Bencana Kabut Asap

Kebijakan Terkait Kabut Asap di Riau

USULAN HIBAH PENELITIAN UNGGULANUNIVERSITAS

ABDURRAB

DEMAND AND SUPPORT FROM CIVIL SOCIETY

ORGANIZATIONS (CSOS) FOR THE HAZE-FREE ASEAN 2020:
EVIDENCES FROM RIAU

Tim Peneliti

Ketua : Alfajri, S.IP., MIA 1022098303

Anggota : Azhari Setiawan, S.IP., M.Si 1028049302
Anggota : Herry Wahyudi, S.IP., M.A 1021129002

Sumber Dana: Universitas Abdurrab Tahun 2019

LEMBAGA PENELITIAN DAN PENGABDIAN KEPADA

MASYARAKAT UNIVERSITAS ABDURRAB

TAHUN 2019
 HALAMAN PENGESAHAN
Tema Penelitian : Bencana Kabut Asap
Judul Penelitian : Demand and Support from Civil Society
Organizations (CSOs) for the Haze-free ASEAN 2020:
Evidences from Riau
Ketua Tim
a. Nama Lengkap : Alfajri, S.IP., MIA.
b. NIK dan NIDN : 64.201.0815050/1022098303
c. Jabatan Fungsional : Asisten Ahli
d. Program Studi : Ilmu Hubungan Internasional
e. No. HP : 082112430385
f. Alamat Surat (email) : [email protected]
Anggota
a. Nama Lengkap : Azhari Setiawan, S.IP., M.Si
b. NIK dan NIDN : 64.201.1217051/1028049302
c. Jabatan Fungsional : Tenaga Pengajar
d. Program Studi : Ilmu Hubungan Internasional
Anggota
a. Nama Lengkap : Herry Wahyudi, S.IP., M.A
b. NIK dan NIDN : 64.201.1217051/1021129002
c. Jabatan Fungsional : Tenaga Pengajar
d. Program Studi : Ilmu Hubungan Internasional
Lamanya Kegiatan : 6 (enam) Bulan
Biaya Diajukan : Rp. 15,000,000.-
Sumber Dana : Hibah Yayasan, LPPM Universitas Abdurrab
Pekanbaru, 12 Mei 2019
Mengetahui
Dekan Fakultas Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik Ketua Peneliti,

Tengku Fahrul Gafar, S.IP., M.Si. Alfajri, S.IP., MIA.

NIK. 64.201.0115001 NIK. 64.201.0815050

Menyetujui,
Ketua LPPM Universitas Abdurrab

dr. May Valzon, M.Sc.

NIK. 112.010.109.003
 ABSTRACT

Riau is one of the most forest and land fire-prone Provinces in Indonesia.
These forest and land fires cause haze pollution affecting not only Riau, but also the
South East Asian region. Even though Indonesia had ratified the ASEAN Agreement
on Transboundary Haze Pollution (AATHP) in September 2014, the haze pollution in
2015 by forest and land fires had proven that the AATHP regime was ineffective to
tackle the haze issues in Indonesia, particularly in Riau. Relatively less forest and
land fires and haze pollution in Riau (also across the nation) in 2016 and 2017 was by
no means due to the implementation of the AATHP regime nor by the Riau Province
government policies, rather it is believed to be due to the heavy rainy season during
those last two years. This research applies David Easton’s theory of decision making
which belongs to the approach of behavioralist. This article aims to discuss how the
Easton’s behavioralist theory connects situated responses with outside pressure to
change government policies and local practices.

The findings in this research show that the outside pressure has not yet
provided significant change to the Riau government policies and local practices
regarding land and forest fires as well as haze pollutions issues. However, there are
actually greater opportunities that the outside pressure may create sustainable
collaboration with the local government and society to resolve these transboundary
issues in the short- and long-term periods. This sustainable collaboration extends in
multi aspects spanning from law, social, health, economy, education and even
security.

Keywords: Riau, Haze-free, ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution

(AATHP), Multi-aspect Collaboration.
 CONTENTS

HALAMAN PENGESAHAN........................................................................................i
ABSTRACT..................................................................................................................ii
CONTENTS.................................................................................................................iii
TABLE AND DIAGRAM LIST..................................................................................iv
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION...................................................................................1
1.1 Background..........................................................................................................1
1.2 Problem Statement...............................................................................................3
1.3 Research Objectives.............................................................................................3
1.4 Research Outputs.................................................................................................4
CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW........................................................................5
2.1 Theoretical Framework........................................................................................5
2.2 Previous Researches.............................................................................................9
CHAPTER 3 RESEARCH METHODS......................................................................13
3.1 Research Type and Source of Data....................................................................13
3.2 Collecting Data Technique................................................................................13
3.3 Data Analysis Model..........................................................................................14
3.4 Research Time and Location.............................................................................15
CHAPTER 4 RESEARCH BUDGET AND TIME SCHEDULE...............................16
4.1 Budget................................................................................................................16
4.2 Research Time Schedule....................................................................................16
BIBLIOGRAPHY.......................................................................................................17
APPENDIX.................................................................................................................18
 TABLE AND DIAGRAM LIST

Table 1.1 Achievement Target Plan of Action

Table 1.2 The Study of Transboundary Haze from the Local to International Level
Diagram 2.1 David Easton’s Decision-Making Theory
Diagram 2.2 Riau Government Decision Making
Diagram 2.3 Sequences of Riau Government Policies
 CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background

ASEAN has set a roadmap to achieve a haze-free region in 2020 (Roadmap,

2016). However, looking at the imminent time that the ASEAN has set to reach its’
target-two years from now-it is very necessary to look closer and deeper at one
Province that has suffered from land and forest fires in Indonesia in the past few
decades. It is the Riau Province that is in the middle of Sumatera Island that has a
large amount of peatland area, an estimated of about 4,360,740 million hectares of the
nearly 9 million hectares of the land that it has (Alfajri & Luerdi, 2016). Riau consists
of two municipals and ten districts and is very close to two ASEAN neighbouring
countries, Malaysia and Singapore. Due to this proximity, any terrible forest and land
fires that happen in Riau usually affect those two countries.

Haze pollution caused by forest and land fires in which most of the time
followed by peatland fires in Riau Province has more than a couple decades issue.
The notable land and forest fires case in Riau Province prior to a major outbreak in
2015 was the 1997 forest and land fires, affected several ASEAN countries (Pakar:
Asap Riau 2014). Meanwhile, in 2015 together with several Kalimantan and
Sumatera provinces, Riau forest and land fires haze pollution had reached far beyond
Malaysia and Singapore as the regular affected countries, reaching Thailand, Brunei,
Philippines, Vietnam and even Cambodia (Sarmiento, 2015). The haze issue in Riau
has received serious attention from local, national and the international community
since several years ago, particularly after the 1997 land and forest fires. However, for
Singaporeans, this haze issue was not new, it had affected them since 1972 and 1977
when their country was blanketed with haze suspected from Palembang and Sumatera
Island (where Riau, Jambi and Palembang are located) respectively (Haze in
Singapore, 2015).

