The Adaptive Medicine: Kaushal K. Srivastava and Ratan Kumar
The Adaptive Medicine: Kaushal K. Srivastava and Ratan Kumar
The Adaptive Medicine: Kaushal K. Srivastava and Ratan Kumar
The adaptation of any system either biological or otherwise involves interaction with the
internal and external environment. Since the latter is ever changing, the biological system
would be continuously changing to survive and reproduce. This change entails in itself
structural (morphological) and functional (Physiological and Biochemical) change/s
called Adaptation. It simply means that the man has limited capacity to work but it can be
enhanced. In addition; the capacity to work deteriorates as the man performs in time, he
ages, he is under mental distress and the environment in which the work is being done is
hostile to his well being. The latter may be due to high and low environmental
temperatures, atmospheric pressure such as in high mountains and deep sea, absence of
gravity and oxygen as in space, presence of noise and absence of sound and so on.
Increasing work performance played a key role in competitive sports all over the world.
Thus, there are many factors which affect the work performance and efficiency. The
methods and means to improve the work performance and overcome the adverse factors
are the part of Adaptive Medicine. These have played a key role in competitive sports and
the use of such Doping Agents had to be regulated by legislation. We shall briefly follow
the historical aspects of Adaptive Medicine.
The use of plants, animals and minerals for combating adverse effects of extreme
environment and malfunction by animals and man is as old as advent of mankind. This
becomes evident from the behavior of higher animals such as Chimpanzees in wild.
Evidence of the beginning of Medicine is seen some 6000 years back in the form of
Prescriptions found in Egypt. The “Ebers” papyrus contained the names of some 700
medicaments many of which are even familiar today. The Middle East medicine also had
the same beginning. Aesculapius, the son of Apollo, is the legendary father of Greek
medicine. Medicine was practiced in Aesculapian temples where priests diagnosed,
massaged, mixed medicine and offered musical and spiritual assistance to the body and
mind, though it was clouded with many strange and bizarre medicaments and procedures.
The ascetic Pythagorean brotherhood introduced the doctrine of physiological harmony.
The body was regarded as undifferentiated from the environment, and there was a flux
between them. The body, like the rest of the universe, was composed of fundamental
elements described metaphorically as earth, air, fire and water, together with affinities
between these elements.
Similar thoughts were expressed some 5000 years ago by Indian Medicine Sages; Chit,
jal, pawak, gagan, samira, Panch tatva yah rachit Sharira.
Disease arose, according to Alcmaeon, from a preponderance of one or other of the fiery
(hot), watery (fluid), earthy (solid) or airy (diffuse) elements. Medicines possessed
within them corrective powers to make adjustments to the internal balance. Some might
restore the fire or the dryness to the body, others drain the moisture. Indian and Chinese
systems of Medicine, some 5000 years old, embody the same principles, though perhaps
independently evolved. The Buddhists also believed that earth means the quality of mass
or solidity, air means motion, fire means energy and water means the binding quality.
They all move in space, or ether, sometimes called the fifth element the ‘akash’. The
four elements were later taken up by Aristotle, and through him transmitted to Europe
where they were a central dogma in life and medicine until the Renaissance in Sixteenth
Century
The equilibrium between the various elements in the organic body with the environment
described the health status of the individuals. The disease or the illness was considered to
be the disturbance in this equilibrium. If an ancient Greek or Indian practitioner described
that an organ is too ‘earthy’, he may be meaning that it is too dense and compact for its
own good. He was able to use this language to describe the way the body reacted to the
elements outside itself; the heat of the season generated ‘heat’ diseased, heavy foods
generated ‘solid’ diseases. The basic concept in these systems was that health was an
aggregate of elements, maintained in equilibrium with nature. The latter consisted of the
same elements.
Hippocrates, the father of modern medicine, criticized the Pythagorean four elements as
insufficient: Instead, he introduced the concept of ‘humours’ or fluid qualities of the body
which again needed to be in equilibrium – ‘crasis’ – for proper health. Every person had a
natural dominance of certain humors constituting his individuality. Disease arose when
the humors were diminished or strayed out of phase with a person’s natural dispensation.
