See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/318296123

The Effects of Moisture Damage on Asphalt Mixtures Modified with Additives

and Polymer

Article  in  Journal of Engineering · July 2017

DOI: 10.17576/jkukm-s-01-01

CITATIONS READS

3 1,065

4 authors, including:

Ahmad Nazrul Hakimi Ibrahim Nur Izzi Md. Yusoff

Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
30 PUBLICATIONS   62 CITATIONS    173 PUBLICATIONS   1,353 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Waste Material & Geo-polymer Modification in Asphalt Pavement View project

PAVECO; Sustainable airport pavement management system View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Ahmad Nazrul Hakimi Ibrahim on 09 July 2017.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

 Jurnal Kejuruteraan - Isu Khas 1 (Special Issue 1) 2017: 3-8

The Effects of Moisture Damage on Asphalt Mixtures Modified with Additives

and Polymer
Kesan Kerosakan Lembapan kepada Campuran Asphalt Terbubah bersama Bahan Tambahan dan Polimer

Akmal Othman, Ahmad Nazrul Hakimi Ibrahim, Naeem Aziz Memon &
Nur Izzi Md. Yusoff*

ABSTRACT

One of the causes of premature failure is moisture damage due to loss of adhesion and cohesion which then lead to stripping
and decrease in mixture strength. Previous studies have shown that adding additive, such as nano clay, nano carbon and
nano calcium, to binder is useful in enhancing mixture properties. In this study, the effect of adding nano-clay on mixture
properties was determined. Nano clay in the amount of 2 and 4% by weight of bitumen was added to 60/70 penetration
grade bitumen and mixed at a temperature of 150°C using the melt blending technique at a shear rate of 2000 rpm. The
indirect tensile strength (ITS) test was used to evaluate the cracking properties of the asphalt mixtures and the tensile
strength ratio (TSR) was calculated to determine the degree of asphalt mixtures’ resistance to moisture damage. The results
for the mixtures modified with nano clay were compared with results for mixtures modified by adding 2 and 4% by weight
of bitumen polymer modified bitumen (PG76), hydrated lime and cement. The addition of polymer appears to result in the
greatest potential benefit amongst the modified binders and its highest TSR value indicate that polymer modified binder is
the least susceptible to moisture damage.

Keywords: Nano-clay, polymer, moisture damage, indirect tensile strength

ABSTRAK

Salah satu sebab bagi kegagalan pramatang ialah kerosakan lembapan yang disebabkan oleh kemerosotan dalam
lekatan dan kejelikitan yang seterusnya menyebabkan pelucutan dan menjejaskan kekuatan campuran asfalt. Kajian lalu
menunjukkan bahawa penambahan bahan tambah seperti nanolempung, nanokarbon dan nanokalsium kepada pengikat
berbitumen telah meningkatkan sifat campuran asfalt. Dalam kajian ini, nanolempung digunakan sebagai bahan tambah
untuk menguji kesan terhadap sifat campuran panas asfalt (HMA). Proses pencampuran nanolempung sebanyak 2 dan
4% mengikut berat bitumen ke dalam bitumen gred penusukan 60/70 dilakukan pada suhu 150°C dengan menggunakan
kaedah pencampuran cair pada kadar putaran 2000 rpm. Ujian kekuatan tegangan tak langsung (ITS) digunakan untuk
menguji rintangan retakan p campuran asfalt dan nisbah kekuatan tegangan (TSR) telah dihitung untuk menentukan tahap
rintangan campuran HMA terhadap kerosakan lembapan. Keputusan yang diperoleh untuk nanolempung dibandingkan
dengan keputusan untuk ujian campuran bitumen terubah suai polimer (PG76), kapur terhidrat dan simen dalam peratus yang
sama, iaitu 2 dan 4% mengikut berat bitumen. Keputusan ujian menunjukkan bahawa penambahan polimer menghasilkan
keputusan positif dengan nilai TSR tertinggi berbanding bitumen terubah suai lain.

Kata Kunci: Nanolempung, polimer, kerosakan lembapan, kekuatan tegangan tak langsung.