Even though the haze unresolved problem was not a new one, particularly in
the Riau Province, the issue seemed to be forgotten until a series of quite recent
raging forest and land fires that took placed in 2013, 2014 and peaked in 2015. Riau,
Palembang and Jambi once again became a spotlight in the media together with
several other provinces in Kalimantan. Not only in the regional media, but these three
consecutive years (2013, 2014 and 2015) haze outbreak had become a global media
outcry, from Russia to South Africa, from United States to Australia (Singapore
Smoke, 2013; Smog Returns; Aw, 2015; Malaysia Closes, 2013). The 2015 land and
forest fires, where Riau also contributed to, was estimated as having the highest
losses, even compared to the 1997, with a total of 200 Billion Rupiah (Lestari, 2015)
and caused 19 loss of lives where 5 of them resided in the Riau Province (Akuntono,
2015, Haryanto, 2016). Going into 2016, 2017 and 2018 to lesser amount of degree,
the land and forest fires still took place in the Riau Province, although it did not cause
a global or regional outcry as the haze remained polluting Riau Province only without
or slightly touching Malaysia and Singapore as its’ regular victim (Warsito, 2018;
Safutra, 2017; Jerome, 2016).

Looking at this unresolved issued, regional and international community

might ask the question, what has really been done by the local Government to
overcome this perennial problem and to achieve the ASEAN haze-free 2020? Due to
strong outside (overseas) pressure and national outcry, the 2013 and 2014 haze
outbreak had pushed the Riau Government to issue the 2015 Gubernatorial
Regulation, Number 5 which include several key activities. In 2018, the Riau
Governor also has signed the local (provincial) regulation number 10, 2018 regarding
Riau Province Spatial Plans. However, this effort also gained critic from local civil
society organization, Jikalahari, stating this regulation was not in line with higher
regulation, elite business-pro and do not portrait serious effort to ensure the protection
of ecology governance (Yugo, 2018). Hence, the legalization of these two local-level
policies has not yet become a long-term or short-term solution. Therefore, this
research tries to look at this problem from CSOs perspective using the David Easton
theory. How far is the effectiveness of the demand and support that have been done
by CSOs, including outside pressure to influence the Government policy? Also, this
research offers other solutions, in addition to what have been done to meet clear
objectives or solutions either in short- or long-term projection. Thus, this research
discusses further details regarding what the ASEAN haze-free may look like in the
next two years from now as targeted in 2020.

1.2 Problem Statement

Top map the discourses and dig the narrations up to the ground, we have
prepared some key questions, which are:

1. What are the factors that have been the major causes of haze problems in
Indonesia, especially the Riau Province, from CSOs and other related parties
point of view?

2. How is CSOs perspectives toward ASEAN Haze-free roadmap 2020?

3. To what extent, the Government’s (central, provinces, and districts) efforts to

achieve ASEAN Haze-free Roadmap 2020?

4. What are CSOs recommendations to solve the land fire, haze crisis, and
generally other aspects on sustainable developments agenda?

5. What are CSOs challenges and obstacles on fighting for haze problem solving
and other environmental issues?

1.3 Research Objectives

The research tries to look at this problem from CSOs perspective using the
David Easton theory. How far is the effectiveness of the demand and support that
have been done by CSOs, including outside pressure to influence the Government
policy? Also, this research offers other solutions, in addition to what have been done
to meet clear objectives or solutions either in short- or long-term projection. Thus,
this research discusses further details regarding what the ASEAN haze-free may look
like in the next two years from now as targeted in 2020.

1.4 Research Outputs

The output of this research is a publication which is projected to be published

in International Journal Publication. The results of this study are also projected as
teaching materials related to the research on haze-related issues. The research team
will deliver and present the results of the research on international level scientific
conference. The outputs in detail are in the following 'Achievement Target Plan'
Table 1.1.

Table 1.1 Achievement Target Plan of Action

No Output Type Indicator

1 Publication in international journal MJIR Published
Presenter or panelist at academic International Executed
2
conference National Executed
3 Teaching or lectures materials Draft
 CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 Theoretical Framework

The theory used in this study is the analysis of the political system proposed
by David Easton with the behavioralist approach. The analysis of the political system
described by Easton is a decision-making theory that can be applied from the local,
national to international levels. Easton's analysis explains the concepts of demand and
support, the political system (the behavior or actions of the authorized actors) and
outputs (policies or decisions) for how political systems and structures work. The
research analyzes the sub-national role towards the international issues in the local
context. Local policy and decision-making process then become the main discussion.
By applying David Easton’s Decision-Making Process theory, we aim to explore the
input, process, and the output of the policy regarding haze and haze-related issues that
affected ASEAN region as the international level.

The analysis embraces an asumption that a political system is an individual

unit into which persistent inputs flow (David Easton, 2008: 5). The flowing inputs
guarantee the system to work continuously. The inputs are turned into outputs by the
process in the system, which afterwards influence the system or its environment as
well as the inputs through feedbacks (David Easton, 2008: 5). The illustration of
Easton’s system theory can be described as follow:

Diagram 2.1. David Easton's Decision-Making Theory

 Based on the illustration, this research can explain the decision-making
process that involved the authorized government in the Riau province regarding the
policies made after the AATHP ratification by Indonesia, to realize the goals of the
AATHP as follow:

First, the phenomenon of land (peatland) and forest fires that occurred in Riau
for years to reach the worst situation in 2015 caused severe haze pollution and caused
environmental damage. Many economic and peoples activities are disrupted. Health
problems also afflict children and women, there are even fatalities in this incident.
The school issued a policy to close schools for its students to protect them from
health problems caused by air pollution from haze (Riau Pos, 2016).

Some local pressure groups ranging from non-governmental organizations and

local communities (civil society) such as Walhi, Jikalahari, Riau Melawan Asap, etc
and students movements from various higher education institutions gave pressures to
the local government as a grassroot response to the problem (Riau Aktual, 2016). The
pressures coming from the various groups highly demanded that the governor with
his power immediately issued any policy or decision considered the best way to
tackle the haze due to its intolerable damages. The demands were expressed in many
ways like frequent protests, dialogues and intelectual criticisms in the media. Local
media’s coverages over the haze pollution and its impacts strengthened the demand.
The media’s coverages consistently reported forest and land fires in the province, the
haze and Riau government’s slow responses, even its inability.