In so far as the body was the cause of its own diseases, it could also heal itself by an inner
restorative process, the “medicatrix naturae”. Hippocrates always attempted to encourage
self-healing by designing a health regimen for a diseased person. This involved diet,
exercise, relaxation and other methods. These were supplemented by various drugs,
administered in order to correct those imbalances in the bodily secretions which produced
the weakness and susceptibility to disease. More or less, the Ayurveda, the ancient Indian
system of medicine and the Modern Medicine also believes the same way except that the
words or the symbols are different.
Galen, born in Pergamum in AD 130, the son of Nicon, the engineer in his fiery mission
to bring reason, logos, to bear upon medicine, emphasized once again the importance of
the humors and the Hippocratic concepts as a life force. The life force manifested itself
in the organism as various powers such as ingestion, expulsion and so on. These
balanced the humors, which Galen also saw as the arbiters of internal equilibrium, much
as we see hormones functioning in today’s physiology. Drugs could restore the inner
balance by regulating those self-same body powers. This would, according to the
Galenic system, restore the “physic” and the body would then throw off disease by itself.
Galen prepared many effective plant drugs and made the first attempts at standardization
of doses and of botanical sources. The systems of Galen and Pedanius Dioscorides, a
compiler of plant medicines, together with a smattering of Hippocratic naturalism, were
the legacy of Greek medicine and these systems also emphasized that divine design had
made physical resemblances between a medicinal plant and the disease or organ that the
plant could cure. This was preserved in a circuitous manner by the Arabs, spiced by the
return of some occult law.
Concept of Health
There is a need to have an adequate understanding of the meaning of “health”. It is
difficult to give an honest answer. As difficult as the answer to the question – are you
happy? It is possible that there is no such thing as perfect health or sickness but a
spectrum of states, ranging from very fit to fit to healthy; to a bit off color to partly sick
to sick and so on. A man may be affected by subtle damage brewing inside him – a
cancer or clogged arteries – and still be called healthy due to inability of biomarkers to
detect such non critical changes. The person may be decrepit, debilitated, lethargic,
incapable, doped, with chronic aches, irritations, infections and itches; he would still be
classed as ‘not ill’. The modern medicine can provide many cures for detectable disease
state; it is difficult to deal with the states of chronic sub-health. Therefore, it is important
to revise our attitude to health, to add more subtle concepts of health to the already
advanced concepts of disease.
Health is not only absence of illness. It means the ability of the body and mind to quickly
adapt itself to constantly changing environmental conditions, and its ability to perform
every kind of activity at optimal levels. Health is that “state of the human body which
enables a person to carry out his social and biological functions with the highest possible
efficiency” At the same time it is a state of man’s complete equilibrium with nature and
his social environment.
We may consider as a useful minimal definition of health that was put forward by the
World Health Organization:
‘Health is a state of complete mental, physical and social wellbeing and not merely
the absence of disease.’
However, you cannot call a man healthy unless he is capable of fulfilling some of the
potential of man. Therefore one could improve the definition by adding something about
capacity. One could improve it even more by adding something about longevity. For
health is substantial if it can lead to resistance to the pathogen prevailing in that time.
One has to add the happiness of the individual as the harbinger of health. This brings the
spiritual aspect of life within the definition of health. Thus, we can define health as
‘Health is a state of complete mental, physical, social and spiritual wellbeing and not
merely the absence of disease.’
Though this definition undermines the current efforts at disease prevention, most of us
recognize that the chronic diseases are caused largely by environment and life-style. This
has led to a vociferous group of health and community medicine workers to put forward
programmes of preventive measures as solutions to the ills of modern man. They
formulate instructions on diet, cigarette smoking, blood pressure and physical fitness.
People would be tested for risk factors at regular intervals and legislation introduced to
reduce environmental contamination and improve foods. Health maintenance
organizations are being set up and the population is continuously screened to detect
diseases early. These health care efforts are going side by side with improvements in
clinical medicine and each would be given a more appropriate slice of the cake.
Such measures are steps in the right direction, but the whole problem is likely to be
postponed for some time until the health burden builds up again to the same levels.