INTRODUCTION Apart from fiber and polymer, hydrated lime and cement
are also commonly used in the modification of bitumen.
In recent decades, researchers have tried utilizing various Hydrated lime is an active filler in bitumen. According to
types of additives to modify binder and improve road Little et al. (2001), the addition of materials has the beneficial
pavement resistance to damage (Al-Hadidy & Tan 2009; effect of enhancing binder and asphalt mixtures’ ability
Moghaddam & Karim 2012; Sanchez-Alonso et al. 2013; to resist deformation and cracking at low temperature. In
Yao et al. 2012). In general, fibers and polymers are the two addition, cement-based materials have been widely used
main materials used to modify bitumen. Fiber is one of the for many years as composite materials for various types
most common additives used to enhance the bond between of structures. To reduce or control permanent deformation
bitumen and aggregate (Yao et al. 2012). Studies have proven due to water damage, various studies have been conducted
that bituminous materials reinforced with fibers such as which have resulted in anti-stripping additives such as
nylon fibers, carbon fibers and glass fibers could improve cement additives. These additives are used to enhance the
resistance against aging, cracking, fatigue and damage due physico-chemical properties of bitumen and aggregates
to moisture (Yao et al. 2012). (Behiry 2013).

Chap 1.indd 3 09/06/2017 15:31:35

 4

During the past decade nanotechnology has emerged MATERIALS AND EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
as an alternative solution to improve the performance and
durability of construction materials. Due to their small size BINDER
and high surface area, the nature of nano-scale materials is
very different from the nature of the ordinary sized materials. The binder used in this study is 60/70 penetration grade
Several researches have been conducted and results of these bitumen and its properties are presented in Table 1. It was
researchers showed that the rutting and fatigue resistance of found that the 60/70 penetration grade bitumen used meet
asphalt mixtures increased with the addition of nano materials all the required specifications.
(You et al. 2011). According to Liu (2007), the physical
characteristics of bituminous binder can be improved when POLYMER MODIFIED BINDER

the polymer is modified with a small amount of nano-clay

The climatic condition in countries such as Malaysia is
under nanoscopic conditions.
fairly consistent throughout the country and the supply of
To deal with the problems related to the environmental
performance graded (PG) binder in this region is based on
factors in Malaysia, a study need to be conducted to find a way
the higher temperature. This study does not consider low
to increase the asphalt mixtures’ resistance against moisture
temperature environment since the temperature in this country
damage. Alternative methods should be identified to be used
rarely falls below 30°C during daylight hours and usually
in the construction and maintenance of roads. This study
range between 35-45°C. A polymer-modified bitumen,
was conducted to investigate the effect of adding materials
PG-76, was used as a control sample and its physical and
such as nano-clay (NC), Portland cement (PC), hydrated lime
rheological properties are presented in Table 2. The physical
(HL) and polymer modified bitumen on the performance of
and rheological properties of PG-76 meet the minimum
asphalt mixtures.
requirements as compared to the standard specifications.

TABLE 1. Properties of 60/70 penetration grade bitumen

Binder Tests Value Unit Specification Method
Penetration@25°C 63 0.1 mm 60-70 ASTM D5
Softening Point 47.2 °C 47 Min ASTM D36
Ductility >100 Cm >100 ASTM D113
Specific Gravity@25° 1.0354 D-70 ASTM D70
Flash Point 318 °C 250 Min D-92
Trichloroethylene Solution 99.5 wt% 99.5 Min D-2042
Wax content 1.84 wt% 2.0 Max DIN 52015
Loss of Ignition 0.2 wt% 0.2 Max D-5
Penetration Balance 76.0 % 75 Min D-5