The Indonesian central government approving and joining the AATHP also
criticized the local government in handling the fires and haze. The Indonesian
government as the representative of the country in the regional level held national
responsibilities to solve the fires and haze pollution within its territory according to
the articles of the agreement. Therefore, the government of Riau was supposed to take
action seriously regarding the problem. Some ministers and even the president
already visited Riau, which meant another pressure for the local government (The
Jakarta Post, 2014).

Riau annually became one of forest and land fires sources which produced the
haze pollution and potential transboundary haze, which also worried neighboring
countries. Singapore and Malaysia often expressed their disappointments to the
ineffective actions taken by either the Indonesian or Riau government to prevent and
control the land and forest fires. The international criticisms were also demands for
the local government.

Secondly, despite the pressure and demands from NGOs and civil soceity that
were explained earlier, input also came in the form of support from the central
government. The central government hopes that local governments can cooperate and
continue to coordinate in responding to this problem. Cooperation and coordination
are also expected to be able to produce collaborative actions with stakeholders related
to this problem.

Thirdly, both demands and supports were processed in a box-like political

system. The process here was the actor’s action or behavior. Riau government as the
actor in the system considered itself as a part of national unity which had to work
together with its upper-level government mainly in fires reduction, risks management
and possible future prevention within its area by creating or issuing local policicies or
decisions. Those were directed for the purpose of domestic need as well the AATHP
agreement’s realization.

The demands and supports coming from a variety of sides regarding the fires
and haze pollution were necessary to consider into actions so that the local
government kept gaining trust from the people. As an authorized decision maker, the
governor created the plan of action on carrying out the prevention of forest and land
fires as well as raising the statuses of emergency in its area. The former was
integrated in the 2015 Gubernatorial Regulation, Number 5, while the latter was
followed with the inception of a task force on forest and land fires and haze disaster,
an ad hoc body which then fought fires and haze pollution. Those policies were
expected to contribute to the realization the AATHP within its area as demanded by
the people and especially the national government.

The decision making and sequence of the policies can be seen through the
following illustrations respectively:

Diagram 2.2. Riau Government Decision Making Process

Political
system
Demands (local, Decision maker's Policies/decisions
national and regional behavior (Riau (plan of action and
actors' pressures) government/ emergency statuses)
Supports (domestic governor)
and national level)

Inputs Outputs

Diagram 2.3. Sequences of Riau Government Policies

 Signed the AATHP in 2002 in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
ASEAN

Ratified the regime in September 2014 and legalized the ratification in

Indonesia October 2014 through the 2014 Indonesia's Law, Number 26.

Created the plan of action on forest and land fires prevention through the
2015 Gubernatorial Regulation, Number 5.
Riau Raised the local emergency statuses.

In addition, in the case of peatland fires in Riau at the level of local

government policies such as missing links, like an analogy "rubber market law", what
should be sought is absolute responsibility in accordance with the Law and it is
purely from concessions, but always the people and individuals who are blamed,
while concessions are always in a favorable position. Missing links in the case of
peatland expanse can also be seen in the policies of the Riau regional government
regarding the 10/2018 RTRWP regarding the allocation of land space in Riau 2018 –
2038. This policy like there is no synchronous decision and policies between demand
and support in political systems which theorized in Easton’s analysis.

2.2 Previous Researches

The study of transboundary haze spreads out from the “national and regional”
context to the ‘‘policy and mitigation’’ scale and intensity. Therefore, the existing
literature can be mapped by looking at the level of analysis: regional, national, and
local; public issues. This map can be used to analyze the scope of transboundary haze
issues, the level of political context, and the area of study that can be examined in the
future. This article groups international and regional as one category. A specific
phenomenon in a particular state such as in Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore can
be categorized in this group of studies. National level refers to the study in a
particular country or the study that uses country level as the case. Finally, local level
stakeholders, corporations, and civil society groups act as the focus of study.

This research observes 10 journal articles published between 2013 and 2017
by various reputable international journals. They can be categorized into three groups
namely international/regional, national, and local level (public) of analysis. The table
below shows the following result: 4 of the contemporary samples of literature that are
interested in analyzing transboundary haze use international or regional contexts
(ASEAN), either studying this phenomenon worldwide or assessing a particular
region or group of countries. Most of them actually discuss the unique case of
ASEAN mechanisms on transboundary haze. Interestingly, 5 of them focus their
studies on the national or state scale such as policy, public concerns, risks, potential
threats, and so on. Lastly, only 1 of these journals examines the existence of
transboundary haze in the local political context including public health.

Table 2.1. The Study of Transboundary Haze from the Local to International Level

International / Regional National Local (Public)

Gabrielle SIMM, 2016 H. Varkkey, 2013 Nazia Nazeer & Fumitaka

(ASEAN); Sarah Tan Yen (Indonesia); Yuan Lin et.al, Furuoka, 2017 (Public
Ling, 2017 (ASEAN); Janic 2017 (Singapore); Lee Poh Health)
Ser Huay Lee et.al, 2015 Onn, 2013 (Singapore);
(ASEAN); Ku Mohd Tim Forsyth, 2014
Kalkausar Ku Yusof et.al, (Indonesia, Singapore,
2017 (ASEAN) Malaysia); Heilman Daniel,
2015 (Indonesia)

As mentioned earlier, at the international or regional level researchers are

interested in analyzing the AATHP mechanism in ASEAN which can be seen from
the research by Tan and Ling (Tan & Ling, 2017), and there are also researchers who
connect the transboundary haze problem with the causes of disputes mitigation in
regional level and history of deforestation in ASEAN as explained by Kuh Mohd
(Mohd, Ku, Azid, Saiful, & Asrul, 2017). The relationship between local and regional
patron politics in the effort to mitigate transboundary haze can also be seen from the
research by Janice Ser (Ser et al., 2016). Finally, the interesting research at this level
is the journal by Gabriell Simm (Simm, 2017) which analyzes the response to disaster
management in the ASEAN region by comparing several disasters that occured in
ASEAN, such as the 2004 earthquake and tsunami disasters in Indonesia, Malaysia,
and Thailand, cyclon Nargis in Myanmar in 2008, and typhoon Haiyan/Yolanda in
the Philippines in 2013. This study also explains the role of non-state actors in
disaster mitigation efforts in ASEAN.

