Perceived Status of The Filipino Film Industry: Implications For Media Education
Perceived Status of The Filipino Film Industry: Implications For Media Education
Perceived Status of The Filipino Film Industry: Implications For Media Education
Isolde E. Valera
De La Salle Univeristy - Dasmariñas Cavite,Philippines
Communication and Journalism Department
Abstract
Media use is seen as a very important part of Filipino life as exposure to media mirrors the
desire to be part of both society and environment. Yet, despite claims of some critics that
Philippine cinema is dying, this study determined the perception of communication educators
on the status of the Filipino film industry and its implications for media education. The study
determined the technical, artistic, business, and social responsibility aspects of the Filipino
film industry. The study utilized the descriptive normative survey method to describe and
interpret the current condition of Filipino film industry. Results of this study revealed that a
majority of the respondents have less exposure to film from both mainstream and indie or
independent cinema. Educators put the highest premium on the aspects of story concept or
screenplay which were followed by cinematography and casting. The artistic and business
aspects received good status but very evident is the dissatisfaction of the educators in terms
of screenplay. Educators suggest better story concepts for films and more trainings for those
who will constitute the backbone of the industry. Educators believe that the industry has
inadequately skilled movie workers which represent the major problem of the industry. In
order to address the issues, Cavite Communication Educators proposed solutions to the
pressing problems of the industry such as patronizing Filipino films and more trainings or
seminars for movie workers.
85
Isolde E. Valera
Introduction
86
PERCEIVED STATUS OF THE FILIPINO FILM INDUSTRY
e) media practice
2. What is the exposure level of respondents to Filipino films?
3. What is the status of Filipino film industry in terms of
a) Technical b) Artistic c) Business d) Social Responsibility
4. What are the problems confronting the film industry?
5. What are the proposed solutions to the problems of the industry?
6. What are the implications of perceived status to media education?
87
Isolde E. Valera
Method
This study used a descriptive survey method to determine the present condition of the
Filipino Film Industry. It combined quantitative and qualitative approaches to interpret the
current state of the industry. Five schools offering communication programs were selected
with a total of 40 full-time and part-time educators from the province of Cavite, Philippines.
Key informants are from the following academic institutions: Cavite State University, De La
Salle University-Dasmariñas, Emilio Aguinaldo College, Perpetual Help University-Molino,
and San Sebastian College-Cavite City.
In-depth interviews were conducted with practitioners to validate results and to
provide insights on the current condition of the industry based on their experiences. Focus
interviews were also utilized to determine the views of some educators in the use of media
education techniques and determine the extent of usage for such.
A survey questionnaire was used as data gathering tool for this study. It was divided
into six parts: Profile of the Respondents, Exposure to Filipino Films, Status/Condition of
Filipino Film Industry, Problems of Filipino film Industry, and Implications to Media
Education. An open-ended part was included for insights on the variables of the study.
The units of analysis refer to the key informants or participants in the interview. They
qualify as key informants if they have been teaching for more than 10 years and with industry
practice. The respondents of the study are those who have been teaching from the identified
institution offering Communication programs and are teaching major subjects that are not
necessarily film subjects.
88
PERCEIVED STATUS OF THE FILIPINO FILM INDUSTRY
Five (5) schools are represented in the study with majority of full time and part time
faculty members participated from the selected schools namely Cavite State University, De
La Salle University-Dasmariñas, Emilio Aguinaldo College, Perpetual Help University-
Molino and San Sebastian College-Cavite City.
Table 2.
Age bracket and tenure of respondents
3-5 8
6-10 3
11-15 3
16-20 1
21 up 3
Total 18
Table 3
Years of Media Practice
89
Isolde E. Valera
It is determined that twenty-two (22) respondents do not have any work experience in related
communication fields.
Table 4
Educational Qualifications
The following table corresponds to the exposure level of respondents to films such as:
• frequency of exposure
• medium of exposure
• elements watched in films
General Classification of Films
Preference Yes No
Mainstream 10 0
Indie 2 0
Both 28 0
Table 5.