Prevention is essential, but it must be tied to a more enlightened view of health. Cancer,
heart and circulatory diseases are primarily a long slow drift from harmony in the
workings of the body, aided and abetted by environmental stresses. As the societies
develop in different regions of the world, the pattern of diseases keep on changing. We
see it happening every now and then. The details are not at all understood at present.
Despite the application of colossal resources to the problem, it is only possible to state
that the causes are so subtle and diverse that none of the programmes currently available
are capable in preventing, controlling and treating ill-health in the world. To stop
smoking and reduce consumption of cholesterol will only, so to speak, cream off the top
of the chronic disease figures, but not bring them down to the level of simple agricultural
communities. It will extend the life-span, but not the quality of living and life. It will
relieve the health services, a little. It might improve the health of those surviving to old
age. If we want to achieve very much more than that, the subtle development of the
degenerative diseases needs to be dealt with by subtle measures.
2. A science on how to maintain genuine health and human capacity for as many years
as possible now being called Geriatrics.
This means a marriage of traditional means to maximize health with modern means
to minimize disease.
There are living traditional medical systems which have such knowledge. These are in
India and China. The traditional Chinese medicine is now acceptable to a limited area.
The systems which we need now have been in daily use in India and China for more than
5000 years. China is running traditional Chinese medical system along with modern
medical system in their hospitals and clinics. In India too, the traditional Indian systems
like Ayurveda, Siddha, Unani and Yoga are being popularized and practiced in Modern
Hospitals and Clinics. This is considered not only to preserve the methods of traditional
medicine, but to fuse them with modern medicine.
Chinese Drugs
Shen Nung, the ‘Heavenly Cultivator’, was the father of both agriculture and herbal
medicine in China, the creator of the first Chinese pharmacopoeia, and mentor of Chinese
physicians and folk healers until today. He is supposed to have written the Shen Nung
Pen Tshao Teaching, or Pharmacopoeia of the Heavenly Cultivator. This work contains
365 remedies as well as the basic teaching of Chinese herbal medicine. Of the 365
remedies listed therein, 237 are botanical, 65 from animals, 43 mineral and the rest
unidentified. Shen Nung, according to some apocryphal sources, lived about 3000 BC.
Others say that he never existed. His book, Pen Tshao, was known at least as far back as
the second century BC.
The remedies are classified in a most interesting manner. They are placed in three
grades according to their toxicity, in an order. The most important group is the
‘kingly’, ‘superior’ drugs. They are characterized by being absolutely harmless, by being
used for a great variety of health purposes by the sick and the healthy, and by their ability
to increase vitality.
Superior healing herbs: They support at least one of the “three treasures”. The three
treasures according to traditional Chinese medicine, are known as qi (kinetic energy),
jing (essence or vital force), and shen (spirit or consciousness). Qi is the energy that
causes heart to beat, the lungs to breathe, and movement of blood throughout the body.
Furthermore, there are five categories within the superior class of Chinese herbs
(Winston and Maimes, 2007), and some herbs may fit in more than one category. These
categories include:
1) Qi tonics: Herbs that increase physiological energy production and are used to
treat the depletion of qi, examples include Asian ginseng (Panax ginseng, Chinese
name- Ren Shen), Eleuthero (Eleutherococcus senticossus, Chinese name- Ci
wujia), and licorice (Glycyrrhiza glabra, Chinese name- Gan cao).
2) Blood (xue) tonics: Herbs that nourish the blood and are especially useful for
woman, Example include lyceum.
3) Herbs that nourish the jing: these herbs helps conserve or strength the vital force,
Examples include Asian ginseng, cordyceps (Cordyceps sinensis, Chinese name-
Dong chong xia cao), reishi (Ganoderma lucideum, Chinese name- Ling zhi), and
schisandra (Schisandra chinensis, Chinese name- Wu wei zi).
4) Yin tonics: Herbs that nourish the fluids of the body, relieve dryness, and strength
the lungs, skin, stomach, and bowel, Examples include American ginseng, lyceum
and shatavari.
5) Yang tonics: Herbs that strength yang. They are especially used for deficient
kidney conditions and affect reproductive and adrenal functions; Examples
include Ashwagandha, Cordyceps, and Morinda roots.