At the national level there are 5 researches that analyze the condition of
countries in ASEAN in the face of transboundary haze including challenges and
constraints. The challenge of regional political patron relations in Indonesia in an
effort to open new plantation land can be seen in the research by H. Varkkey
(Varkkey, 2014). While the correlation between the environment, especially the
transboundary haze problem on the social and economic aspects in Singapore and
Malaysia, can be seen in the journal by Lin (Lin, Wijedasa, & Chisholm, 2015). Lin
et.al analyzed the effects of transboundary hazards on social and economic activities
in Malaysia and Singapore which resulted in a decline in trends when the haze
disaster occurred. Haze disaster relations with decentralization in Indonesia are
explained by Lee Poh (Lee Poh Onn, 2013). Political analysis related to the analysis
of news frames on transboundary haze cases in Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore is
explained by Tim Forsyth (Forsyth, 2014). Whereas, the reason why Indonesia
ratified AATHP to carry out this mechanism is explained by Heilmann (Heilmann,
2015). Finally, the journal that analyzes at the local (public) level about the
development of regional environmental degradation, institutional capacity, and the
health impacts on transboundary haze can be seen in the journal of Nazzer Nazia
(Nazeer, Baharu, Furuoka, & Baharu, 2017).

This map of the literature has some meaning to this area of study. First, at the
international/regional level the focus of previous research put in the AATHP
mechanism. Secondly, at the national level the focus of previous research has
provided a lot of information and analysis on the political situation of a country in
responding to haze problems to the challenges and constraints of countries in
implementing haze disaster mitigation efforts in each country. Third, at the local /
public level the focus of research is still at the health level, so that the output of
policies that should appear at this level has not been rigidly explained. Lastly, all of
these researches provide information and inspiration for researchers to further analyze
the existence of non-state actors, especially civil society grups, in assessing the
transboundary haze problem along with the role of the groups
 CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH METHODS

3.1 Research Type and Source of Data

Based on the theoretical framework, the research problematizes the input

section of David Easton’s theory which are the demand and support. We explore
CSOs as one of the main sources for the demand and support of Riau Government
decision making process on haze and haze-related issues.

The research could be classified as an explorative research which applies

qualitative analysis approach especially the phenomenology method. Regarding to the
topic, the participants for collecting data process consists of several environmental
civil society organizations (CSOs) in the Riau Province. We invited several
delegations from environmental Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) and
disaster research center (Pusat Studi Bencana) in Riau to conduct a focus group
discussion. FGD was taken place at Universitas Abdurrab, Pekanbaru, Riau Province.
The invited environmental CSOs are Pusat Studi Bencana Universitas Riau (PSB,
Universitas Riau), Wahana Lingkungan Hidup Riau (Walhi Riau), Jaringan Kerja
Penyelamat Hutan Riau (Jikalahari), Forum Indonesia untuk Transparansi Anggaran
(FITRA) Riau, and Himpunan Penggiat Alam (Hipam) Riau.

In this research, the qualitative data refering to the quality of research object
data and non-verbal information were applied to describe the phenomenon of Riau
government’s policies toward haze-related issues. A variety of secondary data
containing relevant information and made analysed materials in this research are
ranged from books, journals, documents and useful articles. So did this research rely
on the information gained from the medium of internet, more than half of which were
national and international websites, since the scope of issue in this research was the
constantly-occuring events in the local context in which the information was
available.

18
3.2 Collecting Data Technique

The method focuses on CSOs perspectives toward Riau Government and the
Haze-Free ASEAN. We discovered the CSOs point of views toward Riau
Government implementation of the AATHP (ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary
Haze Pollution) regime which has been ratified by Indonesia Government into
Undang Undang No. 26 Tahun 2014 as primary sources of data. The outside pressure
has not yet provided significant change to Riau Government policies and local
practices regarding peatland fires and haze pollution issues.

3.3 Data Analysis Model

We assume that there are greater opportunities to enhance a sustainable

collaboration with the local government and society to resolve these transboundary
issues for short- and long-term periods. Our assumptions also deliver an
understanding that the sustainable collaboration extends in multi aspects spanning
from law, social, health, economy, education, and security. The FGDs was conducted
to map discourses that flourish on transboundary haze narrations, especially in Riau
Province as one of the most peatland fire-prone in Indonesia. Our aim
methodologically speaking, is to draw those assumptions and those flourishing
discourses in between. Top map the discourses and dig the narrations up to the
ground, we have prepared some key questions, which are:

1. What are the factors that have been the major causes of haze problems in
Indonesia, especially the Riau Province, from CSOs and other related parties’
point of view?

2. How is CSOs perspectives toward ASEAN Haze-free roadmap 2020?

3. To what extent, the Government’s (central, provinces, and districts) efforts to

achieve ASEAN Haze-free Roadmap 2020?

4. What are CSOs recommendations to solve the land fire, haze crisis, and
generally other aspects on sustainable developments agenda?

19
 5. What are CSOs challenges and obstacles on fighting for haze problem solving
and other environmental issues?

These key questions were delivered to draw an analytical induction and

thematic analysis. The analytical induction was delivered to find the universal
explanation and data exploration. The thematic analysis was delivered to categorize,
qualify, and classify the data into theme clusters which have been extracted from the
theoretical framework.

We also deliver a triangulation toward the data and analysis. The qualitative
data and insights are triangulated with some statistical data (e.g. Palm Oil Plantation,
Pulpwood Concession: Hutan Tanaman Industri: HTI, Licensed Logging
Concessions: Hak Pengusahaan Hutan: HPH), peatland data, fire spots, haze maps
and statistics, etc.) and interviews with some key persons which are relevant to the
topic and problem discussion.

3.4 Research Time and Location

The research mostly will be located in Riau Province. We also have visited
some places in Singapore and Malaysia on collaborating some preliminary studies
and discussions about haze-related issues with our epistemic community on haze-
related issues. Insights and results from the discussion will be added to few parts of
the research to enhance the analysis. As we predict, the research will be conducted for
maximum of six months.