Respondents’ preference for general film classification
The data shows that all of the respondents are exposed to Filipino films – both Indie
(Independent Cinema) and Mainstream cinema.
Frequency of Exposure
Frequency of N=40
watching
Very often 4
Often 9
Fairly often 17
Seldom 11
Not at all 0
Table 6.
Frequency of exposure
90
PERCEIVED STATUS OF THE FILIPINO FILM INDUSTRY
Twenty-eight (28) of the respondents have less exposure to films while thirteen (13)
have high exposure. This notes Clarino’s (Agence France-Presse, 2012) observation that local
movies are not given as much support. It was also noted that thirteen respondents watch
movies often while thirteen seldom watch movies. These films are watched usually in movie
theaters or through cable TV.
When watching films, communication educators put the highest premium on the
aspects of story concept or screenplay followed by cinematography, the casting of lead actors
and actress or star appeal, then production design.
The artistic aspect of the Filipino film industry covers three factors; “screenplay”
which got a mean score of 3.15 interpreted as “good status.” “Acting” and “creativity” got
mean scores of 3.5 and 3.4 respectively interpreted as “Satisfactory.” Creativity covers the
use of symbolism, lightings, and special effects in the presentation of the story.
The overall rating of the artistic aspect is 3.35 interpreted as “Good status.” These
results are similar with the 2001 study “Communication Educators in Metro Manila” which
yielded the same results. The study determined that the majority of communication educators
look for good story concept or screenplay in films that they watch. They believe that there is
a need for good stories to elevate the state of the film industry for the audience to appreciate.
Regarding the current condition of the industry, communication educators expressed
neutrality with 3.1 in terms of their satisfaction to the story concepts and creative approaches
of Filipino films.
In an interview with Director Jose Mari Avellana (2001), he said that Philippine
culture is so rich from its language, arts, and literature which can be used to come up with
better film outputs (Garcia & Marasigan, 2001).
According to the Attorney Espiridion Laxa (cited in Garcia & Marasigan, 2001),
former Chairman of the Film Academy of the Philippines (FAP), “In order for a movie to be
considered a quality one, it must possess the following features: 1) good story, 2)
believability, 3) well-written script, 4) good acting, 5) competent direction, and 6) technical
aspects such as sound, photography, music, cinematography, etc. should be world-class.” He
reiterated that, even though a movie possesses the first five aspects, if it did not conform to
the technical requisites, then it is not a quality movie because technicalities bring out the best
in elements of the film.
91
Isolde E. Valera
Ms. Rosanni Sarile, a film educator, said that Filipino films lack creativity or
uniqueness because filmmakers use the same “kilig” or romance formula without depth. An
important aspect of a film is its ability to connect to its audience which is observed to be
missing. In order to establish a connection with the audience, visuals are important and it
comes with creativity and artistry in films.
Included in the technical component of a film are editing, directing, production
design, cinematography, and sound. Directing got the highest mean of 3.67 which is
interpreted as “Good status.” Cinematography Editing techniques follow. The lowest mean
score was obtained for “production design” with 3.2.
The overall mean score is 3.47 interpreted as “Satisfactory.”
In general, technical aspect rated well with a total mean score of 3.48 which is the
highest of all the aspects of film industry measured in whole. In an article from Inquirer.net
(March 12, 2010), it was pointed out that the sound aspect of Filipino films is one of the most
ignored parts of production work that can be attributed to lack of time especially for “pito-
pito” movies (indie film), resources, budget, and experts in the field.
The business aspect of the film got a mean score of 3.2 with a mean value of 3.3 for
earnings and 3.1 for budget both interpreted as “Good status.” With local films and Indie
movies shown in mainstream cinema, some of these films earned well with proper marketing
and promotional strategies. In 2013, the following movies earned the most during the Metro
Manila Film Festival: “Boy Girl Bakla Tomboy” (429 million) followed by “It Takes a Man
and a Woman” (405 million) both produced by Star Cinema. In 2014, Star Cinema produced
“The Amazing Praybeyt Benjamin” (456 million) and “Starting Over Again” (410 million).
