Complementary Feeding: A Practice Between Two Knowledges: La Alimentación Complementaria: Una Práctica Entre Dos Saberes
Complementary Feeding: A Practice Between Two Knowledges: La Alimentación Complementaria: Una Práctica Entre Dos Saberes
Complementary Feeding: A Practice Between Two Knowledges: La Alimentación Complementaria: Una Práctica Entre Dos Saberes
2018;89(5):612-620
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
DOI: 10.4067/S0370-41062018005000707
a
National Institute of Health, Colombia
b
Bacteriologist, Master of Science
c
Anthropologist
d
Nutritionist
Abstract Keywords:
Practice;
Introduction. The complementary feeding (CF) comprises a period in the life of the infant that starts Complementary
with the introduction of foods other than breast-milk. It is determined by social and environmental feeding; Infants;
factors which facilitate or limit the appropriate initiation of this practice, directly affecting the nutri- Breastfeeding
tional and health status of children. Objective. To identify barriers and facilities for the follow-up of
nutritional recommendations regarding the early start of CF in children between 0 and 24 months of
age belonging to a comprehensive early childhood care program. Materials and methods. Phenome-
nological, longitudinal, qualitative study in which 43 in-depth interviews and 11 focus-groups were
carried out. Predefined categories were the context of the mother, representations and experiences of
gestation, meanings and experiences of breastfeeding (BF), and CF. The analysis included the rela-
tionships between the units of meaning and predefined and emerging categories. Results. The CF is
a social practice which is the result of medical and popular knowledge mixture, however, the degree
of influence that the latter has on mothers is higher due to the degree of support that they have from
their close circle, especially from mothers, grandmothers, and women of the family. The lack of con-
ceptual and practical knowledge about exclusive breastfeeding (EBF) and CF prevents mothers from
carrying out good practices. Most of them do not know clearly what is involved in the EBF, resulting
in an early start of CF, or do not have objective criteria to assess their milk production. Despite having
received specific training, CF started early in most cases, a fact in which close family influence was
decisive. Conclusions. The CF experience is strongly influenced by sociocultural aspects not only of
the mother but of her immediate circle, and the recommendations they received from health pro-
fessionals are not enough to change their practices. Therefore, it is necessary to improve CF support
interventions.
Correspondence:
Yibby Forero Torres
[email protected]
612
Original Article
Complementary feeding - Y. Forero T. et al
613
Original Article
Complementary feeding - Y. Forero T. et al
child, siblings, uncles, and cousins. It worked as a sup- cipants. This codification type and analysis were per-
port network in relation to economic matters and in formed through an individual approach of each mem-
home and care tasks15. ber of the investigation team on the emerging and the
The data collection techniques used were the in- previously proposed analysis categories, therefore their
depth interview16 and focus groups17, which were relevance and theoretical saturation could be verified.
performed at home of the participants and at places This exercise was the result of a qualitative methodolo-
assigned by the program. The participants were called gical triangulation18,19 between the two used informa-
during 2016 and 2017 at six different periods: during tion sources, the interviews, and focal groups, and the
the third trimester of pregnancy, after the birth of the contrast between emerging and previously established
child, at six, 12, 18, and 24 months of age. The team categories (Table 2).
of professionals in charge of the collection, codifica- In order to guarantee the anonymity of the par-
tion, and analysis of the information was made up of ticipants, each one was assigned a code composed of
anthropologists and trained sociologist with experien- the initials of the researcher, followed by the district
ce in the implementation of qualitative methodologies code for each of the localities of the city of Bogotá, the
headed by the lead researcher. Following the contribu- initials of the data collection technique, and finally the
tion of the grounded theory and the phenomenological code assigned by the investigation team for each par-
health studies the codification was performed based on ticipant.
previously established analysis categories, according to The information was collected and recorded on
the investigation purposes and with emerging catego- audio after the sign of the informed consent. It was
ries among the narratives and perception of the parti- transcribed and subsequently systematized through a
codification process that included the identification of
the first work codes, as well as the emerging categories
and then the process of category saturation was veri-
Table 1. Sociodemographical features fied and the information analyzed13, 17,20. The analysis
was performed inductively without forcing data into
Variable Percentage Value (%)
the previously established categories.