20
 CHAPTER 4
RESEARCH BUDGET AND TIME SCHEDULE

4.1 Budget

No Type of Expense Proposed Cost (Rp)

1 Honorarium 4,500,000.-
2 Research Equipment and 9,000,000.-
Materials
3 Research Trips 4,500,000.-
4 Others 2,250,000.-
Total Expense 15,000,000.-

4.2 Research Time Schedule

N Months
Agenda
o 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th
1 Research Plan Meeting
2 Collecting Data
3 Processing Data
Data Analysis and Research
4
Results
5 Writing Research Report
Research Report Evaluation
6
Meeting
7 Research Report Revision
8 Research Report Submitted
9 Publication Article Submitted
Publication Article Reviewed,
10 Revised, and Scheduled to be
Published

21
 BIBLIOGRAPHY

Forsyth, T. (2014). Public concerns about transboundary haze : a comparison of

Indonesia , Singapore , and Malaysia.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2014.01.013
Heilmann, D. (2015). After Indonesia’s Ratification: The ASEAN Agreement on
Transboundary Haze Pollution and Its Effectiveness As a Regional
Environmental Governance Tool. Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs,
34, 3, 95–121.
Lee Poh Onn. (2013). No end in sight to haze dilemma. ISEAS Perspective, 39.
Lin, Y., Wijedasa, L. S., & Chisholm, R. A. (2015). Singapore ’ s willingness to pay
for mitigation of transboundary forest-fire haze from Indonesia Singapore ’ s
willingness to pay for mitigation of transboundary forest-fire haze from
Indonesia. (June 2013).
Mohd, K., Ku, K., Azid, A., Saiful, M., & Asrul, M. (2017). An overview of
transboundary haze studies : The underlying causes and regional disputes on
Southeast Asia Region An overview of transboundary haze studies : The
underlying causes and regional disputes on Southeast Asia region.
(December). https://doi.org/10.11113/mjfas.v0n0.719
Nazeer, N., Baharu, J. P., Furuoka, F., & Baharu, J. P. (2017). OVERVIEW OF
ASEAN ENVIRONMENT , TRANSBOUNDARY HAZE POLLUTION
AGREEMENT. 13(1), 73–94.
Ser, J., Lee, H., Jaafar, Z., Khee, A., Tan, J., Carrasco, L. R., … Pin, L. (2016).
Environmental Science & Policy Toward clearer skies : Challenges in
regulating transboundary haze in Southeast Asia. Environmental Science and
Policy, 55, 87–95. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2015.09.008
Simm, G. (2017). Disaster Response in Southeast Asia : The ASEAN Agreement on
Disaster Response and Emergency Management. (December 2005), 1–27.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S2044251316000205
Tan, S., & Ling, Y. (2017). The ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze
Pollution : exploring mediation as a way forward. 20, 138–161.
Varkkey, H. (2014). Regional cooperation , patronage and the ASEAN Agreement on
transboundary haze pollution. 65–81. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10784-013-
9217-2

22
APPENDIX

23
24
 Lampiran 1. Justifikasi Anggaran Penelitian

1. Honorarium
N Jenis Pengeluaran Honor/Jam (Rp) Waktu Minggu Honor per
o (Jam/Minggu) Tahun
1 Ketua 85,000 1 25 2,125,000
2 Anggota 1 47,500 1 25 1,187,500
3 Anggota 2 47,500 1 25 1,187,500
SUB TOTAL 4,500,000
2. Bahan Habis Pakai dan Peralatan
N Material Justifikasi Pembelian Kuantitas Harga Satuan Harga Peralatan
o (Rp)
ATK
1 Kertas HVS A4 5 40,000 200,000
2 Booklet Bahan Penelitian 3 56,000 168,000
3 Alat Tulis 3 20,000 60,000
4 Staples 1 16,000 16,000
5 Pin Penjepit 6 20,000 120,000
Cetak dan Fotocopy
1 Cetak Bahan 50 Lembar 30 Bahan 1500 200 300,000
2 Cetak Laporan 30 Lembar 6 Laporan 180 200 36,000
3 Fotokopi Laporan 30 Lembar 5 Laporan 150 200 30,000
4 Jilid Hard Cover 6 Jilid 6 15,000 90,000
Laptop
1 Sewa Laptop Analisis Data 3 250,000 750,000
Komunikasi
1 Pulsa dan Data Internet 3 Orang per Bulan 18 110000 1,980,000
SUB TOTAL 3,750,000
3. Biaya Perjalanan dan Akomodasi
N Material Justifikasi Pembiayaan Kuantitas Harga Satuan Biaya
o (Rp)

25
1 Biaya Perjalanan Pengumpulan Data 3 Orang 3 Hari 9 150000 1,350,000
2 Akomodasi-Konsumsi Pengumpul Data 2 Orang 3 Hari 6 150000 900,000
3 Akomodasi-Konsumsi Rapat Kerja 3 Orang 5x Rapat 15 150000 2,250,000
SUB TOTAL 4,500,000
4. Biaya Lainnya
N Jenis Pengeluaran Justifikasi Penggunaan Kuantitas Harga Satuan Biaya
o (Rp)
1 Publikasi Jurnal Internasional 2,250,000 1 2,250,000
SUB TOTAL 2,250,000
TOTAL ANGGARAN YANG DIPERLUKAN 15,000,000

26
Lampiran 2. Biodata Ketua dan Anggota

Ketua

Identitas Diri

1 Nama Lengkap Alfajri, S.IP., MIA.

2 Jenis Kelamin Laki-Laki
3 Jabatan Fungsional Asisten Ahli
4 NIK. 64.201.0815050
5 NIDN. 1022098303
6 Tempat dan Tanggal Lahir Lubuk Bendahara, 22 September 1983
7 e-mail [email protected]
8 Nomor Telepon/HP 082112430385
9 Alamat Kantor Universitas Abdurrab, Jl. Riau Ujung, No. 73,
Pekanbaru
10 Nomor Telepon/Faks -
11 Lulusan yang telah 21
dihasilkan
12 Mata Kuliah yang diampu Resolusi Konflik dan Keamanan Global
Negosiasi dan Diplomasi
Politik Ekologi

Riwayat Pendidikan

S1 S2 S3
Nama Perguruan Universitas Riau Australian
Tinggi National
University
Bidang Ilmu Ilmu Hubungan Asia Pacific
Internasional Studies
Tahun Masuk-Lulus 2002-2007
Judul Kebijakan Iran Course Work
Skripsi/Tesis/Disertasi Melanjutkan
Program
Pengembangan
Nuklir di bawah
Tekanan AS
2005-2007
Nama Dr. Mhd. Saeri, -
Pembimbing/Promotor M.Hum.