Still, there are Indie movies shown in mainstream cinema due to its remarkable
reviews and awards in the Cinemalaya Independent Film Festival with the likes of “Ang
Babae sa Septic Tank” (Woman in Septic Tank) which won Best Screenplay and Best Picture
and was even nominated for the 6th Asian Film Awards. “Transit” (2013) competed in the
18th Busan International Film Festival and was even selected as the Philippine entry for Best
Foreign Language Film in the 86th Academy Awards. These are low-budget films yet
producers were able to get formidable returns of investments. Other independent films such
as “Thelma” by Director Paul Soriano won the Bronze Palm Award for "demonstrating
excellent and outstanding filmmaking" at the 2012 Mexico International Film Festival.
http://www.abs-cbnnews.com
“Thy Womb” in 2012 of Director Brilliante Mendoza was awarded three special prizes
by other Italian film groups - La Navicella Venezia Cinema Award, the P. Nazareno Taddei
Award - Special Mention, and the Bisato d' Oro Award for Best Actress (for Nora Aunor)
given by an independent Italian critic group called Premio Della Critica Indipendiente.
In September 2015, Heneral Luna made history through its promotion in social
media. In five (5) weeks, the film earned 240 million gross ticket sales even with the 50%
discount offered to student viewers. Facebook pages, Twitter, and other media platforms
acknowledged the film’s excellent features apart from its story concept and cinematography.
Moral and social realism got mean scores 3.15 and 3.17 respectively interpreted as
“Good status.” The statement “films educate or inform” received a mean score of 3.05 which
is the lowest in this category.
An executive of ABS-CBN, Ms. Charo Santos Concio, during the 7th Pinoy Media
Congress in 2012 said that the “economics of our country pushes Filipinos not to prioritize
local movies much more socially responsible movies.” But according to Enrico Santos, head
of the concept development group and new media for ABS-CBN Film Productions Inc.,
movie outfits now try to balance depth and feel-good entertainment. What is important is that
movies promote discussion among its viewers in which they can reflect on their lives, give
92
PERCEIVED STATUS OF THE FILIPINO FILM INDUSTRY
B. I believe that the movie industry has improved in the last three
3.475 2 Agree
years as seen in excellent production aspects
Table 7.
Current condition of the film industry as perceived by communication educators
93
Isolde E. Valera
House Bill 3840 as a 5-year tax holiday for the film industry to help in its recovery. He
believes that the Filipino film industry is dying due to the decline of a number of movies
shown in theaters. Being one of the fastest growing industries, the Philippines was used to be
recognized internationally in terms of creativity, originality, and talent (www.philstar.com).
The technical quality of foreign films made it difficult for the local industry to
compete since moviegoers mostly watched films for entertainment and a sort of enjoyment
and diversion. In an interview with cinematographer educator Mr. Richard Padernal, he said
that the industry lacks a new breed of good filmmakers and movie workers. From the staff
down to the key production heads and even directors, he attested to the unprofessional
handling of important aspects of production and the process of filmmaking alone. He also
reiterated the lack of support from government leaders considering that past President Joseph
Estrada was an actor. Even some of the senators in the country failed to support the dying
film industry then. The industry is not dying but the people who are working in the industry.
In contrary to what Padernal presented, one communication educator noted that
“Filipinos artists are good directors and actors and have complete stable creative production
staff. The producers are just around the corner. It is the story concept or idea that should be
given emphasis. Filipinos are great filmmakers too. They just need support from the
government.
The table below presents the perceived problems as attested by the respondents:
Table 8
Problems of Film Industry
Data reveals that patronizing Filipino films ranked first, followed by protection
against film piracy and support from the government in terms of tax exemption. In an
interview with professor and film maker Elvin Valerio, he said that educators need to use
local films in classrooms. Still, he understands the reasons why some communication
educators failed to do so because of the lack of film materials in schools. Most of the best
films since the 1960s, 70s (Golden Age of cinema) and even in past decades are not archived
due to the absence of a national film archive in the country.