Another quality that distinguishes the superior tonics is their ability to enhance normal
body functions. They help to establish homeostasis. They can strengthen the regulatory
mechanisms of the body and mind in such a way that body can maintain its balance
during stress. They increase inner vitality and energy and promote disease resistance.
They are ‘harmony remedies’.
In the second grade are the ‘ministerial’ herbs. These common drugs are more
powerful, are used against some diseases and are slightly toxic. For example:
Sophora angustifolia (k’u-shen)
Scrophularia oldhami (hsuan-shen) (a figwort)
Polygonum bistorta (tzu-shen) (bistort)
Angelica sinensis (tang-kuei) (type of angelica)
Fritillaria thumbergii (pei-mu)
Thirdly come, the inferior ‘assistant’ herbs, whose toxic dose is close to the
therapeutic dose. They are used to cure specific diseases. They are the last resort when
all other methods have failed. For example:
Aconitum Carmichael (aconite)
Platy Odon grandiflorum (chi-keng)
Adonis amurensis (pin-liang-hua) (pheasant’s-eye)
Veratrum nigrum (hellebore)
Strychonos nux vomica (vomit-nut tree)
There is also a subsidiary ‘servant’ class of drugs. They have the ability to conduct
other medicines to the place where they are intended to act in the body. Chinese
medicines largely follow the principle of ‘’noli nocere’’ (harmlessness). Few poisonous
plants are used, and if they are, the toxins are removed by processing. Almost all modern
medicines would be assigned to the assistant category by the Chinese pharmacologists
because of their toxicity and side effects.
All the herbs listed above are included in the Pharmacopoeia of the People’s Republic of
China (2000 English Edition).
In the two millennia since the first Pen Tshao, the principles of the Chinese use of drugs
have changed very little. They have only become somewhat more complex, and many
more remedies have been discovered. Chinese traditional medicine today is the result
of a continuous skein of evolution with occasional revisions along the way. Traditional
doctors still derive inspiration from the most ancient medical texts. However, Traditional
medicine suffered considerably, sinking in favor steadily in China with dominance of
Europeans during 15th to late 19th century. The intelligentsia of the Chinese urban was
won over by European ways including the health system. After the revolution in China all
physicians were urged to study traditional methods and incorporate them into their
modern training. Specialist hospitals using traditional methods and universities of
traditional medicine were established, as well as experimental institutes on acupuncture
and pharmacology. The Central Research Institute of Traditional Medicine in
Beijing,China coordinated the revival. Traditional medical experts joined with Modern
medicine-trained doctors in the Chinese medical association, and a flood of old books,
new compendia and reference works were published. Traditional physicians were no
longer the second-class experts dominated by imported foreign medical techniques.
Their procedures were no longer secret. They handed them over to a new generation of
professional traditional doctors. The traditional art again became the medicine of the
people. They included acupuncture, moxibustion, massage, physical culture and
medicines. These ancient techniques have been refined continuously. Their effectiveness
has also been demonstrated by modern methodology to entire world.
A long healthy life has been the cherished goal of man since antiquity. A number of
hymns and prayers are in Indian Scriptures including Vedic texts devoted to healthy
living and longevity. There are prayers to promote rejuvenation, healing and regeneration
of tissues i.e. Dhatus in the body. In addition to the rejuvenation of tissues, mention is
made to the important nature of the Jiva or Soul and its eternal transformation and rebirth.
The Vedic concepts of rejuvenation, longevity and immortality are the basic
philosophical concepts in Ayurveda. These concepts are embodied in Naithiki cikitsa,
Rasayana and Vajikaran; the procedures and the drugs meant for promotion of health in
otherwise healthy persons. The Rasayanam and Vajikaran seem to be the beginning of a
new branch of Medicine now being called Adaptive Medicine.