27
Pengalaman Penelitian dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

Pendanaan
No Tahun Judul Penelitian
Sumber Jml (Juta Rp)
1 2017 Sinergitas Pembangunan di Kementerian 30,000,000.-
Provinsi Riau Guna Menghadapi Pertahanan
Ancaman Non-Militer dalam Republik
Rangka Mendukung Indonesia
Penyelenggaraan Pertahanan
Negara
2 2016 Riau Government’s Policies to LPPM Univrab 5,000,000.-
Realize the AATHP’s Goals
(2015-2016)
3 2015 Civil Society as Precursor and LPPM Univrab 5,000,000.-
Consequence of Democracy
4 2018 Operasi Kontra Teror Koalisi LPPM Univrab 5,000,000.-
Global dalam Menghadapi
Pergerakan Islamic States of
Iraq and Syiria (ISIS)

Pengalaman Pengabdian Masyarakat dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

Pendanaan
No Tahun Judul Pengabdian Masyarakat
Sumber Jml (Juta Rp)
1 2017 Pemberdayaan Turas Sustairable LPPM Univrab 4
Development Globals (SDGs)
tingkat SMA/MA sederajat di
Pekanbaru: tujuan No.11 dan 12
(masalah sampah Pekanbaru)
2 2017 FGD Mewaspadai Ancaman Kemhan RI Riau 30
Non-Militer di Propinsi Riau
3 2016 Peningkatan Partisipasi LPPM Univrab 4
Kesadaran dan Kewaspadaan
Masyarakat terhadap Ancaman
Human Security Akibat
Kejahatan Bencana Asap di
Desa Suka Damai, Kabupaten
Rokan Hulu

Publikasi Artikel Ilmiah dalam Jurnal dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

28
 N
Judul Artikel Ilmiah Nama Jurnal Vol/No/Tahun
o
1 Civil Society as Precursor and International Society Agustus/2015
Consequence of Democracy
2 Sinergitas Pembangunan Tata Global & Strategis Vol. 13, No. 1,
Ruang Pertahanan Daerah 2019
dalam Menghadapi Ancaman
Non-Militer di Indonesia
3 Turkey’s Foreign Policy Jurnal Hubungan Vol. 7, No. 1,
Strategy Change in Syrian Internasional UMY 2018
Crisis (2016-2017)

Pemakalah Seminar Ilmiah dalam Jurnal dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

N Waktu dan
Nama Temu Ilmiah/Seminar Judul Artikel Ilmiah
o Tempat
1 Prosiding Seminar Hasil Peningkatan Partisipasi 2016, Pekanbaru
Pengabdian Masyarakat Kesadaran dan
(SHPPA) Universitas Kewaspadaan
Abdurrab Masyarakat terhadap
Ancaman Human
SecurityAkibat
Kejahatan Bencana Asap
di Desa Suka Damai,
Kabupaten Rokan Hulu
2 Prosiding Seminar Hasil Riau Government’s 2016, Pekanbaru
Penelitian (SHPPA) Policies to Realize the
Universitas Abdurrab AATHP’s Goals (2015-
2016)
3 FGD Sinergitas Sinergitas Pembangunan 2016, Pekanbaru
Pembangunan di Provinsi di Provinsi Riau Guna
Riau Guna Menghadapi Menghadapi Ancaman
Ancaman Non-Militer dalam Non-Militer dalam
Rangka Mendukung Rangka Mendukung
Penyelenggaraan Pertahanan Penyelenggaraan
Negara Pertahanan Negara
4 Joint Public Lecture Haze Joint Public Lecture 2017, Malaysia
Issues in Southeast ASEAN Haze Issues in Southeast
ASEAN
5 IIASA Workshop on Haze Riau government’s 4-5 Oktober
and Biomass Burning in Asia policies to realize the 2018, Institut
goals of the ASEAN Teknologi
Agreement on Bandung

29
 Transboundary Haze
Pollution (AATHP)
6 Haze-Free ASEAN 2020: Haze-Free ASEAN and 23 Januari 2019,
National and Local Strategies Riau: Global Issues with University of
and Challenges in Managing Local Context Nottingham
Fires and Haze in Indoensia Malaysia
Campus, Kuala
Lumpur,
Malaysia
7 Workshop on Sustainable Riau Government and 1-2 November
Transboundary Governance the Haze-Free ASEAN 2018, Asia
of the Environmental 2020: Civil Society Research
Commons in Southeast Asia Organizations (CSOs) Institute, National
Perspectives Universituy of
Singapore,
Singapore

Semua data yang saya isikan dan tercantum dalam biodata ini adalah benar dan
dapat dipertanggungjawabkan secara hukum. Apabila di kemudian hari ternyata
dijumpai ketidak-sesuaian dengan kenyataan, saya sanggup menerima sanksi.

Demikian Biodata ini saya buat dengan sebenarnya untuk memenuhi salah satu
persyaratan dalam pengajuan Hibah Penelitian Dosen Muda

Pekanbaru, 12 Mei 2019

Ketua Pengusul

Alfajri, S.IP., MIA

30
Anggota (1)

Identitas Diri

1 Nama Lengkap Azhari Setiawan, S.IP., M.Si.

2 Jenis Kelamin Laki-Laki
3 Jabatan Fungsional -
4 NIK. 64.201.1217051
5 NIDN. 1028049302
6 Tempat dan Tanggal Lahir Duri, 28 April 1993
7 e-mail [email protected]
8 Nomor Telepon/HP 081372979543
9 Alamat Kantor Universitas Abdurrab, Jl. Riau Ujung, No. 73,
Pekanbaru
10 Nomor Telepon/Faks -
11 Lulusan yang telah 2
dihasilkan
12 Mata Kuliah yang diampu Pengantar Statistik
Metode Ilmu Hubungan Internasional
Hukum Internasional
Kerangka Legal Kerjasama Internasional
Politik Internasional

Riwayat Pendidikan

S1 S2 S3
Nama Perguruan Universitas Riau Universitas
Tinggi Indonesia
Bidang Ilmu Ilmu Hubungan Ilmu Hubungan
Internasional Internasional
Tahun Masuk-Lulus 2011-2015 2015-2017
Judul Diplomatic Transformasi
Skripsi/Tesis/Disertasi Dilemma dan Kekuatan
Standar Ganda Nasional dan
Politik Luar Derajat
Negeri Amerika Dependensi
Serikat pada Kawasan sebagai
Konflik Sipil- Modalitas
Militer Mesir Pembentukan
Tahun 2013 Komunitas
Kemanan
ASEAN
Nama Dr. Mhd. Saeri, Edy Prasetyono,

31
Pembimbing/Promotor M.Hum P.hD

Pengalaman Penelitian dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

Pendanaan
No Tahun Judul Penelitian Jml (Juta
Sumber
Rp)
1 2019 Peran Global Qurban Aksi Cepat PDP DIKTI 16,294,000.-
Tanggap (ACT) Indonesia dalam
Menyalurkan Bantuan
Kemanusiaan Transnasional
2 2018 Operasi Kontra Teror Koalisi LPPM Univrab 5,000,000.-
Global dalam Menghadapi
Pergerakan Islamic States of Iraq
and Syiria (ISIS)
3 2018 Bagaimana Negara-negara Pos- LPPM Univrab 5,000,000.-
Kolonial Memandang Keamanan
Insani? (Studi Kasus: Dilema
State-Building and Pembangunan
Manusia di Asia Tenggara)
4 2017 Sinergitas Pembangunan Tata PPTP 30,000,000.-
Ruang Pertahanan Daerah dalam Kementerian
Menghadapi Ancaman Non- Pertahanan RI
Militer di Indonesia di Provinsi
Riau
5 2017 Menaklik Modalitas Pembentukan CSIS 2,000,000.-
Komunitas Keamanan ASEAN
6 2016 Modernisasi Alutsista Indonesia: CSIS 1,000,000.-
Sebuah Evaluasi
7 2016 APSC: Mekanisme Kerjasama KPK-RI 5,000,000.-
Multilateral dan Mutual Legal
Assistance dalam Menangani
Kasus Money Laundering di Asia
Tenggara

