Home Mortgage Disclosure Act: JUNE 30, 2017
Home Mortgage Disclosure Act: JUNE 30, 2017
Home Mortgage Disclosure Act: JUNE 30, 2017
Prepared by:
1
Table of Contents
Introduction
Report Description & Summary of Residential Lending Activity
City of St. Louis: Income Distribution
Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) Small Business Activity
Loan Applications
County Comparisons
City & Metropolitan Comparisons
City of St. Louis: 20 Year Loan History
City of St. Louis: Bank Performance Comparison
City of St. Louis: Loan Distribution
Maps – Loan Totals, Home Purchase Totals, Home Improvement Totals & Refinancing Totals
Individual Loan Bank Analysis
Bank of America
BMO Harris
Busey Bank
Commerce Bank
First Bank
First Financial Bank
Lindell Bank
Midwest BankCentre
PNC Bank
Regions Bank
Reliance Bank
Royal Banks
UMB Bank
US Bank
Loan Denials: City & MSA Totals
Loan Denials: County Totals
City of St. Louis: Loan Denial Distribution
Appendix A: Maps
Appendix B: Bank Rankings
Appendix C: City Totals Loan Amount & Number of Loans
Appendix D: Ordinance & Methodology & Terms
2
Introduction
This document was prepared by the St. Louis Planning and Urban Design Agency in accordance with Section 8 of Municipal Ordinance 57332, amended by Municipal Ordinance 57500. This annual report
contains information about the residential lending activities of the banks that have applied to be City of St. Louis Depositors. All information provided in this report comes from these banks and the Federal
Financial Institutions Examination Council (FFIEC), which monitors institution compliance with the Federal Home Mortgage Disclosure Act and the Community Revitalization Act. This information has been
analyzed and presented to promote readability and comparison.
The intent of the ordinance is to encourage St. Louis lending institutions to continue their financial commitment to the revitalization of the City and its neighborhoods through mortgage and home
improvement loans to credit-worthy individuals. The approach used by the City of St. Louis is to place its funds in those institutions that show such commitments.
The ordinance requires the potential depository to submit the following information each year at the request of the Treasurer’s Office:
1. Copies of reports from the most recent reporting period compiled by the institution under the requirements of the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act of 1975 (HMDA).
2. Certification by a responsible officer that the institution has adopted and publicly posted the pledge of fair lending practices found in Section 6 of Municipal Ordinance 57332.
In addition to those terms required by the Ordinance, the City Treasurer requests that additional materials be submitted to enable a more thorough analysis of the lending institution’s activities. These
materials may include items such as newspaper advertisements, copies of office directives dealing with fair lending policies, and recent Community Reinvestment Statements.
The intent of this law is to make loan data available to the public, thereby allowing for determination of whether or not depository institutions are fulfilling their obligations to serve the housing needs of
their communities. Similarly, this data can be reviewed by public officials, allowing them to invest public sector funds in institutions that are making the most effort to encourage private investment in
neighborhoods.
The Disclosure Statements which the potential depository institutions are required to submit under the HMDA have been a useful tool in determining which institutions are the most involved in issuing
loans throughout the City’s residential areas. According to the HMDA rules, each year depository institutions are required to compile information concerning their residential mortgage loan performance
by geographic area.
3
Report Description and Summary
Description
Bank analyses were based on raw information received from each institution and data obtained from the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (FFIEC) website. This report was produced by the Research
Department of the Planning & Urban Design Agency (PDA), City of St. Louis. PDA supports the Planning Commission in planning the future of the City of St. Louis. Considerable staff resources were involved in the writing,
data analysis, and mapping contained in this report. This report is on file at PDA and can be obtained by calling the Research Division at 314-657-3700.
Lending Summary: Summarizes the five-year lending patterns for each applicant bank. The summary depicts the number and dollar amount of each applicant’s loans within both the city
and the metropolitan statistical area (MSA). From this data, percentages for each year are calculated regarding the proportion of city loan activity to MSA loan
activity for each bank. In some instances, data was not available because a bank did not apply for City depositor status in a given year and historical data was not
available.
Historical Patterns: Provides a historical overview of an applicant’s lending activity based upon available data. The overview covers the years 1996 to 2016.
Maps: Visually displays where loans were made within the city. Each census tract is color-coded to show the number of loans and their dollar amount.
Distribution of Loans: Provides a geographic breakdown by loan type of each applicant’s residential loans. This includes a census tract summary of each type for loan originated.
Application & Denial: This report includes the number of applications and denials by bank, county, MSA, and tract-level for the City of St. Louis.
4
Summary
Overview
This report summarizes the lending patterns of fourteen local banks that applied to be depositors of City funds. The summary includes only loan originations. There are three types:
Home Purchases
Home Improvements
Refinancing
The summaries below illustrate the general activity of the banks in the City’s & Metro area market (for a full ranking of bank activity please refer to appendix B page 63). The tables displayed throughout this report
illustrate select counties in the St. Louis Metropolitan area. There are also tables comparing the City of St. Louis to the entire St. Louis Metropolitan area.
For the purposes of this report, the St. Louis Metropolitan area is comprised of the following Missouri counties:
All charts, maps and data in this report refer to the year 2016, unless otherwise noted.
Home Purchases: 576 loans totaling $107,761,000. This represents a 6.8% decrease in the number of loans and a 2.6% increase in the amount as compared to 2015.
Home Improvements: 167 loans totaling $9,416,000. This represents a 51.8% increase in the number of loans and a 12.8% increase in the amount as compared to 2015.
Refinancing: 676 loans totaling $112,897,000. This represents a 13.2% increase in the number of loans and a 35.7% increase in the amount as compared to 2015.
5
Bank Rankings for Ratio of Applications to Loans Originated (City of St. Louis)
Lindell Bank had the highest ratio of applications to loans originated, 97.9%.
UMB Bank had the second highest ratio of applications to loans originated, 78.6%.
Busey Bank had the third highest ratio of applications to loans originated, 74.5%.
Royal Banks had the fourth highest ratio of applications to loans originated, 71.4%.
First Bank had the fifth highest ratio of applications to loans originated, 70.5%.
Summary
Overall mortgage lending activity increased in the City from 2015 to 2016: 17.1% in the total dollar amount of loans originated and 7.1% in total number.
Home improvement and refinancing loans both increased in the total number of loans originated, although home purchase loans decreased. Home improvement loans had the largest increase by number
of loans (51.8% increase) and refinancing loans had the largest increase in amount (35.7% increase)
Loan activity in the MSA increased by 40.4% in the number of loans originated and 60.3% in the amount, although this increase is likely a result of the underreporting of MSA loan data in 2015. Refinance
loans, which typically represent the majority of loans reported on the Loan Application Register, increased in every county by number of loans and dollar amount, although this is also likely a result of
underreporting of MSA data in 2015.
The City of St. Louis represented 20.3% of loan denials (by number) in the MSA while representing only 11.5% of loan originations.
6
City of St. Louis – Income Distribution*
2016 FFIEC 2016 FFIEC
Est. Est.