TABLE 2. Physical and rheological properties of PG-76

Test Unit Result Requirement Test Standard
Quality Specification
Softening Point °C 93 Min 70°C ASTM D36
Penetration 0.1 mm 46 Min. 45 ASTM D5
Flash Point °C 343 Min 260°C AASHTO T48
Performance Specification
Viscosity at 135°C Pa.s 2.45 Max. 3 Pa.s ASTM D4402
Dynamic shear, G*/sin δ kPa 2.10 Min 1.00 AASHTO T315
Test temp @ 10 rad/s, 76°C kPa
Rolling Thin film Oven Test Residue (AASHTO T240)
Mass Loss % 0.04 Max 1% AASHTO T48
Dynamic shear, G*/sin δ kPa 3.40 Min 2.20 AASHTO T315
Test temp @ 10 rad/s, 76°C kPa
Pressure Ageing Vessel Residue (AASHTO R28)
PAV Ageing Test Temperature
Dynamic shear, G*/sin δ kPa 1200 Max. 5000 AASHTO T315
Test temp @ 10 rad/s, 37°C kPa

Chap 1.indd 4 09/06/2017 15:31:35

 5

NANO CLAY MOISTURE DAMAGE

According to Sarsam (2013), the effect of binding the filler A widely accepted test method known as the Modified
particles increase with the decrease in the particle size of Lottman test (AASHTO T283) was used to determine moisture
the filler. Researchers in China have studied the effect of susceptibility of asphalt mixes, and this method was adopted
montmorillonite nano-clay on the copolymer properties of in the Superpave system. The AASHTO T283 test method is a
bitumen modified with styrene-butadiene styrene (SBS) by better procedure than the immersion-compression test (ASTM
mixing the molten mixture with sodium montmorillonite (Na- D1075) or Marshall Immersion method since both these
MMT) and organophilic montmorillonite (OMMT). The result methods fail to effectively predict the moisture susceptibility
of the study showed that the addition of Na-MMT and OMMT of mixtures (Behiry 2013). The immersion compression test
enhanced the viscosity SBS modified bitumen. In addition, the was introduced in the 1950s as the first moisture damage test
mixture showed a higher complex modulus and lower phase on compacted samples under the ASTM standard. More recent
angle, which resulted in a tougher and more elastic bitumen. attempts to develop a test to predict the moisture sensitivity of
Therefore, asphalt mixtures modified with nano-clay could asphalt mixtures took place in the 1960s and 1970s with the
improve rutting resistance compared to unmodified bitumen work of Lottman (1978) and Schmidt and Graf (1972). The
(Polaccoa et al. 2008). importance of simulating field condition by accelerating test
conditions in the laboratory is generally acknowledged.
HYDRATED LIME The specimens were placed between the steel loading
strips using the UTM-25 in the indirect tensile test. Load was
Limestone consists of calcium carbonate, CaCO3, and has applied on specimen at a constant head rate of 50 mm/min
a heating temperature of 980°C at which there is no carbon and the maximum compressive force was recorded until the
dioxide left and only hydrated lime (CaO) is present. When specimen cracked. The ratio of the average tensile strengths
water is added to the hydrated lime, it will expand and crack of the conditioned (saturated) subset to the average tensile
(Little et al. 2001). Adding hydrated lime to asphalt mixtures strength of the controlled (unconditioned) subset is the tensile
produce many benefits such as anti-stripping which could strength ratio (TSR). Moisture sensitivity could be calculated
improve performance under heavy traffic load. using the following Equations 1 and 2:

CEMENT ITS = 2P/πLD (1)

For many years cement-based materials have been widely and

used as composite materials in various types of structures.
TSR = ITS (cond)/ITS (dry) (2)
In order to reduce or control permanent deformation due to
water damage. Various studies have been conducted which where ITS is tensile strength (kPa), P is maximum load (N),
produced anti-stripping additives such as cement additives. L is sample thickness (mm), D is sample diameter (mm),
These additives are used to enhance the physico-chemical ITScond is average tensile strength of the moisture-conditioned
properties of bitumen and aggregates to improve wetting subset (kPa), and ITSdry is average tensile strength of the dry
by lowering the surface tension of bitumen (Behiry 2013). subset (kPa).
Portland cement is one of the additives used in this study.