≤ 18 19-34 ≥ 35 Total The use of reliable data collection techniques, strict
Age Groups by Year 26 67 7 100 procedures, and controls in order to guarantee the
Etnia quality of the findings31 ensured the scientific rigor of
Afrodescendant 3.7 4.5 11.8 4.8 the study, its credibility, fidelity, confirmability, and
Indigenous 0.9 2.6 2.9 2.2 transferability13. The findings were shared with eight
Without ethnicity 95.4 92.9 85.3 93.13 participants in order to confirm that the study results
Socioeconomic level reflected their experiences. Similarly, the authors re-
1 21.1 19.2 14.7 20 corded every step of the research and analysis process22
2 68.8 64.3 55.9 65.2 (Figure 1).
3 9.2 16.6 29.4 15.8
The research was performed in accordance with
Marital Status the health research studies regulations established
Married or consensual union 4.4 66.6 58.8 53.9
in the Helsinki’s Declaration (1975 and reviewed
Single 8.9 31.7 38.2 45.2
Divorcee 0 0.3 2.9 0.4
in 1983)23 and took into account the Scientific, Te-
Widow 0 0.6 0 0.4 chnical, and Administrative Guidelines for Health
Research established in the Resolution No 008430
Education grade
None 0 0 2.9 2 of 19939 in Colombia24, which defined it as research
Primary 2.2 5.6 14.7 5.6 with minimum risk. No one was forced to participate
Secondary 95.5 71.9 61.8 75.8 in the study if they did not want to and could leave
Higher education (Technician, 2.2 19.5 20.6 16.6 at any time. The study had the approval of the Ethics
technologist, professional) Committee of the National Health Institute (NHI) of
Afiliation with social security in health Colombia.
Subsidized 48.9 48.8 38.2 48.1
Contributory 44.4 41.4 52.9 42.9
Not registered 6.7 9.8 8.8 9
Results
Main activity
Job 4.4 20.1 26.5 17.5
Household activities 41.1 69.5 73.5 64.3
The results address the predefined categories (table
Study 48.9 7.7 0 14.9 2) and are expressed sequentially from the third gesta-
Without activity 5.6 2.7 0 3.2 tion trimester until the child reaches 24 months of age,
and include textual quotes from the participants.
614
Original Article
Complementary feeding - Y. Forero T. et al
Characteristics of mother’s context We inquired about age, marital status, family structure, educational level, and socioeco-
nomic status
Representations and experiences We investigated the representations and experiences of the participants of the gestation,
facing pregnancy experienced changes, positive or negative aspects perceived, health situation during preg-
nancy, attendance at prenatal check-ups, psychoprophylactic courses, and/or emergency
service
Meanings and experiences of We searched for perceptions and knowledge about breastfeeding and complementary fee-
breastfeeding and complementary ding, access to information on breastfeeding and complementary feeding during and after
feeding pregnancy, sources of information on breastfeeding and complementary feeding, reasons
to breastfeed or stop breastfeeding, social networks of support, family environment/breast-
feeding/complementary feeding, work/breastfeeding/complementary feeding, facilities and
difficulties felt in relation to breastfeeding/complementary feeding, representations of food,
use and access to the health system, and breastfeeding support groups
615
Original Article
Complementary feeding - Y. Forero T. et al
56.7% of the women were first-time mothers, and as food since they were not solid, therefore they were
although 58.4% of the pregnancies were not planned, considered not to interfere with the EBF.
especially for those younger than 18 years, 90% of The traditional knowledge was a major influence
them stated that they wanted the child later. Until the on the participants; the recommendations from their
second month of age, 93% of the children were un- relatives were more welcomed than those from physi-
der the care of their mothers, the rest were under the cians and/or other health professionals. The internet
care of their grandmothers or others. The participants was an important information source in topics related
were planning to resume their pre-pregnancy activities to the CF, especially for younger participants, while
once their children were six months old. None of the older participants preferred to be informed through
participants had maternity leave since their economic workshops and training. “I followed my aunt’s recom-
activities were informal. mendations, also especially as I have read on the internet,
All deliveries were performed in a hospital, 60% I also have a book where I’ve read about the CF and there
of the cases were natural deliveries and 67% of the are also recipes (…) I haven’t consulted with the pedia-
mothers had immediate skin-to-skin contact with their trician, because, the truth is we haven’t gone, and I know
children. Only 20% of the women had complications, it is a fight” (JV02EN440).
such as high blood pressure, dilation problems, fetal The expected total breastfeeding (TBF) matched
distress or bleeding, and a small number required hos- with what happened in practice, since those women
pitalization after delivery. who said that they intended to breastfeed their chil-
68.8% of newborns received BF during the first dren still did so when they were six months old. Howe-
hour of life and those participants who did not so re- ver, the EBF prevalence was lower compared with the
ported reasons such as the lack of medical advice or expectation that they had during the pregnancy period.