Distresse Tract 2016 Est. 2010 Distresse Tract 2016 Est. 2010
MSA/MD MSA/MD
Tract d or Median Tract Tract Tract Tract Minority Owner 1- to 4- Tract d or Median Tract Tract Tract Tract Minority Owner 1- to 4-
Tract non- Tract non-
Income Under Family Median Median Popul- Minority Populati Occupied Family Income Under Family Median Median Popul- Minority Populati Occupied Family
Code MSA/MD Code MSA/MD
Level -served Income Family Family ation % -on Units Units Level -served Income Family Family ation % -on Units Units
Median Median
Tract % Income Income Tract % Income Income
Family Family
Income Income
1011 Middle No 87.04 $70,000 $60,928 $58,141 2,600 15.46 402 1,019 1,170 1074 Moderate No 57.66 $70,000 $40,362 $38,519 2,788 98.85 2,756 591 1,281
1012 Middle No 107.01 $70,000 $74,907 $71,483 3,100 11.97 371 1,227 1,383 1075 Low No 45.79 $70,000 $32,053 $30,588 2,711 98.89 2,681 568 1,224
1013 Middle No 99.29 $70,000 $69,503 $66,326 4,336 17.41 755 1,215 2,079 1076 Low No 42.51 $70,000 $29,757 $28,399 2,225 99.69 2,218 517 1,049
1014 Moderate No 67.1 $70,000 $46,970 $44,826 2,703 37.88 1,024 806 1,308 1081 Moderate No 61.57 $70,000 $43,099 $41,129 3,403 96.03 3,268 923 1,348
1015 Low No 45.32 $70,000 $31,724 $30,273 3,126 39.8 1,244 564 1,355 1082 Middle No 89.48 $70,000 $62,636 $59,773 2,698 96.4 2,601 658 1,131
1018 Low No 46.15 $70,000 $32,305 $30,833 3,092 40.17 1,242 555 1,436 1083 Moderate No 50.6 $70,000 $35,420 $33,802 2,267 94.66 2,146 591 1,087
1021 Moderate No 75.44 $70,000 $52,808 $50,395 2,780 11.69 325 571 1,493 1096 Moderate No 50.74 $70,000 $35,518 $33,899 3,316 99.52 3,300 733 1,795
1022 Upper No 135.98 $70,000 $95,186 $90,833 6,028 7.5 452 2,308 2,977 1097 Low No 36.57 $70,000 $25,599 $24,432 2,487 95.5 2,375 426 1,609
1023 Middle No 92.7 $70,000 $64,890 $61,923 1,846 10.4 192 635 842 1101 Low No 36.63 $70,000 $25,641 $24,474 2,984 98.86 2,950 594 1,454
1024 Moderate No 70.09 $70,000 $49,063 $46,821 2,478 18.12 449 593 1,000 1102 Low No 45.2 $70,000 $31,640 $30,199 2,654 98.53 2,615 423 1,380
1025 Middle No 97.54 $70,000 $68,278 $65,156 1,918 12.25 235 799 1,024 1103 Low No 48.96 $70,000 $34,272 $32,708 2,483 99.23 2,464 616 1,598
1031 Upper No 131.22 $70,000 $91,854 $87,656 3,299 13.76 454 932 1,410 1104 Moderate No 56.13 $70,000 $39,291 $37,500 2,539 98.62 2,504 507 1,374
1034 Upper No 136.07 $70,000 $95,249 $90,897 1,968 9.3 183 681 925 1105 Low No 35.18 $70,000 $24,626 $23,500 1,562 98.21 1,534 395 880
1036 Middle No 80.11 $70,000 $56,077 $53,512 1,329 12.49 166 474 535 1111 Low No 43.25 $70,000 $30,275 $28,895 1,556 97.11 1,511 301 660
1037 Middle No 97.73 $70,000 $68,411 $65,288 2,531 12.84 325 980 1,371 1112 Low No 33.13 $70,000 $23,191 $22,131 1,276 94.04 1,200 270 851
1038 Middle No 110.7 $70,000 $77,490 $73,951 3,819 9.61 367 1,402 1,825 1113 Low No 34.87 $70,000 $24,409 $23,295 1,554 99.16 1,541 188 856
1042 Middle No 93.02 $70,000 $65,114 $62,137 3,401 14.88 506 978 1,683 1114 Low No 37.11 $70,000 $25,977 $24,792 1,643 99.09 1,628 393 911
1045 Moderate No 71.03 $70,000 $49,721 $47,448 1,846 24.81 458 448 868 1115 Low No 46.47 $70,000 $32,529 $31,042 1,010 97.92 989 187 451
1051.98 Upper No 136.6 $70,000 $95,620 $91,250 3,463 31.3 1,084 760 729 1121 Middle No 92.08 $70,000 $64,456 $61,513 4,285 36.5 1,564 671 615
1052 Upper No 123.63 $70,000 $86,541 $82,589 2,675 64.37 1,722 507 626 1122 Moderate No 62.86 $70,000 $44,002 $41,991 1,586 96.97 1,538 289 826
1053 Low No 23.24 $70,000 $16,268 $15,526 2,203 94.05 2,072 325 578 1123 Low No 36.08 $70,000 $25,256 $24,103 2,415 98.92 2,389 434 1,097
1054 Low No 48.91 $70,000 $34,237 $32,672 2,507 92.58 2,321 208 767 1124 Upper No 141.21 $70,000 $98,847 $94,327 4,023 34.53 1,389 704 564
1055 Middle No 90.79 $70,000 $63,553 $60,651 2,922 97.33 2,844 595 1,201 1135 Middle No 80.85 $70,000 $56,595 $54,010 2,331 6.39 149 688 1,299
1061 Moderate No 50.16 $70,000 $35,112 $33,507 2,427 99.09 2,405 331 1,284 1141.01 Moderate No 79.68 $70,000 $55,776 $53,229 4,281 30.95 1,325 994 2,452
1062 Low No 32.8 $70,000 $22,960 $21,914 1,738 98.96 1,720 181 937 1141.02 Upper No 134.11 $70,000 $93,877 $89,583 4,128 7.61 314 1,095 1,991
1063 Low No 40.34 $70,000 $28,238 $26,949 1,966 99.34 1,953 395 1,224 1142 Middle No 91.55 $70,000 $64,085 $61,157 4,721 18.03 851 1,314 2,531
1064 Low No 43 $70,000 $30,100 $28,725 2,392 99.08 2,370 439 1,379 1143 Middle No 103.97 $70,000 $72,779 $69,453 5,485 12.82 703 1,922 2,710
1065 Low No 45.66 $70,000 $31,962 $30,500 3,267 96.85 3,164 481 1,351 1151 Moderate No 65.94 $70,000 $46,158 $44,052 4,287 28.2 1,209 1,041 1,566
1066 Low No 31.87 $70,000 $22,309 $21,292 1,783 99.44 1,773 452 1,191 1152 Low No 37.12 $70,000 $25,984 $24,799 3,149 54.68 1,722 634 1,072
1067 Low No 42.05 $70,000 $29,435 $28,092 3,515 99.2 3,487 689 1,879 1153 Moderate No 50.15 $70,000 $35,105 $33,500 4,958 50.83 2,520 1,321 2,203
1072 Low No 41.83 $70,000 $29,281 $27,946 1,342 98.51 1,322 143 681 1154 Moderate No 54.38 $70,000 $38,066 $36,330 3,122 33.02 1,031 836 1,364
1073 Moderate No 64.05 $70,000 $44,835 $42,788 4,983 99 4,933 1,403 2,376 1155 Moderate No 52.16 $70,000 $36,512 $34,844 5,625 64.6 3,634 959 2,508
7
2016 FFIEC 2016 FFIEC
Est. Est.