Rasayana is one of the eight clinical specialties of classical Ayurveda. It appears to have
been practiced in ancient times as an important specialty aiming at rejuvenation and
geriatric care. Rasayana is not a drug therapy but is a specialized procedure practiced in
the form of rejuvenative recipes, dietary regimen and special health-promoting conduct
and behavior i.e. Achara-rasayana. The focal basis of Rasayana is accelerated and
appropriated nutrition leading to improved biological competence of the body; the very
meaning of the word Rasayana (Rasa+Ayana) refers to nutrition and its assimilation in
the body. A state of improved nutrition is suppose to lead to a series of characteristics
like prevention of diseases, decreased ageing, improved immunity, mental competence,
vitality and luster of the body. However with the passage of time the importance of the
Rasayan and Vajikaran declined in popularity. This was an important part of Ayurveda
during the times of Charak, an important sage physician who lived and practiced about
three thousand years ago. Perhaps during his times, the diseases in the community were
controlled and not so common. With the passage of time, the diseases became more
common. It became necessary to deal with their cure and therapeutics of diseases.
Since Rasayan and Vajikaran seem to be the progenitor of Adaptive Medicine and
signatures for promotive aspect of modern Medicine, these are described in little detail.
The Rasayana promote health through one or all of the following three modes:
1. By the enrichment of nutritional quality of Food (Poshaka Rasa). A large
number of Rasayanas, both drugs and foods, contain in their bulk high quality of
nutrients and as such when administered, they are directly added to the pool of
nutrition and in turn, help improve tissue nourishment. Satavari, Dugdha, and
Ghrit are few such examples of Rasayanas.
2. By promoting nutrition through improving the Agnivyapara i.e. digestion and
metabolism. Several Rasayana drugs are known to promote digestion of food
and vitalize the metabolic activity resulting in an improved nutritional status.
Bhallataka is such an example.
3. By promoting the competence of Srotas i.e., the micro-circulatory channels in the
body leading to better bio-availability of nutrients and improved tissue
perfusion. Guggulu as mentioned by Sarngadhara is such an example. The
hypolipidemic and anti-atherosclerotic activity of Guggulu is in conformity with
the Rasayana effect of this drug.
The Rasayana are primarily of promotive value and are essentially meant to rejuvenate
the body and mind, to impart longevity against ageing and immunity against disease.
However, a rational classification of Rasayana into Ajasrika, Kamya and Naimittika has
been made (Mishra, 2011). Ajasrika is the nutrition which is taken regularly as food.
Kamya rasayana is suggestive in health to promote the vigor and vitality. Some
Rasayanas may be used in patients suffering from specific diseases in order to promote
their vitality. This is called Naimittika rasayana; Silajatu and Tuvaraka are the specific
examples of Naimittika Rasayana. In view of the contents, usage and purpose, the
Rasayana may be classified as given below (Charak Samhita, 1985):
A. As per scope of use:
1. Kamya Rasayana (promoter of normal health)
A. Pranakamya (promoter of life-vitality and longevity)
B. Medhakamya (promoter of intellect)
C. Srikamya (promoter of complexion and luster)
Vajikarana drugs:
According to the texts Vajikaran dravyas have been divided into five categories.
Promoting production of semen: (milk, ghee, onion, vidari, musali, gokshura,
shatavari, yashtimadhu and semen from various other animals).
Purifying action on semen: (kushtha, sugar cane, and bayberry).
Promoting fertilization capacity in semen: (brahmi, shatavari, katuka, guduchi,
amalaki, bala).
Herbs that increase libido: (akarakarabh, saffron, clove, garlic, pippali).
Tonics to combat premature ejaculation: (nutmeg, ashwagandha, chandhan,
jatamansi, kapikachchu).
In addition to above substances of animal origin viz. eggs, semen of animals and birds,
testicles of goat etc. are also important ones. The use of Cannabis which is known to be
of use now as aphrodisiac was not used as such in early times. These drugs provide
pleasure, progeny and stamina.
References
Charaka, Caraka-samhita, Ed.P.V. Sharma, cikisasthana, ch.1, Chaukhamba orientalia,
Varanasi 1985.
Sharadini Dahanukar and Urmilla Thatte, Ayurveda Unravelled, 1996, National Book
Trust, India
Singh R.H.: Ayuvediya Nidana Cikitsa-Siddhanta, Vol. 1, Chaukhamba Amarabharati
Prakshan, Varanasi, 1986.
Winston and Maimes (Eds.) Adaptogens: Herbs for Strength, Stamina, and Stress Relief,
Published by Healing Art Press, One Park Street, Rochester, Vermont 05767, 2007.