support and weakness. 71.9% received counseling Among the reasons why mothers stopped breastfee-
in BF after the birth, mainly from their Health Care ding their children and therefore started with the CF
Providers (HCP) in breastfeeding techniques. For the was the perception of low milk production, problems
participants the immediate support that they received in breasts and nipples, child or maternal illness, and
in the healthcare institution was essential while breast- rejection from the child.
feeding. 69% of the children in the study had eaten something
The participants had the intentions to start the CF other than breast milk at the second month of life, which
after the children were six months old, however, they was consumed by more than half of them between the
did not care much about the fact of introducing foods two and six months of age. The main reasons for the
like water, formula, and juices before this age. Many mothers to offer formula to their children were the per-
did not know how and when to start the CF, and few ception they were still hungry, the feeling of low breast
believed they would breastfeed for less than six months. milk production, the fact that they had to leave them
Regarding the initiation of the CF, the mothers under the care of another person, and that they consi-
received advice from female relatives, mainly their dered that formula is better than other food, including
mothers, mother-in-law, sisters, grandmothers, and breast milk.” I feed him milk powder as a supplementary
sisters-in-law, who recommended that they start the food, so I can’t feed him a dish of dry food, then I have the
practice before the children were six months old. “My option of the bottle” (AH10EN902). 57% of the mothers
mother told me to give him bean broth that would help used a bottle to feed their children with foods other than
his stomach” (SR01EN03130). In contrast, the recom- breast milk, mainly formula, and in many cases, it was
mendations from health professionals, such as general presented as a substitute of breast milk, since they feed
practitioners, pediatricians, nurses, and nutritionists them with it as frequent as they breastfed.
usually indicated that it was best to maintain the EBF The CF was characterized by the early incorpora-
until the sixth month of age, and therefore start the CF tion of liquids and semisolids, such as water, natural
at this age. However, the mothers did not receive any fruit juices (passion fruit, apple, pear, mango, tange-
indications on how and why to follow these recom- rine, pitaya, orange, plum), fruit or vegetable water
mendations or any information on the consequences (lettuce apple, celery, tomato, among others), and
of early CF initiation. “I started feeding him food after infusions (anise, cinnamon, chamomile, mint). The
six months because let’s say… the pediatrician said so” reasons for fluids initiation were mostly related to the
(SR05EN05). mother’s perception of thirst and constipation.
The milk formula was considered as supplemen- The initiation of feeds with semisolids was varied,
tary food: “What happens is that my milk doesn’t feed not all mothers started at six months, most of them
them well, that’s why I’m reinforcing it with S26®, that started in the fifth month. The participants emphasized
is, it’s like watery milk” (CG08EN011601). Drinks such the influence of female relatives, who advised them to
as water, juices, and milk formula were not perceived start it early “to get the baby used to it” (JV12EN0103).
616
Original Article
Complementary feeding - Y. Forero T. et al
617
Original Article
Complementary feeding - Y. Forero T. et al
ween the medical and popular knowledge, therefore followed the protocols of their Center and Local regu-
an approach of both pieces of knowledge is essential lations on the publication of patient data.
for them to recognize each other, and the mothers can
take the best of both in order to work for the nutritio- Rights to privacy and informed consent: The authors
nal well-being of their children, thus generating a posi- have obtained the informed consent of the patients
tive impact on the public health of the country thanks and/or subjects referred to in the article. This docu-
to free and informed CF practices. ment is in the possession of the correspondence author.
The revealed results of this study correspond to
the reality of a specific group of women who share Conflicts of Interest
similar sociodemographic characteristics, thus their
conclusions offer a partial view of the issue. However, Authors declare no conflict of interest regarding the
it allows seeing the point of view of these mothers re- present study.
garding the way in which they experience the CF with
their children. Financial Disclosure
The research was funded by Colciencias, National Ins-
Ethical Responsibilities titute of Health, the District Department of Social In-
tegration, and the Colombian Association for the Ad-
Human Beings and animals protection: Disclosure vancement of Science.
the authors state that the procedures were followed ac-
cording to the Declaration of Helsinki and the World Aknowledgments
Medical Association regarding human experimenta-
tion developed for the medical community. We thank the mothers and families who agreed to par-
ticipate in the study and the entities that contributed
Data confidentiality: The authors state that they have to its realization.
618
Original Article
Complementary feeding - Y. Forero T. et al
619
Original Article
Complementary feeding - Y. Forero T. et al
620