AGGREGATE PROPERTIES
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

The aggregate used in this study was excavated from a mine AGGREGATE PROPERTIES ANALYSIS
located in Kajang, in the eastern part of the state of Selangor,
Malaysia. The aggregate gradation was selected according The physical properties of the aggregates used are presented
to the ASTM D 3515-96 (D-5). The physical properties of the in Table 3. The table shows that the aggregates used met all
aggregates used was determined through several aggregate the requirement of the specifications. The selected gradation
tests, namely Aggregate Crushing Value (ACV), Aggregate of the aggregate and the specific gravity values are presented
Impact Value (AIV), Flakiness Index (FI), Elongation Index in Table 4. The specific gravity values for both coarse and
(EI), Los Angeles Abrasion Value (LAAV) and Polished Stone fine aggregates are between 2.53 and 2.64 and the specific
Value (PSV). The results for all tests must be below the limit gravity for the bitumen was taken as 1.03.
of the standard specifications. The specific gravity test for
coarse and fine aggregates was conducted to measure the MOISTURE DAMAGE ANALYSIS
strength and quality of materials by determining the relative
density and porosity of an aggregate in accordance with the Moisture damage is among the most critical distresses exerted
BS 812: Part: 1975 standard. upon asphalt pavements. Moisture damage can be defined
as a decrease in the values of asphalt mixtures’ stiffness and
strength durability caused by moisture (Yusoff et al. 2014).

Chap 1.indd 5 09/06/2017 15:31:35

 6

TABLE 3. Aggregate properties

      Aggregate test Result (%) Criteria (%) Method
Aggregate Crushing Value (ACV) 22.57 <30 BS 812: Part 110:1990
Aggregate Impact Value (AIV) 15.10 <30 BS 812: Part 110:1990
Flakiness Index (FI) 6.00 <20 BS 812: Section 105.1:1989
Elongation Index (EI) 12.00 <20 BS 812: Part 1:1975
Los Angeles Abrasion Value (LAAV) 32.13 <45 ASTM C: 131-81
Polished Stone Value (PSV) 45.00 >40 ASTM E303-93

TABLE 4. Gradation of aggregates and their specific gravity (SG) values

      Percent Passing (%)
Sieve Size
Upper Limit Lower Limit Design SG (g/cm3)
12.5 mm 100 90 95 2.63
9.5 mm - - - 2.64
4.75 mm 74 44 59 2.64
2.36 mm 58 28 43 2.54
300 µm 21 5 13 2.53
75 µm 10 2 6 2.64
Dust 2 0 1 2.65

The water trapped in the coated aggregate might cause for both conditioned and unconditioned samples. Mixtures
moisture damage, which then cause severe distresses on the prepared with 2% of cement have the lowest ITS value for
pavement, such as stripping, localized bleeding, potholes, unconditioned sample while the addition of 4% of hydrated
shoving and structural failure due to moisture intrusion lime shows the lowest ITS value for conditioned samples.
into the asphalt pavements. The moisture damage test was On the other hand, mixtures prepared with 2% HL have the
conducted on all mixtures at the OBC for each individual highest ITS values before conditioning which is higher than
mix. the control mixture, and mixtures prepared with 2% NC has
The indirect tensile strength (ITS) values for unconditioned the highest ITS value after conditioning (higher than control
and conditioned mixtures are shown in Figure 1. The use of mixtures).
different type of additives showed varying values of ITS

700

600
Indirect Tensile Strength

500
(ITS, kPa)

400

300

200

100

0
2% 4% 2% 4%
60/70 PG76 2% HL 4% HL CEME CEME NANO NANO
NT NT CLAY CLAY
Unconditioned 593.56 576.96 597.05 583.05 572.45 587.08 594.06 578.36
Conditioned 474.05 571.57 472.48 443.14 507.68 554.45 574.27 565.61

FIGURE 1. ITS values of unconditioned and conditioned mixtures

Chap 1.indd 6 09/06/2017 15:31:36

 7

120

100
Tensile strength ratio

80
(TSR, %)