Pengalaman Pengabdian Masyarakat dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

Pendanaan
No Tahun Judul Pengabdian Masyarakat
Sumber Jml (Juta Rp)
1 2019 Pelatihan Analisis Big Data dan FAIR Riau 3,500,000.-
Data Science
2 2018 Pelatihan Menulis Artikel Ilmiah FAIR Riau 2,500,000.-

32
 untuk Mahasiswa
3 2018 Pengayaan Pengetahuan Metode FAIR Riau 2,500,000.-
Penelitian di Bidang Ilmu
Hubungan Internasional

Publikasi Artikel Ilmiah dalam Jurnal dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

N
Judul Artikel Ilmiah Nama Jurnal Vol/No/Tahun
o
1 Diplomatic Dilemma dan Jurnal Hubungan Vol. 4, No. 1,
Standar Ganda Politik Internasional UMY. 2015
Amerika Serikat terhadap
Konflik Sipil-militer Mesir
Tahun 2013
2 Memahami Modernisasi Analisis CSIS Vol. 45, No. 4,
Alutsista Indonesia: Sebuah 2016
Evaluasi
3 Formulation of The Ideal Indonesian Quarterly Vol. 43, No. 3,
Format of APSC 2017
4 Sinergitas Pembangunan Tata Global & Strategis Vol. 13, No. 1,
Ruang Pertahanan Daerah 2019
dalam Menghadapi Ancaman
Non-Militer di Indonesia
5 Operasi Kontra Teror Koalisi Jurnal Dinamika Vol. 1, No. 2,
Global dalam Menghadapi Pemerintahan 2018
Pergerakan Islamic States of
Iraq and Syiria (ISIS)
6 Syed Abul Hasan Ali Hasani Tasfiyah Vol. 1, No. 2,
an-Nadwi tentang Keruntuhan 2017
Peradaban, Pandangan Hidup,
dan Pendidikan Islam
7 Menaklik Modalitas Analisis CSIS Vol. 46, No. 3,
Pembentukan Komunitas 2017
Keamanan ASEAN
8 Military-themed Video TRANSNASiONAL Vol. 5, No. 2,
Games sebagai Alat 2014
Propaganda Amerika Serikat

33
Pemakalah Seminar Ilmiah dalam Jurnal dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

N Waktu dan
Nama Temu Ilmiah/Seminar Judul Artikel Ilmiah
o Tempat
1 Haze-Free ASEAN 2020: Haze-Free ASEAN and 23 Januari 2019,
National and Local Strategies Riau: Global Issues with University of
and Challenges in Managing Local Context Nottingham
Fires and Haze in Indoensia Malaysia
Campus, Kuala
Lumpur,
Malaysia
2 Workshop on Sustainable Riau Government and 1-2 November
Transboundary Governance the Haze-Free ASEAN 2018, Asia
of the Environmental 2020: Civil Society Research
Commons in Southeast Asia Organizations (CSOs) Institute, National
Perspectives Universituy of
Singapore,
Singapore
3 Konferensi Ekonomi Bebas ASEAN ‘Political- 2015, Univesitas
Korupsi Security’ Community: Gadjah Mada,
Mekanisme Kerjasama Yogyakarta
Multilateral dan Mutual
Legal Assistance dalam
Menangani Kasus
Money Laundering di
Asia Tenggara

Semua data yang saya isikan dan tercantum dalam biodata ini adalah benar dan
dapat dipertanggungjawabkan secara hukum. Apabila di kemudian hari ternyata
dijumpai ketidak-sesuaian dengan kenyataan, saya sanggup menerima sanksi.

Demikian Biodata ini saya buat dengan sebenarnya untuk memenuhi salah satu
persyaratan dalam pengajuan Hibah Penelitian Unggulan Universitas Abdurrab

Pekanbaru, 12 Mei 2019

Anggota Pengusul

Azhari Setiawan, S.IP., M.Si

34
Anggota (2)
Identitas Diri

1 Nama Lengkap Herry Wahyudi, S.IP., M.A.

2 Jenis Kelamin Laki-Laki
3 Jabatan Fungsional -
4 NIK. 64.201.0918031
5 NIDN. 1021129002
6 Tempat dan Tanggal Lahir Ujungbatu, 21 Desember 1990
7 e-mail [email protected]
8 Nomor Telepon/HP 081268206201
9 Alamat Kantor Universitas Abdurrab, Jl. Riau Ujung, No. 73,
Pekanbaru
10 Nomor Telepon/Faks -
11 Lulusan yang telah -
dihasilkan
12 Mata Kuliah yang diampu Pengantar Ilmu Hubungan Internasional, Sistem
Hukum Indonesia, Sejarah Dunia Moderen,
Perusahaan Transnasional dan Rantai Nilai
Global, Diplomasi Ekonomi Indonesia, Hukum
Laut Internasional, Sistem Sosial Budaya
Indonesia

Riwayat Pendidikan

S1 S2 S3
Nama Perguruan Universitas Riau Universitas
Tinggi Gadjah Mada
Bidang Ilmu Ilmu Hubungan Ilmu Hubungan
Internasional Internasional
Tahun Masuk-Lulus 2009-2013 2014-2016
Judul Langkah-langkah Standar Ganda
Skripsi/Tesis/Disertasi Pencegahan yang Politik Luar
Diambil oleh Negeri Amerika
Amerika Serikat Serikat Terhadap
Dalam Kudeta Mesir
Mengantisipasi 2013
Ancaman Lone
Wolf Terrorism
(2005-2011)
Nama Indra Pahlawan, Dr. Siti Mutiah
Pembimbing/Promotor S.IP, M.Si Setiawati, MA

35
Pengalaman Penelitian dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

Pendanaan
No Tahun Judul Penelitian Jml (Juta
Sumber
Rp)
1 2017 Politik Luar Negeri Indonesia LPPM UR 20
Terhadap Myanmar Dalam Isu
Rohingya

Pengalaman Pengabdian Masyarakat dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