Distresse Tract 2016 Est. 2010 Distresse Tract 2016 Est. 2010
MSA/MD MSA/MD
Tract d or Median Tract Tract Tract Tract Minority Owner 1- to 4- Tract d or Median Tract Tract Tract Tract Minority Owner 1- to 4-
Tract non- Tract non-
Income Under Family Median Median Popul- Minority Populati Occupied Family Income Under Family Median Median Popul- Minority Populati Occupied Family
Code MSA/MD Code MSA/MD
Level -served Income Family Family ation % -on Units Units Level -served Income Family Family ation % -on Units Units
Median Median
Tract % Income Income Tract % Income Income
Family Family
Income Income
1156 Moderate No 56.7 $70,000 $39,690 $37,875 5,279 56.83 3,000 737 1,960 1231 Moderate No 56.03 $70,000 $39,221 $37,429 3,351 72.52 2,430 776 1,745
1157 Low No 45.84 $70,000 $32,088 $30,625 3,567 70.17 2,503 477 1,817 1232 Middle No 95.74 $70,000 $67,018 $63,958 2,298 41.56 955 536 1,114
1161 Low No 43.87 $70,000 $30,709 $29,308 3,274 57.27 1,875 784 1,696 1233 Moderate No 62.63 $70,000 $43,841 $41,842 2,586 35.81 926 612 1,649
1162 Moderate No 78.99 $70,000 $55,293 $52,765 4,325 37.53 1,623 1,154 2,301 1241 Moderate No 55.12 $70,000 $38,584 $36,821 4,644 80.81 3,753 786 2,480
1163.01 Moderate No 64.42 $70,000 $45,094 $43,036 2,999 37.18 1,115 619 1,499 1242 Low No 35.83 $70,000 $25,081 $23,940 3,201 74.88 2,397 552 1,831
1163.02 Low No 39.8 $70,000 $27,860 $26,591 3,007 78.18 2,351 331 1,175 1243 Moderate No 79.63 $70,000 $55,741 $53,194 3,131 36.98 1,158 796 1,978
1164 Low No 37.45 $70,000 $26,215 $25,021 4,891 77.98 3,814 657 2,372 1246 Low No 28.13 $70,000 $19,691 $18,792 1,845 71.71 1,323 284 906
1165 Moderate No 66.04 $70,000 $46,228 $44,114 3,844 59.65 2,293 892 2,086 1255 Middle No 119.25 $70,000 $83,475 $79,663 2,885 41.59 1,200 358 26
1171 Moderate No 77.12 $70,000 $53,984 $51,515 1,537 32.01 492 183 1,065 1256 Moderate No 68.79 $70,000 $48,153 $45,956 4,113 52.47 2,158 191 124
1172 Moderate No 66.99 $70,000 $46,893 $44,750 5,359 54 2,894 1,066 2,398 1257 Low No 14.69 $70,000 $10,283 $9,813 3,329 98.38 3,275 75 513
1174 Middle No 112.56 $70,000 $78,792 $75,189 4,235 44.91 1,902 912 1,952 1266 Low No 34.71 $70,000 $24,297 $23,188 3,543 82.13 2,910 344 1,038
1181 Moderate No 63.95 $70,000 $44,765 $42,721 1,324 74.77 990 180 713 1267 Low No 37.81 $70,000 $26,467 $25,263 1,258 78.38 986 179 800
1184 Unknown No 0 $70,000 $0 $0 1,159 38.74 449 0 22 1268 Middle No 88.37 $70,000 $61,859 $59,032 3,698 19.52 722 1,113 1,753
1186 Low No 47.27 $70,000 $33,089 $31,577 3,421 53.26 1,822 507 1,109 1269 Low No 48.65 $70,000 $34,055 $32,500 5,016 99.1 4,971 1,339 2,383
1191.01 Middle No 103.76 $70,000 $72,632 $69,310 2,584 50.15 1,296 462 441 1270 Low No 33.64 $70,000 $23,548 $22,476 2,470 85.99 2,124 295 617
1191.02 Middle No 111.69 $70,000 $78,183 $74,609 2,994 38.14 1,142 524 395 1271 Low No 47.6 $70,000 $33,320 $31,799 2,234 97.31 2,174 286 897
1192 Upper No 153.71 $70,000 $107,597 $102,679 1,703 64.18 1,093 469 717 1272 Middle No 87.73 $70,000 $61,411 $58,606 4,075 26.01 1,060 1,022 1,879
1193 Low No 42.1 $70,000 $29,470 $28,125 5,454 40.98 2,235 66 208 1273 Moderate No 73.54 $70,000 $51,478 $49,125 3,769 72.88 2,747 690 1,445
1202 Low No 43.41 $70,000 $30,387 $29,000 1,271 90.64 1,152 162 519 1274 Low No 22.31 $70,000 $15,617 $14,909 4,795 75.54 3,622 393 1,240
1211 Low No 37.24 $70,000 $26,068 $24,878 1,941 86.55 1,680 3 424 1275 Low No 36.47 $70,000 $25,529 $24,362 2,237 77.29 1,729 111 441
1212 Low No 21.87 $70,000 $15,309 $14,612 2,474 99.23 2,455 9 457 1276 Upper No 128.93 $70,000 $90,251 $86,125 3,239 26.46 857 450 1,585
*This data was obtained from the Summary 2016 FFIEC Census Report
8
Community Reinvestment Act:
Small Business Loan Activity
Small Business Loan Activity
City of St. Louis Loan Amount Loan Amount Loan Amount
Total Loans < $100,000 $100,000 to $250,000 > $250,000
Loan Loan
Number Loan Amount Number Loan Amount Number Number
Amount Amount
Bank of 442 $11,921 426 $5,136 8 1,435 8 5,350
America
Commerce 158 $30,926 91 $2,526 28 $5,085 39 $23,315
Bank
First Bank 39 $8,377 15 $755 11 $1,999 8 $1,187
PNC Bank 201 $15,648 166 $2,936 17 $3,115 18 $9,597
US Bank 927 $20,583 897 $8,839 15 $2,582 15 $9,182
TOTAL 1767 $87,455 1,595 $20,192 79 $14,216 88 $48,631
Source: Community Reinvestment Act, 2015
*Loan Amount is represented in thousands
**CRA Disclosure: This table does not reflect all data for these institutions, and is not available for all institutions
9
Loan Applications
Loan Applications
St. Louis St. Charles Franklin
St. Louis City Jefferson County MSA
County County County
Bank of America 543 1,641 739 292 65 3,280
BMO Harris*
Busey Bank 330 1,687 963 263 50 3,293
Commerce Bank 215 915 427 285 16 1,858
First Bank 95 716 388 106 84 1,389
First Financial Bank 6 11 24 1 1 43
Lindell Bank 47 113 29 1 190
Midwest Bank 235 599 85 108 11 1,038
PNC Bank 171 497 259 101 47 1,075
Regions Bank 198 649 217 121 11 1,196
Reliance Bank 33 119 54 12 5 223
Royal Banks 7 16 1 24
UMB Bank 14 68 17 11 1 111
US Bank 883 3,444 1,772 663 251 7,013
Grand Total 2,777 10,475 4,975 1,964 542 20,733
*The data provided by the bank did not include loan application information
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
St. Louis City St. Louis County St. Charles Jefferson Franklin County
County County
10
Loan Applications by Census Tract in the City of St. Louis: 2016
First
Bank of BMO Commerce Lindell Midwest Regions Reliance Royal
Census Tract Busey Bank Financial First Bank PNC Bank UMB Bank US Bank Total
America Harris* Bank Bank Bank Bank Bank Banks
Bank
1011 6 5 2 3 4 2 4 11 37
1012 11 7 2 1 2 2 4 1 18 48
1013 11 9 3 6 2 2 5 14 52
1014 5 2 2 3 5 3 1 7 28
1015 2 1 1 2 5 1 4 5 21
1018 1 2 1 1 5 2 9 21
1021 8 3 2 1 1 2 3 1 9 30
1022 27 7 7 3 1 4 5 3 1 29 87
1023 5 4 1 1 1 7 19
1024 6 3 2 1 2 7 2 4 1 11 39
1025 3 3 2 1 1 5 3 1 11 30
1031 11 5 4 1 2 1 2 2 16 44
1034 12 4 4 1 1 2 12 36
1036 7 1 1 1 2 12
1037 15 5 5 4 2 3 3 3 14 54
1038 26 2 6 1 2 6 27 70
1042 5 9 6 1 4 1 3 2 2 15 48
1045 5 8 2 1 3 5 24
1051.98 6 4 7 3 1 10 31
1052 5 6 4 2 1 1 4 3 7 33
1053 1 2 1 4 1 3 12
1054 1 2 3 1 7
1055 3 1 2 2 3 11
1061 1 6 4 11
1062 4 2 1 7
1063 1 2 1 1 3 8
1064 1 1 2 1 5
1065 1 1 3 5