60

40

20

0
2% 4% 2% 4%
60/70 PG76 2% HL 4% HL CEME CEME NANO NANO
NT NT CLAY CLAY

TSR (%) 79.01 99.07 79.14 76 88.69 94.44 96.67 97.79

FIGURE 2. TSR values of mixtures

As can be seen in Figure 2, except for the mixtures Little, D. N., Epps, J. A. & Sebaaly, P. E. 2001. The benefits
prepared with hydrated lime and the control mixtures, all other of hydrated lime in hot mix asphalt. National Lime
mixtures meet the 80% lower limit on TSR value of Superpave Association.
specifications. The mixtures modified with polymer (PG76) Liu, P. 2007. Polymer modified clay minerals: A review.
is the least susceptible to moisture damage with a TSR of Applied Clay Science 38(1-2):.0 12 64-76.
99.07% followed by mixtures with 4% NC (97.79%), 2% NC Lottman RP. 1978. NCHRP Report 192: Predicting Moisture-
(96.67), 4% PC (94.44%) and 2% PC (88.69%). This finding Induced Damage To Asphaltic Concrete. Washington,
indicates that the strength of the asphalt mixtures increase DC.
with the addition of polymer. Moghaddam, T. & Karim, M. 2012. Properties of SMA
Mixtures Containing Waste Polyethylene Terephthalate.
Proceedings of World Academy of Science 618-621.
CONCLUSIONS
Polaccoa, G., Křížb, P., Filippia, S., Stastnab, J., Biondia, D.
& Zanzotto, L. 2008. Rheological Properties of Asphalt/
Based on the laboratory work done in this study, it can be SBS/Clay Blends. European Polymer Journal 44(11):
concluded that the addition of polymer could improve asphalt 3512-3521.
mixtures’ performance against moisture damage. Similarly, Sanchez-Alonso, E., Vega-Zamanillo, A., Calzada-Perez, M.
the addition of NC also shows a great improvement in A. & Castro-Fresno, D. 2013. Effect of warm additives
enhancing asphalt mixtures’ resistance to moisture damage. on rutting and fatigue behaviour of asphalt mixtures.
Construction and Building Materials 47: 240-244.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Sarsam, S. I. 2013. Nano Materials on Asphalt Cement
Properties. International Journal of Scientific research
in Knowledge (IJSRK) 1(10): 422-426.
The authors would like to express their gratitude to the
Schmidt, R. & Graf, P. 1972. The effect of water on the
Department of Civil & Structural Engineering, UKM for their
resilient modulus of asphalt treated mixes. Proceedings
cooperation and the information provided in ensuring the
of the Association of Asphalt Paving Technologists 41:
success of this study.
118-125.
Yao, H., You, Z., Li, L., Shi, X., Goh, S. W., Mills-Beale,
REFERENCES
J. & Wingard, D. 2012. Performance of asphalt binder
Al-Hadidy, A. I. & Tan, Y. Q. 2009. Mechanistic analysis of blended with non-modified and polymer-modified
ST and SBS-modified flexible pavements. Construction nanoclay. Construction and Building Materials 35:
and Building Materials 23(8): 2941-2950. 159-170.
Behiry, A. E. A. E. M. 2013. Laboratory evaluation of You, Z., Mills-Beale, J., Foley, J. M., Roy, S., Odegard, G. M.,
resistance to moisture damage in asphalt mixtures. Ain Dai, Q. & Goh, S. W. 2011. Nanoclay-modified asphalt
Shams Engineering Journal 4(3): 351-363. materials: Preparation and characterization. Construction
and Building Materials 25(2): 1072-1078.

Chap 1.indd 7 09/06/2017 15:31:37

 8

Yusoff, N. I. M., Breem, A. A. S., Alattug, H. N. M.,

Hamim, A. & Ahmad, J. 2014. The effects of moisture
susceptibility and ageing conditions on nano-silica/
polymer-modified asphalt mixtures. Construction and
Building Materials 72: 139-147.

Akmal Othman
Ahmad Nazrul Hakimi Ibrahim
Nur Izzi Md. Yusoff1*
Department of Civil and Structural Engineering
Faculty of Engineering and Built Environment
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
43600 UKM Bangi
Malaysia

Naeem Aziz Memon

Department of Civil Engineering
Mehran University of Engineering and Technology
Jamshoro, Pakistan

*Corresponding author; email: [email protected]

Chap 1.indd 8 stats

View publication 09/06/2017 15:31:37