Ms. Mojica of Cavite State University likewise said that as educators, support for the
industry is shown by simply patronizing Filipino mainstream/indie films as well as
encouraging students to watch films in the cinema though she sees the difficulty in
convincing students to support the local film industry, unless there is an improvement in story
concepts, lessons, or social implications in films. Ms. Rosanni Sarile reiterated that
We failed to educate our moviegoers but as communication professors, we
educate our students. However, teachers need to be educated also in terms of
94
PERCEIVED STATUS OF THE FILIPINO FILM INDUSTRY
the use of local films for teaching and that is media literacy. But it seems
only a few communication educators really watch local films and use them in
teaching. (September 2015)
This perspective of Ms. Sarile was even attested by the views of Mr. Padernal and Mr.
Valerio, filmmakers and educators who said that most of the communication educators use
the old classic foreign films in teaching. Thus, appreciation of the cinema was in foreign
films not in the local films among students, despite the fact that there are Filipino films that
have been awarded locally and internationally.
This part presents the suggested solutions from the academic sector to address the
present problems of the film industry. From the scale of 1-5 having 1 as the major solution
down to 5 as the least solution. The highest rank in terms of the solution is to provide high-
quality training to those who will constitute the backbone of the profession. This represents
the need to educate students who will be the future workforce in the industry to be more
creative.
More training and seminar programs for movie workers 2.25 Above A. 4
Table 9
Solutions to the Problems of Film Industry
Legend:
1.00-1.79 Major
1.80-2.59.1 Above Average
2.60-3.39.1 Average
3.40-4.19.1 Below Average
4.20-5.0 Least
95
Isolde E. Valera
cooperation with the Cavite Filmmakers Association, is an avenue where love for films and
eye for details are being enhanced among the students.
Hence, the academic sector is already doing its part in the suggested solution
mentioned that ranked 1st in this category. Regarding the inclusion of film appreciation
subject in the curriculum, the K12 program has already included the subject in the Grade 11-
12 curriculums.
Both Cinemalaya and CinemaOne film festivals aim to develop and provide an
avenue for new breed of filmmakers but centered primarily in Metro Manila. In 2009, the
National Committee on Cinema (NCC), under the National Commission for Culture and the
Arts (NCCA), launched Cinema Rehiyon to bring the festival in several regions in the
country with the hope of providing the needed support of local filmmakers (Valdoz, 2015).
1. Provide high quality training to those who will constitute the 1.725 1
backbone of the profession
2 . Come up with extension activities to enable faculty to 1.775 2
disseminate and share their expertise with groups, institutions,
associations outside the academe
3. Strengthen the use of media education techniques(films) in 1.825 3
the classroom
4. Allowing teachers and students to use the medium of film in 2.025 4
teaching-learning process
5. Incorporate film appreciation subject in the curriculum 2.075 5
Table 10
Proposed Solutions from the Academic Sector
The respondents perceive the film industry as “Good” which means that there are still
areas that need improvement to achieve a satisfactory mark. Findings of the study reveal that
the majority of communication educators have a fair exposure to both mainstream and indie
films which could possibly lead to the non-endorsement of local films for appreciation or
critiquing. In terms of their exposure to the medium, it was evident that almost half of the
respondents are exposed to local films through DVDs and cable TV.
96
PERCEIVED STATUS OF THE FILIPINO FILM INDUSTRY
Table 11
Media Education Techniques
Conclusion
Results of this study reveal that the majority of the respondents have less exposure to
films and that 11 out of 40 respondents seldom watch movies. These mainstream and indie
films are mostly viewed through movie theaters, cable TV, and videos at home. When
watching films, communication educators put the highest premium on the aspects of story
concept or screenplay.