1066 1 1 1 1 1 5
1067 3 1 1 1 1 9 16
1072 2 1 2 2 7
1073 1 2 2 7 3 1 10 26
1074 1 1 2 1 5
1075 2 2 1 8 13
1076 2 5 2 9
1081 2 1 5 1 2 6 17
11
First
Bank of BMO Commerce Lindell Midwest Regions Reliance Royal
Census Tract Busey Bank Financial First Bank PNC Bank UMB Bank US Bank Total
America Harris* Bank Bank Bank Bank Bank Banks
Bank
1082 2 2 1 2 1 1 9
1083 1 1 6 8
1096 1 1 1 3 1 3 5 15
1097 2 2 2 2 1 9
1101 3 1 3 2 4 13
1102 1 4 1 4 10
1103 1 2 1 5 1 4 14
1104 3 1 2 2 1 1 10
1105 1 2 3
1111 2 3 2 11 18
1112 1 1 1 2 1 6
1113 2 1 4 7
1114 1 2 1 1 5
1115 1 1 2
1121 7 9 2 3 2 1 1 2 19 46
1122 3 1 6 10
1123 1 4 1 2 8
1124 7 8 2 2 3 2 2 2 1 1 10 40
1135 8 5 1 1 1 12 28
1141.01 17 6 4 2 4 2 2 1 2 22 62
1141.02 21 6 6 5 4 3 1 8 20 74
1142 24 3 2 5 2 3 2 12 1 1 19 74
1143 33 14 1 3 2 4 9 36 102
1151 5 1 2 1 3 2 1 9 24
1152 1 3 1 2 4 8 19
1153 10 4 3 2 1 7 6 4 15 52
1154 6 2 5 1 1 7 4 2 1 8 37
1155 8 3 1 2 7 1 4 10 36
1156 7 7 1 5 6 1 4 31
1157 3 2 2 3 1 1 11 23
1161 5 5 1 1 2 4 2 1 20 41
1162 23 10 7 2 1 7 4 6 20 80
1163.01 5 6 4 2 2 3 2 15 39
1163.02 2 4 4 6 2 1 1 9 29
1164 2 3 4 1 1 1 1 12 25
1165 6 8 6 4 1 1 16 42
12
First
Bank of BMO Commerce Lindell Midwest Regions Reliance Royal
Census Tract Busey Bank Financial First Bank PNC Bank UMB Bank US Bank Total
America Harris* Bank Bank Bank Bank Bank Banks
Bank
1171 4 1 1 1 1 1 6 15
1172 20 13 6 2 4 7 2 1 26 81
1174 6 5 9 2 2 1 1 1 1 20 48
1181 6 3 1 1 1 14 26
1186 7 6 3 1 7 1 1 3 6 35
1191.01 8 6 2 3 5 24
1191.02 4 8 1 3 2 3 6 27
1192 1 6 4 1 3 1 8 24
1193 2 1 2 5
1202 3 3
1212 1 1 2
1231 6 2 4 2 1 3 7 3 11 39
1232 5 10 1 1 4 1 6 28
1233 4 6 2 3 1 3 1 2 1 8 31
1241 7 1 3 3 1 4 1 1 7 28
1242 2 2 1 2 1 1 6 15
1243 7 7 6 1 1 2 4 3 12 43
1246 1 1 1 3
1255 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 4 14
1256 2 1 1 2 1 3 1 6 17
1257 1 2 3
1266 4 3 2 2 2 3 16
1267 1 1 1 1 1 5
1268 10 5 11 2 3 1 5 5 1 33 76
1269 5 1 2 1 1 5 15
1270 1 1 2
1271 1 1 2
1272 11 5 5 1 1 7 10 20 60
1273 5 5 2 1 2 4 3 1 7 30
1274 7 9 3 1 1 3 2 2 10 38
1275 2 1 3 1 1 8
1276 11 6 1 3 2 2 8 33
Not Provided 2 2
Grand Total 543 0 330 215 6 95 47 235 171 198 33 7 14 883 2,777
*The data provided by the bank did not include loan application information
13
County Comparisons – Loans Originated (dollar amounts in thousands)
HOME PURCHASE St. Louis City St. Louis County St. Charles County Jefferson County Franklin County MSA
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans
Bank of America 14,345 81 88,027 282 27,047 138 5,841 34 741 5 136,001 540
BMO Harris 677 6 6,088 26 1,162 5 607 4 8,534 41
Busey Bank 28,193 142 179,962 775 107,258 549 22,229 136 5,560 28 343,202 1,630
Commerce Bank 7,880 43 34,653 128 9,824 58 4,774 35 270 2 57,401 266
First Bank 7,218 41 71,498 280 36,968 186 6,706 42 4,544 28 126,934 577
First Financial Bank 178 2 443 4 38 1 659 7
Lindell Bank 2,691 19 8,141 52 1,056 7 70 1 11,958 79
Midwest Bank 7,684 55 46,997 180 7,106 32 4,422 28 1,150 5 67,359 300
PNC Bank 3,665 24 15,655 66 6,927 38 754 5 1,069 7 28,070 140
Regions Bank 4,778 32 24,898 107 11,163 48 4,296 27 64 1 45,199 215
Reliance Bank 441 2 3,521 14 567 5 8,816 4 13,345 25
Royal Banks 10,605 3 870 6 139 1 11,614 10
UMB Bank 533 3 23,721 13 913 5 56 1 25,223 22
US Bank 19,051 125 107,328 502 56,311 301 16,818 108 8,822 56 208,330 1,092
Grand Total 107,761 576 611,537 2,433 266,884 1,377 75,427 426 22,220 132 1,083,829 4,944
HOME IMPROVEMENT St. Louis City St. Louis County St. Charles County Jefferson County Franklin County MSA
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans
Bank of America 290 3 5,234 29 1,830 12 470 6 145 1 7,969 51
BMO Harris 112 3 1412 13 58 1 1,582 17
Busey Bank 328 2 3681 18 1,311 8 667 4 5,987 32
Commerce Bank 845 28 7,150 118 1,841 53 1,603 46 11,439 245
First Bank 12 2 2736 22 3,936 20 690 10 7,374 54
First Financial Bank
Lindell Bank 821 11 1,582 15 2,403 26
Midwest Bank 1,183 48 19274 71 1,067 6 576 13 1,270 2 23,370 140
PNC Bank 706 16 3,031 45 1,552 17 442 15 293 9 6,024 102
Regions Bank 235 111 1377 52 406 18 116 6 2,134 187
Reliance Bank 2,679 9 3,290 5 56 1 6,025 15
Royal Banks 180 2 350 1 530 3
UMB Bank 115 1 4,693 2 5 1 4,813 4
US Bank 2,731 42 17,582 186 12,185 124 1878 44 683 14 35,059 410
Grand Total 9,416 167 70,631 573 25,771 275 5,810 135 3,081 36 114,709 1,186
14
REFINANCE St. Louis City St. Louis County St. Charles County Jefferson County Franklin County MSA
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans
Bank of America 23,070 153 116,560 503 47,822 291 11,635 87 2,587 23 201,674 1,057
BMO Harris 5,087 47 28,471 145 4,473 37 2,616 24 40,647 253
Busey Bank 18,949 102 122,562 501 57,538 233 9,298 59 3,377 13 211,724 908
Commerce Bank 7,254 48 67,581 300 15,360 116 6,615 71 954 4 97,764 539
First Bank 4,429 24 69,128 236 19,014 114 5,332 36 2,278 20 100,181 430
Firtst Financial Bank 276 1 649 4 1,944 11 2,869 16
Lindell Bank 2,963 27 4,226 48 842 7 8,031 82
Midwest Bank 4,248 28 72,342 204 8,767 32 6,327 39 624 2 92,308 305
PNC Bank 2,672 23 29,334 127 14,233 82 3,603 28 541 5 50,383 265
Regions Bank 3,049 33 30,416 152 6,073 53 4,054 33 360 2 43,952 273
Reliance Bank 13,651 8 8,564 42 3,419 22 497 3 26,131 75
Royal Banks 590 3 590 3
UMB Bank 2,052 7 54,250 38 945 7 590 7 57,837 59
US Bank 25,769 178 211,914 1,025 86,269 520 27,337 196 10,638 78 361,927 1,997
Grand Total 113,469 679 816,587 3,328 266,699 1,525 77,904 583 21,359 147 1,296,018 6,262
TOTAL: ALL LOAN TYPES St. Louis City St. Louis County St. Charles County Jefferson County Franklin County MSA
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans
Bank of America 37,705 237 209,821 814 76,699 441 17,946 127 3,473 29 345,644 1,648
BMO Harris 5,873 56 35,971 184 5,635 42 3,281 29 50,763 311
Busey Bank 37,819 203 187,020 806 127,518 659 145,458 641 63,098 261 560,913 2,570
Commerce Bank 15,979 119 109,384 546 27,025 227 12,992 152 1,224 6 166,604 1,050
First Bank 11,659 67 143,362 538 59,918 320 12,728 88 6,822 48 234,489 1,061
First Financial Bank 276 1 827 6 2,387 15 38 1 3,528 23
Lindell Bank 5,654 46 13,188 111 3,480 29 70 1 22,392 187
Midwest BankCentre 13,115 131 138,613 455 16,940 70 11,325 80 3,044 9 183,037 745