Pendanaan
No Tahun Judul Pengabdian Masyarakat
Sumber Jml (Juta Rp)
1 2019 Pelatihan Analisis Big Data dan FAIR Riau 3,500,000.-
Data Science
2 2018 Pelatihan Menulis Artikel Ilmiah FAIR Riau 2,500,000.-
untuk Mahasiswa
3 2018 Pengayaan Pengetahuan Metode FAIR Riau 2,500,000.-
Penelitian di Bidang Ilmu
Hubungan Internasional

Publikasi Artikel Ilmiah dalam Jurnal dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

N
Judul Artikel Ilmiah Nama Jurnal Vol/No/Tahun
o
1 Sinergitas Pembangunan Tata Global & Strategis Vol. 13, No. 1,
Ruang Pertahanan Daerah 2019
dalam Menghadapi Ancaman
Non-Militer di Indonesia
2 Standar Ganda Politik Luar Insignia: Journal of 5/1/2018
Negeri Amerika Serikat International Relations
Terhadap Kudeta Mesir 2013
3 Sinergitas Pembangunan Tata Jurnal Global & Strategis 13/1/2019
Ruang Pertahanan Daerah
Dalam Menghadapi Ancaman
Non-Militer di Indonesia

36
Pemakalah Seminar Ilmiah dalam Jurnal dalam 5 Tahun Terakhir

N Waktu dan
Nama Temu Ilmiah/Seminar Judul Artikel Ilmiah
o Tempat
1 Haze-Free ASEAN 2020: Haze-Free ASEAN and 23 Januari 2019,
National and Local Strategies Riau: Global Issues with University of
and Challenges in Managing Local Context Nottingham
Fires and Haze in Indoensia Malaysia
Campus, Kuala
Lumpur,
Malaysia
2 Workshop on Sustainable Riau Government and 1-2 November
Transboundary Governance the Haze-Free ASEAN 2018, Asia
of the Environmental 2020: Civil Society Research
Commons in Southeast Asia Organizations (CSOs) Institute, National
Perspectives Universituy of
Singapore,
Singapore

Semua data yang saya isikan dan tercantum dalam biodata ini adalah benar
dan dapat dipertanggungjawabkan secara hukum. Apabila di kemudian hari ternyata
dijumpai ketidak-sesuaian dengan kenyataan, saya sanggup menerima sanksi.

Demikian Biodata ini saya buat dengan sebenarnya untuk memenuhi salah
satu persyaratan dalam pengajuan Hibah Penelitian Unggulan Universitas Abdurrab.

Pekanbaru, 12 Mei 2019

Anggota Pengusul

Herry Wahyudi, S.IP., M.A

37
Lampiran 3
SURAT PERNYATAAN KETUA PELAKSANA

Yang bertanda tangan di bawah ini:

Nama : Alfajri, S.IP., MIA
NIK dan NIDN : 64.201.0815050/1022098303
Jabatan Fungsional : Asisten Ahli
Program Studi : Ilmu Hubungan Internasional
Fakultas : Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik
Dengan ini menyatakan bahwa usulan penelitian dengan judul DEMAND AND
SUPPORT FROM CIVIL SOCIETY ORGANIZATIONS (CSOS) FOR THE
HAZE-FREE ASEAN 2020: EVIDENCES FROM RIAU yang diusulkan dalam
Skema Hibah Penelitian Unggulan Universitas Abdurrab tahun anggaran 2019
bersifat original, tidak dalam pengusulan untuk pendanaan lembaga/ sumber dana lain
dan belum pernah dibiayai oleh lembaga/ sumber dana lain.
Bilamana dikemudian hari ditemukan ketidaksesuaian dengan pernyataan ini, maka
saya bersedia dituntut dan diproses sesuai dengan ketentuan yang berlaku dan
mengembalikan seluruh biaya yang sudah diterima ke kas Universitas Abdurrab.
Demikian pernyataan ini dibuat dengan sesungguhnya dan dengan sebenar-benarnya.

Pekanbaru, 12 Mei 2019

Yang menyatakan,

Alfajri, S.IP., MIA

NIK. 64.201.0815050

38
Lampiran 4a
SURAT PERNYATAAN KESEDIAAN ANGGOTA

Yang bertanda tangan di bawah ini:

Nama : Azhari Setiawan, S.IP., M.Si.
NIK dan NIDN : 64.201.1217051/1028049302
Jabatan Fungsional : Tenaga Pengajar
Program Studi : Ilmu Hubungan Internasional
Fakultas : Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik
Dengan ini menyatakan bahwa saya bersedia menjadi anggota tim penelitian judul
DEMAND AND SUPPORT FROM CIVIL SOCIETY ORGANIZATIONS (CSOS)
FOR THE HAZE-FREE ASEAN 2020: EVIDENCES FROM RIAU diusulkan
dalam Skema Hibah Penelitian Unggulan Universitas Abdurrab tahun anggaran 2019.
Bilamana dikemudian hari ditemukan ketidaksesuaian dengan pernyataan ini, maka
saya saya tidak akan mengajukan keberatan dan menuntut hal lainnya.
Demikian pernyataan ini dibuat dengan sesungguhnya dan dengan sebenar-benarnya.

Pekanbaru, 12 Mei 2019

Yang menyatakan,

Azhari Setiawan, S.IP., M.Si

NIK. 64.201.1217051

39
Lampiran 4b
SURAT PERNYATAAN KESEDIAAN ANGGOTA

Yang bertanda tangan di bawah ini:

Nama : Herry Wahyudi, S.IP., M.A.
NIK dan NIDN : 64.201.0918031/1021129002
Jabatan Fungsional : Tenaga Pengajar
Program Studi : Ilmu Hubungan Internasional
Fakultas : Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik
Dengan ini menyatakan bahwa saya bersedia menjadi anggota tim penelitian judul
DEMAND AND SUPPORT FROM CIVIL SOCIETY ORGANIZATIONS (CSOS)
FOR THE HAZE-FREE ASEAN 2020: EVIDENCES FROM RIAU diusulkan
dalam Skema Hibah Penelitian Unggulan Universitas Abdurrab tahun anggaran 2019.
Bilamana dikemudian hari ditemukan ketidaksesuaian dengan pernyataan ini, maka
saya saya tidak akan mengajukan keberatan dan menuntut hal lainnya.
Demikian pernyataan ini dibuat dengan sesungguhnya dan dengan sebenar-benarnya.

Pekanbaru, 12 Mei 2019

Yang menyatakan,

Herry Wahyudi, S.IP., M.A

NIK. 64.201.0918031

40
Lampiran 5
DAFTAR MAHASISWA YANG TERLIBAT DALAM PENELITIAN

Nama Lengkap : Sri Wahyuni

NIM : 14501012
Program Studi/Fakultas : Ilmu Hubungan Internasional/Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu
Politik
No. Telpon : 085274335450
Email : [email protected]

41