Path Analysis On The Determinants of Pap Smear Utilization For Cervical Cancer Early Detection in Women of Reproductive Age
Path Analysis On The Determinants of Pap Smear Utilization For Cervical Cancer Early Detection in Women of Reproductive Age
Path Analysis On The Determinants of Pap Smear Utilization For Cervical Cancer Early Detection in Women of Reproductive Age
ABSTRACT
Background: Cervical cancer is the fourth most common malignant cancer among women after
breast, colorectal, and lung cancers. Pap smear has been recognized as an effective strategy for
reducing the incidence and mortality rate of cervical cancer. This study aimed to investigate the
determinants of Pap smear utilization for cervical cancer early detection in women of reproductive
age using path analysis model.
Subjects and Method: This was an analytic observational study with a case-control design. The
study was conducted in Cilongok and Ajibarang Sub-districts, Banyumas, Central Java, from
January 3 to February 3, 2018. A total sample of 200 women reproductive age was selected for this
study by fixed disease sampling. The dependent variable was Pap smear utilization. The
independent variables were education level, attitude, perception on the quality health care, access
to the health center, family support, peer support, and health personnel support. The data were
collected by questionnaire and analyzed by path analysis.
Results: Pap smear utilization was positively and directly associated with education (b = 2.63;
95% CI= 1.77 to 3.48 p<0.001), perception on quality of health care (b= 1.04; 95% CI= 0.22 to 1.86;
p= 0.012), attitude (b= 1.48; 95% CI= 0.51 to 2.44 p= 0.003), access to health center (b=1.02; 95%
CI= 0.20 to 1.84 p= 0.015), family support (b= 1.29; 95% CI= -0.22 to 2.61; p= 0.029), and health
personnel support (b= 2.02; 95% CI= 0.60 to 3.45 p= 0.005). Pap smear utilization was indirectly
associated with peer support through perception on quality health care (b = 0.66; 95%= -0.01 to
1.33 p = 0.031).
Conclusion: Education, perception on quality of health care, attitude, access to health center,
family support, and health personnel support are directly associated with Pap smear utilization.
Keywords: Pap smear, cervical cancer, path analysis, education, attitude, perception, family
support, peer support, health personnel support
Correspondence:
Gesit Kusuma Wardhani. Masters Program in Public Health, Universitas Sebelas Maret. Jl. Ir.
Sutami No. 36 A, 57126, Surakarta, Central Java. Email: [email protected].
the duration of suffering, and the high cost infrastructure or health facilities for the
of treatment, it is better if people pay community such as puskesmas, hospitals,
greater attention to the disease and posyandu, polindes, and so on); and
increase the preventive efforts that can be reinforcing factors (factors that reinforce
done (Bustan, 2007). According to Rasjidi the occurrence of behaviors such as the
(2009), if the disease is not immediately support of a husband or family, community
detected and treated, patients with cervical leaders, peers, religious leaders, health
cancer-without metastasis to the lymph workers, laws, regulations and so on).
nodes will only have 5 Year Survival Rate Based on preliminary study results
(5-YSR) or survive for 5 years. through interviews of 10 women who have a
One reason for the growing develop- partner in May 2017 in Cilongok sub-
ment of cervical cancer is caused by the low district, Banyumas regency, only 10% of
coverage of early detection of cervical women have had pap smear due to full
cancer, such as pap smears. Based on WHO support from their husbands, while others
data estimation in 2008, only 5% of women have never done pap smear examination
in developing countries, including Indo- with no reason to know and have never
nesia are receiving services, whereas effec- received information about cervical cancer
tive screening coverage is needed to reduce and papsmear. About 20% of them are
morbidity and mortality from cervical because of the cost limitation because they
cancer is 85% (Linadi, 2013). do not have BPJS card and have difficulty
According to Arum (2015), pap access to Pap smear examination.
smears can detect cervical cancer by finding Several efforts have been made by the
premalignant and malignant processes in local government of Banyumas Regency to
ectocervix and infections in endocervix with cope with the incidence of cervical cancer,
90% -95% specificity and 90% accuracy. one of them is through free pap smear
This is one of the advantages of Pap smear screening in collaboration with BPJS
tests compared to Visual Inspection with Kesehatan and some public health center in
Acetic Acid (IVA) with specificity of 64% - Banyumas Regency, but in fact this effort
98% and positive predictive value of 10% - has not been effective yet increase the
20% and accuracy of 85%. active role of women of childbearing age in
According to Rokhmawati (2011), Banyumas Regency in making preventive
behavior is still a barrier on Female Age efforts early detection of cervical cancer
Fertile to perform early detection of servical with pap smear method. The purpose of
cancer. The process of formation or change this study is to analyze the determinants of
of behavior can be influenced by various early detection of cervical cancer Pap smear
factors both from inside and outside of the method in women of childbearing age in
individuals. Banyumas Regency ".