PNC Bank 7,043 63 48,020 238 22,712 137 4,799 48 1,903 21 84,477 507
Regions Bank 8,062 176 56,691 311 17,642 119 8,466 66 424 3 91,285 675
Reliance Bank 16,771 19 15,375 61 4,042 28 9,313 7 45,501 115
Royal Banks 10,785 5 1,810 10 139 1 12,734 16
UMB Bank 2,700 11 82,664 53 1,863 13 646 8 87,873 85
US Bank 47,551 345 336,824 1,713 154,765 945 46,033 348 20,143 148 605,316 3,499
Grand Total 230,646 1,422 1,498,755 6,334 559,354 3,177 159,141 1,144 46,660 315 2,494,556 12,392
15
City and Metropolitan Area – Loans Originated (dollar amounts in thousands)
16
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
40,000
45,000
50,000
0
5,000
Bank of America
BMO Harris
Busey Bank
Commerce Bank
First Bank
Home Purchase
First Financial Bank
Lindell Bank
Midwest BankCentre
Home Improvement
PNC Bank
Regions Bank
Refinance
Reliance Bank
All Loan Types (by $) - City Of St. Louis
Royal Banks
UMB Bank
US Bank
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
500,000
600,000
Bank of America
BMO HARRIS
Commerce Bank
Eagle Bank
First Bank
Home Purchase
Lindell Bank
Midwest Bank
Home Improvement
PNC Bank
Pulaski Bank
Refinance
All Loan Types (by $) - MSA
Regions Bank
Reliance Bank
Royal Bank
US Bank
17
18
19
20
21
City of St. Louis-20 Year Loan History
St. Louis City MSA* City as Percent of Total City % Change (yearly)
22
City of St. Louis – Loan Distribution (Originated Loans)
City of St. Louis Originated Loans by Tract City of St. Louis Originated Loans by Tract
Home Purchase Home Improvement Refinance Total: All Types Home Purchase Home Improvement Refinance Total: All Types
Tract Amount Loans Amount Loans Amount Loans Amount Loans Tract Amount Loans Amount Loans Amount Loans Amount Loans
($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
1011 1,142 10 60 1 354 6 1,556 17 1081 0 0 11 2 72 1 83 3
1012 1,385 12 29 2 1,247 13 2,661 27 1082 0 0 6 1 0 0 6 1
1013 2,066 14 160 2 1,301 14 3,527 30 1083 29 1 3 1 0 0 32 2
1014 550 5 40 4 313 3 903 12 1096 0 0 45 1 0 0 45 1
1015 172 2 10 2 157 2 339 6 1097 95 1 24 2 32 1 151 4
1018 94 1 94 4 808 3 996 8 1101 0 0 6 1 96 3 102 4
1021 1,161 8 15 1 779 8 1,955 17 1102 0 0 8 1 0 0 8 1
1022 3,428 23 141 3 2,998 27 6,567 53 1103 47 1 0 0 46 1 93 2
1023 774 7 0 0 316 3 1,090 10 1104 39 1 0 0 0 0 39 1
1024 533 5 22 4 813 11 1,368 20 1105 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1025 980 8 0 0 498 8 1,478 16 1111 0 0 45 1 403 5 448 6
1031 1,967 13 75 2 1,881 12 3,923 27 1112 0 0 180 2 0 0 180 2
1034 847 8 156 3 868 10 1,871 21 1113 0 0 25 1 60 1 85 2
1036 399 2 10 1 425 6 834 9 1114 0 0 0 0 18 1 18 1
1037 1,732 17 47 2 1,860 17 3,639 36 1115 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1038 1,974 13 42 2 2,208 20 4,224 35 1121 6,523 16 827 3 8,003 16 15,353 35
1042 2,902 8 87 1 2,081 18 5,070 27 1122 102 1 35 1 408 2 545 4
1045 974 7 135 1 885 8 1,994 16 1123 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1051.98 2,553 7 0 0 4,930 15 7,483 22 1124 5,075 10 16 1 11,799 11 16,890 22
1052 1,708 9 250 2 1,554 6 3,512 17 1135 784 8 70 2 1,567 13 2,421 23
1053 190 1 70 2 31 1 291 4 1141.01 2,122 16 48 4 1,806 16 3,976 36
1054 202 2 5 1 125 1 332 4 1141.02 3,304 15 218 3 4,830 28 8,352 46
1055 87 1 0 0 496 3 583 4 1142 2,720 21 55 1 2,251 22 5,026 44
1061 47 1 9 1 56 1 112 3 1143 5,468 37 216 5 3,259 26 8,943 68
1062 0 0 7 2 24 1 31 3 1151 205 3 25 3 430 7 660 13
1063 0 0 5 1 0 0 5 1 1152 207 2 0 0 421 6 628 8
1064 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1153 771 8 7 2 820 15 1,598 25
1065 13 1 5 1 0 0 18 2 1154 435 5 168 4 371 7 974 16
1066 0 0 17 2 0 0 17 2 1155 171 3 21 5 183 4 375 12
1067 12 1 49 2 0 0 61 3 1156 2,096 9 23 1 340 5 2,459 15
1072 0 0 5 1 0 0 5 1 1157 193 3 0 0 337 5 530 8
1073 55 1 39 3 81 2 175 6 1161 798 9 1,020 4 568 7 2,386 20
1074 0 0 23 1 0 0 23 1 1162 3,067 19 330 4 3,894 25 7,291 48
1075 0 0 10 2 0 0 10 2 1163.01 1,675 7 54 2 1,503 13 3,232 22
1076 0 0 3 1 29 1 32 2 1163.02 694 8 168 2 824 6 1,686 16
23
City of St. Louis Originated Loans by Tract City of St. Louis Originated Loans by Tract
Home Purchase Home Improvement Refinance Total: All Types Home Purchase Home Improvement Refinance Total: All Types
Tract Amount Loans Amount Loans Amount Loans Amount Loans Tract Amount Loans Amount Loans Amount Loans Amount Loans
($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
1164 526 6 0 0 362 3 888 9 1242 231 2 54 3 137 1 422 6
1165 1,618 8 397 5 1,833 11 3,848 24 1243 2,234 11 52 1 1,759 9 4,045 21
1171 537 3 0 0 912 8 1,449 11 1246 64 1 0 0 0 0 64 1
1172 4,228 19 3 1 5,157 30 9,388 50 1255 440 4 0 0 387 3 827 7
1174 1,301 6 474 3 1,995 11 3,770 20 1256 276 2 0 0 713 5 989 7
1181 8,500 1 0 0 2,451 12 10,951 13 1257 0 0 0 0 207 2 207 2
1184 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1266 154 2 78 2 400 3 632 7
1186 1,624 9 396 5 5,856 9 7,876 23 1267 0 0 3 1 0 0 3 1
1191.01 2,622 10 0 0 1,123 5 3,745 15 1268 2,770 18 232 4 1,100 12 4,102 34
1191.02 2,095 9 418 2 4,454 7 6,967 18 1269 38 1 5 1 43 2 86 4
1192 1,515 5 70 1 1,588 8 3,173 14 1270 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1193 0 0 100 1 0 0 100 1 1271 0 0 0 0 25 1 25 1
1202 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1272 1,382 11 451 6 1,620 16 3,453 33
1211 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1273 756 3 1,086 3 3,062 12 4,904 18
1212 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1274 2,963 10 181 4 1,800 8 4,944 22
1231 1,480 9 61 2 1,260 9 2,801 20 1275 0 0 16 1 282 3 298 4
1232 2,261 10 0 0 1,011 7 3,272 17 1276 1,500 9 0 0 1,143 6 2,643 15
1233 1,579 10 45 2 1,223 7 2,847 19 Total 107,761 576 9,416 167 113,469 679 230,646 1,422
1241 500 6 19 1 107 2 626 9
Notes:
*No Loans originated in tracts 1064, 1105, 1115, 1123, 1184, 1211, 1212, and 1270
**Loan amounts are in thousands of dollars
24
Individual Bank Loan Information
Bank of America
25
26
BMO Harris Bank
27
28
Busey Bank (formerly Pulaski Bank)
29
30
Commerce Bank
31
32
First Bank
33
34
First Financial Bank
First Financial Bank: 5 Year Summary First Financial Bank: 20 Year Summary
Number Amount
St. Louis City MSA City as Percent of Total
City Loans MSA Loans City Loans MSA Loans
2012 Year Amount # Loans Amount # Loans Amount # Loans
2013 1996
2014 1997
