fairly straightforward and requires little interpretation. A liberal
    and a conservative who read a newspaper editorial against the death penalty may
    disagree with each other on that particular issue, but (unless the editorial is badly
    written) they will agree that the writer is against capital punishment. That is, they
    won't have different interpretations of what the article means. Language usually
    requires special interpretation, however, when it is ambiguous or unclear. In order to
    clarify a sarcastic statement, for example, we may ask a question like "What did you
    mean by that remark?" or "Are you serious?" Because literature (other than
    propaganda) presents us with more than one possible meaning, interpreting literature
    requires more care and attention than does responding to an essay. Approaching
    literature with an inquiring attitude helps maintain this fruitful complexity.

    What Kinds of Questions Help with Interpretation?


    Specific questions that allow only one answer (like "What is the main character's
    nickname?") may enable a teacher to see if a student has read or studied a story, but
    they rarely challenge the reader to see beyond the plot level. Because they respect the
    complexity of your own experience and the author's vision, open-ended questions are
    much more useful. After seeing the film Schindler's List, in which the protagonist
    changes from a greedy businessman to the compassionate savior of over a thousand
    Jews in Nazi-held Poland, you might ask "How and why does Schindler change?" Or
    you might reflect on your own values: "How would I react in this situation?" Clearly
    there is no single answer for this kind of question, and your answer may change each
    time you read or think about the work.

    Why Should We Interpret Literature?


    Although the interpretation of literature can be challenging, it may also provide
    unique and important rewards. Authors of fiction, poetry, or drama choose literature
    for their expression because they believe that there are at least two valid sides to any
    major issue--not just a simple right and wrong. Reading and interpreting literature,
    then, nourishes us with a sense of the complexity of life's deepest mysteries-- love,
    hate, death, conflicts between the individual and society, and so on--so that when we
    approach these problems we do so with greater self-awareness and greater tolerance
    for the views of others. We may react angrily to a news feature about physically
    abused children, but when we read a story like James Joyce's "Counterparts" we are
    asked to understand (without necessarily excusing such an action) the reasons why an
    adult would hit a harmless child. When we interpret literature at this level, we are
    taking what we already know about human nature and adding in the experience and
    wisdom of the author (even if we don't share all of the author's convictions).
    Interpretation then is a social act--we bring to it all of our past experiences with
    people, and we come away with an even richer, more complex understanding.

    What Is Literary Criticism?


    Literary criticism is an extension of this social activity of interpreting. One reader
    writes down his or her views on what a particular work of literature means so that
    others can respond to that interpretation. The critic's specific purpose may be to make
    value judgements on a work, to explain his or her interpretation of the work, or to
    provide other readers with relevant historical or biographical information. The critic's
    general purpose, in most cases, is to enrich the reader's understanding of the literary
    work. Critics typically engage in dialogue or debate with other critics, using the views
    of other critics to develop their own points. Unfortunately, when critics assume that
    their readers are already familiar with previous criticism, the argument may be
    difficult to follow.

    Why Is Criticism Important for Students?


    As a reader of literature, you may find the views of others very helpful in developing
    your own interpretations. When you write an essay about literature, you will also find
    criticism helpful for supporting your points. But criticism should never be a substitute
    for your own original views--only in very rare cases would an assignment require you
    to summarize a critical work without including your interpretation of the literature.
    Besides being useful, good literary criticism can be fun in itself, like listening to and
    participating in a lively discussion among friends. By reading the critic, you add yet
    another point of view to yours and the author's.

    Is All Literary Criticism Valid?


    Certainly if a critic has added to your appreciation of a literary work, then that person
    has been useful. But as you read a variety of criticism on a given author, you will
    discover that some criticism more useful than others, and you may find some
    completely useless, particularly if it only summarizes the plot, focuses on an issue
    you're not interested in, concentrates too much on other critics or theories and not on
    the literature itself, or uses an unnecessarily technical vocabulary. As in all fields,
    there are those whose main goal seems to be to confuse or impress rather than to
    communicate. Still, an article or book that at first seems difficult or irrelevant may be
    very valuable in supporting your opinion once you see the overall picture. Since your
    goal in reading the article is to enrich your view, you may find only part of the
    argument valid, and you may even challenge the views of other critics as a means of
    explaining and developing your own views.

    When Do I Use Criticism?


    Occasionally, you may want to begin with some preliminary literary research to make
    sure that there is enough critical commentary available, particularly if you're
    considering writing about a recent author. You may also want to basic overview or
    article in a reference work before beginning to read and interpret a particularly
    difficult work. Nevertheless, it's usually best not to worry about literary criticism until
    you've already developed your own basic interpretation of the work. If you later find a
    critic who arrives at the same conclusion you've reached, you can still use that critic as
    support. Remember that the main purpose of your writing is to express and support
    your views on the original literature, not to quote as many critics as possible.

    How Do I Incorporate Literary Criticism into My Paper?


    Just as it's usually best to read criticism after you've developed your own views, so do
    you normally refer to or quote criticism after you've expressed an idea of your own. A
    typical paragraph may consist of a topic sentence (expressing a portion or subtopic of
    your interpretation), followed by an elaboration of the idea, a reference to or brief
    quote from the work that you're analyzing, an explanation of how this passage
    illustrates your point, a quote or reference from a critic on this passage (or a similar
    one), and perhaps a brief discussion of the critic's comments. In our reader, Literature
    and Ourselves, you'll find several casebooks, containing essays about works of
    literature (the casebooks are on gray pages). Each casebook has a student essay that
    uses literary criticism for support. Notice how the most important part of every
    student paper is the student's own ideas--the criticism is used within the body
    paragraphs to support the student's ideas. Although there is no single best way to
    incorporate literary criticism into our paper, it would be unusual to base a long section
    of your paper solely on quotations or paraphrases from others.
    How to Find Literary Criticism
    You'll probably start your search with an index or bibliography that targets the
    humanities. An all-purpose index like the Reader's Guide to Periodical Literature does
    include articles about literature, but these tend to be reviews from popular magazines.
    The two most useful indexes are the Humanities Index and the MLA Bibliography,
    which are available both in book form and electronically.

    Book Form vs. Electronic Form


    Although simpler, searching through books rather than computer databases has
    several disadvantages. First, since print indexes consist of separate quarterly or annual
    volumes, you have to repeat the same search many times. A computer database may
    let you search through 10-20 years of indexes by entering a single command or search
    word. Book indexes have rather limited subject headings, while computer databases
    let you choose not only subject but also key words (which are much less restrictive
    than subject headings). Computer searches also let you combine subjects and key
    words. For example, if you were using a print index to find material on flower
    imagery in Shakespeare's poetry, you might have to browse through all articles and
    books on Shakespeare's poetry (perhaps as many as 50 per year). A computer search,
    on the other hand, would allow you to type in Shakespeare and poetry and flower to
    find only the relevant information. Still there are times when you may need to use
    print indexes (or a combination of electronic and print), particularly if the electronic
    version does not go back far enough in time to cover enough major criticism.

    This essay by Steven Hale, Humanities Division, DeKalb College.


    Last updated 3-4-97. Return to Handouts page
    Home

    Página creada y actualizada por grupo "mmm".


         Para cualquier cambio, sugerencia,etc. contactar con: [email protected]
         © a.r.e.a./Dr.Vicente Forés López
          Universitat de València Press
        Creada: 15/09/2000 Última Actualización: 18/06/2001

    You might also like