Based on Lawrence Green (1980),
behavior is determined by three main SUBJECTS AND METHODS
factors namely; predisposing factors 1. Study Design
(factors that facilitate the occurrence of This was an analytic observational study
behaviors such as knowledge, attitude, with a case control design. The study was
perception, education level, socioeconomic conducted in Ajibarang and Cilongok
level); Possible factors (access to health districts, Banyumas regency, from January
services, availability of facilities and 3 to February 3, 2018.
1 for have done a pap smear examination in was done by calculating the total-item
last 1 year. correlation and Cronbach alpha.
5. Data Collection 6. Data Analysis
The variables of perceptions of service The characteristics of sample perception
quality, attitude, family support, peer data on service quality, attitudes, educa-
support, health personnel support were tion, access to health services, family
measured by questionnaires. While the support, peer support, health personnel
variables of education, access to health support were described in n and%.
service and the use of Pap smear test were The bivariate analysis was done using Chi-
measured by checklists. square test.
The research instruments were The data were analyzed by using path
questionnaires and medical records. The analysis, with the following steps:
validity test in this study was conducted on a. Estimation
20 women of childbearing age in Cilongok b. Model specification
district. The face validity has been consult- c. Model fit
ed to prof. Dr. Ambar Mudigdo, dr., Sp. PA d. Model re-specification
(K) and Dr. Eti Poncorini Pamungkasari, 7. Research Ethics
dr., M.Pd. The research ethics included research
The reliability test in this study was approval, anonymity, and confidentiality.
conducted on 20 women of childbearing
age in Cilongok district. The reliability test RESULTS
1. Univariate analysis
Table 1. Sample characteristics
Variable n %
The perception of service quality
Good Perception 107 53.5
Bad perception 93 46.5
Attitude
Positive attitude 61 30.5
Negative attitude 139 69.5
Fertile Age Women Education
High 136 68
Low 64 32
Access to Health Services
Good access 108 54
Poor access 92 46
Family Support
Good support 14 7
Poor support 186 93
Peer Support
Good support 152 76
Poor support 48 24
Health personnel support
Good support 180 90
Poor support 20 10
services on Pap Smears, the greater the Pap Smear utilization. This study is consis-
willingness of women in reproductive age tent with a study by Ketut (2011) about the
(WRA) to perform the Pap Smear test. relationship between knowledge and
Research subjects stated that the quality of WRA’s attitudes on Pap Smear test in
health services in health center was already Sukawati II health center. The result of
good and proper, so WRA was satisfied the study showed that attitude was
with the services provided. The services strongly related to Pap Smear test.
include the expertise of health personnel, Sakanti (2007) also stated that all
health personnel response/responsiveness, women who perform early detection of
security guarantees of service, empathy of cervical cancer check-up have a positive
health personnel, hygiene, and comfortable attitude towards early detection of cervical
places and service equipments. cancer.
This study is consistent with a study Based on the result of this study, it
by Mursyida (2012), which stated that was known that most women in repro-
quality of service was closely related to ductive age were afraid of doing Pap
satisfaction, satisfaction was able to provide Smears tests because they were worried
a good foundation for behavior change and about the results of the tests that may
mothers' re-visit, as well as spreading the diagnosed them to have cervical cancer.
recommendation. There were also some mothers who feel
It can be concluded that if the quality embarrassed because the Pap Smear test
of health services was not guaranteed, then required them to show their genitals part to
it would affect the perception of the other people. Mothers assumed that Pap
recipients of health services and would be a Smear tests were not neccessary because
barrier to the mothers to perform a health the mothers did not have history of cancer.
service, including Pap Smer test. Mothers felt the need to do an early
This study is consistent with a study examination of cervical cancer if there were
by Candraningsih (2011) who stated that some symptoms of cervical cancer such as
several constraints to Pap Smear test were bleeding and vaginal discharge.
the mothers felt embarrassed and afraid to Most of the subjects of this study were
check their cervical reproductive organs to mothers who worked outside the house.
health personnels, and the lack of sources 16.5% of mothers who did not do Pap smears
of information and facilities or health test were working as laborers/farmers, entre-
services for Pap Smear test. Therefore, the preneurs, private employees, and civil
facility and quality of a health service was servants. Mothers assumed that they did not
considered very important for a health have free time to perform health services
service provider. If the quality of health except services that were considered import-
ant, such as pregnancy check or did the
services was good, then the perception of
treatment due to illness.
the recipient would be good as well,
Regarding the positive attitudes on Pap
therefore, it increased the willingness of
Smear utilization, 35% of mothers were
WRA to perform health services, especially
housewives, therefore, mothers have more
Pap Smear test.
time and opportunity to attend a health
2. The relationship between attitude center. This suggested that the type of
and Pap Smear utilization employment greatly affect the maternal
The result of this study showed that there attitudes to perform Pap Smear tests.