2015 1 18 $117 $2,778 1998
2016 1 23 $276 $3,528 1999
Total 2000
Amount is represented in the thousands of dollars 2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015 $117 1 $2,778 18 5.56% 4.21%
2016 $276 1 $3,528 23 7.82% 4.35%
Amount is represented in the thousands of dollars
35
36
Lindell Bank
37
38
Midwest BankCentre
39
40
PNC Bank
41
42
Regions Bank
43
44
Reliance Bank
45
46
Royal Banks
47
48
UMB BANK
49
50
US Bank
51
52
Loan Denials - City and MSA Totals
Loan Denials
Institution # City # MSA % of City Denials
BMO Harris*
Busey Bank 21 161 13.04%
53
Home Purchase - Loan Applications Denied Home Improvement - Loan Applications Denied
St. Louis City MSA City as Percent of Total St. Louis City MSA City as Percent of Total
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans
Bank of America 4,166 25 24,280 114 17.16% 21.93% Bank of America 441 5 2,940 17 15.00% 29.41%
BMO Harris* BMO Harris*
Busey Bank 2151 11 20,743 103 10.37% 10.68% Busey Bank
Commerce Bank 60 1 5,059 28 1.19% 3.57% Commerce Bank 1,105 38 6,985 241 15.82% 15.77%
First Bank 560 5 3,846 29 14.56% 17.24% First Bank 166 2 412 30 40.29% 6.67%
First Financial Bank 53 1 0.00% 0.00% First Financial Bank
Lindell Bank Lindell Bank
Midwest Bank 587 5 1,214 12 48.35% 41.67% Midwest Bank 330 68 1030 132 32.04% 51.52%
PNC Bank 864 7 7,881 43 10.96% 16.28% PNC Bank 899 50 3,385 203 26.56% 24.63%
Regions Bank 1,382 10 7,476 48 18.49% 20.83% Regions Bank 1,156 31 3,707 127 31.18% 24.41%
Reliance Bank 313 3 0.00% 0.00% Reliance Bank 20 4 55 11 36.36% 36.36%
Royal Banks Royal Banks
UMB Bank 138 1 138 1 100.00% 100.00% UMB Bank 25 1 0.00% 0.00%
US Bank 5,636 35 35,617 197 15.82% 17.77% US Bank 4,896 105 18915 418 25.88% 25.12%
Grand Total 15,544 100 106,620 579 14.59% 17.30% Grand Total 9,013 303 37,454 1,180 24.06% 25.68%
* The data provided by the bank does not include loan denials
54
Refinance - Loan Application Denied Totals: All Loan Types - Loan Application Denied
St. Louis City MSA City as Percent of Total St. Louis City MSA City as Percent of Total
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans
Bank of America 9,410 88 82,732 416 11.37% 21.15% Bank of America 14,017 118 109,952 547 12.75% 21.57%
BMO Harris* BMO Harris*
Busey Bank 1,211 10 9,949 58 12.17% 17.24% Busey Bank 3,362 21 30,692 161 10.95% 13.04%
Commerce Bank 1,930 26 19,914 170 9.69% 15.29% Commerce Bank 3,095 65 31,958 439 9.68% 14.81%
First Bank 311 4 5,493 42 5.66% 9.52% First Bank 1,037 11 9,751 101 10.63% 10.89%
First Financial Bank 239 4 330 6 72.42% 66.67% First Financial Bank 239 4 383 7 62.40% 57.14%
Lindell Bank 60 1 310 2 19.35% 50.00% Lindell Bank 60 1 310 2 19.35% 50.00%
Midwest Bank 1,402 15 14,235 61 9.85% 24.59% Midwest Bank 2,319 88 16,479 205 14.07% 42.93%
PNC Bank 5,349 30 36,929 172 14.48% 17.44% PNC Bank 7,112 87 48,195 418 14.76% 20.81%
Regions Bank 2,783 39 27,343 221 10.18% 17.65% Regions Bank 5,321 80 38,526 396 13.81% 20.20%
Reliance Bank 214 2 4,391 22 4.87% 9.09% Reliance Bank 234 6 4,759 36 4.92% 16.67%
Royal Banks 735 2 0.00% 0.00% Royal Banks 735 2 0.00% 0.00%
UMB Bank 283 2 1,756 12 16.12% 16.67% UMB Bank 421 3 1,919 14 21.94% 21.43%
US Bank 16,431 133 108,630 777 15.13% 17.12% US Bank 26,963 273 163,162 1,392 16.53% 19.61%
Grand Total 39,623 354 312,747 1,961 12.67% 18.05% Grand Total 64,180 757 456,821 3,720 14.05% 20.35%
Notes:
* The data provided by the bank does not include loan denials
55
56
Loan Denials – County Total
Home Purchase
St. Louis City St. Louis County St. Charles County Jefferson County Franklin County MSA
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans
* The data provided by
Bank of America 4,166 25 17,346 67 1612 11 800 7 356 4 24,280 114 the bank does not
BMO Harris* include loan denials
Busey Bank 2151 11 12057 53 3872 20 2387 18 276 1 20,743 103
Commerce Bank 60 1 2,792 15 1310 7 897 5 5,059 28
First Bank 560 5 2194 12 582 4 346 4 164 4 3,846 29
First Financial Bank 53 1 53 1
Lindell Bank 0 0
Midwest Bank 587 5 328 4 244 2 55 1 1,214 12
PNC Bank 864 7 4709 17 1941 13 197 3 170 3 7,881 43
Regions Bank 1382 10 4204 28 671 3 1219 7 7,476 48
Reliance Bank 131 1 182 2 313 3
Royal Banks 0 0
UMB Bank 138 1 138 1
US Bank 5636 35 16531 89 10288 48 2868 20 294 5 35,617 197
Grand Total 15,544 100 60,292 286 20,755 111 8,769 65 1,260 17 106,620 579
Home Improvement
St. Louis City St. Louis County St. Charles County Jefferson County Franklin County MSA
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans
Bank of America 441 5 2,057 8 355 3 87 1 2,940 17
BMO Harris*
Busey Bank 0 0
Commerce Bank 1,105 38 2,342 99 2424 52 1054 49 60 3 6,985 241
First Bank 166 2 56 8 100 8 20 2 70 10 412 30
First Financial Bank 0 0
Lindell Bank 0 0
Midwest Bank 330 68 313 56 216 1 171 7 1,030 132
PNC Bank 899 50 1437 88 671 31 337 29 41 5 3,385 203
Regions Bank 1156 31 1466 70 439 15 621 10 25 1 3,707 127
Reliance Bank 20 4 35 7 55 11
Royal Banks 0 0
UMB Bank 25 1 25 1
US Bank 4896 105 8460 176 2611 67 1534 41 1414 29 18,915 418
Grand Total 9,013 303 16,191 513 6,816 177 3,824 139 1,610 48 37,454 1180
57
Refinance
St. Louis City St. Louis County St. Charles County Jefferson County Franklin County MSA
* The data provided by
Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans Amount ($) Loans the bank does not
Bank of America 9,410 88 52,620 196 13,841 84 4,900 36 1,961 12 82,732 416 include loan denials
BMO Harris*
Busey Bank 1,211 10 5948 32 2186 13 604 3 9,949 58
Commerce Bank 1,930 26 10,542 79 4468 33 2974 32 19,914 170
First Bank 311 4 1884 18 1752 12 196 2 1350 6 5,493 42
First Financial Bank 239 4 91 2 330 6
Lindell Bank 60 1 250 1 310 2
Midwest Bank 1402 15 10369 33 316 1 1288 10 860 2 14,235 61
PNC Bank 5349 30 19977 77 7432 42 1155 12 3016 11 36,929 172
Regions Bank 2783 39 17326 122 3797 35 2554 21 883 4 27,343 221
Reliance Bank 214 2 2,809 12 1,158 7 210 1 4,391 22
Royal Banks 735 2 735 2
UMB Bank 283 2 783 6 334 2 356 2 1,756 12
US Bank 16431 133 64,163 433 17557 125 7411 66 3068 20 108,630 777
Grand Total 39,623 354 187,497 1,013 52,841 354 21,438 184 11,348 56 312,747 1,961
58
Percent of Applications Denied by Institution Percent of Applications Denied by Institution
St. St.