The academic sector suggested the following solutions on the problems of the film
industry as follows: provide high quality training to those who will constitute the backbone of
the profession; come up with extension activities to enable faculty to disseminate and share
their expertise with groups, institutions, associations outside the academe; and strengthen the
use of media education techniques (films) in the classroom.
It was evident that most communication educators ranked 1st the conduct of film
showings and film discussions followed by the making of videos, films, storyboards, scripts
etc. as part of the course as mostly used media education techniques in the classroom.
Communication educators believe that there is a need to educate film workers and
personnel and not only intensify but also promote media education in secondary and tertiary
levels. Suggestions were made to strive for originality, new formulas, better story concepts
and use films as tools for education and not just for its entertainment value. They believe
that, in order to elevate the status of the film industry, story concept and screenplay must be
given crucial attention. Media education is a great responsibility and Cavite Communication
Educators agree that they are called for to propagate the importance of such in this changing
society.
97
Isolde E. Valera
References
Baran, S. J., & Davis, D. K. (2012). Mass communication theory: foundations, ferment, and
future. (6th Ed.) India: Cengage Learning.
Baran, S. J., & Davis, D. K. (1995). Mass communication theory: foundations, ferment, and
future. India: Cengage Learning.
Bill seeks 5-year tax break for local film industry. (n.d.). Retrieved October 15, 2015, from
http://www.philstar.com/nation/2014/02/27/1295153/bill-seeks-5-year-tax-break-
local-film-industry
Contending the present Issues of the Film Industry in the Philippines. (n. d.). Retrieved
October 25, 2015, from http://hubpages.com/entertainment/Contending-the-Present-
Issues-of-the-Film-Industry-in-the-Philippines
Deocampo, N. (1995). The FAP Educational Survey/Program. Manilla : Philippines.
Garcia, L., & Masigan, C. (2001). An in-depth study on the film industry in the Philippines.
Retrieved November 05, 2015.
Gervacio, R., Serquiña, S., & San Pedro, R. (2015). Perception of Philippine independent
cinema as basis for promotion of cavite filmmakers association (Unpublished
undergraduate thesis).
Griffin, E. (2013). A First Look at Communication Theory. NY: McGraw-Hill Global
Education Holdings.
Media education: A teaching manual. (1995). Laguna, Philippines: AMIC-Philippines.
Movie review: 'Heneral Luna' a hero for the millennial generation. (n.d.). Retrieved October
27, 2015, from
http://www.gmanetwork.com/news/story/536252/lifestyle/artandculture/heneral-luna-
hero-for-the-millennial-generation
News archives (2014) - Senate of the Philippines. (n.d.). Retrieved October 10, 2015, from
http://www.senate.gov.ph/news.asp?year=2014
News. (n.d.). Retrieved October 27, 2015, from http://www.abs-
cbnnews.com/entertainment/03/01/12/why-ph-movie-industry-dying downloaded
October 30,2015
Owens, D., & Hunt, P. (1985). Teacher’s Guide to Introduction to the Mass Media 1 &
Understanding the Mass Media 1, Dublin: Veritas Publication.
Philippine Film Industry in decline. (2012). Downloaded from
http://entertainment.inquirer.net/30455/philippine-film-industry-in -
decline#ixzz3qPkIZLek downloaded October 27, 2015.
Thy Womb. (n. d.). Retrieved November 5, 2015, from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thy_Womb
Valdoz. (2015, July 30). Manila Times.
Valera, I. E. (2001). Status of Filipino Film Industry as Perceived by Communication
Educators: Implications to Media Education (Unpublished master's thesis).
Pamantasan ng Lungsod ng Maynila.
Why the PH movie industry is dying. (n. d.). Retrieved November 10, 2015, from
http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/entertainment/03/01/12/why-ph-movie-industry-dying
News. (n. d.). Retrieved October 27, 2015, from http://www.abs-
cbnnews.com/entertainment/03/01/12/why-ph-movie-industry-dying downloaded
October 30,2015
98