was a relationship between attitude and
distance of residence to health service in the society that was suspected to be the
facilities, therefore, it can be concluded that cause of the mothers to not conduct Pap
access to health services has an important Smear test even though she has a good
effect on the occurrence of a health service. education and work. This indicated the
If the access was good, it would encourage existence of cultural values that have
the mothers to perform a health service, changed the perception and behavior of
especially Pap Smear test. mothers in making decisions. Mothers felt
5. The relationship between family that every decision taken should be based
support and Pap Smear utilization on the husband's decision. Mothers who
The result of this study showed that there did not get support from their husbands felt
was a significant relationship between that their husbands did not know about
family support and Pap Smear utilization. women's health issues. Similarly, mothers
Family support was related to Pap Smear who have a positive attitude would not do a
utilization through perception on quality of Pap Smear test if they did not get positive
health care. This study is consistent with a supports from their husband. As long as the
study by Purba (2011) which stated that an mother did not complain about certain
important factor in encouraging the symptoms, then the husbands would think
mothers to perform test of early detection that the mothers were healthy.
of cervical cancer was the closest people Based on the result of this study, the
which were husband and family. researcher can concluded that if the
This study is consistent with a study mothers have awareness and interest in the
by Kinanti (2012) which stated that there Pap Smear from themselves and get the
was a relationship between family support support from their husbands/families
and the implementation of Pap Smear on (emotional support, real support and infor-
reproductive age couple (RAC) in Pustang mation/knowledge support) it can signi-
Gading Housing Semarang in 2012. ficantly increase the maternal desire to
Family was a reinforcing factor that perform pap smear test.
can affect WRA behavior. More husband 6. The relationship between peer
mobility also help them to get information support and Pap Smear utilization
about cervical cancer and Pap Smear from The result of this study showed that there
their work environment. The support given was an indirect positive relationship
by the family or husbands was positive between peer groups and Pap Smear
response if the mothers invited discussion utilization. This study is consistent with a
on women's health issues, two of them was study by Sri Wahyuni (2013) which stated
cervical cancer and Pap Smear. Families that peer group support was related to the
who responded well would be followed by behavior of early detection of cervical
the provision of financial support for the cancer.
cost of a Pap smear test, and the husband/ From the questionnaires used in this
family expressed no objection when the study, it was showed that most of them
mothers asked to be taken to the Pap Smear assumed that WRA often did association
test. Most of the supportive husband would with peers, and in the forum WRA did a lot
have the initiative to motivate the mothers of ideas exchange with each other. WRA
to conduct Pap Smear test. claimed that they got many information
Based on the result of the study, it was and recommendations about health from
showed that there was patriarchal culture their friends, and most of WRA was
accompanied by their friends to do a cancer test. The result of this study was in
consultation to health personnels in order line with Rohmawati (2010), who stated
to get information about Pap Smear. The that in a population, the support from
invitation from peer simply affected the health personnel was related to maternal
maternal decision to conduct the test, behavior in Pap Smear test. Romadani
especially if the person who invited was a (2014) also stated that lack of support from
close friend, because usually the mother health personnel became a great factor on
believed in the stories of their peers. the delay of early detection of cervical
This study is consistent with a study cancer.
by Parapat (2016) which stated that many According to Bascommetro (2009),
mothers who eventually decided to do the when a person was important to mothers,
test after being told by the their friends who then the mothers tend to agree and did
invite them to conduct the test, therefore, what that person was saying or doing.
the mothers actually did Pap Smear test. These important people were often referred
Based on the results of this study, it to as reference groups, among others;
can be concluded that peer groups can teachers, religious scholars, customary
provided support and motivation to change chiefs (tribes), headman, and the like.
the perception of Pap Smear, the quality of Health personnel was a source of health
health care, and cervical cancer, therefore, information and in this case was Pap Smear
this can provide support for the mothers to test.
perform early detection of cervical cancer. This study is consistent with a study
The supports can be in the form of by Sakanti (2007) which stated that women
emotional support including an attentive who were suggested by health personnel to
expression, instrumental support including conduct health check up tend to have a
material support, and informational strong desire to conduct such tests.
support. To increase the coverage of the Pap
7. The relationship between health Smear service, it can also be done by
personnel and Pap Smear inviting the mothers to conduct Pap Smear
utilization test. Because based on the experience, the
The result of this study showed that there
majority of WRA were willing to conduct
was a relationship between health person-
Pap Smear test if they were invited by the
nel and Pap Smear utilization. The propor-
officer or health cadre.
tion of WRA who received good support
from health personnel (62.5%) was greater
REFERENCES
to perform Pap Smear than WRA who have
Ali M, Asrori M (2014). Metodologi dan
lack of support from health personnel
Aplikasi Riset Pendidikan. Jakarta :
(27.5%).
Bumi Aksara.
Based on the results of the study
Arum SP (2015). Stop Kanker Serviks. Yog-
above, it can be seen from the support of
yakarta: Notebook.
health personnel in research subjects' point
Bascommetro (2009). Konsep Perilaku
of view which was quite good, due to the
Kesehatan. http://www.bascommet-
active role of health personnel in providing
ro.com/2009/05/konsep-perilaku-
health education about Pap Smear test, and
kesehatan.html. Diakses 08 Januari
it helped the research subjects to know the
2018 jam 19.40WIB.
importance of early detection of cervical