St. Louis St. Louis Jefferson Franklin St. Louis St. Louis Jefferson Franklin
Charles MSA Charles MSA
City County County County City County County County
County County
Bank of America 21.73% 16.51% 13.26% 15.07% 24.62% 16.68% PNC Bank 50.88% 36.62% 33.20% 43.56% 40.43% 38.88%
Loan Denials 118 271 98 44 16 547 Loan Denials 87 182 86 44 19 418
Total Loan Applications 543 1,641 739 292 65 3,280 Total Loan Applications 171 497 259 101 47 1,075
BMO Harris* Regions Bank 40.40% 33.90% 24.42% 31.40% 45.45% 33.11%
Loan Denials Loan Denials 80 220 53 38 5 396
Total Loan Applications Total Loan Applications 198 649 217 121 11 1,196
Busey Bank 6.36% 5.04% 3.43% 7.98% 2.00% 4.89% Reliance Bank 18.18% 16.81% 16.67% 0.00% 20.00% 16.14%
Loan Denials 21 85 33 21 1 161 Loan Denials 6 20 9 0 1 36
Total Loan Applications 330 1687 963 263 50 3,293 Total Loan Applications 33 119 54 12 5 223
Commerce Bank 30.23% 21.09% 21.55% 30.18% 18.75% 23.63% Royal Banks 0.00% 12.50% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 8.33%
Loan Denials 65 193 92 86 3 439 Loan Denials 0 2 0 2
Total Loan Applications 215 915 427 285 16 1,858 Total Loan Applications 7 16 1 24
First Bank 11.58% 5.31% 6.19% 7.55% 23.81% 7.27% UMB Bank 21.43% 10.29% 11.76% 18.18% 0.00% 12.61%
Loan Denials 11 38 24 8 20 101 Loan Denials 3 7 2 2 0 14
Total Loan Applications 95 716 388 106 84 1,389 Total Loan Applications 14 68 17 11 1 111
First Financial Bank 66.67% 18.18% 41.67% 0.00% 0.00% 16.28% US Bank 30.92% 20.27% 13.54% 19.16% 21.51% 19.85%
Loan Denials 4 2 1 0 0 7 Loan Denials 273 698 240 127 54 1,392
Total Loan Applications 6 11 24 1 1 43 Total Loan Applications 883 3,444 1,772 663 251 7,013
Lindell Bank 2.13% 0.88% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 1.05% All Banks 26.73% 17.10% 12.90% 19.76% 22.32% 17.79%
Loan Denials 1 1 2 Loan Denials 757 1,812 642 388 121 3,720
Total Loan Applications 47 113 29 1 190 Total Loan Applications 2,832 10,596 4,976 1,964 542 20,910
Midwest Bank 37.45% 15.53% 4.71% 16.67% 18.18% 19.75%
Loan Denials 88 93 4 18 2 205
Total Loan Applications 235 599 85 108 11 1,038
* The data provided by the bank does not include loan denials or loan applications
59
Loan Denials - City Total
Loan Denials by Census Tract in St. Louis City Loan Denials by Census Tract in St. Louis City
Home Home
Home Purchase Improvement Refinance Total: All Types Home Purchase Improvement Refinance Total: All Types
Amount Amount
Tract (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Tract (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans
1011 191 2 185 5 346 5 722 12 1076 129 6 129 6
1012 116 1 290 4 406 5 1081 40 8 129 3 169 11
1013 292 2 133 4 715 7 1,140 13 1082 63 4 84 2 147 6
1014 165 2 13 4 184 2 362 8 1083 1,120 1 80 3 153 3 1,353 7
1015 96 2 100 3 330 4 526 9 1096 153 9 35 1 188 10
1018 62 3 444 7 506 10 1097 53 4 53 4
1021 10 1 252 3 262 4 1101 54 3 116 3 170 6
1022 749 4 25 1 978 6 1,752 11 1102 112 8 112 8
1023 53 3 107 2 160 5 1103 50 6 156 4 206 10
1024 2 1 694 9 696 10 1104 40 4 243 4 283 8
1025 284 2 36 3 339 3 659 8 1105 4 2 79 1 83 3
1031 75 1 437 4 512 5 1111 65 5 409 4 474 9
1034 416 2 416 2 1112 34 2 238 2 272 4
1036 488 3 488 3 1113 39 1 55 2 94 3
1037 316 3 221 4 477 5 1,014 12 1114 88 3 22 1 110 4
1038 300 2 1,121 13 1,421 15 1115 165 2 165 2
1042 320 1 253 6 717 6 1,290 13 1121 764 1 143 3 129 1 1,036 5
1045 59 1 5 1 136 2 200 4 1122 25 2 15 1 40 3
1051.98 261 2 323 2 584 4 1123 20 4 190 3 210 7
1052 46 3 585 4 631 7 1124 1,304 4 25 1 4,020 5 5,349 10
1053 267 1 40 5 235 2 542 8 1135 113 1 202 4 315 5
1054 30 1 45 1 75 2 1141.01 801 5 756 6 1,557 11
1055 6 2 6 2 1141.02 10 1 717 7 727 8
1061 131 8 131 8 1142 180 2 12 2 965 8 1,157 12
1062 10 2 24 1 34 3 1143 217 2 125 2 1,125 9 1,467 13
1063 50 3 97 2 147 5 1151 112 1 62 1 434 6 608 8
1064 17 3 120 1 137 4 1152 293 2 91 3 384 5
1065 10 2 10 2 1153 405 5 47 5 632 9 1,084 19
1066 13 3 13 3 1154 100 1 117 4 623 9 840 14
1067 39 1 78 6 118 3 235 10 1155 53 1 272 9 228 5 553 15
1072 30 2 36 2 66 4 1156 252 3 137 8 558 5 947 16
1073 101 1 215 14 257 4 573 19 1157 98 1 99 2 453 7 650 10
1074 14 2 35 1 49 3 1161 352 3 50 2 751 7 1,153 12
1075 84 2 92 5 246 3 422 10 1162 354 3 30 4 923 7 1,307 14
60
Loan Denials by Census Tract in St. Louis City Loan Denials by Census Tract in St. Louis City
Home Home
Home Purchase Improvement Refinance Total: All Types Home Purchase Improvement Refinance Total: All Types
Amount Amount
Tract (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Tract (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans Amount (S) Loans
1163.01 179 1 385 3 755 6 1,319 10 1241 18 1 148 8 576 5 742 14
1163.02 285 3 5 1 210 3 500 7 1242 189 3 8 2 55 1 252 6
1164 56 1 180 7 50 1 286 9 1243 458 4 45 2 101 2 604 8
1165 64 1 138 1 566 5 768 7 1246 89 1 89 1
1171 200 1 305 3 505 4 1255 204 1 407 2 611 3
1172 181 1 1,151 4 765 5 2,097 10 1256 361 2 387 2 748 4
1174 358 1 173 4 661 6 1,192 11 1257 14 1 14 1
1181 1,092 11 1,092 11 1266 169 2 24 3 100 2 293 7
1184 1267 140 2 47 1 187 3
1186 180 1 33 3 567 3 780 7 1268 497 2 55 2 1,244 17 1,796 21
1191.01 436 1 436 1 1269 72 3 88 2 160 5
1191.02 225 1 177 2 402 3 1270 34 1 34 1
1192 118 1 206 2 324 3 1271 3 1 3 1
1193 6 2 6 2 1272 64 1 154 5 1,540 11 1,758 17
1202 6 2 6 2 1273 101 1 125 2 588 4 814 7
1211 1274 224 1 28 2 1,026 5 1,278 8
1212 5 1 5 1 1275
1231 246 2 190 4 601 5 1,037 11 1276 15 1 1,074 6 1,089 7
1232 170 1 90 2 1,746 4 2,006 7 Not Provided 107 2
1233 527 2 734 2 1,261 4 Grand Total 15,544 100 9,013 303 39,623 354 64,180 757
Notes
*No Loans Denied in Tracts 1184, 1211, or 1275.
**This table does not include loan denials from BMO Harris.
61
Appendix A - Maps
62
Appendix B – Bank Rankings
Rank Institution
Amount (in
Rank Institution # Loans City of St. Louis Loan Value, 2016
Thousands)
50,000
1 US Bank 47,551 1 US Bank 345 45,000
40,000
2 Busey Bank 47,470 2 Busey Bank 246
35,000
3 Bank of America 37,705 3 Bank of America 237
30,000
4 Reliance Bank 16,771 4 Midwest BankCentre 131
25,000
5 Commerce Bank 15,979 5 Commerce Bank 119 20,000
6 Midwest BankCentre 13,115 6 Regions Bank 76 15,000
7 First Bank 11,659 7 First Bank 67 10,000
8 Royal Bank 10,785 8 PNC Bank 63 5,000
9 Regions Bank 8,062 9 BMO Harris 56 0
10 PNC Bank 7,043 10 Lindell Bank 46
11 BMO Harris 5,876 11 Reliance Bank 19
12 Lindell Bank 5,654 12 UMB Bank 11
13 UMB Bank 2,700 13 Royal Bank 5
14 First Financial 276 14 First Financial 1
Amount (in Thousands)
Grand Total 230,646 Grand Total 1,422
63
MSA Loans: Value MSA Loans: Number
MSA Loan Value, 2016
Amount (in
Rank Institution Rank Institution # Loans 700,000
Thousands)
1 US Bank 605,316 1 US Bank 3,499 600,000
2 Busey Bank 560,913 2 Busey Bank 2,570
500,000
3 Bank of America 345,644 3 Bank of America 1,648
4 First Bank 234,489 4 First Bank 1,061 400,000
5 Midwest BankCentre 183,037 5 Commerce Bank 1,050
300,000
6 Commerce Bank 166,604 6 Midwest BankCentre 745
7 Regions Bank 91,285 7 Regions Bank 575 200,000
8 UMB Bank 87,873 8 PNC Bank 507
100,000
9 PNC Bank 84,477 9 Lindell Bank 187
10 Reliance Bank 45,501 10 BMO Harris 177 0
64
Appendix C – St. Louis City Tract Loan Information
1011 Middle No $60,928 2,600 15.46 64 1 87 2 180 2 60 1 250 3 2 156 157 1 238 2 364 3
1012 Middle No $74,907 3,100 11.97 677 6 338 4 559 5 68 1 138 1 2 235 180 2 160 2 306 4
1013 Middle No $69,503 4,336 17.41 775 7 140 1 873 7 128 1 633 4 1 116 140 1 296 4 426 4
1014 Moderate No $46,970 2,703 37.88 79 1 121 1 195 2 7 1 52 1 3 76 25 1 348 2
1015 Low No $31,724 3,126 39.8 7 1 3 175 60 1 97 1
1018 Low No $32,305 3,092 40.17 664 2 170 1 3 79 83 2
1021 Moderate No $52,808 2,780 11.69 182 2 219 2 196 2 108 1 1 119 91 1 15 1 370 1 655 6
1022 Upper No $95,186 6,028 7.5 2055 15 50 1 1031 7 299 2 332 3 194 1 3 247 147 2 235 2 120 1 1857 16
1023 Middle No $64,890 1,846 10.4 223 2 85 1 353 3 61 1 122 1 121 1 125 1
1024 Moderate No $49,063 2,478 18.12 68 1 326 3 119 2 5 1 6 302 80 2 105 1 363 4
1025 Middle No $68,278 1,918 12.25 108 1 268 3 126 1 69 1 1 69 208 3 123 1 507 5
1031 Upper No $91,854 3,299 13.76 577 4 125 1 751 5 626 3 226 1 406 2 40 1 233 2 939 8
1034 Upper No $95,249 1,968 9.3 607 5 76 1 323 3 185 2 101 1 21 1 66 2 492 6
1036 Middle No $56,077 1,329 12.49 521 3 95 2 12 1 1 99 10 1 97 1
1037 Middle No $68,411 2,531 12.84 994 9 230 2 442 4 289 4 440 4 123 2 3 276 47 1 798 7
1038 Middle No $77,490 3,819 9.61 1512 11 118 2 389 5 260 1 326 2 167 2 1452 12
1042 Middle No $65,114 3,401 14.88 180 2 1117 8 431 4 94 1 476 4 135 1 109 1 2105 2 423 4
1045 Moderate No $49,721 1,846 24.81 320 2 623 6 102 1 236 1 2 335 378 4
1051.98 Upper No $95,620 3,463 31.3 839 4 360 1 1891 4 2728 6 268 2 1 402 995 4
1052 Upper No $86,541 2,675 64.37 1131 3 1011 4 666 4 123 1 109 1 1 100 372 3
1053 Low No $16,268 2,203 94.05 65 1 221 2 1 5
1054 Low No $34,237 2,507 92.58 3 207 125 1
1055 Middle No $63,553 2,922 97.33 112 1 2 303 168 1
1061 Moderate No $35,112 2,427 99.09 9 1 2 103
1062 Low No $22,960 1,738 98.96 2 7 24 1
1063 Low No $28,238 1,966 99.34 1 5
1064 Low No $30,100 2,392 99.08
1065 Low No $31,962 3,267 96.85 13 1 1 5
1066 Low No $22,309 1,783 99.44 7 1 10 1
1067 Low No $29,435 3,515 99.2 12 1 34 1 15 1
1072 Low No $29,281 1,342 98.51 1 5
1073 Moderate No $44,835 4,983 99 14 1 44 1 2 58 59 2
1074 Moderate No $40,362 2,788 98.85 23 1
1075 Low No $32,053 2,711 98.89 5 1 5 1
1076 Low No $29,757 2,225 99.69 29 1 1 3
1081 Moderate No $43,099 3,403 96.03 1 5 6 1 72 1
1082 Middle No $62,636 2,698 96.4 6 1
1083 Moderate No $35,420 2,267 94.66 29 1 1 3
1096 Moderate No $35,518 3,316 99.52 45 1
65
2015 Est. Bank of Commerce First Financial
Distressed BMO Harris Eagle Bank First Bank Lindell Bank Midwest Bank PNC Bank Pulaski Bank Regions Bank Reliance Bank Royal Bank US Bank
Tract Tract Tract America Bank Bank
Tract or Under- Tract
Income Median Minority
Code served Pop.
Level Family %
Tract Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt
Income Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans
(000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s)
66
Bank of Commerce First Financial
2015 Est. BMO Harris Eagle Bank First Bank Lindell Bank Midwest Bank PNC Bank Pulaski Bank Regions Bank Reliance Bank Royal Bank US Bank
Distressed America Bank Bank
Tract Tract Tract
Tract or Under- Tract
Income Median Minority
Code served Pop.
Level Family %
Tract
Income Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt Amt
Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans Loans
(000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s) (000s)
67
Appendix D: Ordinances & Methodology & Terms
Ordinance 57332
Section Eight Each year, following the receipt of the applications, the Treasurer shall forward the information from the applying banks concerning their mortgage lending practices and policies to the Planning & Urban
Design Agency (PDA) which shall prepare a report on the performance of the various applying institutions in respect to their lending activity in the City of St Louis This report shall consider the materials submitted by the
applying banks as well as other material relevant to lending activity in the City of St Louis which the Planning and Urban Design Agency is able to obtain. PDA shall present its report, with the materials from the applying
banks attached, to the Treasurer so that the Treasurer may forward this report to the Funds Committee of the City of St Louis for its use in the designation of depositories.
Ordinance 57500
Section Nine All applications and other material received from the banks and the report prepared by the Planning & Urban Design Agency shall be delivered to the Treasurer not later than June 30 and shall be reported by
the Treasurer to the Funds Committee of the City, made up of the Mayor, the Comptroller, and the Treasurer.
The figures for 1996 through 2001 were obtained from reports from previous years. Figures from 2002 through 2016 were based upon the electronic data the Depositor Applicant Banks submitted to the City of St. Louis.
The general categories of the various tables and maps contained within this report are defined as follows:
Amount of City Loans: The total dollar amount of City residential loans originated by an applicant bank. This number includes home purchase loans, the refinancing of home purchase loans & home improvement loans.
Amount of MSA Loans: The total dollar amount of residential loans in the St. Louis MSA originated by an applicant bank.
Assets: A measure of a bank’s worth and size based upon the total holdings of the bank.
Asset to Loan Ratio: A bank’s total dollar amount of city loans divided by its total assets. This is used to normalize the value of a bank’s loan activity.
City as a % of MSA Number & Amount: number of residential city loans (number & amount) divided by the total MSA loans.
Number of City Loans: The total number of residential loans originated by an applicant bank in the City. This number includes home purchase loans, the refinancing of home purchase loans & home improvement loans.
Number of Applications: The total number of residential loan applications submitted to an applicant bank in the City. This number includes home purchase loans, the refinancing of home purchase loans & home
improvement loans.
Number of Denials: The total number of residential loan denials by an applicant bank in the City. This number includes home purchase loans, the refinancing of home purchase loans & home improvement loans.
68